Diet, Nutrition, Metabolic Psychiatry, Brain & Mental Health | Georgia Ede |

[@MindAndMatter]

All M&M content is available on Substack. Podcast, writing, free weekly newsletter: [mindandmatter.substack.com] If you enjoy M&M content and want to provide further support, read this: [mindandmatter.substack.com/p/how-to-support-mind-and-matter?Fsearch%2Fsupport&] Thanks!

[@katgreen4149]

Georgia Ede; one of the best 🥇

[@stephanieschurheck7869]

Oh, God... please...🙏 if only I could download Dr. Ede's knowledge into my brain... 🧠😅 @Mind&Matter Thanks for your valuable questions! 🙌

[@wendyloui1]

This is one of the best discussions about what our bodies require that i have ever heard. Dr. Ede is great!

[@MindAndMatter]

Thank you mindandmatter.substack.com/

[@tootstoyou1]

Such a comprehensive talk! Totally worth everyone’s time.

[@graphicmaterial5947]

I have never met a carnivorous human who didn't care about animal welfare. Have you? We are not angry, we are kind, inclusive, positive and helpful, because we are healthy and FEEL GOOD.

[@Kyarrix]

This is correct. I try to only buy sustainably raised beef, grass-fed, grass finished, treated with kindness and decency. We owe that to animals. They fertilize the fields, they provide food, they have the right to be treated well. I won't buy meat that comes from conventional farms, I won't buy it if it was raised in a concentrated animal feeding operation, in a feedlot. We owe better to animals. For the vegetarians and vegans who think that their way of eating is better for animals, it isn't. Read the great plant-based con by Jayne Buxton as a start. There is no diet where something doesn't die. I don't like that truth, I don't like that reality but it is true. Mass agriculture kills more animals than carnivores do. The carnivore will eat a cow over the course of months. Combines in fields kill thousands of small furry animals and birds everyday. Leveling habitats for monocropping destroys the environment. Most of the carnivores I know are also concerned with animal rights. They want animals to be treated decently, fairly, to be raised with kindness, responsibly. When we feed animals corn and soy they become metabolically sick. We are what we eat, they are what they eat also. The same goes for eggs and dairy, eggs from pasture-raised chickens. Dairy from pasture raised cows. I wish it were possible to eat a healthy diet, I genuinely healthy diet without killing anything. That would make me happiest but it isn't possible and we have to accept that, recognize it and act accordingly. That means eating a primarily carnivore diet for me but doing so responsibly. I won't eat at fast food restaurants, I don't eat processed food, and I spend more money for sustainably raised meat, dairy and eggs. Some might say that's too expensive but it isn't, I don't drink soda, I don't eat snacks, I don't eat five or six times a day, when you break it down buying good quality meat allows us to be healthier and that saves money. For someone who is struggling financially, it's possible to buy ground beef in big packages. When I was in school I struggled to feed myself, I recognize that being able to buy good quality food is not something everyone can do. But everyone can make a decision to eat better. Responding to the other thing you said, I have encountered many ragingly angry vegans and vegetarians, they don't get enough carnitine in their diets, they aren't feeding their brains and as a result frequently have mental health issues. I'm not saying that to be disparaging, it is an unfortunate reality. Almost 2/3 of us cannot make sufficient carnitine. We have to get it from our food.

[@13Pandam]

I’ve watched a lot of videos about nutrition, mental health, Keto/ carnivore lifestyles recently, if I were to choose one that covers everything you need to know in an easy to understand way this one would be it.

[@MindAndMatter]

Thanks! You may enjoy my written content about diet & metabolic health: mindandmatter.substack.com/p/why-are-we-getting-fatter-part-i

[@amanuelgebremesih2170]

Thank you both … it is very kind of you to inform and feed us with this priceless information and knowledge for free 🙏❤️

[@MindAndMatter]

Thanks! You may enjoy my written content as well, which integrates information across different podcast episodes: mindandmatter.substack.com/p/good-carbs-bad-carbs-how-good-is

[@TimGreig]

Great interview. Dr Ede is a gem. Highly recommend her book

[@MindAndMatter]

Thanks! mindandmatter.substack.com/

[@liondiet.healing]

Thank you, I enjoyed listening to this very much. 🌷

[@juliechurchwell3398]

Development of insulin resistance seems very much like how one develops a tolerance to alcohol, or any other drug for that matter. The more often you use it the more it takes for the same effect.

[@MindAndMatter]

Correct: mindandmatter.substack.com/p/good-carbs-bad-carbs-how-good-is

[@dorothybutterfield8428]

Thank you very interesting discussion the doctor was very balanced giving some options for people who are struggling to accept a different diet

[@cthornton523]

I have an uncountable number of TBIs from having a bipolar parent (who also had bipolar parents). High protein and high fat eating has put all my issues into remission, including numerous autoimmune conditions. I figured this out in massage therapist school, happy to see doctors like this & Dr. Chris Palmer figuring it out too. Delighted to hear their successes in this area.

[@LaurieAnnCurry]

Makes evolutionary sense and fits the feast - famine - opportunity evolutionary theory very well

[@LaurieAnnCurry]

Good morning Nick, Georgia and all y’all

[@Justme_here123]

As much as I love animals, I just don't understand why a human body would be able to digest meat if it didn't mean to consume it. My problem lies in the way we are getting that meat... The horrible farms and so on... 😔

[@throrth]

There is no risk of linoleic acid consumption on a carnivore diet! 😎🦋

[@terrirafiq9329]

There is some if you're eating a lot of pork or poultry, as their feed often contains LA and their fat reflects their own diets. Beef is a safer option if that's a primary concern. Some farmers are specifically trying to raise pork and poultry with a better ratio.

[@Fröhlich1985]

Wow Thank you. Best Wishes from Germany ❤

[@MindAndMatter]

Thanks! You may find my writing interesting as well, which integrates information from across podcast episodes: mindandmatter.substack.com/p/good-carbs-bad-carbs-how-good-is

[@andrewdawson5281]

I have a problem with the use of the word "burn" when referring to the process of converting food to energy. Humans are enzymatic chemical factories not combustion engines.

[@MarmaladeINFP]

Some argue that, for those who have enough exposure, they'll get most of their energy from sunlight. We are both enzymatic chemical factories and energy-light systems.

[@TimGreig]

It's a convenient metaphor 😊

[@andrewdawson5281]

@@TimGreig It is a misleading metaphor which reinforces the mistake of believing calories are relevant to metabolism.

[@soriniliescu12]

The amino acids L-tryptophan and L-5-hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP; oxitriptan) are precursors of serotonin and melatonin, while the amino acids L-phenylalanine, L-tyrosine, and L-DOPA (levodopa) are precursors of dopamine, epinephrine (adrenaline), and norepinephrine (noradrenaline)

[@christinethometgoetz465]

Super 👌 thank you 🙏

[@MindAndMatter]

Thanks. You may also like my written content: mindandmatter.substack.com/p/good-carbs-bad-carbs-how-good-is

[@js1mom]

Plants are carbs; there's not an essential carb!

[@D4rkBl4de]

Csrnivore for the win! Ribeyes!

[@rigaleb]

I love tomatoes, of course without pesticides and herbicides, and I've ate tons of them since I was a kid (had a special but simple combo of them along with cheese) especially in the summer and I can just eat tons of them and never had one single symptom. Am I predisposed to brain degeneration, or do I have a certain biome that deals with the toxins?

[@CalumnMcAulay]

Everyone is different… if you have never had any problems with tomatoes then eat tomatoes

[@rigaleb]

@@CalumnMcAulay I know everyones different, I m just trying to understand the underlying mechanism

[@pabeader1941]

You are having symptoms. You just don't know it because you haven't experienced it the other way. If you are happy with where you are, more power to you.

[@carolineboyd6878]

I’m SDA. We get the plant based diet from the Bible. In the Old Testament, the book of Daniel. It’s called the Daniel diet. Also Genesis. But there are many SDA’s who are not vegan or vegetarian. Our focus is just to live as healthy as we can and to help others too, and treat our God-given bodies the as healthy as we can. Having said that, I am not saying being carnivore is not healthy. Just trying to answer the question more appropriately.

[@DWS1023]

Genesis 9:3. Carnivore added.

[@pabeader1941]

The Bible is not to cherry picked. Only following the parts that fit your narrative is no different then lying. You are lying to yourself and using His words to do it. Shame.

[@theskyehiker]

I’m 72. Not diabetic or even pre-diabetic. I have had a hell of a time getting, and staying in, ketosis. I must not be very metabolically flexible.

[@N7eptune]

Have restricted carbohydrates by replacing them with animal fats and continuing to have sufficient protein . 8M carnivore and continuing to do D'Adamo eat for your type, sequential eating, whole foods, one meal per day (OMAD), and Ekadashi fasting .

[@MarmaladeINFP]

If you spent the previous 70 or so years eating a high-carb diet, then it could take a while to regain metabolic health. Or it's possible you'll never reverse all the damage. This might mean you'll have to be more strict in eliminating carbs. Instead of doing merely keto, you could consider ketovore (ketogenic carnivore diet). You might even have to be careful about too much protein at a single meal. Primarily focus on fats with moderate protein and no carbs.

[@CalumnMcAulay]

Why are you doing it ?

[@theskyehiker]

@@CalumnMcAulayA life time of depression.

[@tumbleweeduk7479]

I notice that Dr Georgia’s eyebrows are missing the outside growth! I wonder is this make-up or a thyroid problem?? Thank you for a fascinating conversation and great questions. Namaste 🙏

[@jayros4269]

It looks like she grooms her eyebrows.

[@GlennMarshallnz]

Hi, timestamps would be helpful please.

[@MarmaladeINFP]

Ede is pulling her punches by making a weaker argument. In fact, if an individual is fat-adapted, the brain will use more ketones than glucose. Keep in mind that much of the rest of the body will use even more ketones. And the body will produce enough glucose from fats and amino acids, without eating any carbs at all. Also, it's not only that fetuses and infants are always in ketosis. Dr. Angela Stanton has tested children. Every child she has had as a patient, no matter their diet, has been in ketosis up to the early teen years. Basically, it takes many years of a high-carb diet to cause such metabolic harm that individuals fall out of ketosis.

[@MindAndMatter]

Interesting

[@CalumnMcAulay]

How do you explain cultures that support themselves on carbohydrate rich diets?

[@CalumnMcAulay]

And how do you explain that breast milk an infants primary food intake is mostly carbohydrate? Obviously glucose is a fundamental energy unit throughout our life

[@pabeader1941]

@@CalumnMcAulay They are sick, just hide it well. Mostly they are TOFI. Also, epigenetics does play a part. But in the end, they are sick and may not even know it.

[@pabeader1941]

@@CalumnMcAulay It's not. It's mostly saturated fat. There is some carb because infants need to grow fast. It's the carbs that fatten them and make them ready to survive on their own.

[@amanuelgebremesih2170]

Wow “A half truth is very dangerous iand powerful in this world!”👌…truth and lie😂

[@CalumnMcAulay]

Personally I think it’s best to eat small amounts of carbohydrate especially from honey given how tasty it is. Egg yolk lemon juice honey and inulin powder makes a lovely dessert like mini snack or after dinner treat. Half tsp honey with two egg yolks and a tsp of inulin.. utterly gorgeous treat after a nice steak 😊

[@JeffreyWilliams-dr7qe]

We handle many Burdens and a fair amount very well. Should not have to do this one. More sophisticated and humane meds. Retire all the antipsychotics. Cheeseburgers and Ice Cream. Some fun for a change.

[@Kyarrix]

Respectfully, why do you keep repeating the same questions? She made everything very clear. Nonetheless at the end of the video, you asked her again, "so you're saying don't eat grain and seed oils and carbohydrates? Are you sure?" Yes, we are sure. You do not need to eat any whole grains. You do not need to eat any carbohydrates. Carbohydrates are not a necessary macronutrient. The body makes, through the process of gluconeogenesis, the small amount that your brain needs. We function better on ketones. That doesn't mean everyone has to be in ketosis all the time but vegetables are not necessary. Grains are not necessary. They never have been. Whole grains are less damaging than refined grains but less damaging doesn't mean healthy or necessary. Why didn't you ask her where the dietary myths came from? Ancel Keys and his six countries and later seven countries study. There were really 22 countries but he ignored the data from most of the countries because it didn't fit his hypothesis. The Seventh-Day Adventist Church which is behind a lot of the nutritional guidelines. They believe that meat makes people lustful and that it shouldn't be eaten. Look at the state of our health since the advent of processed food, high carbohydrate diet and our current nutritional guidelines. We went from being primarily lean to 2/3 of us being diabetic or pre-diabetic. Alzheimer's is now also increasingly being referred to as type 3 diabetes, there was almost none of it 100 years ago. When we ate what we are biologically designed to eat we didn't have these problems. Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease didn't exist, now children present with it. We are fatter, sicker, even those of us who are not overweight are metabolically unhealthy. I wish you had asked her more of the right questions rather than repeating the same ones again. You hmphed at something she said as though it were out there or questionable. Why would you think that is appropriate? Then you asked her "where do you think this metabolic psychiatry thing will go?" Why are you being disparaging? She's brilliant, she's saving lives and improving lives and you have barely 9,000 subscribers and you're condescending in her direction? I would have subscribed but that last bit caused me not to. She gave you an interview, you should have treated her with significantly more respect.

[@pabeader1941]

Because he is trying to overcome all the misinformation that his viewers have been subjected to. They hear the falsehoods many times a day so to counteract that he needs the truth to be repeated in different ways and multiple times.

[@Kyarrix]

@@pabeader1941 Okay that's reasonable but what about the last part of my comment? He was borderline disrespectful to her.

[@UnapologeticAhole]

Manage insulin first and foremost.