BTS WINGS ERA EXPLAINED (Breaking down Blood Sweat & Tears MV & Short Films)

[@theincrediblekhasi9873]

If Hybe makes a movie about BTS...i'm voting for xceleste to be the director or at least narrator

[@kittykatjagirl]

We’re still waiting for that Youth KDrama “airing in 2021.” …still waiting for that release date. 🥲

[@veronicamunoz9035]

Totally!!!!

[@houseofalex]

We actually have an actual film director who is a fan of BU - Cedric Gegel

[@babyc3482]

If not her then bookish theories

[@yb8291]

Xceleste- Screenplay Cedric Gegel- Director

[@icaughtseokjinslipping8964]

Sorry Namjoon, but Wings era is not something we can ever move on from. It's THE MASTERPIECE. THE BEST.

[@kathleenroderick6833]

Absolutely ! I hope you're hearing this Namjoon. This level of artistry is TIMELESS. It is never something to be forgotten or moved on from - it is only to be built upon even further.

[@space676sof]

What did Namjoon say and where did he say it?

[@dkcryer]

Exactly 😭

[@playtimewithrachelabigail]

Yeah😁 even though I have only been an ARMY since July 2021, I still "miss" wings, and it is one of my favourite albums. All of BTS's songs are great, but as someone who is a bit of an old soul, I love their old style best, I don't mean the genre in particular, I mean the feel. That's why it makes me sad to think I joined so late. ( and now they are on a break as a group, the whole military thing is going on, plus they are getting older, and it's kinda sad watching someone start to grow old, once they've grown up.😭) I am sooooo glad I found them though.🙏🤗💜 I will probably always wish I had found them sooner, but I am forever grateful, that I found them at all. 🙏😍💪🔥💜

[@playtimewithrachelabigail]

BTW where did Namjoon say that?

[@MichelSampson]

The amount of work and thoughts put into their music and MVs... the whole storyline, all the symbolism, references, details... What other artist is doing this? Seriously? This isn't just about making music anymore, or simply just writing songs. They create pure art. And it always makes me mad when somebody's so fast to judge them only after hearing 1% of their discography, or just because they are "mainstream", "k-pop" or similar bs. They are truly such a unique group of artists. I've been an ARMY for quite some time, but they still manage to impress me even more every day. I seriously hope more people give them a chance, and that more people discover all these hidden meanings and stories in their art. They are one of a kind, a masterpiece, and deserve all the love and recognition in the world.

[@Bangtannies.07]

The truth is many of the armies don't know about these theories. They just enjoy the mvs. It's such a shame that they don't know about their pure talents. BTS is the only artist who can make such a masterpiece . Their talents are beyond our imagination

[@ariaisgays]

@@Bangtannies.07 I am now and I’m so proud of them of how smart and unique they are

[@mimilovesbangtan]

If only people could keep their biases aside and give them a genuine chance, they would discover something so beautiful and brilliant!

[@afreenkhan6635]

I dont know much about kpop, i just know BTS thats it. so genuine question to kpop fans do others also make such music? Although i feel BTS is beyond just kpop. love thier lyrics, concepts, music videos all of it. BTS is Amazing and their Wings era is just out of the world.

[@MichelSampson]

@@afreenkhan6635 I'm not sure. I listen to quite a lot of groups now but mostly based on sound, not lyrics or concepts. There definitely are groups that have meaningful songs with depth and layers, but I don't think I've seen any go to such length as BTS.. but there could be.

[@madxinthebox]

When Namjoon jokingly said that we should move on from Wings era, I felt that. Sorry Joon, that is something I cannot do. No one's moving on from Wings.

[@A_wildflower7]

This era will always be Masterpiece. The theories and everything about this era is the reason why i came to know BTS and became ARMY💜.

[@xCeleste]

This era will always be my favorite and that's cause I also made a lot of memories as an ARMY during WINGS

[@indeedical26]

Ikr! I became a fan during this era

[@lohoriray2013]

True Even me at this era this beautiful people entered my life. I thought they are just like any other artists I will support and cheer for but never thought they would become the reason I smile, laugh and cry now and will in the future. They educate me more gently about myself and them as a person. They are irreplaceable in my world and even if it happens I'll make sure that there will be no one like these 7 boys in my small world.

[@A_wildflower7]

@@xCeleste Omg i got reply from you🥺💜.I wasn't ARMY at that era i got to know them in 2018 suddenly watching the BST and i was literally blown away and my brain couldn't process what happened then your videos are the reason i actually get to know BTS's whole storyline and i got reply from you today🥺💜i am so happy. I love you so much if you were not there i won't even know how amazing BTS are .Thank you so much for your hard work in every videos and everything. You are just amazing 🥺💜

[@A_wildflower7]

@@lohoriray2013 I can feel you. This feelings are literally so different how they make us happy ,reason to live and love ourselves and 9999999+ positive things . I was a worse person before because of BTS i became a developed person with a strong personality and i survived depression and now fighting for my dream. Best of luck bestie for your future.I Purple you💜

[@soumilinath1743]

I'm just so much surprised, how BangPD linked the concepts of "Demian" with "Jung's Map of the Soul" with their own concept of Love Yourself😳 This is real talent. Thank you so much for these theories. We love you 💜❤️

[@zainabtanweer2910]

And it even has references to themselves in their real life. For example the 15 year old boy in begin by Jungkook, and apologizing to sister AND brother in stigma cuz tae has a brother too. 💜♥️💜

[@space676sof]

@@zainabtanweer2910 Can you explain if you want to :D

[@zainabtanweer2910]

@@space676sof I meant that the characters are inspired by real life BTS members. Their ages, families and emotions etc.

[@theincrediblekhasi9873]

And people think listening to butter and dynamite they Understand BTS discography. i have watched maybe 95% of their creativity (all included) and still can't categorise them with any artist. BTS is BTS BTS the BEST

[@xCeleste]

YUP! There so much deeper than that but their discography is filled with so much creativeness and diversity in genres!

[@AndreaDiaz-rc3iy]

THIS

[@iamjust1normalgirlfromindi446]

@@xCeleste I am an army since last 6 months but I don't know much about other kpop groups. Do other groups also have such theories and their own universes like BU? Is this common in kpop or only BTS have BU? I've watched this whole playlist. From that i know you do a lot lot lot more work than i can imagine. Thank you very much for helping us armies. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@bobatea1289]

@@iamjust1normalgirlfromindi446 I don't think this is common in kpop I didn't heard about other groups but groups under Hybe have their own univers story BTS BU ,TXT TU ,Enpypen EU .

[@iamjust1normalgirlfromindi446]

@@bobatea1289😁 oh thank you dear... I've been waiting for answer for so long😅

[@Jah-jw1pt]

one of the many reasons why I chose to stick to this fandom is because of the community with smart and deep people who are very willing to share their knowledge to everyone, and xCeleste is definitely one of those. Thank you so much for this video. I enjoyed a lot, understood the story and loved BTS even more 💜

[@happles_OT7]

😵 The BTS Discography Rabbit Hole is so vast! 😌 Thank goodness I can rely on OG ARMY like you & José for helpful explanations. 🤗💜

[@xCeleste]

It's insane LOL Like there's so much details that it's hard to summarize. Thank you for watching!

[@gravedletters]

Who's José? 😅

[@Jewelytt7]

@@gravedletters Another Army KZbinr. He’s amazing. 😁💜💖

[@Bird_with_out_wings]

I became an army during the wings era,this era was the most mysterious for me .got soo many answers through your video.It was worth watching.wings era is a masterpiece

[@yeaanevermind]

I still can't believe it, what kind of masterminds are sitting in BigHit. This is unbelievably deep and that's one reason I love them so much!

[@zedekiahthemoonwalker]

This era was a masterpiece.

[@kimtaejin8196]

Bang PD Nim and BTS including the entire production behind every BTS discography/Cinematography is just on a whole different level. It blows my mind everytime xCeleste uploads theories and revelations like this.

[@trinamc76]

Isn’t it all just mind blowing?! I love that they’ve created this whole world throughout their work… true artists!

[@christinahanle9449]

I never regret becoming an ARMY. The concepts and the theories of their era are just amazing and so well thought out. Bangtan never fails to blow my mind.

[@naafilabasheer]

Wooowwww.... Finally out. This is what you had worked for a lot of days and you explained it so great. Its so AMAJIN...

[@xCeleste]

YUP! It's finally out! I hope you enjoyed it and I'm glad you think I explained it good.

[@trusfratedebadita7560]

Queen dropped the thing I wanted for a long time..

[@xCeleste]

YUSSSS LOL Finally! Thank you for watching!

[@trusfratedebadita7560]

@@xCeleste THANK YOU FOR UPLOADING ❤️❤️ You are the best!!

[@anshikayadav9249]

the stroryline always gives me goosebumps.....I most cried. Wings really is my favorite era

[@chanslaptop7522]

I've seen your every theories and it all makes a lotttttt more sense now you are a JINious 💜

[@arvind8011]

😭😭it is soo sad that this video has very small amount of views and a large portion of the fandom doesn't have any idea of all this storyline,deep meanings They just stan them bcoz of their looks or listens to their songs without context

[@jasnaraoof3143]

Yeah maybe half of the fandom didn't know about these storylines

[@kangelsekai]

I doubt they stan them bc of their looks bc toxic army only think 3/7 of bts is pretty

[@juliettedemaso7588]

BTS knows how to create a hook though, they understand there’s a journey and it often begins with a first glance.. and in that, many many people end up beginning there, but then walking the path to their true meaning. I feel like Western media is the biggest obstacle to finding the deeper side of bts. What they deliberately choose to show, and not.. mmph. My feed is always loaded with the junk. I have to weave around it every day. But I think (if I’m feeling optimistic) even that can teach people how to better filter the internet and media in general. I hope so ..

[@sanyadalal13]

The most anticipated video is finally here !!!💜👑

[@xCeleste]

YUSSSSSS

[@shamiiithar]

IF BTS WAS A SUBJECT, I AM DEFINITELY THE TOPPER

[@lilywrites4357]

i am in it too😅

[@malihatabassum2852]

Gentle reminder we all failed in the BTS exam lmao😂😂😭😅

[@lilywrites4357]

@@malihatabassum2852 yaa.. don't expose😭🤣😂😅 yeah thats the sad truth by the way. i will work hard for that..... funny fact - i got low marks than my math paper😅

[@microcosmoslove1515]

BTS and everyone that worked on their storyline are amazing artists, and genius. I am so inpressed by their meaningful work, that is deep, thoughtful, dramatic; but also beautiful and highly artistic. I stan the right band. also, thank you so much xceleste for your hanrd work, you are truly amazing for doing all this content for us. I can't even imagine how much time you spent in doing researches, reading books and quotes, watch over clips and lyrics. Talking to people or just thinking about everything. Thank you so much!

[@mariamnoora]

i love rosan's voice... especially while explaining things..... its so calm.... you really wouldnt notice time passing by....

[@JannatulFaiza2005]

After so many days!! The theories will keep me up at night now🥲💜

[@xCeleste]

LOL I hope you enjoyed the video! Thank you for watching!

[@thekidnextdoor1099]

xCeleste never ceases to impresses my by her videos. She and her videos are so amazing!

[@KAM-gd7om]

감사합니다🙏 긴 시간 이영상을 올리기위해 많은 시간과 에너지를 쏟아부은 당신의 열정과 노력에 박수를 보냅니다 아미들이 방탄의 산물들을 더 깊게 알게될거에요💜

[@xCeleste]

제 영상을 즐겨주셔서 기쁩니다. 시청해주셔서 감사합니다! 어떻게든 계속 도울 수 있기를 바랍니다. 💜💜

[@ellafroah6545]

i’ve never ever in my entire life have seen something so complexed and beautifully produced. BTS deserves so much because this is truly mind blowing.

[@benlaozk327]

The amount of time n effort u must have put in to make this video, hats off to u n thank you so much for creating this video, armys are grateful to u as always💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@auspicious8415]

This era will always hold a special spot in my heart. I came to know about kpop and bts because of bst in 2016, but I hated them before cuz "they looked like girls", but then in 2018 I started listening to their music more, so yeah I became a fan. But many people make fun of me because i'm a boy who is a fan of them, which really makes me sad. Great video.

[@injilaansari28]

Hey, don't be sad about that, those people who make fun of you are the ones who are missing out. Just enjoy your time with BTS and don't worry about those people it's their loss after all. :)

[@kaylee9185]

so many people judge them based on their looks without listening to their music. they don't know what they are missing. I also didn't like them at first bcs I judged them without getting to know them.

[@florabashang]

You’re the best literature teacher ever!

[@josephineacod2335]

I had goosebumps throughout the video. Psychology is quite complex but I love it. BST is difficult to understand if you do not know what is behind it. Thanks to xCeleste for enlightening us. She is really good . 👌🤗💜🤟

[@Aurie_d]

Your analysis are always so understandable, wow... 😊 The effort you put into this research and piecing one and two together is much appreciated ☺🙏😊

[@xCeleste]

I'm happy to hear that it's so understandable cause that's always my goal. Thank you so much for taking the time to watch this long video!

[@keevai7828]

I love you X thank you thank you Your a true hard-core Army

[@xCeleste]

Awww love you too! Thank you 💜

[@keevai7828]

@@xCeleste you so welcome , keep it up

[@ami_rheyia]

OMG Xceleste, I don't even know how to compliment you anymore 😅 This is amazing! I'm sure there are other ARMYs who've made explanation videos about BTS Universe and Wings Era but yours is just on another level!! The way you explain things is very calm and clear that's why even though you're feeding us with sooo much information we still manage to understand and not get overwhelmed!! 🤩 I think even BH staff and the members themselves would be very impressed and shocked about how you managed to piece together all their BU contents, heck I even think BTS member themselves don't understand everthing about their alternate characters 🤗 You're such an irrecplaceable member of the ARMY fandom, I hope you get recognized by the members in the future if not sooner. You literally researched and went through EVERYTHING related to the BU from scratch (meaning you didn't based your opinions from other explained videos) like meticulously studying every frames of MVs to notice all details no matter how small they are, watching all short videos related to the BU, reading the Save Me webtoon legally, purchasing The Notes Book 1 and 2, collecting all notes from the albums, dissecting related lyrics of songs, understanding all the paintings and symbolisms used, studying about the books that BH used, even interviewing Carl Jung himself! and finishing the BTS Universe game! 🤯 Then combining all together to help fellow ARMYs understand what's happening, editing the videos and finally creating a script to properly narate everthing perfectly 😵 And all these while staying up to date with BTS, moving to a new home and living your personal life to the fullest.......I don't know how you do it girl, in my eyes you're amazing! I just wish someday you get to interact with BTS again in a more proper and private setting because you damn deserve it 💜💜💜

[@susannazeller9021]

I agree, it's like Rosan even met CJ himself😊...but it was probably easier in the form of Murray Stein💜🥰💜🌈🌈🌈🐳🐳🐳💜💜💜🌈🌈

[@brianlampugnani1911]

This was brilliant from your part, from army theorists and from de BigHit team who came up with this beautiful creation. I still enjoy it like the first time.

[@agresthetic]

If you pause it at 14:45, you’ll notice there is a poster that is similar to something we see in fire. The handshake.

[@katetk5775]

I will never watch th BS&T MV the same anymore after watching this. It has a lot message and meaning that i didn't know until i watched this. Thankyou!

[@aecheul1089]

I'm a new BTS fan and have been watching MVs of their songs. Been thinking that their MVs are somehow related to each other and then I saw this. Glad I found your videos, my mind is now at ease but blown with their creativity.

[@nirvana6172]

Your brain is amazing, wings era was a total mystery for me, thank you for putting this together. Though it's impossible, I wish Hybe made a movie out of this with BTS.. I just wish it's still them as a character.

[@tanjam5286]

that was the most interesting Literature class I ever attended, just now :)

[@christinahanle9449]

these videos deserve way more recognition. Everything makes sense now! I can really tell hoe hard you worked on these videos. Thank you so much, keep it up!

[@kathleenroderick6833]

I'm so glad to hear others say what I've always felt that I'll never be over the Wings era ! I'll NEVER be over BTS showing such beautiful artistry 💜💜💜

[@Courroxxi879]

I hope BTS will continue the story more in upcoming mv's and vcr's for the concerts.

[@Lisanont]

I study on a Music line, and choose to pick BS&T as the music video for my danish assignment, so here I am. Thanks for this video !

[@rjbirmingham]

Thank you. You have pulled it all together in one video. This is outstanding work. I hope HYBE see it and sees how you would be a wonderful team member for that organziation.

[@carolinej9407]

I just started listening to BTS a couple of months ago, but this made me feel like I was meant to find them to help me find myself.

[@Megan9689]

Thank you for working hard on this. Makes it so much easier to understand when you pull and organize everything from all the different medias(webtoon, mvs, BTS Universe game, The Notes, even quotes from the members like Yoongi's at the press conference right at the end).

[@kuku0113]

thank u as always , this was so helpful honestly wings era is the most complex era for me so figuring out everything and connecting the dots together now makes so much sense

[@prana9714]

I started with wanting to know their names... Im now wanting to read this psychological book!!!

[@leasaina2838]

This is fricken amazing

[@ATPWKH7]

9:30 sent shivers down my spine... again

[@alice.t2879]

who is the genius behind this . i never thought it would be this detailed and intricate when i found out about the BU . definitely understood it better watching your videos but still its so complex and brilliant.

[@andreaasdfghjjkl]

The attention to detail!!!! *chef kiss* Rosan you really are a blessing to Army!! 💜💜

[@ot-7]

Whoever makes the story lines of bts's mv's.. Are actually truly genius.. Like tf the way they link each nd every song🙂✨and meaning behind it!.. That only few armys who're actually curious knows💀

[@mirapyaar8932]

I really enjoyed this ..you are one of best when it come to those summary and explaination,I like the way you try to organise and simplify each points with different era and how it inspired from books /phycology

[@Stephanie-is7bu]

imagine if they released this story line today? any industry must be shaking.

[@Abhinav2828-q3h]

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR MAKING AN EXPLANATION VIDEO ON WINGS I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR SOMETHING LIKE THIS 😭😭😭😭💜💜💜💜

[@imissjjwan]

22:59 did anyone notice the wallpaper in this scene? OMG I LOVE THIS STORYLINE IT DRIVES ME INSANE IN THE BEST WAY EVER

[@imissjjwan]

24:13 nvm u guys

[@veraafenyo2137]

These boys take art to a new dimension. Taking so many conceptual pieces if media to make their own story and reality is so amazing. Love you always 💓 and thank you for your immense media literacy

[@charestriart]

just... how far u analyze all these is mind blowing!. great job 🙌

[@pama1442]

20:05 Snickers made me realise that in fake love jhope was laying on Snickers chocolate

[@bereasonable8018]

Bravo XCeleste! The amount of work and knowledge you have about the BU is astounding. I don't know how you remember all of the details and connect them so clearly.

[@kandaarmy2020]

Thank you for making this video. I know it took a lot of time, effort, research ect. I was entranced the entire time. Hats off to you Sis. If it wasn't for your storyline explaination and this video I would've been completely lost. It is unreal how brilliant the Storyline and the Wings era are. How they overlap and stand alone. Their connections to real life, literature and Art. When I tell you a lot of these artists can't even shine BTS's shoes, I mean just that. 💜

[@BackToBlueSide218]

Just when I thought I knew everything, some new details comes to light. I would be absolutely lost without Rosan!

[@rach7922]

This so well explained 🤯😵 thank you for the explanation dear 💜

[@sylviabruhin3058]

Danke!

[@xCeleste]

Thank youuuu!! 💜💜

[@lizrazo5530]

Your voice is so nice, and the words are so clear. Thanks for doimg this. You mind is so amazing.

[@AngelaSealana]

Congratulations on getting this done, Rosan!!!!

[@jonahmicahmanalang3530]

Can't wait to watch this! 💜

[@xCeleste]

💜💜💜💜 yesss hehe

[@batool_OT7]

I cannot thank you enough for this intricate explaination. I was having a hard time dealing with all the theories and haters coming up with rumours about BTS being satanic especially in the bst mv but the way you explained evey thing was just too amazing! Now I get all of the theories and have understood much of it! Thanks a lot again! You're amazing and have an amazing voice!! 🤍

[@ATPWKH7]

13:02 and I started to cry... again

[@itsbtszone]

Omg I was wait for this !

[@xCeleste]

💜💜

[@zidianowner5105]

I felt really sad. I came to know bts after the dynamite song released. Actually I feel like I missed this era so much. No matter how many albums and how many singers would come in the future, WINGS and BTS are my favorites forever.

[@jenmaranan1798]

Thank you @xCeleste for saving our brains and putting so much effort in doing this. Respect and hugs to you my dear. Keep safe. God bless!

[@chrissturkenboom6080]

You are truly amazing. The way you explain everything. The way you show how genius BTS is with their concept. How they use art to create new art. Also how good BTS is into bringing and stimulating people to read, watching art, exploring yourself, find yourself etc. It is a pitty that so far as I know there is not a single interview out there asking RM Suga JHope Jin Jungkook V Jimin about all of this. Throughout their songs (also dancing) we are always stimulated to find out by ourselves or together what it all means. (What I like) BTS'S art work (songs) can be taken seperate but, also linked in BU or the total concept. The Wings era was and still is magical. Also "the luxury" of following BTS from when they started/ and still following Them..... Means we are growing together. It is a pitty that there are still people who are still looking down on BTS. In my country (The Netherlands) the media; music industry, tv, radiostations, magazines etc are so superficial/shallow (not only with BTS, but with more different type of music, example Nightwish) they only follow the mainstream most of the time the same old songs and from the well known big companies that buy there way into getting promoted. Throughout the years they very seldom play BTS'S music. The only song that you heard a lot of was DYNAMITE even Butter and Permission to dance you very seldom hear on the radio. Thank you for making this. This is aspecially important for people who are just discovering BTS. Sorry, I don't have money to pay for anything but, I do tell people about your channel. I have a deep respect for what you do. Keep on going. Never give up. Warm greetings from a 61 years old Mom from The Netherlands that have been following BTS from the beginning. I started following Korean music since Seo Atiji and I was so happy that BTS was invited into his: Seo Taiji: 25th Anniversary Time Traveler feat. BTS (2017). To me that was a dreams came true. Thanks again and sorry for the long reaction. Again warm greetings from The Netherlands 👍💜🍀🤘🇳🇱🌷👏💜🍀R💜🍀S💜🍀 J💜🍀J💜🍀J💜🍀V💜🍀J🤗

[@gabrielle13461]

Unbelievable. I totally feel the same way. I’m from the Netherlands too, and your remark on the Dutch media (tv and radio) is exactly true. DYNAMITE was probably the only song dutch people knew about in 2020. And I must confess, for me too🥴. But after Dynamite, BUTTER and PTD didn’t receive that much attention in our country. And now ‘MY UNIVERSE’ is played on the radio, only just because it’s a collaboration with Coldplay. COVID-19 made me dive into the Korean world with K-dramas and K-music, mostly OST-songs. I only knew BIG BANG by name, because of their tour some 10 to 15 years ago. A friend of mine then asked me about BTS and so I dived into their rabbit whole. I loved BTS’s reaction to ARMY-TIME during The Love Yourself concert in London. (I wished I was there). And like the Pied Piper song said, I then was hooked, buying dvd’s and watching online concerts. I’m an ARMY since March 2021 and XCeleste helped me with this addictive journey. Thank you XCeleste ☺️. And you know what….believe it or not, I’m not that young either (grandma-stuff, but age is just a number☺️).🇳🇱Gabrielle 💜

[@rackyshak]

Most important: this is an incredible video! Thank you for taking the time to create and share it with us~ It’s fascinating. Less important (but still very important): I paused the video. Because. I did not realize. That there is a *BTS Universe Story Game*. I repeat, *there is a BTS Universe Story Game??* Also: looking back at the individuation/differentiation theme, it’s bittersweet because it foreshadows how, in real life, all 7 members will go on to have solo careers that share their truer selves with us. Their styles are all so different, but BTS is the home that empowered them to hone their talents and pursue their ambitions.

[@catherinesotilbrown9837]

This is simply mindblowing! Just another proof of how incredibly well thought their artistic concepts are, not only is it their music but all the creative process behind it to put together a consistent storyline

[@prity4799]

*Thats what I was waiting for* !!

[@xCeleste]

💜 It's finally here! Enjoy!

[@audreystewart6442]

Awwwww I’ve been so excited for this!! Thank you hon for all your hard work!! You are so appreciated and loved😊💜

[@theamateurwriternaruuna]

Just one word for your explanation : GREAT!

[@4AMReflections]

Just today I finished my book Demian. I'm excited how well i can understand this.

[@kay141]

Good job girl we need another one abt dark and wild era

[@avantikapandey5507]

Girl!! You have no idea!! I always waited for you to do this video!! Omg thank youuu😭😭🥺

[@xCeleste]

YAY!! I'm happy to hear that you were looking forward to this! Thank you so much!

[@alexandrastengarn9671]

I always enjoy watching you're analysasion videos breaking the bone of eras and BTS universe. It helps me to understand more clearly but also just to generally admire the all creativity and philosophy of BTS discography, specially since i'm a baby Army from last year, so still going through back in time myself seeing their previous work of arts. So far except from TXT there's no other artists with fully detailed to the point of conveying out the story of their albums and eras. I mean BTS is themselves same with TXT and I think you can't categorize them into other artists that has same style of music production because that's how unique they are. Thank you for you're hard work into summarize it. Highly appreciated, btw love you're channel generally 💜

[@babitachettri9552]

Thank you for the explanation ❤💜

[@xCeleste]

Thank you for watching my video!

[@babitachettri9552]

@@xCeleste you're very welcome...keep it up

[@stephanomalyarts2647]

This was an INCREDIBLE explanation!!!

[@Gidget110]

Well done Celest 👏🏼. This was so helpful and makes me more appreciate the Wings Era 🥰💜

[@glo1761]

Xceleste...Brava! such clarity... wonderful explanation. You are doing something very important. Dont stop ...thank you. I applaude you

[@Call_Me_LiaB]

Thank you for this video. I attended a zoom with Dr. Stein a little over a year ago when I first fell down the BTS rabbit hole. I have a sociology degree and remember briefly studying Jung in college. It was an amazing Zoom. Very informative.

[@alinapark1]

Thank you for all the research and beautiful storytelling, without you I wouldn't have understood the BTS universe 💜

[@chanslaptop7522]

27:03 this painting is on the set when blood sweat and tears starts if you see properly

[@moonchild07613]

I still can't move on. This era was so special for me. A feeling. I can't describe it but I love that feeling.

[@nuovum1944]

So brilliant...analyzing & connecting everything, revealing all d details that has significant meanings that will complete d picture, d storyline. I admire... BTS is really no joke, so deep & philosophically beautiful, they r everything☝💜 Thank U for this 😃🥰🙌👍👌

[@saralafernando9243]

Every time I watch your theory videos my jaw drops to the ground. thanks for doing this :)

[@atinybangtan]

No matter how many of these videos i watch it keeps blowing my mind how they thought of all of this.

[@kopal.mishra]

That's why bts is my favorite, they and the directors put so many efforts into it to help it become a masterpiece...I really love map of the soul, Love yourself and wings Era a lot❤

[@Jennifer-fy7oe]

Thank you so much for the explanation. It's so incredibly good. You are so good in explaining, patiently without running & it's a great insight into the Wings Era. One of my favourite eras. BTS are Angels trending this earth. Awesome 👍🏻

[@LovelyAngel415]

I can't wait for the drama series of this finally all in detail from these explanations🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼 I wonder what names they will be using tho since they will not use the members real names...🤔🤔

[@noemibernal4882]

Amazing!! Thank you, xCeleste!