Cavatina - Carbon vs Nylon strings comparison on the Classical guitar 클래식기타 카본줄과 나일론줄 비교

[@inlego6356]

아아 항상 좋은 연주 올려주시고 타브악보도 무료로 제공하시는 당신은 그저 빛

[@Sean1991Guitar]

Careful with carbon strings if the neck isn't reinforced, I put some on my guitar and within 3 weeks the neck bowed forward. had to shave the saddle down almost all the way to get the action playable again.

[@Waltriani]

Both sound very nice. It's a matter of personal preference. Today I prefer carbon strings or titanium strings, but both strings demonstrated are very good. The guitar seems very balanced too and the player is excellent. I hear also a touch of reverb that also enhance the sound experience, make the guitar sound better.

[@JamesMcCutcheon]

I like my Titanium strings very much. The carbon may have a fit for various guitars, the Plain nylon from Savarez is also a different animal too. I have played on almost every string type since 1973 and I feel that each guitar may need a certain string to bring out the timbre, nuances and the age of the guitar also have a meaning.

[@nikolapetricevic]

Great video, I actually preferred Carbon, they sound more warm and a bit muffled, while Nylon sounded more pure but also colder and with a bit less character. Your playing is exquisite, however, you could make a fishing cable sound beautiful I bet.

[@CosasdeDios1089]

That was wonderful, Jeremi. Thank you for this video.

[@ANA-tp5bk]

너무멋져요.. 스승님

[@guicasoamillo]

THANK YOU SO MUCH MR. Choi, excellent version and mastery play with the extra carbon/nylon test. I appreciate you so much. Regards from Spain

[@weedwormschlag]

Tension is slightly higher on carbon strings so they will naturally have more volume.

[@sjjames4399]

가끔방문하지만 올때마다 영혼의정화됨을자주느끼게되네요 감사합니다^^

[@AwitAmihan]

They both sound good but I resonate better on the carbon strings - it sounds brighter and crisp.

[@GreenRose242]

Very helpful video, thankyou dear friend 💚

[@af-np4pg]

Looks like you're playing a Brazilian rosewood guitar with cedar top. I find the spruce top is sharper and louder, and I'm also playing more modern stuff now. Don't hear a tremendous difference between carbon and nylon. I use ghs silver wound G 3rd strings. That's right. They bring the guitar alive.

[@userAA]

Bernabe sounds more open, more balanced and hides the scratch sounds more. It's in my to buy list. I can't believe d'addario sounds so bad in comparison, the exact opposite of positive things i said about Bernabe! Yet,I used EJ45 for years, on 3 different guitars! I had a thing against Carbon strings and this video changed it! Thanks! Meanwhile, who's your guitar luthier?

[@adnen.benali]

So, what is the verdict of the player? Nylon or Carbon?

[@harwindho]

Beautiful playing

[@iqiegraphy219]

I think nylon much pleasing to my ears

[@eduardobenassi3072]

D'Daddario's 3rd string is not very good, but it's not so bad on cedar tops.

[@악기쟁이이쌤]

연주가 너무 좋아요

[@atomic432]

Beautiful I did not hear much difference but I am old snd my hearing is compromised. Thanks .

[@noeul_hwang]

좋네요 특별하십니다..

[@Miki720802]

Hi Choi, have you ever written for Lonely Shepherd? Shall share with me?

[@cjj6117]

잘 감상 하고 갑니다. 나일론이 좀더 무겁고 기본스런 소리가 나고 카본은 좀 더 밝고 화려한 듯 합니다.

[@edgardodomingo5029]

Carbon: Thin, bright, artificial sound, long sustain. Nylon: Thicker, warm, soft

[@penc1189]

좋은연주 잘 들었어요~

[@awiwii110]

nylon is more beautiful tone for me, thank you for playing beautifully 🙂👏👏👏

[@차승엽-z9l]

병욱님, 팬으로써 좋은음악 늘 감사합니다 한가지 부탁드려도 될까요 Whole nine yards 연주 부탁드려도 될까요 개인적으로 너무 연주하고 싶은 곡입니다

[@Bflatest]

You can buy cat gut strings online anyone tried?

[@andywijayass3881]

1st - 3rd string i prefer nylon 4th - 6th string i prefer carbon

[@KindagoodAtguitar]

I am personally a fan of the carbon. I’m surprised how much of a difference there was.

[@달빛페리오치약]

난 들어도 모르겠는데...ㅠㅠ 난 수양이 모자르다...😢

[@ArtificiallyConcious]

What’s the name of the first piece???

[@johnlay3040]

A very good comparison by doing alternately like this. Definitely carbon doesn't give the romantic sound of guitar that we all love.

[@은하수-g1q]

나일론 카본 떠나서 비싼줄이 좋은 줄이라는게 몇십년 써본 결론입니다. 가성비라는 말은 기타줄엔 예외더군요. 딱 돈 액수만큼 갚어치 하는게 기타줄입니다.

[@jeong-gimin8220]

연주를 들을 때는 나일론이 부드럽고 듣기 편한데 왠지 제가 직접 둘다 쳐본다면 카본 스트링의 한알한알 터지는듯한 댐핑감이 더 기분 좋을 듯 합니다 나일론은 상대적으로 먹먹하게 느껴 질 지도 모르겠네요

[@lujan-lo5gs]

👏👏👏👏👍👍👍

[@Nnnn-nw8mb]

요즘 항상 이 연주 들으러 찾아오고있어요! 연주하시는 기타가 어떤 모델인가요?

[@jeremy7strings]

영상속의 악기는 이용한기타입니다.

[@ajhwb]

So good..

[@javierdiazsantana]

Use warm sounding nylon if you like very pronounced colors and if you have a very powerful (lattice or very bright) guitar. At the other side, use carbon if you have dark instruments.

[@jothaman3555]

Well, its complicated. I have a cedar guitar that is very warm but has very bright and sharp high tones. I used carbon for a year on that guitar but it just sounded to sharp and it killed all the warmth. So now i use nylon, although you give up those powerfull bases, you get to have very nice sweet warm tones that nylon gives you

[@javierdiazsantana]

@@jothaman3555 I'm also using nylon now. but your guitar would rather be bright, i think, if it sounded like that.

[@jothaman3555]

@@javierdiazsantana yeah but heres the thing, i own a south spanish cedar guitar. An alhambra. These tend to have loud and warm bases but bright high's by default. My carbon strings really make the basses pop but overbower the brightness to the point where its too thin. Now i have nylon on them again and the basses sound a bit worse but i have round high's now. Its complicated. I wished i could have the warm highs and strong basses. What strings do you use and what guitar do you own?

[@javierdiazsantana]

@@jothaman3555 Well with an all wood lattice guitar where i used carbon, red cedar top, D'Addario carbons in medium tension or Oasis carbon trebles, seem to bring out the best character of that instrument, and actually i think that i was in the same situation as you with that guitar (Ultradeep warm basses and the highs sounded extremely bright with certain carbons such as Savarez Alliance, but sounded quite dull with nylon from D'Addario ProArte) Please tell me which carbon strings did you use to give you a recommendation on strings, so you can swap out the trebles for nylon and keep the basses you like.

[@javierdiazsantana]

And also, i stopped playing with carbon because i found the colors quite poor and the excessive string tension was hurting my left hand. I now play a spruce top guitar, fan braced, which was built by the mexican Paracho luthier Daniel García Corona, (He also built my cedar lattice) and i am using D'Addario ProArte nylon which seemed to remain nicely balanced in that guitar, that instrument is very bright and came strung with Augustine Regals, which sound amazing but get worn quickly by the nails, and since i prefer durability on the strings (Change them after around 3 months if possible) i tried the old ProArtes which sounded dull on the cedar and damn they sound good on the spruce top. Loved the sound.

[@renshimarek]

Super ! :)

[@louiscyfer6944]

is that a Gilbert?

[@billykalimas181]

I think nylon is better. My opinion

[@Truongchihai83]

what is the title of this song, thank you very much

[@jeremy7strings]

It's Cavatina

[@paoz.]

Звучат они абсолютно одинаково.

[@陳東明-j6j]

賞心悅耳

[@pS-eo2wi]

Carbon, trebles ring out with a richer tone to my ears..nylon sound dull in comparison

[@정명자-g2m]

너무 아름답네요

[@x햄구]

나일론줄이 역시 더 좋네요 또롱또롱 몽글몽글한 소리💕

[@hjroh88]

카본보다는 나일론이 따뜻하고 풍성한 소리가 나는 것 같아요!! 제 취향은 확실하게 나일론이 맞는 듯합니다!

[@paulchow611]

What tension are the carbon strings? It seems like carbon 1 to 3 strings have a higher tension which gives a brighter and longer sound.

[@jeremy7strings]

it says 'upper middle tension'.

[@j_thn]

이용한 제작가님 모델 중 어떤 모델인지 알수 있을까요?

[@mmbd777]

로제트를 보니 이용한 선생님 악기네요

[@mohammadmelhem6215]

Nice as usual... Can we ask yoy for a guitar pieces for intermediate players...thanks

[@나다-r2h]

아래 링크에 이 곡이 없어요 ㅠㅠ 타브악보 구할 수 있을까요?

[@나다-r2h]

곡 제목이 카바티니였군요 감사합니다

[@jaehoonchoi8472]

제 취향에는 다다리오 나일론 줄이 더 좋게 들리는군요

[@saberwork]

I wish I could tell some difference, but, they both sound great. Fortunately, my career as a music critic ended as a teenager so I didn't waste a lot of time...;-)

[@swjaco4848]

오른손 엄지손톱만 기르시고 나머진 손톱으로 안하고 지두탄현으로 하시나요???❤

[@jeremy7strings]

모든손가락 손톱으로 칩니다.

[@jmdh55]

Paulino Bernabe 장력은 어느정도인가요? 하드인가요?

[@jeremy7strings]

미디엄과 하드 중간정도 된다고 합니다.

[@MagicGuitara]

both are nice and rich, thanks for beautiful playing. waht is your guitar brand name?

[@jeremy7strings]

It is made by Korean Luthier, Yonghan Lee.

[@LanNguyen-fg6mj]

@@jeremy7strings may I ask how much does it cost?

[@TerrenceDuggan]

Very Pretty, on either set : )

[@marzjam5040]

i like nylon more, thank you for this video

[@mrrokfor4041]

Can you make Yiruma' s version "He knows my name", this composition is nice )

[@jeremy7strings]

I've done that song before. kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2Kkd418ob2jhqM

[@addictpageant]

what's the title of the piece? please!!

[@slpatterns]

Cavatina

[@gordonpage1]

I got those runny , watery thingies in my eyes, with both types of strings

[@Dalvit1]

A는 먹먹한 느낌이었는데 나일론이었네요. 카본 줄 좋군요. 장력이나 수명도 궁금하네요

[@장가람-l2r]

근데 얼클루, 리릿나워 같은 재즈 거장들은 나일론을 고집한다네요..

[@kali2109]

i notice no difference at all

[@PedroDias-hj2jy]

This is a double top or lattice so the comparison does not seem fair to me...Nylon will not sound that great on most double tops..

[@hsvsvv6129]

Nylon

[@marcosafonsodias7089]

Hello, What's the piece called!? Its lovely, thank you!!

[@quoccuong042009]

It's Cavatina. I used to play it all the time. so beautiful.

[@marcosafonsodias7089]

@@quoccuong042009 thanks; ) will look it up

[@doutordrive]

Your guitar string action seems too high

[@XT55555]

카본은 좀 더 명료하고 나일론은 좀 자연스런 느낌..

[@Morte_Deus]

B!

[@waynzwhirled6181]

The nylon sounds better to my ears.

[@ABC_Tokyo]

아... 차이를 느끼려다가 연주에 빠져버립니다. ㅠㅠ

[@BilguunBatbayar]

B strings sound purer to me.

[@kanker5256]

A B who tf understand anything