Chlöe Swarbrick Buried by Luxon, Peters & Seymour

The Greens are seriously, very low-IQ.
Thank you Chris Luxon, Winston Peters and David Seymour,
WhangareiTim

[@WillDouglas-z1h]

Would have liked to have heard Chloe's answer to Winston at the end. I worked on a coal mine on the west cost for a number of years. It's the only place where I have seen wild kiwis running about. The mining didn't bother them in the slightest. As well as Kiwis there was also a large seagull rookery on the mine, they weren't bothered by mine trucks going past them night and day.

[@eduardrozner943]

She is big problems for all new zealanders.😂

[@critical_always]

Yes, but... There are plenty numb nuts voting for it.

[@Kiwi-Ahh-Nah]

​@@critical_always And there are plenty of clueless cunts like yourself.

[@mymaster-myboss]

Chloe Do you stand by your party when they employ slaves/people and not pay them Chloe Do you stand by your party when shopping, using the five finger discount method.

[@corrietabak5573]

This is why people shouldn't vote for the greens, Chloe doesn't understand how manufacturing components for what she uses every day come from mining. Great speech by David Seymour.

[@robinsmith7465]

Chloe could you stand by your principals and stop printing so many stupid posters

[@mezmernz]

principles???? are they not fluid like her gender

[@luckyM9963]

hahahhahahahahahahahahahahahah love it

[@johninnz]

I think she should be mandated to take the paper home and wipe her arse with it too.....about all.its good for, after all she should be leading by example and not missing an opportunity to recycle.

[@alanhayward8237]

.... ah ... I think that's principles.

[@fbpmuffs5715]

Gotta say,I am liking the coalition government.

[@J33319]

Coalition of clowns

[@msimpson2779]

Except they have approved second reading for MASS immigration, tens, hundreds of thousands of 3rd world immigrants!!! Agreed to with U.N and WEF. Let that sink in.

[@kenbearsley8322]

Loved how David pointed out to her that her pictures were all done by equipment that needs mined materials. All three leaders certainly put the opposition into red faced shame.

[@vincentcarmine8731]

Chloe - What a twit , way past time she grew up and got a real job and saw how most people live.

[@margueritemccartney3607]

Chloe is not fit for any government role. Why are we the people being forced to waste tax payer on paying her. It’s ridiculous.

[@georgesione6859]

she should hand her phone in, walk to work and not sit on any chair

[@Fedoratip79]

Drill baby drill

[@DivineFeminineOracle777]

👌

[@JG-us9lu]

The IPCC has had 70 scientist resign due to the misrepresentation of their research.

[@yarraman8595]

The Green thieves have a whole herd of mad cows

[@EdwinWilkinson-w8e]

😂😂😂👍

[@suetempleton5150]

Well said

[@iansmith9706]

Chloe can talk shit without breathing

[@jr8899]

Who are these experts regarding climate change,I think you will find these experts receive funding for their opinion,hence conflict of interest

[@SailingAwayNZ]

This was the most interesting time in modern parliament. Chloe seems to be a "Not in my back yard" but coal and mining in China is still Co2 into the world (Not that I think there is a problem with that) Why shouldn't NZ benefit from mining?????

[@dennismenace4188]

Swarbrick is a ideologue. These people can't even comprehend the realities of real life.

[@Kiwi-Ahh-Nah]

She uses data to support her arguments. Not smoke and mirrors and personal attacks.

[@hepburn118]

@@Kiwi-Ahh-Nah No, she uses the maori party for those.

[@dennismenace4188]

@@Kiwi-Ahh-Nah you mean "data".

[@Raidyn98]

Peters with the mic drop at the end

[@suetempleton5150]

That's the one ❤️

[@JerryMander2024]

And Winston nails it yet again!

[@mrspecialk1234]

Gold 🤣….tag teaming Swarbrick into submission 👍

[@mezmernz]

only need a few facts

[@iainseymour-hart3347]

Cloe, You should be aware that steel cannot be made without good quality thermal coal. Steel is widely needed in many of the tools and equipment we use in every day life. All vehicles, whether EVs or ICEVs have critical components in them which must be made of steel. Likewise, bicycles and escooters have critical components made of steel. We will need fossil fuels for many years to come.

[@Larshhhh]

Steel can be made without using good quality thermal coal. There are several alternative methods and technologies being developed and implemented: Using renewable hydrogen instead of carbon as the reducing agent to remove oxygen from iron ore. This produces water vapor instead of carbon dioxide as a byproduct. Utilizing biomass or charcoal derived from sustainable sources as the carbon source instead of metallurgical coal. Increasing the use of scrap steel in electric arc furnaces, which can produce new steel with minimal emissions if powered by renewable electricity. High-temperature molten oxide electrolysis processes like ULCOLYSIS that use chromium electrodes instead of carbon to reduce iron oxides. Direct reduction of iron using natural gas or biomethane as the reducing agent instead of coal. While these alternatives are currently more expensive than traditional coal-based steelmaking, the costs are expected to decrease as the technologies mature and become more widely adopted. Several steel companies have already begun commercial production of "green steel" using hydrogen and electric arc furnaces powered by renewable energy. The key challenge is making these low-emission steelmaking methods cost-competitive with conventional integrated steel plants that use metallurgical coal. But it is technologically feasible to produce steel at scale without relying on good quality thermal coal.

[@hepburn118]

@@Larshhhh Aren't they having issue's with that hydrogen reduction tech? I have this nagging feeling I read they were finding the steel was having brittleness tests failing at rates seen only in hardened steel before tempering, but it was happening in steel that hadn't been heat treated yet. No idea if thats right, I might be getting part of a report mixed up with something else. Only thing other thing is that bit about scrap steel. That would require a lot more care in identifying, making the process more expensive, what the scrap is. If not, the end result is un-usable for a variety of uses because the steels make-up can't be known before its cast. Tool steels for example. They rely on exact concentrations of trace elements to give heat treatment the right result. If they didnt't know what the make up of the steel was they can't add the right amounts of silicon and chromium etc to make a specific steel. If you're just making re-bar out of it, then all good, use as much scrap as you like... I like the ideas you put forward, I can just see teething troubles plaguing the processes for a while yet.

[@Larshhhh]

@@hepburn118 You raise some valid concerns about the potential challenges associated with hydrogen-based steelmaking technologies. Let me address them based on the information provided in the search results: Regarding hydrogen embrittlement in steel produced via hydrogen reduction processes: The study in [3] directly investigates this issue and finds that the hydrogen content in green steel produced via hydrogen-based ironmaking (both solid-state direct reduction and liquid-state plasma smelting reduction) is similar to conventionally produced steel after vacuum treatment, around 1-2 wppm. This low level of residual hydrogen is not expected to cause severe embrittlement issues.[3] The authors explain that while the initial hydrogen-reduced iron product can have high hydrogen levels (around 40 wppm for direct reduction), subsequent melting and degassing in an electric arc furnace drastically reduces the hydrogen content to acceptable levels.[3] So proper melting and processing appears to mitigate embrittlement concerns. On the challenges with using scrap steel: You make a fair point. Increased scrap use in electric arc furnaces for green steelmaking would require more stringent quality control and sorting of scrap feedstock.[4] This is because the precise chemical composition needs to be known to produce specific steel grades by adjusting alloy additions accordingly. However, this is already a well-established practice in the scrap-based EAF route today. Advanced sensor-based sorting technologies exist to characterize scrap streams.[4] So while it adds complexity and cost, it is a solvable issue with proper implementation of quality control measures.[2][4] For lower-grade construction steels like rebar, using more uncharacterized scrap may be feasible as you mentioned. But for higher-grade alloy steels, controlling scrap quality would be essential regardless of the steelmaking route.[2][4] So in summary, while hydrogen embrittlement and scrap quality control are valid concerns highlighted in the literature, studies show these can likely be managed through appropriate processing steps and quality control measures as the hydrogen-based technologies mature.[2][3][4] But you are right that teething troubles should be expected initially as these low-emission steelmaking methods are scaled up and optimized. Citations: [1] www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2542435122004111 [2] www.greins.jp/en/technology/technology02/ [3] www.nature.com/articles/s41529-023-00397-8 [4] www.globalefficiencyintel.com/green-h2-dri-steelmaking-15-challenges-and-solutions [5] www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095965262103972X

[@iainseymour-hart3347]

@@Larshhhh - would you fly in planes which have critical parts made using scrap steel [with impurites] using unproven arc furnace technology. Another example of a Net Zero driven alternative, and there are many, that will likely kill innocent people.

[@bradprouting9280]

She doesn't listen mate - someone lied to her at 5 and told her 1+1=3

[@acegikmoii]

If the Greens have the highest aviation expenditure of any party in parliament , then instead of just quoting it, ask them to explain it!

[@SapientiaHumilitas]

You think she'd be embarrassed to show her face again after that high-school effort. Decimated.

[@davewatt28]

😂 Oh Chloe, dear Chloe, reality is so pesky. Don’t fall off your grandstand now will you 😢

[@Mark-g6l7i]

Chloe is IRRELEVANT

[@maryjordan1483]

Hairy is spelt with only one R.

[@msimpson2779]

Wish we could deport her somewhere... and a few others

[@billytapurau]

problem with these kids that are over-schooled ..... they really think they know something ....

[@cra1gf]

And the silly druggie held up pages from Stuff LOL

[@fredjones9750]

You may as well hold up a Ronald Mcdonald coloring competition for kids from maccas. That has more credibility.

[@HB-iq6bl]

table cloth missing today

[@mezmernz]

well noted

[@jackiebiggs7071]

Got the lanyard though.

[@fredjones9750]

Actually used it last night after the roast dinner.

[@jackiebiggs7071]

@@fredjones9750 😆😉

[@selwyndyer8357]

She studied under Ardern for to long.what a waste.

[@roddas26]

There will not be a transition to EV's. They are not green or clean. Time to stop the nonsense.

[@kenking3188]

More kindergarden whining from the reds/greens

[@harrycurrie9664]

At least the Member for Mexico seemed to agree with everything she said.

[@Jack-rc1yl]

Think before you print Swarbrick

[@burgthorburn5406]

Most unproductive party in the nz parliament...they would rather pay you the doll just to stay home..Can someone please name a great greens policy l bloody struggle to find one?!?

[@garethbrown4798]

Cloe...come on...science can't be that hard....

[@donr2176]

Go back to sleep, Chloe.. Stop wasting Parliament time..

[@robdowsing3361]

Every question from the opposition starts of with ….does the opposition stand by ? If they didn’t why would they do whatever they are doing.What a waste of parliamentary time😂

[@chrisnorth3458]

because they have to ask a question, but they have no actual real questions to ask, they just want to point out some kind of so called fact or pick at the governments decisions

[@MrWarkwark88]

Chloe should hold up cave drawings…

[@amrobinson5006]

Her own sign says it all!

[@willtekata1763]

Mr speaker quilt can quilt tell us how much oil is in my fake eye lash. Unquilt.

[@marshallgarrett1593]

Hi, I hate her to be running the country. We would be in major major problem with every part of the economy. They couldn’t work their way out of a paper bag although they probably want to recycle that.

[@wateratz]

I guess we need people like Swarbrick to remind us of just how dangerous they would be if let anywhere near the levers of power. Yet with all their scandals in the Greens, their popularity isn't dropping, which shows what a mad hard-core bunch of activists we now have in the country.

[@theoriginaltoadnz]

Haha she shows a print out from NewShub, that's like the wolf advertising sheeps clothing!

[@ANTHONY1983--]

Mic drop by Winny at the end

[@jinwan3088]

Chloe is ideologically-possessed

[@robertbaldwin5771]

Greens too yellow to admit they r really reds

[@bronwynsearle2117]

She just doesn't get it...🙄

[@VenomRoadRacing]

The greens think you can hard boil an egg and call it an omelette.

[@bharatdahya776]

If we had retained first past the post, then we wouldn’t have such a large block of clowns, controlling parliament.

[@JackMeoff-gu7om]

Chloe please stop wasting our trees.

[@nevillemckenzie2542]

Why Is Chloe wearing the Palestine card holder

[@mezmernz]

noted, trying to be subtle and go unnoticed by the people who simply detest those pushers of hate, violence and genocide (she and Davidson are the two who made it internationally shouting hatred) worst loud mouths in parliament, maybe not.. I would find it difficult to work that one out.. also we need to make it nz citizens only

[@nevillemckenzie2542]

I don't like the fact that the greens and some of the left parties are loaded with members who are not naturalised Kiwis

[@fredjones9750]

It's actually a student ID.

[@YesNutritionWorks]

She is behaving like a six former.

[@the80iesguy]

To C.S.Brick "Do you pay taxes when you're paid from taxes?"

[@chrisballingall5972]

Chloe Thunberg always has an ego powered smirk like The Joker 🤣

[@bryanwalkerCT7729]

Brilliant ❤❤❤ #MHLivingHistoryLeapyear2024

[@therealdrbyte]

Gold

[@briananderson-f1n]

Why the heck are we importing coal???,considering there's a hell of a lot local. Someone needs investigated for this stupidity lets have names

[@katechurch3956]

What a waste of time!

[@Sarah-ne6cv]

And then she pulls out a picture of a kiwi 🤣. I am about ready to say goodbye kiwi.

[@peteb2]

And again we see that Chloe Swarprick can’t read & has to hold up flash cards for some very weird reason….

[@enumeratenz]

The IPCC is a political construct of the United Nations. It consists of three working groups and a task force. Working Group 1 offers the scientific muscle. The other working groups are focused on impacts and mitigation ... following the assumption that there is some degree of climate change risk. WG1 publishes Assessment Reports - the latest being AR6. The report itself consists of a summary for policymakers and technical summary followed by a set of chapters detailing research. It does not appear that people assembling the physical research data are the people writing the technical summary and even less, the policy recommendations. New Zealand seems to be represented by Andy Reisinger - Physicist and James Renwick - Professor of Physical Geography. Chloe claims that there is an absolute scientific consensus on climate change As a Physicist, reading the IPCC AR6, I am reminded by Richard Feynman: "I would rather have questions that can't be answered than answers that can't be questioned".

[@brucethomas5123]

Love the nodding head on the green speakers left ,reminds me of my Childhood visits to Luna Park ,just for fun

[@Jugsy77]

Newshub Chloe!!!....really??!!...Chloe?!!

[@optimumperformance]

More coal, more gas and thorium reactors

[@laurencejenner1127]

So they would be the 19th century’s latest fuel, the thing we are running out of, and the thing that has never been built? Great thinking. You fit right in here.

[@stealthkiwi1869]

Well she's probably going to go on a clothing free spree because of the stress of being so wrong!

[@paulthompson5546]

Would that Chloe would demonstrate 100% devotion to her religion and build a wooden temple on a remote island and eat insects, and wear clothes made of leaves and stop consuming what she abhors.

[@josiah5471]

"You critique society yet you participate in it? I am very smart"

[@whatshappenedhere1784]

Using a news headline as your argument, is like listening to someone who attended the seminar instead of the person who gave the seminar. And the cherry on top is that she's in the green party and the only one there wasting paper XD

[@KaczorFitzhenry]

Chloe, let the grown ups run the country. Go back to school. With that lanyard you'll fit right in.

[@thetravellinghillbillies5386]

Does Chloe assume that ev batteries and solar panels grow out of the ground like the pot she smokes?

[@honeyholly001]

She doesn't care about minerals mined in other countries.

[@luckyM9963]

Watch your pockets everyone! Chloe is around! hahahah

[@lightforce3642]

I wonder if Chloe drives a car ? powered by electricity from Indonesian dirty coal

[@Grumpyhub247]

Chloe is delusional

[@MarkBurgher]

Actually there are many very talented scientists who say the exact opposite. Such a pity they are not allowed to participate in the climate change debate and are no where to be seen in the climate change commission

[@suetempleton5150]

Boom 💥

[@Abuamina001]

Chloe is just sad. Can she even hear herself ?

[@stu290bushrider]

How many times can these numbskull politicians ask the question?

[@alanbrooke144]

That is what you get when your MPs only real world experience is that of a university activist.

[@roga8681]

Whats the matter Chloe? Lost your barbie doll ????

[@TestAccount-uu9vp]

if she cared about the environment she would have printed on a smaller a4 piece of paper and not used colour

[@jeffbarbour2194]

This is embarrassing. Go home Chloe.

[@dash-kt7uf]

This is the funniest thing ever 😂😂 is Chloe for real? 😂😂

[@MrWarkwark88]

Apart from China …..

[@diablojames]

What an embarrassing clown show the Greens are 🐑

[@kenhorlor5674]

1:30 He's wrong. EV's are a dud, solar panels are an expensive way of generating electricity, and we don't need to waste minerals on pursuing it. It is a fools errand, and Luxon is a fool for saying what he said.

[@dash-kt7uf]

Huh? You obviously don’t have any EQ. Read the room dude

[@kenhorlor5674]

@@dash-kt7uf Remember to get your booster.

[@arrongoodwin3339]

Correct. Luxon is another wet net-zero disciple. More of a hypocrite than even Chloe

[@suetempleton5150]

Glad someone said it. Luxon is a globalist fool, and not many seem to be picking up on it

[@Chopper650]

to the greens... do they stand by all their air travel and pollution

[@NZ_Kiwi1010]

Enough of the climate hoax Greens... we see you and know what you're about 😂

[@Brian-NZ]

💯 puppets for the UN 2030 agenda

[@arrongoodwin3339]

Lefty Luxon still believes in it. Ask Maureen Pugh

[@mra4955]

Brilliant

[@bunning63]

How much do the greens spend on their constant change of attire?Well OK some haven't actually spent anything in the past.

[@robertbaldwin5771]

Chloe pls go!

[@lisac1619]

Chloe's Hamas-supporting lanyard is made of plastic too

[@banquo46]

World Co2 output 2023 China 29% USA 14% India 7% Russia 4.5% Japan 3.4% UK 1. 1% Co2 New Zealand 0.09%

[@dubstepXpower]

Lmao a news hub article as source wtaf

[@GienetteDaniel]

What a ballhead! Him and Winnie the Pooh

[@murrayforsdyke5634]

Slam dunk

[@keithsymonds9323]

It's a bit ironic that the audience that resonates with Shane Jones "absolutely thoughtful speech" includes many people who either don't understand, or don't believe science...

[@BlackSiphoNz]

No Greenpeace for now we ain't Australia we don't have there safety nets

[@tinaaroha8205]

Not the EV's

[@KaneTaylor-z2x]

thick

[@tinaaroha8205]

Luxton talking about the smart cities of Treason

[@peterburnett3735]

popatoe head