We Play the Most Evil Cards in Magic | We try THE DECK With

[@BrewersKitchen]

That was the least lethal Craterhoof Behemoth I’ve ever seen 😆

[@SoggyWaffles.]

it was simply the flagbearer for the oncoming siege

[@Marutein]

Damn and i thought i will see your Marneus Calgar deck in action XD

[@lenardEkko]

I absolutely LOVE when you said "fair magic is over" and then flipped the spaghetti monster 😂

[@CoL_Drake]

u never played momir huh ? xD

[@TCG9777]

Curse the top comment XD now I know

[@neco9590]

"Instead of explaining Chains of Mephistopheles, I'd rather concede" is the sanest sentence in this entire video.

[@clockblower6414]

Its not a hard card to understand. If you would draw a card outside of first draw, rummage instead, if you cant, mill 1

[@blueplayer6197]

@@clockblower6414 yep, don't get this meme either, it's like wizards hired whoever writes YU-Gi-OH card text just to write the rules on this one card then realized it was a bad idea and sent him to konami to write for the competition.

[@Jedicake]

How does it work with Sylvan Library?

[@Oxygen1004]

@@clockblower6414It's just like banding, once you sit down and read it out it makes sense. It's not something that can really be explained to you.

[@blueplayer6197]

@@Jedicake Like with any multi-draw, library let you draw 2 extra cards so we get the one we normally get for the turn then we rummage twice (each rummage happens separately, in order) then we may pay 4 life twice, for each time we don't pay we must put a card back on top of the library. Note that you'd draw your normal card for the turn first so this should never be mill but always double rummage. And because of how library is worded if you choose to draw twice (hence rummage twice) I believe you only need to pay 4 to leave the one card you still have in your hand in your hand (because it says for each of the chosen cards so that should only happen once when you only have one card)

[@marshroverv5632]

carl achieving the two turn one with nothing into dragon appeasement self-lock combo was insanely hilarious

[@seeker296]

One with nothing - omniscience. This video is a masterpiece

[@cerocero2817]

"Fair magic is over" (flips Emrakul, the aeons torn and Blightsteel Colossus for 0)

[@treeofthetrees9132]

I laughed so hard at that moment. Too funny

[@livedandletdie]

I mean, who doesn't want a Free Emmy? She's the cutest 15/15 in the game. I do warn you, she has a bit of a temper tantrum, and might munch on some of your stuff.

[@Korwinga]

Chains of Mephistopheles- "instead of explaining it, I would rather concede. " Truer words have never been spoken.

[@Hawk_of_Battle]

Play of the Game.

[@livedandletdie]

Whenever you would draw a card other than their first draw in the draw step, instead discard a card. If you can't Discard a card mill a card. If a player discarded a card this way, draw a card. Which is fun, because then you gift them a Colfenor's Plans, or a Dragon Appeasement, to make sure they don't have a draw step, and can't draw any cards in the future. With for example the use of a Puca's Mischief. Also Puca's Mischief in conjunction with Maralen the Mornsong, and giving your opponent a Colfenor's Plans, means they don't have any way of playing the game in the first place. And you could easily do that in a Dimir deck, All you need is Maralen, Colfenor's Plans and Puca's Mischief. Then you could easily combine that with Hivemind+One With Nothing. Just for the luls. Making sure your opponent doesn't have any fun at all. Also remember to keep a Bojuka Bog to get rid of their grave. There's a lot of fun you can have by giving your opponent fun cards.

[@Chroniclerope]

It’s a true combo

[@Darkprosper]

Ok, Carl destroying his resources AND any way for him to get more is amazing, what were the odds that it would line up so well ?

[@Debatra.]

About the same as Emrakul into Blightsteel I'd say...

[@claudio_wild]

I think this game was perfect proof that random doesn't necessarily mean fair

[@Tinnituss]

they stage their content homie

[@wafersmash338]

I love how about 5 minutes in, NO ONE played with their deck anymore lol Good content

[@couchpotatoe91]

Yeah, it would've been cool if it was like "every even turn" and you still draw from your deck as usual.

[@Gwinnmusic]

@@couchpotatoe91 Or it could have been an additional draw alongside your actual draw from your own deck. Even though it still wouldn't helped Carl but still.

[@MrMartinSchou]

Well, once you ended up with a dead board, what's the downside? When Toralf got Gin Gitaxis, Phil HAD to go for the Deck of Doom, because he only had 2 mana to work with, and he needed an answer. And since Phil got Emrakul followed by the Blightsteel Colussus, everyone else had to hope for a boardwipe from the Deck of Doom-

[@WitchOfTheSword]

@couchpotatoe91 Call it a "wild magic deck' and say that once on your own turn as a sorcery you can free cast the top card for like, 2 mana Still heavily incentives using it without completely turning off everyone's own deck or turning into a random mess after a wipe like what happened here

[@MrMartinSchou]

@@WitchOfTheSwordYeah, it was a fun video, but it certainly needs to be balanced out. And I do like that it includes cards that can doom you as well as your opponents. That One With Nothingness was just fantastic.

[@0ctaviaPony]

i love how fast the game just turned into 'play the top card of the salt deck' because everyone IMMEDIATELY lost all their resources

[@jblackrazz]

Next time, do it more like Planeschase. During your main phase you can roll a d6, on a 6 you get to draw a card from "THE DECK". You can choose to roll again but it costs a cumulative 1 mana each time beyond your first roll on your turn. This way, you always draw from your deck each turn and if you have extra mana, you can blow it on more chances to draw from the deck.

[@illyannalavynne2033]

That's a banger idea. Definitely would spice things up but also let everyone still play their decks

[@Joshimuz]

Saltchase

[@Aaackermann]

I loved that they've edited Chain of Mephistopheles into a real wall of text! :-D

[@Garymaster4321]

I was like holy shit this is not the original, right?

[@Aaackermann]

@@Garymaster4321 I have to admit, I had to look it up. No, it's not! 😄

[@MasonSeamancer]

It is the original card but it also has the entire rulings page on the card

[@Aaackermann]

@@MasonSeamancer So it's not the original card but an edited one. ;-)

[@Hysteresis.Actual]

Very Apropos for the wall deck

[@fwop7436]

WE, THE MOST EVIL 🙌

[@MagicalSpoon]

Weeeeee

[@CardmarketMagic]

Yes 👹

[@beastzerkerjet]

i like that phil has become a regular guest, he really fits in for the more goofy group games

[@filippoc.1865]

I know the reason of why Phil was so lucky, he had a blue Ultramarine with him and in the setting of 40k it’s a well known fact that Blue is the luckiest color and therefore the ultramarines are the luckiest.

[@DanielGarrido02]

I was so ready for someone to bring in the flowchart when that last card was flipped! Everyone loves simple mechanics, right?

[@blueplayer6197]

If anyone ever draw cards outside of the one card in their draw step then for each card they'd draw rummage instead (discard then draw) If they can't- mill 1 instead for each of those cards. It's not hard it's just worded the worst possible way.

[@plasmakitten4261]

Ok so this is basically Judge's Tower but instead of bullying people over the rules, you're just bullying them in general.

[@Loki-]

I like seeing "The Strategist" below Carl's name because it made me think it was all his plan the whole time! 😅

[@CardmarketMagic]

🤣

[@victhefoxygamer_6180]

0:20 "no.. I'm scared" Me too, me too Just wanna say, love to see Fele, generally a really cool guy, I just hope Jaimin doesn't disappear too much, I love seeing that guy too c:

[@CardmarketMagic]

Jamin is just available less often since he manages social media. Thoralf, Fele & I (Carl) are directly involved with the video team and are simply at the office more often, so it simply lines up less that Jamin is around when we record. He's not going anywhere :)

[@victhefoxygamer_6180]

@@CardmarketMagic That's good news. Keep up the fun stuff y'all!

[@yoshimitsu5537]

Hahahaha, I just posted pretty much the same thing then scrolled down. Glad to hear Jamin is still around!

[@bricelory9534]

I absolutely love the concept of this format - seems like a great way to mix up your EDH sessions! I mean, if you want, it doesn't even have to be evil cards if you set it up yourself, just whatever seems fun for your group.

[@xaropevic7918]

If it is not evil cards, then it is just treasure cruise

[@bricelory9534]

@@xaropevic7918 fair enough. I don't keep up with format variants.

[@Umbral-Hero]

One with Nothing into Dragon Appeasement into Omniscience is one of the most twisted jokes I have ever seen in my life

[@michaelstapley4878]

"Instead of explaining it, I would rather concede." Carl's got jokes. His misery was a beautiful part of this piece of content.

[@TheVillainsProjects]

Love seeing new spins on an "effects deck"! Me and my MTG pals used to do a similar thing, but we simply flipped it at the end of everyone's turn, once per full round. So in a two player match it would be every other end step, in a 4 player it would be every 4th end step.

[@MrMartinSchou]

Basically, when Thoralf destroyed Ashnod's Altar, he killed himself. If that had been left on the board, Fele could have made Phil sacrifice both the Blightsteel Colossus and Emrakul.

[@bricelory9534]

I really want to see a few more games of this format - seems like there is just a lot of chaos that can happen!

[@hotcoldman9793]

Phil with the most insane draws I've ever seen!!!😂

[@XTimTheEnchanterX]

This was wild, I would definitely watch this "format" again or play it for myself some time

[@rinan5317]

The skill of Brewer's Kitchen here is off the charts!

[@stormycat0905]

So the middle deck is just my EDH deck? Cool. Happy to join you today!

[@ZeVentriloquist]

Finally, I was waiting for you guys to reveal you were the most evil cards

[@CardmarketMagic]

We are 👹

[@cronchable]

The crew reinventing Magic every other video - love it!

[@JoshuaNaslund]

Thoralf and his trolling is beautiful. His little 'doing math' when he cast the Jin Gitaxis was too funny!

[@brianarsuaga5008]

The absolutely brutal self-lock by Carl, into an Omniscience he couldn't use at all, is just about the funniest thing I could imagine happening with this deck

[@disafear3674]

This channel shows that so much fun can be had in Magic with just some imagination

[@manuelito1233]

WE THE MOST MAGIC

[@CoL_Drake]

VIDEO IDEA: Momir in paper, just make make around 13 stacks of like 100+ cards for each mana value 0-12 you could do this in a commander format with 4 players, maybe even with a commander and all lands in ur deck :) the cards you get to put in the stacks could be randomly selected and you can also do alot with this, like only common or only mythic. or maybe even "only cards

[@DragoSmash]

they already did this one in a 1v1, quite a fun watch

[@johnny_crash]

Fele AND Phil? Love it!

[@sB-wt7jy]

That dragon appeasement was the funniest thing ive ever seen 🤣

[@Generic42]

This was so much fun! Great gameplay, great camaraderie

[@alfredoc.4609]

That's the revenge of Chain of Mephistopheles for the throw the other time 🤣🤣

[@Jinxedfromthestart]

More content like this please! Y’all are very entertaining and there are plenty of channels doing all the boring deck techs and such, y’all make me laugh and that’s the best thing you can get out of a hobby.

[@CardmarketMagic]

I'm happy you enjoyed it! We'll do our best to make you laugh again :D

[@Chris-yb8bg]

Thought i recognized that voice, so glad to see ya Phil!

[@Silverhand264]

lmao timing king Thoralf there. Games over "Oh your deck is good" XDDD

[@andrewneben7949]

Carl my man. I felt your pain there, and Phil..... well played sir!😂😂

[@dustinmartin648]

I'm 1000% doing this with all the typical chaos cards! Thanks for the great idea guys!

[@lucasalexander3365]

WE THE MOST EVIL MAGIC

[@CardmarketMagic]

I forgot to write Play* 😅

[@CoL_Drake]

considering that Boromir, Warden of the Tower, Lavinia, Azorius Renegard and cards like this would be banned in this format obviously, i think the best deck might either be 99 lands or half land half exile creature and some destroy cards and then go for the middle from turn 1 only. as commander best thing would be something that gives your creatures haste or that works with casting cards without mana costs :) you can so hard break this xD

[@GotchaPlaysGer]

We love Phil, please get him on videos every week!😁 I think putting that many big eldrazis in „the deck“ is a mistake. The video could have been more fun and longer:)

[@Alejandrodemontana]

Carl, I love the beautiful irony of you playing a commander that says “the strategist”

[@CardmarketMagic]

I think I needed a better strategy 🤓

[@Alejandrodemontana]

@@CardmarketMagic Strategy and luck are the same thing right?

[@mregecko]

MORE of these games, this was super fun. Haven't laughed this hard in a while.

[@manaentzug]

Das ist eine so dermaßen coole Idee, ich will das auch mal testen 🤩 Aber nicht nur einfach mit den salzigsten Karten, sondern einer Liste, in der es entweder nur krasse Downsides, oder krasse Upsides gibt! 😍 So unheimlich cool, danke für die Idee 😁✌️

[@TheKaosKilla16]

Phil pulls a Craterhoof and then hits nothing but bombs all game. Meanwhile, Carl is self mutilating from the start.

[@Spotifist]

One With Nothing -> Omniscience is poetic, thanks for the fun video!

[@acetraker1988]

Phil came into this game with the "Skill Issue Mindset".

[@rikytie7011]

Phil is the topdeck master it literally felt he was scripting 😂

[@rustybrooks8916]

I wish every game of magic had something like this going for it. I love the madness.

[@dannyboy1200]

One Into Nothing into Omniscience is a cruel joke lol

[@joelhammitt8914]

Thoralf rocking the survivor buff is the reason I subscribed. Only a few minutes in and it's great so far. Loving it and can't wait for more.

[@MetalHev]

"The top 100 saltiest cards" The cards: *100 copies of Sheoldred the Apocalypse*

[@collinbeal]

I mean, it might be saltier than Emrakul, which simply resigns you to your inevitable death.

[@LogoMotive11]

This was some of the most fun I've had watching a game in a long time. Thanks guys! Excited to try this with my group.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Hope you have fun! Let us know how it goes :)

[@TheKazzerscout]

Type 4 was the jam for kitchen table magic. One deck in the middle of the table with about 500 cards in, you have infinite mana but can only cast one spell per turn. Everyone draws from the big deck only.

[@TravisHDev]

Killer Content. I finally played my first game of commander. Honestly it wasn’t all about the cards. It was mostly getting to know people and having a good time, the game just got us to the table. Thanks for the content.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Yes! That's the true spirit of commander :)

[@chaos530]

I think this is my favorite video you guys have ever done. Best deck of all time series being a multi way tie for second.

[@SomeOfTheJuice]

Okay, seeing crazy modes like this are great, and it makes me want to see some planechase with you all! My friends and I would play commander planechase before they started putting new cards with the commander precons, and it's made me want to see play with the new and old planechase cards included!

[@JustsomeMTGplayer]

Great video dudes!

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you :)

[@thewannabecraftsman]

Day 4 of complimenting great plays instead of pointing out misplays. This one isn't so much of a great play, as a way to go Carl for being such a good sport this game. There were moments ( 22:19 for example) where you can tell he was a little tilted, he did absolutely NOTHING the entire game thanks to his top deck luck, but still was trying to have fun, and be a good host, and enjoy the game for everyone else's sake. Thumbs up

[@CardmarketMagic]

This is such a healthy and kind comment thread idea :) I can't wait to see the other ones!

[@captainofthesevenbees]

I would love to see a game where yall play the decks without the twist, they seem like fun commanders and I’ve never even see the boros one before

[@CardmarketMagic]

There is regular commander on 80% of the magic channels, we decided that, as Ling as we have the creativity to offer something that you can't see on most of magic youtube, we always will :) there is no point in offering you more of the same

[@kendallhall7502]

I would love to see this again it looks amazing

[@classicclipsF_TV]

That was a lot of fun. Sick idea, chaos magic on overdrive but much simpler

[@oliverbrown1419]

Please do this again, I would love to even see this as a series

[@retronymph]

Carl flipping One With Nothing into skipping his draw step into omniscience is so perfect you'd think it was scripted

[@STS-qi1qy]

Poor Carl but, damn, was it amusing to watch that bad luck.

[@bchap5429]

The deck 100% felt an evil kinship with Phil. I really thought Thoralf had the best shot. His commander was definitely the most suited for the challenge. Too bad commanders weren’t even a factor 😂

[@considerthehumbleworm]

So happy we’re getting more Fele :D

[@yoshimitsu5537]

Fele makes me really happy! I'm so glad he has been appearing in more videos. YOU HAVE MY GOAT! has become a common phrase in our house now. I miss Jamin though. Hope he's just on vacation and having a good time.

[@crispy86]

what a perfect episode! Thanks so much for the content.

[@provoidcloak]

Phil @brewerskitchen simply believed in the heart of the cards

[@joekendall8401]

Any chance someone could let me know where to find Phil's list for Marneus Calgar? It looked sick

[@dreadwoe7661]

thoralf being a genius giving those two extra turns to carl so he would be the threat that phil kills. GENIUS too bad he saw through it and killed him anyway

[@shaneg9081]

I don't love commander the way so many others do, but I love a shared deck. This is a great idea.

[@aniesc3257]

Lol, I saw the name The Deck, i thought Old School, I was wrong 😆

[@CardmarketMagic]

That would have been such a funny but niche joke 😅 we just flip Serra Angel and Counterspell, then Feldon's Cane

[@PugFeist]

That was a lot of fun. Luck is a fickle bitch but sometimes it shines on one player and that was fun to see.

[@svankensen]

So glad to have you people back making content. The vacation felt long.

[@CardmarketMagic]

We're also happy we're back at making content :D I hope you enjoy what we have coming up!

[@annalunceford3206]

Phil is always the lucky person in commander. Great game!

[@ThereIsAnExtension2UndoHandles]

it would have been hilarious if no one ever drew from THE DECK the entire video, but i imagine you would have waited for April 1st to post that one

[@CardmarketMagic]

That would make an incredible April fools joke! 🤯

[@DragoSmash]

poor Carl, i wanted to see more of that wall deck

[@olivergalitch5584]

And phil didn't take control of the land and creature... Forgot the salt in the open wound... tsk tsk tsk

[@RodrigoCML7]

Fair magic is over. Proceeds to cast Emrakul. Checks out, Phil. Please continue.

[@Kal1voda]

Top notch editing and content guys, as per usual!

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you :)

[@gmpd4191]

This quickly turned into the card game war with extra steps.

[@Daniel-uq5cd]

Not that it matters, but in Phil last turn he should have put the 2 permanents his opponent sacrificed under his control. Just to add more salt to the wound, you know...

[@lastnamefirstname8655]

very fun game! so many evil cards in mtg in this one video, very dangerous!

[@Jolfgard]

I love how Carl is so good at outplaying himself.

[@davidwipperfurth8465]

I love the idea, but it seemed to get unhinged a bit too quickly, and the opportunity cost made it such that no one had any good reason to play their own deck, so it quickly devolved into the card game "war". I'd love to see something like this again, but with tweaked rules to change the incentives. Maybe [[Kiora Soverien of the Deep]], [[Momir Vig, Simic Visionary Avatar]] or [[Chaos Wand]] style rules?

[@TheFudorin]

I love this format, I want to see more!

[@XenoSun]

The Emrakul jumpscare edit was great.

[@chummer2060]

That was the perfect ending to that wacky game, hahahaha! Explain this? No...guess I'll die

[@SoulWhiteAngel]

I love arcades. Finally get to see it played in a video :) Even if it wasnt played much or at all.

[@dandundun]

This is probably the best way to play AI generated cards too

[@jean-michelfrenette2865]

This is wholesome and super enjoyable, but I'm still so triggered : GENERAL IS PRO MONOCOLOR ! HE BLOCKS CRATERHOOF AND SURVIVES DESTRUCTIVE FORCE ! 😆

[@locwul]

Phil just made it into another episode of brewer’s kitchen out of nowhere

[@michaelquinn8064]

lmaooo, strips his hand, cant draw enchantment, then omniscience, that was beautiful