Barstool Pizza Review - Picco (Boston, MA)

Dave tries Picco in Boston, a place in the South End that had become his go to favorite while he lived in the city. Will it taste as good as he remembers?
Download The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: onebite.app/do...
Follow on Instagram: / stoolpresidente
Follow on Twitter: / stoolpresidente
Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolspo...
Follow Barstool Sports here:
Facebook: / barstoolsports
Twitter: / barstoolsports
Instagram: / barstoolsports

[@hankfanelli719]

It's very simple, dock the pizza dough and par bake it for about 3-4 minutes, take it out and brush the dough with olive oil, sauce it, top it and bake until done, nice and crisp with ZERO FLOP. Most pizza places have no clue.

[@zanedietlin7645]

just depends how you like it. Depends the oven. Depends the recipe. It’s not ‘very simple’

[@armuk]

preach buddy. most joints don't take the time for the extra step

[@corbin6304]

One nostalgic bite. Everybody knows the rules.

[@keith3946]

I'm an hour away from this place. I might actually take the drive and eat a whole pie in the car like an animal.

[@GetOffMyPhoneGoogle]

I used to have to eat in the car if I went to get lunch, the looks you get while devouring a slice at a red light are magical.

[@AwestruckChemicals]

Why not just eat it in the restaurant?

[@4cylfreak46]

Gotta do what you gotta do. I’ve done it many times.

[@kacksonjeel442]

Eat it naked in your car like an animal

[@leorickt.9604]

@@AwestruckChemicals extremely valid question

[@scottmcwave9479]

Not sure I’d use that analogy but if Dave says so it must be one of the rules!

[@katherineluttmann82]

Hi, current south end resident, previously lived in NYC and new haven area. 👋 can confirm this score is 100% accurate 🤝

[@kylemcgill2966]

I randomly had this like 4 years ago while visiting. It was 🔥🔥🔥

[@jefferson3341]

Is fire good?

[@toddlesiak3837]

@@jefferson3341 That means it sucks a**, Einstein:)

[@bumblebee623]

Idk what 🔥 means. Did they burn your pizza? It was that bad?

[@jasonbreesejr7718]

@@bumblebee623 it means the pizza was Really good 💀 it was Fireeeee

[@bumblebee623]

@@jasonbreesejr7718 I don't speak Walmart

[@Woozlewuzzleable]

That looks good, I finally agree with his score. He usually scores it low if it's not thin.

[@user-sq8ki8zi8u]

lol same boat, i was ready to roast him if that got in the 7's

[@TexanInItaly]

I'm glad y'all agree with his score on a pizza you didn't eat yourself.

[@nathanel2306]

You agree with it even though you've never eaten it?

[@Deathstar_TV]

Agreed! No lazy 7.2, and frankly I even appreciate the “rookie” score of the .5 on this because it’s actually like this pizza has its own reputation, not just like better than an 8.

[@skullz_lg654]

First high score in a LONG time, great vids keep it up.🔥

[@gradybrowning3976]

Pizza with a Hard on, everybody knows the rules!

[@bumblebee623]

What rules? You just keep copying the same slogan everyone does. Get your own line. Don't be a sheep.

[@quarters-eye8922]

You can hear that crunch from outer space.

[@peteb9279]

One bottle of Addies everyone knows Dave is the plug

[@Hooligan4200]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 faxxxxxxx

[@greent1942]

The hair plug😬

[@kyle896]

Plug me in

[@GentleSoul999]

He's off the painkillers and the addys...

[@presouz5]

I’m confused I saw you do a review for a 9.2 and you didn’t rave about that pizza like you did this come on now everybody knows that’s not a good rule 🤣🙈

[@ratemybeers6406]

Picco you need to hire 8.5 more staff to help you with all the new orders you will get.😧

[@connive5159]

one bite everyone knows the rules, Dave likes it hard

[@samtastisch86]

😂

[@bumblebee623]

He actually does.... true story. Ask some of the "MtF" groups. He's hot on them. Pics and texts to prove it

[@krisfrederick5001]

Davey's hair survived the War. Everybody knows the rules 🍕💙💛

[@TheSinfuljustice]

I literally spit my drink out lol.

[@kacksonjeel442]

The real war going on right now

[@krisfrederick5001]

@@kacksonjeel442 We're counting on a strong under carriage.

[@krisfrederick5001]

@@TheSinfuljustice I she was a cheap one!

[@dingdongdaddy589]

Ahhh yes, a moment of escape from the end of the world onslaught.

[@siratabeachflorida9883]

You are not kidding at least we'll go out with a couple pizza reviews

[@danielk8626]

Easily a hometown score. That was a 7.6 at best.

[@MrFluffycow]

8.2 on the app soo…

[@aaronbourlard5038]

An inflated score unlike the footballs back in the day in nearby foxboro

[@michaelgoldberg518]

he barely took 3 small bites in 12 seconds, avg score for a 2 min video is below 5.0

[@marksmith6331]

Without actually tasting it I have to go by his body language. I've watched him for several years now on pizza reviews. This review seems phony. He didn't show the under carriage in fact looks like was hiding it. It just didn't look like a pizza he'd put in the 8's. Maybe it was sprinkled with coke. Just my opinion.

[@Kment011]

I have over 150 reviews on the one bite app and I'm usually tougher than Dave, and I gave Picco an 8.6

[@Jmitch767]

That does look absolutely amazing

[@EddieDBama]

That looks fantastic. I want that!

[@xDelfinoRubio]

Had this last week. Best pizza I've had in my life

[@indykalia8224]

Outrageous score! Forgot Dave is back in Boston! No favoritism!

[@BushidoBrownSama]

I'm a fan of Picco 8.5 is too low imo

[@randhika5636]

already looks crispy just by looking at it

[@WilliamToll]

I’ve brought people from all over the world here. Everyone says “best Pizza ever”. It’s been my go to pizza place since I moved to Boston in 2010

[@jakefroese6695]

I would like to try this pizza

[@enricopallazzo3244]

Concise, positive, and informative. You have earned my like sir.

[@shoulderlabrum520]

His phoenix review brought me here

[@AlokSomani]

Yo Dave! I like Pizzeria Rustico in Boston if you have the chance. Felt more like a local spot but cool owners/workers and actually really good!

[@andrewcuneo7206]

I used to go there before I moved. That is excellent pizza.

[@Venividivici55555]

Look at that crunch, almost as good as the One Bite Pizza...

[@theripoffchicago]

That pie does look delicious:::

[@pandafragrance]

I live about a block from here and basically next to where Dave used to live. It’s more of a 7.7 type of pizza. Dave gave it the Sundays with his ex wife nostalgia score.

[@mikeoley13]

Nostalgic pizza is the best pizza.

[@rainkinggw]

That pizza is beautiful

[@lordsircocktheviijr.4622]

I always try to guess the score based on his first bite and reaction and I'm always like .2 off! I'm gonna get it one of these days

[@itsyaboiuni]

Been doing that for years, it eventually becomes too easy to guess the right score haha

[@lockjaw3388]

The "WIND.. said one Bite , everyone knows the rules..!!!

[@beece16]

As a fan of little to no flop pizza, I remember saying" a pizza is like a dick,it shouldn't be limp".

[@ErnestGoesToMadeas]

"I love the Gays!" -Dave Portnoy

[@Anybodyelse2294]

You can take that to the bank

[@Redvinetv]

One great Boston strong, no flop bite, everybody knows the rules.

[@ulogy]

Try Ducali Pizzeria in Boston - Solid 8.6 or 8.7 when I went. (Needs a rescore!) Maybe a little generous given they squeezed me and a buddy into their café side because we caught them after a Celtics playoffs game let out and everywhere was packed. Can't recall the name, but the sausage and basil pizza was A1.

[@trevorrusso1037]

Everybody knows 8.5 is a ROOKIE score 😂

[@johnvoorhees7881]

Good to hear a better score 👍

[@boxy1011]

You should go to sals pizza on the Bronx near gun hill very good spot.

[@BushidoBrownSama]

Picco & Tremonte are my favorite spots

[@diddlez2]

Is it always Dave Portnoy eating a cheese pizza giving it a random number between 6.1 and 8.9?

[@enricopallazzo3244]

Have you even read the rules?

[@Anybodyelse2294]

Sometimes it’s Debbie

[@legitrips5728]

One shakey hand after a coke bender, everybody knows the rules

[@Kment011]

I've been trying to get him to go here for months! Now he has to go to Angela's in Saugus and Ziggy's in Brighton! He's going 8.5 or better on both of those too!!!

[@BushidoBrownSama]

He needs to go to Tremonte

[@crizzonet]

I’ve ate there a few times. It’s good for real!

[@MRRVADrums]

That crunch added a whole point. I’d have gone 8.6 at least.

[@shaneoleary9919]

Awesome video Dave. Yay raven pizza rock 🍕

[@Cocytus]

@One Bite Pizza Reviews - Montilio's, Adams st, Quincy. Yes this bakery has pizza and yes it's good.

[@markgriffin3158]

Head up to Riverview Pizza in Ipswich. Best bar pie ever. You're welcome.

[@originalfiremancancelled7303]

Everybody knows Davy helps out small businesses👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@johnc2645]

DO ERNESTO’S in the North End

[@coloneljan]

I finally guessed the score today. Looked like a damn good pie, especially for Boston.

[@FamousDexxx]

One bite, everybody knows Dave inflates the Boston scores

[@JimJamSandwich]

As he should, because Boston is the greatest city on planet Earth.

[@tamathawalden2037]

Patriots red sox bruins celtics. Its hard to argue

[@absoluteunit8628]

That pizza deserves an 8.5

[@yc_030]

This is a 7.6 max in ny or ct

[@libraryofthoughts0]

@@JimJamSandwich Says a guy Who never went outside of US😂😂

[@watagump1]

I found a hair in my pizza, that's YOUR hair. 😁

[@jasonsantiago8148]

Let's go Boston...... one bite you know the deal

[@waltermatthewberg]

Day 1 of a 3 day fast isn't going so well if I'm already watching pizza reviews

[@TheQats]

He said do do 😂

[@benvasilinda9729]

Spider did a great job holding that camera still during that hurricane. Everyone knows the rules!

[@chrisphallheatlover9848]

Massive score

[@reviewforthetube6485]

Could here that crunch from a mile away lol

[@Jimbowlcoach]

FREAKING Crunch on that!

[@shape816]

Truly is the best. Must eat.

[@RussellSyx]

Not gonna lie. That pizza looks fire.

[@davidphelps4159]

You said doo doo lol!

[@TheGrandMaster1942]

I went there before I saw this review. Rating is earned. Very good

[@JustRideZipp2001]

I'll be in Boston next month, so I know where I'm heading for lunch.

[@complicatedtime]

I used to like Harvard Gardens on Cambridge St when I lived in Beacon Hill in 1993-1995. Is it still any good?

[@corenko]

I just ordered the floppiest pizza in the world. Everybody knows the rules 3.40 from me

[@fearless_gaming2056]

If I ever go to any of these cities I'm definitely coming back here to find the best pizza lol

[@pizzamanpepperoni8192]

Dave likes his men like his pizza ZERO flop 🙂

[@Jack-yz9xw]

You gotta try Ziggy’s Magic Pizza In Phoenix Arizona

[@tirojiro9275]

Maria’s and Venice in Arlington MA

[@AnthonyBottari]

Picco is great!

[@churchbryan35]

Great Review!!

[@buzzy5350]

Dave, if you like picco then next time ur in ny/nj u have to go to Cassie’s restaurant and get the pizza. It’s a spot 20 mins away from the city in englewood nj, and one of the best pies I’ve ever had no joke. Gotta give it a try

[@dharmaram7527]

This review became Dave’s coming out confession. Everyone knows Dave made the rules.

[@hoddtoward]

Due to nostalgia, Chuck E. Cheese's would taste good too

[@scottd9287]

Do a review for ally cat pizza. Manchester, NH.

[@trevorphillips2868]

Can you guys record in landscape mode?

[@3500camarz]

You know Dave, you should turn the phone to landscape mode when recording...just sayin

[@esj4373]

we know dave ! when is the coming out party

[@ZackMorris1]

There is a little nostalgia scoring going on here with that 8.5 monster. I'm more inclined to think this is in the high 7s low 8s

[@Ssnipez71]

one bite we all hope dave isn’t celiac after all these reviews

[@wiskysin]

Nice box.

[@mikemaclean858]

Finally representatives thee best pizza city , and state. in the world.

[@alboogietang4136]

Try Casa pizza Ludlow, ma

[@tonylotito3845]

Home sweet home bro

[@brucewayne4814]

This is my first episode watching

[@yojix5805]

That looks fineeee

[@IZotit]

My guy, I hit the like button, but buy El Prez a microphone that can block out wind. We all want to hear his glorious voice. The End.

[@Yokoohellno617]

I’ve eaten there. It is a good pie.

[@unfairlytreatedmexican6380]

Do you think these pizza reviews will ever go internationally? One bite everyone knows the rules.

[@StonedMewtwo]

He did one or two when he was in Italy a couple years back. Maybe one in France too

[@ScottyRules33]

I could inhale that pie. 8.5 is a great score.

[@evannewton3104]

The south end : 4k a month for a studio while a mass Ave resident OD's on your front stairs, everyone knows the rules

[@Traxdagamble99]

Do Espresso Pizza in Lowell

[@alexrivera437]

8.5 cuz is in Boston yea you the pizza expert

[@daviclar867]

You know, it would be a real pizza review if he actually knew and commented on why the pizza is so good, because imo it's the sauce and flavour of the crust and he never really details any of what a real food reviewer would comment on. Everybody knows there's only one rule with Dave!

[@chrissygerwitz520]

That is because he actually doesn't know anything about pizza. He just knows what he likes.

[@jackiehedges320]

he's a simple man

[@pwebb34]

@@jackiehedges320 He’s like Lenny from Of Mice and Men.

[@Kment011]

I've been here. They use a sourdough crust which has a really good unique flavor and other worldly crisp! I would have preferred either shredded motz or more of the cheese they use (chunks of whole motz I believe), but the flavor on their pie is unreal!

[@monkeygraborange]

Prez! Ernesto’s on Salem Street!

[@hvacdr]

Believe it or not I took a red baron 3 dollar frozen supreme pizza and I pulled apart 2 mozzarella string cheese and put it all over it and baked it at 400 till it got kinda smoky I think like 18 minutes.That pizza was as good as pizza gets in Las Vegas. That said there is no such thing as a good pizza in Las Vegas. I'm sure it could have ranked like a 7.1 It was delicious. Imo I'd give it like a 7.3 compared to restaurants but compared to other frozen pizzas ya its like a 9.7 definitely the very best frozen pizza I ever had. I thought I had actually bought it from a restaurant. Now that's only due to how I cooked it and the fact that I put the extra cheese. Also I put it directly on the rack. I would love Mr barstool give this a review. I'm so sure he'd give it a 7. And in terms of honestly grading frozen pizzas it's gotta be in the 9s...

[@cafezo87934]

that pizza gave you a salute 🤚

[@michaelsoucy7618]

he scores it 8.5 inches

[@EnkinduGamer]

One windy review. Everybody knows this is Chicago.