Blackstone Griddle - I Don't Need One

[@wingandhog]

I just bought the Coleman grill to replace an excessively large 25 year old gas grill that could barely reach 300 degrees F. I only grill for two, so I was looking for something compact and portable. I hooked up a 5 gal propane tank and have used the grill half a dozen times. My full size cast iron flat top will be arriving tomorrow. No need for a black stone in my opinion. My first impressions are that this grill is a winner. I am very happy with it.

[@HowToRV]

That was my thought exactly. We did recently purchase a blackstone just to see if we would like it. As nice as it is, I think that there are other companys out there that can provide the same experience.

[@marktucker3716]

I’ve got both, 22” dual burner blackstone and the Colman grill. I bought the Colman first, and to be fully honest, I’ve not gotten it back out since I got the Blackstone. I’m actually not usually a fan of steaks and burgers on a flat top, but they are good on the BS. For me the Colman would continue to heat up as you cook, also the cleaning isn’t easy. All the grease catching in those trays, and always a mess cleaning them. Plus the little green bottles don’t last long. The stand is easy on the Colman and already being attached is nice. I agree the wheels help, have the same camper as you and with the wheels it’s easy to get it all the way to the back of storage. On the BS, clean up is super easy. All dripping go the the foil lined cup on the back. Comes with the hose to use a full size propane tank. I do have the legs/stand with mine. The legs can be tricky to get level because each one adjust individually, however each one adjust individually so if the ground isn’t level, no prob. Easier to control the temp. I cook everything on it, omelets, bacon, burgers, steak even hibachi style rice and whatever meat the family requested. Prob a highlight to me is being able to scoot a item to one side with the burner off to keep food warm while wrapping up other items. And the big one…less dishes to wash. I can cook any meal on it and my only clean up is the spatulas I used and the foil liner that I just toss away. The BS is heavy also. And my biggest complaint with it, mine came with an attachable side table, but it’s the same side the gas hooks up, so you have the hose crossing half the table. Otherwise, love it.

[@HowToRV]

Very good reply. I must say that i am a huge fan of not have any more mess that i need to. I like the fact that you talked about clean up.

[@FindUsCamping]

Looks like a great grill. We love how easy it is to close up and move. Very portable

[@HowToRV]

It works for us. Keep things simple is key

[@yoster77]

If you asked me a few years ago, I would have agreed with this video. After using this product for quite some time however, I've changed my mind on it. I've owned three of these since they first came out (even the first edition before your model). I have all the accessories - the griddle attachment, (the 2 piece AND 1 piece) - the stove attachment etc. I even have the propane attachment allowing me to use a full-size propane bottle (vs those little camping ones). Btw, if you don't already have that accessory.. get it. Game changer! I don't want to bash this coleman product because I DO like it and this is your channel/video, but, I've found clear differences/weaknesses in this product vs a purpose-built griddle. I've since swapped this grill out in my RV for the blackstone (and btw, you can now get blackstones that work exactly how the roadtrip does with the pop-up stand w/wheels.) Though I WILL say, the Blackstone portable/wheel model is higher profile (even when collapsed) vs the coleman. So if you have one of those older trailers/RV's with very short storage compartment doors, then this coleman might still be the ticket for you. Speaking of mobility.. wheeling the coleman around? Not a fun endeavor. If you're over 6ft (maybe even shorter) and try to wheel that around, the angle drags the handle on the other side. Plus the part you actually hold (basically the leg of it) is so short, you're slouched the entire time you wheel it around anyway. It's so uncomfortable to wheel for any distance at all that I usually just pick it completely up and carry it. And then there's the heat control (or lack thereof) with this coleman and the glorious like, 10 degrees (I'm making that up but you get the idea) of motion in the heat dials. "Low" isn't low enough and "High" is the surface of the sun. And the grease catch on this thing - UGHHH. If it's just you and the wifey and maybe 1-2 kids - sure. But if you're cooking for a large family or group - and heaven forbid you're cooking bacon - that grease catch is going to overflow. Been there doooooooone THAT (a lot) lol. And then of course on the grilling side - indirect cooking doesn't work well but even if it did, because of the short lid, you can't do things like a whole chicken (it hits the underside of the lid). Thick cuts of steak (tri-tip for instance) is also a challenge (for the previously mentioned indirect cooking issues). Doable? Yes. But plan for it to take awhile. Like I said I DO like the product here, but, on it being better, or even just as good as an actual griddle (for griddle purposes).. now that I have a lot of time on it (at least 100 cooks), I sadly can no longer agree. Is it worthless? NO! This grill is now my tent camping grill because, due to those accessories I mentioned above, it can be both a grill (though like I said it's not really that wonderful as an actual grill - it suffers in indirect heating), and a stove, and a griddle. It's like a swiss-army knife - excellent for tent camping where you really only want to bring one device! It does everything 'ok' but nothing really great. Actually, that's not fully true. If you're only looking to cook a few burgers (4-6) - then this thing is the jam with the griddle attachment. Most of the time though, in my RV, I'm either griddling (for more than 5 people) pancakes, bacon, burgers, potatoes, etc, OR BBQ (steaks, chicken, etc). Rather than the 'swiss army knife' I now just bring a purpose built griddle and a purpose built small charcoal BBQ (the Oklahoma Joe Rambler to be specific). I'm in cookin' paradise!!!! Before with the coleman - it always got the job DONE, but I was never a top-notch experience. It's still fun to have both though - I love having options!! And sometimes I still swap it out.. just for funsies. In fact, after writing all this that no one will probably ever read, I think I'm going to swap it back into my RV for the next trip, just for fun LOL.

[@HowToRV]

Glad that you wrote this detailed comment. I would have to agree totally on all of it. Actually (Shhhhhh) we baught a blackstone and my wife will never return. She has the accessories too and loves every aspect of it. However like you, I diid not get rid of my coleman. My plan is to give to my daughters so they can use it when they go out camping. I agree on the fact that the colemant is a great addition for those who are tent campers. As far as others reading your comment. I can only hope that a bunch of others will respond and comment too. Happy camping and God Bless.

[@paulvanderborgt5581]

We have a 22" Blackstone. While we love it, we rarely take it camping anymore. Prefer grilled foods when camping. Love the Blackstone at home though.

[@HowToRV]

To reallly get a full review, I think that i may need to get one to see if i like it better or not.

[@dougd7410]

Grilled vs. Frying it's just that simple. I prefer grilled.

[@jcshort31]

I had the Coleman and a 22" Blackstone sold them both and bought a Weber Q1200 and never looked back. The Coleman I had took water in the drip pan and was difficult to dump without a mess.

[@HowToRV]

I can see where water could get into the drip pan. And yes it would be difficult to empty

[@wingandhog]

Yes. After using mine a half dozen times, I am not a fan of the water tray but understand it’s purpose. I still rate the grill a 10 though

[@darkspd31]

no joke, get a lodge cast iron griddle and put it on top, BAM! you have a blackstone lol

[@HowToRV]

That is a good thought. Thanks

[@eddygoodwin7089]

I’ve been looking at these Coleman road trip grills for a while they make one that doesn’t have wheels that has a little different burner setup and it is easier to clean with a bezels that pulls out and wipes off

[@HowToRV]

I have heard of others saying the same thing as you.

[@pollybitterman414]

We love our u r roadtrip grill! Only down side is the cleanup! Would love to be able to put an aluminum pan inside to help with cleanup!

[@HowToRV]

I would have to agree. It is a tad difficult to keep clean. I have not found an easy way to keep it cleaen either. Let me know if you find a way.

[@chapmansus1]

That’s a nice looking grill and that food looks good, thanks for all the information and sharing the video

[@HowToRV]

Our pleasure!

[@donaldokray868]

Just purchased full swaptop griddle, one frame many cooking options

[@HowToRV]

Hope you enjoy it!

[@TheDrunkenBBQ]

Love portable equipment. Thanks for sharing this great video.

[@HowToRV]

Thanks for watching!

[@AmpedtoGlamp]

Great video. Wish I saw it before I bought my blackstone! 😊

[@HowToRV]

For the most part, I think Blackstone owners still love the capability of them.

[@SmallSpaceLiving]

We dropped our Black Stone as well. Did not care for it. We went with the Weber grill and like it much more. When I cook a steak or burger I want stripes on it. lol For your grill you can also get a flat top for the breakfast stuff like eggs. So then you can have the best of both worlds. I agree with you the Coleman is better.

[@HowToRV]

I am glad that you agree. Also, do you have tried the flat top? I was thinking about ordering it but havent yet.

[@SmallSpaceLiving]

@@HowToRV Yeah we used it and it worked great. Just like a Griddle but cast iron. We like it better to be honest.

[@bluskyodyssey]

So you know what the solution is, buy both . . . lol. That's what we did. We have owned a 17" Blackstone Griddle for a while now, and I do like it. But I missed those grill marks for steaks and burgers, so we bought that exact grill you have a couple of months back. And I love it. If we got the cast iron flat surface for this grill, I might not need the griddle. But one thing is, I think it's a little easier to clean the griddle than the components of the grill. But still I like them both! Happy grilling. Debbie - BluWave Odyssey

[@HowToRV]

I may try out the Blackstone just to say that i have the experience to discern the difference.

[@melgendemaisonvlog3428]

Thank you for sharing,full support here ,a big like here❤️🙏♥️

[@HowToRV]

Thank you for the awesome comment. Love the praying hands too.😀😀😀😀

[@Wildernessadventuresoz]

We use Webber’s and Ziggy type bbqs her in australia they all do the same thing really. It’s just preference really. We can cook roasts in them which is the part I like

[@HowToRV]

I have not heard of the Ziggy. I will have to check that one out. Your right, preference is key factor.

[@jontnoneya3404]

Have you see the Weber or Napoleon travel grills with the scissor stands and wheels? They look A LOT like the Coleman but they're more expensive. They do look like they are made out of better quality materials tho and the Napoleon has a 10 yr warranty so maybe the higher price is worth it. I'm not sure tho. Anyways thanks for the experienced perspective!

[@HowToRV]

I have to admit. My wife made me buy a blackstone and now......She will not part with it.

[@shanedenmark5536]

The biggest difference with the Weber is the grates are more similar to what your home grill might have, so you’re actually cooking with the flame instead of scorching your food on the Coleman half grill/half griddle.

[@jerrypatton7260]

Nice griddle, i own one but the thing that sucks about coleman griddle is grease trap. I wish they made inserts to keep bottom of burner tray clean. Other than that coleman is good little griddle, but i will be investing in some sort of blackstoone soon to replace coleman. Coleman clean up is horrible.

[@HowToRV]

I will have to agree. Oh and by the way. Shhhhhhh, I got a blackstone and we love it.

[@martinmccary5131]

Great griddle, had my road mate since 2004

[@HowToRV]

Shhhhh. Please don't tell anyone but we just bought a Blackstone. The wife wont use anything else now. Happy Wife Happy Life.....:)

[@williamcox9865]

Dude! 😂 Really, you got one after the vid 😂😂. Now you need a BS vid…or I’ll tell everyone 😮

[@macho.3088]

I’m debating on the Coleman road-trip 285 n the Weber traveler.

[@HowToRV]

If I may, since I made this video, my wife made me buy the blackstone and----drum role ( she will not stop using the blackstone.) her words. Happy wife happy life right?

[@NursingOurTravelBug]

Right now, we travel with a foldable charcoal grill and a smoker. While we’ve thought about upgrading to the Blackstone, we’ve also heard people have issues cooking certain meats on them. I think upgrading to the Coleman would be a better option for us. I am curious, though, do you know what the price difference is between your grill and a black stone?

[@HowToRV]

In my opinion, a smoke can not be beat by any means.

[@ThriftyAngela]

Sounds like this grill works great for you and does everything you need. You might have started a war... LOL! 😂😁

[@HowToRV]

I may have. I really think it would be good for #Blackstonegriddle users to share their story. I have seen some compelling comments already.

[@dannyday1370]

Could you deep fry turkey using the coleman roadtrip grill

[@HowToRV]

I would have to think that it would not. the heat just would transfer to something that big. Plus, I would not think that it it stable enough to be safe. just my thoughts though.

[@joynylen7488]

I totally agree with you on this Coleman. I have a flat griddle that will go on my Coleman stove that will do exactly the same thing I'm sure as these silly Blackstone grills which in my opinion are far too over rated! The only thing I would use a griddle for are: pancakes, bacon and eggs, yes! that would be it! I would not fry any meat on a griddle other than bacon, leave the steaks & hamburgers to a portable bbq to get that bbq flavour in your food. But to be honest, I use a portable weber bbq with stand (not this coleman in your video) for our meats and then use our Coleman stove for frying up those breakfasts, boiling things, etc.(they will hold a 10" and 12" fry pan) Our Coleman stove is the original slim line stove that takes up very little room to store away in your RV and the weber portable bbq which works the same, small and compact. Thanks for this video!

[@HowToRV]

I was thinking about getting the flat griddle for ours. Where did you get yours?

[@joynylen7488]

@@HowToRV You can get them at any local hardware store or camping store, I'm sure Walmart carries them. I got ours at Canadian Tire here in Canada. They fit perfectly on top of a Coleman stove creating your own griddle and then also the 10" and 12" fry pans fit nicely on the stove side by side. The griddle even has a gutter around the outer edge that funnels to one end for grease catching. So, we operate a 'original Coleman stove'(sleek and compact design and very cheap) with the added grill you can buy separately and the weber portable bbq. for that bbq flavour. Thats it for all of our outdoor cooking needs and 2 great space savers as well..

[@joynylen7488]

I forgot to add, there is a flat griddle for your's and wherever you purchased your Coleman you should be able to get the flat griddle as a separate accessory. Mine for my Coleman stove is flat but is rectanguler in shape. But I am sure any shape would work for your Coleman to sit on top. Just make sure you get a cast iron one.

[@HowToRV]

@@joynylen7488 I will most definitely look for it. Cast iron for sure.

[@Koalabearsuits]

Are you able to hook this grill up to your quick connect on your rv?

[@HowToRV]

I have since making this video naught a new grill but yes. I searched Amazon for mine and found one.

[@DIlic-iz9tx]

_Good grill, I like it. If it was a better quality material, it would be even better._

[@HowToRV]

Yeah I agree

[@ReelMenCOOK]

life is funny, let's enjoy it

[@HowToRV]

Absolutely. RMC...Cool channel name

[@shanedenmark5536]

I’d love to see how you use this Coleman grill. I’ve had no luck with mine. I wanted one ever since I first saw one at a Buffalo Bills tailgate party. Finally scored a nice little deal on one, and have been completely disappointed. It’s either not hot enough or go to cook or hotter than Hades. And the solid cast iron grates gets even hotter still. Can’t even cook hot dogs; the grates burn the outside long before they cook inside. Most folks I’ve talked to at the campgrounds have had similar results. Great idea, poor execution, total bust. Womp womp womp (sad trombone).

[@HowToRV]

Sorry for my laugh but the trumpet sound got me. I have to use foil to block side winds from the burner. Outside of that. We didn’t really have any issues. I do let mine go and eventually got the Blackstone. I must say that I am sooooo glad that we did. It’s way better. This video is older and that’s the latest

[@shanedenmark5536]

@@HowToRV Yep we upgraded to a Blue Rhino Grill/Griddle Combo. Grill grates are much more of a standard grill look. Here's hoping... Stand by for a review, it's new for this season.

[@HowToRV]

@@shanedenmark5536 I am looking forward to your thoughts.

[@ronfamous1]

No flare ups on a blackstone...

[@HowToRV]

Oh i do like that reason. I have not given that a thought.

[@calliejennings6185]

Blackstone griddle all the way nothing can compare to it

[@HowToRV]

I am starting to think that the consensus is the same across the board

[@nancythinbluelanervlife]

I have one of those ! And we absolutely love it. Different brand but it is awesome. This is a great video ! #THINBLUELANERVLIFE

[@HowToRV]

Good choice!

[@ProvidingResources]

I don't own a blackstone either. I don't see the benefit of a blackstone.

[@HowToRV]

I must admit that I bought one since I made the video. Wife told me too. Since then, she says that she will never go back. I would have to agree with her.

[@havesomemustard]

Aaaahhhhhhhh

[@HowToRV]

MmmmmmHHHHmmmmmm

[@havesomemustard]

It's got lid it's gas it's got its green how many colors do blackstones come in the lid opens and closes it gets hot it's got ignition when runs out of fuel you just hook up another bottle its green it folds up it holds spatulas it folds up it folds down suck it black stone I don't want Blackstone do I I don't know where am I

[@HowToRV]

I would've to agree