Cinemare Sins: Everything Wrong With Hard to Say Anything

They made a whole episode about waifu stealing.
Cinemare Sins is a long-running brony fan series since 2013. Subscribe for new videos on the 1st of every month!
► Inspired by Cinema Sins:
/ cinemasins
► Cinemare Sins Playlist:
• ALL Cinemare Sins Videos
► Learn more about me and find links on my website:
LittleshyFiM.com
Thanks to WikS, guarskywind, Fluppup, and StudioMEGA for suggesting sins and ideas!
► Suggest your own sins and ideas for future episodes here: www.littleshyf...
► Live streams of video production and more can be found at my Twitch: / littleshyfim
► Consider supporting me on Patreon:
/ littleshyfim
$1 tier includes Discord server perk, patron-only feed, and early access to new videos. Thanks for your support!

[@RoseyCakess]

Feather bangs is an interesting character, and I'm glad the show didn't make him stereotypical, he's one of my favourite background characters

[@skootergirl22]

He's clearly a Justin beber

[@gracekim25]

@@СержГарелов-б8юplease go away troll

[@gracekim25]

@@skootergirl22yeah but he’s not a stereotype thankfully 😅

[@jannowak4731]

In offical mlp game feather bangs and Blaze are couple.

[@Gettrolledlol1]

@@jannowak4731no way!? Really!?

[@justincarawan-carawanco.pu1639]

The biggest sin: BigMac, a grown stallion, accepts help from three fillies who know less about love than Pre-FlashSentry Twilight.

[@star-boltlover9609]

I was going to say the same thing 😂

[@SkiggsMoDiggs]

desperation does that to you

[@shadow_shine3578]

Honesty this episode handled itself really well. It definitely is framed from the view of the kids which is pretty funny. I like that the message is you can't force love on someone, but in a much more realistic setting. A child isn’t going to make a love potion, but they very well could end up in situations kinda like this one

[@monsterjambrony]

Don’t you mean “hoofed itself very well?”

[@Insert_Creativity_Here]

@@monsterjambrony hoofled*

[@shadow_shine3578]

@@monsterjambrony lol

[@sebaschan-uwu]

Yeah as a kid I was taking bill cosby's relationship advice

[@cosmiccod6284]

Much like “steer” it’s actually quite weird to distinguish “heifer” from other cattle, because a heifer is a cattle who hasn’t calved yet. This makes sense in our world, but why do the ponies care about the mother status of another intelligent species? It’s funny how this show often forgets that they’ve shown cattle and other ungulates to be sapient and kinda just throw random farm words around

[@JohnSmith-iw1wd]

They obviously realised the implication of having sentient species as cattle, so they tried to pretend it never happened and farm animals are just beasts.

[@cosmiccod6284]

@@JohnSmith-iw1wd it’s even more funny with the existence of yaks. Not only is there cow racism, there’s a cow caste system

[@cosmiccod6284]

@StoryWeaver777 huh, interesting. In the community I’m from it was always used to mean heifer who hasn’t calved. Maybe just a regional thing. “When the heifer is milked and fed” you don’t milk a heifer, Big Mac!!! Though maybe that adds to the song because it’s suppose to be made up on the spot and descend into nonsense

[@BlackDawnYaoiLover]

​@@cosmiccod6284Some farmers roll continue calling a heifer a heifer until they're pregnant with their second calf, so maybe they just got new cattle lol

[@killz0ne215]

@StoryWeaver777 As a farmer/ rancher I will try to put to rest the dispute over the term heifer. In true technical terms "heifer" is a bovine that has never calved. Thus they wouldn't be producing milk or least not enough until they're about to calve. Now, some or most will say, 1st calf heifers, to refer to a cow that had it's first calf, thus meaning they are young and may even still have calving issues with their second calf. So in all real technicalities that was an error in the show, as you do NOT milk heifers.

[@elizabethrose644]

the kissing scene might be the most awkward thing this show has done

[@classydays43]

I'm going to say it - the pigs are there to get rid of old and bruised apples. They can't sell them and they can't have them lying around, and the pig manure would work well for soil quality.

[@FanOfMostEverything]

There's a clear need for more lighthouses in Equestria given how this ship came out of nowhere. It did turn out cute, but _no one_ thought Sugarmac would be a thing before this aired... which might have been the idea.

[@JoePCool14]

"Department of Friendship Enforcement" So that means Big Mac and Sugar Belle are *only* friends then, right?

[@jayreid2513]

Just a couple of besties getting married and having babies for tax benefits

[@gracekim25]

😂

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

Sugar Belle is voiced by Rebecca Shoichet Feather Bangs is voiced by Vincent Tong Yeah, they knew what they were doing here.

[@jayreid2513]

Oh my god it's sunset and flash

[@gracekim25]

😂OH

[@SonicJrandSarah]

I noticed at the end during the ending gag that Scootaloo spotted Blueblood, Flash Sentry, and Garble. I knew that Flash and Garble are both voiced by Vincent Tong, so I looked up to see if he also voiced Blueblood, and to my surprise, he actually did. I wonder if that was intentional?

[@jayreid2513]

@@SonicJrandSarah it's 100% intentional

[@SonicJrandSarah]

@@jayreid2513 To put in three Feather Bang Soundalikes together?

[@PhantomAarantula]

People think this episode is bad? Could have fooled me, I thought this was a very fun episode when you get past how Sweetie Belle believed fairy tales would work in sparking a relationship when she's at the same time too young for puppet shows.

[@PhantomAarantula]

Wait... I said young when I meant to say old. Shoot.

[@MadPieS2]

00:19 now that you mention it... the Twilight Sparkle's Twinkling Balloon is probably the most advertised playset release because its in every episode from season 1-7 in the intro

[@SailorMaxie]

I think Big Macintosh has said more words in this one episode than he could in an entire season.

[@Commenter839]

The later seasons did a surprisingly good job at fleshing out Big Mac- I never would've found myself calling him one of my favorite side characters before S6. And iirc every episode that starred him knocked it out of the park.

[@shivamkamil1581]

1:25 Yeah, that was always unintentionally funny to me, like a love potion and kissing someone while they're asleep aren't THAT different.

[@CyberWarezz05]

Wait, so if Pinkie and AJ are related, does that mean that Big Mac had a crush on his cousin??

[@CelticFish0103]

That's what confused me in that part, I don't think they had "sparks flying" in that episode I think they were just both shy ponies shooting the shit in their own way

[@Commenter839]

If the Pies and Apples were related, it would've been so distant that it's debatable if it even counts as incest at that point. But I guess the reason SugarMac became canon was primarily to avoid the controversy with MarbleMac

[@christiantwist3360]

Eh, if they are related, they’re too far removed for it to be weird.

[@gracekim25]

@@christiantwist3360yeah 😅 they’re distant

[@dusksunsetio6042]

Read on TvTropes that the reason SugarMac even started existing because execs didn’t like the implications that Big Mac was crushing on his something-cousin how-many-times removed.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Even though a lot of people think that "Hard To Say Anything" is a bad episode, I for one enjoy it! It was totally awesome that Big Mac one of the shows most underrated yet most popular secondary characters had a genuine crush on somepony, Though I can understand why some people didn't like that it was Sugar Belle because it was so random and out of nowhere and on some level Big Mac and Sugar Belle aren't that much compatible, I mean I'm a SugarMac fan i'm just saying that I can see why many people disapproved of this random canon pairing. And I can still remember when the Brony analysts were griping about how Sugar Belle didn't seem to like Big Mac romantically because it was kinda lazy writing that she didn't seem to despite all of the obvious facial expressions she kept giving Big Mac, Talk about mixed signals. And don't get me started on Feather Bangs, I mean like so many in the fandom I too thought of him as basically the ponified Justin Bieber, He had a totally awesome singing voice and I especially loved that his 3 "Not-so-secret" admirers were based on the Bimbettes from Beauty and the Beast. But at least Feather Bangs didn't totally lose in the end. lol As for the CMC's this may have been the 2nd time that they tried to "help" is somepony's love life, But just like the Hearts and Hooves Day incident they managed to sadly once again mess things up for Big Mac. I mean yeah their hearts were in the right place but just like with the Hearts and Hooves Day episode they went about it all wrong, But luckily they were able to help Big Mac and Sugar Belle get together in the end. Anyway I overall enjoy the episode, Regardless of the hate it gets.

[@pinkfanatic]

I can understand the out of place relationship thing. I mean, how did Big Mac even know, and also, we still don't know the name of the village TO THIS DAY!

[@CosmicWavS]

To whoever gave the 50 memberships in that one Littleshy Livestream, thank you very much! Also, great video as always Littleshy, as the way I've seen r/place, you really need some mental rest 😂

[@FrenchRarity]

Oh look, a Cutie Mark Criminals episode! It's a good thing little tiny unicorn fillies are able to lift rocks as big as they are. Imagine all the missing big macs that would have never been found again without them... Very fun as always! Well done.

[@PramkLuna]

0:15 is one of the greatest mysteries in mlp. Sure the blimp makes an appearance multiple times in the show, but it's strange no one has ever questioned it

[@FuzzyStripetail]

After somepony stole her bag, Sugar Belle was seeing mostly blue when she decided not to "do a magic" to get her bag back, however, she was later feeling blue as well when she leaned all over that freshly painted dessert display thereby getting blue paint all over her body.

[@atsukokagari_]

"they made a whole episode about waifu stealing" as if simple ways doesn't exist

[@novalightfim]

I publicly nose booped someone once… I’m still awaiting trial on my trip to the moon.

[@ChaosEnjoyer69]

Absolutely amazing, as always, loved the additon of the crime counter

[@MCLegoboy]

And with one episode, the headcanons were ruined. It was always going to be Fluttershy or Marble Pie, but Sugar Belle of all characters? I mean, I guess, it's a nice way to bring back that town, but it does kind of just come out of nowhere. And then there's the ramifications of all this. Sugar Belle leaves that town to live with Big Mac in Ponyville after getting married, but shouldn't it be the other way around? Sweet Apple Acres always felt more like Applejack's farm to run, and it was established in canon that Apple Farms help boost communities and allow towns thrive, and that small town not only lost a business (one that fed people), but they lost the opportunity to have sustainable food that's locally sourced, and any chance of new residents coming to do business and eventually join in that community is now less. It may be on the edge of nowhere, but that town's now going to die in obscurity.

[@Commenter839]

Tbf, Sugar Belle ran a bakery- sure, her pastries are technically food, but it's a bit of an overstatement to say she's feeding people. It's also entirely possible that other food-related businesses exist in the town too, we really haven't seen much of the town since Starlight left it but it's entirely reasonable to assume more people have been visiting the town (since I don't think Featherbangs and his admirers were there when the town was enslaved). Big Mac moving in with Sugar Belle rather than the other way around would've been an interesting conclusion, though, now that you bring it up. I'd imagine the farm being pretty crowded since Apple Bloom and Rainbow Dash live there too

[@BlueBlueberries]

When watching this episode, Feather Bangs just gave me serious “Young Justin Bieber” vibes until the end of the episode. 💀 Great video, though! 💙

[@Nora-id5hu]

IT DID 😀

[@ajshiro3957]

This episode just reminds me that I'm an oldest sibling. I'd be boiling mad if my youngest sibling tried hooking me up and all in my business. Apple Bloom is really insistent on getting a sister in law. Just ready to replace AJ

[@lucidfangirl1030]

Oop-

[@TheEternalSamurai]

I still remember popping by your Twitch livestream when you were writing for the script for this and examining the episode. Nicely done as always 👍

[@Thegr8MC]

The CMC getting all their understanding of romantic relationships from fiction? How silly! I mean, who does that!? [Nervous weeb coughing]

[@rainydashiebrony]

Another great video keep up the great work!

[@DWAkhaten]

In hindsight, something MLP: FIM was really good at was creating parody songs that are so silly and so over the top that you can't help but laugh at them. "The Showstoppers" had the "Cutie Mark Crusaders" song, where the girls tried (and failed) to become metalheads. "The Mane Attraction" had "The Spectacle" song by Lady Gaga's ponysona that was gloriously autotuned. And this episode has "The Battle For Sugar Belle", the beautifully cheesy country vs pop rap battle.

[@Psychedlia98]

Poor marble, she deserved better

[@SonicJrandSarah]

I hated Feather Bangs throughout most of the episode, but at the end, I felt sorry for him. I don't know how, but I just did.

[@Hepoxni]

when I was like 11 I didn't know any better so I shipped Sweetie Belle and Feather Bangs 💀educate your children

[@FabioFabioFabio1]

The random edit gags in this one had me laughing so much, good job

[@PygmentSplat]

[Laughs in Spikeabuse] WHEN DOES IT END

[@swibishdumbhorse]

lol I love how the three ponies that simp on Feather Bangs look like the three girls from Beauty and the Beast

[@82dorrin]

Everything wrong with this episode Cutie Mark Crusaders' bedroom eyes! *Ding!* Sin counter: ♾️ End of episode

[@jjlewis3723]

Soooooo. Even though you said you wouldn't do it... whens the r/place 2023 deep dive?

[@MarsNotPlanet]

Honey wake up Littleshy Posted

[@LittleshyFiM]

Thank you so much!

[@MarsNotPlanet]

@@LittleshyFiM 👍🏻

[@CrabRang00n]

Nice video! First time getting to see it sooner :D Can’t wait for the next one!

[@rock7176]

MEMBER! WOO

[@primrosevale1995]

Not gonna lie I thought the last Crime Count was gonna be polyamory for Frather Bangs attempting to date those three ponies at once.

[@NathanielPiscian]

The Justin Bieber of equestria and I fucking love it. In my opinion we got a lady gaga, lizzo or Megan stallion I think, now a JB, I wonder who be next

[@frenchthefennecfoxmlp]

Hey Littleshy, Ive been suggesting a lot of sins for pretty much every episode in season 7 and have a few saved up for when season 8 becomes an option. This was the first episode I suggested a sin in and I don't see any of them here. I was wondering if they have been submitted, because if I cant suggest sins then I'll just stop looking for them.

[@LittleshyFiM]

Hey there! I don't use submitted sin ideas by default, but I appreciate the help all the same. I see your suggestions, and even came close to coming up with a sin related to the barn paint continuity you noticed, but it didn't work out this time. Thanks!

[@DailyDoseOfPonyYT]

This video was featured in an article of Daily Dose of Pony! Stay pony, friend /)

[@Sparky6Voltz]

I haven't thought about this series in years and suddenly I got this on my reccomended, so ofc i just had to watch

[@iamthegreatest50]

wait around the 3 min. mark wasn't sweetie and scoot that switched. I'm probably dumb. idk

[@rexyemperor]

Amazing analysis as always Littleshy! Continue the wonderful work /)

[@skootergirl22]

Feather bangs is a justin Bebier

[@Sollace]

1:19 He remembers that well xD

[@Vari137]

Great video as always! The Sunset pillow got me, again.

[@pinkprincess6136]

I love this episode because of the song, the cmc and Big mac and Sugar Belle I love when those two ponies are together so cute.

[@StudioMEGA_]

I really want to do a magic. But I would have to become an alicorn to do so.

[@ZZDoesStuffYT]

"having more than 1 waifu will ruin you laifu" 💀💀

[@JettLockette]

Marble deserves the world🤍

[@NeoTrggrTheGammer]

What a fantastic way to wrap up my birthday, but with a new Cinemare Sins...keep up the awesome work!

[@llamawalrushybrid]

Happy birthday! Was it good?

[@LittleshyFiM]

Happy birthday!

[@NeoTrggrTheGammer]

@@llamawalrushybrid It was a awesome birthday for sure!

[@NeoTrggrTheGammer]

@@LittleshyFiM Thank you! Keep up the great work!

[@CatKun1234]

I forgot Justin Bieber pony was in that episode

[@gaymare6236]

Wow, a bunch of new members, whatever could be the reason for that?

[@skylarrossspeedpaintstheory]

Is feather bangs mandopony?

[@WigWoo1]

Am I the only one that thinks Feather Bangs is Mando Pony's OC?

[@PlayABetterGame]

I mean, background characters can't be competent. Especially when using magic is an option!

[@rubyblaze7225]

You forgot to say beauty and the beast reference with the feather bangs fanmares.

[@watergirl929]

Exactly what I was thinking lol

[@GoodCraftingYT]

And the Shrek (2 or 3, idr) reference in "cheese fondue" moment (at least I think it's from Shrek. Could be referenced by Shrek from another place)

[@rubyblaze7225]

You're thinking puss in boot's dancing in the rain part in livin la vida loca when he poured water on himself.

[@Mushroom8980]

AM I ACTUALLY MARRIED TO THIS GUY HELP-😭

[@GMan17256]

I almost forgot there would be a new video today. Great video and nice addition with the new "crime counter".

[@silveryuno]

4:07 Goddamn Littleshy, was this scene already suggestive enough xD (Oh! I didn't knew Vincent Tong also voiced Blueblood!)

[@Jeece2020]

(On 3:02) OH NO THEY F UP THE VOICE AUDIO JUST LIKE NINJAGO 💀

[@MrJPablo10]

I was today years old when I realized that it’s currently more difficult than ever for me to be able to finish watching MLP FIM, and that I should’ve properly kept up with it until the end. So I would like ask anyone that reads my comment, is Amazon really the only remaining way to watch all of MLP FIM without “sailing the seas”?

[@LittleshyFiM]

The best way to enjoy the show is probably "brony distribution" but if you don't want to go the piracy route, every episode is free and legal here on KZbin last I checked. There are many playlists like this one: kzbin.info/aero/PLJea3s83pK2RzLCqUusIWQZRsO59h72BQ

[@MrJPablo10]

OMG thank you so much!!!!! I guess I didn’t research well enough 😅

[@gracekim25]

I love callbacks 😂 it’s been forever since I watched the show 😅 2.8.23

[@timwoods2852]

I'd never heard ungulate used to describe equines before. Turns out it's a pretty wide term that includes pretty much anything with hooves and hippos, rhinos, and tapirs! Because science is weird!

[@eeveeextreme]

Also whales. Because whales are weird like that

[@timwoods2852]

@@eeveeextreme But rabbits aren't rodents because of the way their teeth grow!? Go home science, you're drunk, high, and tripping!

[@Kai_Hallow]

"Characters that break the fourth wall, pinki pie, discord, feather bangs" what about derpy? She broke it at least once I believe during twilights coronation, she was in the background and you commented "this offensive pony breaks the fourth wall to wink at us"

[@ponyhorsemuledonkey.1635]

sugar belle is with big mac now

[@windygleam9821]

Unicorns always forget their magic, Sugar Belle included

[@ImAnnabelle_8D]

Whenever I see a new cinema sins video all I can think is Finally someone’s going to say what needs to be said

[@blinky6254]

I hated Feather bangs because looks like Justin Bieber and now... I still do, not because he looks like Justin Bieber but he just hate him

[@TheSimba86]

Big Mac and Marble Pie was destined for each other and I was disappointed they had him marry somepony else

[@malachiwonder6800]

Do you, Big MacIntosh, take this mare to be your lawfully wedded wife? "Eeyup" Do you, Marble Pie, take this stallion to be your lawfully wedded husband? "Mmhm"

[@n00bxl71]

Nice video.

[@franciscotapia9682]

Painting:it's time for the big and epic music war to defend our stolen musical rights from their rightful owners 0:12 SHAKY CAM FOR BREIF SECONDS *+7737 AND SHAKED NEW FORMAT *+107* 0:27 reminding me that the reason we are sinning this series again its because of the wiener episode [you'll see why we call it that] *+222* 0:46 1st time the dumb horse doesn't cause a sin removal in forever *minus662626* 0:51 dumb segment that suddenly appears and gets dropped off quickly *+20* 1:04 scene from an episode that has yet to happen *+101* 1:13 AGH THAT WAS AN EAR-PEARCING RHYME *+76271* 1:58 what's worst than parenthesis that have personalities? PARENTHESIS WRITTEN IN DIFFERENT COLOURS SO YOU CAN'T READ THEM *+234* 2:02 i remove a sin for that *minus1* 2:27 this crime should have been counted at the end of the episode, to avoid surprises and spoiling things *+1* 2:27 HORRIBLE SECONDS WHERE HORRIBLE *[phone]* 2:32 should also sin that he's an obvious justin beaver parody in a show made by canadians, which is rather fitting *+11* 2:39 what? *+13* 2:44 IS THAT A SCENE FROM THE FINALE EPISODE?! THEREFORE A MASSIVE SPOILER?! *+1313* 2:53 first a justin clone and now a beauty and beast extras clones? *+3* 2:57 failed to mention the crime *+1* 3:13 i can't read coloured letters despite being a painting *+8* 3:21 ungulate? Isn't that inappropiate? *+1* 3:38 and here removal due to accuracy *+minus1* 3:42 actual good use of a shaky cam *minus7634567* 4:00 this won was slightly worst than the above example *+76* 4:24 both are bad and the name's dj-pon3 *+88* 4:41 STAY OUTTA MY LIFE, DUSTBIN BOTHERED *+247* Episode sin tally:70,781,533 Sentence:some dumb punishment that combines the Haltmann plotlines that happened the same time as this episode [John wick, mad max fury road and mahito yokota's revenge]

[@Stardust_42]

I thought that said “Spikephobia” 💀

[@Drflash55Official]

2 months remain until Glimmerglammer Smokingstar gets to star in her own episode.

[@alejandrootero8894]

If that is the sentence, I want to be the criminal.

[@Owl_Edits_toh]

You know how Applebloom had Sweetie Bells’ voice? Well on the episode “ The Beginning of the End “, S9 E1. Twilight had Starlight’s voice when she asked “ Starlight, can you stay here and take care of the School? “ 🤯

[@windygleam9821]

No waifu, no laifu. More waifus, more raivus.

[@Wissle]

Shipping is canon! 1:11 I need that Daki!

[@EonityLuna]

Surprised you didn't do the Feather Bangs/Justin Bieber comparison. 👀

[@-Leelos_Creations-]

THEY KNOW WHAT HANDS ARE???? Also my nickname is AJ too

[@glitchjam]

1:02 everyone forgets marble pie bc marble pie x big mac is incestual. and don't even give the typical "ohh but they might not even be related"/"well everyone is probably related if you go back far enough" that ain't an excuse. if that's your first thoughts when something is potentially incestual, you need to do some serious self reflection. absolutely disgusting 💀

[@JohnSmith-iw1wd]

Ever since the episode aired there's been a meme that Feather Bangs' fangirls are actually dudes.

[@monsterjambrony]

0:16 After a decade you finally sin that? What too you so long? It’s hard to say.

[@3fatkid]

I've always hated this episode basically saying that Hearts and Hooves Day was the ONLY time they teased Cheerimac. And it all went downhill from there.

[@howtheworldworks3]

I miss this show. HASBRO!!! What the hell? Bring it back!!!

[@seventhofearth]

Heifer means a cow that has not yet given birth. There is no reason to milk a heifer since it's not lactating.

[@Hadeshy]

Oh. I didn't realize I saw the episode early. I thought we were the first. But today's the first.

[@lilythearcticfox]

Remember, there is a difference between crush and romantic interest. So multiple crushes really isn't an issue, a crush is just a crush, you get over crushes, usually within a few weeks but it can take a bit.

[@cian.o]

Oh yeah I forgot about the frosted tips pony. Eheheheh, what a wimp, heheheh.

[@Ayransevenpony]

Well, episode show us women can't understand how we are love them

[@ponyhorsemuledonkey.1635]

too late feather bangs

[@SBaby]

And people wonder why I had Chaotix make these three honorary members...

[@Werefangx]

Well scootoloo didn't go on the trip to the rock farm so she shouldn't know about it unless Apple bloom has a gossiping problem

[@stryke-jn3kv]

What's the neat Derpy going serious bit from at 0:45? Don't recognise it so guessing it's some fan animation?

[@DulcetNuance]

Mares That is all. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk. Carry on.

[@KlaviceGavin]

Feather Bangs, or as I like to call him Justin Biebstallion.