Battlefield 5 vs Battlefield 1 | WHICH GAME IS BETTER?

[@Mai_Tai_Meyers]

I’ve enjoyed both games, but BF1 had that magical “it” factor. I get chills whenever I hear the squad leader signaling his whistle to storm the trenches.

[@rn4341]

BF1 is a masterpiece! Game of the decade!

[@Zesmas]

i played multiplayer and that literally never happens.

[@rn4341]

@@Zesmas it does

[@tylerlane4587]

@@Zesmas it does

[@BobbyBingoV2]

Loading up operations just to see a 32 man charge with men screaming and whistles blowing is an experience no other game I've played has achieved. BF1 is such a masterpiece

[@inwoner7190]

The problem with horses in BF1 is the fact that for some reason, the soldier on the horse seems to have ultra-super powers and you cannot kill him with anything.

[@clamcrewcarclub6017]

He’s wearing full torso body armor lol now his horse on the other hand is an actual tank. I’ve never unloaded a full magazine from a Browning BAR into a horse in real life, but I’m assuming it wouldn’t survive hahaha

[@Nitrox_909]

@@clamcrewcarclub6017 XD

[@silver92simo]

@@clamcrewcarclub6017 😂😂😂

[@madtechnocrat9234]

without it they would be completely useless. it is necessary for them to work in game. the fact that horse blocks sometimes on random objects would be instant death sentance. But i would be all in for reduced hp of cavalry if they increased their spawn rate by like 3-4 horses.

[@insertname3293]

yeah, some details have to be obviously dropped for the sake of enjoyment, if horses and rider had normal health, no one would play them as it would literally just be a downgrade as you'd just be a bigger target

[@VaJohn]

BF1 is by far the best battlefield i ever played so far.

[@jerrychappell255]

@CHIEF KEEF DROP DESTINY bf1 is way better then 3 or 4

[@SVT_LIGHTNING]

@@jerrychappell255 hard facts!! Agree 100%

[@dextorus4719]

My favourite is bf4

[@Devinn504]

@@jerrychappell255 Only thing better about 1 is the graphics

[@redtord7194]

I played Battlefield 4 and liked it a lot even if I'm not a very big fan of futuristic first person shooters. Although I gotta say Battlefield 1 gives a WWI atmosphere so as a World War enjoyer I really like it.

[@qwerty65432168]

Battlefield 1 all day long, just for the atmosphere. the weather, the dirt on the gun, it's just all-around better. I just installed BF5 the other day and the maps suck ass as they are very big and bland.

[@shart69420]

Yes

[@redtord7194]

yea it just gives more of a World War vibe and that darker lightning, it just fits.

[@rahul-qm9fi]

I just played bf5 and this is the most irritating thing. The maps are huge yet they are so underutilized.

[@hayrantavares]

This Battlefield V looks like a Battle Royale, giant maps, where few people are working together to cooperate with the objective. What saves it are the maps on expansion by pacific islands.

[@kixakii436]

The only immersion i get on bf5 is when i'm playing as a fighter plane

[@planetari7607]

Alternative title: why I like BF1

[@Hellbryan1]

You mean: why Battlefield 1 is way superior to Battlefield v

[@Sweatedsiren895]

@Petice PH because Battlefield 1 is Sooo good , and Battlefield V is Designed to fail

[@carrops]

@@Sweatedsiren895 designed to fail? Hard to believe that bf5 is a failure when it has a higher player count than bf1

[@adamelestratega]

@@carrops well if your game dosent have a higher player count than a 5 year old game then something isnt right

[@carrops]

@@adamelestratega i was just pointing out the flaws with saying that bf1 is the best battlefield ever and bf5 is a failure when bf5 has a higher player count than bf1. And 5 years really isn't a very long time when it comes to these kinds of big hit games. Gta5, csgo, wow, league, the souls games, and many others are proof of that. Bf5 also came out only 2 years after bf1 fyi

[@Omar-Asim]

The BF1 intro is one of the most iconic intros in gaming. Truly amazing.

[@123cez123]

Completely agree with your points and view, for me BF1 still is an amazing game. After playing BF2042 Open Beta I immediately jumped in BF1 to wash that awful taste.

[@Randomstlhero]

BF2042 wasn’t any good?

[@123cez123]

@@Randomstlhero in hindsight we know that they given us a bare bones BF2042 Open Beta, which was bleak. I had to wash the taste from BF2042 Open Beta with BF1. Will wait and see how BF2042 will be at launch, which from previews look like a different game than the Open Beta.

[@hrthrhs]

Let's hope the awful taste in our mouths is temporary. I really want 2042 to carry on what was great about 1, even what was great about V but my experience from the Beta made me genuinely sad haha.

[@jishddx2481]

@kartoffel Salat let's wait

[@arcanusluvalus1388]

so how is everyone liking 2042? just want an update

[@soumyajitroy5239]

Bf1 campaign was very good, felt like a real war. Bf5 was sometimes too much inaccurate. Multiplayer in both games are fun ngl

[@Gamofran]

I hope bf 2042 failure make Dice developers to focuse more on simulation and historical accuracy again. We should stop all this arcade allucination

[@JohnJohn-bz1lq]

Inaccurate? battlefield 1 had a ww2 Motor

[@CCP-Lies]

@@JohnJohn-bz1lq it's not 100% accurate

[@gerrardbg3052]

@@JohnJohn-bz1lq wait really?

[@deerecoyote2040]

Same

[@SVT_LIGHTNING]

Bf1 hands down the best battlefield to date imo. And Yes I’ve played them and yes I think it’s better than 3 and 4. Bf1 is a masterpiece.

[@scfcfamily2153]

i would argue that bf1 is one of the best if not the best shooter game of all time. It’s realistic and has so much immersion i find myself cranking my sound up till it shakes my house to feel like i’m there 🤣

[@scfcfamily2153]

@BlueWarHead name a more realistic triple a title

[@okiean1321]

@@scfcfamily2153 not triple a but games like squad is way more realistic

[@Zesmas]

@@scfcfamily2153 Verdun.....red orchestra......battlefield 1942......Squad.......Arma........hell let loose......Heros and Generals......Post scriptum...... do I need to say more?

[@wikz8480]

@@Zesmas Half of those aren’t even triple A

[@alexschmidt5612]

With BF1 it feels like the developers loved the game, the small details that they didn’t need to add but did, especially with the guns. In BF5 they just didn’t care. For example in BF1 you could hold down the trigger on the M97 trench gun and it would slam fire like an actual M97, they didn’t need to do that, but when you find it you can’t help but smile. The M97 trench gun in BF5? Yeah that feature is nowhere to be seen. And that’s just one of the countless little things they did in BF1

[@tufflucal4037]

+Alex Schmidt BF5 was a victim of its time. The push for cosmetics, women in video games, etc. I Also think BF5 was rushed. BF1 was a different story. The fan base was tired of modern warfare and futuristic if you will. It is not surprising the ambitions were a lot more recognized and favored for its BOOTS ON THE GROUND GAMEPLAY, over its competitor, COD Infinite Warfare. Which btw, is actually a good game, story wise. Its a shame that it didn't get the love that it deserved at launch. So while BF5 may be the unfavorable BF game, it did had some moments and improvements over BF1. Their particle based system and raytracing were the big ones. The destruction, got MY attention mostly as building or houses would crumble realistically, while BF1 still had this BF bad company design overall where you could just blow up holes in walls and that's it. The zeppelins were a nice touch however. Others like the full body awareness dialed up a notch in BF5, like when prone crawling backwards. I think other animations like climbing up ledges and running while crouch was also new compared to BF1?! Guns acted more realistic because of its setting, something that ACTUALLY really really bothered me when playing BF1. But yes, I'm not a fan that the ambitions for this game was and still is, not there. The Story is POOR compared to BF1. The maps were uninspired and boring.

[@lotte2899]

BF5 has more small details like mud and snow sticks to clothes. Footsteps and stuff. BF1 has less detail but seems more realistic still

[@ramiere1412]

you can slam fire in bfv. you’ve obviously never played the game so why talk about it

[@zzodysseuszz]

Bfv has the same thing. It just doesn’t have the same atmosphere and sound design. People literally only like bf1 bc it manipulates you into thinking it’s fun with superficial things like visuals. When in reality it’s a broken mess of a game with horrible game design that rewards scummy bullshit like spawn trapping. The fact that I can throw an incendiary grenade at an area and then run into an enemy objective from the opposite side and then wait bc players will spawn at that spot and instantly die is just the most unfair game design in an fps. Hell sometimes I can just aim at that spot and they’ll spawn in my sights.

[@alexschmidt5612]

@@zzodysseuszz BF1 isn’t perfect for sure. But it doesn’t trick you into a good time with small details, it’s legitimately one of the best online FPS games. And no I’m not a try hard or a dirty player, if I see someone spawn I give them a 5 second head start before shooting. From the small details, to maps and gameplay it’s a masterpiece.

[@VanderSNeto]

As someone from Brasil, the 7x1 score hits hard.

[@SirNoobWulf]

I was just thinking this lol xD Germany really did a number on y'all

[@BigZaddy_]

😂😂😂😂

[@ahmedazhar8485]

lol 😂

[@youssefkassabi]

😭😭😭

[@AverageJ1]

B5 is too bright for it to be taken seriously in a war. B1 is a perfect mixture of bright colors while still maintaining a war look to it. B5 has an interesting gun gameplay. B5 has red dots that you can just put on your gun without a rail. B1 doesn't have red dots because it really wasn't invented in WW1 unless you are talking about a sniper scope. B1 has THE BEST sound design.

[@ramiere1412]

the sun disappears when people start shooting at each other? yes bf1 does have red dots.

[@Azzi_0161]

BF1 by far. It’s an actual representation of WW1 for the most part and doesn’t contain any political correct bs. Great Campaign too.

[@simonjohansson248]

An actual representation of ww1 would be sitting in a muddy trench being very bored and wanting to go home. Bf1 is a war hero fantasy, like most games!

[@Azzi_0161]

@@simonjohansson248 True, I didn't say it was 100% but it's certainly a better representation than bf5 and feels much more immersive. (In my opinion)

[@KrishnaGUPTA-bx7pw]

I disagree it was great, but ww1 verdun was the most realistic one. But yeah bf1 is a better game ofc

[@peksn]

oh cmon stop it with the political correct bs, you the type of guy who thinks a girl wearing actual armour in a game is political correctness Everything out there is political correctness watch out dont get triggered

[@jadynescobar9118]

It’s not realistic at all, it’s more of a steampunk fantasy ww1

[@jamiecurnock2910]

Bf1 excelled in immersion, audio & operations Bfv for movement & gunplay Why couldn't they combine them and throw in a bf4 setting I'll never know.

[@RodderickPrinceParker]

😂😂😂

[@Lord_ofcinder]

but rather we get 2042 which is an abominition in every aspect. Not one aspect of both these games they took and made it well infact infact they took everything battlefield stood for and shat on it and called it a love letter. More like an eviction notice.

[@IcyVeinsWithin]

Facts

[@rileyadams1]

BF1 for gunplay very easily and I prefer the more simple movement its way more realistic BF5 only for customisation that’s it

[@weirdchamp7790]

bf1 is so immersive, behemoths are so cool imagine running on a zipline while its burning down

[@Dime_time333]

The zeppelin would fall rapidly. Therefore taking the tension off the zipline. Making it useless and you fall to your death lol

[@alexnowicki286]

That’s what ruined the game for me those bs trains while bfv went back to more fair approach now I get killed by skilled players than a battleship on the other side of the map

[@AssassinIsAfk]

@@alexnowicki286 the battleships make more sense from a realism perspective but from a game perspective it was a bit unfair getting mass killed by a battleship or a zeplin or even a armoured train. However let's not forget the AA tank in bf5 which was just essentially a way to farm kills from across the map.

[@alexnowicki286]

@@AssassinIsAfk dude that pales in comparison it’s not even close 1 guy can take that thing out compared to the battleship and armor train.

[@AssassinIsAfk]

@@alexnowicki286 dude I really prefer the battleships and the armoured trains and zeplins since they make it at least fair when your team is losing and the enemy team is winning. Plus battlefield 1is full of hackers now that use aimbot.

[@pandito46]

The thing with planes in Bf1 is that you don't really need a stationary AA gun, just 2 or 3 supports can easily take down any plane in a matter of seconds, not to mention the assault AA cannon and the artillery truck AA variant. For this reason I feel Bf1 planes are pretty well balanced

[@Lajos_Kelemen]

I forgot just how much damage you can do to planes with an LMG in BF1, unlike in BF5 where you need an AA

[@puma2334]

In bfv you can fight back against planes way more imo

[@mattgolka6266]

Say that to the cluster height bombers

[@hiigherup]

i took bf1 for granted when it first came out. i probably spent about 200 or so hrs into it and i went back to playing bf4.. but man i went back a couple months ago and its now one of my favorite fps shooters of all time next to halo 3 and mw2. truly a masterpiece game. not to mention the incredible war stories single player. that intro with hud off is one of the best openings to any game. its so emotional and surreal to how frontline firefights were probably like. bf1 is amazing to say the least

[@shirleyracing5283]

It was the most immersed I’ve been in any video game. A truly incredible experience

[@deerecoyote2040]

This is exactly my experience with the game. Also I love Halo 3 and MW2.

[@pietrobonaldo]

Unfortunately the mcc version of Halo 3 is full of sweats who have been playing halo since it came out so it's rlly hard getting into it

[@deerecoyote2040]

@@pietrobonaldo Yeh, I played back on the day, but played mostly wacky customs and forge. So me with a 0.85 KD vs guys with 2-3 KDs.

[@pietrobonaldo]

@@deerecoyote2040 yeah now I just play infinite since it's pretty new so not many sweats that know every inch of the map

[@kingjames7904]

This video made me buy bf1 missed that game so to hear it’s still active was the last straw

[@Skellissaint]

It's plenty active, I'm on almost every day and full lobbies aren't hard to find

[@BasilFawlty3]

Conquest, operations and tdm are active. Not so much on other gamemodes

[@studmuffin3264]

@@BasilFawlty3 no rush?

[@BasilFawlty3]

@@studmuffin3264 you can find like one server occasionally or a couple when it shows up in weekly rotation

[@almightynova4095]

bf 1 is by far the only dice game i've ever played that have a good campaign, the multiplayer of course for both games are fun and addictive the first couple hour

[@AlluringPegasu13]

bruh you saying u enjoyed it ?huh its one of the worst campaigns you can get both 1 and 5 have shit campaings lol

[@gamecazm4025]

@@AlluringPegasu13 everyone have different tastes suppose that I have only play minecraft in my life then minecraft would be the best game ever made for me..... Hope you get it

[@AlluringPegasu13]

@@gamecazm4025 hmm but many people like majority agree that battlefield campaigns are bad dice knows to made good singleplayer like mirrors edge but its completly different game

[@gamecazm4025]

@@AlluringPegasu13 glad someone has mentioned mirrors edge it was the first campaign game that I completed...... And although majority doesn't like it but they were pretty decent.....

[@AlluringPegasu13]

@@gamecazm4025 yeah there were moments which were bad especially the combat sections I think they thought without guns a game won't sell well lol, I liked both first one and catalyst both were great do you can understand dice knows how to make campaigns but their battlefield ones are bad , when I play battlefield campaign I remember the combat sections of mirrors edge which were boring

[@t10god]

BF1 was amazing. BF5, I feel like I can't even see what's happening, everything is too fast and too slow at the same time, I have all the information on my screen except for information that I need like the spotting mechanism every soldier possessed in BF1... BF5 is absolutely chocked with nonsense weaponry too. I never see people using the traditional arsenal, just the Sturmgewehr 1-5.

[@adamelestratega]

why use other weapons if the Sturmgewehr is literally the best weapon in the game, thats something that i dont like

[@manwithballsonarm6775]

@@adamelestratega there all the same man it doesn't matter what gun I used on it. It shot the same it sounded the same.I did just as good no matter what weapon because there all the same

[@yesdude3914]

I played 2-3 rounds of BFV recently, and it was literally just a 'meta' experience. Everyone was laying prone just camping in the same spots every match, literally their asses backed up vertically against the fucking corners of buildings/structures etc. couldn't even see enemies until you get to a choke point where a bunch of lmg sweat-lords camp the entire match with their golden guns and lvl 300 cringe skull-bearing gamertag...its like every map and mode in bfv is a similar experience. No ones running around causing chaos or having fun, its just a sweaty and meta experience

[@lumbagoboi1649]

Definitely, you explained the major issue I had with bf5... It felt so fast and incoherent, like there was no real organization to the team other than just sprinting around spamming the slide button hoping some sweat doesn't evaporate you in under a second. Bf1s slower limited movement, and clear battle lines really helped the team play.

[@dromedda6810]

I got bf1 yesterday and I've really been enjoying the atmosphere and immersion I spent a good 5 hours yesterday screaming curse words in german while looking at the explosions

[@syatek]

I expected BFV to look and feel like BF1 just in WWII and boy was I disappointed.

[@RodderickPrinceParker]

I was surprised when it wasn’t just a WW2 BF1. How’d they mess that up?

[@syatek]

@@RodderickPrinceParker typically change of talent at the developer studio - the old DICE we loved is long gone and they literally have people from Candy Crush and FIFA running the Battlefield franchise now

[@hobgoblin6551]

These are honestly the only battlefield games I can really get into, simpler and more exciting gameplay compared to some of the other games

[@biologicalengineoflove6851]

Gas, bayonets, cavalry. Quite a unique fps, and WWII gets so much attention, but we rode into the Great War on horses and out of it on tanks. BF1's greatness has inspired many to delve into the often forgotten history of WWI which played a definitive role in shaping the modern world. The Great War is still a stellar KZbin channel. Beneath Hill 60 is one of many great WWI flicks. Poilu, the journal of Louis Barthas, barrelmaker, who was in the trenches through much of the conflict is a fantastic read.

[@DaveWithAKnife]

I'd say BF1 on average has better war stories, but BFV does have "The last Tiger" arguably the best war story between both games.

[@darkfirevr523]

BF1 had the plane war story then BFV had the tank one, I say both are good in their own right. (Still prefer the Tiger though because it kinda shows how the Germans thought on the last bit of the war.)

[@pretzelkch8322]

BFV was a good game, but BF1 was a special, unique sorta good game. Probably why they have about equally active player bases even though one has a few years over the other.

[@burgbass]

They’re also entirely different time periods. Some people may prefer the history of WWI over WWII or vice versa.

[@Anonymous71892]

BF5 felt bland to me. Maps were huge but boring

[@almightynova4095]

hey master assassin isnt it time for you to finally rank the assassins creed franchise from worst to best

[@Amoroph]

Got battlefield V for free with prime gaming recently, played it for about 4 rounds and got matched with hackers on the other team 3 out of the 4 times and some visual glitches in all of them. Battlefield one came with my xbox about 5 years ago and haven't encountered very much glitches and the campaign was super enjoyable to replay for someone who didn't have xbox live. Battlefield V's campaign was finished in 2 hours and was pretty boring. Battlefield one is 100% my favorite of the bunch

[@friendlyatheist9589]

Lucky you i also have amazon prime but mfs don't give gaming perks

[@georgs4656]

@@friendlyatheist9589 lol sad monkee vibes ): i hope that i could too get those perks

[@qpwoeiruty850]

Battlefield 1 was the first Battlefield game I ever played and I bought it after 5 had come out. Tons of players. Stunning sounds and visuals. I played it with a 2080 ti and my jaw dropped at the sights it gave me!!!! I was a terrible player, unable to hit my targets so though it was a lot of fun I didn't dive deep in the game. A bit overwhelming as a first time player.

[@checkario-uw6cw]

You can actually choose a novice server，called“noob ”

[@duryan3956]

Two years back when hating on BF5 was popular, love how people grew to love the game, and now it's pretty much as good as BF1.

[@GRGCompletionist]

Hope you'll try out the MGS franchise at some time especially MGS V, the gameplay was so much fun i'm sure you'll like it!

[@ys0Minecraft]

Iplayed it for 12 h and then deleted because it was SOOO BOORING

[@alexandercalderon824]

Stfu those games are so old.

[@Directorschair553]

@@alexandercalderon824 sorta like you’re edgelord attitude..

[@FantasyNero]

You are SNAKE you should be on Metal Gear Solid.

[@sugoi9680]

@@ys0Minecraft WHAT. Why man?

[@vinayaks7994]

The immersion in BF1 is on another level. For eg open a custom map that has no people in it, you can see the artillery fires going of in a distance, plane flying above, men yelling in a distance etc; even if you are not in an actual match of bf1 you still feel like you are close to an actual match going on and is just heading to there. The actual gameplay is refined to perfection. When you are in a match, you dont feel like you are the one controlling everything or like the protagonist of a story of some sort, you are an infantry in a greater war with many other people just like you working for the same goal and the only time you feel like a leader is if you are the head of a group and is giving objectives, communicating with your teammates to do what is best and relaying info to one another. That is when you need a "leader" experience and that is exactly what you get. I could go on for hours about how great this game is but I dont have enough time so I'll wrap this up with saying "Just buy it, you will not regret any one second of it"

[@OSIRIS_0]

Do you know BFV also had background design 👍 and each game can be made to what you just said it all just depends for your feel for it I personally enjoy BFV because LMG aren’t broken in it compared to BF1

[@rileyadams1]

@@OSIRIS_0they aren’t game breakingly strong if that’s you’re biggest problem you’re just hating

[@AndyKunkel]

I think movement mcehanics should play a role in the scoring system. I would give that one to BFV. Crouch run is an awesome mechanic and the mounting and lunging in BFV makes it the best movement system for a BF game ever, if not one of the best movement systems for an FPS game in general.

[@tyleryoung306]

100% everyone sleeps on how incredibly fluid the movement physics were. Hands down the best in the franchise, and the best in any FPS game. When you play it, and you go back and play the Bad Company's, BF3&4, you realize how far we've come with movement, and why we can never go back lol.

[@ronburgundy8174]

Yeah, the movement may have been ok but the gun engagements themselves and the bizarre deaths were so bad that the movement doesn't even matter. I swear there's EOMM in this game.

[@L.P.1987]

Nah, BF1 shows how decisive the attack planes and bombers could be in a battle, and encourages the opposite team to make antiair estrategies (like teamworking between fighters and AA guns).

[@adamelestratega]

well i can confirm

[@figgy_9611]

True, that’s what I love about bf1. If your team isn’t able to pivot and focus on taking out a really good fighter pilot or take out snipers that have been wrecking your team, there is a good chance you’ll lose the game. It’s not just about blindly running to an objective and trying to kill as many people as possible. Gotta play smart and with your team!

[@adaada7318]

are you kidding right? I dropped million times a huge bomb on a single guy and did 50% damage,same goes with tank cannon on plane I am pretty sure in a real battle the guy would be in at least half

[@L.P.1987]

@@adaada7318 Uhmmm... that's weird.d I usually get tens of kills on airplanes. Even if it's not 100% realistic, it's still a great proof of the value of airplanes.

[@adaada7318]

@@L.P.1987 if you want that then play bf5 I am pretty sure you will feel the value of planes

[@santiagomartiinezdevotto7226]

the fact that Battlefield 1, is the only triple AAA shooter game in the first world war, and not another clonic shooter game gives it a special vibe, the graphic style is more realistic, sound and ambience are 10/10

[@cristobalsoza7298]

Battlefield 5 in its current state is pretty good and solid, but battlefield 1 is just superior

[@TheGreenDragon.]

I don't think bf1 will ever be beat. Imo it's the best shooter game ever made

[@og_sane]

Around 2min mark you talked about the immersion in BFV vs BF1 and its true, Dice made some huge mistakes with including unrealistic stuff in BFV. The biggest fail for me are the nydar sights for SMG's and other weapons. So many players use them and they really seem to help with the recoil. I'm on of the few who choose to make the game a bit harder and use iron sights for SMG's, always. The gunplay is otherwise great in BFV, for me even better than in BF1. I've been playing V more than 1, but it's often a hard choice. In 1 the atmosphere is better, but it also has it flaws. Not the atmosphere, but other things. It's a huge shame how Dice gave up on BFV and we never got the Eastern front etc...

[@jbragg1001]

The definitive thing for me was that bfV was just TOO clean. Firing the guns feels like using a BB gun. Another example that really changed it for me that I only noticed while watching this is the edges of ur screen when under fire. BfV the edges go white for some reason, as opposed to the blackout tunnel vision look in bf1. Just makes it look so much grittier and like ur rly in ww1

[@thegamingbean953]

I find the opposite for me, BF1 for me was like shooting nerf guns

[@theTF2sniper]

BF1 will forever be one of my favourite FPS games, So many great memories and moments, i truly hope the servers stay populated for many years to come. BFV Was a missed opportunity in my book, If they took the basis from BF1 and put it in a WW2 setting, i believe the game would be allot more succesfull then it was. Kind of like a Fallout 3, Fallout New vegas kind of story, when you found a good formula, work to perfect it, dont change it.

[@checkario-uw6cw]

确实是这样子，这个制作组没有像做战地一样那样用心，如果像战地一样做战地二的话，那可能是新的神作

[@rileyadams1]

Are you referring to fallout 4? You’re not one of those 3 over NV ‘people’ are you?

[@francischarron4218]

Battlefield 1 all the way, the only thing I wish they did with BF 1 was for each dlc they should have had a new war story link to what that dlc represent

[@adamelestratega]

it would be great to actually play the german campaing in Verdun or the austro hungarians in galitzia, or even the White russians in the civil war

[@joshmohrbach8657]

Agree 100%. Recently went back to bf1. It’s still so good. Was considering trying bf5 again but I don’t have it on ps5 so I was dabbling with the idea of rebuying it but thank you for talking me out of it lol

[@tatumwilliams2192]

98% disagree, I’d give bf5 all points in these categories. Aside from the campaign which I don’t care for in either game, bf5 by far surpasses bf1 in all the categories you listed. Bf1 feels cartoony and bf5 is the best ww2 game I’ve ever played. Perfectly captures the guns, maps and chaos of the second world war while bf1 has horses running around the map while everyone is using fully automatic guns in 1917. Bf1 is still a good game but bf5 takes the cake when it comes to capturing what I want from a battlefield game set during the 20th century. Bf5 all day

[@jordan9292]

Lmao about time someone kept it real in this comment section. I’m with you 100% when he scored BF1 7-1 or whatever it was I LOL’d. It’s not that big of a disparity but I could understand how someone would like 1 better but not 7-1 that’s just plain bias and not truly being objective.

[@polskaoperator376]

BF5 is an unimmersive mess, yes, look at our Germans who's flag and symbols are all from the German Empire. Let's have the US Marines call each-other 'soldier' and say the most stereotypical shit ever. The running feels to fast and light, as if all of the characters weigh 20 pounds and can just glide on the floor. Why complain about the soldiers using SMGs in BF1 when bolt-guns were still the main service weapons of countries in 1944. Hans wouldn't be running around with an StG-44 that has a holographic, he'd have a Kar98k. Young McMillan wouldn't have a Bren, he'd have a Lee-Enfield. Self-loading rifles only became standard in the mid-1950s with things like the G3 and FAL.

[@jordan9292]

@@polskaoperator376 BFV BF1 movement are almost identical and maybe slightly more airy than Bf4 or 3 but have you played BF2042?? Talk about being 20 pounds and being able to bunny hop and slide everywhere like a cod game… BFV still has pretty heavy weight to it and when you hop your character actually has hard time getting back to aiming down sight. And yeah bolt rifles were more the main service weapon but smgs and automatic guns were highly highly more common in world war 2. To the point where it makes sense to put them in the game BF1 is a strong reach. Either way respect your opinion but on the movement I just don’t see it go play a cod game or BF2042 and you’ll know what light feels like BFV is still heavy and clunky

[@polskaoperator376]

@@jordan9292 Well I simply pretend that 2042 didn't actually release and that it was all a fever dream.

[@jordan9292]

@@polskaoperator376 🤣🤣🤣 that’s a fair way to look at it I can’t blame ya for that I lost 70 bucks falling into the hype

[@thathalflatino]

Bf1 beats bfv in almost every case aside from movement I do prefer the movement in bfv tho for some reason

[@Jesus4Guitar]

BF5 is one of the best looking games ever made. It looks better than BF1, its close, but BF5 edges by. Gameplay is definitely better in V for me as well,, along with the vehicles.

[@sally2395]

@@Jesus4Guitar BF5 looks terrible compared to bf1 what the hell

[@thegamerfe8751]

@@sally2395 Dude go see an ophthalmologist 💀

[@lordeddy05]

0:36 idk from what game that soundtrack is, but the music is amazing!

[@ottomansempire3083]

Battlefield 1

[@GRGCompletionist]

Battlefield 1942 theme will always be the best though!

[@ottomansempire3083]

@@GRGCompletionist it came out before i was born, soooooooo

[@VendPrekmurec]

Atmosphere in BF1... i was blown away. I still play it almost every day when i come home

[@nimeetkumardhir5558]

Please make a video about metal gear franchise it has the best stealth games with great convoluted stories. You will definitely love them!! There is even an AC easter egg in mgs peace walker

[@Galithrania]

I honestly think that players blend in equally well in both games. Sniper glimts are much easier to spot in BF1 though, and the larger "fortify your objectives" maps in BFV personally gives BFV a huge win for me.

[@beanother1an690]

Depends. The skins and stuff for BFV can stand out in certain environments and get you spotted, although the winter maps of BF1 can fuck you up if you're fighting in the open, because dark uniforms on a white, snowy backdrop sucks, and the Soviets learned this the hard way in the Winter War.

[@Joeldcn]

1500 hours in BF1, 900 in BFV. BF1 its just the best FPS ever made....BUT BFV got better gunplay. No random bullet deviation. And got TONS of vehicles. And better sniping ( but no Martiny ) The big factor are maps: BF1 has way more good maps, and more maps in general. The atmosphere its simply amazing. Conclussion: BF1 its a masterpiece, BFV its a really good multiplayer FPS.

[@polskaoperator376]

The random bullet deviation was an actual thing, guns in the 1910s very often caused flyers. If I can snipe with the optical Cei Rigotti, you guys shouldn't have an issue and I'm not even good at FPS games. Maybe I have an easier time dealing with it because I'm big into guns and it helps with immersion I dunno...

[@Sweatedsiren895]

Battlefield V gunsplay take no skill to use

[@dasportsfan2122]

Everyone gangsta till battlefield 2042 rolled around and make these games feel like game of the year

[@CunningStuntsGoFast]

battlefield 5 is aparently a good shooter . but it has no ww2 feel , no battlefield feel and it has no soul . a good game some say but i was done with it after 4 weeks and went back to bf1 . trying to get the hang of bf2042 now but i wont rule out having enough of that if they dont fix it quick

[@UdithaMelanMahindarathna]

BF1 is the most immersive battlefield experience ever in the franchise! I completely agree with your comparison!

[@Haris.nycc1]

Bf1 and bf3 best multiplayer games ever Bf1 has such a charm

[@bersrk_josx-1337]

I don't really think anyone would argue with these points tbh, battlefield 5 was definitely a step backwards which could've been perfectly fixed if they kept adding content instead of dropping the game at just half of its lifetime in order to focus on making an even worse half-baked thing that took them three years to fix. And still, despite V and 2042 being playable and enjoyable nowadays, they still can't beat BF1 and 4

[@devontegreen421]

I just deleted battlefield V, and now I'm downloading battlefield 1!!!💯🔥

[@elite6848]

Shit move

[@ufcsabbath412]

Just did that and it's not collecting

[@aarontexeira7408]

I've only played battlefield five on console but something about it has me HOOKED

[@georgs4656]

Battlefield 1 is masterpiece, i think, one of if not then the best games ever made.

[@addr1algørithm]

Glad that I stumbled on this video comparison.

[@Mina_the_Doll]

I prefer the movement from Battlefield V much more It's hard for me to go from Battlefield V to Battlefield 1 bc it gives a whole new control system im confused with since im used to sliding and fast crouching Thats why I mostly go back to Battlefield V

[@iCoolaxe]

BF1 is better to me just because it has operations, best game mode I've ever played in any BF game hands down.

[@Mina_the_Doll]

@@iCoolaxe i agree operations is rlly fuggn cool

[@onionshakingapillow4268]

i agree, after playing v you forget that crouch running and diving forward isnt in 1

[@gamerDnoob47]

I really love your comparisons. Your videos are like a good source for me. Like if you say earth is flat, I be like, this is absolutely right. I should change my way of looking the earth.

[@EastSideBlitz1337]

BF1 is not only better than bf5 but it's also one of the greatest FPS made IMO.

[@vSkreamer]

Agreed with everything u pointed out. Good video brotha.

[@samarth1698]

I love BF5 i have played both for 100+ hours . The Story Mod of BF1 is amazing but when it comes to multiplayer i love bf5

[@bozopennywize]

agree

[@samarth1698]

@@bozopennywize ty man

[@masteroftheblaster9523]

So bfv has a more fun multiplayer experience?

[@Romulus84]

@@masteroftheblaster9523 It's just a better shooter. If you like fast, good and accurate shooting and movement, the BFV is the best. In this game, skills and reflesk count, if you like it, you will like five.

[@Romulus84]

@samarth I love BFV too, I have something like 3000 hours in it. My nickname is 19romulus84, maybe you met me?

[@slayermate07]

it's like comparing resident evil 5 with resident evil 4. Some may love the former but the entire industry knows which one is the all time classic.

[@Drzahman]

from someone playing since Battledield 1942 (in cafes) I am glad of BF1's return

[@shahzzz_gaming7803]

Dude you should be able to get millions of subscribers. Love this series. ❤️❤️

[@kurasol7908]

After playing both games for a similar number of hours, I can definitely say that I enjoyed Bf5 more. Immersion isn’t a very big factor for me since it breaks after the first 10-100 hours and when it breaks, you can definitely start seeing Bf1’s balance problems a lot more. Bf1’s guns have an extremely big difference in TTK due to large variance in firerate and damage, which is not as big of an issue in 5. Tanks are also something I love in 5. Bf1’s tanks were more like mobile spawn points with the ability to shoot whereas 5’s tanks are a lot more mobile and will need your support as much as you need their’s.

[@MattGG_21]

Let's be true.The guns in BF1 are kinda slow,even if they're balanced.And the BF5 campaign has more emotional parts.BF5 is better in my opinion.

[@dl30wpb]

Battlefield 5 was the beginning of the end for the franchise. Total flop of a game

[@MattGG_21]

@@dl30wpb O yea?I think you're a flop,because you don't know how to respect a game that's made with brain.

[@adamelestratega]

i dont like playing whit a tank and needing someone to be able to enjoy it, im a solo player and relying in other people is not a good idea, in BF1 tanks are there to support the push and thats why they are mobile spawn points, but your teamates are basically that but whitout armor

[@lalazazaff]

thinking of which one to buy, this really showed me, thanks!

[@cosmefulanito9388]

I am missing a very important question, the best thing that bfv has is mobility, resupply centers and revive your fallen teammates (although the animation would change) and weapon specializations allow you to play in different ways. Point aside is the balance. BFV is not a good game but the design of the flags allows you to go different ways. BF1 is a very good game but the gameplay isn't all that good either. The sweet spot and explosive respaw take your patience away. Not to mention the excessive AA on consoles.

[@BonoImFaded]

the medic system also seems a lot better in bf1. Its easier which encourages slightly more revives. This is more personal, but I appreciate how bf1 is a lot slower paced, you can't really run and gun that well, even as assault (other then fort veaux). Camping also never felt like that huge of an issue, and the guns (especially sniper and medic class) are truly that satisfying.

[@CaesarAugustus27_]

"bf1 weapons are balanced" Me: *Gets mowed down by hellreigels and telescopic weapons 200 yards away.*

[@alamo134]

Hellreigel? Raise to Annihilator and SMG 08/18. Plus MG1917 telescopic.

[@zakkmarchant]

Shot guns casually having the same effectiveness as the kolibri

[@hrthrhs]

Looking forward to your Battlefield 1 vs Battlefield 2042 vid 😉

[@turdgoblin6113]

Battlefield 1 is the absolute best damn Battlefield game ever!! Been playing battlefield since 2003 and bf1 by far was the absolute best.

[@michael.waddell]

Your content is great man, definitely deserve more subs over here!

[@hjrmedia9062]

I am not going into any debate cause my pc can't run any one of them😢😢 but for future this video might be helpful, and I watch all the videos anyway.. just love the videos..❤

[@sunilkumarsingh9933]

@icantthinkofaname my is ryzen 3200u vega 3 graphics 2gb ram 8gb ram

[@DurdenTyler21]

After Battlefield 1, the talent at DICE Studios clearly exited…

[@igormnbr]

I agree with most of the points, but, one thing that always gets me is: why people hate camuflage? Not all FPS games should be easy to spot enemies. In fact, that's one of the things that makes me enjoy BF more than other FPS games. If you rush like Rambo, you probably gonna end up dying really quickly.

[@ollobot123]

Personally, I think BF5 is underrated, but Battlefield 1 just overshadows it in everyway possible

[@gamerboy4life684]

B1 is 10X times better we all know it B1 had such a good Campaign BV was kinda alright but B1 has planes flying weather and everything so we all know B1 is better.

[@Npcmike2521]

Another thing that's bad in bfvs maps is that they purposefully added spots where people can camp and snipe people just out of where the enemy team can go

[@Gdtji-09]

This seems very accurate lmao, now I like BF5 but it’s just ugh, frustrating and sometimes just not fun. But I always and I say ALWAYS have fun with BF1 idk why but I still find new things in BF1 and enjoy it

[@Romulus84]

I play a lot in BFV, my nickname is 19romulus84 maybe you've met me before?

[@onionshakingapillow4268]

if battlefield 1 had the movement and gunplay of 5 it would be perfect

[@bruhhhhmoment4848]

Going back to bf5 today after getting bf2042 it isn't as bad as a remember. There are some people still playing it had I was able to have fun. The plane combat somehow feels slower than bf1 but it isn't as bad as bf2042 plane combat. So what I am saying is bf5 may not be the best bf but it isn't as bad as we might remember it.

[@AntDaGreatest]

BF1 was magical, nostalgic. Logging into my console and seeing BO3, BF1, pvz garden warfare, assassins creed unity, and gta v was something I miss.

[@jimmyjohns8737]

Just go download them again and play them! There are still people playing Nintendo 64 to this day because that’s what they like :)

[@ilmonachefabestemmiaregerm6364]

Battlefield 1 campaign: Accurate, a mix of moments between loud war and stealth. Battlefield V campaign: Stealth, Stealth, Stealth, Stealth, Stealth... Did I say that it's Stealth?

[@igotisekaid5699]

I downloaded BF5 two weeks ago and I agree it does have its moments but it doesn’t satisfy me the same way BF1 does. Im also glad there are more people playing it these days. You can literally find a ton of servers

[@evobsm2328]

What you failed to mention is historical accuraccy im sorry but if i ever see one more laser dot sight on a ww2 weapon im gonna flip

[@FAULOU13]

This is like comparing mona lisa to an drawing of a 4 year old man

[@thebeldam5823]

I've put wayyyy too much time into BF1. I haven't had this much fun since MW2!

[@gabrielangelos2877]

I'm level 100 in bf5 and recently bought bf1 on sale. I can already say that bf1 is a better game. So if you are having seconds thoughts or need advice there you go. Play bf1 game is amazing

[@VampireJoe]

Same for me, I feel the only downside of "Battlefield 1" is that the infantry really lacks air defense capabilities.

[@DrFear-ey5wx]

Man idk Anti Air Guns are really OP and if you have 2 people with machineguns you can already shoot down a plane pretty easily I think the tanks are actually a bit too weak and the stationairy AA guns should be nerfed they are seriously OP

[@usedsweatpants799]

Not so sure about that. You have the burton with incendiary rounds on the support class , the anti air rocket in the assault class and K bullets in the sniper class. Not to mention that ALL infantry guns cause damage to planes . I’ve downed many planes with all sorts of weapons . Even hand grenades

[@Go-Big-Red]

I have been playing bf1 for almost 4 years straight, and i didn't get bored yet.

[@user-rf5px3gh3p]

Battlefield’s sweet spot is old, classic warfare. Battlefield 2042 just doesn’t feel the same. Also, the maps are way too vertical in 2042. It’s also not as easy to see the other players if that makes any sense… they all are too small. Not sure how to explain it but something in BF1 and BF5 let you see your enemies better and it was easier to see where they all were coming from and get more kills.

[@michalhruz8734]

I can't help myself but I feel like BF V's gameplay is more like Call of Duty than Battlefield. Same goes for the soldier customization... I like BF1 a lot, mainly because of the immersive gameplay and weapons. Each weapon has unique abilities, you can't play with just one weapon on almost every map.

[@keithdaniels7491]

I can't help but feel this is a Fanboy for BF1 video. I understand immersion of course.....

[@eggypatrick5875]

BF1 has a better atmosphere, better maps, and better war stories. BFV has better movement, better gun play, better customization (for guns and characters), better destruction, and a all around more responsive feel. They both have their own strengths and weaknesses, both great games in my eyes.

[@polskaoperator376]

How is the movement better?? It feels like the characters are plastic bags in the wind, they basically weigh nothing. It feels like CoD.

[@eggypatrick5875]

@@polskaoperator376 I’m just saying it’s a tad bit more responsive. It may not be realistic but it’s fun.

[@datnigga7445]

Bfv wasn’t that bad just wish they made it feel a lil more like ww2

[@smorcknight9547]

I just dont understand how can you like BF1 gunplay with that shity random spread. Its definitely better in BF5 at least because of it doesnt have that ridiculous random spread. In BF5 you have to LEARN how to properly shoot with each since every type of weapons has its own recoil. And im realy serious, there is not enough words to describe how much I hate random bullet spread in shooters, especially in multyplayer ones. Also you are wrong with balancing between ranges. You referenced real life that smgs is for close ranges and that its ridiculous that in BF5 smgs can shoot up to hundred of meters. Ok first - the most annoying for me, about realism - its actually the opposite: irl SMGs CAN shoot up to hundred of meters since the first smgs of WW1. So in this case BF5 is realistic while BF1 with its horrible mechanic called "random spread" is not. 1:43 - ok while I understand the thing about SMGs, but assault rifles? "Its supposed to be a close range weapon" - no its NOT since assault rifles can shoot even farther than SMGs. And the second - balance in BF1 is good in paper but bad in action since scouts just dominate the game in most of the maps using bad, made for camping casuals sweetspot mechanic. This is also one of the reasons why I dont like gunplay in BF1. Ok now customization. If I can some kinda understand your opinion about gunplay. But customization?! Im not going to write a lot on this one, but objectively BF1 DOESNT EVEN HAVE CUSTOMIZATION. You just pick bayonet or not, sight, recoil and skin. Thats all?? At least BF5 has customization and just a decent specialization mechanic. Anyway BF1 has the best graphics design, OST and atmosphere but no more. Overall balance, maps, gameplay and content is definitely better in BF5.

[@swifty6759]

😴😴😴

[@smorcknight9547]

@@swifty6759 ok

[@bluredstoneiii5594]

Its beacuse all thinks bfv sucks beacuse of the bad launch so they fake all

[@CheddarMannn]

Like... I absolutely prefer BF1, but I have to totally disagree in customization department. There's a difference between customization, and historical accuracy. In BF1 you have some camos and you can't customize weapons at all, but zoom and kick. BFV allows a MUCH better range of customization, and saying "Uuuh, it's not historically accurate" - it's not as big of a deal like making Germans not so bad in the campaign; 80% of players use machine guns in BF1, and there's no problem with what?

[@adamelestratega]

actually BF1 has more snipers than machinegunners

[@PomiDarQu]

One word. Immersion

[@coolamericano]

Perhaps the worst thing that Battlefield 1 ever did is that it set the cinematic bar so high for future games in the series. If people question why subsequent entries couldn't build on its success, it's because Battlefield 1 marked the pinnacle of a certain era at DICE, and for all intents and purposes it was no longer the same development team after that. Throughout 2018 and 2019, DICE went through serious changes and downscaling, experiencing what one former developer called a "mass exodus of talent". Who knows if the series will see those glory days restored, but for now Battlefield 1 continues to thrive (enjoying similar player numbers to Battlefield 2042, incidentally) and runs like a dream on modern hardware. Until DICE takes cues from the things that made it great, I'm going to stay hunkered down in these trenches.