Bratz vs. My Scene: An Overview

[@yvetteayase3566]

I'm definitely a MyScene girl, as I found the characters to be more relatable. I was a huge fan of the webisodes and I thought the dolls were absolutely stunning! However, even as a child, I could see the impact that the Bratz had on the doll/toy industry and so I have respect for both.

[@adriantucker5532]

Even as a child you could see the impact the Bratz line had on the industry? Really lol? Culture, I could maybe understand. Everyday life as a young girl, fashion, toys, ok, maybe. But "the industry"? As in the toy/doll industry? Ok sis.

[@krustykringle]

​@@adriantucker5532 this is such a needlessly condescending reply and for what?

[@starryskies113]

@@adriantucker5532 ur a dude so how can u guess

[@starryskies113]

i mean there winter bratz . i do agre eit kinda sltty but it a toy

[@starryskies113]

i never seen any atomic body part on bratz unlike lol toys

[@mizore217]

i wished bratz would use their 2d animations that are usually shown in their ads, in more than just their ads. the art work is too iconic and pretty to limit it

[@razminfox1787]

I’m personally not that big a fan of that look mostly because the no nose part of the style

[@mesovogue]

I agree, I wish all their media (cartoon/movies) had that art style of animation from the commercials

[@leilavalentina2787]

to be fair, their first movie was in this style, so ur wish kind of came true:)

[@georgiagalaxy]

And the first movie: Starrin N Stylin’

[@georgiagalaxy]

@@leilavalentina2787YASSSS what I said 💗💗

[@Aviescquien]

MyScene was my favorite. I did dabble in Bratz when I was a kid and I had the prom themed Cloe, but we didn't form a connection.

[@KBarraza]

Omg the my scene games are so memorable to me as well!! it and it holds such nostalgia.

[@alishasnecklace]

i feel like with bratz, they were… “the girls with a passion for fashion”, like that’s literally what they were. them not having consistent styles actually made sense because they dressed in clothes and not personality traits. it’s something barbie also started out as, many collectors of vintage barbie like to point out how her early looks can be seen as fashion time capsules that captured the fashion of that exact decade or even year. also, you could imagine the bratz girls as models that are just posing for the magazine, getting to new looks after the one they just shot.

[@DarlingDollz]

I agree! I think especially with the framing of the girls running a fashion magazine on the side, a lot of the lines you could probably imagine as them modeling the looks they were going to feature in the magazine. I think both lines did a great job of being fashion time capsules in their era, but whereas My Scene was on the side of more casual fashions in their early years, you can see a lot more tangible inspiration in Bratz from specific runway pieces or popular high fashion items in that era.

[@alishasnecklace]

@@DarlingDollz myscene’s idea of casual is very mattel-ified (very much monochromatic, not something you would pull out of the closet and throw on) and bratz on the other hand wore actual pieces that didn’t necessarily match bc… that’s how clothes work irl !! it’s rare when someone is wearing matchy matchy

[@justrosie]

I grew up with Bratz and never got into MyScene, although I really wanted to. It was kinda like Investing in Nikon vs Canon equipment--once you choose one, its a big effort to "switch". All of my friends had myscene, though!

[@lostjunglist8704]

I Love Your Voice... I'm sitting here all cracked out feeling while strolling through Pinterest for the past 2 or 3 hours. Damn I need to quit and get to work...Making a Polly Pocket Collection Wish List. I loved that one too! Thank You for being YOU!

[@Erudiriel]

I really like your take and how balanced it is! I was a MyScene gal in my younger days but I absolutely see the ways in which Bratz work better. Thank you for this nice nostalgia trip!

[@citonita2207]

I'm here from the Equestria Girls video and can't wait to comb through your channel a bit. And it's true tbh, as a kid I wanted Bratz so bad bc I loved fashion, but now I feel much more nostalgia for MyScene bc I spent hours connecting with the girls as characters and pretending I was in their group. My parents didn't want to indulge me in either brand lol so I still feel envy as an adult for these dolls looking at these old commercials. I can't believe how wild Bratz got even by today's standards

[@jlbeeen]

I never really watched either of them, but I always liked the Bratz dolls in the stores. I never had any as I didn't like to play with dolls as a kid, but as someone who sews, their outfits always looked so cool, like things I'd want to wear but wouldn't be allowed to. I still like that type of aesthetic of the 2000s slightly edgier girl they were going for.

[@paper_maiden]

I really loved MyScene and I spent many late night playing around on the website

[@zerotatertots]

im more of a bratz person but i had ALOT of myscene accessories , i just thought they were better tbh

[@UltraViolet666]

I always wanted a MyScene doll as I saw them as more mature, but none of my friends had them, and my mum even once convinced me that getting a Bratz doll in the store was better than trying something new with a MyScene doll. I don't mind now, because I'm die-hard Bratz again, but I wish that I had at least seen one MyScene doll in person!

[@Cinnamon1161]

The whole competition with Bratz is what ultimately made my scene fall short if it was it’s own idea without trying and failing to compete with Bratz it might have done better but also the bling/Kennedy era might have also contributed to it

[@Backwithuagain]

BOTH !!! the myscenes were always the parents or siblings of my bratz😂

[@annw7843]

I never had a MyScene doll but I remember playing the MyScene web games for hours.

[@therobotdevil2284]

My brain at 3:00 a.m.: IT'S MY SCENE, YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN IT'S MY SCENE 💀🎶

[@helenmoreno5631]

Great video! I was a My Scene kid. I loved their web episodes. ❤️ I still have a ton of My Scene dolls. I always appreciated that they could wear other Barbie clothes and shoes. Chelsea was my favorite.😍

[@Vermillionchord]

I'm not sure if anyone's mentioned this or not but ive watched a couple recent and old and noticed the same problem still prevalent. When you use audio from a commercial or show the audio channels always on my left ear (when wearing headphones. Both of my headphones work fine btw) i hope this gets fixed for future videos since i have sensitive hearing. Another audio issue is the hard cut to the end credits audio and how loud it is. I'd suggest fading it in and adjusting the volume as well. My last concerned, opinion, critique, suggestion, however this will be seen, is to have your icon at least there when there's no image on screen for the topic your talking on. I usually wonder when a segment like that happens but then immediately go back to look at the screen when I notice some visuals flashing at the corner of my eye. Take this at you will, i hope i don't across negative, insensitive or rude. These are merely my suggestions.

[@KassandraQuiseng]

I never had any brats dolls because I just thought they didn’t look right as a kid. I much preferred the proportions of barbie’s so I loved my scene. The website so so iconic and I still love the my scene faces. Seeing the dolls and the flash games on the website gave me so many warm and fuzzy memories.

[@loganvorrias5487]

I love both lines 💓

[@ryuspiritvtuber]

As someone who had both a my scene and Bratz why choose one when you can have both at the same time

[@kandy1643]

Omg jeepers media :0 I use to watch that dude

[@MLPRarityBrony]

I am Team Barbie but I like bot

[@amybellerive-jewell9730]

My scene all the way. The removable feet of the Bratz creeps me out.

[@Neonrain08]

to me myscene dolls are the most pretty they look like stunning 00s supermodel it girls and they have such good outfits. maybe its because i'm from Europe and my scene dolls where bigger here but i just never cared for brats at all as a kid. plus i liked how my scene dolls could fit into barbie clothes/cars/houses wheres brats where too small for barbie stuff. chealsea was my fave myscene doll

[@jaredjameson3707]

Bratz super babies? Wtf lmaooo

[@JessicaAliyahE]

I think Mattel became the weaker competitor when they started to adopt ideas from the Bratz. Bratz dolls were not only about urban club outfits. Myscene seemed to struggle with creativity for a minute bc they were inspired by Bratz without understanding the full vision .They had a good thing going with their high Fashion Girl/NYC girl aesthetic . I personally love Myscene dolls and still do. They seem like a perfect medium between Barbie and Bratz dolls. I've always loved their stylized appearance and in depth persona's. Although Bratz has so much and range and was more inclusive.

[@Adv18]

But who were Bratz inclusive to? They all shared the same face mold that perpetuated euro centric beauty standards. Even their POC dolls had the thin noses. large eyes, pouty lips and straight/wavy hair? The only difference between the dolls were the coloured plastic.

[@LBYRNTH_]

@@Adv18 I'm gonna speak from the perspective of a black person on this. Both lines have issues with diversity imo but in different aspects. Bratz has a known history of lightening darker skinned characters for commercials and the graphic designs on the boxes but Jade is routinely coded as asian and Sasha is undeniably black with deep skin, dark hair, and some of her dolls feature brown eyes and/or hairstyles like a fro or braids. Madison on the other hand... I personally don't find her relatable in the regard. She looks like Yasmin but with wavier hair and blue eyes. She seems to be coded as black with her interests and personal style but that's as far as it goes. To me, especially as a got older, that always gave the impression of Mattel wanting a black character... but not *too* black. Combine that with Sutton who started off with a fro and then they chopped it off so he basically looks like a tan Ken with dark hair, then dropping Nolee to replace her with Delaney, and I just end up feeling like the representation in My Scene is incredibly lacking. Bratz lacked the character development of My Scene but they have a wide spectrum of skin tones for kids to pull from with their huge cast of characters and 2 of their core 4 were racially *un*ambiguous. But that's just me!

[@bgcrp2005]

Sasha and Madison if they were real would benefit from futurism lkme the loose wavy curly hair and blue and green eyes and so what black girls should be able to feel included their dolls should be able to have long hair cause most girls in real life love long hair

[@starryskies113]

@@Adv18 there is some mole and the eye change eyes slighlty

[@starryskies113]

@@LBYRNTH_ yea bratz baby sasha had became tan i wanted her to be dark skin with yellow eyes so pop out they made jade blue eyes yasmin with blue green eyes

[@Pyonkotcchi]

I’m definitely a Bratz guy to the core but the my scene theme song lives in my head rent free at all times and I always really liked them and had fond memories of them, like I never grew up thinking eww wanna be Bratz it’s very much an oh boy two cakes moment

[@bemyshadow0]

if there ever was a right way to see it, this is it! hahah

[@nanimarie2959]

Comment of the video right here

[@GrrrlStyleNow]

The My Scene website was an early internet glory and I spent hours and hours on it as a tween. But I never owned an actual My Scene Doll - it just wasn't a socially acceptable thing for an 11/ 12 year old in my school and I feel super sad about that.

[@inori_shiki]

Same. I loved the online games for My Scene, especially the bedroom design.

[@em84c]

My doll obsession was at its height when I was 10-12. Lucky my best friend did too. Other kids thought it was babyish.

[@lalasarchive1]

I think that the bratz were kept with less personality for the play aspect, I definitely liked this as a child because I would create my own worlds andand characters with ambiguous lives and loved to mix and match

[@3s_muycar0]

This! I think the series and movies have been consistent with they personalities but at the end of the day I was playing with bratz more than any other doll because of the fashion, something I’d like to imagine I’d dress when I got older and still to this day I wish I could have the wardrobe my bratz had😩😭😭 Plus me n my sisters n cousins had so much fun playing with em ❤️

[@plasticaloud9072]

You should definitely do a video on Barbie circa 2003-2005, those years were really good for the line and really focused on bringing more detailed and fashionable pieces to play line, something we hadn’t really seen since 1999!

[@dolleyez13]

for bratz personalities i thought it was always yasmin: the smart one that always gets them out of situations, mom friend cloe: the one that panics easily , drama queen (bc sasha always called her that) n overachiever jade: the sarcastic one who wanted to b a designer sasha: the firey, confident one who loved music

[@AnonyMous-lh3cm]

If I remember Barbie was Replaced with Kennedy as a result of a settlement with one of the MGA lawsuits

[@StarlaBizarre]

I was going to say, how the heck did they get away with the name?!?

[@em84c]

@@StarlaBizarre my scene was made by Mattel who owns Barbie

[@milkcanfan97]

i love ur observations! i think bratz r undeniably iconic but myscene has a special place in my childhood memory bc of the lineless art style they went for and the web games

[@robertomarin9864]

Great video! I'm definitely a MyScene boy at heart. When Bratz came out it was such an outstanding moment at the time because there were not fashion-forward dolls with such an innovative proposal as Bratz. We all loved the high-end fashions, very elaborated and glam makeup, trendy hairdos of that time that Barbie wasn't giving us. When MyScene came out everyone thought the same: They were copying Bratz with the characteristics of a large head, big expressive eyes, glam makeup, large lips, large feet, and stylish cheekbones. The MyScene fashions were also high-end with an urban modern look that was very inn of its time and Barbie did a great job by giving us something very different from past decades. I agree that in the beginning, the Bratz girls did not have a signature and singular fashion style to identify each character but through the years MGA noticed that and did it successfully. The good points on the Bratz doll lineup it was the diversity of each character and the representation of different people, and the low point of it is that there were not developing the background stories of the girls. On the other hand, MyScene did a great job by developing a deep back story for each character to make them feel more relatable to the kids through the tv ads, merchandising, and of course, the website. Although the graphics were very basic, the website was so much fun to spend hours playing there. Nowadays Bratz did an impact on culture and they're still a world phenomenon and they remain relevant.

[@starryskies113]

mystett had canceled daly wish they had a monster or different style like hrajuku punk preppy idk

[@ladyaries]

I'd love to see you cover the Fashion Fever days or talk about the short life of Novi Stars.

[@Nina_dollinista]

This video is awesome! As a long time Barbie and Bratz fan/collector I crave content like this. Videos about Bratz that aren’t “Y2K” fashion or makeup challenge. But real content about Bratz dolls and how they changed the doll industry 💖💖💖 You’re doing a great job!

[@DarlingDollz]

Thank you so much! I really appreciate that ❤❤

[@girlybrunette]

i love ur video bratz and myscene were equally important to my life as a kid so seeing praise from both sides was so good to listen to

[@girlsniteout]

you clocked the tea

[@bratzscene3131]

An iconic My Scene line you definitely forgot: 💎Super Bling💎 I also think both brands have their positives and negatives, personally I prefer My Scene though.

[@abigailbostic2198]

Growing up, my mom was always very critical of fashion dolls (I was very sheltered and my mother thought they were "vain" and "promoted bad moral values") and I was always discouraged from enjoying toys like this. I've found myself, as adult, realizing that a lot of these dolls were super cool and I've since started to gravitate towards them in ways that I was never able to enjoy as a kid, so... discovering your channel to learn about them has been a huge joy! Thank you for making content like this!

[@juliaoocampo2961]

great video! I do have to disagree about Bratz not having characteristics & peronalities to the extent of the main 4 of course. the secondary characters were definitely more just dolls. straight from the first release we know that Yasmin is a bohemian earth girl, Cloe is the girl next door, Sasha is into music specifically hip hop & Jade is into making her own clothes. In the digital media those personalities are expanded of course making Yasmin a writer & animal activist, Cloe was sporty & studious, Sasha was into making music and Jade wanted to be a fashion designer and they all shared a passion 4 fashion. As a kid none of them really represented my ethnicity perfectly so i always identified with Sasha for her love for hip hop and music :) I do agree that both Bratz and My Scene ended up with dolls that looked similar and less personal however i think Bratz also did a good job with showing the girls personal styles in the earlier years like Slumber Party, First Edition & Xpress It!

[@DarlingDollz]

I actually agree! Slumber Party is one of my fave lines for that reason. It's just so playful and the girls' personalities really shine through in it even though they all have the same basic silhouette.

[@juliaoocampo3973]

@@DarlingDollz I love how they play with the characters ethnic background a bit with Slumber Party as well! Jade’s kimono style robe & silk pants , Cloe’s western cowboy theme, Sashas hair twists and Yasmin’s top I believe is similar to a Latin American style blouse! I thinks it’s so cute

[@solarambala]

Both are pretty and both uses real fabric the 2000's fashion dolls are the best. I can't stand the quirky vibe childish aesthetic of recent fashion dolls

[@nileysnursery4408]

Ikr some of them I like for example rainbow high dolls but a lot of the fashion dolls these days are so boring and "childish" I like lol omg dolls tho they have the quirky child aesthetic but they still have really good fashions in my opinion

[@starryskies113]

@@nileysnursery4408 lol doll had npple when dipped in water in pany hose and male body parts shown wow bratz babies seem more tame but bratz babie was kind aweird bratz kidz is ok but the og is cool

[@starryskies113]

@@nileysnursery4408 lol doll kids is cool

[@nileysnursery4408]

@@starryskies113 lol dolls aren't really a problem it just bothers karens in my opinion

[@princessstella6552]

Fashion dolls nowadays look childish and cartoonish so those companies can attract parents and marketing children nowadays, even the quality gets bad as time goes by compared to the 2000s.

[@HeySas]

I'm from Germany and the Bratz didn't make it as big here. I remember only having Cloe as a mini Bratz while I had every MyScene girl once and a few different Barbies. I also only remember the MyScene and Barbie movies and video games but nowadays I love Bratz. Their style is so iconic. I loved the MyScene style as well but I feel so personally connected to Bratz when it comes to fashion

[@gracehaven5459]

My parents didn't let me have any Bratz dolls because they said that the name was vulgar and the dolls were too sexualized. Meanwhile last Christmas my step-brother's daughter got an LOL doll that I can only best describe as wearing nothing but a black fishnet lingerie suit 😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@babygirla5717]

Well LOL surprise doll is literally made from the same man and company that created Bratz

[@inkling457]

My Scene looks like 6Teen.

[@vitorlunkes]

I really love both, in Brazil both doll lines where really expensive in my childhood, so i just enjoyed the cartoons and the movies

[@bradlee1916]

i think bratz will forever be the superior doll line but my scene also had its own shine to it :)

[@ischeele7203]

MyScene were perfect for kids whose parents wouldn't let them have Bratz

[@shadowpuppet8192]

I wasn't big into dolls growing up. But I was given a Yasmine doll when the Bratz came out. And she's been my girl ever since.

[@Lars1996]

I think My Scene body proportions and face sculpts were prettier. Bratz had better fashion.

[@alolisa113]

Personally, as a child, I was intimidated by the MyScene girls as I thought of them being much older, and their more realistic body proportions made me feel more connected to the cartoonish Bratz girls. I cared more about the visuals than the personalities. I also felt that the Bratz girls were more international so as a non-American I resonated with them more haha

[@novembercrust]

One line that was a predecessor to both of these was Barbie Generation Girls (1998 - 2002 I think) - it featured a group of international, somewhat multi-ethnic characters with distinct personality + styles and had book tie ins. Set in New York too like My Scene, and trying to push more contemporary teen fashion like Bratz. There were only about 3 lines of dolls, but I feel like this was kind of a line that was pushing fashion dolls into the Bratz and MyScene era (I am pretty sure the Bratz creator worked for Mattel at this time too so highly possibly he worked on this line.). Maybe not as high quality fashions but really cool accessories. I have always loved distinct styles and hobbies between my doll characters so this kind of stuff is what I lived for. MGA still often fails in this department in my opinion - all the Rainbow High outfits are amazing quality but feel like one guy's idea of 'fashion' and I wish they pushed individualized characters more.

[@Pinkyyyy13]

I loved my barbies and I played with MyScene dolls, but i never liked bratz honestly because of the removeable feet 😅 i guess thats my take on the rivalry

[@karleecraziness9216]

I love both Bratz and My Scene but my issue the dolls are not so much the dolls themselves but the parents hypocrisy surrounding them. Okay so they hate Bratz because of their features but My Scene was meant to compete with Bratz. They have Bratz inspired facial features, but obviously with Barbie bodies but why is one deemed worse than the other?

[@Blake1720]

Madison and Delaney were my favorite my scene dolls and Chloe was my favorite Bratz doll. I had no idea my scene was even inspired by bratz or in competition. I never liked Barbie’s much so it’s interesting to see the backstory now and why I was drawn to My scene along with Bratz.

[@princessravendiamond4288]

Ngl, I actually kinda like the weird CGI Bratz movies. I still have the Fashion Pixiez movie and I still love the drug trip that is that movie.

[@e.d.t.]

As someone who didn't like either brand initially, I could at the very least respect Bratz for being more different and edgy. I don't need media to determine my dolls' personalities. That's what imagination is for.

[@nileysnursery4408]

Surprisingly I didn't hear of myscene until last year (ik im so late wtf) but I'm definitely a bratz girl nothing can top them for me but I'm interested in giving myscene a chance and watching the cartoons maybe I can hopefully find a myscene doll and see what I think. they seem really great :)

[@aliceinscaryland]

I have one masquerade madness my scene doll, and she's beautiful. I love everything about her, two outfits, lots of accessories etc I miss this doll line, it was a perfect mix of barbie and bratz.

[@adileneolivares6777]

Please, I loved the bratz movies but in general I think the Myscene dolls were just better built. I hated that if I wanted a beach look for my bratz i would have to find their feet to pop on instead of taking their shoes off. Which is pretty much the reason I only had barbies… yet I watched all the bratz movies.

[@Potatogirl-oz8be]

Same

[@jacquelinelugo5518]

Honestly as a kid who was the target demographic for both dolls. I loved them both but I was definitely more of a Bratz dolls kinda girl. But honestly what I loved about MGA and Mattel at the time. Is that we as kids got some great dolls out of both of them. I always thought as a kid that Bratz was going more for an L.A. fashion type of vibe and MyScene a more NYC fashion type of vibe. If Mattel would have stuck with that, MyScene would have had more iconic lines to remember

[@Sonicsis]

Im MYsCENE fan just because I spent HOURS on the site.

[@chandlerrrrrrrrrrrrrr]

will you cover barbie fashion fever next

[@jediknightdeeja4185]

Am I the only one who grew up watching the my scene webisodes and just....never realized that Barbie was supposed to be THE Barbie?? I guess I never knew that my scene was also Mattel lol Seriously tho, I was more into My Scene because even as a kid, story and character content was always more my thing, but this video has given me an appreciation for Bratz. I hope those rock star fashion designer genies keep showing off their Passion for Fashion and inspire kids out there to do the same 💕

[@nikadusko6327]

Bratz is my favorite i like hun dressings and make up my favorite girl Bratz is Cloe she is so pretty and hear friends Too Yasmin and Sasha and Jade i love Bratz she is my life girls so pretty girls than My Scene and Barbie she is so f*king Scroll hear friends too Winx Club is beatiful Monster hihg little bit*! Bratz is pretty i miss you i well back old Bratz!* 2001 - 2002 - 2003 - 2004 - 2005 - 2006 - 2007 - 2008 - 2009 - i well you so much back Bratz Party is so hot too Crush from Cloe wowwww super niceeee

[@naomistarlight6178]

I aesthetically prefer Barbie/MyScene, but I appreciate Bratz more now. It was something I didn't like when it came out, but now I do. They grew on me.

[@kenziehurlock]

As a kid I liked MyScene ans thought they looked like adult Bratz. I only ever owned 2 amongst my many Bratz. As an adult I found some MyScene at Savers. I loved the Bratz movies. Rock Angelz and Genie Magic were my favorite.

[@jordanjohncarloj.8878]

I have 3 Myscene dolls, Barbie, Kennedy and Delancey but I think I love to have Bratz dolls more especially Jade!

[@moonbaby222]

i'm a big bratz fan but i loveee myscene, the fashion and music were amazing and the movies♡ i love delancey and madison 💗

[@Blake1720]

Those were my favorite my scene dolls too. 😍

[@muckyboys6658]

I grew up with both My Scene and Bratz dolls as a kid. Bratz definitely had more to offer when it came to playsets and lines, but they just didn't do it for me. I can appreciate both, but its totally My Scene all the way for me.

[@delilahandaria6198]

I only watched the bratz kidz and babyz movies but I looooved them. I was so jealous of their smooth, shiny hair haha.

[@suricato151]

Growing up outside of the United States, the presence of a MyScene website with multiple attractions like games, webseries, written lore and trivia made a definite difference. Both Bratz and MyScene dolls were very expensive in my country, but the MyScene website had such chuckhold on me that I managed to get a Nolee as a gift one year. Bratz didn't have the same level of accessibility - I know they had their movies, but they were available only in a purchase form, it wasn't like I could just log on their website and have the videos there to watch whenever I wanted, like MyScene had.

[@Beatlelover21]

I was a myscene kid! I think the thing that really endeared me to them was the included multimedia items. The CDs were so cool and i watched jammin in Jamaica and masquerade madness a million times. The Mattel website was also really incredible at the time, I preferred the my scene games to Bratz.

[@MoonMoonTM]

I played with both Bratz and My scene. I still have some of my dolls from both brands. Lol

[@averyl6]

This made me remember how I played my scene flashgames ALL THE TIME as a kid. I never even had the dolls or honestly knew what the doll line was until recently. Now I finally know why I recognize the art style so vividly.

[@hollowrat4905]

"Dyllan stop!!! Your standing in poison Ivy" "aAaaaAAhH"

[@imauniryne6757]

I was obsessed with Barbie when I was little I had a theme Barbie room and I loved bratz but I never knew my scene had dolls I played the games online

[@jailanelson233]

Definitely a bratz girl I had so many clothes and dolls I loved the bratz though I do love the my scene games and movies

[@krystajustice1608]

Our daughter Elizabeth has super bratzz babies movie DVD

[@GUAGA0612]

I grew to really appreciate my scene tho, the quality was amazing

[@markgoldby6502]

Imma MyScene guy. love the sultry eye makeup and pouty lip shape. It made me nostalgic for Generation Girl.

[@krystajustice1608]

I love both i want campfire bratzs but so pricey

[@emflowersbooks]

as a kid I simply preferred myscene dolls because they had feet lol

[@makeuplover_99]

I personally like both bratz and myscene. However the myscene i tend to lean more to from childhood memories. The bratz also hold a special place to my heart. Idk. Its hard to chose but if i did i believe i would chose myscene. Just bc of the memories they hold for me

[@kidanygascot1410]

I Know right?!, it's so hard to choose. I am a guy and even though that I played a lot with hot wheels cars, max steel action figures, I also used to watch the My Scene and Bratz commercials without caring about if people were criticizing me or making a fuss about these commercials. 2000s toys are so ICONIC.

[@adriantucker5532]

Bratz will forever be my favorite. I'm on my boyfriends account right now, but growing up with the name "Anissia", being constantly made fun of for my DSL's (yes...children in Texas know what DSLs are), and having the darkest skin in my all white school, it felt...idk...cool to see dolls with exaggerated versions of my already exaggerated natural features + with names just as -"weird"- *unique* as mine, being played with by Lilly white suburban girls who knew nothing about an aesthetic I had grown up with and learned to idolize as I attributed it to how my older imo-glamorous older cousins looked. The big hoop earrings, the super slick ultra shiny lip-gloss, white eyeshadow, lip liner + no lipstick, belly shirts with cute AF bubbly graffiti letters/decor...like, that "zoom in zoom out" photo-background kinda vibe (if anyone remembers those places), high ponytails with random braids thrown in, "fendi capri pants & pedicured toes", etc. White girls & people in the business industry may call it "urban", but I call it "our style". Us: Latinas, chicanas, dominicans, black, phillipina. Whether "Cholas" or "around the way" girls. The ghetto superstars & barrio barbies ha😹 This was US. And it felt validating and special and made us feel cool and exotic but in the good way. Our features and fashion, once made fun of, were now idolized and admired. I will always LOVE Bratz for that. The people saying they look sexualized, dirty, gaudy, tacky, etc. and that say how when they were younger "they didn't want one" (lies) and try to make it seem like the more "natural looking dolls" are somehow morally and culturally superior are sick and stupid. Id rather look gaudy them boring. And makeup/loud bold fashions are just a celebration of unashamed femininity, a symbol almost, like the ornaments on a Christmas tree. No one looks at a Christmas tree, all done up with fabulous lights and bells and says "its masking the trees true beauty. How shallow". No that would be ridiculous. The ornaments are a celebration! An enhancement of our beauty! The way we express ourselves. There is nothing wrong with that. And its not Bratz fault that they just did it in a way that the naysayers are unable to pull off. So they can stick to their frumpery and their no makeup looks. They can be the morally superior ones who find value in the empowerment of not showing their value through the male gaze and blah blah blah But as for me and mine? Well embrace the camp and look fab while doing it and not spend our time with weirdo thoughts in our heads about how and why a CHILDREN'S TOY is "sexualized" (like...ew?). Bratz dolls don't look "cheap". They look _fun!_ and for us melinated sisters, they looked how our older cooler cousins were dressing at the time. Besides, as one of our Patron Saints of Fabulousness once said: _"Well Darling, it takes alot of money to look this cheap!"_ -Dolly Parton P.s: the my scene website SLAPPED tho like fr. Esp That music video maker yall remember that? lol!

[@dahlrjay63]

You've hit several nails on the head with this one. 💯 You've explained their appeal in a way I couldn't quite put a finger on!

[@Donteatacowman]

I really loved Bratz when I was a tween, and mostly remember things like "The brown haired one with a ponytail was the basketball one," "that one nerdy-chic skirt." I also think I was secretly attracted to them almost a decade before I would come out as gay, and there was a lot of internalized homophobia there. So I think it was more "I REALLY REALLY like these dolls because they uh, they look cool." I know people say they're ugly (my mom definitely thought so) but I just can't see it because of the nostalgic connotations.

[@mukuroikusabafan]

i was never aloud to play with either one but now i can and i prefer bratz

[@thischannelisdead000]

I perfer both

[@skyephoenix9925]

was moxie girls ever involved with this feud? i know they were produced by MGA, but maybe as like an answer to parents who wish there were more ‘innocent’ looking bratz dolls/take away my scenes purpose of being similar to bratz but kind of glammed down?

[@DarlingDollz]

Moxie Girlz were definitely envisioned to be a sort of "wholesome" alternative to Bratz as a way for MGA to have their cake and eat it too, but I don't know if they factored Mattel into that particular decision

[@scatmanjohnfan22]

waaaat i had no idea my scene had cartoons, the 2d animation looks very nice

[@MinmoKitty]

I always thought My Scene had one of the loveliest face sculpts of any doll line now or then. And Bratz one of the most hideous. Bloated and no nose having.

[@bratzliplogical]

The salt in the Bratz community over the 2015 Bratz dolls is so childish , embarrassing and honestly super pathetic

[@erinbailey7940]

Does anyone remember Flavas? I never owned the dolls, but the theme song lives alive and well in my brain forever. But they were, like, kids I would never be allowed to hang out with 😅

[@himbaek8533]

I liked both Bratz and MyScene, really any kind of doll I loved. Even though I played with them less I have strong fond memories of my MyScene dolls. They just seemed so cool, I liked their faces and the webisodes definitely helped

[@LBYRNTH_]

I'm very much settled in the Bratz camp since they're over cartoonized aesthetic and focus on fashion has always drawn me in. I also grew up watching the cartoon. I remember My Scene and while the aesthetic was certainly applause worthy, Sasha just felt like better representation for me as a black kid then Madison ever did. That being said, to this day, I dip into combing through different My Scene dolls on Google or ebay because the earlier aesthetic really hits hard. They truly had the fashion of everyday put together young women and I struggle against my chains to buy Sutton and Madison from the Hanging Out line. The impact of My Scene can't be denied though overall Bratz has gotten into my heart and my wallet. Lol

[@SticksGazetteFan2005]

I definitely wished that the 2d animations from the commercials should’ve been used again in the movies.

[@Exxylux]

I never clicked on a video so hard LMaO. I always found this topic in toy history so fascinating. I also cannot believe u pulled up chart of the bratz secondary characters. Insane! 💜 thank u for ur videos, I like the narration and when I have time i always find one of ur vids ! 😀

[@catbug8509]

bratz girl right here. I was never allowed to have them as a kid, but omg im obsessed with them now

[@buttercupdabaddieutonium9257]

My scene kinda reminds me of a doll version of sex and the city

[@Neonrain08]

omg yes it does