Dimash "Qaragym-Ai" REACTION & ANALYSIS by Opera Singer/Vocal Coach

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com

[@vilkoskorlich259]

Sorry for making a comment, but I wanted to add that the PIANIST in this performance was also Kenes Duisekeev's student. So he too is grieving, and it can be heard so clearly in his playing. Stunning. I saw a comment on another video for this performance, something like: "Dimash built a monument with this song, only not by his hands". All the many Kazakhs who were personally touched by the loss of this great teacher can see this as their eternal monument for Duisekeev, I hope. Dimash commented on his Instagram when he uploaded the new video: "Maestro Adilzhan Tolykpayev and I sang the song ‘Karagym-ay’ by our teacher, Honoured Worker of Kazakhstan Kenes Duisekeev” - so the performance was emotional for both of them, I think. As a 83 year old father of 2 daughters and son...this brought me to tears. Not the first time with Dimash...and with his passion and sincere quest for vocal expression I will cry again with his songs. What a performance. Of all the songs he has sung, this one hit the hardest. It was raw and vulnerable. Everything he was feeling I felt. No Tricks. No Acrobats vocally. Just a song that needed to be expressed, feelings that needed to be let out. I mean, do you applaud it or just sit and reflect? Had I been in an audience and he sang this, I think at the end I would turn to the person next to me and hug them.

[@osovagabundo1]

I never knew beauty could be this beautiful.

[@sundetzhumanov9745]

Реакция фаната на Димаш Кудайберген 😍 kzbin.info/www/bejne/f6TZooN9drCoa7s

[@kamelea_roze4069]

Hands down the best comment ever

[@Antoniooooooooooooooo]

Dimash or Elizabeth? Both?

[@henrydenner5448]

Awesome comment

[@osovagabundo1]

@@Antoniooooooooooooooo Dimash, Dianna, Angelina, Grace, have all changed the shape of beauty in music. Even Puddles has too

[@ruthmanning105]

Dimash was nervous when he had Maestro Kenes as his Professor at university as he was in awe of him but has said that it became like having a cup of tea with his grandfather! He paid special tribute to him at his graduation. I’m sure that his Professor would love this version of his song. Plymouth UK 🇬🇧

[@Frol551]

Спасибо огромное The Charismatic Voice!!!!!!!!Димаш превосходит себя,я Русский,но слушая Димаша( на казахском) я плачу.Жду Вас!

[@csgomaxvideo7989]

Может сделаете реакции ,👍👍👍

[@ИсламгазиеваМая]

Коп Рахмет сiзге.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

You're welcome! Glad you like the video! Thanks too!

[@davidricks7128]

@@TheCharismaticVoice When you started listening to the tribute version i could see and hear how much it got to you this is beautiful and the best tribute song i have ever heard x

[@FluffysMum]

Interview with Karagym-Ay song composer, Kenes Duisenkeev, pronounced Kenes DoosenkEEv. In 2016, my 70th anniversary was celebrated right here in Astana. It was decided that it would take place in the concert hall Kazakhstan. Then Dimash Kudaibergen came to me and said, "Kenes aga," how do you look at it when I perform the song Karagym-Ay?! In fact, I already invited another singer to perform this song. But I didn't want to disappoint the boy. I thought he was a talented boy who had just gotten to his feet, so I didn't say no, but said, prepare yourself for the performance. In two days, a rehearsal will take place in the concert hall Kazakhstan, on the day of the concert day, you will come and i will hear your performance. Dimash finished performing, I didn't notice when I got up and called Dimash. Come here dear, come here and I hugged him. I hugged him and said, God gave you not only a voice but also a heart and, most importantly, wisdom. I didn't think a young boy who wasn't even 20 could understand the philosophical depth of this song. In fact, he realized all my thoughts on this song. instagram.com/p/CGiDdnCArPA/?igshid=14s02s38e7t1d

[@FretsOnFire]

That must have been a translation error, Dimash had to be 21 or 22 in 2016. But even at 26, many men are still wasting a lot of time with drunken friends, doing stupid things...Dimash must be the deepest 26yo on the planet! 😉

[@FluffysMum]

@@FretsOnFire hi nice to see you again, yes could have been an error, but still he was young to be understanding the complexity of the emotions in this song. Yes Dimash is very deep, very emotional and very wise. He is an old soul, wise beyond his years. He doesn't drink at all, and can't have cold drinks. So when he goes out with his friends he orders a Coke and asks for some hot water in it. He suffers for his art ❤❤❤❤

[@FretsOnFire]

@@FluffysMum Haha...I don't drink it just to avoid the ridiculous amount of sugar! Nothing to do with my art! 😉 Always nice to see you too...yeah, even now at 26 you would never expect such depth from a singer - in fact, I've barely heard it from any singers at any age! So amazing. I was very profoundly affected & influenced by Bruce Lee since childhood, and I often think of Dimash as the Bruce Lee of vocals, because they both completely revolutionized their arts at very young ages. But Bruce was both cocky & somewhat humble at times (cocky can help when you're a fighter, lol), whereas Dimash is completely humble, but somehow still completely confident. Amazing! 😇

[@FretsOnFire]

@@FluffysMum I forgot to say: I'm guessing that in the interview his meaning was more like "a young boy who is barely 20", something like that?

[@FluffysMum]

@@FretsOnFire yes that sounds more likely. Dimash was devastated when his Professor died, he was very close to him. So the grief here is very real, I don't know how he didn't fall apart performing thus song that meant so much to Kenes ❤

[@kaycherry2908]

His heart filled with sorrow, so hard to get his voice out. I started to cry when his first word came out nothing but pure breath for a second just like it is so painful to sing and then his softer voice start singing. I felt his pain inside of my soul. Not many singers can feel into your soul but Dimash does it every time yet I keep listening his musics every day. I love both versions.

[@АскарИщанов-ч2и]

Бұкіл жер жүзіне қазақтың өлеңдерін тыңдатып қойған батыр, талант.! 🙏 Аман бол Димаш!

[@ashraff6450]

i'm crying. And i'm a guy. can feel the pain so clearly. thanks Elizabeth for this heart wrenching reaction. maybe for next Dimash reaction, you can react to Okinish.

[@Secretsongs20]

You’re not the only guy crying!

[@ashraff6450]

@@Secretsongs20 yepppp definitely ❤️😥

[@FretsOnFire]

@@Secretsongs20 Yep, me too! 😥

[@ЕленаШумкова-щ3ц]

Благодарю! Это моя любимая песня! До слез пробирает! Димаш браво!

[@primavera5451]

Здравствуйте, Элизабет. Люблю смотреть и слушать ваши реакции на Димаша. Вы большой профессионал в своей области. Эмоции на лице отражают ваше душевное состояние, вашу искренность. Первое выступление Димаша с песней " Карагым-ай" было на творческом концерте, посвященное 70-летию композитора Кенеса Дуйсекеева в 2016 году. Когда Дуйсекеев узнал, что эту песню будет исполнять молодой парень, он засомневался, сможет ли он передать все эмоции, заложенные в ней. Ведь её по замыслу исполняет зрелый уже человек, который выдаёт свою дочь замуж. Но 22-х летний парень спел её так, что композитор прослезился от переполнявших его чувств. Второе исполнение этой замечательной песни Димаш посвятил памяти Кенеса Дуйсекеева, который ушёл из жизни в июле этого года, в возрасте 74 лет. Здесь Димаш исполняет её с бОльшим трагизмом. Спасибо вам за реакцию, удачи во всех начинаниях, здоровья вашей семье и процветания вашему каналу. С приветом из Алматы, Казахстан.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Thank you Prima Vera!

[@mgenius630]

Спасибо Элизабет, за очень внимательную и сентиментальную оценку выступления Димаша. Если первое исполнение более жизнерадостное не вкусившее боль утраты и смерти близкого, нежную любовь и тревогу отца к дочери. То последнее исполнение Димаш вложил всю трагедию жизни человека. суть песни мы гости в этом бренном мире, все что мы любим, покидает нас и сами мы покидаем эту земную жизнь, утрата учит нас ценить близких, каждое мгновение. Суета, заботы, человек отвлечен и беспечен от самого главного, это подготовка возращение к Единому Создателю всего и вся.

[@jonrazon7379]

Thank you for your sincere analysis and review...the landscape of Dimash reviews is wrought with insincerity meant for subscriptions. As a 54 year old father of 2 daughters...this brought me to tears. Not the first time with Dimash...and with his passion and sincere quest for vocal expression I will cry again with his songs. Keep up the good work...

[@САРАСАРА-э9ш]

Как я люблю эту песню в исполнении нашего Ангела💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕спасибо дорогая Элизабет❤🌹

[@Al_8519]

"Жабала жабала" )

[@Snarky_Tart]

Sorry for making a second comment, but I wanted to add that the pianist in this performance was also Kenes Duisekeev's student. So he too is grieving, and it can be heard so clearly in his playing. Stunning. I saw a comment on another video for this performance, something like: "Dimash built a monument with this song, only not by his hands". All the many Kazakhs who were personally touched by the loss of this great teacher can see this as their eternal monument for Duisekeev, I hope.

[@aisera1986]

'I have erected a monument for myself, without hands' are lines of the greatest russian poet Alexandr Pushkin. Everyone who speaks Russian knows his poetry and his work is part of every day language.

[@ТамараТокарева-к3ы]

Элизабет, спасибо за ваши эмоции. Вы настоящая!!!!!!!!!!

[@docdurdin]

This was crushing for Dimash, a eulogy for a much-beloved mentor. Dimash, a first born son was raised by his grandparents who instilled him with passion and love. The elderly are deeply loved in his homeland, not only for their wisdom but the knowledge they bring forward. Thank you so much for the thoughtful care you brought to this story. My work was mostly in the jazz and pop genre, but I got close to the theater and operatic field where the story drives everything. Dimash approaches all of his compositions from that point of view and it shows brightly. This was very different, I say, with tears flowing.

[@LemonSquezzed85]

IMO second version brought Dimash to an exact emotional maturity and heart- felt pain of real loss of his mentor, that his mentor meant to put into song composing it. Song's and personality evoliution at its best.

[@naruto_op_7]

Dimash has put so much emotions to this song..i am telling you his vocal teacher will be veryyyy proud of him from Above🥺

[@rosemarybirrell1580]

Dimash shows such respect and admiration for Kenes Duisenkeev. Dimash reaches into his heart and shares with us the loss. So emotional!!!

[@filipequeiroz9857]

For me this song is a great piece of art musical I cry all time, so emotional, remembering my dear dad. Thank you Dimash for that memories 😢 God bless you 🙏 Excellent reaction 💐 for you

[@ildanoch]

The early version has more love and hope. The more recent is filled with love and heartbreaking grief. It amazes me how Dimash can sing so beautifully while sounding a on the edge of sobbing

[@МаринаМаринина-ш3т]

Вы не представите, как невообразимо красиво звучит эта песня на открытой природе. Голос льется в пространство, уносит с собой всех! Сколько жизни здесь, и как печально прозвучал новый вариант. И Димаш- уже взрослый мужчина, и повод драматичный. И столько страдания в новом звучании.

[@klikakate]

Dear Elizabeth, you had a brilliant idea to compare the two performances of this wonderful song👍 How Dimash has developed over these 4 years is simply unbelievable! In the latter performance, he contained all the pain, longing and hope for a better fate for his beloved Professor... I deeply believe that the Master looked down on his beloved Student, perhaps crying, but also joyful and certainly very proud of him💗 Best regards and I embrace you, Dear Elizabeth, stay safe and God bless you❤️ Kiss 💋 Kate

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

I would like to think his mentor was looking down on him as well.

[@nantampa4922]

I cry every time I hear this song, it’s amazing what a pianist and Dimash touches my soul. Thank you 😊. This is also the saddest I’ve ever seen him so it’s just so sad

[@ТелТел-ж3н]

Заметили как он поёт? Пианино практически не играет, а он так поёт музыка сама исходит от него с первых слов!!! Браво!!!!

[@KitaBelle23]

Elizabeth, I loved this song when I heard it way, way back and was so pleased you did both. I just love his Kazakh music. The recent one made me bawl from the first note out his mouth. It immediately brought to mind my recent loses and I felt like he was singing it for all of us to all the lost 'apples of our eyes'. Your compassion and empathy also makes you a truly wonderful coach, reactor and human. Thank you.

[@k.vn.k]

My beloved, this is what true beauty is. You didn’t even need to dream of being that beautiful. People are only guests in this world, this life is so short. My beloved, while deer's wander in the steppe, who is waiting for you on your path? Why is this sorrow that I feel? Who will be your destiny in the future? My beloved, the life is passing by but life makes no sense without love. All the wealth saved up in your life can never have the same worth as a day of your love. My beloved, your glance awakens the fire of my soul, what a beautiful eyes you have.

[@MrGlad2beme]

Dimash in mourning is heart wrenching. He is so vulnerable in this performance. I just want to hug him and tell him it will get easier. 💜😢

[@Lilka20061990]

I can’t watch this performance without falling apart, and I learned how to control my emotions pretty well. He gets it out of me every time with this

[@israeldiaz-rivera1375]

Even his neck veins are big and red, I never seen this when he sings. He always sing with his instrument really relax, I never seen the push on his neck. Yessss! From the first sentence you can hear and feel the pain in his hart, incredible! Another thing; thank you! For all the work you put in your work. I love that you go deep on this preparation, his feelings, his mint set at the moment of the presentation. You really go deep and it is incredible because we get the felling, what it is happening while his singing. Thanks! Always great show, God bless (I’m not very religious but I think here I could send a bit of a pray for your well being ❤️

[@Love_Lara]

Version from 2020 is another level. I wish he would do more of piano voice type of songs

[@rebeccavandam2834]

I agree the 2020 is at another level

[@manuelabartolini8974]

In the first version he was a kid with a big voice, now ( only 4 years later) he's become a great interpreter with an unbelievable voice.

[@FretsOnFire]

Such deep emotion, even in the earlier version - in the recent one even deeper...Dimash is indescribable!!

[@lynnemartin2291]

I love that you listen to both versions to hear the different interpretations. You always give us marvellous reviews. Dimash never ceases to give me joy. 🤗🤗😘

[@sophiamcl]

Can't wait! I love this performance. It blesses my ears and my soul. Dimash turns pain and sorrow into transcendent beauty.

[@littlecricket3140]

What a performance and what a reaction. Of all the songs he has sung, this one hit the hardest. It was raw and vulnerable. Everything he was feeling I felt. No tricks. No acrobats vocally. Just a song that needed to be expressed, feelings that needed to be let out. I mean, do you applaud it or just sit and reflect? Had I been in an audience and he sang this, I think at the end I would turn to the person next to me and hug them.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

It was really difficult to hold my tears back. I sat in contemplation for a bit after filming, then watched again for more context.

[@VisionStance]

Elizabeth, this so far is your most heart felt reaction to "Dimash" I have seen. To say I am a Fan is an understatement. I am moved at the depth of your soulful evaluation and your true emotion. You're beautiful to the core. Thank you!

[@Brazahall]

Dear Elizabeth, I don't know how you can do it, but you always make the sadder songs that Dimash sings, touch even deeper in my soul after your reactions... It happened with "Qairam Elim", and now again with "Qaragym-Ai". I ended seeing this video in tears... Dimash is a Special One, no doubt. But so do you. Congratulations!

[@Secretsongs20]

Thanks for comparing the 2 versions, they are so different. I can’t stop crying. During these times of pandemic, deaths, and isolation of our elders, Dimash’s angelic voice heals our pain. What a wonderful hommage to his mentor. God bless his kind and pure soul.

[@rebeccavandam2834]

What an aching heart! Thank you so much for bringing this song to us. It seems like Dimash’s last 2 releases are expressing his sorrows, both personally and universally. I wonder how the loss of a live audience is affecting him? It has not hurt the quality of his singing but has taken him somewhere else.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Thank you for suggesting this double reaction, Rebecca!!

[@ViviZafir]

I think he's missing the stage and performing for a live audience very much, he was born to be there.😢 It's also showing in quite a few of his instagram posts. instagram.com/p/CG4ww4rHOHp/?igshid=lgys2fmqwpf9

[@V_S_-tj9bq]

song of my youth! Thank you very much for your reaction! Hello from Kazakhstan!

[@shamyrkvin6431]

That was Absolutely Beautiful. Powerful song Dimash’s voice is so Beautiful, Powerful AMAZING!!!! Thanks

[@hellotomka]

The creator formed a miracle, he Dimash . It is not possible to keep silent without tears, Beautiful , I LOVE IT !!!

[@mariaacosta6821]

I love you Elizabeth! Besides being a great opera singer, you are a sensitive human being and I can tell you have a great heart! I’m simply a Dear and love Dimash so much that I couldn’t live without him any more! Thanks for your heartfelt reaction. From Oklahoma 🍃🌸💜🌸🍃

[@veronikam8161]

Thank you for reaction. I thought nothing will make me cry more than Daybreak, and now this? So much pain, and I dont even know the words. This is old black and white movies material. I am transported into 1920 with this.

[@sabineluhs8919]

I am excited. Since he released the song I listened to it over and over. It’s really hard to get your feelings together with him singing in your soul...........

[@BelleNewman]

Dimash commented on his Instagram when he uploaded the new video: "Maestro Adilzhan Tolykpayev and I sang the song ‘Karagym-ay’ by our teacher, Honoured Worker of Kazakhstan Kenes Duisekeev” - so the performance was emotional for both of them, I think.

[@taniam.749]

Beautiful song that touches your soul over and over again. The lyrics are very nice. Thank you for the reaction to Dimash 😊

[@rafaelgililov4622]

Потрясающе - искренний , душевный , но и профессиональный комментарий , спасибо , Лизочка Жарова !

[@aurixho2278]

Dimash has sense of midas touch that brings back life's to yesteryear- golden song with a pure and heartfelt rendering to perfection ever not seen before.. Bravo Dimash.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Midas touch. I like that analogy!

[@jossfan]

How beautiful, how utterly, totally beautiful is this 2020 version. The earlier one is very lovely, but this one is so full of pain and devastation and yearning and deep, deep sadness. And such a beautiful reaction dear Elizabeth, so in tune not just with the technical aspects, but also with the emotional strength and truth of this performance - thank you!

[@ГульнараБайжуменова-п5я]

Когда слушаю эту песню,всегда плачу! Большое Вам спасибо за такую реакцию!

[@tsumi5854]

Massive thanks to Elizabeth for doing this double reaction. I’ve been seeing your reactions and analysis of Dimash since the start of the pandemic and you’ve given us something to look forward to every week.

[@Tica..77]

Bravo 👏Ty 4 a beautiful reaction 💕 FYI... the Pianist on the recent version was also a student of; Kenes Duisekeev. Love that ur always so prepared on facts/background before ur analysis. ✌🏼❤️ - 🇺🇸Dear

[@OnMyWay1968]

The song makes me cry. It's extremely emotional and deeply touches me.

[@diassmagulov8818]

Здравствуйте Элизабет я вас обожаю.❤❤❤

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Thanks so much, Dias Smagulov. This is such a sweet comment!

[@dyaneleblanc6447]

As I mentioned when listening to the new version. Dimash is a pro when singing others sadness and sorrow. This time it’s his sorrow. The loss of his mentor and teacher is very sad for him. You see and feel his hurt.

[@КулашБимурзаева]

ДИМАШ 💖💙💜💛❤💚

[@ГульжанМусина-ю7р]

На сколько трагичнее и осмысленней второе прочтение этой песни!!! Димаш Гений не только вокала, но и Гений- инженер человеческих эмоций и чувств!!!! Блогеру огромный Рахмет!!!! 🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏 Кстати, напишите, как зовут эту чудесную девушку! Заранее благодарю!

[@paveldronov9944]

Элизабет Жарофф.

[@АрсенБастыров]

Зайди на её канал там начиная с 8месяцев назат реакции на димаша

[@ГульжанМусина-ю7р]

Арсен Бастыров Зайду, только почему на ты??? Мы ровесники???

[@ГульжанМусина-ю7р]

Pavel Dronov Спасибо! Привет из Алматы!!!

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Thank you Гульжан Мусина! It means a lot to me that you like the video.

[@kathleendufour9719]

Thank you for your wonderful reaction, Elizabeth. You are always so well prepared and completely enhance our understanding and our appreciation of this wonderful artist that Dimash is.

[@leonaserena11]

I love your reactions! Off course I LOVE Dimash's voice and his out of this world hability to sing.

[@emineorhan5724]

The second performance's feeling gets me everytime i listen to it 😭😭😭 Thank you Elizabeth! Beautiful reaction/analysis again ❤❤❤

Great analysis Elizabeth...ya seem you got sad news that your energy was more reflective, relaxed, less bouncy, excited & brisk. Its life, we all have those days. Still a great review expressive reaction, smiles. Sad story losing a maestro. He slows it down Dimash and gives it more vibrato...he makes it more meloncholic...in the 2nd. Echoes of the love of tired swans and love is lika a dream. Good job. Time for a hubby hug...thanks Elizabeth..look forward to more as always

[@adanalbanez8079]

Thak you teacher for reacting to the two songs....in the first the recently deceased teacher is present👍👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@charlyruth630]

Nadie, nadie jamás en la vida, ningún artista, me ha echo sentir y derramar tantas lágrimas, sentir tanta emoción ,que mi cuerpo se paralice y mi pecho se apriete , al escuchar esta voz, esa interpretación, que aunque soy argentino y no entiendo ni Jota lo que dice, me transmite su sentimiento a mi corazón, es un deleite escuchar y sentirlo , gracias a la música, a Dimash que te encontré, y gracias Elisabeth por enseñarnos y además transmitir lo que también sentís, abrazo enorme, GRACIAS TOTALES.. !🦋🌺❤🎶🎤

[@silviajimenez6514]

Hola me encanta tu comentario, a mi me pasa lo mismo, me gusta mucho las reacciones de ella también las disfruto mucho , soy una fiel admiradora de DiMASH. Hay que apoyarlo en MTV los viernes votamos por el en KZbin y toda la semana a partir del lunes en twittear

[@charlyruth630]

@@silviajimenez6514😊😊😊😊😊

[@evagiacomelli5027]

This song is unique and so struggling itself...Dimash bow to this song he is worshipping almost this song and the story...this attitude so humble from him without any ego presents us a pure song like a gentle white flower ...

[@aldoshaclacud8184]

THANKS A LOT...ELIZABETH,..NICE,..REACTION,...AND SO STUNNING,.AND AMAZING,..PERFORMANSE,..BY DIMASH,..

[@lms1144]

Dimash 😥 Those eyes, the cries, his voice, the pianist who is so in tune with Dimash and the song and the loss, that hopelessly sad exhale at 19:12... Qaraqym ai in itself is so potent in its meaning, that we simply won't find a lovelier or more fitting tribute than the one Dimash gives his teacher . I've watched this (2nd version) countless times and I'm NOT the crying type. I'm NOT. My parrot has a new habit: nibbling at my tears.

[@gabenewell3711]

I know the video is about the song but every time you make a video I can't but think you're actually the most beautiful person I've ever seen in my life. Everything from those gorgeous hair, eyes and smile to your lovely personality. Makes me speechless every time.

[@Tricia_K]

Such a beautiful lady! :)

[@Julia_2]

Wonderful reaction and analysis! I loved that you've made a research on the background of the song and reacted to both performances. The first is beautiful but the latest is absolutely amazing! Only Dimash can top Dimash.

[@pommem8965]

What i really admire about Dimash is not only his crazy vocal abilities it's the way he can convey emotions in any style or language he sings

[@debbienockels7255]

Even more beautiful than the first one; a more powerful performance altogether. Loved your comments/explanations. Greetings from Florida.

[@trudib972]

I have been so looking forward to you reacting to this. Thank you for an impressive reaction!

[@YaNevrNo]

Thank you for comparing these two performances. It's a beautiful, beautiful song.

[@kanatjanussov9005]

Dear Elizabeth! You are a seriously professional. Many people waiting for your reactions, thanks a lot❤️❤️❤️

[@withs2155]

Can I just watch this once without crying? ... Oh Dimash. He is amazing, beyond words. Thanks for your in-depth / sensitive reaction. I love your videos x

[@kirbys1370]

Hi Elizabeth, I Loved both performances and your reaction! I do prefer the newer version as Dimash is more aware of his voice and brings out the emotional connection he had between himself and his former professor and mentor (a sort of requiem). It's sad that Maestro Duisekeev will never hear this completely new interpretation of this performance but I believe he is smiling from Heaven!!! Thank You again, Elizabeth, for another Excellent Reaction & Analysis!!!

[@lbrounen]

Great choice to compare the two versions. It showcase Dimash's growth, not only as a singer, but as a human being as well. Stay healthy and safe!

[@martha-sierra]

I love your reaction and analysis to this song by Dimash. Thank you very much, and a hug from Colombia.

[@ChrisPhoenixMusic]

I cried. I needed it. Grateful for you, and grateful for Dimash.

[@andrecostermans7109]

in this new version he sounds pretty insistent, he is part of the pain and sorrow, what's to say, it's a masterpiece ...

[@sandrak.robbins6305]

Thank you! I love that you are comparing these 2 performances. And the feeling behind the lyrics and the music and then how Dimash sings the song each time. The tribute is so so emotional and beautiful. Also, thank you for doing your research so to tell the multiple stories that make up these performances.

[@NancyBayona-bj2ru]

So emotional! Thank you for your reaction. Dimash completely and always pour his emotion into each song, so that we al feel it with him when he sings. I cry my eyes out and feel the pain in my heart every time I watch Story of One Sky.

[@brittag.pedersen5340]

♥️.... I have nothing to say.... speechless! Dimash says it all through his singing! ♥️🌹🌹🌹

[@janicechen3451]

Dimash is so emotional, I love this song, Dimash is the best one to sing it, thanks for your reaction.

[@hdndndhdbddn9081]

Потрясающе! Именно, потрясающе! Благодарю! За этот огромный труд души!

[@valyatodorova5511]

I'm really glad that you react to the both versions of the song. I love both of them. It's great, beautiful song.

[@joaomateus4386]

Dimash shows the HUMAN BEING he is,letting all his feelings in each note.Your rection is sublime,Thanks.And kisses.I admire you

[@Меломан-ч3ы]

Thank you so much for reaction It's so beautiful and beautiful

[@henrydenner5448]

I always love listening to you, Elizabeth. You are so wonderful as a reactor and as a technical expert. Thank you.

[@valezavillalobos4414]

Uffff .. Hermoso homenaje, que sale del corazón ...te traspasa el alma ... Solo él, el piano y su recuerdo. Gracias. Excelente como siempre.

[@davidcullen6797]

I'm amazed at how Dimash was able to limit both tempo and range yet unleash such a depth of emotion. Like a poet, I suppose: few words, much meaning. The deliberate withholding of his "acrobatics" lets him (and us!) focus on just how much such emotion can draw our focus to one wrenching thought. Superb and sublime. Also, I may not be the only one to notice this, but especially when this performance is compared with the early one, you can see how mature Dimash has become; his face is becoming that of a man. (But not only because he is now 26; the way he shares this grief with us adds a richness to his appearance.)

[@chriskorn2238]

Thank you for this reaction. It`s really a quality by you to always be prepared, knowing about the background and evaluate in the right way. You are the first I saw who compared these two versions of the song. Both versions are beautiful, but the second one is so sad, pure emotion and mourning. He gives a voice to all the people who have experienced a loss. That doesn`t make anything better, but to feel the pain and sorrow, to cry together with Dimash perhaps is taking away a little piece of pain and makes it easier to deal with it. We can go through it togehter.

[@serc13]

Малачина красавица видно в музы́ке разбираетесь некак некоторые морды корчат а сами не в зуб ногой спасибо вам

[@divinaalbay9595]

Oh my! I heard you but I can’t barely see you. Tears kept flowing uncontrollably. The good thing about your reaction is that even though you pause you are not breaking the momentum in fact you are adding to it by explaining how it is done. If there’s a voice when a love one is being lowered to the grave, this is it... so poignantly beautiful, reaping the heart apart. Beautiful reaction as always. I had waited... Dimash is the best voice. No need for high octave, just that finest one full of emotion.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Thank you for this, Divina. I am glad I could add to the experience with Dimash for you. :-)

[@judyannmoreno4398]

Great reaction! Out of most reactors, your’s was the best!! You took the time to search the background of the songs. You felt the joy in the first version , and the pain of loss in Dimash’s performances!! Thank you! Keep safe!!

[@portiaj4374]

Thank you Elizabeth for yet another well done reaction and analyze of the two versions. I sincerely hope Dimash will put this song on his coming album of kazakh songs.

[@tekmepikcha6830]

The growth in four years!

[@gboete]

It is mainly different circumstances imo. But of course there is growth.

[@ishannaram5216]

Beautiful reaction, it is refreshing when i see and feel you express your true feelings, you are an example of goodness and compassion, may it spread to the world, thank you..... here is another from Dimash you may/may not have heard of : kzbin.info/www/bejne/e6DYf6x_aJiVj6c - Quote "Қaratrғai is in itself an original beautiful and tragic poem. An old bird that was once a proud eagle, but now aged and blind with a wounded wing, but with a proud soul, flies across the sky with its last strength. The pain and suffering of the bird is transmitted so spiritually by the music itself. And the voice of Dimash revived not only this folk song, beloved by everyone. Dimash gave a second wind to Karatorgai. Fresh breath of the steppe wind, the coolness of the blue sky, the vastness of the endless steppe. This is what I hear in this song. So tenderly and carefully Dimash sings this song. It's an art to be able to take a song with all your heart, perform it with your heart and bring it to the heart of the audience. Dimash conquered everyone with his clear voice, personality and purity. " I want to flap my wings, Wear coral under the wings. Greetings from childhood, I lost you suddenly. Chorus: Starling, It's too late. Poor thing, you whistle, Do not land. On the other side of the Irtysh there is a deep ravine, The towed silk rope is brown. Landing on a branch of a tree, Singing, blackberry in the morning. Chorus: Starling, It's too late. Poor thing, you whistle, Do not land.

[@aliciaaraya9647]

Bella reacción . Dimash demuestra todo el sentimiento a su mentor hermosa creación ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@kahu54KiOM]

Thank you Elizabeth. I appreciate the research and work you and your team put into the reactions to Dimash. This reaction in particular because it has a deep storyline and significant history for Dimash. You nailed it!!! This is why you are my no.1 reactor and analyst for his music videos.