[defensive stage] 'Jinie' - BREATHE, '지니' - 한숨 복면가왕 20190804

[@bobamochi2679]

So many people forgot that Kyuhyun almost died during SuJu's car accident back in 2007. The doctor literally said there was no way, funeral was almost prepared for him, he was on his death bed fighting to stay alive at the age of only 19. Him being able to breathe right now is a miracle and I'm sure he's able to relate to this song a lot.

[@flady4967]

Boba Mochi Yeah and not to mention that the doctor suggest to do a surgery which may cause him to not be able to sing again but then his father disapproved because he said it will affect Kyuhyun’s career as a singer and asked for other solution. Fortunately, another doctor suggest a surgery that was safe for him. I am so grateful for the doctor, his father and God for giving him another chance to live.

[@mdheartsuju]

This song was written by jonghyun so it must have been very painful for kyuhyun to sing

[@fujidenzo-w6g]

kyuhyun's second life is a great gift from God ....

[@tssss3966]

@@fujidenzo-w6g Nope. Thank the doctor who saved his damn life.

[@nurulmarifah5029]

my tears....

[@tinadiary]

Kyuhyun like "Jonghyun i'm here and this song for you"

[@gurdkaur7974]

This makes me miss him so much...

[@airies1680]

Why I'm cry 😭

[@airies1680]

@@steventkun3592 yes

[@영혜-z8z]

2020힘내요

[@김시은-f7r]

반아_ 같이 힘냅시다!

[@oh2863]

한국 아이피로는 이영상 못보지 않아여!? 외국 사시나봐용

[@hellojamiee]

힘내요 같이

[@einsammadchen9074]

힘냅시다 우리!

[@lonelytree533]

감사합니다. 힘 받고 갑니다

[@SuperChikha]

Breathe’s message...I love how every masked singer who sang it had a different feeling to it. Sohyang’s version and the way she sang it brought comfort and hope. Han Donggeun’s was desperation and almost frustration. Kyuhyun’s version was regret and sorrow. Each one sang it so well and they all left me in tears. Jonghyun, you did well :,)

[@ultrakill40]

Omggg seem like you watch those 3...i love all these singer

[@jamsgamboa]

Singing this song takes a lot of courage... from the technical aspect to the emotional effect. Genie did really well.. I dont understand korean but the message really cuts deep. Pain. Sorrow. Desperation. Hope. Chances... You did well Jonghyun!

[@hazardkante17]

SuperChikha Couldn’t said it better

[@kimkaira1275]

omaygad you're so right!

[@wu_kembaren]

Couldn't agree more. ♡

[@1000ntahpapentah]

At the end when he sings “정말 수고했어요..”, it feels like he’s telling SHINee Jonghyun “YOU DID WELL JONGHYUN, YOU DID REALLY WELL” ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@misscaunseling5404]

Also when he repeat its okay 3 times at the end..i'm cryingf..its like he's saying that to jonghyun.

[@1000ntahpapentah]

miss caunseling yes exactly ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@LanTheDreamer]

i already sobbing at that part TT

[@wu_kembaren]

The last lyrics always got me in tears. Now that Kyu sang it looking like he said that to Jonghyun, I don't even care anymore that I'm crying like an idiot at WORK. ㅠㅠ

[@ryomandu]

That was it really seemed like 😭 it gave me goosebumps 😢

[@송승원-t3c]

진짜 대충들어도 규현이네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 음색이 있는 사람은 진짜 목소리로도 구분이 되는구나

[@송승원-t3c]

쥐조쿠 Wls

[@이요셉-l2o]

어이!!!! 여기서 쥐조쿠 망신 시키지말라구

[@김기복-n2g]

진짜로 그냥 들어도 규현이....ㅋㅋ

[@김기복-n2g]

@@일반인-f4i 규현이 목소리 많이 들어본사람은 그냥 알아챌것같은데...? 본인이 몰랐던거가지고ㅋㅋ

[@최우형-b2d]

규현 노래 평소에 안듣고 신서유기만 봐도 딱봐도 규현임 ㅋㅋㅋ 남의 말 꼬투리 잡아서 좋디?

[@camixena]

"It's alright It's alright It's alright, I'll hold you You really did a good job" I sobbed like an idiot. Kyuhyun is telling Jonghyun that Jonghyun did very well. Their lasting friendship. Kyuhyun is keeping Jonghyun's music alive. Thank you!

[@laughlater4562]

Yes. Jonghyun shouldn't be a taboo, we should celebrate him.

[@darylgracecastillanes5685]

😭😭😭

[@breezymango4113]

Now I am bawling even more... Memories too come to me..😭😭

[@ggulggul-v6b]

I couldn't stop sobbing too. Thank you so much for singing this as a memorial of jonghyun

[@maihwang7035]

I can't stop crying on that part 😭

[@ninetyoneliner]

He’s a wall that need to be passed by any idols who want to brand as a talented vocal. His technique is on another level and he knows exactly what he wants his sound to be and that, for a vocalist, prove his maturity. He doesnt stray from his style which is a detailed and dynamic straighforward ballad singing which is quite rare these days among korean singers who has this tendecy to belt really high over and over again (sometimes straining) and reach low notes by whisper and half breath sound. I’m not saying those singers are bad but I just like Kyuhyun’s style even tho sometimes ppl may think it’s more boring, but the way he stays to that style and keep perfecting his craft is admirable and on top of that, his voice itself is a pure gem, so pleasant to the ears. I’m a fan for sure.

[@XimenaSu1609]

It's not just your opinion, I assure you ^_^ Kyuhyun is widely regarded as one of the best if not the best idol technique wise. His rage is very wide, and he always sings with a lot of support (I don't think I've ever heard him strain tbh). And his lower tones are clear, not breathy (which is bad technique). People say he sings easy songs just because he prefers ballads over other genres but ballads are mainly carried by the voice (while other genres can receive help from the music) you also need an amazing voice and confidence in it sing ballads like Kyuhyun.

[@hoppipollaedits5116]

This is the only time I cried hearing someone’s ballad besides BTOB. You could hear the sincerity in his voice. It’s so emotional 😭 I’m a new fan.

[@bobamochi2679]

Setting him as a standard for a good vocalist is kinda extreme imo simply bc he IS the best vocalist in kpop. His technique, resonance, and range is unbeatable. Its been years and million idols debuted every year but I hv yet seen someone that can surpass him.. yet he keeps on improving his vocals. There are still talented vocalists in kpop tho their skills are unmatch with kyuhyun so putting him as a standard of a good vocalist is just too unrealistic and brutal lmao.

[@shiningjewel4034]

@@hoppipollaedits5116 you won't regret discovering Cho Kyuhyun

[@mumu_02]

@@hoppipollaedits5116 same..i feel really emotional when hearing btob and KRY singing..never ever feel enough with them...

[@정예림-j3h]

이노래도 종현이가 기쁘게 들어주면 좋겠다...

[@룽룽이-c1w]

청혜 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@user-gu3rq1ku1r]

우엑

[@최승엽-j1q]

@@user-gu3rq1ku1r 개념이라는게없냐?수준보소

[@김민용-x2z]

@@user-gu3rq1ku1r 떠나간 사람한테 그런 ㅈ같은 소리하면 기분이 좋아요? 할말이 따로있지.. 못배운거 너무 티내지 마요 추해요

[@user-qp3nc1jn8i]

ᄋᄋ 개념장착좀

[@casendramars]

Kyuhyun must loves Jonghyun lots, he sang songs written by Jonghyun twice on the show?

[@7scoups_of_suga]

Kyuhyun & Jjong are close friends and him singing these songs were tribute for his late friend.

[@azisahashary6246]

They were close and they were part of SM the BALLAD

[@regievillarico1623]

Can i ask kyuhyun and jhonghyun is real life brothers..? the two of both very nice voice..

[@7scoups_of_suga]

@@regievillarico1623 No they were labelmates. Kyuhyun was Jonghyun's sunbae (senior) & close friend.

[@markmybirds]

@@regievillarico1623 After he removed his mask, Kyuhyun explained that when Jonghyun passed away, Kyuhyun was in the military for his service so he didn't get to see him or talk to him before he passed. So I gather they were like brothers :).

[@kimpark7306]

People know its kyuhyun for sure though the identity is not yet announce because of his unique voice. 👍 if you agree.

[@seoyadi]

kim park exactly my thought! His voice is so unique! My favorite member from SJ

[@kimpark7306]

@@seoyadi waiting to reveal his identity.. 😂

[@tyarsyad]

IKR?! I can tell that is Kyu the second he started singing.

[@KimYuieJae]

its impossible not to know that it is kyuhyun based on his voice

[@chelle7180]

Imagine it's not him... we'll so dead

[@kukku0_0]

혜야랑 한숨 때 진짜 덜컥 내리앉는 기분이었어요. 얼마나 아꼈고, 얼마나 생각하면서 골랐을 노래일지... 목소리 하나로도 참 많은 위로가 되는 것 같아요

[@조민성-x3o]

와 이렇게 좋은말에 댓글이없냐 다시 생각하게 해주셔서 감사합니다

[@홍홍홍-b5x]

@@조민성-x3o 그러게요

[@홍홍홍-b5x]

감사합니다

[@명이나물-y2u]

공감해요 그 기분 아직도 못잊어요 저도 그랬어요..

[@leaf836]

진짜 헤야 추억의 개띵곡 종현형 진짜 내기준 아이돌 보컬원탑이야 많은노래가사쓰고 불러줘서 고마웠어 그리고 고마워.....

[@iouww]

I guess this was the only way he could pay tribute to an old precious friend, without the whole world watching him. Wearing that mask, i can tell it gives you the sense of personal space. And he needed that to comfortably sing jonghyun's songs and truly immerse himself in it. He didn't want the world to see the sadness in his expressions, but he wants the world to hear him sing the songs.. You did well, kyuhyun.

[@jimintho3066]

MultifanTrashcan very well said

[@josicr5498]

He sing it in a concert and it's painful see him, his voice has a feeling without description...

[@zealmae9082]

exactly. he had a speech after he was unmasked. and he talked about Jonghyun. I'm glad he talked about him

[@justdoit87x]

그러고보니까 이것도 종현이 곡이었네. 참 많이 아꼇던 듯.

[@김기복-n2g]

혜야도 그렇고 다른 콘서트에서도 심심찮게 한숨 부른거 보면 진짜 많이 아꼈던것같아요..

[@주먹짱고양이-f8q]

혜야 공연 끝나고 인터뷰에서 이노래 꼭 부르고 싶었는데 불러서 다행이라고, 종현아 형 열심히 불렀어 잘 들어주길 바래..라며...내가 눈물나,,

[@user-gz6ok6hn3p]

@@김기복-n2g 최근 규현님 목소리가 끌려 영상 찾아보는데 항상 계시는거 보니 정말 찐 팬이신거 같아요 ㅋㅋ

[@김기복-n2g]

@@user-gz6ok6hn3p 엌ㅋㅋㅋ

[@이승훈-u9v3m]

한숨은 이하이가 부른 곡 아닌가요?

[@라지벌랄라-e3s]

종현이 노래인줄 알고 들으러 왔지만 작사,작곡 김종현 이라는 글자 읽자마자 눈물나네 보고싶다 종현

[@누seo]

저도 작사, 작곡에 김종현 보자마자 눈물이 너무 나서ㅠㅠ 처음부터 감정 주체가 안되더라구요..ㅠ

[@박준민-x5u]

이게 그정도임..? 뭐 가족 관계였나

[@user-yr9rq6ze5g]

@@박준민-x5u 가족 관계가 아니더라도 좋아하던 사람이 멀쩡하고 잘 살아있을 줄 알았는데 갑자기 떠났다는 소식이 들리고 다시는 못 본다고 생각하면 충분히 그럴만 하지..

[@이름못정했음]

@@박준민-x5u 넌 공감 능력이 없냐..

[@hyun8389]

일부로 공감능력없는 척 태클걸어서 여기 댓 다는거 진짜 싫다 공감능력 없는 척하지마 찐따같아 진심 좀 이런 영상까지 와서 그래야되나

[@aheve]

Kyuhyun perform Lee hi - breathe. This song was written by jonghyun and I believe that jonghyun would be very happy to hear this song. But end of the part im in tears 😭 but congratulations kyuhyun had 2 consecutive wins!!!

[@christys_emily]

He wins 3/4 times??

[@aheve]

@@christys_emily 5 wins

[@Alex-vs5dh]

i can’t even begin to think about the pain kyuhyun’s been through. he almost lost his life in a car accident. he lost one of his closest friends whilst he was serving in the army, and yet he’s gone to sing two songs by jonghyun on this show as a tribute and i think that’s beautiful. no one could have done it as well as kyuhyun did

[@ashx9292]

Who is his friend who lost him while he is in the army ?

[@yuniartiaminahnoe4544]

@@ashx9292 jonghyun

[@lizxse4206]

@@ashx9292 jonghyun he wrote breath

[@린e]

난 왜 이 노래만 들으면 눈물이 나는지..

[@SUNZAKA]

수고많았어요

[@김해민-d7j]

@@user-gu3rq1ku1r 굳이 이런 댓글을 다시는 이유가 무엇인가요. 관심을 받고 싶은것인 가요?

[@포로리-e3o]

@@user-gu3rq1ku1r 관종ㅅㄲ 다른댓에도 이래놓더니

[@동글동글-t3x]

ᄋᄋ 진짜 이딴 ㅅㄲ는 뒤졌으면 좋겠다

[@nataliaam6943]

저도 ㅠㅠ

[@ZeeTaylor25]

Technically, he's THE BEST male KPop vocalist.

[@xjbt1]

The best man at the world!!!! Love him

[@wolfspain7385]

Park Hyo Shin wants to know your location.

[@hm-wm4qb]

@@wolfspain7385 hyosin is not idol category, she said about idol kpop vocalist

[@reny5282]

I have to say him daesung and of course jonghyun

[@4leaffy]

For me is between yesung and kyuhyun but still conclusion is Super Junior 💙😂

[@Thankyou99999]

Han Dong Geun's version feels like watching a strong man fighting to keep his emotions in check, finally breaking down under emotional load. Kyuhyun's version feels like a man reminiscing his most painful memories before finally moving on. In conclusion, I love both versions.

[@hedgehod6437]

This is the best description for the versions I've read! Loved it very much 🥰

[@judithleexD]

Both versions are both beautifully done, with different messages being conveyed. You described it perfectly

[@alunauwie27]

How about lee hi version? Just curious about ur description...

[@matt_villanueva]

Aluna Yui I feel like hers is expressing the message of the song writer’s feelings in hopes of someone to notice the writer’s pain.

[@alunauwie27]

@@matt_villanueva i think the same

[@allwest_]

노래들으면서 댓글내리는데 간간히 보이는 한국어들에 정말 울컥한다.. 이 노래를 불러준 규현님도 위로의 댓글을 달아주시는 여러분들도 이 글을 보고있을 당신도 모두 행복한 하루가 되길 바라요.

[@포로리-e3o]

@설백련 추천영상에 나온 이 노래에 눈물흘리고 이 노래를 불러준 규현님의 목소리에 위로받고갑니다... 오늘 하루가 끝나가는데 행복한 하루 되셨길바라요.

[@ranirahayumuis4689]

Kyuhyun and jonghyun under same company, they're senior and junior, they're in the same team called ”SM The Ballad” so kyuhyun really can deliver this song perfectly, with his goddess vocal with his memories with jonghyun and yep kyuhyun is the definition of prince of ballad he feel the song, deliver the meaning of the song perfectly to audience. HE’S REALLY A FREAKING GOOD SINGER! FULL PACKAGE!

[@jennifero8646]

Kyuhyun is singing jonghyun's song😭. I think it means a lot to kyu to sing this song💙

[@Sopiano_Choi]

처음시작하는 부분도 그렇고.. 숨을 크게 깊이 쉬어보라는게.. 처음에는 그냥 한숨을 쉬라는건 줄 알았는데.. 해보고 나니까 알았어.. 공황발작오고나서 알았어. 과호흡와서 숨 못 쉬고 나니까 알았다. 숨 크게 쉬고 숨이 벅차도 내 잘못이 아니고.. 손 발이 떨려서 아무것도 못 해도.. 그게 내 잘못이 아니니까.. 폐 끝까지 숨 쉬라고.. 어쩌면 본인이 힘들때 정말 숨쉬는것도 어려웠을때 듣고싶었던말인가보다.. 진짜 미안하지만, 감사합니다.. 힘들때 꼭 들을게요. 고마워요.

[@명이나물-y2u]

종현이 마음 이해해줘서 감사해요

[@구름-l1s]

마음아프네요 ㅠㅠ

[@이민영-n1n]

와...

[@표채원39]

저도 공황장애있는데 같이힘냅시다 이게 약먹으면 약에의지할거같고 더 피폐해질까봐 에이 정신적인거야 좀만참으면별거아니야라고 생각했는데 진짜 좀만 스트레스받아도 숨안쉬어져서 죽을뻔했습니다 참 힘드네요

[@Sopiano_Choi]

오늘 종현님 기일이세요. 당신의 숨결이 닿았던 모든 사람들이 이렇게 위로받고 살아간다는것을 저 하늘의 별이 되어 반짝이는 당신이 알아주기를....

[@novitarosanti7792]

I feel Kyu sing with all his heart and was remembering old memories with Jjong... I can't handle myself to not feel sad but at the same time feel touched and happy there are so so many people still and will always loving Jjong 💙

[@reglest2527]

I cried when the second half started

[@CraigWinstanley1]

This was fabulous. A perfect delivery of a wonderful song. Kyuhyun has a rare gift. His pitch and timing is perfect.

[@youniverse4363]

Craig Winstanley his soulvoice is totally outstanding. Its really a rare gift.

[@지니-b3w]

종현이를 기억해주고 이렇게 불러주셔서 너무 고마워요

[@zefanyadiva9293]

I CANT IMAGINE HOW KYU'S EXPRESSION WHILE SINGING THIS SONG 😭😭😭😭😭

[@sholehalfarys5263]

Me too

[@amalartan8530]

I can’t imagine how sad he feels when he sing this song

[@이윤리-o2y]

규현이 종현을 얼마나 아꼈는지 노래에서 알 수 있겠다 진짜 너무너무 자랑스럽다 규현이 ❤

[@lewihemms9081]

I don't know why but something in the way he sang the last part of the song tells me he was tearing up behind that mask (idk theres something about his little breath at the end of the two last lines that were kind of shaky) and I love it, because he delivered it genuinely and got mixed with his own story of this song and what it means to him and that what makes an artist. The ability of interpreting another artist's song (coming to an understanding of what the artist was feeling or thinking, bringing them feelings through life through lyrics) and how powerful is when you add your own story to the already told story and make people experience a new insight of what haven't been told. Idk if someone gets me. I'm just glad he is able to touch people's hearts like this because is not about winning but empathizing and connecting, because people tend to rely on music and artists because they sing and bring to life the feeling that we as listener can't put into words, so we let them tell our own personal story through theirs. Its amazing

[@lewihemms9081]

miss caunseling yeah, I didn't want to imply it because remembering this for some people is still hurtful. I know for sure he (Jinie) was and is still affected by it because he used to be close friends, they even were in a sub unit together. The fact he was so strong and deliver his side of story to this song is so sweet. Jinie is known for doing covers that honor and respect the original song and artist but he gave it an even more deep sign of honor to this one I think because he knows and had history with the composer. It was personal to him. They both did well, we are proud of them. ❤️

[@misscaunseling5404]

@@lewihemms9081 yup..i'm sure it must be hard for him to sing this song..i'm sure he still affected by what happened..but he did well.. I can feel his emotion

[@lewihemms9081]

miss caunseling I'm proud of him and I know that Jjong would be too.

[@brightharu1034]

I felt that too!

[@elainethong3924]

Same feeling to me...

[@fitriannisa4463]

As a singer this Jinie has it all. From technique, pitch, timing, and a sweet powerful voice. He’s not overdoing it and just delivered perfectly every time. I’m torn between wanting him to win or wanting him to take off that damn mask and see everyone’s shock reaction lol.

[@hazardkante17]

Fitri Annisa LOOLL he would take off that mask but rather later than sooner. I want him be a King as long as possible

[@ZARAxELF95]

He can take it off later. We know who he is already anyway 😂

[@skiyline]

@@ZARAxELF95 I read his name in the comments but I still have no idea. Can you please tell me who he is? 😅

[@annisaolivia8721]

@@skiyline he is kyuhyun from super junior.

[@skiyline]

@@annisaolivia8721 thank you ^^

[@알모정]

누군가를 위로해주던 그 마음이 위로받고 싶은 본인의 마음이었던 것을, 너무 늦게 알아서 미안해 종현아. 오늘도 보고싶다 참 많이.

[@tinatinarmainteresebs9255]

3:41 anyone else remember a certain popular video of Vocal Coach Reacts to kpop singers where Kyu did the same thing with the mic and the guy said that there must be some funny business going on with the mic cause it was almost impossible to sound that good with the mic so far? And it started a whole controversy and fight with some comments urging him to watch more of Kyu because he always did that; some saying that yes, he was THAT good lol; and some deciding that, ah! they finally found the trick to Kyu's perfect singing :D

[@tia329]

Oh that one! It always made me laugh everytime I remembered that. Kyuhyun almost always did that when he hit the high note. There was a compilation of kyuhyun live high note and he did that numerous times. The voice teacher just lacks of informations about kyuhyun so I think it's understandable for him to make that comment because not anyone can do what kyuhyun has always done :)

[@aspireone722]

I know that video because I watched it. While he strongly doubt, I was just shaking my head like 'hey, it's just a normal Kyuhyun's style' and he did it once again in this stage. I dare say that among ALL kpop idols, Kyu has the strongest resonance followed by Chen and Ryeowook. Sandeul is very very good, but resonance, not that much.

[@anglecho8236]

yeah that one...the vocal teacher who made a reaction to kpop vocalist high notes and he’s doubt on kyu part...😂😂😂Im just laughing and made me prouder of our baby kyu..Imgine its a vocal teacher and he cant tell if kyu high notes is reall..I mean yeah we all knew thats its 100% pure coz that clip is from a contest prog fom immortal song..But hmmm i also understand him coz yeah our baby is just so goodddd😁✌✌✌ sorry im just beimg bias...

[@brightharu1034]

And he's been avoiding his videos ever since 😆

[@aspireone722]

@@brightharu1034 I actually wonder why he isn't doing any Kyuhyun or KRY's vocal review since it is known in KPOP community of how great SJ's vocals are but I guess the disbelief of kyu's vocals hunted him and avoided these videos since then haha tho he did one with SJ KRY's Dorothy.

[@uniique3231]

Suddenly miss the real smtheballad,,,,,

[@mkl3513]

Same here.. hot times is my favorite... I wish they can bring it back..

[@cezdany4630]

Jino and Jonghyun... Miss them... Still Kyuppa and Jay ahjussi.. I think it will be different from the real SMtheballad

[@mkl3513]

@@cezdany4630 maybe they can keep these 2 and few more.. It won't be the same.. but atleast it'll be close

[@kguerr197]

@@cezdany4630 Jay left SM last year though. Kyuhyun is the only active member in SM The Ballad as of now. The only way we are going to see the original line up is through SM Station.

[@uniique3231]

Cez Dany Jay also left sm,, after trax contract with sm has been expired 4 months ago~

[@목경팔]

이 노래를 작곡한 종현이는 다른 이의 한숨을 이해하며 글을 썼지만...정작 자신의 한숨을 알아주는 이는 없었구나.. 남긴 노래 때문에 위로 받는다..고맙다

[@Turtlee1013]

One of Kyuhyun's first performance stages after recovering from the car accident was A Whole New World from Aladdin duet with Charice on Star King. Very fitting to be in a Genie costume as well.

[@whyherrodere3784]

and also I'm reminded of Robin Williams, who played the Genie in Aladdin, may he rest in peace too. Suicide took both Robin and Jonghyun's lives :(

[@Kenjireukin]

This is too much to me. Oh please 😢😢😢

[@수학나형]

신서유기에서 여기까지 왔다 ,,,, 조지니 만세

[@Leenuuuu]

아니 생각해보면 저런 눈 똥그란 빡빡이 지니 가면 쓰고 무게 잡고 노래 부르는데 전혀 우습지 않고 감동스럽다는 게 ㄹㅇ 노래 개잘부른단 증거임

[@moe8882]

This is the best cover of leehi's breathe. Im crying I miss jonghyun. Still can't accept the fact that he's really gone

[@moonbright7373]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bmLOgqepnLZ2prs

[@najibsultan9765]

Just curios, have you heard Sohyang version? I'm not against your taste or opinon, maybe u would consider to listen to Sohyang version, and tell me your opinion about it.

[@koeykyu]

@@najibsultan9765 Kyuhyun and Jonghyun had good relationship.. so Kyuhyun sang this song more emotionally..that's why some ppl love Kyuhyun's version more

[@najibsultan9765]

@@koeykyu I see I see, for emotion wise, Kyuhyun indeed, but for vocal wise I choose sohyang

[@tssss3966]

Same. I just prefer male singing voices since there's a very clear distinction between male voices. Sometimes when hitting particular notes, female singers sound almost the same to me.

[@reigisama]

Come back here again at 2023 and still cry.....listen to the song........

[@dhgfflh]

수십번도 더 들었는데 들을때마다 뭉클하다...규현은 정말 표현력이 최고인듯

[@Emareldia]

I'm so thankful to kyuhyun for keeping Jonghyun alive through his songs... I love kyuhyun, and this song is just so meaningful, in every aspect. Thank you for sharing it with us

[@aarushimittal9112]

You really did a good job ? Was it really part of the lyrics ? Or did he put this msg for bling bling ?

[@Emareldia]

@@aarushimittal9112 it was part of the song. Those are the words Jonghyun always wanted to hear, and he could hear them thanks to lee hi 💜🙏

[@madeinbusanjkjm]

정말 수고했어요 종현아..

[@paldavi2876]

Oh my . what a beautiful singer 🌹🌹 Paul /Ireland

[@김한솔-u9g]

규현인데??

[@프리미엄10-q8y]

@@김한솔-u9g 작사 작곡이 고 종현님이어서 그래요!

[@yeopbojagi]

진짜 규현 노래하는 거 들을 때마다 규현 아버지께 너무 감사하다 아버지 아니었으면 이런 좋은 목소리 못 들을 뻔했잖아... + 슈퍼주니어 컴백 많관부

[@user.dear.j]

어머니가 낳음

[@yeopbojagi]

@@user.dear.j 수술 얘기한 거였음

[@roopov5713]

Genie 꼴깝찐

[@동글동글-t3x]

딩동댕동 모르면 말을 하지 맙시다 ^^

[@이재원-j7p6c]

아버지가 꿈을 지켜주셨죠

[@yeesiigii]

Just thinking that Jonghyun wrote this song when he was going through a bad time, it breaks my heart, and listening to this song from Kyuhyun's sweet voice makes me cry even more😭😭💜

[@veela86]

Hi!! Just to spread the word so each artist get the credit they deserve: Y si fuera ella is a song of the songwriter and singer Alejandro Saens, he is spanish and wrote the song a long time ago. Jonghyun translated to korean and did an amazing cover!

[@yeesiigii]

@@veela86 yes, I know..Sí ya sé, me encanta esa canción, quise decir que la escribió en coreano jaja

[@SHINeeNAilee]

@@veela86 You're right, but the op is talking about Breathe, which is a song composed and written by Jonghyun. Alejandro Sanz absolutely deserves credit for Yi Si Fuera Ella, but this song isn't Yi Si Fuera Ella.

[@veela86]

@@SHINeeNAilee ohhhh!!! Thank you for the info! Breath is such a wonderful song!!

[@hannahvillamor1507]

The message is so deepppp. It really tells the situation of our Jonghyuniee huhuhu

[@elfallsuju7762]

previous when he sing breath - park hyo shi, i wish it was breath - lee hi (miss jonghyun) Suddenly bam kyuhyun fulfill my wish

[@user-dm2hr3qk9l]

Breathe is Lee Hi's song. Breath is Park Hyo Shin's song. I believe those mean different things like: breath is what comes when you breathe the air out. And breathe means like it's a command that you have to breathe

[@elfallsuju7762]

@@user-dm2hr3qk9l oh i get it. English not my first language so I not really focused on the title spelling so i thought it was the same title. Thanks for telling me this info

[@lalala622]

Same , until I’m not ready for those surprises !!!

[@Baldaggae]

실수해도 된다고 수고했다고 노래해주는 조규현이 있어서 다행이다

[@jaellibean]

Genie singing Lee Hi's song composed by the beloved late Kim Jonghyun. ♥ I hope everyone will be free and feel at ease whenever they hear this masterpiece. That acapella hit my heartstrings. Congrats Kyu. More wins for you. I hope he'll sing Fate again. :)

[@weiying8252]

Yeah I am looking forward to him to sing fate again😍

[@donghae941107]

Me too 😍 but i guess the song is quite hard to sing alone, even more with female's key right?

[@etherealnu6346]

This one hits differently especially that everyone knows he is close to jonghyun. The way kyu sang this song so heavenly and you can legit feel the emotions - this punch hits right in the gut

[@marsh1103]

I don't know, it's just my personal thought. I think when Jonghyun wrote this song, it was actually the way he convinced himself that it's okay to be imperfect sometimes, that he actually could take a rest for a bit. And when he gave Lee Hi this song, he actually wanted to say that "Hey, I might not exactly understand your condition, but I think we are having similar experience, and I hope this song can help you go through your difficulty too". But when Kyuhyun sang it, it feels like he tried to say, "I have been in this condition before and I have been able to get through it so I hope you will be able to go through it too." I haven't read any interviews or fan theories concerning this song, but I believe the message it carries is so powerful and I hope more people who listen to it will feel helped.

[@helloctober15]

marsh1103 💙

[@hamsanp3628]

❤❤❤

[@rajs7876]

This song always gives me help when my anxiety feels out of control. I cry and feel comforted at the same time thank you JJong

[@yukisuet0215]

At the last line of the song, kyuhyun sings it like how Jonghyun sings it. He is using his voice to reminiscence Jonghyun.

[@bl_area]

IM CRYING KYUHYUN-AH NO WONDER WHY PEOPLE CALLED YOU PRINCE OF BALLAD, YOU ARE REALLY THE BEST 😭😭

[@goddamnit7698]

규현의 한숨은 평소보다 더슬프게들린다

[@묘한-x3o]

진짜 2008년에 조금 더 세게 부딪혔더라면, 리더가 규현이 먼저 태워 보내지 않았으면, 병원에 조금 더 늦게 도착했었다면, 아버지가 수술을 반대하지 않으셨다면, 새 수술 방법이 성공하지 않았다면 우리는 이런 목소리를 듣고 위로받을수도 없던 거잖아... 살아줘서 정말 고맙고 다행이라고 생각되는 가수....

[@KYU_Balla]

그쵸. 어린 나이에 큰 일 겪은 친구라 그런가 확실히 인생을 대하는 마음가짐이나 일에 대한 자세... 많이 성숙하죠. 주기적으로 도는 영상인데 볼 때마다 규부심에 가슴이 넘나 웅장해집니다....

[@user-vq5bj8yq6n]

2007이에요!

[@JJUNGE12346]

노래를 하는게 아니라 진짜 괜찮다고 위로하는 것 같아 약간 속삭이듯이

[@lucete-r8k]

샤이니 팬은 아니었지만 작사•작곡에 ‘김종현’이라고 적혀 있는 것만 봐도 울컥하네요 샤이니란 그룹은 타팬에게도 너무 좋았던 그룹이에요 어릴 때 노래 진짜 좋아했어요 좋은 노래 많이 남겨줘서 고마워요 거기에선 행복하게 지내길 바랄게요 이걸 보는 샤이니월드분들도 행복하게 지내요 샤월들이 노래 들으면서 그리워하는 것만 봐도 종현 님은 뿌듯하고 기쁠 거예요

[@dewimartini8028]

Kyuhyun brought this song very well. I think he sings from the heart because he remembers his togetherness with Jonghyun. Every lyric is delivered with a feeling so unconsciously makes me cry could Kyuhyun shed tears behind his mask? I want to see Kyuhyun sing this song again without a mask ... proud of Kyuhyun miss jongyun ..

[@bravennn]

When he said "it's alright" 3 times, I lost it.

[@lallal-xc7cm]

가왕의 시작과 끝을 종현이로 맺어줘서 너무너무 고맙고 고맙다

[@taronrose8896]

It's interesting how with the 'Bob Ross' masked man, he sang the song very differently. He was acting as the friends/family that are angry at the person who committed suicide. Angry at the person that they didn’t talk to them. Angry at themselves that they couldn’t do anything about it. When he practically screams asks what was I supposed to do, he is heartbroken. While Kyuhyun, who Jonghyun was his closest friend, he sings it as a 'it's okay.' Like he is accepting Jonghyun's reason for dying. Like when he sang "it's alright it's alright it's alright. I'll hold you. You really did a good job." From what Kyuhyun said, he's been trying really hard to forgive himself for Jonghyun's passing. He was in the military for his mandatory enlistment so he wasn't able to truly say goodbye and go to the funeral like the other member. But, through this performance, Kyuhyun isn't doing it to win. He is telling his precious hyung that he did very well and their friendship's gonna last forever. With this mask on, however silly it may look, it is what is - a mask. With this mask, Kyuhyun can probably freely cry (you can tell he is in certain parts) and have a sense of personal space. He needed that space to comfortably sing the song and immerse himself in it. He didn't want the world to see his emotional expression or his tears.

[@foxstarnation6441]

@@yeonjays kyuhyun said himself he couldn't be there . what r u saying?

[@zeleeyah_]

Both the Bob Ross guy and Kyuhun are so good at singing it's ridiculous.

[@nlaras5830]

For me, instead angry, Bob Ross actually more like someone who desperately trying to help someone even when he don't understand fully that person sadness while Kyuhyun sing as someone who have more understanding about the sadness of that person (the difference how they sing the last verse)

[@taronrose8896]

@@nlaras5830 A good point.

[@taronrose8896]

@@zeleeyah_ The Bob Ross masked man is popular ballad singer Han Dong Geun.

[@신현우-m8i]

혜야, 한숨, 숨 은 정말 ... 들을때마다 규현님이 숨쉴때마다 같이 숨쉬어보게 됨... 감정이입해서 들어보게 되고...

[@엥-e3b]

노래 불러준 규현 너무 고마워.... 종현아 너무 보고싶어...

[@uniique3231]

지니 sang Jonghyun's song. And won over his own song. CRIES!!

[@Pos1t1veThinking]

I know! It cracked me up when I saw N.CA performed Kyuhyun's song for 3rd round 😃

[@hanameowww]

I think he thought "WTF this girl want to beat me with my own freaking song??!!! not on my watch! now listen to this..." LOL

[@mirela4386]

@@Pos1t1veThinking omg I didn't know 🤣🤣🤣

[@aw8256]

@@hanameowww if u r referring to the singer who sang At Gwanghwamun in one of the rounds whilst Kyu was still holding the crown, Kyu was so touched the singer honoured him by singing his song that he (Kyu) wanted to give the singer a hug, but the MC stopped him as that may give away Kyu’s identity behind the Genie mask. Just want to set record straight

[@nguyenhanh4270]

I could hear Kyuhyun's sound when he was trying to suppress the crying...

[@규현찾으러수만리]

이기적으로 들릴지 모르겠지만 코로나 터지고 혼자 있는게 정신적으로 타격이 너무 컸어요 평소에도 비관적이고 심하게 내성적인 내가 원래 있던 친구 마저 못 보고 맨날 있는 곳은 집... 공부는 집중이 안돼고 공부하라는 엄마한테 뭐라고 할수도 없고 우울한 생각은 떠나지 않고 살기 싫었던건 물론 한두번도 아니고 제대로된 위로 한 마디 못 들어봤어요 친구한테 메세지 보내면 위로는 커녕 "어 너도 그러니 나도 그래 ㅋ" 하고 넘어가고.... 난 진짜 힘들게 꺼넨 말인데... 만약 위로를 해준다면 진심 같지가 않고... 그래서 요즘 힘들어도 혼자서 끙끙 앓다가 넘어가고 넘어가고... 그런 와중에 규현만의 음색에 빠져 규현씨를 좋아하게 되고 한숨을 부른거 까지 찾았어요 그런데 따듯한 음색에 이런 가사를 부르니까 위로가 되네요 날 위해 쓴거 아닌거 알지만...종현씨가 쓴 곡인거 알지만... 왠지 따듯한 위로 한마디 같네요. 이 노랠 불러준 규현한테 고맙고...종현씨 기억할게요 그리고 감사해요

[@해화-j7r]

우리모두 수고했어요 "쓰담 쓰담" ~^^

[@jasmine21ish]

For everyone who comment they like other version better, just praise your fave at their video. No need to flaunt it here. Everyone has diff taste. If you like other better, watch their video, no need to comment here.

[@peoplecomepeoplego9029]

is there any comment like that? Where? why I did not see it.almost the comments is good comments for Kyu 💙💙

[@qinz.716]

But they need to watch this vid too to see which version they like better right? And people have their rights to share their minds isn't it?

[@SelenaLaVonne]

I like bbn oth tbh

[@러비-h7v]

진짜 지금생각해보면 종현은 정말 완벽했던 사람이였다... 잘생기고 노래잘하고 성격정말 좋고 작사 작곡도 진짜 잘해서 종현이 쓴 곡도 다 내가 제일 좋아하는 정말 위로가 되주는 그런 노래들이고.... 정말.... 형이 있어 내가 지금까지 있어... 내가 정말 형 잊지않을게...

[@SJSJ0404]

노래해줘서 고마워 규현아 좋은노래 만들어줘서 고마워 종현아

[@bonniroller]

Knowing that Kyuhyun is on a higher level singing, is a given. Hearing him sing the song sweet Jonghyun wrote, had to make him feel like a miracle. I was crying throughout, but when he sang "You really did a good job" I'm still sobbing. That was a direct message. It's still heartbreaking. I wasn't even a fan at the time, but, it's so very sad. He was a fragile soul in a cruel wotld. You did well Jonghyun💙

[@cutretyme7064]

슬픈 기억을 이겨내고 부를 수 있었다는 게 대단하다...나였으면 반주만 들어도 다리 풀려서 주저앉고 펑펑 울었을 것 같은데...정말 강한 사람..

[@오정현-g8d]

방구석에서 컴퓨터로만 봐도 소름 돋는데 현장에서 들으면 어땠을까........

[@jglet8307]

너무나 애썼고 자신의 힘겨움을 위로로 또 다른 누군가의 힘겨움에 공감해주고 어루만져줘서 너무나 고맙고 부디 거기선 행복하고 만족스런 하루들을 보내고.. 따뜻한 겨울이 됐으면 좋겠어

[@sidnslqpqy35]

같은 소속사 선배로서 얼마나 소중한 곡이었을까..

[@소심한관종-v8q]

진짜 규현이 한숨 부를 때마다 심장 덜컥한다... 복면 써서 안에 표정이 상상이 안되니까 나은거 같기도 하고 아닌거 같기도 괜히 더 슬프고....

[@LooneysWorldOfficial]

Lee Hi Breathe never gets old how many times has been it sang here? Wow still loving eaxh rendetion! 💖🔥🏆

[@vrg8307]

종현아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ규현 오빠 고마워요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@김진아-f1b]

아니 왜이렇게 잘부름....ㄹㅇ 내가 본 남자가수 중에 얘가 젤 잘부르는것같아(내기준)

[@chelle7180]

I want to see him sing this song without mask so bad 😥

[@fujiisgrlfriend]

search on youtube: kyuhyun honey mallow he recently performed this at a festival

[@yepee2357]

이 노래를 하늘에서 들을 종현도 행복했으면 좋겠고 오늘 하루도 꿋꿋이 버텨준 어딘가에 분명히 숨쉬며 존재하고 있을 그 사람 하나하나 까지 전부 행복했으면 좋겠다...

[@KiyoTaroMori]

Here I go again watching this video in 2022 and it always successfully making my eyes full of tears. For someone who is battling with depression and stressful days, this song always remind me to not give up. It has a really deep meaning for me. Thank you Jonghyun for creating this song, you did well.

[@shayMint7795]

Your doing well as well x

[@halimamahmood4905]

❤

[@gingeryoongisupremacy7826]

right back here again, i come every year, more so around this time of year...11 years ago the person who introduced me to the feeling of happiness is jjong, my first ever idol, i live in ignorance still talking in present tense but i refuse to do otherwise, i lost the person who is the only reason i am able to fight my struggles, i am diagnosed with four mental disorders but above anything my depression has been prominent since the earliest of my childhood that i can remember, i have never felt happy until jjong and yet i lost him to the struggles i am only able to fight because of him.

[@죠르지-q7h]

노래 듣고 한번도 운 적 없었던 제가 규현 한숨 듣고 처음으로 펑펑 울었어요,,, 힘들었던 날 새벽에 들으니까 진짜 눈물이 의지와 상관없이 나오더라고요...노래와 목소리로 위로를 받을 수 있다는 걸 알게 된 노래에요,,

[@성이름-c2r7z]

아니 진짜 규현은...음색도 음색인데 진짜 뭐라해야되지..청량보다는 깔끔? 너무 깨끗하다 진짜...

[@김기복-n2g]

진짜 딱 제가 원하던 음색ㅠㅠㅠ 노래도 깔끔하게하고 고음도 깔끔.... 제가 진짜 듣고싶던 목소리..

[@Daringriwoo]

감정이 담겨 있어서 무게감 있지만 또 그렇다고 무겁지는 않은 느낌 노래의 감정에 잔잔하게 스며들게 되는 그런 목소리....❤

[@해화-j7r]

우리모두 누군가에겐 기적,, 규현. 그 중에 그대를만나 들어보셔요

[@라따뚜이-n5q]

너가 말한것처럼 난 너의 마음을 헤아려 줄 수는 없었지만 ... 난 항상 너 옆에서 응원하는 사람이라고.. 너의 노래와 말 한마디 한마디에 위로와 사랑을 받았던 사람이라고... 말해줄껄 그랬나봐..난 당연히 너가 아는줄 알았어 ... 미안해 말 못해줘서... 그리고 정말 수고했어 사랑해

[@cassie020490]

Everytime I hear this song, I cry and can’t help but to remember Jonghyun.. this song has got more deeper meaning after his death.. and Kyuhyun sang it beautifully giving justice to the song’s message..

[@jeru5222]

Reading your comment make me cry, plus Kyuhyun's voice singing as a background, it really broke my heart

[@ha2il]

미치겠다,.... 진짜 전하려는 진심 그대로 받은 거 같애서 먹먹해짐,, 조규현이 하고싶은말이었구나

[@estellev795]

Kyuhyun is one of the most amazing singers out there and nobody can fight me. It's just plain fact and I really hope that younger generations and new fans should appreciate him more. He deserves to be loved.

[@박수-f5t]

위로 받고 싶을때마다 와야지ㅜㅜ 오늘도 수고했다 나 자신

[@solsol1656]

종현오빠 안녕 잘지내고 있지?? 보고싶네 늦덕이라서 오빠랑 함께 한 시간이 별로 없었어서 너무 아쉬워... 그래도 정말 많이 사랑했어 오랜만에 오빠 노래 듣고싶어서 왔어 규현오빠도 내가 좋아하는 오빠거든.. 오빠 거기에서는 꼭 행복했으면 좋겠어 사랑해

[@maryrosedimaculangan9945]

Genie is so great. He won over his own song. 💙

[@pitchy2490]

everytime I listen this sing it's so saaaddddd like I can't help to remember Jonghyun 💔💔💔 and now Kyu sing it and it make more saaddddd 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔

[@omr6284]

규현 특유의 고음 올라갈 때 힘 있는 목소리가 너무 좋다

[@해화-j7r]

규현 밤편지 들어보셔요

[@kico___]

이 노래만 들으면 왜 이렇게 슬프고 눈물이 나오는지.. 괜찮아,수고했어,내가 안아줄게 라는 등 나를 위로해주고 토닥여주니깐 이 노래가 더 더욱 고맙고 종현이 생각이 많이 나는 거 같다. 정말 수고했어요

[@인절미-h5o]

종현아 어쩜 이런 위로같은 곡을 남겨놓고 갔니.... 네가 힘들 때 한마디라도 건넬 수 있었다면 달라졌을까....

[@ttocareeny]

아무도 잊지않았고 못 잊는 많은 위로가되고 많은 위안을 주는 노래지만 이렇게 다시 한음, 한숨 소중하게, 빛나게....,, 하지만 새롭게 불러줘서 너무 좋네요.... 너무 고마워요 규현!항상 응원하고 잘 보고,듣고 있습니다!!😊

[@pengpeng3906]

...지금도...규현이 한숨과 혜야를 부를때 어떤 마음으로 불렀을지...얼마나 그리워했을지...그 크기가 가늠이 안돼... 그리고 규현이 부른 한숨과 혜야를 들을 때마다 종현이 떠난지 벌써 시간이 이렇게나 지났다는걸 실감하게 되고...괜찮아진 것 같아도 들을 때마다 울컥하게 되고...그러네

[@s9697ek]

복면을 썼기에 부를 수 있던 곡이 아닐까 싶다

[@---xl2kc]

님 말이 맞아요..ㅠㅠ 규현이가 복면 벗고부른거 봤는데 더 슬프더라구요ㅠㅠ

[@우성군-s8m]

도덕책 어떠한 알고리즘의 흐름이 나를 여기로 이끌고 왔는지 나로써는 도저히 헤아릴수 없지만 너무나 감동적인 무대였다고 생각된다. 이하이씨가 골든디스크 무대에서 노래 안하고 울먹일때 "아 또 감성팔이 하는구나... 안사요 안삽니다." 하고 넘기다가 댓글에서 샤이니 종현의 유작이라는 말을 듣고 너무도 울컥했다. 분명 본인도 몹시 힘들었을텐데 그 와중에도 누군가를 위로하는 노래를 만들었다는 게 너무 슬프다. 개인적으로 그가 어떤 사람이었는지 잘 알지는 못하지만 분명 너무나 아름다운 사람이었을 것 같다. 너무 일찍 피고 진 당신의 인생은 마치 노래 한숨과도 같았을 거라고 믿습니다.

[@Yana_na_]

김종현 이름만 봐도 눈물난다.. 종현아 오늘도 너의 노래를 듣고 위로받곤 해. 보배같은 종현이 그렇게 일찍 가바렸으니 하늘에선 사라지지 말고 행복한 별이 되길 바랄게. 사랑해 김종현 행복하자