GR Corolla vs Type-R vs Golf R - Remember Hot Hatches? | Everyday Driver

[@kgthegreatone943]

People left this market because they can't afford it.

[@realjaklap]

Yep, I was just in the market a few weeks ago and all of these are either impossible to find or marked up more than they are worth - I ended up going with a spec’d out Mazda 3 turbo hatch. A “warm” hatch I suppose

[@dre32pitt]

@@realjaklap i would've looked at some older hot hatches.. one of the ST's or a MS3.. The new mazda3 isnt as good as a handler as they went from an independent rearend to a torsion beam to save money..

[@ShattuckEsteban]

So true. Golf R new and Corolla are going for 55k+

[@realjaklap]

@@dre32pitt amenities took priority over raw numbers for me and the new 3 has everything there. Never had an AWD car or a car over 150 HP; torsion beam or not, the car has been a blast for me in the mountains!

[@superchargedsteve3411]

What a joke! They sell like hotcakes, even at markup.

[@boost331]

Remember when cars like this used to be affordable?

[@bearclaw5115]

The Civic Type R never existed in our market. Nor the GR. They did add 5k to the VW this past year. But in large, this kind of performance has never been 'affordable'. And affordable still exists one rung down with the Civic Si, the GR86 and the GTI. I don't think it's fair to complain about the MSRP's but they definitely aren't building enough of these cars!

[@lilripsta911]

yea that was eons ago

[@hallkbrdz]

Yes, back when pickup trucks cost less than cars.

[@boost331]

@@hallkbrdz RIGHT...!! Now you have to pay a premium for that hollow empty box in the back

[@nah3193]

Not exactly that was always more Civic SI, Corolla XRS and GTI

[@DJMotoVlogs]

The dealer mark ups are really ruining it for a lot of ppl. I can afford to buy one but I absolutely refuse to pay +55k for a Civic Type R. Smh

[@Asiansxsymbol]

It's already sold out and has a waiting list anyway. It doesn't need you. 😅

[@06fz1000]

Good for you

[@tizodd6]

DJ MotoVlogs: Same boat. It's the principle of it for me. Can I afford it? Sure. But I just refuse to pay that much for an upgraded Civic.

[@andyzedd3236]

I agree at 50 - 60K I could get an Audi S4, Acura TLX Type S, the whole of point of these cars was supposed to be sport cars at a decent price point, with the added markup I'd rather just spend a little more and get a legit sports luxury.

[@akilh340]

​@@Asiansxsymbolstupid reply

[@robertpeterson2579]

As a Golf R owner, I also factored in how much the car settles down and becomes comfortable in comfort mode with the adjustable shocks- essentially gives you the dynamics of two vehicles in one. After working stressful 12-16 hour shifts, sometimes you just want the car to take care of you when it's not lighting your hair on fire. The AWD was also very important for my geographic location (untreated icy roads with hills)

[@theday2learn]

what year golf R do you own? I wanted a 2023 Golf R, but all the dealerships had a 15k-17k mark up on them...a 63k Golf R? no way

[@robertpeterson2579]

@@theday2learn I have an immaculate '19, last year of the mk7.5. I don't like any of the changes that were made to the mk8

[@tomg.4287]

I agree. I have the mk8 R also and had lots of city miles today through town. I kept switching back to Eco mode to soften everything and make it as comfy as possible. But with a push of a button it can change its personality and be way more playful in ways that my FWD VR6's never could.

[@Evinrudeeee]

Same for me. My mk8 is a great car

[@99Lezard99]

the accountants choice

[@johna.4350]

Can confirm the crazy markups. Went into my local Honda in SF to try and order the FL5 Type R and they quoted $64,999 before tax, title, and registration ($20k markup over MSRP). Had the exact same experience with the FK8. After I failed to get an FK8, I traded my Accord for a Golf R (Got one for $3k UNDER MSRP from Mission Bay VW) and since then bought/sold 3 other new cars from VW. The Type R was my dream car since I was young but the dealer experience killed my interest and my loyalty to the brand.

[@clos2132]

Went to go look at what seemed to be the only mk8 Golf R in Chicago last year and it was also $20k over MSRP...which was also exactly how much they would give me for my Mk7 GTI as a trade in. Ridiculous

[@marvinmurakami8828]

It's amazing that the tiny 3 cylinder engine in the GR Corolla makes the exact hp and torque numbers as an early 90's Nissan 300zx v6 twin turbo.

[@aadriohno]

Best comparison of these 3 cars by far :) Well done folks, would like to see you guys grow to be a bigger channel ! love the summary at the end

[@EverydayDriver]

We've been around longer than most, but never been as successful as we'd like on KZbin. We appreciate you watching, and glad you enjoyed. Thank you!

[@ankursharma8624]

I've been watching Everyday Driver for years and love all the scrutinized details in every video. This channel and Throttle House are the best "Driver Focused" channels on KZbin.

[@sectr8747]

@EverydayDriver You guys are one of the best in the business in real world reviews. Even doing things like pulling retired cars like Evo and Focus RS into current reviews to answer the question on how past fan favorites would fare. Absolutely brilliant!

[@shiftmotorsports9803]

The prices of these pushed me into the arms of a Camaro SS 1LE. Different animal, but great driving experience. Neighborhood kids love hearing the obnoxious exhaust, too!

[@EverydayDriver]

You got a great car!

[@Luke-cb3ly]

These hot hatches are fun, but the 1LE is on a different level of performance. for the money it's an easy choice

[@z32luvr]

So ugly though

[@tizodd6]

Shift Motorsports: I've been seriously looking at the SS as well. The value you get, when compared to these overprices hatchbacks is ridiculous. Performance-wise, the SS is almost on par with the Supra, but thousands less expensive.

[@shiftmotorsports9803]

@tizodd6 You get a lot of car for the money. It's a great canyon carver and track car. Only problem is keeping the speed under an arrest-able number

[@2strokeFORever]

The missing engine cover is because they were recalled for coming loose and potentially causing a fire. thought they would of had plastic covers figured out by now lol

[@jeremyb4493]

I've always removed the covers on my vehicles because I don't want them trapping any amount of heat.

[@phattyhales]

@@jeremyb4493 actually that’s why the covers are there. It helps with dispersing the heat better believe it or not. They aren’t just for hiding wiring.

[@2strokeFORever]

@@phattyhales yea and they are there for noise reduction as well

[@mahmga1]

They can pry my Golf R from my cold dirty hands! Mad respect ya'll showcased these!

[@timhahn7358]

What year golf r? (I've got a 2018)

[@aaronschen9896]

32k for an sti in 2004 is 47k today. The difference to me is that when usdm evo and sti came out they were almost as fast as contemporary sports cars. These cars arnt a whole lot faster 20 years later

[@bluboxes]

And wages haven't really increased meaningfully for a very long time.

[@KurokoShirai]

It depends a lot on what you mean by "faster". If you go and look at C&D's lightning laps chart, you'll find that the FL5 CTR laps VIR faster than cars like 911 S (2013), F-Type R (2021) and M2 Competition (2019), amongst many others...which I feel still qualifies that it's almost as fast (and indeed, faster) than many contemporary sports cars.

[@aaronschen9896]

CTR is the closest but also the highest priced in practice. LL interpretation is tricky, it gets faster every year for similar cars. Tires are getting better but I think they are just getting better drivers as well. Their ctr was on cup 2s, maybe actually one of the slowest car to get cup 2s. The difference in lap time between a 2003 evo and say a 2003 vette or 2003 911 is smaller than the difference between the lap time for a ctr and say a 2023 911 or vette. Maybe its just that sports cars were particularly bad in the early aughts.

[@aaronschen9896]

I guess also, a 2003 evo or sti on cup2s wouldnt be much slower than a ctr. That is my opinion of course without internet racing data to prove

[@SpartanPM4K]

Well, a C6 Corvette has a higher top speed than a C8, which technically means it's faster than the C8, but it's not quicker. The new cars are just more refined.

[@flexinclouds]

Sat in this new type R at the Chicago Auto Show and the interior is basically perfect. Simple, straightforward, & covered in nice quality materials/red suede/red carpet etc. It has great seats, great gauges/infotainment, real hvac buttons and nothing more. And I can admit all that as a die hard GM/Vette/Camaro/Cadillac guy.👍

[@AyySorento]

I love hot hatches. Sadly, it's really only possible to buy a hatch nowadays. Maybe a comparison of the more "basic" hatch models? Like the Civic sport and GTI? Still fun for most at a more reasonable price.

[@DekiaryCarter]

That is a great call out. It would be cool to see someone compare the cheaper versions of these.

[@EverydayDriver]

We drove the GTI vs the Current Civic SI for a video last year. Thanks for watching!

[@stories1984]

​@@EverydayDriver plenty of markup on both GTI and SI, too 😢. Had to shop around for months to eventually get my GTI without markup. Base S trim in 6MT. Roughly in line pricing with the SI.

[@hduncan2587]

Si being limited to a sedan rules out the perks of a hatch, and Toyota... well, we can tell that there's no inbetween the XSE and GR, and they're leagues apart. Sadly the still-pricey Integra is as close to a hot-hatch as Honda Corporation is giving us, and it's still the same problem I have with the Mazda3, Corolla, and Civic: they're basically fastbacks. The GTi is a proper squared off shape without the roof cascading down on bulky items. Apart from that and a Mini Clubman (a regular Mini really seems too small inside for much practicality in that regard), that's the problem with hatches these days.

[@BenTroxell]

This comment doesn’t make any sense. A GTI is a hot hatch lol

[@Oni1975]

The one thing I always come back to for the Golf R is its stealth. I love that my Golf R doesn't look any different from a dull base Golf on the road. That doesn't make it drive faster or better, but it does help me avoid undesired attention. :)

[@neilmcguinness4422]

Couldn't agree me. I love my black Golf 7 R for how it goes under the radar as much as it handles and performs. At 57 years of age my boy racer popping exhaust days are behind me now (they were fun though!).😂😂

[@gaycha6589]

Love my 7.5R for same reasons. But massively prefer my GR Yaris for driving fun.

[@brOblio]

Great review! I’m surprised you guys didn’t mention one of the most endearing, amazing and downright necessary parts of the GR Corolla. The mechanical handbrake. It adds another level of fun that the other two cars can’t access. In the snow, in the wet, in the gravel and in the dry if your mad. Kudos to Toyota for including that even though the new Corollas went to the dark side. I think electronic parking brakes should be illegal.

[@mkei8973]

Hi, from Japan!! What a great editing film. Beautiful!! Especially, I love musics you put into the film. All three cars are definitely great and fun. These cars must make Everyday Driver enthusiasts smile. I think we can say these three are almost at same level but slightly different flavors they have. It depends on you which one you pick. Because of design. Because of running flavor. Because of car brand. There would be no mistake on these three whatever you pick.

[@kblack3970]

I owned a Mazda Demio in Japan and wished I could have brought it to the states! I want the VW but Mazda makes sense.

[@mkei8973]

@@kblack3970 Thanks for the reply!! Yes, I think Mazda2(Demio)is a good car. Tiny, but usable and fun to drive. Maintenance cost is low, too. You have a good car. I’m glad to talk with an Everyday Driver person in Japan!!

[@Brian_the_Red]

Definitely Motortrend TV stuff, but glad it is a YT video and not hampered by the 21 minutes, whatever seconds and 12 frames. Very thorough and enjoyable video. Thanks.

[@EverydayDriver]

Glad you enjoyed. We were glad to have a bit more breathing room here. Thank you very much for watching!

[@KuyaArbee]

YALL MAKE THE BEST CAR CONTENT COMPARISONS!!!! LOVE IT!!!! subbed for years and ya'll make amazing content! keep up the amazing work! LOVE THE HONEST AND REAL REVIEW

[@EverydayDriver]

We greatly appreciate your kind words. Thank you for watching!

[@elliottharley1386]

I would buy a Civic Type R but I have a Hyundai i30N which is so much fun, I can't justify the price increase for the more serious car. You guys hit the nail on it's head! It's all about the fun.

[@VPoje]

I have a Kona N and i 100% agree with you.

[@EliteGi]

I have the previous model CTR, if you have fun with your car do not change it! I do have fun in my Type R which is why I haven't changed it, I know the day I do change it I will regret it and miss it!

[@Quixorion]

i30N is the much better choice than the Civic Type R as a everyday fun hot hatch. I would rather get a i30N with a used Miata than a Civic Type R. You did nothing wrong

[@harrylo2316]

​@@QuixorionThis sort of copium could only come from i30N owners.

[@Quixorion]

@@harrylo2316 I am student. I unfortunately do not own any car yet and also would not own an i30N in real life. I much rather take a ioniq 5N than a i30N. But I LOVE the Miata and would definitely own day own a used one.

[@julio1982]

Great video guys I finally understood the hype behind the GR. Underrated channel and video!!

[@COB86]

Todd and Paul - please never stop with your analogies.

[@EverydayDriver]

Glad they work for you! Thanks for watching!

[@44actual]

Hyundai N cars and the GTI are the last affordable Hot Hatches in the states.

[@dre32pitt]

New, yes.. Go used my friend.. Just get a PPI and rest easy..

[@44actual]

@@dre32pitt yes as far as new cars go. I bought a VN last year and love it.

[@dre32pitt]

@@44actual Hopefully you didnt pay any mark-up.

[@44actual]

@@dre32pitt MSRP. Saw it online one day and picked it up the next.

[@dre32pitt]

@@44actual nice!

[@rongchangwang]

Great content as usual, just wondering if you guys could bring some Todd once said "old retired assassin" like Mitsubishi EVO X and WRX STI VAB into the test for GR Corolla, since with current dealership markup averages 5k to 10k on GR Corolla, a lightly used lightly/unmodified EVO X (as a 2015 EVO X owner mine is unmodified except the 2014 Recaro seats I put in @Paul!, and yes you could still find them even today) and WRX STI might fit the bill in terms of the fun equation (according to Tood in the Focus RS reviewed 7 years ago), and for the car enthusiast, buying used is as likely as purchasing new ones. Please do it, guys! - an old viewer from 2015

[@EverydayDriver]

We actually wanted to bring one of those cars for this video. And we searched. We were unable to find one where the car was close to stock configuration and valid for the comparison. But, thank you for the interest and we appreciate you watching!

[@kylepetersen1915]

I was thinking almost the same thing. I think cars are so expensive today the real value is used. I think the VA WRX also makes a great case for a fun daily. A good one can be found around 25k for those that don't want the harsher ride of the STi which is also at great value around 30k used. I love the AWD sport compact segment and was really excited about the GR Corolla when I heard about it, but immediately moved on when I heard the price (Edit: just looked at a core with performance (both diffs) and cold weather package, it's 37.5k which actually isn't as bad as I thought). Maybe in a few years when the depreciation comes they will be a great value.

[@rongchangwang]

@@EverydayDriver Hi Paul and Todd, thanks for your reply! If you ever need a clean unmodified 2015 (except the Seats swap for 2014 Stock Recaro seats that bring back life! @ Paul) Rally Red EVO X GSR only has 36K miles in Northern/Southern California to shoot, I could lend you the car, because I brought mine 15 after seen all three of EVO X (08 GSR, 13 MR, 15 GSR and EVO vs GTR/STI video) I miss the old day when Todd says “I want buy a EVO”lol! I could DM you guys on instagram.

[@kirkwagner461]

I was thinking much the same. I'd like to finish this video with a base WRX. Sure, you miss 30ish HP. But you also save $10,000. And sure, its not available as a hatch anymore. But how often do you really need to move a washing machine?

[@coldvaper]

I too would love to see an Evo 10 comparison.

[@dyee1979]

Haven't test drove a Civic Type R, but after test driving the GR Corolla and the Golf R, I opted going for the Golf R and bought that over the GR Corolla. The GR was fun, but at the same time I wanted something more refined, as well as with more tech and comfort features that the Golf R has.

[@TheCarCrazyGuy]

I've owned a 2019 MK7.5 Golf R DSG and a 2019 Civic Type R. I would pass on the Toyota but it would be a difficult decision between the Golf and Civic. I would lean towards the Civic. It's more desirable and holds it's resale better.

[@petertran8623]

I ended up buying a Type R and I love it. Lotus and the GR Corolla are also in my sights when I decide to upgrade my Type S and MDX respectively...

[@Digiphex]

It is amazing what the engineers did with basically a grandma 4 door econohatch. What a challenge, and they met it.

[@seannedelko3497]

I love the comparisons and honesty that goes into these reviews. Sometimes it goes beyond spec sheet and it's about the feeling of driving the car

[@EverydayDriver]

Thank you! We appreciate you watching!

[@seannedelko3497]

@@EverydayDriver your welcome. I love your videos. I love driving as well. I currently drive nd2 Miata, but have owned a ta 392 challenger, 15 wrx (terrible car), 11 wrx (amazing car). My wife gives me shit for only getting manuals, but I can't help it.

[@krane15]

You forgot to mention the Golf is also best suited for the cross country. Try that with the Civic or the Corolla and you'll be vibrating for a day after you've reached your destination.

[@dogshmog]

They did say that. It’s the best for actually commuting and sitting in traffic. I have a minivan or a pickup for that. I find every reason I can find to drive the GRC. I put propane tanks in the kids car seats last night for an excuse to rip.

[@nobleman-swerve]

​@@dogshmog I get it but i feel like the point of these cars is exactly because they can be the one to do it all kind of vehicle. Personally if i already had comfortable daily drivers, i wouldn't even be looking at this class of car. Probably would be in some miata which would run circles around these for drivers enjoyment.

[@gregblack3860]

@@nobleman-swerve yes exactly. Could buy 2 slightly used cars that did there intended jobs better. I bought a new 2018 accord sport Manuel for 23,800 new then a loaded New Rf gt in 2019 for 31,000. Buy these used now and you would be happy .

[@sectr8747]

I did just that. Flew in to S Carolina purchased my Type R than drove it back cross country to Colorado. Was an awesome road trip due to how impressive that car was. Has a really good lane keep assist that even steers around curves. Has a Comfort mode for when I just wanted to kick back and relax. The seats where some of the most comfortable I've sat it. Was really a great place to spend behind the wheel for 30 plus hours.

[@audriusbaranauskas6227]

Right now, in Germany, you can go and buy a brand new Type R. They have it in stock. For 69900 euros, that's 76300 USD or 102700 Canadian dollars. Crazy.

[@DudeThedudesky]

You can get one for about 46k euros in Germany. Don't know where you got those prices from

[@xClyptox]

Had a long reply typed up but whats the point, pricing sucks, markups suck, limited production/availability sucks, and with now the new ITS starting atk 52k - Im just going to pickup an older vehicle and fix/build it around myself instead.

[@trapt29]

I chose the WRX, not paying above msrp for any of these.

[@mikeLOL45424]

This is a fantastic comparison! Best comment in the video about the GTI "it's like a butler in a race suite"

[@enriquepliego2322]

I love all three but with there markup I might as well get an M2. Speaking from experience they wanted 50k for a Corolla GR!!no way I got a 2019 m2 with 28k miles for 50k no regrets happy 😊

[@99Lezard99]

bit unfair to compare a used car with a new one tho.

[@neilmcguinness4422]

Considering how overweight and ugly the new 2023 M2 is, your (great looking) car may actually go UP in value @enrique!.😂👍

[@roypeterka]

I used to have an M2 OG and it burned in a wildfire. I couldn’t replace it and bought a ‘21 Type R on a whim. The M2 is a much more fun car and I was thinking of swapping back but I hesitate because of future repair and maintenance costs. I know that’s priced in a little in the used market but it worries me when the price of the Civic Type R is the same as the M2 it makes me wonder.

[@mikemorales4806]

I agree picked up a 19 Audi RS3 for 52k I was going to buy an Acura tlx type s but mark up was crazy! So glad I didn’t the performance of that 5 cylinder Audi is something special 400hp out the box muah 😘 perfect!

[@simonstaub6752]

Almost did this very same thing but found a 7.5 golf r that was perfect. It’s fast enough to hang with just about anything from a stop but I do wish it could slide a little. Congrats on your purchase.

[@maxcurry9667]

I bought a used GS F for the price that these are selling for new. Couldn't be happier other than the lack of a manual transmission.

[@AXELBONNAIRE]

As an owner of a gs350 you have my dream car

[@maxcurry9667]

@@AXELBONNAIRE I've owned 4 other Lexus sedans in the past. The GS F is by far the most fun packaged into an everyday sedan I've ever owned. I absolutely love it. Make sure you somehow pick up a used one. I promise you won't regret it...... unless you try to drive it in the snow like I did. It's worthless in the snow as to be expected.

[@DekiaryCarter]

This is a solid comparison! Thanks for the detailed commentary.

[@InclusiveOrange]

It’s not JUST dealer markups. I’m not paying 40k+ for a Corolla, Civic, or Golf when I can pay 40k for a Mustang (still overpriced) or used M car.

[@upperleftnorthwest4278]

All of these cars should be about 6k cheaper. The CPI inflation states 40k today has the same buying power as 34k pre covid march 2020.

[@brownwhale5518]

The manufacturers need $$$ to make crappy EVs.

[@nobleman-swerve]

Actually by this measure, the VW isn't too bad. 2019, the last model year that the Mk7 Golf R was sold you could climb into one for a now inflation adjusted ~$49.5k. Given the ~$44.7k MSRP of the 2023 R, VW is pricing well below current inflation rates. Type R on the other hand (also baselining 2019) would be ~$44.5k in today's dollars compared to an actual 2023 MSRP of ~$44.7k. So you're being screwed there a bit more, but no worse than just about everything else nowadays. Besides in my eyes, the biggest issue isn't inflation, it's the obscene dealer markups.

[@JohnsArchipelago]

22K for my 2017 GTI with 12K miles in August of 2021, best money I’ve ever spent

[@thirdpedalnirvana]

The longest wheelbase car is the lightest... I know what you guys are feeling. I have an RX-8 and a 300zx. The RX-8 is 200 lb lighter but has a longer wheelbase. Directly off center, when you first start to make the car change direction, the RX-8 feels the most nimble, because it has the least resistance to changing it's direction of motion. But paradoxically, on a switchback, the 300zx feels more nimble, because you've brought the speed down a bit so the momentum trying to keep you moving in the same direction is lessened. This means the dominant factor affecting a sense of nimbleness becomes the rotation of the car; its willingness - not to change the direction in which it is moving - but the direction in which it is pointing. And the shorter wheelbase 300zx feels substantially more nimble in aggressive, tight corners.

[@dogshmog]

Does it still have HICAS?

[@Wind_slash0]

Imagine posting a review of two completely different cars in a video about three specific hot hatches

[@justwatchingffs371]

As a diehard vw fan, I've never wanted a civic more. Something not talked about much in this video is the styling, and Honda absolutely nailed it here.

[@ethanmellein]

BEAUTIFUL cinematography & an excellent in-depth look at these cars. well done fellas!

[@artemlobov4239]

Just got a 2023 manual wrx... corola wasn't even available to try the others are like 20k more lol and love the wrx

[@touringteg]

I enjoyed this video! Nicely done. I wish I could get my hands on an FL5 Civic Type R at MSRP. For now I will keep enjoying my FK8.

[@microsickful]

Same! I love the way the FL5 looks and I love how it is more practical and has more space. But since the mark up is so ridiculous now I will keep enjoying my FK8.

[@Risible1]

Engine cover was missing on the Golf because there was/is a recall on the engine cover

[@basslinefreshdetailing]

Great work! Such amazing options, but IMO The Civic wins it for me, ultimate utility and sportiness in one package!

[@MrRez808]

In Australia it’s illegal to sell anything above manufactures msrp. I wish America had the same for you guys.

[@1337pickle]

Your choice for back ground music was excellent throughout the video. The Honda track you guys used at 29:00 gave me Gran Turismo 1 Dealer BGM vibes.

[@andreasbeaufort3594]

Yeah, the Golf is cool. Yeah, the Corolla is cool. But I want that Honda Civic Type R. It's a Civic, it's turbocharged, it's a Honda... and it's white! I just need it! Thanks for another excellent video, guys!

[@askay747]

Finally! This is what I've been looking for! Thanks guys👍. GR Corolla All Day Everyday!!!

[@Azorthefirst]

But what about the MINI JCW? Last 2 door hatch left in the US but people always seem to forget about it.

[@tedjones403]

Great review - and I think that my take is that the traditional hot hatch is dead. As the average car now costs $50K, these models are actually a lot of car for the money. These cars each offer something different that can appeal to a wide audience of drivers. As a 2022 Golf R owner I have no interest in the GR Corolla, but am curious about the Type-R, my take from the test is that I bought the best car for my needs and I have been delighted with my car. The spec.and performance of the Golf R is amazing and I enjoy the tech. A similarly equipped S3 would cost approx. $10K more and lack the new AWD system fitted to the R and the RS 3. As both testers pointed out the engineers of each company put a lot of work into each model and what you have is a truly high performance cars that appeal to a wide audience. I like each of them, but would always go with the Golf R for my own personal reasons!

[@michelfauteux4500]

Great review with evocative impressions. Total fun to watdh.

[@GeraldPUR]

I drove the previous gen type R and liked it but, saw the corolla and was not impressed..... However after driving it everything chage. It's fun at slow and high speeds. Like a go cart with a/c 😂 nimble and predictable. Now is my daily 😂 fully spec Core edition

[@alexscott9195]

Exactly why I got the GR. Wonderful compare!

[@danny2607]

Definitely my 3 favorite modern cars available but i just cant be a part of the mark up game. I ended up getting the WRX, which should be offered in a hatch. But aside from no hatch its been perfect all in one enthusiast car and got it under msrp on last day of the month

[@douglaskrueger357]

Splitting hairs for sure but the CTR just looks so good. The interior is 100x better than the GR and that’s where you live. Considering how close the call was, I’m taking the Honda.

[@ericvermeulen9853]

It’s been more than 20 years since TOYOTA did something special, and coming from a line of BMWs i must say well done TOYOTA, I actually own a Yaris GR rally now😁😁

[@alexandrasvulfgang1205]

VW has just announced that the MKVIII will be the final generation of the Golf platform.

[@westleyvanzant]

I really wish the US got the hatch version of the Elantra N. That would’ve been the one for me

[@griffinfairchild]

Yeah then the engine blows up after 20k miles and Hyundai fights to not cover it.

[@danlee3939]

@@griffinfairchild you mean the one that had FBO, upgraded turbo, ECU/TCU tune that the Hyundai tech owner lied about being stock? Yeah, that guy gave up when he realized he wasn't fooling Hyundai and just bought a new one.

[@ryanw3907]

We kind of did already with the Veloster N lol, which they cancelled for the Kona N (dear god). But yeah ikr, i30n would be sick to have over here!

[@ellomurz]

I liked this video before watching it, because I know these guys always make good content.

[@EverydayDriver]

Thank you for enjoying what we do!

[@robme3660]

I'd have to go with the Corolla. It's just so raw and cool. Maybe it's just the rare factor.

[@i.d.6492]

I agree. Type R is just looks more like sedan not a hatchback. Golf R is overhyped and overpriced

[@TraceyAllen]

The GR Corolla is the best msrp, at 37k but I’ve called every dealer in my state, 6 year wait list with a non refundable $1000 deposit. I did find one several states away. But double tax, title, plates times 2 put it out of my budget, so a 23 mk8 gti se came home from my local dealer at msrp.

[@disco.lemonade]

It's weird how they can't stop praising the CTR like... They both love it, it's a road killing machine, it's perfect in some ways, yet they pick the Corolla. It's like saying "this is the clear winner by a lot, but and it's so obvious but we're gonna pick other car".

[@aaromon43]

would be thrilled to have any of these vehicles as my new daily but not paying $40-50k for them. subaru dealer near me has a half dozen WRX's you can pickup same day below sticker at sub 30k. they're probably getting my money.

[@wellsbengston4132]

Same conclusion i came to. The GR Corolla is the most fun, and that's why I'll be buying one.

[@Nick-hz2kl]

I’d take the civic R it looks the best and drives great

[@4thManonCross]

Awesome review

[@brentd8462]

Super informative video and a really great job of adding nuanced driving and potential ownership opinions missed in other reviews. Lucky enough to have a GR Corolla in the garage, hope to swap keys with a TypeR owner - what a total package. I never thought I would be back in a Toyota after a string of German cars, but wow I had to support the tremendous engineering work GR and Toyota are offering. The current GolfR feels like a miss vs older generations, but don't count VW out... they'll be back

[@classicarl1795]

All the negatives they're giving about the Golf R are positives to me. I want a practical mature(ish) car for commuting that can have fun too.

[@JacesOwnWorld]

If all prices stayed MSRP, it would be the CTR for me. But since they aren’t, the Golf R is the winner here, despite its horrific interior. Maybe videos like this should be stopped until MSRP prices came back. That in itself skews the stats.

[@SapphireSamC]

Be interesting to hear from you guys how you feel how these cars match up to the awesome 308 Gti 270 byPeugeotSport?

[@trigganometry168]

I called every dealership in California and only found one that is willing to sell at msrp. I’m first on the list for a circuit and hope it shows up soon!

[@jonathanchan5667]

there should be more than 1 dealership in CA that's msrp

[@trigganometry168]

@@jonathanchan5667. Agreed but what can we do? I think it would be even harder to get if it was all sold at msrp.

[@trigganometry168]

I finally got the call this week. Glad it is a 2024 Circuit with the Morizo wheels!

[@jjjpetersen]

Great video! I’d go with the GR Corolla not just for the looks, AWD & power but very much for the reliability. I’ve got a Lexus RC F & I pound on it w/o issue.

[@volkswagenhawk7094]

Golf R with DSG and APR Plus tune is my choice all day. But I’m 35 and can’t see myself in a civic or Corolla. Maybe if I was 25 still… but couldn’t afford any at that age.

[@GeraldPUR]

I'm 49 and got a full spec GR Core and don't regret it.

[@BenTroxell]

This is the way

[@steve8803]

@volkswagenhawk7094 6mt or go home.

[@paulsilva5999]

I'm 56 and bought a GR Corolla Premium (2024)! My daughter has the Corolla Hatch SE (2024), and my other daughter has the Corolla sedan SE (2021).

[@duanen2337]

I'm 44 and I bought a Type R in Championship White and my wife and son LOVE that car. Possibly one of the best cars I've ever driven and I loved in Germany for 3 years and drove Porsches, Lamborghini, and Ferrari. I rented them. Of course, I'm not that rich, lol. But I enjoy the type r the most. Well, actually, I enjoy my motorcycle the most, but that's another story. Lol

[@RobHTech]

This is a thorough review. It's not just the lack of being able to order a Toyota/Honda GR/Type R, but also the markups AND interest rates are ridiculously high, ... like 5%+. I saw Toyota's website advertising rates at 7%. Who the heck wants to pay $200/month in interest? It just doesn't make sense, too, that you can't build/order a Toyota or Honda.

[@kerney3043]

If the pricing was identical, I'd probably go with the Type R....the issue is that the Core model of the GR is the same car for $4-5k less with all three options including the LSDs. The only difference between the Circuit and Core is then cosmetic (roof, wing, hood, seat coverings - seats are the same). After visiting multiple dealerships, I can found GRs for close to MSRP ($1k or so required accessories) while the Type Rs were in the $10k ADM/accessory range making the difference in price $13-14k. I loved driving the Type R, but I'm buying the GR.

[@tifthetif6567]

Never go FWD, trust me...

[@landon5104]

@@tifthetif6567your confused

[@ArtVandelayOfficial]

@@tifthetif6567 Some of the fastest time attack cars are fwd You really have no idea

[@Tlh2092]

I love that these cars exist! Great review

[@EverydayDriver]

Glad you enjoyed. Thanks for watching!

[@andyzedd3236]

It's sad that dealers are going to be the death blow for this segment. Manufactures will say they didn't sell like expected when in reality at MSRP they could print money, but with the added markups it defeats the entire purpose of the turbo hatch segment.

[@hartmutthomas989]

6:10 Ich fahre diesen FK 8 . Und ich muß sagen . Nie hat mich ein Voderradantrieb derart begeistert . Ein wunderbare strammer , radikal Zug an der Vordachse . Eine Herrlichkeit wie das ans Lenkrad geht . Und die Spur steht . Genau genommen steht sie immer so , wie ich es haben will . ich bin sehr sehr glücklich mit diesem Auto .

[@nickbuchanan4179]

Great review, Just put a deposit down on the new FL5 Type R! I expect it soon

[@tr1ckster726]

How much

[@nickbuchanan4179]

@@tr1ckster726 53otd with shipping from the east cost to the west. I knew a few people I pulled strings on.

[@rolan2dr]

I’m shocked you guys picked corolla over type R. I just watched a similar comparison on savageese and totally agree with them. Type R is superior in in car infotaiment, audio quality, driving dynamics. The corolla even had heating issues in their tests.

[@EverydayDriver]

We hope you noticed that we acknowledged many superior things about the Type R. It is a truly impressive car. We’ve also seen the Savagegeese comparison and we love their work. Consider the following: The goal of our work is always to find the car that is the most fun, and we test on back roads. SG is looking for cold hard lap times and engineering for track use. Many times in our 16+ years of doing car comparisons, the one that’s the “superior” car isn’t the most fun to actually drive - and that happened here. We found Carlos Lagos comments on the SG piece quite interesting as he discussed the Corolla for the street. In SGs testing format the CTR is an obvious winner. Depends on what you’re looking for. We hope you’ve driven all of these. Thanks for watching!

[@Loopsrainforest]

My local VW dealer wants a $3000 mark up & have to wait 3-4 months to get one & the Type-R & GR Corolla are unobtainable unless you're willing to wait a year or more or pay insane markups but but I just dropped in at the Hyundai dealership & they have two Elantra N manuals & NO mark up. I had my my heart set on a Golf r but I refuse to pay a markup on any vehicle.

[@couch6180]

golf r’s are plentiful where i live. They go for sticker

[@tr1ckster726]

@@couch6180 where?? I will fly it there.

[@tr1ckster726]

Where??? 3k markup is so cheap compared to what I have been seeing

[@danny2607]

I don’t think I could ever leave this market. Nothing else compares to a Hot Hatch for me no matter what price point

[@yvesmaetz4839]

Excellent, thanks guys. Very nice cinematography (as always)! I'm a bit sad that the Renault Megane RS is no longer existing. That would have been an great contender for the Type R. It has been killed by CO2 Taxes.

[@EverydayDriver]

We’ve driven the Megane a few times on trips to Europe. We wish the would have sold them here!

[@vMaxHeadroom]

Totally agree! Have had two Megane RS's including a Megane RS 250 Cup and just traded it for the Megane RS 280 Cup which is just immense....Sad to see hot hatches go and the latest crop are so over priced. The Type R which is just stellar but well over £40K and forget finding a GR Corolla at a sensible price and with the i30n on the way out and electrifcation on the way in, it is not looking good.

[@markthibault8579]

If Honda only made a Civic Si hatchback with about 225hp. That would be the best of all worlds and would take the fight to the GTI. As for the GRC, it's awesome but a bit too compromised on space if you need the back seats and the cargo area. And, until VW fixes their trainwreck interface, the Mk8 R will not be an option for me.

[@Robt772000]

It's a pity you guys can't get the Megane RS

[@EverydayDriver]

We've driven it on trips to Europe, and it's excellent!

[@Robt772000]

@@EverydayDriver it's my daily driver down here in Australia

[@trigganometry168]

The GR was built by Takumi’s at the Motomachi factory birthplace of the legendary LFA. Type R engine was built by Tyrone that smoked a joint during lunch break at the lazy union factory in Ohio. Plus GR has a proper manual hand brake.

[@slyarsenal]

I test drove the Golf R and Type R on the same day to gain fresh impressionable comparisons between both vehicles. I agree the type r is so much more fun and dynamic even though a front wheel drive. The gearbox is a pleasure to use. The grip from those 265mm tyres and balance of the car pushes you to test the car even more. I think the golf r is a great car with terrific linear power on demand but it felt too sterile for me. The corolla hasn't been released in Australia yet, but for now the type r seems like the car I want to buy even though there is a 20 month wait atm

[@GRCorollas]

Great video! I drove my GR Corolla in those roads and what a blast 🔥 what a car for twisty roads 😮‍💨 so fun!

[@stms4411]

The real hot hatch of the three is the gti - save 300 lbs and a fair bit of $ if you want a “chuckable” car

[@stms4411]

@@layne4376 - I did. So I didn’t constrain myself needlessly to the hot hatch formula and bought a GR86

[@TheFK8Life]

​@STMs new gr86 is decent but slow overall - no backseat or hatch for life and will get clapped on the highway by a CTR with 4 people in it waving goodbye 😂 Although I do appreciate gr86 kids trying to keep up, always good for a laugh 😂

[@stms4411]

@@TheFK8Life so says someone who’s likely not driven either car

[@TheFK8Life]

@@stms4411 I drive the GT86s off the ship at work since the began making them - the GTI has been shit forever and hasn't changed much If you want to have a go with my 640hp Type R lemme know - show me how your tofu delivery car keeps up kid 🤣

[@ryanw3907]

@@TheFK8LifeInsecure af. What happened to the car community

[@travisflowers]

Considering the performance potential and value for money, the Elantra N deserved a slot in this comparison video

[@EverydayDriver]

We just did a video with the Elantra N and the Type R. Thanks for watching!

[@bjshaffer1983]

This is a great comparison and the overall video production was excellent! Been watching you guys for years and they just keep getting better.

[@EverydayDriver]

Thank you for watching! Glad to have you with us!

[@horurbjarnason5448]

Superb analysis! Thank you, gentlemen. Top-notch as always.

[@EverydayDriver]

Thank you for watching!

[@abc162]

Imagine the GR Corolla in a smaller, lighter package, aka the GR Yaris.

[@bearclaw5115]

We can't have that here. We're too fat and nobody buys two doors. Except me!

[@betteheadbettehead4800]

Same! I'd love a gr yaris in the US

[@BlueFL5]

Fun, but not practical and realistic for most buyers.

[@abc162]

@@betteheadbettehead4800 I’d love that too, so the rest of the world can have more parts

[@mnt2391]

Do you think it would be better or more wise to just get the Core with the $1180 Performance package adds the Torsen differentials and red brake calipers?

[@EverydayDriver]

After driving both extensively, we think most people will be better off with the Core and LSDs than chasing the Circuit edition. We hope you can get one! Thanks for watching!

[@mnt2391]

Thank you!

[@Hyros7]

Just checked out a gr going for 15k over ticket like 30 minutes ago lol look so sick in person tho way better than the photos/vids

[@tinhinnh]

cant imagine what the morizo would go for

[@noobmmd9862]

i had a corolla 1992, i had it till last year and quality and driving exprience with that car was really amazing, i can feel how enjoyable can be this new gr corolla

[@saviordream]

What a great video, guys; those roads you were driving on were fantastic! If I had to have only one car, I still think I'd gravitate to something the the GR86, but that's because I find I prefer rear wheel drive. If I was just picking between these 3 here, I would probably agree with both Todd and Paul and choose the GR Corolla. At least in that I'd have the option to make the AWD system rear wheel drive biased. And if, as these two are saying, it's the most outright playful in demeanor, I think that's what I'd gravitate towards. Of course, I say this not having driven (or even seen) any of these cars personally.

[@timhahn7358]

I was considering a gr86 for a long time (even test drove one and LOVED it) but ultimately I went with a mk7.5 Golf R due to my hopes of moving back to my home state of Wisconsin and not wanting to have only rwd in the winters

[@shinn43]

@@timhahn7358 I won't disagree with your decision. I bought the GR86 and did not test drive the MK7.5 or MK8 GTI and I regret it. The GR86 is definitely a fun car but for daily city driving sucks especially driving it in the winter (used Blizzak's WS90). I kept looking at the MK7.5/8 GTI as the best middle ground, AWD, more than enough power, good interior space, and better mileage.

[@rusher38]

Been trying to buy a Mk8 Golf R for the past year. They just don't exist. No dealer lets you order one. I've never even seen one in person.

[@ronnie7061]

Loved the review, but implying auto-tempest is the solution to dealer markup is just laughable.

[@Tastelikeb4c0n]

No point of video if the common enthusiast cant pick these up without paying outrageous markups. As big as the mark ups are there should be a big asterisk to this video.