Big Brother (US) - Ranking Every Player PART 4 (80-1)

[@nickfran348]

Props to you for doing this! personally I am very bias with your rankings but, respect for taking your time doing this.!

[@tzxyuaesthetics9338]

i've seen people question dan's legacy because of traitors but honestly being bad at traitors doesn't mean you're bad at big brother. cirie was masterful at traitors but just pretty good at big brother. honestly dan being willing to come back says more about his tenacity than someone like will who is only willing to make cameos 🤭

[@thecamishere4344]

he wasn't particularly great at Traitors but still... he wasn't immediately out and yes still had it in him with a killer instinct. Ppl who do rank him lower cuz of traitors can go tf to hell obviously

[@NovaContext]

@@thecamishere4344 it’s not that serious, why should they go to hell for that?

[@thecamishere4344]

​@@NovaContextbecause they don't understand the point of BB rankings and lose the big picture. Stupidity annoys me greatly

[@iconique08]

Just pretty good at Big Brother is one of the biggest understatements I’ve seen on Cirie.

[@caitr21]

@@iconique08i mean she did make some pretty questionable moves in bb, but i also think that it’s undermining how well she did

[@tajneeley]

Will is so overrated by the community. 😅

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

Not as much as Nicole Franzel is. Or Janelle in fact (this video does not overrate her but the community, wow).

[@voodoomcspaghettipants4082]

Thanks for 5 years Brandon! Every week I look forward to Wednesdays and Saturdays at noon. This was an awesome list and I will never get enough of your content. Bravo

[@dictatureduaevuxgi8619]

Brandon ?

[@totaldramasimmer1]

I don't see Kyland winning another season because he mentioned on a podcast that he would never cut Matt if he was in Jag's position which tells me everything I need to know. His ego is strong lol

[@JordanMC12]

Why would you in Jag’s position? It clearly paid off and Jag won. Lmaooo

[@totaldramasimmer1]

@@JordanMC12 he said it before the finale which also Jag himself thought he would lose to Matt

[@desmondcoppin591]

It worked out for jag, though. Meaning he’s right.

[@Joeiscool447]

Though I think Dr. Will is quite low on the list, for the most part I do agree with a lot of the list and I wanna commend you on your dedication to give us this content. Thank yew Meranian! 😁

[@thecamishere4344]

I definitely don't think he's below Nicole but in the top 5 at least is good enough or top 3

[@TransparentEclipse]

Enjoyed this large scale ranking, can’t wait until the next one!

[@WilsonReviews]

I look at Ian the same way I look at Adam Klein on survivor. I don’t think his game is bad, I just think his game is messy

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

His game is bad

[@patrickmexiquinn]

Adam is a scatter brain but a better social and strategic player. Ian comped out but maybe have saved us from a Jen City win 😂😂

[@MarsinMars]

​@@patrickmexiquinn If Ian didnt win out, maybe we wouldve seen a Dan win but Jenn City being a winner would be hillarious

[@birkarandhillon5059]

Both of their games are bad and messy

[@antoniomarcos2504]

Adam's Game > Ian's Game BY FAR And as a player the same is applied

[@grantgoffin4774]

Holly btw 100% beats Nicole if she cuts Jackson to take Nicole. The jury has confirmed this. Nicole probably beats her if she is the one to cut Jackson and take Holly which is the more likely scenario, but if she does cut Jackson she for sure beats Nicole. Still agree with all the criticsms of her game, and overall she is probably a bit overranked.

[@SurvivorxTWD]

Not true, Chrissy and Tommy said they vote Nicole over holly no matter what and she has LOCKED votes with kat Jessica and cliff

[@grantgoffin4774]

Nick, Chrissy, Tommy, Jess all said they vote whichever cut Jackson in that Final 2 in post show interviews. And in what world are Kat and Jess locked votes, LOL! Kat and Jess both even said they vote Tommy who they both HATE over Nicole in a Final 2, so likely would vote Holly over her too. Then you add Jackson, Analyse, Jack who are never voting Nicole in any Final 2.

[@dougierichardson484]

@@SurvivorxTWD Kat on Survivor reddit was asked about a Nicole-Tommy Final 2 and said Tommy wins 9-0 which I disagree with, I think it is 8-1 with Cliff voting Nicole). So safe to say she for sure votes Tommy over Nicole in a Final 2, so it is pretty obvious she votes Holly over Nicole then. She knows Holly in real life remember.

[@nizzle428]

@@SurvivorxTWDkat knew holly outside of the game though

[@rogerleblond499]

@@SurvivorxTWD You are lying. Tommy and Holly both said they vote whoever booted Jackson if Jackson and each other aren't there. And Jess and Kat never called themselves locked votes for Nicole in any Final 2, except maybe vs Jackson. They aren't locked for her vs any of Holly, Tommy, Cliff, Christie (Jess 100% votes Christie over Nicole in fact).

[@bluedevils481991]

Taylor is the only person from reindeer games that it impacted my opinion of her ability. Getting to see her play how she wanted to play coming in bb24 gave me faith she could handle any season. Take that with players would probably fear the backlash of sending Taylor out first on a comeback makes her set up well if she played again

[@thecamishere4344]

well according to Lala (and idgaf about a short and futile 6 week bs Reindeer games) her skillset isn't that good like ppl thought

[@austindynes99]

yeah taylors bottom 5 winners for sure

[@EdwardJarvis-be3ck]

Nicole Franzel being top 5 and Dr. Will being outside the top 5 already makes the entire list uncredible.

[@edenzachary454]

What a way to discredit the only woman in top 5, Dr Will is overrated and ISN'T a good player

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@edenzachary454 She shouldn't be the only women in the top 5, as she isn't even the best women player ever. Not even close. Maggie, Jun, Danielle, Vanessa are all better. Are if your barometer is "almost winning twice" then Jordan is better as she was closer to winning twice than Nicole is.

[@Total_Drama_Pups]

Just say you hate women and move on, he’s completely justified that Will is overrated

[@nks1384]

disliking one woman's playstyle = hating women

[@EdwardJarvis-be3ck]

@@Total_Drama_Pups Just say you are a blind Nicole fanatic like the video maker and move on. I have said many women were underranked on this list fool, just like your crush Nicole Franzel is badly overrated, which nearly everyone agrees on.

[@grantgoffin4774]

I agree with putting Tommy just above Cirie. For one thing I agree Tommy beats everyone in a jury vote for sure (against Nicole he wins 8-1, against Cliff he wins 8-1 or 7-2, against Jackson he gets Christie, Analyse, Nick, Jack, Kat, Jess, probably Nicole so wins 7-2, against Holly he wins 8-1), while Cirie probably loses to both Matt and Jag. Plus as you said he was more likely to survive the Final 5 vote which he was going to until the end.

[@grantgoffin4774]

An actual good top 15 in order: 1. Dan 2. Cody 3. Will 4. Derrick- only not higher due to only playing once. 5. Andy 6. Jun 7. Hayden 8. Danielle Reyes 9. Vanessa 10. Lisa 11. Xavier 12. Maggie 13. Adam 14. Nicole F. 15. Paul

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Uh Derrick is definitely better than cody...

[@theorignalvirgo9598]

Um..

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@noahnussbaum8693 There is valid reason to rank Cody over Derrick, namely that he played 2 really strong games, and Derrick hasn't. Plus Cody's actual winning game is atleast on par with Derrick's. And you can't say since Cody lost to Derrick the season they were on together he has to rank lower, when after all many are trying to rank Nicole over Cody when Cody destroyed her (even worse than Derrick did Cody) both seasons they were on together.

[@tajneeley]

Cody over Derrick is crazy

[@noahnussbaum8693]

@@rolandgreen7484 so we’re just gonna penalize Derrick for not playing again? That’s stupid. Put Derrick in Cody’s place in all stars, you probably get a similar result. Also, I personally am not putting Nicole over Cody, so that’s irrelevant.

[@pabs109]

I have done the math for average placement for all the seasons, which I did by adding all the placements divided by the number of players in that respective season. FYI: The strongest is BB22 and the weakest is BB19. The rankings are listed below: 01. BB22 (75.13) 02. BB7 (84.79) 03. BB10 (130.23) 04. BB17 (130.88) 05. BB13 (131.50) 06. BB12 (139) 07. BB18 (145.25) 08. BB24(145.38) 09. BB11 (148.15) 10. BB20 (148.69) 11. BB2 (149) 12. BB23 (149.75) 13. BB6 (150) 14. BB15 (150.63) 15. BB16 (150.69) 16. BB21 (151.88) 17. BB14 (152.75) 18. BB3 (154.42) 19. BB5 (155.57) 20. BB4 (155.85) 21. BB8 (168.14) 22. BB25 (169.29) 23. BB9 (178.56) 24. BB19 (183)

[@SG-sj5in]

Crazy 16 is so low with 3 winners and 3 people in the top 5. Everyone else was that bad I guess

[@Kizaco]

The gap between all stars seasons and then 10 😭

[@rolandgreen7484]

Keesha had a chance of beating Dan. She would get Renny, Libra, Jerry 100% and only needs 1 more. Michele has said she would consider voting Keesha in that Final 2, so that could be her. If Dan ever betrays Memphis (which he probably doesn't) he likely bitter votes Keesha too. Keesha 100% beats Jerry or Memphis despite some very anti Keesha jurors. Renny, Libra, Jerry, Michele are completely locked for her in both those Final 2s, which is already enough. Ollie and April were anti Keesha but could see them voting her over Memphis atleast too.

[@brianregan5933]

Michele votes Memphis over Keesha for sure, and Jerry probably votes Memphis over her too. They both REALLY hated Keesha. Jerry in particular disliked Keesha just as much as he did Dan, he just saw Dan as the bigger threat. And Michele hated Keesha with a passion and was friends with Memphis, and Jerry too. I think Keesha HAS win equity, but the entire BB10 jury is really really hard to predict

[@DouglasJefferson-tp9kp]

@@brianregan5933 Dan hated Memphis even more than Dan, hence why he voted Dan to win over Memphis, so not sure how hating Keesha as much as Dan, indicates he votes Memphis over her, LOL

[@KettleTheStick]

Dr. Will is a better player than Nicole F, Cody, Andy, and Derrick, its not even a question.

[@tuckervincent9774]

He is light years better than Nicole. Ranking Nicole over Will is one of the most absurd things you could do.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

@@tuckervincent9774not absurd in the slightest. Nicole’s winning game is much better than Will’s.

[@tajneeley]

No 💀

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

Respect for putting christmas high. I feel like lots of the fandom underrates her. I do disagree with a lot of opinions especially in the 70s-30s tier but it’s hard to make a list that satisfies everyone and I appreciate you making this series

[@desmondcoppin591]

Yeah, bad personality does not mean bad player.

[@jerryberry8181]

I think we need a 6 hour video on if Kyland could beat Goku 🙏🙏

[@helping119]

I haven’t even finished this video but this video is a master piece for realizing the greatness of the one and only Jessie.

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

-Nicole Franzel, Corey Brooks, James Huiling are all far too high. Like all by atleast 10 spots each. Heck Corey I found purely mediocre, he might not make my top 80 even. No idea how he is that high. James too, he was a huge goat on BB18, and just an underdog threat who had no real chance on BB17.

[@wolfcrossing2010]

Also putting Nicole as the only girl in top 5, lol this list is a joke.

[@superraul6449]

Danielle: Am I a joke to youu

[@wolfcrossing2010]

Top 5 not top 10

[@gogogeorge3806]

Nicole does not even merit being in the top 15. Jun, Maggie, Danielle, Vanessa (all way better players than Nicole) are much underrated though.

[@Raul-gm1cr]

You’re right about April (BB6). Had Ivette not won the veto in F4, she would have won the game. I think that Maggie would have taken her if she won the veto, in F6 she chose not to use the veto on Ivette/Beau so that April wouldn’t be evicted.

[@Yeaster]

I would've preferred April winning to Maggie

[@Raul-gm1cr]

@@Yeaster I think Maggie is a deserving winner but April played a very solid game and people rarely mention her. She made it to F5 without ever being nominated and the two times she went on the block was because the veto was used. That’s on playing an impressive social game, especially on such a divided season. Also, she used her HoH to get rid of the common enemy (James) and would have beat anyone in F4 in a jury vote (and if she made it past that week, Janelle and Maggie/Ivette would all have taken her to F2). I think her TV persona somewhat overshadows her gameplay but she was undoubtedly a top 2 player that season.

[@thatfunkymonkey7667]

Stats of number of players per season that appear in your top 80: 2: 5 3: 3 4: 4 5: 4 6: 4 7: 9 8: 3 9: 1 10: 4 11: 4 12: 6 13: 5 14: 7 15: 3 16: 4 17: 4 18: 5 19: 3 20: 5 21: 5 22: 11 23: 5 24: 4 25: 4

[@abhainnxv1554]

Oh boy, the All-Stars seasons tend to have better players, who woulda thunk it.

[@brandonridge1342]

Did you for real rank Dr Will Kirby below Nicole and Cody? The pregaming that happened in all stars 2 was literally set up for the both of them

[@gogogeorge3806]

Cody I can atleast see a case for, although I would have Will above. Both Cody and Will should be WAY WAY above Nicole. Cody totally outplayed Nicole both seasons they were together, and Will is just another league, and was way closer to a 2nd win in only 2 times playing than Nicole was in 3 times winning considering Nicole was never winning Big Brother 22 while Will wins All Stars easily if anyone but Janelle wins Final 4 veto or he doesn't misplay the Final 4 round.

[@Miraclestimesten]

Thanks for respecting Nicole. She’s truly one of the all time elite players. I think people can’t stomach her bc of her whiny personality but she’s a killer.

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

She is definitely not a better player than Will or Hayden though. Especialy Will.

[@Miraclestimesten]

@@luthorlex-fc9ft She is better than Will. She has proven herself 4 times now and has outranked Will overall. Can always lower her threat level. They play together and she will likely beat him.

[@desmondcoppin591]

She’s not a bad player, but she’s not top 5 at all.

[@pabs109]

My opinions regarding the list. -Jag is a weaker winner than Ian & Rachel personally, slightly better than Dick -Both Cirie & Matt are too high; in my opinion both are Top 30 players not Top 25 -Vanessa should have been in Top 10; Paul I believe should be no higher than 11th -Nicole F. is a Top 6 player not Top 5 -I believe Dr. Will is a Top 2 player. -Personally, my Top 5 would be Dan, Dr. Will, Derrick, Andy, and Cody.

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

No fucking way, Nicole F is not top 6. Off the top of my head Dan, Cody, Derrick, Andy, Hayden, Jun, Maggie, Danielle, Vanessa, are all better than her. You could make a good case for Paul considering his BB19 game is better than her BB18 game in everyway except not winning, and his BB18 game is much better than her BB22 game (heck BB18 is Nicole's best game and only Paul's distant 2nd best, and some thought Paul was robbed to lose to Nicole there, even though I agreed with the result). Also it looks like you have Cody 5th and Nicole 6th which is ridiculous when Cody was far better than Nicole in two different seasons they were on together.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Jag stays underrated as usual (somehow)

[@tajneeley]

Explain how Will is better than Cody Or Andy.

[@grantgoffin4774]

Just noticed Nicole Franzel over Will, LOL! That is crazy.

[@edenzachary454]

She's better, will is overrated

[@TDRyan]

​@@edenzachary454finnaly someone who agrees will is overrated Some people agree that his bb2 game was meh but no-one agrees with me that his bb7 game is overrated

[@edenzachary454]

@@TDRyan he was so messy in bb7, boogie kind of carried

[@MarsinMars]

​@@edenzachary454 *jaw drops to the floor* will's gameplay in bb7 is overrated BUT BOOGIE CARRYING HIM??? Have you ever seen bb7, will carried boogie not the other way around

[@grantgoffin4774]

@@MarsinMars He is a troll who probably hasn't watched any of Will's seasons.

[@SG-sj5in]

I 100% agree with Nicole being top 5, and would even argue putting her higher because she's actually shown how repeatable her game is where as other top-tier players have not

[@thecamishere4344]

you and him gotta be smoking really hard stuff cuz that's ridiculous. Reindeer Games I really don't consider that much of a game. 6 episodes it lasted like gimme a break

[@ClubPuguin]

And she's still in the top 5 without reindeer games plus it did have social strategy elements....

[@birkarandhillon5059]

@@thecamishere4344yet she still made it to the end of BB18 and BB22

[@grantgoffin4774]

@@birkarandhillon5059 Jordan made it to the end on BB11 and BB13, per that logic she should be top 5 then. Especialy when Jordan was much more likely to win BB13 than Nicole ever was BB22. Will of course made it to the end on BB2 and BB7 both, and was much more likely to win BB7 than Nicole BB22 as well.

[@DouglasJefferson-tp9kp]

@@birkarandhillon5059 She did not make the end. She was evicted on BB22. The only players to make the end twice are Dan and Cody, both far better players than Nicole, particularly Cody, who badly outplayed Nicole on both seasons they were on together. To have them almost tied on this list is insane.

[@grantgoffin4774]

Good list but Corey is WAY overranked. Cliff is also overranked. And on what planet was cutting Holly over Tommy a good move, no freaking way. One of the worst moves ever, and the fact you don't see that as a bad move is probably part of the reason you wind up far overranking him.

[@brianregan5933]

The problem with keeping Tommy at final 5 is that he's only slightly worse at comps than Jackson, so even though you now have Holly out, you have TWO comp beasts who are massive jury threats in the final 4. Cliff's game entirely hinged on him or Nicole winning final 4 veto, and they do in fact perform better than Holly, so it was probably the right move. Cause even if you get the right configuration of Nicole winning HOH, and then Tommy winning veto to cut Jackson, you STILL have to beat Tommy at final HOH. And even THEN Tommy would've won final 4 HOH anyway, so who actually knows where it goes. Its a really marginal move, that there's no good answer to. Cliff's ACTUAL mistake was not enacting his plan to cut Tommy at final 6. He wanted to use the veto on Christie to take Tommy out at the double, but didn't do it because he didn't have time to talk to Nicole. IF he does that, then sending home Holly over Christie is the obvious move, and his path is much more solid, and he's likely guaranteed final 2 (And maybe guaranteed to win vs anyone but Jackson?)

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@brianregan5933 Tommy has said he isn't sure which of Nicole or Cliff he takes, so Cliff does not neccessarily need to beat Tommy at final HOH as he might have taken him over Nicole. It is atleast more likely than Jackson taking him over Holly which was never happening.

[@brianregan5933]

@@rolandgreen7484Yeah but Cliff for sure loses to Tommy. Cliff CAN beat Jackson, and for sure beats Holly and Nicole. Tommy was the biggest jury threat on the board, which is why its such a hard choice

[@rolandgreen7484]

@egan5933 He is still better off taking out Holly, he now is likely the one Jackson takes to Final 2, and Tommy is atleast taking Jackson out before him everytime (and it isn't even for sure Tommy takes Nicole over him). It was worth the risk. Like you admited Cliff atleast has a chance vs Jackson, and he is who Jackson is likely taking if he wins out (still quite likely) to boot. When you add in agreeing Final 4 HOH to be thrown to Nicole, it becomes an even dumber move for him than it already was, as was broken down in the video. And keep in mind he really convinced Jackson was going to keep him over Holly in each instance, which negates any defense you could make for him.

[@grantgoffin4774]

@@brianregan5933 Yes I can see there are pros and cons, but it still dumb to keep a couple, an actual couple who are screwing each other, of comp beasts together.

[@ChristianMoffet]

Nicole isn't even top 10, let alone top 5, LOL! She might make top 15, not even sure about that. You are being too results oriented. Even in terms of results Will has better resultes in addition to light years better game play, and you have her over him.

[@elijahbarton2959]

At a certain point you have to be results oriented 3 deeps runs with completely different circumstances on seasons add on reindeer games she’s very good at the game she’s proven her game is very repeatable the best survivalist type player and I don’t even like that type of game

[@EdwardJarvis-be3ck]

@@elijahbarton2959 if you are results oriented only Jordan would be a top 3 player all time since she was closer to winning twice than Nicole was. Will was closer to winning Big Brother twice than Nicole too, in addition to being light years better at the game, and this idiot even ranked him behind Nicole which as you can see by the comments almost everyone finds hilarious. Julie Chen and any of the BB alumni would laugh their asses off at that one. Reindeer Games is not a real big brother season and meaningless btw.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

@@EdwardJarvis-be3cknope context matters. Considering their games: 1. Nicole BB18 2. Will BB4 3. Nicole BB22 4. Jordan BB13 5. Will BB2 6. Jordan BB11 7. Nicole BB16

[@travisstrong5389]

@@birkarandhillon5059 LOL at Nicole's mediocre BB All Stars game where she was going to take Cody to the end and lose for sure even if she won final HOH being better than Will's winning game or any of Nicole's games being better than Will's incredible All Stars game it was basically a giant fluke he didn't win. Thanks for the comedy. You really are in love with Nicole aren't you.

[@austinnickell2561]

​@travisstrong5389 Will's winning game is not very good, though. People act like he was this huge manipulator in 2, but in reality, the show was determined heavily by comps at that time. Will was not a threat. I believe the only reason he wins is because Nicole N was disliked more. Yes, his All Stars game is extremely impressive, but I trust Nicole F to win more often.

[@laurengillis2045]

Would you be open to uploading content on Spotify as a podcast? It's mostly an audio content and.sometimes it's frustrating to have yt open :(

[@petreandres]

Why is Cory so much higher than America? They basically played as a pair and America drove more of the choices, and outlasted him despite being the bigger threat. Nicole Franzel is way too fucking high too.

[@lylaj1773]

Cory played a better game than her, especially in the first half of the game. Besides, Matt telling her he won Paths of Power, she never obtained any game info herself. She was always operating on info she got from Cory, which he obtained by building relationships with Cirie, Izzy, and Jared, who were the power players the first half of the game. She knew Cirie was running the game but refused to build any kind of relationship or trust with her, which was why she was constantly in danger of going home. Even though Cirie was playing everyone, getting in her good graces could have ensured her safety and allowed her to be more in the loop and weigh in on decisions, and also gather more info on them and the house dynamics that she and Cory could have used later on. Instead, she tried to work with Cam, who was the main house target and didn’t like her closest ally Cory, and Matt, Jag, and Blue, who were constantly snitching on her. She knew Jag and Blue were always snitching on her but continued to tell them literally every piece of info she had, which put Cory’s game in jeopardy and caused him to lose trust with Jared, Izzy, and Cirie. Sure, she pushed to make the Izzy vote happen and got Cam to realize how bad of a position he was in the game, but Cory was the one who actually gathered the votes. He’s the one who talked to Jag, Matt, Meme, and Bowie and convinced them. She also couldn’t read the room, pick up on the fact that Blue and Matt did not like her and weren’t on her side. Also, the second half of the game when she and Cory were trying to build an alliance with Meme and Felicia, she went and told Blue, Jag, and Matt about their plans, and Blue went and told Meme, which completely ruined Cory and America's relationship with Meme and Felicia. That whole argument after the veto ceremony made her and Cory look shady to the rest of the house. I remember multiple times on live feeds her telling Blue about game conversations she was having and who she’s trying to get closer to, which was stupid and even dumber to share with someone who gave her no information in return. Also, her talking to Blue about not trusting Matt and Jag right after the veto ceremony when it was a double veto was another dumb game move on her part and was what sealed her and Cory’s fate. She should’ve had that conversation with Blue after the veto ceremony. Overall, she did not try to build any connections with people who weren’t Cory, Cam, Jag, Matt, Blue, and Bowie. Couldn’t pick up on the fact that the people she thought were her closest allies didn’t even like her. Would spill vital information and reveal her game moves to people who didn’t like her, and she constantly shared info about herself without getting anything in return. I think the only reason why it looked like she played a good game was because that season, for the most part, was full of recruits and other terrible game players.

[@lylaj1773]

god i’m so sorry i did not realize how long that would be

[@nxx4872]

bigger threat?? ur funny.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

How is Nicole too high

[@petreandres]

@@birkarandhillon5059 Since Dan, Cody, Derrick, Andy, Hayden, Will at bare minimum are all clearly better.

[@melmartinsucksbad7246]

Nicole Franzel at 5th is a disgusting ranking. Is she an ex girlfriend of yours or something. I might have her 10th, if I am being super generous. Hayden is also too high. He just played a typical white bro game, nothing special. Danielle Reyes is far too low. Jun and Vanessa are too low. You underrate almost all women (except for Nicole who you overrate). Will at 6th is crazy. Christie Murphy should be much higher than 80th. Cliff Hogg is far too high, you almost have him in the same spot as Jackson who totally outplays him.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

Nicole at 5 is nowhere near disgusting. She’s the closest to being a 2 time winner.

[@melmartinsucksbad7246]

@@birkarandhillon5059 No she isn't. Will, Jordan, Dan, Cody, were all closer to winning 2 seasons than she was. Heck Janelle even was, despite not winning either. On what planet was Nicole closest to winning twice. She even admits if she won final HOH she was taking Cody which means her chances of winning her 2nd season were practically zero in fact.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Saying hayden did nothing special is ridiculous

[@ramblingrandomthings]

Let's get it! Next we need every survivor player ranked!

[@freakyfridays135]

you must want him to die

[@ijitonline6439]

Good grief that would be 8 parts

[@vaporterra]

Survivor Oz did it but it’s been a long time ago now considering it was only for seasons 1-29 and even that was long. Over 400 players at that point.

[@ramblingrandomthings]

@@vaporterra exactly we need an update lol

[@superwilly55]

The final part has ARRIVED!

[@WypsotorNyloff]

Christmas is the Tori Deal of Big Brother. No, that is not a compliment.

[@corksauls9403]

No that is a compliment

[@vaporterra]

Please don’t put this energy into the universe because we don’t need Christmas to be on The Challenge

[@carolebrown2621]

Nicole in the top 5 and Will Kirby way down the list, LMFAO! What a freaking joke.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

Nicole has the better winning game

[@dramaticwater]

Have you actually watched wills winning game

[@yaboi912]

Tell me you don't know anything about BB without telling me you know anything about BB lmao.

[@ABCXYZ-ch4bd]

I would definitely put Cody Calafiore as #1 on this list. I personally feel that he is the greatest Big Brother of all time. The dude is the complete package: brains, brawn, beauty, & beast mode in competitions! I was beyond ecstatic to see him win season 22!!! I know he definitely would have one season 16 too, had he cut Derrick at the final 3. I’ve never been more impressed by any other player in Big Brother history!! I was beyond amused at how clever and crafty he’d been during All Stars! And he played the perfect game too: never once nominated & also zero eviction votes all season long……. only to then [deservedly] trounce Enzo in an unanimous 9-0 victory!!! I respect others’ opinions here, but still personally put Cody in the #1 slot here - by a landslide over all other Big Brother players. Nobody could beat Cody; he was just too f###n’ good! His stellar social game, physicality & athleticism, intellectual superiority, and master manipulation made him the quadruple threat to win All Stars…… and I’m so glad that he did win!!! The dude is unequivocally Big Brother royalty!!! All hail the champ [literally] and bow down to Master Cody!!! I know that I sure am!!! I never would’ve been able to beat Master Cody either if I was on this show, and several others hadn’t been able to either. I just personally really like Cody and totally love his charming, charismatic, brilliant, master manipulator gameplay!!! I have so much respect for Master Cody, and I unabashedly idolize him for the super strong, smart, socially savvy B.B. legend that he is!!!

[@thecamishere4344]

that's never going to happen at all. Don't let the resume fool you, his leadership intangibles aren't as much as other greats and he was completely outplayed by Derrick his first season. You'd have to be smoking something hard to think he could ever reach Dan

[@taystoner7144]

He got completely outplayed by Derrick and bb all stars barely counts as a season 🤦🏾‍♂️there’s a reason no one talks about the 2nd all stars it sucked not my goat

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

@@thecamishere4344 Yeah but if he is only #3, Nicole should be way lower than #5 as Cody schooled her on both their seasons.

[@davidrb4356]

Yeah Cody Calafiore is my GOAT too.

[@gogogeorge3806]

Cody I have 3rd behind Will and Dan who are my top 2 in either order. There is even a case to be #4 behind Derrick especialy as Derrick outplayed and beat him their season together. Nicole should not even be top 10, maybe not even top 15.

[@connorrogers3570]

Nicole at 10!?!? As if, she wouldn't even make the top 10. I would even put Paul over her considering BB18 they were virtually tied (as the jury vote 5-4 shows) while Paul's Big Brother 19 game is just leagues above Nicole's BB22 All Stars game.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

They weren’t equal though.

[@lars5381]

I love how you said "virtually tied" when 5-4 isn't even virtually a tie at all.

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

Nicole top 5 is crazy. At best she might be borderline top 10. And the almost won twice (which she really wasn't, when she confirms she would have taken Cody, who she loses for sure to if she takes; when Enzo takes Cody even if he wins final HOH, when Cody was never taking Nicole, etc..) argument is stupid since Jordan was closer than her to winning twice, and most would not have Jordan even in the top 20, and when you don't even have her in the top 50, LOL! So that alone can be no argument for Nicole Franzel being that high when Jordan who was closer than her to winning twice can be that low.

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

Jordan wasn’t closer to winning twice. And there was a lot more reason why he ranked Nicole as high as she did if you even paid attention to her almost winning twice

[@thecamishere4344]

​@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny well I paid attention. she's obviously higher than Jordan rightfully but NO WAY deserves to be top 5. Reindeer Games my ass!

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

@elaCruz-lz1ny Jordan absolutely was close to winning twice. If ANYONE but Porsche wins the Final 4 veto she wins. If anyone but Porsche wins Final 4 veto the Final 3 is Rachel, Jordan, Adam. Both take Jordan and she wins over both. End. Nicole was not really close to winning BB22, not nearly as much as Jordan was to winning BB13, when she was planning to take Cody even if she won final HOH, who she loses against, when Enzo was taking Cody, and when Cody himself was not taking Nicole as we saw. So Jordan was much closer to winning twice than Nicole was. Not saying I think Jordan should rank highly or even above Nicole, just showing how ridiculous that line of logic is.

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

@@MontyDelaCruz-lz1nyYou claim Cody doesn't belong top 5 since his seasons were weak, so per your own logic Nicole who was totally outplayed by Cody in both their seasons together, those same 2 weak seasons, wouldn't belong top 20 even.

[@melmartinsucksbad7246]

@@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny "Jordan wasn't closer to winning twice". This is completely false. If anyone but Porsche wins Final 4 veto, Jordan is a lock to win BB13. Porsche goes home, and she goes to Final 3 with Adam and Rachel, who both take her, and she beats both. While Nicole was never winning Big Brother 22, so was nowhere near as close as Jordan was to winning Big Brother 13.

[@tuckervincent9774]

Nicole better than Will, HAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. That is all I have to say to that. Alison Rummans is also way too high in that she literally had no win equity at all. The only Final 2 she possibly wins is against Sam, and not even sure on that. Even fucking Fessy beats her as Hayleigh, Bayleigh, Scottie (he hated Angela so much he still votes Fessy), Sam, Rockstar, and probably JC all vote him over Angela. And she wanted to go to Final 2 with Tyler or Kaycee, who both beat her 9-0.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

You go onto to talk about win equity when Will had almost none in his winning season whereas Nicole did in every season she played, let alone just her winning one.

[@tristndubois5898]

@@birkarandhillon5059 Will beats Hardy, NIcole, or Bunky which is 3 of the other 4 in the Final 5 his winning season. And beats everyone on All Stars. Nicole beats a decent number of people on Big Brother 18 although not everyone like Will on All Stars, but almost nobody on All Stars. The only people of the FInal 7 she beats on All Stars are Christmas and Enzo (but if Enzo is the one to cut Cody, even he beats Nicole). So you are completely wrong.

[@WilsonReviews]

Bold of you to say that Jag is the most masterful dominant strategic player of all time, but I understand the reasons after listening to them. Now I feel like I need to make the right decision and put him at number 1

[@patrickmexiquinn]

Yah loved Dick at 7 too that was a bold but respectable choice

[@sStyleMo]

Dan's Funeral earns him the #1 spot by itself. Unless someone can play 2 dominant games with adversity and top the funeral, Dan will always be the GOAT. Possibly a 2x winner could beat him.

[@thecamishere4344]

depends on their skillset. you can win twice but not be as good

[@jkingisbeast]

The thing about Janelle’s BB6 win equity is that I think she has a shot against Ivette due to the fact that Ivette looses if she cuts Maggie because of the friendship pact, and Janelle probably would have said that Ivette threw the final HOH if she had won it. That could have caused at least one of the friendships to vote for her.

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

Ivette 100% loses to Janelle if she cuts Maggie. She loses 6-1 with only Beau voting her now. Even if Janelle takes Ivette though there is a chance Janelle wins 4-3. James and April (the two swing votes) both claim they vote Janelle in that Final 2, even if Janelle takes Ivette, and obviously Howie and Rachel are locks.

[@DRGOAT999]

Merania loves having unpopular opinion with these list trying to get people mad 😂 Will at 6 crazy

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

Yeah having Nicole at 5 is another trolling point where he is just looking for attention.

[@thecamishere4344]

I really do not like the praise Will gets especially when he's considered #1 by some which is bogus but even I think he shouldn't be lower than 5

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

@@thecamishere4344 5 is too low for him even.

[@DRGOAT999]

@thecamishere4344 Derek and Dan are the only players that could say are better but I give the edge to Will as top 2 over Derek only cause will played twice

[@wadejarati641]

​@@DRGOAT999Will is deffo TOP 3! AT LEAST!

[@radicalswampert7980]

WOOT GREAT WORK THANK YOU VERY MUCH, THIS VIDEO GOT YOU BURNT OUT AHAHA

[@rolandgreen7484]

Nicole Franzel is far too high. Over Dr. Will is asinine, and strongly disagree with over Hayden too. I would personally never put her over Danielle Reyes, but Danielle didn't win, so I atleast see the argument for Nicole there. Personally I consider Maggie and Jun superior to Nicole too, their winning games certainly were.

[@edenzachary454]

Nicole has the best track record in Big brother for a 4 time player and holds record for longest days played , dr will is a bad player and I'll stand by that

[@cjmomma3092]

Nicole has proven out of the 3 main shows she has played that she can make it to the end by using the same strategy 2 out of those 3 try’s. Then she literally won reinder games

[@brianregan5933]

Actually, notably, he said on stream that after recording the video he changed his mind and wanted to bump Danielle down a spot and Vanessa into the top 10 instead of her

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@brianregan5933 He drastically underrates Danielle Reyes. Her first game was groundbreaking and exceptional, despite her flawed jury management. And she was the 2nd best player on All Stars, after only Will, despite not having a big pre game ally unlike what Will, Boogie, Janelle, James, many others had.

[@brianregan5933]

@@rolandgreen7484The problem is that she plays to lose on BB3, and doesn't even play that well on all stars either. She makes massive, preventable mistakes on BB3, and her jury management is LAUGHABLY bad that season. And on BB7, she really is just the "Well we'll take her as a shield because she can't win comps" player. She was just another one of Will's puppets. She's a good player, a very good one, but I don't even think she deserves top 10 tbh

[@Yeaster]

Kyland essentially campaigning to appear on a hypothetical returnee season instead of trying to win the season he was actually playing on was wild to me. So bonkers. I would love to see Reindeer Games Josh play again BB2 Nicole played such a dominant game. Let me tell it, she should've won. Cirie & Taylor ❤❤❤

[@NovaContext]

4:20:40 I was surprised when you put Big D at #1 , but I respect your opinion pookie 💋

[@WilsonReviews]

Right? Dude literally dominated the game just by sleeping around and being there. That’s pretty impressive

[@Snoozzzing-]

@@WilsonReviews Just like Godfrey of BBCAN 😔

[@chrisgaertner1289]

I love the respect you put on Andy’s name! I would have LOVED for him to be #2 like you originally had him, but I’ll take #4 🙌🏻

[@sandybrooks8390]

I think Michael is overrated. He won so many comps in the beginning that weren't necessary and put a target on himself. It was such a huge strategic error.

[@thecamishere4344]

completely agree. he's way too high

[@GalaxyWulf342]

Can’t believe you actually made this full list

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

DR Will at 5 is insane due should be 1 or 2, why tf is Micheal so high when Jag played a way better5 game than him

[@thecamishere4344]

no he should NEVER be 1. 2 is arguable I suppose but he can still be prone to arrogance so idk. absolutely ridiculous to have him at 1 or below 5

[@gogogeorge3806]

@@thecamishere4344 He could be argued to be #1. His BB7 game was light years better than Dan's BB14 game where Dan was never winning, while Will easily wins All Stars if anyone but Janelle wins Final 4 veto (Erika admits she was cutting Janelle, and only tried to turn Janelle on Erika in dseperation to save herself) or if Will does not misplay the FInal 4 round, while Dan was just a goat everyone wanted to drag to Final 2 for an easy win, and still doesn't make F2 without Danielle making one of the dumbest moves in history at Final 4. However Dan's winning game was better so it evens out.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

definitly not 1. Dan is definitely better.

[@thecamishere4344]

​@gogogeorge3806 stfu mf. he has no argument over Dan especially when you fail to mention he actively pissed off ppl week 1 and came in as the primary target if TOP alliance barring Krista won, he then is resolute in quitting to advance Shannon but Shannon was WAY too self destructive. BB7 is way too overpraised since he lost and it was clearly his own fault due to his arrogance of unnecessarily telling ppl he and Boogie were part of CT. Dan was at the bottom week 1 in season 10 yes but no a chance does he ever quit or was even the reason he was at fault. Dan's bb14 game sure wasn't perfect but was still great considering the stigma he had against him

[@thecamishere4344]

​@@gogogeorge3806 so you think taking out Shane a player who had the highest win equity and was NEVER taking him over Danielle was one of the dumbest moves??!! he had no other good choice. Will had a choice to not overplay in BB7 AND DID! Erika and Janelle compared notes. Will was the one evicted in F4. Dan never was and he wasn't dragged you sketchy POS, he outplayed everyone that season. Win equity argument is pointless when you can't even control your showboaty persona. You ever say Will is #1/GOAT to my face you won't like the next move I make so watch it. I ain't playing, I will never agree with your washed up opinion. Idgaf about Cast quality, win equity like you do. I care about skillset. You dk what you're talking about

[@realityrob1951]

CBS loves N. Franzel, R. Reilly, Jordan and Jeff. None are truly good players honestly. The CBS love helped them. But to be fair. Yes Nicole is by far best of the 4 of them. But of your top 5 I can see a good point for all of them except Nicole and Andy. Andy only got there because of the ridiculous MVP twist that favoured the side of the house Elissa picked to side with.

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

Tell me how Andy was in danger at any point in the game without the MVP twist in play. David and Nick were the only ones to leave due to it, David left cause Nick and probably would’ve been the first boot on any season. And Nick was always going to be flipped on, especially after how he spoke to Elissa, he quite literally did it to himself. As for Nicole I would love to know how CBS only helped Nicole but didn’t help Derrick through the ridiculous reset week and battle of the block, Cody with the ridiculous comps they’d cater to him

[@thecamishere4344]

only Nicole is good. Rachel, Jeff, Jordan aren't and Andy is one of the best

[@realityrob1951]

@@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny The house was really split in half from the start in terms of crowds. The Houseguests who were good at comps like Jeremy and others were on 1 side, then Elissa, Helen, Andy, etc on the other side. Regardless of who won HOH. It never mattered due to the power that Elissa held. Which she did NOTHING to earn besides be Rachel's sister which got her the automatic fan votes as no fans knew who anyone was. That power alone let her choose a side and clear out the side of the house that was much better at comps to win HOH and shift the majority of who to take out of the game. By the time the twist ended the majority had already been set to steamroll. It literally shifted the whole way the game would of went. Likely almost everyone who went out pre-jury would of been in the Jury if it wasn't for one of the most ridiculous twists in history. That being said I do believe Andy would of outlasted everyone on his side of the house just because he kept his mouth shut most of the time and was more likable than the others in terms of getting along with people. But still would of been eventually picked off. Hope that makes sense.

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

@@realityrob1951 the point of Andy is he was literally playing both sides and he wasn’t going to be targeted anyways. Elissa’s power only really went through week 2 to overthrow an HOH in Aaryn. In the first week Amanda already had her claws in McCrae and was pulling him over to her side. The twist really only got Nick out because Nick for some reason turned on David and would shit talk Elissa which is why Elissa put him up, everything else happened naturally. Nick turned on David before the twist even mattered, they had no shot from the beginning. Helen won the week 3 HOH, Judd won week 4 HOH. The supposed people on Andy’s side who sucked at comps still were running the show without the twist and they got rid of Jeremy and Kaitlin. Elissa nominated Spencer as MVP and he was safe. After week 3, America is awarded MVP and they nominated either Amanda or Gina Marie and they survive the evictions. When somebody like Aaryn won power or Gina Marie won guess who they target over the bigger threats? Howard and Candice 🤣, it took Amanda flipping Aaryn on Judd for the supposed “comp threat” or better players to ever take out somebody on Andy’s side who was competent. While Elissa’s power certainly was helpful at the Nick round, it’s completely an overstatement to say Andy only won cause of that and that if Elissa’s power wasn’t there the comp beast side would’ve dominated since most of the “comp beasts” got out without the twists or were already turning on eachother

[@vaporterra]

How much did Ethanimale pay you to put Josh that high?

[@HolyAlondite]

For those wondering about overall season placement, I've done the math for average placing. (Which I know isn't the best method, but it's the best one I can think of) First, a TLDR: Best Overall Season: BB22, Best Non-Allstar Cast Season: BB17 Now, for the overall rankings. The number in brackets will be the average cast placing. BB22 (73.25) BB7 (83.64) BB17 (118.00) BB13 (124.43) BB10 (130.15) BB15 (136.56) BB24 (136.63) BB18 (138.38) BB12 (138.46) BB20 (139.50) BB21 (141.13) BB23 (141.56) BB11 (145.38) BB6 (145.50) BB14 (146.56) BB16 (148.31) BB2 (149.00) BB25 (151.53) BB5 (151.93) BB3 (154.42) BB4 (154.92) BB9 (158.69) BB8 (162.71) BB19 (163.29)

[@pabs109]

I did the same but the numbers I got was different.

[@HolyAlondite]

@@pabs109 It's possible I made an error or two, or maybe it's a rounding thing, since I set mine to only 2 decimal points

[@voodoomcspaghettipants4082]

Bb16 being that low with 3 players in the top 5 shows a few things. Most obviously, the cast is top heavy. But more humorously, there are a staggering number of really bad players from that cast. BB16 is truly a tale of two halves

[@conoxr]

there is NO world where nicole franzel is a better player then will kirby in my mind, simply looking at how boldly he plays as a villain and has still been successful vs how cowardly she plays one. i think her ranking has a lot to do with the fact that she's played more seasons then him (one of which wasn't even real big brother)

[@edenzachary454]

SHE IS better than will, will was messy in all stars and he didn't play well in his og season. Nicole played 4 seasons and made it far, can't say the same for will if he ever comes back

[@jackmcg0]

I wouldn’t have Nicole over Will, but I don’t hate it, and their ability to play the villain has no bearing on who’s the better player.

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@edenzachary454 LOL Reindeers is not a real Big Brother season. Will's winning game was better than Nicole's, although I could see saying their winning games are close, but his All Stars Season 7 game was WAY better than Nicole's Big Brother 22 game. His first game was also far better than Nicole's first game.

[@edenzachary454]

@@rolandgreen7484 Nicole's all star game is better than will don't make me laugh 💀 and nicole and will's winning games are not close, Nicole played WAY better

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@edenzachary454 LOL Nicole literally had no chance to win All Stars when she admits she would have taken Cody which means even if she wins final HOH, she takes Cody, and loses. And Enzo was taking Cody, so given her insistence on taking Cody had no win scenario. She was also lucky to nobe be evicted at the Final 8. Will wins All Stars for sure if either he or Boogie win final 4 veto since in a Final 3 vs Janelle and Boogie both take him, and he destroys both, or if he doesn't have that fight with Janelle just before the Final 4 vote. You are obviously a giant troll to argue Nicole's mediocre All Stars game where she had literally no chance to win despite making it near the end was better than Will's All Star game. Won't waste anymore time on your dumb ass.

[@slippp3r67]

the fact that shane sponsored the move for danielle to put him on the block at the final 4 means i cannot put him nearly as high as you did

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

She has to be higher than Danielle for sure. The only way Danielle makes Final 2 is probably with Shane and he beats her 7-0 or 6-1, depending if Dan himself votes her. So if you move Shane down, also move Danielle down.

[@MagnitudeReviews]

Nicole & Andy over Dr Will???

[@cullerjones]

Andy is debateable, but Nicole no way on earth should be.

[@thecamishere4344]

​@@cullerjonesagreed! MR is ridiculous

[@ijitonline6439]

Andy I can see...but Nicole no. She proved she is not that good when chose to let Ian go in 22. She should have cut Tyler, but instead did what Cody wanted. Also in 16 she was cut mid jury twice.

[@potterpeter]

Few points. -Jee is too low. IMO he was the 2nd best player of BB4 after only Jun. -Jun is way too low. She is well inside the top 10. And should be over the person you overrate the most on your entire list probably- Nicole Franzel -Nicole Franzel should be about 12th, 5th is crazy. -Will should be #2, if not #1. Ranking him 6th is absurd. -Hayden should be higher than 7th. -I am not sure on Andy that high. He is a great player, but if he is in a normal house, and not a crazy racist house, not sure he does as well. -Cliff is way too high. I would honestly rank him below his partner Nicole Anthony who you rightly had about 90th, since she was often cleaning up his messes. -Tommy is too low. Should easily be top 20. If you re reun Big Brother 21 10 times, he wins atleast 7 out of 10. -Danielle Reyes and Maggie are both too low. -Vanessa should be higher.

[@thecamishere4344]

no Will absolutely does not deserve #1 get that fkn sht out of your brain. Idek if he should be #2 due to him being prone to overconfidence. If he wanted to quit for Shannon, piss off the house two weeks prior with HIM specifically being the primary target coming into week 3 barring Krista's HOH, and unnecessarily tell ppl with Boogie they were part of chilltown then he doesn't deserve the very top spot. However yes Nicole is top 15 NOT top 5 like Will at least is

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@thecamishere4344 It is clear you are pressed at the idea anyone would have anyone but Dan at #1. Not just Will, but anyone else. You even went beserk on another video over anyone saying his Big Brother 14 was anything less than great. You are as bad a Dan Gheesling fanatic as the video maker is a biased Nicole Franzel fanatic.

[@SG-sj5in]

People in the comments saying Nicole isn't a good player just shows how much they do not understand the game. She is inarguably a top-tier player in every sense.

[@potterpeter]

She is a good player but not 5th best all time good. Your comment is dumb since almost nobody here is saying she isn't a good player, just that she is way too high on this list. Which she is, nobody but this video maker would ever rank her this high.

[@SG-sj5in]

@@potterpeter there are countless reasons that prove otherwise, as outlined in this video.

[@birkarandhillon5059]

⁠@@potterpeterand that’s where you’re wrong. I’d rank her at #4. She excels in every facet of the game.

[@thevenomoth3455]

JAMES HULING SUPREMACY 🗣️

[@lb7421]

Matt over queens like Diane, Karen, and Alison honestly bothered me more than anything else

[@davidrb4356]

I agree on Karen, but would also put him over Diane and Alison. Alison played a great game but was a huge jury goat who had no possible winning Final 2. Diane got played by her gay boyfriend who faked a relationship with her for the game, then cut her. It is also a myth she wins for sure if she is at the end. The twins both vote both Cowboy and Drew over her 200% guaranteed, Cowboy votes Drew over her for sure, Nakomis likely votes her half brother Cowboy over her. Karen was super bitter at Diane in jury house, and could easily vote Drew over her, and maybe Cowboy. Drew might vote Cowboy over Diane, given how fake their relationship was. Marvin could go either way amongst all 3. Her only for sure votes are Will vs both and Nakomis vs Drew, and she has 3 locked votes against her vs both. And she had to comp out to ever reach the end, she even goes home earlier without some of her comp wins, and got put up by her own showmance at Final 6.

[@rogerleblond499]

Diane over Karen and Alison bothered me. Isn't that the clown who got played by her fake gay boyfriend. Yeah no.

[@helenkellerstampon]

@@rogerleblond499Drew isn’t gay, that was a rumor Diane made up cause she was mad. She still would’ve beaten him and she moreso played herself when she got drunk and told him not to take her

[@frankiecisneros5578]

Any list with Matt K in the top 30 is automatically wrong 😭

[@Miraclestimesten]

Disagree. Matt played one of the most flawless social games all with a disability. Extremely safe and could maneuver so incredibly

[@helenkellerstampon]

@@Miraclestimestenhis disability is what gave him that advantage to begin with. Matt straight up was never winning that season despite being golden to do so given his archetype. He wasn’t targeted because he geninuely wasn’t a threat in the game as he was inactive and ended up being Jags sidekick because he always ended up following somebody. First it was Reilly, then Cirie then jag

[@WilsonReviews]

Although we don’t agree with every ranking (i.e. I don’t think Taylor should be that high since her game is a continuous trend of her constantly being targeted and getting saved due to nothing she actually did) this was still a fun ride and I had fun watching this ranking. Thank you for your dedication! :)

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

Also Michael didn’t convince Monte and Turner, Brittany did

[@lucastoft4948]

The last couple of weeks from Cory were a distaster. It was pretty sad to see on the feeds

[@Miraclestimesten]

the way his win equity nose dived was a sight to see. Total loss of control for a potential winning game but it’s mainly due to his very incompetent showmance and hubris

[@wolfcrossing2010]

You can't be serious about Matt being worthy of being in the top 30, or about Cody & Derrick being above Dr. Will, or about putting Tiffany above Taylor.

[@thecamishere4344]

Tiffany and Taylor should be quite lower

[@gogogeorge3806]

Agree on all of that but his worst ranking of all was Nicole at 5th and over Dr. Will or even Hayden. What a huge joke.

[@Peneloppqueen]

I'll never discredit nicole's game ability, i just cant stand her as a character lol

[@creativename7230]

And now I'm waiting for him to do the ranking with both bbus+bbcan

[@thecamishere4344]

i really don't respect a lot of placements I've seen from your long list MR but at least you still have Dan at #1 which keeps the bit of faith in you that you aren't completely wacky with your criteria

[@pabs109]

Matt from BB25 had an all-time historic flop in the jury questionnaire that may never be seen again. All he had to say to the jury and in his GBM was that "everyone felt good with me and I used my social capital to save Jag and get Jag to do moves that benefited my game".

[@jackmcg0]

He ruined his game before then in the goodbye messages. Unless he convinces Cory and America that he was the strategist in the questions, he had already locked himself out of a win

[@pabs109]

@@jackmcg0 I know but still an all-time implosion; purely on goodbye messsages. Both Matt and Jag had atorcious Jury Management; Jag was worse in reality.

[@jackmcg0]

@@pabs109 Jag was by far the worse player. If Matt won I think he’s a pretty good player, but he loses because of his own, very preventable mistakes. He definitely had awful jury questions, but unless he answered them perfectly I don’t see him getting the votes

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Um...Nicole is not better than Dr. Will. Lets stop right there.

[@khntou4178]

Nice to see the conclusion. Some disagreements here and there but I respect your decision. I think James Huling, Christmas, Alison, and Mike Boogie are too high for me. Really nice to Nicole N squeeze into top 30, Taylor almost touching top 20 is great (though I can see why people might put her lower), and Nicole F making into top 5. Out top 10 is pretty much the exact same in order. There is a part of me that wants to push Will into top 5 though.

[@rolandgreen7484]

Nicole F in top 5 is ridiculous, especialy over Will. He is probably the only person who would ever rank Nicole over Will.

[@khntou4178]

@@rolandgreen7484 I'm a big fan of Nicole as a player, but I do think if I wanted to put Will in top 5, I would def trade out Nicole for him.

[@grantgoffin4774]

@4178 Will in the top 5 is a must, probably top 3. And I agree with you James and Christmas are way, way overranked. Possibly Boogie too, but especialy those two. Playing the coattail rider who can never win is not great game play. I would argue Christmas had no chance of winning either season she went deep in. Yeah she might win a Final 2 with Paul on Big Brother 19 (5-4 with the exact same votes) but that is moot as she had no chance of getting there, no chance to win final HOH with a broken leg (not even a small one), and when Paul and Josh were for sure taking each other, especialy Paul taking Josh was for sure. Also she was closer to Paul than Josh was, and less of a jury threat than Josh, yet Paul was still for sure taking Josh over her, which shows Christmas is horrible at threat management, making Paul and probably Josh, and some others, thinking she was a bigger threat than she ever was. And even if Josh takes her (Paul for sure never was), Josh beats her for sure, probably by much wider than the likely 5-4 votes of both Paul vs Christmas and Paul vs Josh. in fact her only vote might come from Paul, maybe she gets Jason too, and that is it. On All Stars it is even worse as she had no shot to make the end, and no shot to win vs anyone left by the Final 4, heck by the Final 7. James BB17 was pretty good but still had no shot at all to reach the end, and on BB18 he was the goat who couldn't win who still got voted out anyweay.

[@thecamishere4344]

​@khntou4178 you already lost my respect for wanting Taylor so high cuz she's clearly not if we look at her true skillset. Nicole in the top 5 is utterly atrocious. Reindeer Games can go to hell

[@ijitonline6439]

​@thecamishere4344 I agree Taylor isn't a top 30 player in my opinion

[@sovereignblastoise6767]

Im watching bb2 rn so my list is really modern at the moment but my top 5 are 1. Tyler bb20 2. Derrick from the hitmen 3. Steve from the season with the twin twist 4. MONTE 5. Xavier

[@diegoprodriguez]

Nice to see my boy Killswitch (fka Luchasaurus) at 41. Great times.

[@JK_kline]

I give Cody above Derrick. People like to just look the way Derrick get vote and win the season becuase he s mastermind. Truth be told, Cody have his hand almost as much as Derrick. All those plan will not work or even exit if Cody cant win all those HOH and POV. Amd people never give him credit for that. Now we have season 22 and everyone see how terrify Cody is. I belive if we look at 3 points : Comp, Strigiest,social ....cody have them all and he s the most all around player of them. Derrick might have strigist more, Dan might have some social more. But for all 3 togther, i think Cody took the crown.

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

Derrick still played a better game on BB16 than Cody there. You are right Cody was a big part of their success, just as Derrick was, but Derrick is still better. Now adding BB22 for Cody, and an even better game here to go with his strong BB16 game, he might deserve to be over Derrick. However there is no doubt Derrick was the superior on BB16 alone, which you seem to be disputing.

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

Also I would say on BB16 Derrick clearly beat Cody both strategically and socially. Cody only beat him physically that season.

[@brandonridge1342]

Also why the hell is Britney lower than Josh like what????

[@gogogeorge3806]

Since he is too results oriented. Britney is a much better BB player than Josh, it doesn't matter that Josh won a season.

[@justinpascal8332]

You forgot to say that Dan won big brother not once but twice

[@drewveflin2842]

Dick is the only winner that should be lower than Jag imo

[@thecamishere4344]

fair enough. I hate both their winning games and hate one of them much more as a person (i don't even need to explain who)

[@robbiesmith554]

i think each season you should put each player like 3 months after into a band there a 80-60 or more likely a 260-200

[@JordanC2004]

I did not see Matt Klotz can someone tell me where he was placed

[@TripleBBBBB]

23

[@Ethang1103]

I disagree that Michael is the better competitor bc he has easier competitions and easier people to beat

[@thecamishere4344]

That's a stupid argument. You don't control who you compete against. He still was impressive competitively so quit thr bs undermining sappiness

[@ijitonline6439]

It's interesting that you don't mention that. Jesse was booted in season 10 over Memphis due to america's vote they did for dan. It could be considered that jesse was screwed over by america twice

[@thevenomoth3455]

to be fair dan would’ve voted him out anyway but it’s still a funny prospect

[@ijitonline6439]

But the fact is Dan didn't have a choice in the matter. Sadly America made the wrong choice as Jesse is better TV than Memphis. However, Dan is awesome so I'm glad it worked out.

[@jackmcg0]

@@ijitonline6439 Dan was begging the live feeds to vote out Jesse. If Memphis leaves there it’s more a case of being twist screwed, and Jesse wasn’t screwed either way. The only person who was really screwed was Dan who had to play both sides until the vote was cast

[@bluedevils481991]

Number 60 on this list and number 1 in my heart, Matt Hoffman!

[@Pixeloflo]

1:21:22 WHY is this so funny ? 😂

[@jackwolff5428]

I think Corey is a lot better physically then he performed on his season, Paul, Paulie, victor and frank were all also really good

[@melissagoodson2519]

Where was nicole frazel rank

[@matthewnguyen227]

It just think it’s FUNNY that 3 out of the top 5 is BB16 😂😂😂

[@thecamishere4344]

not realistically. Reindeer Games I don't think truly is like big brother as a whole. different format kinda. only 6 episodes. Cody can even be argued just out of the top 5 even. Don't let the resume fool you

[@Miraclestimesten]

By far the strongest season for players and strategy. Gave us 3 of the pantheon on one season crazy.

[@carolebrown2621]

Why is Corey Brooks so high? Don't get that at all. He isn't a strategist, he isnt even a good social player, he is good at comps but that isn't that important. He made it deep as basically a goat, even though he might win a Final 2 with James, but neither were taking each other, and it was a fluke James was still there.

[@jasmine1stan857]

This always confused me too, I think he seriously misremembers how BB18 played out. Corey was always doing nothing and his jury prospects were in the toilet

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Once again, i really do not see how its hard to see why jag took matt to the end. There's a human aspect of this game

[@DouglasAtherton-fd2wr]

It is even dumber to criticize so much when Jag won anyway. He criticizes him more for that than Cody's choice to take Derrick or Paul's choice to take Nicole over huge goat James when he wasn't even close to Nicole. *hypocrite*

[@noahnussbaum8693]

@@DouglasAtherton-fd2wr thank you, exactly. There is a human aspect to this game that he completely ignores. These people aren’t robots.

[@Miraclestimesten]

Jag was being righteous bc of Matt saving him with his power. He was willing to fight it out at F2 and be honorable instead of being a snake I respect it and he was rewarded for his good karma.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

@@Miraclestimesten exactly. Also wanted to represent his Sikh community as the 1st Sikh player.

[@DouglasAtherton-fd2wr]

@@Miraclestimesten Yes it looks like just an excuse to bash Jag some more.

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

40:56 dani wasnt on bb12

[@jackmcg0]

I find it difficult to place Dick that high. He’s absolutely atrocious, and cannot win in any normal season because of the way he plays. I understand a lot of players are bad, but I have a lot more trust in someone like Cory getting farther and winning on an average season

[@thecamishere4344]

yeah agreed. maybe realistically he sneaks in as top 100 but he's definitely too high

[@jackmcg0]

@@thecamishere4344 yea I can’t justify putting a player that high up when he can only win in one situation with his daughter in the game, and even then, still loses if a third player isn’t forced to play for him. Even players in the 130s like Jackie, Beckie, and Michelle Costa I think are better players

[@thecamishere4344]

​@@jackmcg0that's fair to me and I'm even convinced Jen would beat him too he's that hated. Worst win equity for a winner EVER. It's saying something that he can only beat his daughter

[@vaporterra]

Normally I’d say winning Big Brother should be guaranteed top 75 but considering the wonky circumstances I wouldn’t be opposed to him being in the 90s

[@wadejarati641]

Will is the GOAT

[@tajneeley]

No

[@CrustyBroBugs]

No he is OAT Overrated of All Time

[@jacobfroese3485]

Erika should be much higher in my opinion. I think she’s a great player.

[@luthorlex-fc9ft]

Does Austin win if he makes the end? He beats Liz for sure. I would guess he probably beats Steve but if Vanessa votes Steve over him, that could be a close Final 2. I don't think he beats John Mac, and I don't think he beats Vanessa. Then again he is most likely to go with Liz if makes it and has any say on the matter.

[@hunterladd6399]

I think Spencer should be higher because he is a good player

[@chrizzje]

Strongly disagree with this list, but thx for the entertainment anyway

[@andrecanton7591]

Dr Will played a rlly bad game in all stars. How is he so high 😅and how is he above Vanessa 😮.

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

Bro Matt literally did nothing all season except be deaf and that’s literally why people trusted him

[@thecamishere4344]

wait what lmaoooo what a terrible argument. I had to laugh

[@MontyDelaCruz-lz1ny]

@@thecamishere4344 it kinda is why. He was dead and had trouble socially trying to talk to people. Everyone felt bad and believed he was so innocent cause of it, it was honestly one of the biggest advantages somebody can have