Canada & Sikh radicals: Votebank politics, an assassination lauded, failure to punish AI-182 bombers

[@ThePrintIndia]

Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

[@originofaholespecies9389]

Excellent analysis, Gupta ji..couple of things india can do..we need covert assassination capability like mossad..we can not rely on goodwill of canada and uk to teach these khalistani scumbags a lessons...second, monitor indian gurdwaras of punjab ..i am ashamed to admit that many of our own is now being influenced by pakistani + khalistani propaganda...third, bring back farmer's bill..this is the financial head of the snake and we need to kill it last by not the least our overseas community should try everything to slowly convince white canadians about the growing threat of radical sikh gangs +terrorists at their backyard..khalistan won't be happening at india but they can take vancuvar because of weak canadians last, wherever you see even a slightest khalistani apologist justifying their act or want to portray 84 riot as genocide, tell them how many innocent hindu families were butchered by coward sikh radicals in 1990 including air india bombing !

[@chetanbs8734]

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😢😢😢😢😮

[@shivramutube]

Hey SOB, why are you mischievously showing the picture of Modi shaking hands with Trudeau as if he has to do anything to do with this float?

[@jagmeetsingh5326]

@shekhar gupta You never talk about Jaswant Singh Khalra who showed evidence of 1000s of state sponsored killings by govt, yet you talk about air india bombing, which sikhs believe was done to defame sikhs and the support they were getting from canada. This is biased journalism

[@subegsingh942]

To , The Print ( Shekhar Gupta ) , you and people like you are biased and manupulator on the matter of Punjab and Sikhs, you all Hindus and Indian government system celebrates the assassination of Ravan every year because Ravan kidnaped Seeta , but when Sikhs celebrate the assassination of Indira ( who murdered damocracy in emergency and created atmosfear of terror with the miss use of her power, attacked on many Sikhs religioous places and killed many Sikh pilgrims in the name of terror only for her dirty politics and lust of rule ) then people like you call them radicals. the whole India should celebrate the assassination of Indira ( female ravan ) and thanks to those Sikhs who assassinated her and saved this country from that dangeorous tarrorist ( Indira ).

[@PindDiStream]

my aunt who lives LA California told me that they have to drive more than an hour just so they can go to the gurudawara which doesn't affiliate itself with these radicals. It's a shame to see how our faith is getting radicalised. I believe the root cause for this is illiteracy.

[@miaomeow69]

It can't be illiteracy. It's misinformation, or lack of proper education. Young people can get misguided by harmful political ideologies if they are not armed(properly educated) to deal with it. Others are often just misinformed.

[@ritikshaw5868]

The young Sikhs being transported in bulks with barely legal college applications is one of the factors I presume. Most don't pursue higher education.. Get in touch with these hooligans and then parrot the same brain washed lines. So instead of 80s era Khalistanis, you'd get these young uneducated technically Indian fools who'd be parroting these lines. I guess that's why Australia has stopped accepting applicants from many colleges.. All exclusively from Punjab it seems.

[@vicky1b]

Surely not illiteracy, but radical ideology of a handful influential Sikhs being promoted after taking control of Gurudwaras.... Sad affair, my relatives in US tell me that earlier they used to visit Gurudwara with reverence and felt no different from Sikh brethren, but now it is very difficult to find a Gurudwara which is not under Control of Khalistanis...

[@abhinashkumar3161]

@@vicky1b that's really sad

[@jiti5034]

It can't be illiteracy. It's misinformation and more importantly silence by the majority

[@armadhillo]

I am ashamed at the the behaviour of my fellow Sikhs who have become so full of hate that they do not recognize how linked and connected Sikhs are to the Indian identity... Radicalism can happen in any religion but it is so sad to see this in one that preaches equality and unity as one of its core tenets... I am a Sikh as much as an Indian living in Canada and those identities are both equally close to who I am. These people do not represent the majority of Sikhs who denounce violence and feel as Indian and patriotic as anyone who loves their country. Any political party, any right wing leader, and ideology cannot separate that Sikhs have been linked with India since its inception. Our freedom fighters who were Sikh would be saddened to see this divide and hatred. Please remember that this not all of the Sikhs in Canada and many support the foundation of India itself like secularism, democracy, unity, and freedom of religion which we hold dear.

[@souviksikdar1864]

But in this age of information overload, it is very easy to have stereotypes, it doesn't take much time. Therefore the responsibility lies with Sikhs in Canada and India to publically come forward and denounce these people.

[@libshastra]

Don't call them Sikhs, they are Khalistanis. Despite that, we are still with you.

[@dnapolren]

I live in Canada as well.. it is nice to hear you speaking against the Khalistanis.. but why don't we guys get together and demonstrate against Khalistanis demonstrations.. why keep mum? why not speak out? That will put pressure on the govt to not allow such Khalistanis exhibitions..

[@suketupatel7834]

People like you need to speak up and form groups to mitigate the radicalization of such groups. Most people dont know the story behind it so they would start assuming all sikhs to be terrorists in future like what happens with other terror supporting religion.

[@Fsmonster708]

@@dnapolren why don't hindus speak out against those advocating hindu rashtra? its same everywhere, those who take extremist position don't tolerate the pacifists

[@nehak852]

Once Hilary Clinton said, "It's like that old story - you can't keep snakes in your backyard and expect them only to bite your neighbours. Eventually those snakes are going to turn on whoever has them in the backyard"

[@sahas397]

That's the first thing that came to mind.❤

[@garymacek4904]

This is the same Hillary Clinton who launched bloody regime change operations in Libya, Egypt, Syria and Yemen while she was Sec of State. Not the person I would quote.

[@manurr10]

Would love to see Khalistan carved out of Canada.

[@SV-wu2my]

True. They created Mullah Umer and his group came hard on them later.

[@binakhimji6509]

So true. I never liked Justin Trudeau.

[@harkritsingh1896]

As a sikh i feel very sad about what is happening in Canada , i have no trust on Trudeau government

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Have trust in Indian government that protects the murderers and does genocide against other religions

[@radhikapandit6819]

How many rapists and killers of 84 riots are roaming free

[@badshahyoyo624]

It will be the same who ever comes to power in Canada because of the vote bank politics...and as a Sikh you need not be sad about the state of affairs in Canada, fix Punjab and Canada will fall in line....

[@mrkps0001]

As if u r Sikh, you should also be sad about suppressing the voices of Sikhs in Punjab and putting the innocent youth behind bars and creating an emergency like conditions, also you should feel sad for the victims of 84 Sikh genocide

[@kps950]

Lol, you're anything but Sikh.

[@prasnair72]

I remember the then Canadian PM calling the then Indian PM Rajiv Gandhi for consoling him and Mr Gandhi telling him that most who died were your people. I even remember the pilot of the Kanishka was a Sikh pilot as his family would put obituaries in the Times of India.

[@pcpolice2314]

It was a right wing Canadian PM then.

[@originofaholespecies9389]

Excellent analysis, Gupta ji..couple of things india can do..we need covert assassination capability like mossad..we can not rely on goodwill of canada and uk to teach these khalistani scumbags a lessons...second, monitor indian gurdwaras of punjab ..i am ashamed to admit that many of our own is now being influenced by pakistani + khalistani propaganda...third, bring back farmer's bill..this is the financial head of the snake and we need to kill it last but not the least our overseas community should try everything to slowly convince white canadians about the growing threat of radical sikh gangs +terrorists at their backyard..khalistan won't be happening at india but they can take Vancouver because of weak canadians last, wherever you see even a slightest khalistani apologist justifying their act or want to portray 84 riot as genocide, tell them how many innocent hindu families were butchered by coward sikh radicals in 1990 including air india bombing !

[@raghvinderjoshi4667]

Hi Prashant, Your words are so simple yet so profound. We need such articulation for making this world a safe and sensible place for all.

[@SodiumSyndicate]

@@pcpolice2314 All Canadian political wings support Khalistani terrorism against India.

[@varoonnone7159]

@@pcpolice2314 Left wing canadians are actually the worse racists

[@ShubhamTiwari-mu8do]

Hearing the Air India story & the Canadian proceedings later clearly shows how cheap these Canadians considered Indian lives then. Its a tragedy. Imagine opposite case if something had happened from here to them. They would have called USA to go on a war against us. Really shameful to Canada for being such a puppet state to politucal game

[@gunngator588]

True it's such a shame, Even some of the perpetrators are walking freely in Canada, Indian lives or brown people lives doesn't matter anywhere

[@pcpolice2314]

Yes. And when Indian govt retaliates against Canada by doing things like suspending e-visas, it again only hurts Indian origin Canadians. In the end, no white Canadian is affected. Most white Canadians cant even find Punjab on a map.

[@saebae7511]

HINDU lives*

[@VijayKumar-dn4pz]

"Canadians considered". Dude, look at how cheap INDIANS consider INDIAN lives. 200+ dead in Orissa and nobody cares. Mass murders going on in Manipur and no one cares.

[@ven41618]

Vote bank politics? --- In other words, they are just like us in India! Even the Modi Govt refuses to act in the fear of losing Sikh support. No wonder, we have no law and order anywhere here. Soon Canada also will be just like us!

[@RaguRaghupathi]

Datapoint: I lost my cousin's family (Husband, Wife ,and two children), and my friend lost his brother's family (husband, wife and two children) in that terrorist bombing!

[@IndianBouyz]

My condolences to u and ur family for the loss. Jai sri krishna

[@ThePrintIndia]

I'm very sorry to hear this. It was a tragedy of epic proportions, made worse by how it was handled later. My condolences...Shekhar

[@rohanbansal9563]

Canada is only good in one thing - projecting itself as a liberal, caring and democratic country. I have lived in both US and Canada. Canada is good at projecting itself as an ideal world - caring people, society, tolerant and peaceful. To make this stronger, they would drag US in this. If you talk with Canadians, it would feel like everyone in US carries a gun like Rambo and uncivilized. On the contrary, I find average Americans to be more polite than an average Canadian. I have found many white Canadians to be extremely rude and racist, when compared to average Americans. One another thing Canada is good at is hiding its negatives. In US, every crime amplifies and comes out bigger in media. In Canada, its generally swept quietly under the carpet. So you would think crime doesn't exist in Canada, purely due to perception. AI 182 is living example of it.

[@NonSecular]

Very well said

[@pikachue602]

Drug addict towns,sudden attacks ,rapes, killings etc are only the few

[@sukhmansandhu6036]

Yes canada is bad, all lindians should pack their bags and head home. We dont want you bastards in this country,

[@Pajit_slayer]

Atleast better then people like Manoj who cooks women. And if you don't like canada then why are you staying there . May be you want a foreign cow.

[@Sebastian-zn3dx]

Canada is a minion country of the USA, its culture is pure decadent anti-human shit and it is doomed to self-destruction.

[@samip3124]

Canada is going same path of Pakistan "if you keep snakes in your backyard don't think they won't bite you"

[@warriors_battle]

Same as india 🇮🇳 such terrorist group like RSS and bajrangdal every indians are facing this issue they just create hatred over here. No freedom of speech in india now days.

[@gagak1557]

I was absolutely amazed that even after such a blatant display of Indira Gandhi l, Congress leadership was completely mum.

[@harshgarg1448]

It apologized in parliament in 2005

[@niharikakhare8763]

Today they are more bothered about Rahul Gandhi and votes.

[@d1p70]

congress would sell their mother for votes

[@ZenFactChecker]

can't deny the truth I guess.

[@vivek1raja]

The BJP celebrates Godse openly in India - and you are worried anout RG?

[@marcopolo8468]

I see a lot of similarities between Rahul Gandhi and Justin Trudeau: Both Justin Trudeau and Rahul Gandhi come from families with a strong political lineage as they are descendants of former Prime Ministers. Both Trudeau and Gandhi have been considered youthful leaders within their respective political parties. Both leaders are known for their charismatic woke personalities and have a significant following among their party members and supporters. They have been able to connect with younger audiences. Trudeau runs the Trudeau Foundation, while Rahul Gandhi runs The Rajiv Gandhi Foundation. They both hold Bachelor's degrees in arts and literature. Trudeau promotes multiculturalism and open immigration in Canada, while Rahul advocates for secularism and refugees from neighboring countries. Canada is going through a tough time right now. The healthcare system is struggling, food costs are rising, real estate prices are going up, and there has been an increase in violent crimes and drug overdoses lately. We have seen Liberals in Canada and the Congress in India protecting minority extremism in their countries. Additionally, both parties target majoritarianism in their respective countries.

[@ShivamGupta-sr9zf]

There is one important difference you missed between those two. Unlike RG who is an idiot and a dumbass, Trudeau is actually smart and clever and that's why Trudeau is in power, unlike RG who can only dream about becoming the PM of India.

[@akshytube]

But people are different, in Canada they elected that clown and in India the clown was rejected.

[@sohamlovessicilian.7387]

​@@akshytube this comment needs more likes.

[@marcopolo8468]

@@akshytube Strong chance for that clown to become king in 2024. People have started taking him seriously.

[@divyanshtiwari3547]

@@marcopolo8468 I beg to differ. Still people laugh at the guy and his supporters especially people calling andhbhakts to other when they indeed unconditionally support congress

[@rajeevkashyap4764]

Sikh community in Canada is rich community possessing all sort of businesses . I don’t know why sitting there in Canada, they demand Khalistan in India, because no Sikh will go to that Khalistan leaving opportunities of Canada. In fact if they want an independent state, Canada has large land with very little of its population, this is high time they demand Khalistan from Canada government

[@shanekishore7784]

@@japneetsingh5015 yes, with Lahore as the capital .

[@mohit19907]

​@@japneetsingh5015 chal nikal apne baap Pakistan se maang pehle khalisthan

[@ritika5363]

​@@japneetsingh5015Punjab doesn't only belong to Sikhs. Hindus and other religious groups have equal stake in Punjab. Logically , if u will demand khalistan, then Punjab can be divided into two parts as hindus and Muslims forms 40% of total Punjab's population . R u ready to divide it ?

[@venuspaulose1066]

@@ritika5363 m

[@souvikbiswas1757]

​@@japneetsingh5015 lawra

[@el_benny_]

"Hate is baggage, life's too short to be pissed off all the time. It's just not worth it." -Danny Vinyard

[@Deepkh]

Now I'm going to watch that movie again

[@wethepeople402]

American History X

[@jackshrimp]

Trudeau's govt is propped up by a Sikh leader of NDP, hence the govt is soft on the khalistanis supported by this Sikh leader

[@dhruvseoni8418]

Hagg meet is a pure Khayalistani, barely a Sikh

[@CosmicJockey]

Gurudwaras are now political units…..sad that religion has been taken over by a few power hungry

[@trevor2372]

They have been always like that. Read the history of akaal Takhat.

[@awadheshkalia]

It appears Canada has way more resources than its population needs. So it may look to be outwardly a developed country. But, there is little rule of law and no consequence management of a developed democratic nation. Quite a shame.

[@egg-h4b]

It's not about rule of law. Canada is so much diverse (in terms of people belonging to different ethnic groups) that most non-sikhs are completely indifferent to what's happening with this community. Even their law enforcement agencies are not well versed with what's happening with this community. Most of them view it as a local community problem where some people are angry with the Indian government. And since these guys are very smart as to not cause any physical injuries to anyone, for the police there is no law broken and hence no action required. Every summer you'll see people from different ethnic group protest against the government in their home country. These include Hong Kongs, Chinese, Afghans, Palestinians, etc. The government just lets them protest. These Khalistanis are also looked upon as one of them. TBH, literally no one bats an eye to these protests. People just ignore their presence and move on with their lives.

[@abhinashkumar3161]

@@egg-h4b wow

[@dukhi_aatma372]

@@egg-h4b I concur with you on this. Indian govt. should first study how Canadian laws work before building a strategy to deal with this menace. Right now India appears like a child throwing tantrum, hoping it can dictate decisions on Canada the way it does in its own country. There are many options India has at its disposal, wonder why it doesn't employ any of those.

[@IndianBouyz]

Sir with utmost respect no country has ample. Its just that they are more of a polished version of indian radical parties like owaisi and his brigade.

[@mikesheth5370]

Canadian high commissioner is behaving like Indian national. Here in Canada liberals and NDP either keep quiet or openly support Khalistanis and don't pay any attention if their Hindu subjects are attacked! Also don't forget Sikhs bribe them, deliver votes and invite them in their function.

[@lantherpagdi]

most of them have a very shallow understanding about india. They think sikhs form majority in India. Sikhs are also active in politics and khalistanis are on a mission mode where as rest of the Indians are confused, lazy self centered and delusional.

[@singhjasbeer5216]

As a Sikh I must say that celebrating this is totally against Sikhism by all means.

[@harmandeepsingh7662]

Wtf ? You are buying hindu propaganda ?

[@singhjasbeer5216]

@@harmandeepsingh7662 What’s hindu propaganda in this??? Firstly you must do some research as to on which channel you are commenting. The Print is despised by hindu right wing themselves so it’s common sense that anyone who is listening to this is far from so called ‘hindu propaganda’ and also to add to it Celebrating a death is never Sikhi by any means that too when she was killed by those who were meant to protect her. This was betrayal by all means and hence completely opposite of Sikh teachings never ever in history such thing has happened where Sikhs have misused their position in such a way.

[@thechosenone3014]

​@@harmandeepsingh7662 wats propaganda in this?

[@diggidiggiable]

@@harmandeepsingh7662waah logic. Where does Hindu ideology come here? Moreover, radical Sikhism will lead to Taliban like situation

[@singhjasbeer5216]

@@thechosenone3014 Right, actually these guys apply less brain and get swayed away by emotions and for everything they’ll put the blame on “hindus” which is totally nonsense.

[@PrateekBehera]

An important point to note regarding the 1985 Kanishka bombing is that Two Japanese Baggage handlers also died in Tokyo Narita Airport. It's shameful how Canada has given free pass to the terrorists. It's quite evident Canada doesn't care about immigrant citizens.

[@pikachue602]

Be it Indian or Japanese a life is a life at the end

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Very shameful of bramin indian government to blow up an international airliner. Shows how demonic Bramins really are

[@SatpalVerma000]

India is a fake country created by British based on Hindu religion just like Pakistan is a fake country based on Islam. In modern world countries are formed on basis of nationalities like Bangladesh is based on bangla nationality and countries in Europe are based on their respective nationalities. Before the invention of countries there used to be empires and kingdoms like the empires in Indian subcontinent or empires in European continent or empires in arab continent. After the fall of empires in Arab subcontinent, and Europe the countries were created based on nationalities but in Indian subcontinent two fake countries India and Pakistan were created based on two nation bogus theory. Two nations were considered as Islam and Hinduism and two fake countries were created. If Indian subcontinent follows rest of modern world, then countries should be created on basis of nationalities after the fall of British empire and modern Indian and Pakistan state empires who are based on Islam and hindusim. The base of India and Pakistan is religious hatred and bigotry. A country should be based on nationality like Bangladesh or countries in Europe but India is based on Hinduism. Bengali Hindus should join the Bangla nation state Bangladesh under their own conditions like great autonomy, 50% reservations for Hindus in parliament and army regardless the population size of Hindu and Muslims bengalis. But Bengali Hindus would never leave india because they support religion over bangla identity unlike bangla Muslims who prefer their national bangla identity over their religious identity and left Pakistan for the sake of bangla nation. Baluch nation been trying for the same. Europe did same. Nations in Yugoslavia did same. Catalonia in Spain and Kosov in Serbia, Kurdish in Turkey, Kashmiri Punjabi nagas and all North eastern nations in the fake union of India been trying for the same. Contrary to rest of the world, Indian Hindus don't care about their national identity but religious identity. That's why india is p*oor and Ba*ckward and would always continue to do so, because it's not a nation state but a multinational state (fake union of nations) and multinational states can never prosper because they would always be busy fixing their internal problems and their whole resources and energy would be wasted to keep the fake country united rather than expending the same on prosperity. See how Bangladesh is better than india on HDI and gdp per capita bcz it doesn't have to waste its resources and energy on defence and fights with neighbours or internal disputes arising due to conflicting interests of various nations in the multinational state, where majority nation or nations try to exploit and prey on the resources and interests of minority. ...

[@sardar_gurjot]

Yes the bombings which the Indian government themselves planned

[@daljitsoni3541]

the book Soft Target, written by two Canadian journalists, proves that the Indian government carried out the bombing. This finding is confirmed by Canadian Member of Parliament David Kilgour in his book Betrayed: The Spy That Canada Forgot. According to Kilgour, a Canadian-Polish double agent was recruited by terrorists working with the Indian government to help carry out a second bombing. The agent declined and reported what had happened. According to Soft Target, the Candian State Investigative Service (CSIS) was so convinced of the Indian government's involvement that at a meeting of the task force on the Air India bombing, one CSIS agent said, ``If you really want to clear the incident quickly, take vans down to the Indian High Commission and the consulates in Toronto and Vancouver, load up everybody and take them down for questioning. We know it and they know it that they are involved.''

[@balrajdeol9054]

Sir Todd has his facts wrong as only few gurdawaras hold elections, most are controlled by Khalistanis. How Sikhs manage to have 15-16 MPs is through political manipulation of nomination system. Also 80% of desi political leaders in Canada are Khalistanis or pro Khalistanis. If India wants to fight for itself than all such leaders should be black listed. Sir I am the one who 1st tweeted the video clip of this parade to highlight the issue.

[@AK-vk7gn]

Jai Hind

[@tamashbeen6610]

Balraj Ji tusi ik bhot bahadar te nek insaan ho.

[@davesingh6168]

SHAMEFUL

[@deadpoolwhoslaysassholes1586]

If there is God.. I'm sure you are in his list of good humans. 🙏🏼

[@sarabjeetsingh4799]

please speak of hindu rashstra terrorists in india .they are also harmful for the integrity of india

[@lathabalakrishnan3751]

Spine chilling recollections of terrible tragedies of the past. I was old enough to see these events unfold. Thank you Shekar. I am sure ThePrint's viewers and listeners are forever grateful to you for important reminders of how these tragedies occurred. Negligent foreign governments have a lot to answer for, but tend to get a free pass if they are the so-called "first" world!

[@koibatnahi4683]

Another gem of a session by SG. There is a saying in Hindi "नंगे के नौ ग्रह बलवान" a person who feels no shame has nothing to worry about. I hope this savage exposure by SG reaches the young Canadians somehow.

[@ThePrintIndia]

Thank you, I'm glad you liked this episode. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar

[@equilibrium1037]

​@@ThePrintIndia Utterly ludicrous. I've never heard a more incoherent complaint than "what kind of liberal nation allows [insert distasteful form of abstract expression]". Quite literally the answer is any liberal nation. If it puts people in a cage for transmitting an abstract thought with zero immanent co-action, than it is not a liberal nation. The rest is literally nothing over and above "why didn't the Canadians convict by fiat without the standard of evidence mandated by law?" Then positing a pseudo-psychology with zero difference from "see how the sinister Jews only really care about their own kind." If you can provide names of people you can prove are a party to action, than fine, arrest them. In a liberal society, feelings do not override liberties. "Gem of a session".

[@carlosgd8903]

Honestly, considering how much Sikh origin Canadians care about Punjab/Khalistan and Sikh affairs goes to show that they are indeed less "Canadian" than native born non Sikh Canadian.

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Because many of them didn’t immigrate their happily but because Bramin Indian forces were doing genocide of their people

[@lantherpagdi]

absolutely, they don't give a damn about canada. Canadians should stop trusting them and allowing their 3rd world politics to flourish in Canada. We have far more things to worry about.

[@harisundar8698]

Its an international shame, an international murder committed with the negligence of Canadian authorities, this needs to be reminded, brought to the light at platforms like UN. Injustice needs to be called out.

[@SatpalVerma000]

India is a fake country created by British based on Hindu religion just like Pakistan is a fake country based on Islam. In modern world countries are formed on basis of nationalities like Bangladesh is based on bangla nationality and countries in Europe are based on their respective nationalities. Before the invention of countries there used to be empires and kingdoms like the empires in Indian subcontinent or empires in European continent or empires in arab continent. After the fall of empires in Arab subcontinent, and Europe the countries were created based on nationalities but in Indian subcontinent two fake countries India and Pakistan were created based on two nation bogus theory. Two nations were considered as Islam and Hinduism and two fake countries were created. If Indian subcontinent follows rest of modern world, then countries should be created on basis of nationalities after the fall of British empire and modern Indian and Pakistan state empires who are based on Islam and hindusim. The base of India and Pakistan is religious hatred and bigotry. A country should be based on nationality like Bangladesh or countries in Europe but India is based on Hinduism. Bengali Hindus should join the Bangla nation state Bangladesh under their own conditions like great autonomy, 50% reservations for Hindus in parliament and army regardless the population size of Hindu and Muslims bengalis. But Bengali Hindus would never leave india because they support religion over bangla identity unlike bangla Muslims who prefer their national bangla identity over their religious identity and left Pakistan for the sake of bangla nation. Baluch nation been trying for the same. Europe did same. Nations in Yugoslavia did same. Catalonia in Spain and Kosov in Serbia, Kurdish in Turkey, Kashmiri Punjabi nagas and all North eastern nations in the fake union of India been trying for the same. Contrary to rest of the world, Indian Hindus don't care about their national identity but religious identity. That's why india is p*oor and Ba*ckward and would always continue to do so, because it's not a nation state but a multinational state (fake union of nations) and multinational states can never prosper because they would always be busy fixing their internal problems and their whole resources and energy would be wasted to keep the fake country united rather than expending the same on prosperity. See how Bangladesh is better than india on HDI and gdp per capita bcz it doesn't have to waste its resources and energy on defence and fights with neighbours or internal disputes arising due to conflicting interests of various nations in the multinational state, where majority nation or nations try to exploit and prey on the resources and interests of minority.

[@warriors_battle]

Exactly In UN we had to raise the issue what RSS and bajrang dal is doing in india....now their is no freedom of speech alive in india....

[@harisundar8698]

@@warriors_battle And from where are you commenting this sir??

[@warriors_battle]

@@harisundar8698 from india sir from maharashtra

[@sreenirajan7229]

​@@warriors_battlehave you heard about Sikhs burnt a bus full of hindus in Haryana!

[@theharryaulakh]

I feel so much ashamed, being a Sikh i feel it's brutal .

[@jitgtij]

@@jatindersingh3387 I think you are the fake one. When Sikhs are becoming terrorists at heart, when the kirpan is not for protection but to attack on behalf of greed, there is no Guru in heaven or earth that can redeem our soul.

[@temp1851]

​@@jatindersingh3387you are no Sikh, you are a khalistani terrorist.

[@deeptanshubhowmik5073]

@@jatindersingh3387 80% sikhs in punjab and all over india are like him 🤣🤣

[@deeptanshubhowmik5073]

@@jatindersingh3387 raho canada me....

[@jatindersingh3387]

@@deeptanshubhowmik5073 fake sikh id hai…😂

[@libshastra]

Shekarji, you should talk more about this at a TVO panel. BTW, Liberal Party of Canada is in alliance with NDP. As long as Jagmeet Singh leads that party, the Khalistani elements will be tolerated. Besides Khalistanis are essentially Jat supremacists (they think Jats are above every other "Pajeets"/Indian). Outside Punjab, Canada is probably the only place where you will find plenty of Ravidasi gurudwara. You don't find such segregation of Gurudwaras by caste in India.

[@vasusingh5909]

Yep even here in Delhi and UP the gurudwaras are quite normal, not influenced by this BS

[@jts1234]

India hindu state killed 150 k innocent Sikhs youth between 1984 to 1995 ,,,,

[@allahbakhshsahib7763]

See what are they doing in 22nd century, so barbaric. Now I understand why Punjab was divided and Punjabis killed and humiliated each other in 47. We Sindhi, Baloch, Saraiki and Pakhtoons are facing this mentality in Pakistan since 47 by Punjabi Fauj.

[@jts1234]

@@allahbakhshsahib7763 i think you are a RSS troll with 5 kilo rice a month payroll

[@naren2k6]

Jat Sikhs are the dumbest people around, historically uneducated, illiterate Farmers arrived in Canada legally and plenty Illegally in the 1960, and 1970 under then PM Pierre Elliett Trudeau, Justin Trudeau father, as a farming community most bought lots of farms with plenty of land which back then was relatively cheap, today that same land especially in places like Vancouver is worth Millions of Dollars, this wealth in turn funds these Terror elements who extort funds sometimes involuntarily or many times via Sikh temple funding their activities. The Khalistani Movement found safe haven in Canada because of lax Criminal Laws and they have gotten away with Murder literally, forty years and still the incompetence of the Canadian government to solve the AIr India tragedy is in itself criminal, had it been any other carrier things might have been different, sadly and funny thing is the majority of passengers with Sikhs.

[@kuku6789]

Thank you SG Sir. This is by far the most detailed explanation of Sikh vote bank in Canada and the Kanishka bombing.

[@SatpalVerma000]

India is a fake country created by British based on Hindu religion just like Pakistan is a fake country based on Islam. In modern world countries are formed on basis of nationalities like Bangladesh is based on bangla nationality and countries in Europe are based on their respective nationalities. Before the invention of countries there used to be empires and kingdoms like the empires in Indian subcontinent or empires in European continent or empires in arab continent. After the fall of empires in Arab subcontinent, and Europe the countries were created based on nationalities but in Indian subcontinent two fake countries India and Pakistan were created based on two nation bogus theory. Two nations were considered as Islam and Hinduism and two fake countries were created. If Indian subcontinent follows rest of modern world, then countries should be created on basis of nationalities after the fall of British empire and modern Indian and Pakistan state empires who are based on Islam and hindusim. The base of India and Pakistan is religious hatred and bigotry. A country should be based on nationality like Bangladesh or countries in Europe but India is based on Hinduism. Bengali Hindus should join the Bangla nation state Bangladesh under their own conditions like great autonomy, 50% reservations for Hindus in parliament and army regardless the population size of Hindu and Muslims bengalis. But Bengali Hindus would never leave india because they support religion over bangla identity unlike bangla Muslims who prefer their national bangla identity over their religious identity and left Pakistan for the sake of bangla nation. Baluch nation been trying for the same. Europe did same. Nations in Yugoslavia did same. Catalonia in Spain and Kosov in Serbia, Kurdish in Turkey, Kashmiri Punjabi nagas and all North eastern nations in the fake union of India been trying for the same. Contrary to rest of the world, Indian Hindus don't care about their national identity but religious identity. That's why india is p*oor and Ba*ckward and would always continue to do so, because it's not a nation state but a multinational state (fake union of nations) and multinational states can never prosper because they would always be busy fixing their internal problems and their whole resources and energy would be wasted to keep the fake country united rather than expending the same on prosperity. See how Bangladesh is better than india on HDI and gdp per capita bcz it doesn't have to waste its resources and energy on defence and fights with neighbours or internal disputes arising due to conflicting interests of various nations in the multinational state, where majority nation or nations try to exploit and prey on the resources and interests of minority. .

[@90skiyaadein69]

Sikhs are enjoying the same blackmail power that Indian Muslims enjoyed in Congress era

[@michealanderson2282]

completely agree ,some of them are using"victim card".

[@hs6736]

​@@rahulvats95 khalistanis . Not all Jatt Sikhs support this, not all khalistanis are jatts.

[@Battlebunny07]

Sikhs are enjoying the same blackmail power that Indian Hindus enjoying in BJP era...

[@90skiyaadein69]

@@Battlebunny07 yes lets convert them all and do wazva e hind

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

@@rahulvats95yes old age enemies of Aryan Bramens, not ever bowing to chotis

[@dukhi_aatma372]

Canada, on the outside, looks united, but is a deeply divided society within where everyone lives in their own community. There are communities of Sikhs, Indians, Chinese, Ukrainians, Italians etc etc. So whenever a tragedy takes place it is up to the respective community to fight for justice. Don't expect others to show any concerns. Take the example of Ukrainian passenger aircraft that was shot by Iranian missile. The people from the Ukrainians and Iranian community fought tooth and nail for a proper investigation. Moral of the story, Canada has many countries within a country, and every 'country' has to stand up for its rights and justice.

[@bradparmar4728]

No a Bad way of looking through the Lens!

[@chanakyabharat756]

Welcome to so called developed , Human rights preserved countries.

[@lantherpagdi]

Tomorrow even Taliban will fool you saying they are champions of human rights.if you believe all that BS it's your fault not theirs.

[@AmitSharma-gf4gz]

I was waiting for your analysis sir. You covered this issue in the most responsible manner. Love from canada ❤❤❤❤❤

[@chintuchoudhary00]

This is what we call a good editorial. Well researched and unbiased. Thanks Mr. Sakher Gupta and team

[@ven41618]

I concur. I also appreciate his candor in calling out the Canadian callousness.

[@NeetuSingh-vh3vk]

Actually the’editorial’ had incorrect ‘facts’ and was extremely biased…but good at spreading hate and misinformation. Canada is a true democracy, india is a joke….learn how to treat minorities better

[@jasdeepkaur3136]

How can you say it’s unbiased? It’s completely biased. You can say whatever you want, but don’t say it’s unbiased, which it clearly isn’t.

[@Rudransh.Rohit1401]

Let the khalistan be created in Kanedda.

[@harmandeepsingh7662]

Yeah Mughal era refugee who we saved now want to kick us out of our land .... ... Hindus wouldn't even have india if Britishers didn't give it to them

[@busypandey]

Lun dege wo inko . Local canadian are already pissed . They have ruined whole city called brampton. All locals moved out from there like all Indian hindus moved from bengals border city bcoz of illegal Bangladeshi invaders.

[@MackyMehra]

Let Hindu Rashtra be created in Aryans own homeland Kazakhstan

[@JagroopSingh-no7xy]

@@MackyMehra 👌👌👌👌👌

[@___SSS___]

​@@MackyMehra average dumb khalistani. We are living here and we will make hindurashtra here , you live there but want to make khalistan here . Koi sense hai is baat ka 😂😂😂

[@ragnarkasnia]

I stand vindicated . Born in 90’s in Haryana I have seen many of my sikh friends expressing khalistani mentality once they turn adolescents. In order to satiate their ego they let go sanity. Everybody talks about 1984 but no one wants to read that khalistani killed bus passengers in Haryana for being hindus. I respect sikhism . I am grateful that when I was born, a sikh friend of my uncle gave his blood to my mother as she was deficient of it.

[@harmandeepsingh7662]

Why are we calling eastern area of khalistan as haryana ?

[@jetank2016]

@@harmandeepsingh7662 smell coffee and then drive truck. Day dreaming can lead to accidents which can kill you. Clowns. Sikh bhaiye in Canada

[@jetank2016]

@@monsters3250 non sense. Your lies are moving through the skies. Khaliatanis are know aa donkey heads for a reason

[@japneetsingh4035]

@Dk banega ta Panjab vich. Tere hikk te chadh ke

[@GS......]

@Dk apni pehelwaanon ladkiyon kee toh ijjat bacha lo pehle delhi mei. Joote ke neeche dab rahi hain, tumhaare mai baap modi shah kee police ke.

[@VK-bk7gi]

Sikh radicalism is a topic so dear to SG. He took it up with Vajpayee as well to make AKalis follow the national discourse. Current situation must be giving him immense pain:(

[@tapemaj]

Your sarcasm will get upon You !!😅

[@originofaholespecies9389]

Excellent analysis, Gupta ji..couple of things india can do..we need covert assassination capability like mossad..we can not rely on goodwill of canada and uk to teach these khalistani scumbags a lessons...second, monitor indian gurdwaras of punjab ..i am ashamed to admit that many of our own is now being influenced by pakistani + khalistani propaganda...third, bring back farmer's bill..this is the financial head of the snake and we need to kill it last but not the least our overseas community should try everything to slowly convince white canadians about the growing threat of radical sikh gangs +terrorists at their backyard..khalistan won't be happening at india but they can take Vancouver because of weak canadians last, wherever you see even a slightest khalistani apologist justifying their act or want to portray 84 riot as genocide, tell them how many innocent hindu families were butchered by coward sikh radicals in 1990 including air india bombing !

[@illzn06]

​@@tapemajI don't think he was being sarcastic.

[@dhruvseoni8418]

It give all of us with ties to Punjab a lot of pain

[@mailrbn]

Do you remember China had a problem with Canada. They even detained Canadian Citizens. May be we should also do that.

[@SavanVyas91]

Lol over scenario is different, if they detained Indians would be happy about it 😂 we have people in planes going to Canada daily

[@Bharat_Pay]

Lesson from this is that a country should itself grow in stature to command respect from others or you are just treated as a pushover! The callousness of security checks are astonishing!

[@krs218]

The average Canadian probably doesn’t even know about this parade that happened in Brampton. I bet you if you interview 100 non-Sikhs in Brampton, less than 5 of them will be aware about this display, and even then they won’t know the real story behind it. The reason for this ignorance is that because Canada has so many immigrants from all over the world, that these types of cultural programs happen regularly all the time throughout the year. It’s genuinely hard for regular Canadians to keep track of all of them. I can guarantee you that even the elected politicians wouldn’t have realized that such a parade took place. They have other important things to do And secondly, they generally allow such activities in the name of “multiculturalism” and “freedom of expression”.

[@harshgarg1448]

See it is not the job of avg Canadian or politicians to track such events and protest , it is a matter of national security for Canadian police and security agency, who have never seen the potential harm in nurturing these sentiments among Canadian society . Giving radical elements free hand in the name of "multiculturalism" and "democracy" is just looking for an excuse to justify these excesses as evident from the instance of Air India bombings. Nowhere in any civilized world one celebrate the assassination of a PM not even in India's bittter enemy i.e, Pakistan.

[@nchandrak17]

Allowing radical elements to thrive is not good for any country. Forget India, this is not good for Canada, because tomorrow they can turn against you. Politicians are turning a blind eye for short term political gains.

[@balrajdeol9054]

No sir the action has not shifted to Canada now, it been in Canada for very very long time but India been keeping its eyes closed. India is still wants to close its eyes and wish this issue to go away. Canada is not friend of India at this point and can not be friend of India for long time to come due to increasing strength of Khalistanis. Indai must fight its own battle and should not ask Canada to fight it for India. When India is ready to fight for itself, than Canada will fall in line.

[@indian9632]

Economically strong India is the only answer. It will happen in a decade or so. Indian political leaders should grow some balls in the meantime

[@divyanshtiwari3547]

@@indian9632 exactly the only solution to every problem is to be strong and independent like China. Everything will fall in line once we rise!!

[@mg.f.9023]

"Hate It has caused a lot of problems in this world, but it has not solved one yet" - Maya Angelou

[@shivmohan2982]

go and explain this to rahul gandhi and his khalistan supporter, but you will not time from your bjp bishing.

[@jaswindersinghnarula4379]

It helps in getting votes!

[@mg.f.9023]

@@jaswindersinghnarula4379 A scarry fact every where !

[@SV-wu2my]

It is clear that with 2% of population they enjoy influential position in Canada. It also says, however the majority whites were divided like how majority in India divided. When elephant sleeps, rats can make under elephant foot. So true everywhere.

[@qwertykumar7282]

Although i am hindu but that's true that gurdwaras specifically in Canada and punjab r no more place of visit for non sikhs ( exception there)..sikh gurus ka liya respect humesha raheha..love you all from Canada

[@ravisingh7928]

Don't be stupid

[@naren2k6]

Khalistani Movement, Funded by Pakistan and executed in Canada, both should be put to task and held responsible in the toughest manner. Zero tolerance to terrorists.

[@MackyMehra]

For us Hindu Rashtrawadi are terrorists

[@El-Dorado930]

That's rich coming from a country that garlands rapists.

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Maybe you should have protested against the bramens to stop suppressing Sikhs rights as of independence ans punish the Manuwadi warriors who used state forces to kill innocent sikhs

[@harshpuri958]

Today @shekhar spoke with some firmness, which is quite unusual, normally he is polite and a sweet talker. Kudos to all the Sikhs who are condemning this act, this shows the strength of the teachings of the gurus. Take care everyone.

[@kek209]

I live in brampton. Yes there are khalistanis everywhere. Most of then came from india in the 1980s so their idea of india is 40 years old. Also canadians in general don't care about any of this. To most canadians south Asians are basically one and the same and the internal conflicts we have is just tribal stuff.

[@0609Bhuwan]

Hey its not at all about what most Canadians think ... Its about the international relations with another country... Canada almost went to war with Iran because the FM shot her mouth off

[@originofaholespecies9389]

how can india counter it ? just ignore or can we incorporate some hard israeli like tactics or may be shake few khalistani trees back at home hard ? any suggestion ?

[@originofaholespecies9389]

Excellent analysis, Gupta ji..couple of things india can do..we need covert assassination capability like mossad..we can not rely on goodwill of canada and uk to teach these khalistani scumbags a lessons...second, monitor indian gurdwaras of punjab ..i am ashamed to admit that many of our own is now being influenced by pakistani + khalistani propaganda...third, bring back farmer's bill..this is the financial head of the snake and we need to kill it last but not the least our overseas community should try everything to slowly convince white canadians about the growing threat of radical sikh gangs +terrorists at their backyard..khalistan won't be happening at india but they can take Vancouver because of weak canadians last, wherever you see even a slightest khalistani apologist justifying their act or want to portray 84 riot as genocide, tell them how many innocent hindu families were butchered by coward sikh radicals in 1990 including air india bombing !

[@kek209]

@Origin of a**hole species soft economic power is the way to go. India needs to make it known to the Canadian government that their business and commercial interests are at risk if they do not take control of the situation. But first india needs to grow its national GDP from its current $3.7 trillion to around $8 trillion. Once this is done, then india will have a lot more economic soft power to leverage agianst canada.

[@yomamasohot6411]

Canadians in general don't care about any of this is an excuse. You can't call yourself a flagbearer of equality and democracy when you follow none of those yourself. Then to have the audacity to preach to the world is the reason the rest of the world would rather trust dictators like in Russia and China than the so-called "liberal democracies" of the West. The fact that they didn't bother to investigate when most of the passengers killed were Sikh Canadian citizens is the blatant example of Canadian racism.

[@Shailesh76er]

Great analysis!! Admirations from Canada!!

[@ThePrintIndia]

Thank you, my friend. Do keep watching and sending us your feedback. Thank you also for your support...best wishes, Shekhar

[@bag747fain778]

Thank you for rising beyond politics

[@IndianBouyz]

As a right wing and a bjp voter, I found this piece to be informative, well researched and perfectly articulated. Kudos to Shekhar Sir and team. ✌✌👍

[@IndianBouyz]

@@Bachpan_moj he should make a video on exposing hate propagater like u.

[@divyanshtiwari3547]

@@Bachpan_moj And the murder of Hindus by that pussy Bhindranwala

[@AA13494]

@@Bachpan_moj sure he should. because everyone needs to know how a muslim mob attacked and burned 56 karsevaks in a train coach S^, the riots were retaliation. ACtion was initiated by muzlims. Also a movie is being made on godhra riots. and m glad that happened for all the pain muzlims have caused to hindus and also sikh gurus( if u have any idea of the history). take your biased and ill-informed ass out of india

[@bhaskar8308]

I was a regular visitor of Gurudwaras in California. I dont go anymore. I feel guru nanak ji preachings over shadowing with something negative. There should not be negative energy at places of worship. Temples or Gurudwaras or Church or Mosque should not be a place of hate. It's not good.

[@RasheedKhan-he6xx]

There was a joke in early 2000s. Manmohan Singh is having talks with Pervez Musharraf about ending the Kashmir conflict. After several weeks, talks are inconclusive so he returns and reports it to Sonia and to the Cabinet. Then Sonia says, "Let me go. I can speak unofficially and I can get more done.". So then she goes and after more than a month of discussions she also fails and comes back. This time Laloo says, "You people have tried and failed, now I will go." Saying this he leaves and very next day he comes back. "I got the agreement, Kashmir is ours, Pakistan has given up any claims." But how? After 5 decades of hostility between us, how could they give up everything so easily? So Laloo replied "Simple yaar. I told him 'you want Kashmir? Ok you can take it. But only on one condition: you also have to take Bihar.' " So now, all those Khalistan flag waving and slogan chanting chaps in Canada, tell them they can have Khalistan but on one condition: they have to give up their Canadian passports. See how many will come.

[@jagannathsethy8889]

😂😂😂

[@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi]

😅😅

[@FantomwithanEff]

I understand human behavior and it won't be a shock if resentment across India for Sikhs increases after repeated acts that have been going on ... Also any country that harbours anti another country elements, they soon become their playgrounds... What Canada is turning blind eye to will pierce their eyes tomorrow 2ndly Canada took over two decades to bother i guess because it wasn't an American or European plane that was bombed.. if that was the case CIA and NATO would have invaded anyone in no time.. and ofcourse Canada was involved in the bombing.. Canada and friends wouldn't have ignored these warnings for an air France whatever

[@Avneet_Sethi]

That 's great tbh . Resentment towards Sikhs means another golden chance to play victim card for life . Already current regime which has tendencies to bend on demands made by Sikhs and they resort to appeasement and pandering of Sikh controversial leaders .More hatred by non Punjabis against Sikhs would result into more appeasement.Tbh such a situation won't arise since Sikhs market themselves well and know how to play double games with inferiority complex ridden right wingers

[@FantomwithanEff]

@@Avneet_Sethi great to get a glimpse into how people think.. tbh i won't think like that so personally it's a value addition to know well okay that's also how one can interpret things. But again because I understand human behavior i can predict that people/leaders will try appeasement to keep the clam but yeah there is a breaking point to everything including how much are people willing to put up with if 2% of India's population will become a constant sore point i know appeasement will also break.. may be in the long-term things don't work as they do in short therm

[@Avneet_Sethi]

@@FantomwithanEff Even i understand human behaviour , but in addition to that understand indian political space as well .With Delimitation 2026 on cards ,all minorities in India are safe ,there won't be a further rightward shift in Overton window .Bjp will keep on winning,there is absolutely no chance for a trad party to prop up and spoil the pluralistic framework of our country.Its end of clout days for Trads like Sai deepak and his fat right ilk

[@FantomwithanEff]

@@Avneet_Sethi if you understand humans and politics and then you forecast with such certainty then i guess you don't know either.. because they can never be predicted that certainty in that long therm. 2ndly.. people of this country will get sick of any group of people who will make it their sole purpose in life to create trouble for the whole country.. at this time India needs to focus on rapid development.. these distractions and threats from a particular group will make everyone else hostile towards them .. never underestimate what people can do in democracy . The laws can be changed and constitutional amendments is not new concept.. ideally may be just get the act together

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Resentment against Sikhs is already there is the evil manuwadis, it can spread more and we see no problem because thats what you are at finest. Though you control majority of resources but 90% populations will soon be non bramin followers and it will be ur demise

[@navneetrohilla007]

I am living in Canada and generally these Gora log Don't react anything until it is related to them and when they do then they make the job done

[@rohanbansal9563]

Yes. The issue with white Canadians is though they consider them to be very tolerant and civilized. They always make uncalled insults to Americans and say we are so nice, caring and civilized community. I have lived i both US and Canada, and can say white Americans are much better than white Canadians. In fact, US would stand for its naturalized citizens than Canada.

[@arnabdutta9326]

A time will come when these khalistani extremists will start an insurgency for creating a separate sikh state in Canada.

[@ahsanmohammed1]

I live in Toronto! I’m a Muslim! I am stunned! I am shocked this was allowed! Imagine a Muslim group holding such a rally for those who killed Benazir Bhutto or Anwar Sadat! The Canadian riot police would be dispatched to violently arrest the crowd and the leaders of the rally would be thrown in prison for decades!

[@arshdeepsingh61]

I am a Sikh living in Brampton. 90% of us don't even know this happened. Just focusing on our family and work. Ask any random Indian here, what do they do on a weekday, they will say "work the whole day". What do you do on weekend "household chores". Nothing more, nothing less. I am not a supporter of Indira Gandhi or Modi, but this is totally tasteless.

[@manisherande4568]

Yeah you are totaly correct we never knew of this event ... work in office and work in home

[@raghunandan9290]

Yes Just be blind to Whats happening. Just don't act innocent. We all know who you vote . Just don't say Religion is NOT your consideration. ....1 Te2rro3rist is good enough.. All Your Sikh leaders are compromised with Pak ISI money or support..

[@nullprophet10]

Let's start supporting Quebec independence 😂😂

[@rajx7120]

No. That will increase Sikh percentage in the new country. We should support the Conservative party instead, that will reduce the power of these Sikh block voters.

[@Clie919]

Indian support to anyone is insignificant. Canada holds referendums and the Quebec issue always fails. Too bad your fake democracy doesn’t have the balls to hold a referendum in any state. Just suppression, that’s not a democracy. That’s Fascist. The world already knows this, just playing India like a fiddle and you fools are falling for it again.

[@anshuraj4277]

There was already refrendum

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Get ready for ur Pajeet chaddis to be deported back if u want to try😊

[@venkat161175]

This was a beauty Sir. You showed why you are famous. Your experience shows in this report. Thanks.

[@naveenseth7034]

Excellent piece …. A fearless and blunt assessment of radical politics .

[@jaykay304]

As a Punjabi Hindu I am deeply upset and angered by the actions of these Khalistani Extremists. I never really liked Indira Gandhi and did not agree with her approach to attacking Harmandir Sahib in the manner that she ordered and did not agree with Rajiv Gandhi’s lack of action and incitement which resulted in the deaths of many more innocent Sikhs especially in Delhi. Having said all this I am deeply angered by the actions of these Khalistani Extremists. This has been building up over the past 20-25 years. As a Punjabi Hindu living and growing up in the UK I have seen first hand how several Grurudwaras have been overtaken by Khalistani Extremists. Once they take over, similar to Islamic Extremists they started to preach hatred against India and Hindus and brainwash young people by spreading fake stories and lies about how Sikhs are slaves in India and how Hindus treat them badly, about how Hindus target Sikhs, how Hindus have infiltrated Sikhs to change their identity and how all the attacks agains Hindus in Punjab and Haryana and the Air India Bombing were carried out by Hindus. All absolute utter nonsense! They never acknowledge or explain why Bhindranwale and his men armed themselves and stayed in a religious complex much like Islamic Terrorists? As a result of all this all Sikhs abroad in the US Canada and UK especially those aged between 13 and 50 have been brainwashed to hate Hindus and India and there is nothing anyone can do about this sad it’s too late and it’s a vicious cycle. Many Khalistanis hold these talks at Gurudwaras and Universities and Community events so that they can “spread their message”. In fact even during wedding in Gurudwaras I have seen several times people make anti India speeches and speeches about Khalistan, and distribute leaflets and booklets. Unfortunately I stopped going to Gurudwaras when I heard speeches against Hindus and Hindu gods which was the final straw for me. It was extremely hurtful. I have never heard a Hindu make any negative remarks about Sikhs or Sikhi yet I have seen and heard several times these Khalistanis make horrendous remarks about Hindus, Hindu Gods and India. On the whole I believe most Sikhs are very nice caring and not anti India hence why I now separate the two. I believe there are true Sikhs and then there are Khalistani Extremists who are like all other extremists and some of them are involved in terrorists activities like attacking, hurting and killing people. What we need now is more normal ordinary Sikhs to come forward and condemn these Khalistani Extremists but the problem is many ordinary Sikhs are afraid to do this as they too are intimidated or threatened if they speak out.

[@gunngator588]

Government should ban this radical from entering India again and should take diplomatic actions against Canada or threaten them to the extent of severing all ties. Our National Security is at stake here.

[@Clie919]

Severing ties with Canada oh please. Indian ties don’t mean shit to Canadians. Don’t forget that in 1994 it was your country that came begging for a bailout just like your neighbour Pakistan. Once a beggar nation will always be a beggar nation. Bottom line is the only thing Indians know how to do is whine and cry on social media. India is insignificant to Canada while India relies on remittances from former citizens.

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Government of India is itself a radical organisation

[@dandmello5283]

❤Excellent and verywell.. It's Great 👍 listening to the original Journalists of India and Shekarji has the benevolence to carry it forward. Thankyou verymuch JaiHind India 🇮🇳

[@ashishb]

Please use the term vassal state of US while referring to Canada.

[@rahulvats95]

Abhijit chavda all the way

[@ashishb]

@@rahulvats95 👌

[@jkardez4794]

And what about India and Indians ? As usual one of the biggest diasporas in the world in the USA with many more vassals waiting in line for education , jobs and green card including the PM salivating at the thought of his umpteenth visit. And how many waiting to enter Kaneda ? Stop your BS spiel ; your relatives too are there .

[@parinchheda]

Thank you for sharing this episode. It is really unbelievable!

[@Dineshkumar-jf2hz]

A country is only as civilised as its people. I have to say this sikh vote bank politics is a ticking time bomb.

[@igsayin]

Bhindrawale threatened to butcher 5000 hindus in one hour, that too if Indira Gandhi Govt did not release their impounded bus, this is much b4 unfortunate blue star operation and 1984 Delhi anti riot. This tells us its sheer HATE for hindus, all else is excuses. PLUS why kill hindus just because Indira Govt impounded a bus, What hindus had 2 do with that ?

[@vinaynaagar2085]

Akshay Kumar will make a movie on this ....😂😂😂😂

[@_kartik_chauhan]

its not a topic to be laughed at

[@vinaybaldawa4606]

Almost feels like Canadian authorities were involved in bombing of that aircraft.

[@AmanPreet-ww3gm]

while everyone knows hindu bomb the plane ... typical radical hindu propaganda ... it must be sikh/muslims or chinese hHAHAAH pathetic

[@indian9632]

Of course, who would let the bag onto the plane knowingly that it's explosive material

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Read Soft target book, Indian government bombed people to justify bombing the Sikhs in India

[@--Dani]

That Bag should never have been sent through to that international flight also the standards for checking bags were a joke.

[@vedanshbharadwaj2576]

Why is Congress not causing a huge uproar about this stuff?? How can they be silent about this stuff especially Rahul Gandhi?? He was heckled by these Khalistani too and he spoke some nonsense like "nafrat ke bazaar mai aman ki asha" GOD DAMN!!!! They are humiliating our former Prime minister and your GRANDMOTHER!!!! bhagwan ke liye kuch bolo bhai. We have to all come together and all parties and teach Kaneda a lesson. I don't think Congress want to woo these Khalistani but I am seriously doubting myself recently.

[@superbat7455]

Why is Modi not saying anything directly? After all he is himself PM. He should not leave this to Jaishankar. He is going to USA in few days, he should abuse Trudeau from the stage in USA.

[@shankares388]

@@superbat7455 you know that there are others i.e Indian Canadians other than Sikhs? And abusing will solve the problem?? You might not like Modi but anyone with 2 neurons in their skull will stand with Indian govt (BJP or Congress). Or you are doing the same petty politics Canadians are being accused of

[@vedanshbharadwaj2576]

@@superbat7455 I will not say abuse him but certainly there should be some name calling now. I am sick of these so called pseudo-liberal politicians abusing free speech when they like but imposing emergency when they feel it's too much upon them. If Modi 56-chest is not filled with air, then he should do something that will hurt them the most. Even if he doesn't call them out but impose tariffs or some kind of pressure then I will be proud of the Gov.

[@vedanshbharadwaj2576]

@@superbat7455 I think Congress should be more offended by this than the BJP, but they are hideously very silent. They should start fucking up the Canadian embassy, but they are bull-shiting about some dumb fuck things that nobody gives a fuck about.

[@pcpolice2314]

Teach Kaneda a lesson how? What is India going to do?

[@psychotormentor3278]

Food for thought: Why is it always that Congress ends up royally screwing up so much that end creating conflicts that last entire generations.....they were the ones who instigated the hindus with the shah-bano case and then performing shilanyas inside the Babri Masjid...they were the ones under whose reign the whole LTTE issue blew up in the face of us Indians.....they were the ones wholly and solely responsible for the 1984 tragedy..it was under their reign that the Assam agitation happened.....and the list goes on and on..

[@harshgarg1448]

It is similar to how it will be decades before we will realise how the potential screwups by Modi Govt will panout.e.g. khalistan flag at Red fort, suppressing wrestler protest to support a repeat offender for vote politics etc.

[@psychotormentor3278]

@@harshgarg1448 You’re right…one effect visible right away is the aggressive polarisation in politics that we see nowadays since 2014 …so much so that most politicians don’t see each other eye to eye in the parliament and slug it out on social media getting entire populations to fight each other ….that being said, I expected a more intelligent reply than whataboutery but that’s ok….I said nothing about third front or Janata Dal either…

[@TGill22]

I can’t even shame Canada. When PM of india Indra herself created Khalistanis and Bhindranwale for Vite bank ignored every indication of this escalating. Ignored concerned Indians and security agencies, she was so focused on this as base of Vote bank who killed innocent Hindus and Sikhs, who did not cared for their own fellow religion practitioners how someone other can care??? She got what she deserve. Now what we have to do sought out this mess she left us, including her son killing Sikhs in Delhi and justified it like many do now

[@prazbhat]

I condemn to paint all Sikhs in Canada in same colour. This is not the fact. Not all expat Sikhs are Khalistanis

[@ThePrintIndia]

Not at all, my friend. That was certainly not the intention of this CTC. The point was to explore the why Canada has been a haven for radical Sikhs, often at the cost of Ottawa's diplomatic relations with Delhi. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar

[@nikhilbaste-kh1cy]

Is there any difference between Pakistan and Canada ? I don’t think so

[@bhadwamodi8294]

India Radical Hindu votebank politics. 24x7 365 days Mandir masjid hindu muslim qabristan shamshan namaz azaan hijab 80% 20% politics.

[@snoopytintin4878]

Yes there is pakistani leadership has never supported terrorism in public, they atleast prosecuted 2611 preparators, so yes pakistani are better

[@ABHISHEKMHT4]

Because of a minority khalistanis you are painting whole canada as pakistan there are indian people in Canada too

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Yes there is Educated people want to immigrate to Canada but not to Pakistan

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

@@zlatan-jo3lt i bet they have more education and money than your all tantani ancestors 😉

[@varoonnone7159]

Indira Gandhi was told to replace her sikh bodyguards with non sikh ones. She refused saying that as head of a secular country, she couldn't discriminate on the basis of religion She paid her moral integrity with her life and this is how she is being treated now by these goons

[@navsin007711]

Yes she was a great leader who did politics of death and brought the biggest tragedy of independence india where hindus and sikhs turned on each others and thousands were killed .not to forgot almost got country on brink of breaking by the most patrotic poeple in india who happened to be sikh

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Even if she replaced we would have executed that demon

[@varoonnone7159]

@@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL That demon was your cult leader Bhindranwale You are nothing more than blood thirsty terrorists who slaughtered innocents in Punjab over two decades Why don't you create your Khalistan with Lahore as its capital ? You seem to forget who butchered you for five hundred years.

[@varoonnone7159]

@@navsin007711 How conveniently you brushed away the two decades during which sikh terrorists slaughtered innocents in Punjab. One of the incidents has remained scorched in our minds, when sikh terrorists stopped a bus, asked the hindu passengers to get down and shot all of them, children included. Had you not behaved like raging dogs, she wouldn't have treated you as such You call yourself patriotic because you benefit from reservations in the army. If the recruitment was purely meritocratic, you would only be a fraction of all army personnel I'm actually in favour of a Khalistan, as long as Lahore is its capital. You seem to forget who butchered you for five hundred years. What's your objective actually ? A theocratic state where infidels are exterminated?

[@hareshgaglani2955]

The Indira Gandhi assassination procession is extremely shameful even by the yardsticks of assassins themselves. They are not known to publicly gloat over such acts. Perhaps it is time for India to classify Canada as a hostile country and strongly retaliate, according. As for the terrorists, the Indian nation has sufficient muscle and willpower to destroy them and must do so, either all by itself or alongwith friendly powers. Meanwhile Trudeau must ask himself if indeed he has any values and character.

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Assassination of RAVANA shameful too

[@sahilgrewal7509]

u guys do not even have toilets to poop in LOL taking about muscle and willpower

[@7rajcan]

I stopped going to gurdwaras. As a hindu we were told it was safe and Nanak Saab teachings were peaceful and service oriented..with recent experience not feel safe

[@gurpriitchd]

It is a sad state of affairs in Canada. One doesn't expect so-called developed countries to give space to radical elements that are working against a nation. There is a rise in pro-Khalistan activities in Canada, Australia & UK in the last two years. It seems there is a geopolitical strategy behind it. The Western world wants to have the upper hand on the negotiating tables with India for the future. As a Sikh who lives in Punjab with many relatives & friends in Canada, I can this for sure that there is none who wants Khalistan. But Many Gurudwaras in Canada have photos of Bhindrawale & other extremists. They are the centre of politics and not religion. Canada should wake up before it is too late and there will be more trouble for them than for us.

[@chalchalachal4942]

Kanishaq accident was very very sad situation May be Canadian justice system spare him but God's justice will be served

[@2010anilshukla]

Thanks for the detailed analysis 🙏

[@sohebahammed2184]

People of every religion has deviated from the core value of their religion....

[@monsters3250]

Nathu ram godse assassination of gandhi openely lauded but no comment from Shekhar , Sikh in punjab fear of hindu rashtra tottaly ignored by majority. .

[@cgkmurthi]

The reason behind Sikh community's ascent in Canada is primarily due to agriculture..... How? - all most all the lentils in USA is imported from Canada grown by Sikh farmers. Canada's food security is ensured by Sikh farm owners. They get good supply of uneducated Punjabi Sikhs to work in farm lands and live in horrible conditions. They're in worse conditions than the illegal immigrants from Mexico the menial labourers in USA. One doesn't see such people in big cities. But everywhere in every so called developed country, such labour forces are there. The Sikh mafia on one hand exploits the labourers and on the other hand is hand in hand with the ruling elites. Indian farm laws were vehemently opposed by Canadian Sikh farmer mafia to prevent India becoming self sufficient in Legumes and Lentils. As on date India imports a lot of lentils/legumes grown in Canada in addition to Sunflower.

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Murthi drink water instead of gau mootr

[@gangadhernarakatla6901]

We love you tha way you deliver the news sir, it is somuch ineterst to watch your cut clutter👍

[@Prashangajraj]

The best journalist whom I know

[@PradeepSNair]

An excellent recap Shekharji. Thanks a lot

[@MrJothindra]

Hope they decide to have their Khalistan in Canada itself. 😊

[@harmandeepsingh7662]

Yeah Mughal era refugees now want us to leave our own land

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Keep hoping we will have it our grave of bramen india

[@dr_greg_mouse4125]

A video every Canadian should watch. Very well explained without any biased views.

[@swamisundaram]

Canada is the new Pakistan. Jai Hind!

[@champtherottweiler9951]

I am a Canadian by citizenship and Indian by heart. Big shame to these radicals residing in Canada specially in Brampton and Surrey. They are poisoning young generations against India. Any big democracy may it be India or USA has their issues but as a country who are proud of India. Govt of India should file strict action against liberal government of Canada. Trudeau is the worst prime minister we have in last 20 years , he is so greedy that under the name of immigration he is selling permanent residencies just for the sake of money and to gain political stability. On top of that, NDP leader jagmeet Singh is another puppet. He is curse in the name of opposition without having any power to check Trudeau. Trudeau is total failure on economical and social front. He wasted billions of dollars (off course of the taxpayers) in the name of helping Ukraine who’s is Miles away from us and our own people are struggling to meet daily needs. Big shame!

[@gauravdhakate1625]

Shame on you canadian sikhs. Canada is a peaceful country dont become burden of canada, be responsible citizens before your community is targeted.

[@MRSINGH.OFFICIAL]

Shame on you Indian bramens for killing Sikhs and stealing their rights since 1947. India was promised to be a great country but you destroyed it

[@adithyachintalapati6851]

What is even more baffling is the silence from Congress party !!

[@jaydeepgadhavi5465]

Btw the series of cascading errors made by CSIS & RCMP before the kanishka bombing resembled the first scene of the movie 'Black Friday '

[@sbh0892]

Excellent analysis, Shekhar ji.

[@--Dani]

What Canada is turning into, in the USA the center right or call us conservatives are fighting against, tribal politics where 2+2 no longer equals 4, if it suits them it can be 5. I know the story of Air India, and the fact it happened and how they handled it was a joke.

[@johnapone9656]

Don't want to comment on the Air India Tragedy but what do you think about handling 1984 genocide?

[@OrangePumpkin150]

Fantastic episode.

[@Prabh892]

Indra was probably good PM but biggest mistake should not have ordered to storm golden temple , I wonder how many india civil society or journalists spoke about justice and reconciliation about Delhi Sikh genocide post assassination

[@Prabh892]

@@chokkalingamsivamd6947 Mr. BS the question is why it was allowed to happen ,it was intelligence failure and then poor Indra was too late to act desperately in the end. They could have come up with alternate plans to neutralize extremist elements and not hurting the religious sentiments of common citizens. Consequences were mutual damage and loss of common people, Indra Gandhi assassination , sikh genocide ,air india bombing and the radicalization till today 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@sohis]

@@Prabh892 there was another operation in 1988 at Golden Temple called Black Thunder. This time government was able to conduct operations without damaging the Golden Temple. In 1984, Indira wanted to teach Sikhs a lesson. That is the only reason army attacked on the same day as the martyrdom of 5th Guru Arjun Dev ji.

[@nomad122]

This is an excellent old school journalism and analysis. Not a big fan of Gupta, but, a great job here

[@abhinashkumar3161]

Such acts only works against their credibility if they have any left .

[@pjx607]

Justin Trudeau has failed a lot of Canadians. I hope he is removed from the office sooner rather than later before things get worse.