Everything Wrong With Percy Jackson & The Sea Of Monsters

They made a sequel to that first Percy Jackson movie? Oh well, better go looking for sins either way.
Remember, no movie is without sin. Which movie's sins do YOU want to see recounted?
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Reddit with us: / cinemasins Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasi...

[@tellurian1131]

Other fandoms: Don't sin our movie! YOU ARE THE WORST PERSON ON TEH EARTH BY SINNING THIS!!!!!!! Percy Jackson Fandom: F*ck it!!!! Sin it more!!!! It needs more f*cking sins!!!!

[@rennpang4865]

Passing pedestrian You're goddamn right.

[@probablyinsane3967]

so truuueee

[@thesharkster1718]

Yup

[@mrvael3152]

Passing pedestrian me tho like the movies are just terrible but the books are great

[@bartvandonselaar3372]

you damn right, this movie sucks real bad...

[@lous9013]

Grover asked for 'an extra shot of nectar' when it was clearly stated in the books that if he drank nectar he would explode.

[@colethompson2185]

Alyssa Deason if he drank to much

[@gerardgarcia4005]

He was trying to get out of being in another Percy Jackson movie.

[@QuigleTheGnome]

Alyssa Deason I’m convinced he wanted that cuz he wanted to die

[@kittenperfect6437]

Grover is a satyr. They were made from gods, they are still magic beings. They are technically half human half goat, but he is more like half nymph and half goat. If he like drank a gallon of nectar, he'd burn up, but one shot isn't enough to kill him.

[@Theuglymug]

he wanted to die because of the awful series

[@420roachdoggjr]

The problem about the Percy Jackson: The Lightning Thief Movie 1. It exists 2. It had a sequel

[@luckyducky5213]

Yes I agree

[@jakojii]

And the sequel was absolute sh!t 😭. Why did he say the prophecy meant Thalia?

[@happylittleloser]

GUYS THERE'S GONNA BE ANOTHER MOVIE RICK'S GONNA DIRECT IT

[@parisewellington3664]

The second movie is hot garbage. Why is percys sword the cursed blade and why is kronos fully resurrected and easily subdued and why is luke dead theres just si much wrong

[@CeCeBookworm07]

*It had a sequel that was somehow ten million times worse.*

[@t1ara_tw1g]

Another sin: Clarisse looks more like Thalia than Thalia herself

[@eebertdeebert]

And I oop-

[@theplushiecrew1486]

In the graphic novel Clarisse is a fatass.

[@aarthilogan7652]

@@theplushiecrew1486 no she’s muscular and bulky

[@DummyThiccCheeseCake]

I had a head to toe tingle from this. The kind of tingle that feels like a ripple flowing over your body.

[@willhornsby206]

+30 sins: there wasnt 2 bulls, no Calypso, no genie pig scene, they made the cyclops live on a amusement park, kronos was revived, luke died, ages are still wrong, prophecy was told a hell of a lot earlier. percy's sword is completely wrong, Thalia didnt die like that and it wasn't just three cyclopes it was a horde of monsters. Luke's cruse ship was a yacht and had a manticorn. +100 sins for the directors not even following the source material and adding whatever random bs they wanted.

[@ooohkaay8502]

Every other fandom complaining about their movies: *the percy jackson fandom quietly sobbing in the corner*

[@renkitten1]

so true

[@maggiekeller9975]

The last air bender agrees

[@josiahtatum1018]

The Eragon fandom is drowning in the same boat.

[@maye1421]

I’m so confused. Why?

[@josiahtatum1018]

@@maye1421 the movie is terrible compared to the book. They litteraly have the same characters, and that's about where the similarities stop.

[@nightwolf3329]

If you have read the books the sin count for this movie are waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay higher

[@tarad3287]

+NightWolf if the books mattered this video would be hours long

[@nightwolf3329]

+Tara Dikyikhangsar yep

[@anthonyhevia2423]

+NightWolf to be fair this is CINEMA sins, not book sins. It doesn't matter what happens in the book because this show isn't called book sins

[@sadsdasdasdasddasd]

+NightWolf You know there is no subjunctive perfect, and your sentence is incorrect?

[@lyriccory198]

yes! haha

[@cooperdavis8296]

The writers: lmao lets put Kronos in this movie Everyone: why tho The writers: 👁👄👁

[@0zer018]

They probably realized their mistake and added him just to end it all but that's highly unlikely because if they did realize the mistake then why did they make a sequel?

[@Moneymakingkev]

The writers : *DID I STUTTER*

[@thatonebookworm6385]

Harry Potter fandom: Our movies aren't the best, but at least they're not as bad as theirs. Percy Jackson fandom: Funny. I don't remember us having movies.

[@almm9486]

True

[@TheYoyogelato]

The Last Airbender fandom: *shakes head* (P.S. hoping they make a better Netflix remake since the OG directors are back!) Edit: Spoke too soon 🤦 Bryke were the Avatars of the live adaptation, but they vanished when Netflix attacked :'(

[@brooks3261]

Middle earth fandom: laughs in great movie

[@princezuko9430]

Heart Beats there is no movie in Ba Sing Se here we are safe

[@brooks3261]

David E. Yeah I didn’t care for botfa much. I like desolation of Smaug tho. But overall lotr did better at adaption

[@Axe5197]

Why even bother calling it Percy Jackson if it has nothing to do with the book?

[@teenielimz]

Mr_Diddlez Yeah! They should've called it Peter Johnson and the Quest for the Golden Fleece!

[@sarahramsay4179]

It should be called "Percy Jackson and the Sea Of Crappy Movies Adaptions"

[@greggauci8373]

I was thinking the same thing! EVERYTHING IS WRONG

[@tommyulshtommyuls736]

NO MORE SEQUALS PLEASE!

[@parkermaisterra8532]

Mr_Diddlez why just why can no one do what they did in harry potter and just FOLLOW THE FUCKING BOOK!? It gives you a plot and everything!

[@sheisthemanheisthewoman4016]

First film: Trying to adapt the first book, keeping many themes from the book, still not a good film, but they tried. Second film: Named after the second book, takes random shit from all the others, skips to Kronos being revived, has no tension, then Kronos dies in 5 minutes.

[@filmfangirls9163]

Thats how i feel!

[@yiayfanaphmaufanpopularmmo5035]

First I still can’t tolerate it, but still can see it’s ok... second doesn’t exist.

[@luvbiin5224]

They were tweaked on something when they made the second movie

[@Shadow10201]

With the first movie, i was waiting for Kronos to make a tiny appearance but i was saddened that he didn't. With the second movie, i was just disappointed.

[@just_eco1666]

WRU_North_11 EXACTLY, the movie adaptations are all bad imo though. But it just HURT ME when I saw them, so many scenes left behind, and I haven’t read the books in AGES

[@abbiepgc0315]

sees cinema sins for the Percy Jackson movies “Haha yes those movies suuuck” cinema sins starts insulting things in books *”Hold up”*

[@acua6032]

Exactly my reaction “Haha, he’s gonna point our all the terrible things and I am so ready for it- wait you’re seriously gonna go THERE-“

[@wysp272]

Really it didn’t seem like he read the book

[@thebackyardman2105]

I'm pretty sure he never read the books

[@machonacho8897]

Xz_LLolMaster_zX_YT yeah he probably didn’t

[@wysp272]

Alisa Davis I know but I could tell he didn’t read the book

[@NoOnesBusiness5]

If you're a book lover, the fact that these movies exist should add infinity to the sin tally. Who agrees?

[@calvinlynn8719]

me

[@user-dn2lf4bu9v]

MEEEE

[@VoidKing666]

Me

[@seabass273]

me

[@mako2king609]

Me

[@eh_maybe]

Other fandoms: HOW DARE YOU CINEMA SINS!!212 THE BOOKS EXPLAIN IT. Percy Jackson Fandom: Movie? We don't have a movie.

[@colleenmcindoe6812]

KZbin Binge there's a movie? There's no movie. Doesn't exist.

[@eh_maybe]

Colleen McIndoe I heard rumours of a movie but it turned out to be fake.

[@thegoombrat8198]

Through gritted teeth.

[@eh_maybe]

The Goombrat Extremely gritted teeth

[@undyne973]

*We didn't have a movie. Oh, you mean the disgrace that Octavian made.

[@kendaldawn0512]

The Percy Jackson movies don’t even deserve to be called the Percy Jackson movies. They should be called the Peter Johnson movies, starring Annie Bell Case and Grape Underpants.

[@sethikus7536]

You are amazing

[@ilikestuff846]

BooksForever and also it's directed by Mr. D

[@azelmamortlake4471]

Oh, and Claire Roo makes an appearance in there somewhere, too.

[@fyrefrost1898]

Script by Ares

[@brokenchalk1607]

Directed by Dionysus

[@triciavanandler7285]

Famous quote from Uncle Rick “They should sensor the whole movie, just 2 hours of blank screen.”

[@conserztasfia0078]

Still it would make the money worthy Instead of this trash

[@Moneymakingkev]

It would have been better than the movie

[@VoidKing666]

Yep

[@donthaveitalltogethertm482]

-Grover should be looking for pan -Percy meets Tyson at school -Percy and Annabeth would be 13 -They see the bulls when they get to camp only after getting away from cannibal monsters -They got to the camp in a Taxi where Percy is told where to find Grover BEFORE getting to camp -The prophecy says the half blood has to be 16, not 20 -Percy was told to stay in camp, but Hermes comes to him, not Percy to Hermes -Hermes gives him gummies and the wind. And the snakes where in a phone thing -After that he leaves 3 duffle bags for Tyson, Annabeth and Percy -This was Clarisse's quest -They dont see Luke again again until Miami, not right after getting the fleece. -kronos didnt rise, Luke never even got his hands on the Fleece, Clarisse took it straight to the camp. -When Annabeth fell, she almost died, thats when they use the fleece. -Grover would cover his face with a vail, not a fake eye -It took days for Talia to appear, and when she did, people freaked out and wouldnt even touch her. -Again... they where 13!!!!!!!!!! -They don't mention that Chris and Silena were with Luke until the 4th and 5ft book -Percy wasn't such an annoying pain, all he wanted was to save Grover

[@abhimanyugauba428]

I think you missed the biggest one They exist

[@Jasmine-vs1ux]

Also tyson dies from clarisses (?) boat exploding and didn't they fight a hydra?

[@alec1267]

-Grover created an empathy link between him and Percy and that's how Percy knew that Grover was in trouble -Tantalus was temporarily the activities director after Chiron was suspected of working for Kronos -There were chariot races, not a climbing obstacle course -Iris messages, in this case the camp finds out that Luke is a traitor bc Percy sent a secret Iris message to camp and got Luke to admit he was working for Kronos in front of everyone

[@Onyx-rl7yg]

Another one: The prophecy wasn't supposed to be revealed until book 5

[@FloweringFeilds]

Also I’m pretty sure that if Kronos came back like that Percy Jackson, his friends and Luke would all turn to dust because Kronos showed his true form.

[@rhetoricalproceeds4835]

The sins I noticed most about this movie (revised version since the whole movie is a sin) 1. Movie Annabeth is a super hot model who doesn't do anything but bully Tyson, scream when Percy's in trouble, scream when she's in trouble, and remind everyone at random moments that she's "goddess of wisdoms daughter" 2. Why is there a mechanical bull? 3. WHY did I not see Percy and Tyson blow up the school gym? 4. Grover isn't supposed to be at camp in the first place, he's supposed to be in the sea of monsters (hence Percy's dream in the beginning of the book) 5. Where's Tantalus? 6. WHERES the chariot race? 7. Movie Clarisse is another super hot model who doesn't do anything but bully Percy in her free time 8. MONSTER DONUT SHOP 9. Hermes: now in a UPS uniform 10. WHY DID I NOT SEE PERCY TURN INTO A GUNIEA PIG 11. Why didn't the sirens show up at all?! 12.The whole last part of the movie didn't even happen in the book at all 13. Why does Clarisse have a cell phone?!?! Demigods are not supposed to have phones!! 14. I thought Clarisse was smart enough not to use a phone at all, let alone use one RIGHT NEXT TO A GIANT CYCLOPS Yeah..... revised version

[@tinatran2613]

Amberly Massey the movie isn't supposed to be exactly like the book it gets its ideas from the book

[@rhetoricalproceeds4835]

no no you don't understand the movie has nothing to do with the book at ALL

[@natuarlynerdy915]

Amberly Massey another question: why have they cramed 3 books into 1 moive?

[@doggorolls5156]

the book had a mechanical bull

[@greggregory8624]

Doggorolls Two mechanical bulls in fact.

[@thegoombrat8198]

Does anyone else hate percy Jackson movies but still want percy Jackson movies.

[@Keruso]

only if done right

[@ofawe7856]

I want them to start again in a few years with a new everything

[@garydotdk]

I've read all of the books, and yeah i still want the movies, i like comparing what i imagined while i was reading to the movie.

[@sophieisnotwise6397]

It's in words!

[@kino_verite]

Me sort of

[@reinerbraun6017]

If the movie directors had actually READ the book,the Percy Jackson movie series would still be alive

[@kevinscott3047]

Thank God they're doing a Disney+ series! My boy Percy gonna be done right finally lol

[@DT_95]

@@kevinscott3047 and good thing Rick Riordan is making it

[@JorvikStars]

100/10 yes

[@Kay-winters]

It’s like one person read the books said the vaguest things then was sick for the rest of the making and the rest of the team just had to guess

[@ResaChiic]

the 2nd movie makes me think they read all 5 books or looked up references, then tried to cram/change them all in an attempt to redeem themselves.

[@darthbricksempire3606]

I found a grammatical sin in the title. It’s meant to say “Everything *’s* Wrong With Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters”

[@thismanexudessex6181]

another sin: half-bloods are not allowed to sit at other tables that are not their own

[@mng3941]

Until the Hidden Oracle, that is. But he had a Doctor's note, he's fine.

[@averytiredpieceofmoss9237]

Chanting from a distance: Solangelo Solangelo Solangelo

[@clementcachico5240]

Same goes for their houses, they sleep to a house that is assigned to their respectivve god. Also they made sure to clearly mark the differences between each childrens of each god so we can reckognize them more easily. When you arrive in the camp and your father/mother is unknown, you go to the Hermes house until we know where to place you. If you happen to be a children of Ares for example, you go with them and all the ugly ones. What do you say ? Clarisse isn't ugly af in the movie ? Well that's another mistake the movie made, in the books, Clarysse is described to be exactly liek the other childrens of Ares, ugly, rude, grumpy all the time and wanting to fight with everyone. She's pretty worse than the others because she's a big bully. To sum up: In the books, Clarysse is a violent, nasty, ugly, bullying asshole. In the movie ? Well she's hot and she's only a lil' bit sassy but that's about it. Also she appear straight at book 1 but she pretty much doesn't exist in movie 1.

[@clementcachico5240]

@@beastongaming1866 He. Should. Have. So. This. Movie. Can. Have. Even. More. Sins. Also. You. Need. To. Stop. Commenting. Like. This. It. Doesn't. Make. You. Sound. Smart. Or. Anything. You. Just. Look. Like. An. Arrogant. Prick.

[@semetrixly3143]

"It was so hard to concentrate on what she was saying because everybody in the dining pavilion was stealing glances at us and whispering. And Annabeth was right next to me. I mean, *right* next to me." Favorite quote.

[@mikesullivan3457]

This deserves 50 more sins for not being a thing like the book.

[@XanderPopko]

Mike Sullivan RIFHT

[@borringguy1006]

it actually explained the American central thing in the book

[@xXFanaticShaXx]

Mike Sullivan sadly. This one was closer to the book than the first one

[@leilanyx]

Mike Sullivan It was literally like "Oh, we don't have the budget to make five other movies on this series, so lets cram the last book into the second film, no one will notice!" ... Fuck off, director.

[@kylpyvene]

Mike Sullivan IT NEED 190 000

[@leenaalkhateeb6665]

I love how they just said "F*ck it, we're not making a third movie even though there's a third book" lmfao like-

[@gradypharr1300]

They really couldn't because of the fact that Kronos was killed and the Great Prophecy was spoken. I hate these movies.

[@ivanad.3318]

Producers be like: okay, we're taking book #2, but we give it a little twist. the ending is lame, so let's steal the ending from the last book. Luke is Kronos? nah. Kronos must be this lava looking monster that is like 10m tall and Percy kills him in 5min. Oh what is that? there are books #3 and #4? yeah no. there are not.

[@ibtgb2]

“The water... it healed me” “But not all the way yet!” 😂

[@endmyfuckingsuffering4593]

THE DIRECTOR DIDN'T READ THE FUCKING BOOK. Yeah I know CinemaSins doesn't give a crap about the books and this is an adaptation, but I'm just trying to make this movie look as bad as it is so. They're supposed to be like, 13. Then again, we learned the hard way that 13 year olds can't act. *cough* the last airbender *cough* They were in a cruise ship, not a fucking yacht. Where's Reyna? This movie came out AFTER The Son of Neptune. Why did they leave out the part where they met the goddess lady at the cruise ship? That part was way better than what happens in the movie. And the part with the Sirens. And the pirates. The Sea of Monsters was not a fucking amusement park, it was a beautiful island. Hermes talked to Percy before the quest began. Kronos was not on the island. He was still in Tartarus. Well, at least they finally got Annabeth's hair color right.

[@Aeidon]

Are you sure you mean Reyna? The Son of Neptune is part of the Heroes of Olympus series, not Percy Jackson and the Olympians. Not only that, but as far as I can remember, Reyna wasn't introduced until The Son of Neptune. That, and she's a Roman.

[@TomasTDE]

I agree with everything except Reyna. She has absolutely nothing to do with this, or any other Percy Jackson book/movie. You could argue the Romans, and Jason, retro-actively do since Jason was leading Romans to fight at another place.

[@endmyfuckingsuffering4593]

Have you guys read The Son of Neptune? Reyna said that she and her sister ran away from their abusive father to the same cruise ship, where they lived and worked, until Percy and Annabeth destroyed the place.

[@daviddaugherty2144]

Yumi Not Luke's cruise ship, it was Circe's Island.

[@endmyfuckingsuffering4593]

3DRamen it was circe's cruise ship. i think. i don't really remember.

[@miam7728]

In the movies- Why does Poseidon hate Percy so much? In the books- *Percy is Poseidon’s favorite son (Edit: I’m kinda surprised this many people are still watching this video, at least I’m not alone though.)

[@jejeakle]

Annabeth Chase and that really becomes a thing in the labyrinth

[@marshmellofan7938]

I agree

[@liliajenkins7887]

Samyak Nope, theres tyson too😊

[@iamrealsamyak]

@@liliajenkins7887 sorry but he is the only half human son that's what I meant

[@iamrealsamyak]

And did you say percy Jackson movie exist? Are you Sirius? I have never heard of them

[@lillianpilon8003]

Dude, “You are the only living half-blood child of the big three” -Jason - Nico - Bianca (At the time) Srsly? Edit: - Thalia - Hazel

[@hyena234thekids7]

Later on,Thalia

[@joshuaayodele8269]

True but they did not know about any of them in sea of monsters Surprised that Lupa did not tell Chiron about Jason

[@dubious_potat4587]

Spoilers lol Well in their defence, no one on the greek side ever knew about the Roman camp(except for Chiron but he barely knew anything other than that it existed) (which is where Jason was), Nico is younger than Percy (at least in the books) and Bianca dies (atleast in the books).

[@dubious_potat4587]

@@joshuaayodele8269 In The Lost Hero didn't Chiron say that Lupa didn't share any information and that she was very secretive?

[@elijahbrown6527]

Technically Hazel Levesque as well (although she was kinda dead)

[@uniformbanjo7402]

“He rises” oH ReALy I DidN’t NotIcE

[@pinkgremlin466]

Annabeth: Hey Polyphemus! Polyphemus: Who said that? Annabeth: Nobody! Polyphemus: Nobody huh? I remember you Damn I wish this scene was in the movie but *N N O O O O*

[@thatcrazydaisey3437]

Same!! It was awesome

[@happylittleloser]

I know

[@sophiecoudert155]

I think you mean DAM you wish this scene was in the movie? 😏

[@happylittleloser]

@@sophiecoudert155 I know right I love this

[@jadaanderson7545]

I wish they redid the movies they were so bad

[@eddthehead123]

Ehh. Kronos wasn't betrayed by his children. He ate them. You do not own loyalty to someone who has literally eaten you, regardless of family ties.

[@PHANTOMCOWGIRL]

Well said, advice for life.

[@connorchin-quee9850]

So what I'm hearing is eat my own children?

[@PHANTOMCOWGIRL]

No, what you heard is that if you DO eat your own children, and then they kill you, it isn't betrayal, just eye-for-an-eye.

[@connorchin-quee9850]

WizardOf So in that "hypothetical" situation eating your own children is okay as long as they kill you afterwards?

[@eddthehead123]

In this hypothetical, eating your children is considered a valid method of preventing them from taking over your family business.

[@kalenkeigo]

Every other cinemasins vid: *fans complain about what was wrong, what they thought, etc Percy Jackson fans: *WHERE TO BEGIN*

[@Bagel_in_space]

So true.

[@ah3llfire]

Everything is wrong with this film. It’s called Perry Johnson and the ocean of scary things Can we burn both of the movies?

[@hydrahunter4629]

Yes. Even Rick Riordan didn't want the movies made. That should let producers know that releasing the movies would've been *a stupid fucking move*

[@annikarosas2720]

It’s called The Stew of Beasties

[@einstein6405]

Alternative title: Perry Johansson and the Bermuda Triangle

[@annikarosas2720]

yes, but we await the Percy Jackson TV adaptation. Rick is directing it himself and it has a huge budget so it can’t be worse than this.

[@TM-tb4di]

It's PETER Johnson

[@keepitpgkidsxoxo455]

“Do you know who gave me this sword?” Me: I know you are about to say Chiron but the answer is Zoë Nightshade

[@nicholaswilliams1691]

Heman Reemah Muruganandam HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@nokiaprick774]

Um no Chiron gave him the sword it was just fashioned from Zoe’s hairpin

[@indranilroy1944]

Yes her father

[@percyjackson3678]

Heman Reemah Muruganandam It was a gift from his dad, Poseidon...

[@tristonwalls6692]

@@nokiaprick774 Well Before Zoë dies she tells Percy she glad he has it and could think of no one better to wield it. In a way, she does give it to Percy seeing as the only reason she lost it was because she was betrayed by Hercules.

[@jacobchappue8666]

I cant believe he didn't sin the fact that annabeth tried to open up the canister that holds the power of four wind gods when she is supposed to be one of the smartest and wisest in the movies and the books lol

[@0zer018]

Well, technically all demigods have superhuman strength no matter the parent. Rick Riordan says so in his website but I'll let this one pass

[@jacobchappue8666]

@@0zer018 yeah but I wasn't saying she couldn't open it I was saying it was a dumb thing to open it in a warehouse when she was just told it holds the power of the for wind gods in it I mean she is supposed to be smart and wise I feel like that's something Percy or Tyson would try in that situation not annabeth

[@0zer018]

@@jacobchappue8666 oh that one. At this point it's just irony, for me that scene was funny lmao. A daughter of athena stupid enough to open that bottle in the warehouse

[@lunerblade13]

@@0zer018 actually what was wrong was that that never happened in the books. The winds were never used improperly in the original story. In fact Percy was the one who came to the conclusion to use the winds to make their getaway. And their were only 13 at the time.

[@chelseawexler715]

Does anyone else realize that the Percy Jackson movies aren't included in Cinemasins positive reviews Cinemawins? Coincidence? I think not!

[@dg2388]

It doesn’t deserve any positive treatment

[@thedude8457]

@@dg2388 the first film was fine and the sequel will burn in the depths of tarterous

[@dg2388]

@@thedude8457 the first film I agree it was ehhhhhhhhhhhhh but the second one they read one page of the book and wrote a movie

[@thedude8457]

@@dg2388 don’t be silly They didn’t even read the book

[@dg2388]

@@thedude8457 no they did read one page of it it was the cover

[@joshuaperez-rios7452]

The movie: a lot of sins The books/series: no sins

[@thewittebanebrothers5906]

Theres a lot of sins in the books aswell that Cinemasins asked in sinning these movies.

[@chickennugget4480]

At the end sort of he was like "They left him with his sword?" bruh it magically appears in his pocket at any timw

[@clementcachico5240]

You know this because of the books, the movie never explained it.

[@KintusTM]

@@clementcachico5240 yea, another sin

[@thehalfbloodreport4248]

Yeah they could've gotten a much higher and more accurate sin count if they looked at what was mentioned in the books. Some of these sins annoyed me because they are things that the movie *kinda* took from the books that are explained much better there.

[@salem-01]

Chicken Nugget Ask yourself this: ‘How would he know that?’ Because the movies never explain that

[@stellabjerkered569]

Clément Cachico I never thought about that

[@DrkDragonz66]

Spoilers below... it's funny how Percy and Annabeth almost go insane and die in Tartarus but Luke is perfectly fine after going there and dragging around a giant gold sarcophagus. Nico is like almost insane but Luke shows no signs of that. The plot holes are real!

[@chance1774]

Yeah, but in the Lost Hero books not the Percy Jackson ones

[@alexf2306]

Nezzaraptor Ruffles In the Second Series of books, yes

[@ARandomGuy24]

DrkDragonz66 Well Luke was probably under the protection of Kronos.

[@MrTiger-zc3fp]

ARandomGuy Exactly, the reason the other three lost it was cuase Tartarus wanted them to go crazy, and fail. It or he, wanted Luke to succeed.

[@keenanbartlome8153]

well luke was under the protection of kronos as said above, also he is kinda friends and allies with all the monsters down there

[@not_solstaartz_0ne225]

every other fandom crying over There movie adaptation Percy Jackson Fandom: *Allow us to introduce ourselves*

[@karthikeyanp2022]

The Atla fandom welcomes you , and one more thing we were lucky we just got one but you guys got two " dam " movies 😂😂😂

[@Nanocide_9]

@@karthikeyanp2022 yeah but getting two was worse we got 2x the touture

[@willhornsby206]

correction: Percy jackson fandom: *Burning the movies* Nothing to see here

[@tjrawal]

@@karthikeyanp2022 Make room, make room! Artemis Fowl fandom coming through...

[@JamesMerlaut]

"Now Mr Riordan, we love your books... but we have this awesome idea for a series, so we'd like to name it Percy Jackson and have the characters named after your characters but that's where the similarities will end; their personalities will be 100% different, as will the plot... sound good?"

[@krimsonfel3676]

The first Percy Jackson film COMPLETLY desecrates the book. Nothing, absolutely NOTHING from the book was incorporated into the movie!

[@TheKeyser94]

And the books completely desecrates GREEK MYTHOLOGY.

[@krimsonfel3676]

TheKeyser94 Why?

[@TheKeyser94]

Christopher Kimson Well, let see, you known the myth of Athena? And of course the fact that most of the Greek Myths are in THE FREAKING EUROPE AND NOT IN THE U. S,? How much you would disrespect the traditions and culture of a civilizations that is even older tan the U. S. for the freaking and stupid patriotism and laziness of no puting the myths in their place of origin.

[@krimsonfel3676]

TheKeyser94 But they did say that the gods moved with the west, or the sphere of influence. Greece was the first. Then Rome, and they spent a few centuries in Great Britain. Read the book before you actually make comments like these plz.

[@TheKeyser94]

Christopher Kimson That is bullshit. The stupid writer dont have any respect for the ancient civilization that was Greece? If he had a little of respect for the myth and legends of Greece wouldnt create so bullshit.

[@liongus]

2:37 Also: half blood camp where they train combat with various weapons 24/7 has only p*ssies that run away from danger unless they are main characters.

[@randomfam85_8]

Sharingus -/l/- Umm, are you just referencing the movie or talking about the book as well?

[@liongus]

randomfam85 _ I have read the book a long time ago, that comment was solely by observation. Like in the 1st movie had this military badass always weapon on hand camp with every single fighting training going on, then the bull (The 1st threat that happened to the camp itself, since Hades in the 1st movie just wanted to chat) bashed in through the security EVERY SINGLE ONE of those badass students ran away like little b*tches leaving only the main characters to fight because of the plot.

[@teutonicknight5664]

Sharingus -/l/- a little late but felt like pointing out it was in the summer. almost all of the campers were gone. the rest were running around on fire or laying around wounded majorly. with only clarisse and a few ares cabin kids left still fighting. Percy also had trouble doing fuck all to them.

[@f00dify]

I mean who'd wanna die in a movie that didn't make you a main character? If your a no body than you don't even get a slow mo death theme.

[@mikebrown8050]

Except that it's primarily a SUMMER camp. Most of the campers go home during the school year.

[@francis7336]

My favourite part about our fandom is that we call the movies Peter Johnson, it's genius

[@pika77289]

here after Rick Riordan announced the show on Disney plus. yay!!✌️

[@translucentchaos4296]

Hope the old characters and actors/ actresses are back

[@Drums_of_Liberation]

@@translucentchaos4296 They're way too old. Besides we're trying to fix the series not ruin it more.

[@jaidengatling2641]

@@Drums_of_Liberation I just want the dude who played Percy

[@conserztasfia0078]

@@jaidengatling2641 he can play apollo tho

[@sophiebubbles07]

Is it good

[@cardboardtenshi1008]

If I were Rick Riordan, I would be really mad at the people producing the movies. They shitted all over the series!

[@mckennaseegmiller7675]

He didn't even watch the movie

[@erniechoi1951]

fuck you , son of a bitch

[@cardboardtenshi1008]

Ernie Choi Why me?

[@minayang461]

+Ernie Choi why? It's true

[@supapie1704]

I'm pretty sure he was. In an interview with Rick he said that they completely ignored his complaints that the script was nothing like the book.

[@kimberleydoe17]

The Percy Jackson films should be called the Peter Johnson films

[@averagejoe6617]

Kimberley Doe Hehe. I get it.

[@lightyagamididnothingwrong5419]

Perry Jonas

[@lemongoddess6005]

YES plz

[@londonbrigid3617]

Kimberley Doe this

[@julia637.]

Omg I'm dying

[@atulkochathanilkumar3542]

I’m glad Percy Jackson tv series is coming to Disney + and ignoring the movie ever happened!

[@yooooo8600]

wait really?

[@hyena234thekids7]

Yeah and Rick Riodhan is working on the show as well.

[@e..972]

omg thank you for telling me. i had no idea. is there a release date yet?

[@atulkochathanilkumar3542]

Isabella Mergens so far it’s under pre-production...so so clue but I think it might be out by 2022

[@e..972]

Atul Kochath Anilkumar dang you replied fast. thank you!

[@rachel9349]

Did the producers even read The Sea of Monsters? No.

[@kirbyguy13]

This movie was a slap in the face to the Percy Jackson fans. They probably read a synopsis of the book for which they based the movie off of. The film attempts the humor of the book, but instead, it turns everyone in the movie into complete idiots. The prime example would be Tyson. In the book, Tyson formed a bond with Percy based on how he defended him from the bullies at his school. He didn't just blunder into camp knowing everything to who his father was and hoping for a brother. Another example of poor writing is Annabeth's hate for Tyson/Cyclops. In the book, Annabeth had a valid reason for hating Cyclops due to the fact that one manipulated her and her friends using her father's voice and getting Thalia killed. The movie didn't show any information that Cyclops have the ability to copy voices. The movie also made Annabeth hate Tyson because one of the monsters chasing them happened to be a Cyclops. With this logic, Annabeth should hate all humans too. Another glaring issue is the revealing of Silena to be an enemy RIGHT IN THE SECOND INSTALLMENT OF THE SERIES. And they also made her a stuck up teenage girl at that. In the novel series, we find out of her betrayal in the final book, and it was a very touching moment as well. The fact that they revealed her this early on shows that the producers have failed to grasp the basic foundation of the Percy Jackson series. This movie has many more flaws when compared to the original series which I feel does not have to be put in this comment. If someone wants to ask me of those flaws and my opinion on them, I'll share more of what my opinion is. tl:dr? 0/2 this movie sucked

[@Bailskywalker]

Ddue, the directors just wanted to get the movies over with and do end it here.

[@Bailskywalker]

This movie made me dread reading the books

[@BlueRiging]

Bailskywalker But they're awesome. Stupid fucking movies, ruining the Percy Jackson series, fucking bastards....nerd rage...grumble grumble...nerd rage...

[@testest12344]

The Silena and Ethan Nakamura thing pissed me off so much in this movie.

[@breeishly]

Such a shame they had to ruin a book series with such potential… I LOVED Percy Jackson (still do, just finished the Heroes of Olympus series) and when the movie came out… it was all just… what? Why? WHAT?

[@keanuwheeze2556]

Movie: has Percy complete the prophecy Movie: brings Thalia back to life Movie Percy: Is ThE pRoPhEcY aBoUt HeR?

[@theratking3075]

_Movie?_ *_We have no movie_*

[@the70ssoundlikehell]

these are the peter Johnson movies we're still waiting for the percy jackson movies

[@silvershadow9967]

Glob The Blob We are supposed to have an animated series

[@idkbalvan6303]

They revealed Silena's secret WAY too early. I remember loving the huge plot-twist when Silena reveals she works for Luke. Here they just said it like it's no big deal.

[@matthacker3481]

That was also in like the fifth freaking book lmao

[@rudolphderainbow8625]

The film makers knew that no one would let them make another movie so they screwed it all on both of the movies and went all out at the second movie lmaoo

[@ivanad.3318]

I loved how she regretted it and I cried a little when I read that. My favourite moment in the 5th book is still when Percy gives Hestia Pandora's box

[@matthacker3481]

@@ivanad.3318 Silena, for being a traitor, was handled beautifully in the fifth book imo. Rick did a wonderful job of making me feel bad for her despite what she’d done

[@kyradavis8194]

whatttt! no im only finished up to 4 silena is the spy! ahghtdfhe what

[@stepchicken532john2]

The bull was just really excited about his new job as gardener

[@_8retro_]

Everyone who read the books can answer so many of those questions

[@cheeseclover]

Memeology Yeah but the point of a good adaptation, you wouldn’t need to rely on the books

[@Al_-cf1dj]

Yeah, wich is just emphasising how bad these movies are as adaptations

[@TarynM716]

I knowww. It’s so infuriating

[@darthbricksempire3606]

Memeology No we can barely answer any of these, the movies are stupid

[@constantTVstatic]

The only one we can't answer is why they made a second movie when the first one was too much of a dam mistake for us to want another

[@halfbloodwitch8545]

Peter Johnson and the Olympics. Characters: Peter Johnson. Annabelle Clark. George Underwater. Tyler (cyclop). Claire Lake. Tania Grant.

[@shivani_hayani]

Yeah and in Mark of Athena, Bacchus called Jason John Green. There may an e after green but I ain’t sure 😊

[@burhanuddinmaskawala187]

@@shivani_hayani Bacchus called Heracles- Harry Cleese 😂😂

[@shivani_hayani]

The dam witch thanks for reminding me I’d forgotten about that

[@burhanuddinmaskawala187]

@@shivani_hayani np

[@Xyloh]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Crow-bb3tt]

"You recovered Ares' stolen chariot!" I actually only realized he said that. Plus, that happened around the 5th book. The movies are the worst thing to ever cross the Percy Jackson fandom. Wait... what movies? I'm watching a video for the Perry Johanson movies. (Not even worthy of Peter Johnson.)

[@laikenschmidt361]

This story is actually in Demigod files and its around book 2 or 3's timeline, Percy is in class at school and looks out the window and sees Clarrise, she explains her immortal twin brothers who drives Ares's chariot played a trick on her. She was told by her father to collect it from where he left it and bring it back, Percy sees how scared she is of Ares finding out she lost the chariot, so he helps her ger it back on time. . . Its Demigod Files right?

[@Chatterbox1237]

@@laikenschmidt361 I think

[@a_gal.in.your.basement]

YAS other people keep using the legendary name Peter Johnson

[@JamesMerlaut]

In this comments section, I've seen people say things along the lines of "Harry Potter/Divergent was just as bad" and I'm going to say, as someone who's read all these books, watched all these movies, that Percy Jackson was by leaps and bounds done more dirty than any other series

[@lorddrakon573]

People dare to put the Harry Potter movies in the same tier as the Perry Johnsin movies?

[@JamesMerlaut]

@@lorddrakon573 Here's what was wrong with the HP movies; as my sister said they shouldn't have been movies. It should have been a TV series because they just didn't add a lot of stuff from the books into the movies and onpy the core stuff. But it's vastly better than a series that was basically rewritten entirely.

[@lorddrakon573]

@@JamesMerlaut Very true

[@flamingvaldez1048]

Wasn't Annabeths hair supposed to be bright blonde?

[@Adrian-D-Rivera]

Leo Valdez Yes, but don't complain too much. The hair problem was just minor compared to everything else wrong in this movie. Also, look at the last movie's Annabeth.

[@naomiireka647]

Leo Valdez yeah the description of Annabeth is stormy gray eyes, tan skin, blonde hair. Also Leo is my fav character

[@dweebpatrol]

Leo Valdez you're my second favourite character, I like Nico a bit more, sorry

[@flamingvaldez1048]

Naomi Ireka hehe, whats not to love about him?

[@flamingvaldez1048]

Lord Pain HISSSSSS Nah jk, Nico ish my 2ndish fav. Percy and Nico are both my 2nd. somehow xD

[@pellaw8011]

Read the books, and I guarantee that you will have hmmmmmmmm... about 6,000 sins.

[@somecunt8166]

percytheblueturtle ill hear you out. Such as? (Give me 10)

[@nico-ok1bp]

1. they dont start in camp in the book 2. percy was freinds with tyson before he knew he was a cyclops 3. the scene with kronos did not happen 4. no eletronics for demigods 5. grover gets kidnapped therefore starting the quest into the sea of monsters 6. Dionysus isnt in the secound book 7. kronos doesnt come back till the 4th book atleast in physical form 8. tantulas wasnt in the movie 9. luke didnt have a scar on his face like he was supposed to 10.no blown up gym

[@markpeters8756]

Quackster Mgee J.R Mr. D was in this book. He was present when Percy got Luke to admit he poisoned the tree via Iris Message.

[@yeho8]

talk about an understatement

[@yeho8]

fine then: circe was not in the movie (wich in itself contains like, 10 sins)

[@red_crow_studios3176]

Who’s back after they announced THE NEW DINSEY+ SERIES!!!!

[@jacksonlintemuth5511]

ESKETITTTTTTTT

[@atrain153]

They did a whomst

[@Rougarou99]

And who’s crying after hearing how bad Disney messed up Artemis Fowl?

[@red_crow_studios3176]

Rougarou ?

[@Rougarou99]

@@red_crow_studios3176 Disney recently released an adaptation of Artemis Fowl, which turned out to be horrid. It makes the Percy Jackson movies seem good in comparison.

[@Ellen-iv4iv]

I love how Luke talks about crawling through the depths of Tartarus. Like the movies make Tartarus out to be like some kind of haunted house not literal hell for monsters aha

[@sweetbutsour6310]

movie: Poseidon hates Percy book: Poseidon: YOO PERCY WHATTUP BTW U BE MY FAV SON YEAH BTW GREAT JOB DEFENDING OLYMPUS OK GTG BAIIIII!!!!

[@angelambrosia6397]

YO MY MAIN MAN I GOT YOU THIS SAND DOLLAR BILL HAPPY BIRTHDAY ALSO SAY HI TO YOUR MOM FOR ME

[@janamahmoudadel14]

Guys remember the scene when he was like saying that percy was mistake and percy was like thanks

[@angelambrosia6397]

@@janamahmoudadel14 was that the lightning thief

[@reinerbraun6017]

Dam,you're right

[@jenXOXOXOXO]

Poseidon:YOOOO MY MANN WATTT SUPPPP ALSO BRACE YOURSELFFFFF LOL BYEEEEE

[@The_Real_Frisbee]

So from what I've gotten from the comment section, this movie is to Percy Jackson fans like what Eragon (movie) was to Eragon (book) fans. And if we're going that route, Airbender to Avatar fans. So basically, all complete shit movies based off of really good original series.

[@TheKeyser94]

Only that the Percy Jackson books can be compared with The Last Airbender movie in terms of originality, because the books and this movie shit in the original Greek Myths and totally insult Greece as a culture.

[@mandAbih]

Wait, there are fans of Eragon? Wow. That's a surprise.

[@345tom]

TheKeyser94 Are you still salty about the Romans as well, taking your people and making them into slaves? It's as relevant. The books aren't supposed to be accurate an retelling of the original myths. They are supposed to be influenced by them and use them for plot points. I don't know why people are so upset by the myths being changed- they are myths, not real. The stories themselves probably changed thousands of times in the day.

[@MKGrowing]

Or dbz movie to dbz show fans

[@MKGrowing]

345tom these "myths" were omce a religion. Still are. Calling them fake is the equivlent of callimg god fake or any other religion

[@Persephone_07]

It’s interesting how you mentioned Zeus not being able to just save Thalia. That was actually a point in the book for why Luke distrusted the gods. He felt betrayed that the king of the gods let his own daughter die. But I guess they just cut that really interesting thread about Luke.

[@beegiraffe6251]

Us (the fandom who read the books) running into battle agaisnt the movies: PEANUT BUTTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! thsnk you, Tyson for this wonderfull battle cry

[@danielcooper8749]

What about how Percy has like a million cyclops siblings. Even Polyphemus is Percy's brother. And that they squished the second and fifth book together. Not sure if you mentioned these or if I'm wrong.

[@karma6400]

He's probably never read the books tbh, or both videos would be clocking in at about an hour long...At least, it would if I made it

[@karma6400]

And yes, they left out MAJOR stuff from books 2, 3, 4, AND 5. They even left out the #1 Best Gay Emo and his sister!

[@kittenperfect6437]

@@karma6400 😂😂

[@kittenperfect6437]

Facts

[@ivanad.3318]

@@karma6400 Yeah! how dare they! Also Emo boo and his glow-in-dark boyfriend are the best part of the second series

[@hannahrule5032]

Fans: Hey since the Movie was shit, can we get a T.V show. Rick's Instagram: Hey guys! There is a musical. Apollo what have you done

[@valhund2629]

Hannah17Rule okay but the musical is bomb

[@ceciliacarney6117]

Valerie Hund I don't think PJO needs a musical. It just feels a little desperate. PJO was fine by itself as a book.

[@jasonbelleza6234]

Valerie Hund I like the musical too! The budget looked limited but the actual songs had so much meaning and characterization.

[@billyhenderson2605]

that musical is awesome

[@therandomhat_]

Billy Henderson After musical: That was great and all (better then the movies) but can we still get that TV/Netflix's series?

[@azthebisaster]

One of my 999,999,999,999,999,999 problems with this movie: IN THE BOOKS PERCY DOESN'T FIND OUT ABOUT THE PROPHECY UNTIL BOOK 5

[@sportsfaniguess154]

Why did “good sportsmanship” get a sin. I’m sinning cinema sins for that. And adding 100 sins to this movie for saying it was based in the book.

[@HinakoNamikaze]

Thank you director of the Percy Jackson series adaptation for completely destroying my adorable Tyson's childlike character...among other stuff you guys fucked up.

[@grant0306]

+Lacie Lim i think hes really an adult when he does the stuff witl Ela

[@HinakoNamikaze]

I mean Tyson's personality. Even in the books, he's still an immortal Cyclops with the body of an adult but the mind of a child. It frustrates me when the movie has taken that away from me.

[@calibribody6776]

+Lacie Lim im kinda with you but on a larger scale, the directors of both movies wrecked the books to much the movies are almost nothing like the books. the main characters are the same, the supposed story is the same even though Kronos is supposed to come in another movie NOT THIS ONE!! and my geuss the way they have left it luke won't be infused with Kronos, and kronos will come back as an actual titan and in this one isn't kronos supposed to incinerate anyone around him? and where is Circe, WHERE IS THE REAL FUCKING MYST, THE ENTIRE FUCKING STRUCTURE OF THE BOOKS!!!!! THE REASON TYSON WAS IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL AND WAS NOT SEEN AS A CYCLOPS!!! INSTEAD ITS A FUCKING BOTTLE!!!!!!!!!! they have one more chance to make it up, IF they do not include Nico in the next one which builds a big chunk of HOO which i wanna see after PErcy Jackson movies down. if no Nico and no Atlas and Mount Doom(forgot the name) then they should be sent beyond Tartarus(the directors that is) also sorry for the major rant but this is my honest opinion on the movies.

[@matthewscorner2990]

+caleb herobrine steve I agree. If they leave out Nico and Bianca, then they should just stop making these movies altogether. That is if they decide to make a third movie.

[@adamkalb1]

No wonder there hasn't been a third Percy Jackson movie in 2 years. The books also weren't popular enough so the film makers didn't care.

[@simoneshull7721]

This video should have been 7 seconds long and just have said “Everything. Literally everything is wrong with these movies”

[@aferretnamedsophie3335]

UU

[@zepchir]

fr

[@craftywindow9916]

well that wouldn't be very entertaining would it

[@annikarosas2720]

Then put how many seconds in the movie for the sins

[@lukegiertz9028]

@@annikarosas2720 there are exactly 6360 sins for this movie

[@nadined3576]

5:41 Tyson leaning out the window looking too damn relaxed considering the fact that the taxi might have a car crash any second xD

[@annvu7530]

Everything wrong with the movie: The movie. *Periodt.*

[@ThunderrrStormm]

I remember reading the books, and I saw that they were making a movie based on the second one (never saw the first one). So I said sure, I'll go see it. After watching it, I checked the title to make sure that I was really watching the movie incarnation of the books.

[@HadesNightcore]

This movie was so inaccurate in accordance with the book that I don't even want to know what they would do if they were to make a third movie. You can't fix the book's storyline in the movie anymore.

[@Guppyta16]

I think they make a second percy jackson movie really bad so the fangirl would shut up about the third one... I mean the first percy jackson is actually so good

[@wolfpax181]

***** I don't know if I should be nervous about the third book having Artemis and her Hunters or not. With their track record they're going to either turn them into the Jail-bait Brigade or they're going to be a swarm of loli-wanna-bes.

[@tommymichael4767]

Th Me too me too

[@andrewblain5202]

At least this was better than the first movie.

[@skeltheshapeshifter2697]

I really despise this movie series. The books are awesome, and they have some many epic moments. The fact that the movie didn't make it like the book, and didn't add the things that made the books the Percy Jackson series, really says a lot that they just kinda tried to make their own little Percy Jackson series, and there's really only one for me. I HATE this movie series. When I saw that you were sinning this, I was like, "YEAH!".

[@skeltheshapeshifter2697]

BTW, in the book, Dionysus kept saying their names wrong, just to annoy them, even though he knew their real names. So, that's not the movie's choice, and I'm not sure you should sin that.

[@videogamep9044]

Skel the shapeshifter They've said before that the books don't matter when they sin movies.

[@kacperdabrowski9433]

If they do the same to the Kane Chronicles, I will... well, I don't know what I will do, but I will surely get... angry...

[@FaustianBargainBin]

Kacper Dabrowski Hopefully Rick Riordan will sell the movie rights for those to someone who actually knows what the fuck they are doing, after this shithole. If I ever publish a book and get a movie deal for it, I'm including a clause that says I can revoke the movie rights if they do it wrong.

[@skeltheshapeshifter2697]

YourEvilOverlady That's exactly what I would do! To be honest, when you're in the author's shoes, and someone is asking if they can make a movie off of your book, you kinda don't know what it'll be until it's out. When they say, "We're gonna make a really cool dragon, that's a comic relief character!" the author might think it's a regular dragon with a smarty attitude. But the movie creator might make it like a stupid badly animated dragon while it makes really stupid jokes that make you want to strangle the stupid thing, or for it to go away but it never happens. Like this dragon: 3.bp.blogspot.com/_QPLoqV9VyqI/TJaidGzK1hI/AAAAAAAAAA4/TVrEgEJExbA/s1600/dragonsaregay.png Just imagine it making stupid jokes instead of breathing fire.

[@deepakkudari2348]

I need to answer this question at 12:32. SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!In the books that's called the great prophecy and Percy doesn't get to know about it till 5th book The Last Olympian. But the second book The Sea of Monsters has a different prophecy which goes: You shall sail the iron ship with warriors of bone, You shall find what you seek and make it your own, But despair for your life entombed within stone, And fail without friends, to fly home alone. This prophecy is intended to Clarisse cuz it's her quest officially. I think they got lazy n used the great prophecy instead and they changed the plot to fit the prophecy. So I thought that there wasn't going to be a next movie since it looked like they ended it using the great prophecy and also by "defeating Kronos"( which never happens in the books btw. He's resurrected in the end of the 4th book The Battle of the Labyrinth ). But they resurrected Thalia who's a main character in the next book and stated that the prophecy could've meant Thalia as well. That's Soo wrong a movie contradicting it's own plot. The worst adaptation they could've come up with.

[@lucl8580]

“Dude, what are you doing? Don’t walk on my roof” is the greatest movie quote of all time

[@naomiireka647]

I have to say this, like actually HAVE TO, so Luke can go through Tartaruas (idk how to spell it) perfectly fine and come back sane and in like 2 days as well but Nico the literal SON OF HADES goes through Tartaruas and comes back emotionally and mentally shattered?

[@shadowhunter240]

Naomi Ireka eactly! I call bullshit

[@skyskit7821]

Naomi Ireka soooooooooooo true

[@drecellthealive8912]

Kronos protection? Maybe? Dunno....Nico had to sneak around though, and Tartarus hates hades kids, so.

[@naomiireka647]

HawkEyed Magicienne yeah but still, Annabeth and Percy went through Tartarus and the only reason they survived is because of each other. But yeah I guess it could've been because he was on the monster's side

[@tanyay1073]

Naomi Ireka Ask Uncle Rick

[@alixhudspeth4912]

"I had to crawl through the depths of Tartarus itself" WRONG! Nico and Percy and Annabeth are the only ones who can survive down there. Idk how you got out with the fandom screaming at you, Jake Abel.

[@RF-mc8cx]

E X A C T L Y

[@gerardgarcia4005]

Hold on wait and don’t forget Cleveland... oh god Cleveland Jesus Christ May you have mercy on his soul!!!

[@bzzztbzzzt2428]

And they're traumatised after that

[@darkestlune9580]

Wait wasn't Nico in the 3/4th books? This is the second????

[@andyhd300]

@@darkestlune9580 Well Cronus also first appeared after the 2nd book

[@Hazyla]

Ya know... I was like, “Hey doesn’t the Sea of monsters adaptation have Clarisse and Dionysus? Then it might be a bit better with accuracy...” Then I re-watched the movie. I gave it way to much credit. They both suck.

[@letstalkfiction5187]

The best part about this is that if you read the books, 90% of sins are explained

[@willhornsby206]

just gives it a thousand more sins

[@Chatterbox1237]

@@willhornsby206 for existing I’d give it 1000000000000000000 sins

[@sydneyleonard356]

All of the PJO fandom: EVERYTHING!

[@cambilodeau9794]

Litterally just give these movies infinite sins just for the awful cross over from book to movie

[@justayoutubechannel1756]

Agreed

[@atasha2928]

this movie is probably a fanfiction of the actual books. I don't find the connection.

[@drakeconsumerofsoulsandche5761]

sleepy yoongi it's Mr Ds fanfic. That's why it's so bad and depressing as a fan to watch

[@catfoy8888]

Even Mr. Ds fan fiction would be more accurate

[@drakeconsumerofsoulsandche5761]

cat foy it involves percy getting turned into a dolphin.

[@MoonPatch]

Louise Drake that was in the director's ultimate cut

[@evie1611]

you right

[@mariajosedacunha58]

Me: *reads the title* SIMPLE!!!!!! IT EXISTS!!!!!

[@lydiebug]

For the record: Mr. D, the "comic relief" guy, it's a huge (ish) character in the books and him "forgetting their names" is just him being a dick to all of the half-blood because he really doesn't like children and he's a bitter man.

[@ethancornelius7163]

I'm not much of a stickler for this but seriously there's pretty mach no conection between the movie and book!

[@hirocheeto7795]

It goes somewhat according to the book for the first bit, but then the other bit I want to hurt everyone who though destroying the book was a good idea. Rick Riorden made masterpeices of books and they just spat on them.

[@wannabeiroh4658]

+Nuclear Winter no the beginning is hardly like the beginning of the book this starts with some random weird training thing not them at a SCHOOL WITH MASSIVE GIANTS THROWING FLAMING CANNON BALLS!!!!!!!!

[@hirocheeto7795]

Yes I've read the series, and I've seen a small portion of the movie. So I just made the assumption that it follows a tiny miniscule bit and then stomps on the book every chance it gets.

[@bromson2369]

Mr.Fuzyhat Cornelius it shares the rough setting and the names of the main characters

[@AshDraws]

Excuse me Didn’t Grover try and find pan and got stuck on an island and he made a empathy link and got Percy to come THIS WAS THE PLOT FOR THE BOOK

[@emilyharvison4257]

They screwed up. And almost got killed by the fandom...XD

[@liviecatt]

Yeah well the plot of the movie verson is themed "bullsh*t" soooo

[@hlmanor8579]

And i think we should see the hydra somwere in the movie

[@_StevenAlten]

•Ash Draws• I know I read all the books then watched this movie it is nothing like it the book is way better

[@MoisterChife]

Yep

[@eviehowlett2535]

i love that a lot of the sins mentioned could technically be explained via the book, even though the two are nothing alike

[@sarahhoch]

I was talking about parts of Percy Jackson to a friend and I start talking about how the “nobody scene” and I said it’s a funny part and my friend asked what it that. I asked her what she meant and she said,” well I only watched the movie but it’s pretty similar I’m sure like when Kronos comes back.” She got lucky she didn’t “fall” off a cliff the next day.

[@luckyducky5213]

Sarah_playz the Nobody part and the dam part in the third book are my favourite parts in the books. I still laugh every time

[@catlover-fp5ig]

I still can't believe they missed the Circe scene. :-(

[@TheCommentsTrollStrikes]

catlover12670 ThatI was planning to jerk to that scene D:

[@MrSupersayian4goku]

***** He was in this.

[@harrietw1409]

catlover12670 I know!

[@TheCommentsTrollStrikes]

Harriet wenke aww CATS

[@TheCommentsTrollStrikes]

***** That would have been cute

[@Xob_Driesestig]

Actually! Voldemort IS a half blood! And YES I am fun at parties!

[@janedoe5836]

I was thinking the same thing when he said that :)

[@OmegaCraftable]

*mudblood

[@cattledogandstaffy]

OmegaCraftable No he's a half blood not a mudblood. Mudblood is the derogatory term for muggleborns, meaning both his parents were muggles. Only his father was a muggle so he's a half blood. =)

[@OmegaCraftable]

cattledogandstaffy I feel so embarrassed it's been too long since I've read the books! :O

[@cattledogandstaffy]

Haha no need to it can be confusing x3 And they never mention it in the movies either so that doesn't help

[@prakharnagpal888]

i really like your videos, thank you for making them!

[@cherry.bomb5659]

It’s a crime how many scenes they left out, and they only did the first two books, I was really waiting for the Nico happy meal scene

[@thatonetheatrekid2530]

The Percy Jackson Fandom: The only fandom that wants more sins

[@drakeconsumerofsoulsandche5761]

Aydin Swimley it's over 9000!

[@mimsilvernote]

ThatOneTheatreKid 25 yeah

[@sgracehuffty877]

Honestly this whole movie is a giant fucking sin. UNCLE RICK HOW COULD YOU LET THEM DO THIS

[@acciousername6776]

The *true* Harry Potter fans do too...(for the HP movies)

[@abri5238]

ThatOneTheatreKid 25 Your profile picture gives me lifeeeeeeee!!

[@rae5505]

Loved the books. Hated the movies. You wanna know why? Well here you go: OMGG THE CHARACTERS LOOK NOTHING LIKE THEY DO IN THE BOOK, AND KRONOS DOESN'T RISE UNTIL THE 4TH BOOK! They skipped like 3 important seens, (sorry I'm kinda bad at spelling ) and just ignored all of the book. Do it right, or not at all. Annabeth is blonde, Grover looks like a hippie, and Percy... I don't even have to explain that one. But it is a good movie...

[@clairedarkstorm8038]

+Raylin Chambers THANK YOU someone for understanding why the Peter Johnson...I mean Percy Jackson fans were so upset about this s***!

[@rae5505]

TobiasEatonRules! I am a fan, this sets me off. OK WHO EVER MADE THIS MOVIE PREPARE TO DIE

[@clairedarkstorm8038]

I'll help! Unleash the Ares cabin!

[@clairedarkstorm8038]

And the Electric spear.

[@rae5505]

I will get the Apollo cabin, and take a visit to the roman camp. LETZ DO DIS

[@janhedani1759]

The movie barely even stays true to the books so these sins are fine.

[@Hazyla]

Well first of all Hermès isn’t in a tracksuit-

[@samrosenbaum4744]

The only thing "Percy Jackson" about this movie is that the title has the words "Percy Jackson" in it.

[@deantasaeran8883]

And that there's a guy whose name is Percy Jackson in it.

[@nebulus4700]

Sam Rosenbaum o. And there’s a guy named Luke too, plus they go to the triangle, have Greek mythology in it , and like half a dozen of other similarities (note: I hate the movies too)

[@priscillalee8574]

True

[@Silver_wind_1987_]

one lonely potato and qualified trash the movie was trash and it annoyed the absolute shit out of me when they fucked up Luke's character completely, percys cyclops half brother wasn't found in the ally way! Ohhhh that struck a cord. they rambled that off later in the mapping room with Mr D...idfk what they did with him he was bad 😑😑😑

[@jenniferboyd5321]

So true. The movies are so much different from the books. For instance Percy Jackson's age in the movie he's like 16 but in the book the lightning thief he's only 12 come on people

[@Sara-rj5gi]

Ok this movie is terrible. 1. Percy is 13 2. Grover was captured while searching for Pan in the beginning of the book (which should be in the movie) 3. Luke does not have whatever that transport thing is 4. Tyson "died" when the boat exploded, and everyone thought he was dead because of the explosion 5. Tyson has a cuter personality 6. Where's Percy being turned into a guinea pig? 7. Where's the sirens? 8. Why won't they explain Grover's abilities to track monsters and monsters' ability to track half-bloods? 9. Percy does not learn the prophecy until much later in the series 10. Luke could not have explored Tartarus (as he says he does) because before the second series, no demigod had and returned alive 11. Kronos doesn't rise until much later in the series 12. Kronos never takes that crappy fiery form, he takes Luke's body 13. Why is Clarisse so nice? 14. This movie sucks + the million other reasons that are in the replies of this comment Can you please take off sins for this not having ANY of the book's AMAZING qualities? Like they changed so much, and all in a TERRIBLE way. I know your job is primarily to judge the movies, but can this be an exception because it's so bad? Good video though! :)

[@wankyukim4825]

They knew Tyson was fireproof, just thought that even the Cyclops couldn't stand that explosion. Other than that, I 100% agree with you

[@waleedsadiq4173]

Sara lol agreed but u forgot the fact that they use phones in the movies when they say in the books that phones attract monsters

[@Sara-rj5gi]

I didn't see that, thanks!

[@Sara-rj5gi]

True, true. I haven't read the book for a while, so thanks for reminding me! :)

[@the-only-useful-lesbian]

And the prophecy says A Half-Blood of the Eldest Gods shall reach 20 against all odds

[@ghostlyapples]

Quite honestly the Percy Jackson series would me MUCH MUCH better adapted as an animation series like Avatar the Legend of Aang. One season per book, reaches the target demographic of the books, no problem with being unable to make CGI stuff happen and much more time to adapt the source material better

[@redtomato3943]

The reason why there are so many unanswered questions is there was supposed to be more sequels Love these videos BTW