ASOIAF: Robert's Rebellion

[@odin6667]

Every time a Stark gets executed it sparks a war across the entire realm...

[@HWDragonborn]

Yes, that's why the Unsullied didn't execute Jon after he kill Daenerys

[@cryptox826]

SH W The unsullied had no idea about the War of the Five Kings. If they did they woudnt care, they still should’ve killed him 😂

[@roadhigher]

@@cryptox826 Without Dany and the Dragons the Unsullied had zero chance surviving if they executed Jon. Sansa would immediately declare war and march south with an army of Northmen, Tyrion is Jons ally and so would help too along with the Westerlands, andGendry in the Stormlands would most likely join aswell since he feels loyalty towards Jon, whilst Robin Arryn and Edmure Tully are 50/50 in joining Sansa/staying out of it. The Unsullied don't need to know about the War of Five Kings to realise that executing Jon means potentially war with Four of the Seven Kingdoms, with zero allies of their own.

[@bestkill6888]

SH W The Unsullied wanted time kill Jon, it was the others that stopped them by exiling Jon

[@bestkill6888]

Comrade Corbyn The North was completely drained after all of the Wars they were in, they wouldn’t be able to amount many men at all. Tyrion is smarter than that and wouldn’t war for the North and neither would his people. Edmure probably wouldn’t aid Sansa bc of the way she treated him. Even if she got Robin to help they couldn’t beat the Unsullied, especially since they’ve lost all of their good commanders.

[@ZappedBanana]

This would make such a good prequel to Game of Thrones!

[@bezukaking6860]

Rickard should have named water as his champion...

[@360bandman]

I think water might not be enough for wild fire

[@dangerousboxx666]

@@360bandman the ocean

[@hiddendagger7291]

madking himself 😄

[@bezukaking6860]

@@360bandman what about Wildwater?

[@ChaseMcCain81]

BezukaKing NO such thing (I get that your joking).

[@dylanjones2295]

We should all start a petition for a Roberts rebellion series

[@relaxandenjoy4006]

for sure

[@LucaMatoke]

Yeah

[@adamsolence6666]

GODS I WAS STRONG THEN

[@lukeskywalkerthe2nd773]

Adam Solence Hahaha LOL XD

[@mysouptoocold1656]

WINE

[@GumaroRVillamil]

thanks the gods for Bessy!

[@dorianzacharyday]

I hear this in his voice

[@targetdemographic1257]

Gumaro R. Villamil and her tits

[@jacksonphillips2075]

Robert, "hiding" in a brothel? I doubt that

[@mysouptoocold1656]

That's where his basterd Bella was born

[@VictoriaTraducciones]

My Soup Too cold correction, that's when his bastard daughter Bella was conceive, he named her Bella because of the Battle of the Bells

[@drfaisalkamal1275]

The most believable thing

[@rexbanner7256]

Your voice and the way you deliver the info is superb. If you did this with actual history, I'd be yours forever. Don't forget; real history is just as wild. Keep up the good work.

[@sl6706]

Just imagine if HBO had started with this for their first show. It would have been just as exciting and would help to lay the ground work for Game of Thrones.

[@vulcranstorm2023]

But it would have ruined the surprise of jon snow

[@trpimirkarlovic838]

​@@vulcranstorm2023 who cares

[@acecopularmma]

@@trpimirkarlovic838deadass

[@tuahupakaapama8953]

I wanna see a prequel about a young Robert like if you agree

[@ocdgaming5791]

Tuahupa Ķaapama If that happens, I want to see Stannis hold Storm’s End.

[@_Tristen_]

It’s happening soon.

[@drfaisalkamal1275]

Yep

[@grantwilson4506]

Robert's Rebellion is so cool. All the kids did it back in the day.

[@andrews5867]

Great video. Glad to see you are still putting out the quality material. Please keep posting more videos for other stories. Maybe cover the Cthulu series?

[@jackguest145]

0:40 Those failed plans are all really interesting concepts.

[@yashmahale599]

For me, Robert's Rebellion and Aegon's Conquest are the two stories I would absolutely love to see on screen! More than anything, I want to see Young Robert who was portrayed as a super strong warrior!!

[@jimsty5222]

Your summarizes are the best!

[@moeyhamka801]

Do more game of thrones stuff like this please. Appreciate your effort !

[@YoImMuzzy]

How old exactly is Stannis during the siege of Storms end? ONE GOD ONE KING STANNIS STANNIS STANNIS

[@gaiusjuliuspleaser]

He was 18 at the start of the siege.

[@MegaLiamgaming]

Stannis Baratheon is the one true king of westeros

[@drfaisalkamal1275]

Stannis the mannis baratheon

[@troyc7726]

One of the best pages out

[@nikolay4101-s7r]

Lyn corbray is also said to have participated in the fighting against jon arryn in the vale, however wether his father had supported the mad king is unknown

[@nevarraven9048]

I mean he switched sides, he even killed Ser Lewyn Martell of the King’s guard

[@raphaelostrowski6336]

He fought at Gulltown under Lord Mark Grafton but was defeated. He was knighted regardless due to his bravery then fought on Jon Arryn side after

[@blackflagsnroses6013]

Rhaegar and Lyanna, this one’s on you 😔

[@jadon3597]

Rheager was married with 2 children he stole a women who was younger than him he was an idiot it’s his fault that his children and wife died

[@sharikakhaled1096]

ikr?hate rhaegar and lyanna for their selfish actions.rhaegar didnt steal anyone,that hypocritical bitch lyanna went with him willingly.

[@MadScientist021]

Actually, this one is on Aerys.

[@arawn1061]

Sharika Khaled she was 14 and on her way to cat and brandons wedding

[@blackflagsnroses6013]

theMADdestScientist_ Aerys wouldn’t have burned the Starks if they had, oh I don’t know, TOLD PEOPLE THEY RAN OFF TOGETHER!

[@only_one_chrisfantazzi]

Great video as always and one you definitely fits your collection to do .

[@madambutterfly1997]

If Ned was truly upset, he wouldn't have reconciled with Robert so easily

[@blackflagsnroses6013]

Hasan Wilson He didn’t even see Robert again until the Greyjoy Rebellion. It was then they reconciled some. Eddard had more worries than exiled Targaryens, like the one that is his actual nephew.

[@madambutterfly1997]

Ruben Avalos yes a nephew he had no intention of being fully honest with. Jon deserved a much better hand than Ned dealt him. Ignoring his suffering at the hand of that hateful bitch Cat. I digress.

[@madambutterfly1997]

Ruben Avalos another thing, he considered Robert family yet Ned barely thinks of his actual siblings in the same loving manner. Why is that? Is it because the only true affliction they had was having the same mother and father

[@blackflagsnroses6013]

Hasan Wilson You can’t expect Ned to think he could trust any with that information. He didn’t knew Catelyn well enough and by the time he could trust her wholeheartedly her opinions on Jon had been established. He could have told her then but why the hassle? Ned is far from wise or perfect so can’t really discredit his decisions. And he was going to tell Jon but fate had other plans. Ned’s reasoning was let the truth be buried with his parents and let that be the end of the tragedy. The only person he ever truly thought of telling was Jon himself, but only when he was safe and far from enemies and notions of vengeance.

[@blackflagsnroses6013]

Hasan Wilson How do you figure? Ned valued his siblings. His love for his sister lead him to betray his friend and king, and his own honor which would have likely lead him to proclaim Jon the true king by birth right. But because Lyanna asked of him he kept Jon far from the throne and the threats that came with it, Ned was tired of tragedy and war. His brother he found brash but loved him well enough, and he always looked after Benjen. Ned grew up with Robert but he still spent the majority of his youth with his siblings. Robert on the other hand loved Ned more than he did Stannis and Renly combined.

[@marko765]

So..just curious, was it possible that the origin of "Lies" about Rhaegars kidnapping coming from Littlefinger? because we already knew he was salty about Brandon.

[@ChevyChase301]

Marko Minko Robert was the main person

[@marko765]

Yes Robert lead the Rebellion but he did not started it.Robert and Ned at The Eyrie at that time. The Rebellion started because of the Mad King burning Rickard alive and strangled Brandon to death.When Brandon heard the news about her sister he was on his way to wed Catelyn in Riverrun.So thats why im curious whos told Brandon.We all knew Littlefinger loved Catelyn.

[@chris19wp83]

Honestly, I don't think anyone knew they both eloped, so I think everyone assumed that she was kidnapped. Knowing what we knowing of Brandon, regardless of whether Lyanna went willing or not I still believe he would have riding to KL. That's who he was, the Wild Wolf.

[@marko765]

@Chris19W ;P - agree, thats what im thinking too. im just curious about it while im watching season 7 finale when Bran said "Roberts Rebellion was based on a lie". so after saw Littlefingers death i was like what if the lie hes talking about coming from Littlefinger? like when he the one who cause the war of the five king by lying to Catelyn about that Valyriansteel dagger.

[@marko765]

@Genghis Khan: - wait dont turn this to an argument, i dont have any proof just curiousity.haha! but im not surprised if its turned out to be true.All he had to do was spread the false rumour.because im pretty sure that he knew Rhaegar and Lyanna were in love.

[@corachloe5748]

Still love these vids! Wasn’t it the Tyrells that held storms end vs the Tarleys?

[@bestkill6888]

What lmao 😂😂. No. Stannis held Storms End while the Tyrells sieged it. The Tarleys were loyal Reachman

[@corachloe5748]

BestKill68 right. The Tyrells sieged storms end. Sat outside and did nothing

[@360bandman]

@@corachloe5748 they were starving out the garrison at storms end

[@celalal2979]

Amazing Channel!!

[@luiscampanella1325]

Aerys was so shady Lmfaooo

[@sanderkoekkoek9866]

Technically there was still a targaryan in westeros. But he was a maester at the wall.

[@vulcranstorm2023]

Two

[@lexflynn1994]

In the show, Robert said his first kill was at summerhal but according to this it was before that?

[@ragingsage3973]

one of the difference between the books and show

[@flynn659]

This is good content. Are you planning on covering other fictional worlds as of now?

[@CivilizationEx]

+Flynn Tom I'll be doing a Wheel of Time video in November. Then possibly Riddick and Elder Scrolls by the end of the year

[@flynn659]

Thats good to hear m8. I can't tell you how much I wish for the best of this channel, but all I can say is, keep up thr fantastic work!

[@prasanthsakthivel6430]

Roberts rebellion is good to watch

[@hiddendagger7291]

how robert hide his army from jon connigton? he had nearly 10000 k soldiers when he started journey from storm land

[@arunsingla3452]

He lost most of them at ashford in battle against reach’s army (the only battle rebels lost in the rebellion)

[@timbrinkhof4683]

god asoiaf lore is so good

[@arawn1061]

Dont get me wrong, i believe in R+L=J but isnt it more likely that lyanna was still abducted by rheagar. I mean she was on her way to her brothers wedding when she disapeared and lyanna doesnt seem to be the kind of person who abandons her family like that. And what happend to her Escort?

[@vinhbao9738]

Doesn't matter much to the story. They are all dead because of Rhaegar's foolishness.

[@mysouptoocold1656]

The war started cause of Arys madness to burn the starks alive

[@mysouptoocold1656]

No not really cause when you compare to who she was with arya and jon, she isn't the type to be handed away or kidnapped. She most likely went willingly. But she was a teenager who wasn't allow to embrace her wildside like arya is.

[@VictoriaTraducciones]

My Soup Too cold yeah right, because a teenage girl is going to be able to stand her ground against warriors like Arthur Dayne, Oswell Whent and even Rhaegar himself

[@blacktallsmart1914]

Is this a reupload. I could had sworn that this video was on here before.

[@snakepliskin23]

They don’t put that part in the songs.

[@calcoffey8713]

Ye but does it need to be, because everything to do with jon sniw, rhaegar and lyanna has come directly from george

[@luiscampanella1325]

More ASOIAF videos.

[@madambutterfly1997]

No more of this tragedy of Dragons

[@JGas20]

How tf did one guy write all this lore. Bless GRRM, he had to be on some great psychedelics

[@Brandonhayhew]

Martin just confirmed that Jon is the chosen one or Azor Azhai.

[@DarthBigBen]

books from Windblown Citation needed.

[@nevarraven9048]

books from Windblown He never did that. The entire idea of Azor Ahai is most likely fake anyway

[@seandivers1]

Real recognize real

[@dndislife506]

Imagine Brandon Stark dueling Rhaegar.

[@matthaggard4815]

Essentially the entire Baratheon house is of Targaryen blood, Orys Baratheon was Aegon Targaryen I's bastard brother.

[@arunsingla3452]

Robert’s grandmother was also a targeryen (niece of maester aemon)

[@JoniukasVader]

113...

[@shortlong8936]

Seems out of Varys' character.

[@SHARKVADERS]

37...

[@Chiefkid20]

Sorry, but didn't Jaime run his sword through the king's back instead of slashing his throat?

[@edmonddantes563]

Defalt47 tv show jaime put it through his back then slit his throat, book it was just his throat

[@CivilizationEx]

In the books he slit his throat.

[@rodesvilobo8670]

yaass queen

[@rhaegartargaryen4450]

I died for love

[@mysouptoocold1656]

Love is the death of duty. I wish you warned your wife at least

[@QueenDaenerysTargaryen]

We have that in common:'( Jon Snow betrayed me Why!?

[@japhetmindana1370]

They call it roberts rebellion but when you think about it Brandon marched to kings landing begging for rheagars head. Rheagar and Lyanna ran off together. Literally Roberts and Neds involvement directly in the war commenced when the mad king asked for their heads 🤣🤣🤣🤣. Imagine being called usurper for defending yourself loooool.

[@LifeAfterFlint]

It’s crazy how this story breaks down to all the Starks being idiots.

[@hristol7537]

And Taragaryens loving fire a little too much.

[@drfaisalkamal1275]

Mad Targaryens

[@treycole8367]

Man this is not cannon👀explain!!!!

[@barkley8285]

Yipee

[@QueenDaenerysTargaryen]

Robert's Rebellion failed I will return and take back what is mine! 💥🔥🔥🔥🐉🐲🐉🔥🔥🔥💥

[@magnusthered4973]

How did it fail you ain’t in Westeros anymore still you both of your shit head brothers are dead thank the gods your crazy dipshitfather got stabbed by a hero so who really won

[@drfaisalkamal1275]

Of course he was hiding in a brothel 😂

[@sufianabuahmad7781]

Second

[@madambutterfly1997]

Being at the Wall would make it worse. Because now Jon has decided not have children. Ned would be content with the ending of his sister's line. Why tell him when he was in a position that not only robs him of his entire life? My God, Ned's not the sharpest knife, but he's not the useful one either. Not even one worth using. Perhaps Joffrey had the right of it.

[@alex-sv8ru]

Hasan Wilson Ned doesn't care about the Targaryen line ending, he just wanted to keep Jon safe, by telling him his ancestory... He isn't helping... & Jon never wants to sit on the Iron Throne anyway. But he can, if he dies and gets revived again like he did in the show.. Then he can leave the wall.

[@luiscampanella1325]

Targaryens are superior

[@goncalomonteiro8395]

Cry some more, incest lover

[@nevarraven9048]

Luis Campanella Stannis Baratheon is the one true king

[@QueenDaenerysTargaryen]

I will take back what is mine🔥💥

[@luiscampanella1325]

A what a downgrade from house Targaryen to baratheon.

[@TheMulletOperator_77]

Upgrade, robert was such a chad

[@calcoffey8713]

@CivilisationEx why'd you make this video unless you were going to add in the part that rhaegar and lyanna were in love, ran off togwther and had a child. But you didn't so whats the point of you making this video

[@CivilizationEx]

+COD: NOOB To talk about Robert's Rebellion...

[@calcoffey8713]

@CivilizationEx there's nothing to add though we all know about it and everything surrounding it

[@CivilizationEx]

lol, you may know all about it, but others do not. And I've already made a video specifically about the Tower of Joy where I talk about Rhaegar and Lyanna in more depth. This video was an updated version of a previous video I made about Robert's Rebellion. And that first vid got 200,000 views. So People are definetly interested in this subject.

[@calcoffey8713]

@CivilizationEx but if you're a got fan or a asoiaf fan you will know all about Robert's rebellion

[@CivilizationEx]

What makes you think that? There are lots of casual fans out there who know nothing about it, and even most the people who love the series don't know everything about the Rebellion.