Film Theory: I SOLVED The Book of Bill! (Gravity Falls)

[@FilmTheory]

Don't let Bill Cipher steal your info. Protect it with Incogni! Use code filmtheory for 60% off an annual plan ► incogni.com/filmtheory

[@Skullz-is-m1chi]

K

[@FredButEvenWorse]

ok

[@PandaSlothProductions]

HE CAME BACK FOR US

[@wolfo8077]

Ok

[@Xiea69]

kk

[@cortexvortex9504]

One thing that was not mentioned was the reason the "how to get into heaven" page was blank was because Bill said the writing would be invisible to people with sinful thoughts. So it's not that he doesn't believe in heaven. It's that he thinks we are all freaks.

[@AnimatingBeats]

It’s kinda accurate though…

[@Justvidsidkwhatelse]

It for perverted thoughts💀

[@No_creative_ideas_today7578]

Makes sense

[@TheallseeingeyeBILL]

bro rigged it

[@SomeChristianGuy9]

Which is hilarious

[@bw-leftturnracing7779]

Me and my friends were going on a trip through Oregon, and one of my friends (Jamcat) picked up the book of bill. The next day we went through Salem, and then thunderstorms started, I got sick, and we had trouble navigating through the city. A few days later, Jamcat found a part in the book where Bill Cipher says to "look out for his work in Salem." Bill deadass tried to ruin our trip.

[@pixelspixelation6418]

Cool

[@osmosisjones4912]

Wonder about the alternate Gruncle Stan

[@kenzieafent6291]

Had something like this happen to me and my friends in school. My friend brought the book of bill at school, and when we summoned bill in the book, a ,ouple minutes later, the lights. Went. Out. Everyone celebrated because people thought we were gonna go home, but the teachers kept us in school, and instead of going home early. Everything was just really, really, hot. And the lights turned to life. Bill gave us hope, and decided to rip it out of our hands.

[@pistincup352]

@@kenzieafent6291I swear, if that book isn’t haunted by Bill himself, then everything we know, will have been all lies

[@aaronpd]

Who is jamcat

[@YaBoiATEG]

Matpat: 'this time, you're on your own' Lee: 'Nuh uh'

[@joshuabarqueesimeth4530]

thanks man, i couldn't really understand what they were saying until i saw this comment.

[@noors..wurldd]

WHAT DO YOU MEAN NUH UH!

[@Adele_Ray]

@@noors..wurlddwhat

[@tibby4503]

​@@noors..wurlddAre you dumb

[@image-a-tion]

​@@Adele_Raynuh uh

[@memesoverdreams3969]

Ah yes. The ORACLE is who Bill is talking about with his angsty ex references. No other character, obviously. Not like there's a whole section dedicated to a character who has a close relationship with Bill. Historians will call them roommates or whatever.

[@malenamancaimunozmeza5244]

XD BillFord

[@netriosilver]

What's with this? Ford himself basically confirms he's ace, what is everyone on about?

[@malenamancaimunozmeza5244]

@@netriosilver being asexual doesn't mean there can't be a "deep" (and abusive) relationship between Bill and Ford

[@netriosilver]

@@malenamancaimunozmeza5244 I misspoke, he implies he is ace and aro, if that's the hang up. Otherwise, do you mean to say that you're actually just shipping them as... Really good friends?

[@Yogurg]

@@netriosilverI think it can be interpreted a few ways unless Alex confirmed that Ford was actually aro ace But also, can’t aro ace people still feel romantic attraction?

[@Zo1nkez-ui6ew]

okay so basically the oracle/"jessie" didnt date bill. she became too powerful and found out a way to defeat bill. we see this in journal 3 when the oracle gives ford the metal plate in his head, she know how to block him out of the mindscape.

[@illslegal]

YES! Finally someone said it! The fact that the vid doesn't explain the crossed paragraph about The Oracle itches my brain so much. Not only that, she figured out how the portals work and transferred the Hechmaniacs far away from Bill. I hope they better explain it in the next video cuz the Oracle ex theory doesn't have a good foundation

[@Silverware867]

@@illslegalthe theory was made by matpat’s son so i still think it’s nice they left it in

[@rowanbyrne6133]

Also I think that it’s implied that ford and the oracle had a bit of a thing, so it would be really funny if Bill was just jealous

[@Urcasualdemon]

Yes but we know she was in the henmainiacks (presumably so she could learn more about bills weakness) and she could’ve gotten in by seducing bill

[@King-gk2ce]

well, its just a theory....

[@Supasmartguy]

This huge Gravity Falls boom that came with the book of Bill had better either be teasing or have inspired a continuation to the show, perhaps a late arriving new season, similarly to what Phineas and Ferb got.

[@Poonda-ju8xe]

Hopefully the continuation is going to be a spin-off about Stan and Ford’s adventures. That is kind of the main way the story can continue with out being ruined by Disney for more content.

[@TheMaleAlicorn]

@@AUTTP-ON-TOP-r4w I find "Violent and Repulsive Content" works a lot. I mean, it covers pretty much everything THEY do.

[@braydenthelander1674]

Alex Hirsch has previously stated that any future seasons will not be sequels, so it will hopefully be a prequel for stan and ford maybe? Not sure what else it could be.

[@amiraakirapascua]

​@Joseph1441-u1e GET OUT😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@amiraakirapascua]

​@TheCoolDude4 bruh.

[@jamezzz0035]

"Life is just a series of probabilities, and I control the odds."

[@Godyeater]

@TheCoolDude4 Nuh uh

[@justkeylimeyogurt3929]

@TheCoolDude4Cool! One small issue. No one cares. Also, you forgot to add YFGA to your name.

[@AccursedPotato]

@@Godyeater don’t give these horrible bots attention

[@justkeylimeyogurt3929]

⁠@Joseph1441-u1eyou too. Y'all can't even got comment right.

[@tomby_]

I am saving that quote

[@arsonzartz]

"the old man and his platonic muse" aah video

[@arsonzartz]

THEY LITERALLY BANGED EACHOTHER-

[@haleybrown8197]

@arsonzartz BRO. ITS A KID SHOW. THEY DID NOT HAVE S*X. THATS JUST SOMETHING PEOPLE MADE UP, SO WHAT IF ITS CANON? THEY DIDNT HAVE S*X A triangle is a polygon with three corners and three sides, one of the basic shapes in geometry. The corners, also called vertices, are zero-dimensional points while the sides connecting them, also called edges, are one-dimensional line segments. A triangle has three internal angles, each one bounded by a pair of adjacent edges; the sum of angles of a triangle always equals a straight angle (180 degrees or π radians). The triangle is a plane figure and its interior is a planar region. Sometimes an arbitrary edge is chosen to be the base, in which case the opposite vertex is called the apex; the shortest segment between base and apex is the height. The area of a triangle equals one half the product of height and base length.

[@arsonzartz]

@@haleybrown8197 the book of bill literally says on the cover "travels to dimensions made for older readers"

[@freshbread4039]

@@haleybrown8197 u madd

[@_____e______482]

All yall are actual freaks if you like that ship unironically 💀

[@I_am_Croissant]

Love how like 90% of the comments are people Telling you to credit the people who really decoded this(r/gravityfalls and its corresponding discord) The other 10 is people talking about you just ignoring the billford hints.

[@Luminar1a]

For someone, who doesn’t have reddit and discord, I’m just very confused 😂

[@alphafoxys5353]

@@Luminar1a basically they took stuff from posts other people made word for word and didn't credit. It's like copying an essay for a school project online and pasting it in a word doc without saying you did so.

[@tajaewarburton1919]

​@alphafoxys5353 they gave credit in description

[@rosecah]

Lee posted an apology on Reddit and they updated the description

[@le_atti]

​@@tajaewarburton1919 Yes but only as an after thought after they were getting a harsh talking to in the comments

[@andrewclark1645]

That Disney+ pop up when Lee says "I've sold my soul for less" was so out of pocket. I love it

[@penguinbeans]

Literally after that was said, I got an ad about Disney+ 😂😂

[@CircusSabre]

Considering what happened recently with someone who used a free trial then I guess actually buying Disney+ is selling your soul

[@Randomdude47-m8i]

@@CircusSabre Selling your wife’s soul.

[@kolbymiller3440]

Matpat: this time you're on your own Lee: Not on my watch!

[@LeanderIsntHere]

​@Joseph1441-u1ebro shut up thats creepy asf

[@CherryMoon-d4s]

Dude what ​@Joseph1441-u1e

[@AnimatingBeats]

I mean technically it was *Mat Pat* who said he wouldn’t help up with this theory. He never said ANYTHING about Lee though…

[@soot6795]

Something that people should know is that basically nothing in this video is new. The book's been decoded by many, many folks over on reddit and discord, and someone on Twitter's video on the silly string pages- around the 18:00 mark- has been used without credit.

[@A_Goose_YT]

@@soot6795 ok, who cares? game theory is popular, so if they upload, atleast more people see it than some random people on reddit and discord.

[@atheahatshizume658]

Jessie wasn't Bill's ex! She betrayed Bill by telling Ford about the portal real function! Bill's ex it's most likely Ford (since in the books it's very obvious how close they where to one another, even if it wasn't something physicaly but emotionaly abusive in both ends)

[@Koranimorir]

There's no point for him to hide that implied "EX" is Ford, because he talks about Ford in other pages, and for Gravity Falls..it seems too obvious, don't you think so? Obviously it's probably not right

[@kawaiielephant7772]

​@@KoranimorirHow is it too obvious 😅

[@thequeen8490]

R/gravityfalls has really done the work on this it's been on of the coolest community projects everyone that was a fan came together for this so some credit to the fans that really put in the hours on this would be appreciated

[@N0va_Fr]

Description. 💀

[@stressedvulture]

@@N0va_Fr It wasn't always credited

[@W3irdgurll]

At the part with bill saying he has no exes is because he still loves this one ex he has and it is... Ford it says in the book they had a relationship then they broke it off leading to bill getting drunk and calling his dead mom. I think the girl that was crossed out was just a friend that turned good on bill and left the group

[@megamau923]

in what part of the book does it say they have a romantic relationship ?

[@mothersuperior2673]

​@megamau923 they don't say the words "they used to date" or anything but there's so much subtext across the book and site it's odd for them to ignore, i.e. if you type breakup or divorce into the website, it gives you a card for the bar bill visited after ford left him

[@QuillyQue]

Really? No mention of Ford? That was so strongly implied...not saying Billford is a thing, but it was a 'Thing', take what you will. It impacted Bill to the point of revenge on an emotional level.

[@Koranimorir]

His "revenge" was never a thing, the whole weirdmaggedon event couldn't be called "revenge", they definitely had a thing, but that was just one-sided relationship, in which Bill probably neglected Stanford.

[@myball37]

⁠​⁠​⁠@@Koranimorir good job youve figured out toxic relationships exist!!! bill obviously manipulated and abused ford but they were still in a relationship and bill literally got drunk at a bar after they split (also if u type breakup/divorce into the website it gives u a card for the bar bill went to in the book)

[@Koranimorir]

@@myball37 it's really dumb of you to assume that they had something serious.

[@FrostWasAbductedYT]

it was at most a onesided relationship.

[@Iemonkkwastaken]

@@Koranimorir im sorry but it's way implied that they did. how are you trying to justify saying the oracle was bill's partner with little to no proof but not billford which was implied SO MANY times in the series and book? it's dumb of you to assume a character we knowing virtually nothing about and is barely important to the story would have such an important role. please shut up.

[@tiredenby705]

Wild that there's so much focus on the "Jheselbraum being Bill's ex" theory (plausible, But) when there's So Much pointing to Ford being his ex-Something, all the romantic (albeit definitely manipulative/abusive) language and subtext/references surrounding those two are very clear

[@daintyroses]

RIIIIGHT? i was like what is this theory?? cuz it's so obvious it's bc of ford........ my brain hurts

[@Infamousspaade]

@@daintyrosesright

[@buckethatboy8719]

AUUGGHH THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU FINALLY SOMEONE HERE IN THESE COMMENTS THAT ISN’T WEARING CISHET-COLORED GLASSES 😭

[@titan1umtitan]

You should learn to differentiate a farmer/livestock relationship with what you want to be true. Bill treats him as a beloved lamb of a flock(victims), and Ford treats him as a beholder of vast wisdom. The way Bill has always treated Ford goes against literally anything that would imply this as true. A better comparison of this is how you had a favorite toy that you used until it broke. The only way they could be "exes" is in a non-romantic way, like Joker and Batman, which is a surprisingly similar scenario.

[@romalea]

i thought i was losing my mind, why did they particularly ignore every detail of billford in favor of something i've NEVER heard of... okay

[@iaminyourwallshehehe]

Fun fact for those of you who aren’t on the TikTok side of things, Songwriter and Gravity Falls theory enthusiast Terminally Silly actually wrote and posted a cover of the song “Rockabye Baby”, from the perspective of Bill’s mother. According to them, after the video was posted, their power went out. 3. Separate. Times.

[@Miliwashere527]

Four

[@iaminyourwallshehehe]

@@Miliwashere527 yes

[@lolliii5477]

oh god it's worse than i thought

[@iaminyourwallshehehe]

@@lolliii5477 this isn’t just a book. It’s real. It’s happening.

[@TheTransparentGuy]

BILL IS REAL. WORSHIP THE ANGLE. H JMNV GHL... GDKO! GDKO! GDKO!

[@samurexatlas7373]

11:23 Cipher's little eye, since his birth, let him see the third dimension. The ARG dives into this so next time you'll note it, no doubt. But he even lost his mother and his father.

[@kimmyko4207]

OMG BRO

[@MC_CN]

The Oregon Parks Dpt. ARG on YT is non-canon and made by a fan

[@Lumaedra]

REPORT THE GUY WITH THE MR BEAST ICON WHO JUST REPLIED, GOOGLE TRANSLATE IT AND YOU'LL REALIZE WHAT THE HECK HES SAYING

[@samurexatlas7373]

@@MC_CN The website attached to the book.

[@Jack-my4bx]

Who knows perhaps a multi-dimensional being made him have that strange eye

[@Kaiyax_]

My main problem with this theory is the oracle part, while yes billford isn’t cannon (coming from a billford shipper) it has way more dang proof then bill dating the oracle. All they needed to do was read the dang book (which they admitted they literally skimmed through it.) and they would’ve understood it so much better. It’s honestly kinda disappointing seeing as gravity falls is one of mat’s favorite animated shows. With the oracle all they did was just see this random person crossed out, figured out it was the oracle, then assumed that the only logical answer was they dated. There’s no actual concrete proof, only speculation, and yes I know it’s a theory but still theory’s are supposed to have actual evidence, at this point this is a hypothesis. Like I said at least billford has actual proof. My second problem with this is the lack of crediting to r/gravityfalls, I’m aware they’ve added credits now, but they should’ve done it in the first place. Not to mention they skimmed over the silly straw page! They literally only mentioned the upside message. Really disappointed as someone who’s been watching team theorists for a while, you guys used to make amazing theories now it just feels like you just throw stuff together without any actual knowledge. I know y’all are busy but you guys knew book of bill wasn’t gonna be simple, not to mention everything that’s in this theory (except the oracle) isn’t even a theory, it’s just stating what we know. Maybe they’ll fix something’s in part two but for now I’m disappointed.

[@haleybrown8197]

yapmageddon

[@Obri55]

"Billford shipper" oh brother

[@KaylieghHereford]

Bruh I totally agree!!!!!

[@rowanbyrne6133]

“Or maybe the fight will be way more personal, with option number 3: bill’s ex-girlfriend” You mean ford?

[@v9an]

Am SO SAD they didn't even mention bill and cipher's situation ship, I wouldn't call it a relationship cause of how it was implied (and cause people will come after me) because this situation ship is actually really important for bill's past and overall history 😞😞

[@Maxyiie]

Ford would not even open the book to read it, imagine putting codes on it. Also, I doubt Cipher would tell deep secrets about his life to him

[@MynameisnotGraey]

@@v9anI mean. It’s end was literally called a divorce. So while situationship isn’t the wrong term here per se, it’s no longer just implied

[@v9an]

@@MynameisnotGraey oh alr!! XD I can see what you mean :]

[@urmom..835]

I have a feeling he’s a bit embarrassed to mention that ford and bill are a couple, I ship bill and ford through and through. It’s kinda funny how I’ve had dreams of bill aswell

[@milomystique]

hi! please make sure to credit the community of the r/GravityFalls! they made lots of effort to solve a bunch of the mysteries, staying up for ages to the point the mods had tell them to take breaks. its disappointing to see the lack of credit given. :(

[@brandonwhitney7964]

Also the code breakers in discord (Ik most of the users are the same but still)

[@skrrrtcoba1n]

completely agree. was very active in the subreddit when the book and website released. These fans worked extremely hard and if the mysteries they solved are being used they should be given credit!

[@juliewasnthere]

yeahhh the discord and subreddit!!! it was so fun :)

[@Novsev9069]

I doubt they will most of their theories they always act like they discovered everything but really didn’t the community did and then they just compile it it all together

[@B1LLC1PH3R]

We Want Credit!!!

[@TheCopyKing]

Love the video but as one of the people who solved the silly straws I kinda wish you guys credited the discord/subreddit for solving all the codes mentioned in the video Edit: Seems like proper credit is being added to the description soon, glad to see it happen but slightly disappointed it come to this. On a side note though, as a game/film theory fan for nearly 10 years now, to know that my google doc of codes had a direct impact on an episode is pretty amazing. Still have a large amount of respect for the team as they help inspire new waves of decoders and theorists

[@therealsemicolon]

so silly

[@JohnDoe-hj9fh]

More than one person can solve something

[@Bladedflame1]

@@JohnDoe-hj9fh quotes are ripped directly from the subreddit! theres even a stolen clip

[@calliecalamity8787]

Fr fr, even just a quick mention or something

[@TheAbaker87]

But did they?

[@Quackervoltz]

Book of Bill: Has Bill describe romance as handcuffing yourself to a mortal, describes romantic things Bill would do as things he literally does to Stanford, has Stanford's own niece describe Bill as a clingy ex, has Stanford INTERRUPT parts of the book to tell you that Bill is dangerous Game Theory: Uhhhhh Bill's ex is this random lady because she used to be a Henchmaniac and is a girl also our boss's kid said so

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

Except Ford learned about Bill's backstory from Jessie. Could Bill have had a crush on Ford? Yes. Did Ford have feelings? Obviously not. And I hope it stays that way. Gravity Falls was not designed for these kinds of implications and Ford is already not the most beloved of characters.

[@katyfive1]

@@Wendeta-hq2cp "Gravity Falls was not designed for these kinds of implications " what do you mean?

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@katyfive1 Gravity Falls, whatever Alex Hirsh's intentions, is not... is not a show like Steven Universe. Let's put it that way. Abnormal and even toxic relationships do not stand at the foundation of Gravity Falls. On the contrary, the show is based on promoting family values, even if it did have some... questionable life lessons sometimes (the unicorn episode is the biggest one I can think of).

[@nerdydragonfan]

IDK what brought you to the conclusion that the Onacle is Bill's Ex... Girlfriend? And not just an Ex Member of Bill's Hinchmaniacs. If that were the case, I would imagine that Bill would dedicate more time talking about HER, rather than a certain six figure nerd he was pretty hung up on.

[@tiffymist]

clock it

[@reidar7838]

Watch the GTLive where Mat goes over the book, they talked about this how and part of how they came to that conclusion, I dont have the exact timestamp but it’s a good video anyway

[@Integrous_Melodies]

To be fair, it *is* possible Ford was just one of his exes (probably the only one he actually liked) with the Oracle being another one

[@KazekoRyu]

Did you even watch the video?

[@shrutisable900]

@@reidar7838 he says that his son ollie made the theory

[@misfitanimations2787]

Notice how all the codes in the glitch cypher refer to bill as Billy and talk about his childhood in Euclidia? It seems to be like it’s most likely Bill‘s mother scalene since the Oracle would have no way of knowing what happened in Euclid on such a personal level

[@ManceAdventures]

I don't know if this is true but it's been pointed out a bunch of times in the gravity Falls discord and Reddit that Euclid is his father and Euclydia is his home dimension with Scalene being his mother,, literally no clue tho, just sharing what I've seen :3

[@dalekkorax4080]

That would make sense although it is included that his mother is confirmed to be dead a trillion years before he even wrote that book. I believe it's the Axolotl purely because the codes are commonly rhyming couplets which is the exact rhythm and pattern he speaks especially when talking to Dipper and Mable in a canon comic to talk about Bill.

[@DarIing_Doll]

please credit sources! lots of folks said it already, but the awesome people of R/GravityFalls (and the corresponding discord, i believe, correct if wrong) did a huge huge majority of the work when it came to decoding and theorizing! it's never cool to steal someones hard work! Edit- WOWIE- I expected this comment to go unnoticed, thank y’all for replying / liking!! I’d like to say, for those folks telling me that the description was updated , thank you so much! It makes me incredibly happy! Secondly, when I originally posted this comment, there was no credit to the sources. If there was credit when the video was originally posted, I doubt I and many others would have felt the need to comment asking for such. Nonetheless!! It’s really happy they did the right thing!

[@quessiant]

You are absolutely right

[@TRULYBIZZARE-d5k]

there’s a high chance he won’t see these comments but if he does I’m pretty sure he will fix the mistake if he doesn’t he probably never checked the comments to the video

[@Biggiecheese20]

there will be a 2nd vid, cuz there was a LOT, I hope they do by as well unless they all solved this within weeks ahahaha

[@bh4vvy33t]

Yes, they went crazy but they were right

[@Luminar1a]

That’s why I haven’t looked. I want to try and work out some of the codes on my own.

[@1Matcha_tea]

NO BILLFORD MENTIONS??? im literally crying😭😭😭 (dude's to oblivious that its ford brooooo)

[@rosem9929]

It's not obvious enough?!?!?

[@1Matcha_tea]

@@rosem9929 IKR????

[@Midlandsmusic]

*too

[@tsunamiwof7028]

I feel not

[@Koranimorir]

That doesn't sounds like Ford tho, this person writing the codes definitely knows MORE about Bill and his past, than Ford.

[@captainphantasma]

They done made bill cipher straight😭😭🙏 noway how does one miss this many clues

[@friendlyghosthost1830]

He always gave me pan/bi vibes. Like he doesn’t really care about gender as long as the other person doesn’t bore him.

[@captainphantasma]

@friendlyghosthost1830 i mean sure, but either way my point is that there is basically no solid proof for the oracle being his ex, atleast in comparison to it being ford, which there is a LOT

[@weirdcakes304]

@@captainphantasmathey’re erasing billford from the history books 😭😭

[@tiffymist]

the whole framing device of the book is bill and fords relationship yet they made it about the oracle bc she’s a woman im crying 😭😭😭

[@captainphantasma]

@tiffymist yeah it's actually nuts, like i don't wanna say that they purposely avoided it, but it's so odd to me that there's no mention of it, like even slightly

[@otterdolls]

are we not bringing up the bill x ford stuff that's hinted (heavily implied) in the book.....???

[@myball37]

its not even hinted vro its right on the page

[@my_vlog2478]

21:57 I’m fully convinced that his “ex-girlfriend” Is literally just Ford… like their breakup was real

[@captainsprinkles6557]

Or uh... The Howling Void? The character that there's literally pictures of him holding hands with in the book? The one he denies dating an overabundant amount of times?

[@Southparkfan598]

@@captainsprinkles6557…Bill doesn’t love like most people do, if he’s holding hands it’s most likely deal making, and considering how Ford talks about Bill and their relationship then vice verse then I think it’s safe to say it was a very one sided relationship

[@Southparkfan598]

@@captainsprinkles6557If he had any love in his heart beforehand it most definitely was vaporized along with his dimension and his parents

[@Fl0wers4rePr3tty]

@@Southparkfan598 bill and ford were both pretty upset and canonically did miss eachother after they split up on bad terms

[@Southparkfan598]

@@Fl0wers4rePr3tty I didn’t say that they didn’t miss eachother, just saying they had different thoughts on the relationship, they were co-workers and possibly more, it is still pretty vague about their relationship but the hints are definitely there, and considering we’re getting more Gravity Falls content, it won’t be long for us to wait until our answers

[@LumiKat117]

Totally brushed over the fact that the book exposes the fact that Bill and Ford were DEFINITELY something more than just "Muse and Scientist" 😏😂

[@haleybrown8197]

shut

[@Lexx_luvs_bredd]

I love how they thought "hm, who's Bills ex, the nerdy six fingered guy that he's obsessed over and literally broke down sobbing at the bar, and has a whole chapter written about Sixer, or the one scribbled out paragraph" 🤔

[@FluffyGhost294]

Brings up ex’s and doesn’t even mention the implications about Ford and Bill. I mean just the kareoke and O’sadleys pages alone tell their story not to mention his melt down. That wasn’t a “I lost my latest pawn meltdown” that was a “I lost my beloved partner and acted super irrationally now he’ll never want me again”

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

Yeah... no. I'm pretty sure it was one-sided honestly. Ford saw Bill as his 'Muse' so something clearly more inspirational, than traditionally romantic. Bill for sure liked Ford though. Dude was probably the first person to let him in a mind in centuries, not to mention that Ford actually built the portal. The final nail in the coffin is the book itself compared to the show: Ford clearly moved on from his obsession with Bill, implying that his attachment was less personal compared to Bill's, who clearly took the end of their partnership very hard.

[@MYSTERIOUS-r9n]

Maybe it's just a joke. Can friends not participate in karaoke. Also, yeah, of course, Bill Cipher would be upset about the falling out with Ford, considering the fact it could've led to him letting his buddies out of the Nightmare Realm.

[@Fukuzatsunayume]

​@@MYSTERIOUS-r9nconsidering the fact that alex fought so hard for lgbtq representation against disney, i don't think it's a joke, alex isn't that type of person, he fought so hard just for two women to be all lovey dovey in the love god episode and fought so hard just for blubs and darland to have some time together.

[@moonbloom2262]

@@MYSTERIOUS-r9n in the book of bill bill says the best way to get someone to fall for you is locking them in a stone pyramid and sing to them until they eventually give up. which is exactly what he tried to do with ford in the show.

[@katyfive1]

@@Wendeta-hq2cp "Ford clearly moved on from his obsession with Bill, implying that his attachment was less personal" You shouldn't be obssessed with someone you like, and that wouldn't make Ford's attachment less personal. the books is from Bill's perspective, but Ford clearly show's a lot of personal feelings towards Bill - hence why he feels so betrayed by Bill's actions. But Bill took it harder because he was more obssessed and unhealthy - since he doesn't think like a normal human.

[@DarkwoodSystem]

this would be really cool video if you guys could credit were given to the users and communities that did the work to make these discoveries!! Us along with MANY others have been working their butts off on this and its super upsetting the people that worked on it didn't get any sort of credit or anything.

[@sweetp285]

Description.

[@OEIFS]

@@sweetp285 are you and many other film theory keyboard warriors not understanding what the words "added after being harshly talked to in the comments" mean

[@o5council349]

give credit to those who deserve it, you took theories word for word that where created in the reddit the day the book released, I'm not against getting information from the community but at least give propper credit man

[@tastyeyes7]

FR!!!

[@TangyByte]

I agree, I know me and a bunch of other people have been working our tails off and seeing it taken without credit is upsetting.

[@thevioletskull8158]

Not agian, they said they would credit reddit users and did it in videos

[@coolguy30215]

I beleive deadpool 2 the part where dp or deadpool is picking out superheros for x force right after his friend the bartender says "isnts that canada" go ahead look at the movie

[@dubsthelongone213]

@@TangyBytetruly man, as someone who’s spent way to long on this it hurts

[@taylormonk5108]

History will say that Ford and Bill were just friends, and APPARENTLY FILM THEORY WILL TOO, WHAT THE HECK, GUYS?!

[@jeffreyu6786]

Because they were. Stop fetishizing a kids show

[@taylormonk5108]

@@jeffreyu6786 It’s not fetish? The Book of Bill literally displays the relationship between Bill and Ford as being more than a friendship multiple times in the lost Journal 3 pages, with Bill often being shown as Ford’s abuser in what can only be described as a situationship. Mabel literally refers to Bill’s behavior towards Ford as being obsessed over an ex.

[@bea7823]

@@jeffreyu6786Why do you people always think everything that’s non-straight is inherently fetishized and sexualized istg

[@daniel-mz8gn]

​@@taylormonk5108 so Bill is an abusive asshole

[@thiscatiskindofcute5556]

Heres proof if you look in the romance section it says you trap them in a love triangle and play piano.​@@jeffreyu6786

[@ry1i1]

how did y'all come to the conclusion that The Oracle is Bill's ex when Ford is right there bro 😭

[@mario_cipher933]

REAL. Theres so much evidence about billford, and yet they ignored all that??

[@anothername2557]

​@@mario_cipher933 i get the "the ex is ford" but do you guys really think HE wrote the codes?? and how would he have gotten all that info into Bill's psyche?? we know Ford didn't know that much about his past as to know he's "haunted" by it. it's not the point they're making. though prob they should have said like "appart from ford, one of his OTHER exes was probably the oracle"

[@pinecone3054]

On GTlive MatPat said Ollie noticed it himself. Certified Oliver‘s first theory.

[@Katt0.0.]

The straightwashing is crazy😭

[@sliceofgarlicbread]

You are so real for this

[@shroomydoodles]

update: hi! they did finally add credit in the descriptions, thank you !! still leaving this comment up though so people can check the description and support those lovely people in the description! hey! as someone who helped uncover and document parts of the book and specifically the secrets of the lofi album, the website, nd etc, PLEASE CREDIT!! people's names especially those from r/gravityfalls deserve to be recognized, i've met so many kind people there and we've uncovered so many things, so *PLEASE* credit!

[@ODOGTURTLE]

YOU TELL THEM,

[@boopthegoose4827]

for real! give credit where credit is due!

[@Crazy_Kids611]

Exactly!!! I helped a little (mostly on smaller theories) but I've been in the discord for awhile and it hurts seeing peoples work not be credited

[@justacuteonigiri]

womp womp

[@TRULYBIZZARE-d5k]

there’s a high chance he won’t see these comments but if he does I’m pretty sure he will fix the mistake if he doesn’t he probably never checked the comments to the video

[@painterguy6469]

The lack of credit and the billford erasure is a mystery on its own that needs to be solved 😭

[@romalea]

CLOCK IT

[@Figaroma]

For real 😭😭

[@phoneboy4620]

frrrr

[@sorble4496]

CLOCKKEDD

[@hope.world.mp3845]

CLOCKKKK ITTTT

[@mythicalpotatoes8832]

Jessie is a really weird way to say Ford the billford erasure will NOT stand

[@thefastrightptg5048]

Here come the braindead toxic shippers

[@rosem9929]

@@thefastrightptg5048 yes and?

[@kazimrittika783]

LET'S NOT EVEN MENTION, HOW 80-90% OF THE BOOK OF BILL IS LITERALLY, BILL BITCHING ABOUT MISSING FORD BECAUSE, ONE DOES NOT JUST SIMPLY SAY,"I DON'T MISS MY EX" AND PROCEED TO MENTION THEIR EX IN ALMOST EVERY PAGE IN OF WHAT IS, BASICALLY THEIR ARTS AND CRAFTS PROJECT OF A DIARY THAT PEOPLE CAN READ, WITHOUT SOUNDING LIKE A 'NEEDY EX' LIKE, MABEL CALLS BILL

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@thefastrightptg5048 Fr. Like Ford idolized Bill as his muse, but he didn't involve himself as personally as Bill did. Now do I think Bill considers Ford his lover? Possible. Bill clearly was damaged by the separation, but Ford managed to pick himself back up way too quickly for him to have had feelings.

[@Koranimorir]

Oh god..THAT side of fandom AGAIN!

[@Samuel_Pythonss]

Not them pointedly ignoring all of the billford implications 😭

[@gottagoquack]

fr like... guys cmon!!

[@SolitarySpoons]

the toxic old man yaoi is literally real

[@squishking]

LIKE!!??!??

[@TheAngelofFate17]

I mean there’s really nothing to talk about it. As it doesn’t matter seeing as Ford have an absolute loathing for Bill. Whatever relationship they had doesn’t matter as it happened in the past.

[@gottagoquack]

@@Samuel_Pythonss like i literally wrote an essay of a reply in these comments abt billford but i barely even scratched the Surface w that 😭😭

[@Cameron_Levine]

22:21 Why didn’t you give credit to Ollie? He came up with that I thought? It would have been cool to show people. EVERYONE THANK OLLIE!

[@user-ayiy824jbd]

the billford erasure is crazy. id rather they not talk abt bills relationships at all than make one up for the sake of keeping bill STRAIGHT 🇺🇸🇺🇸🏈🏈🏈🦅🦅🦅🦅

[@gottagoquack]

tbf i think the primary reason they covered it is because ollie (matpat's son) kinda came up w it haha. so i will give them that. it's not a bad theory for coming from a 6 year old hahaha

[@user-ayiy824jbd]

@@gottagoquack right but if they were gonna do that they could’ve talked about the real present relationship dynamic in the serious part of the video instead of leaving it out entirely

[@3xpl0rer_png]

the billford erasure is diabolical 😭🙏

[@Liamguy999]

It’s not erasure because it’s not the first priority, because it’s just a weird internet ship that’s not canon, does not add anything to the story, and will 100% steer us in the wrong direction of this hunt. So thanks for your time.

[@vambrosiaofficial]

​@@Liamguy999"does not add anything to the story" my guy have you WATCHED gravity falls or the book of bill? Sure the ship isn't canon but ford and bill "situationship" definately add so much to the story. Ford was definately obsessed with bill to the point he made a whole room dedicated to bill and apparently from bill mouth (or eyes idk) he said that weirdmaggedon wouldn't happened if it wasn't because of Ford, and Ford no longer wanting to keep the machine going definately makes bill not so happy.

[@Liamguy999]

@@vambrosiaofficial the ship has nothing to do with the story. Bills heartless manipulation over ford had everything to do with the story.

[@3xpl0rer_png]

@@Liamguy999 It’s most definitely not a “weird internet ship”. have you read the book of bill past this video? there is SO many implications that they had some sort of relationship. whether platonic or not. And its not just the book, also the show. its been hinted SO much. if i didn’t know any better I’d say you read the book and watched the slow blindly. or you just skipped those parts.

[@Liamguy999]

@@3xpl0rer_png the joke in the book is that they’re ACTING like toxic exes. Believing the book of bill as evidence requires you to completely miss the joke. Also have you failed to realize that bill never stopped his plan to manipulate ford? Bill had no feelings for ford. Because he’s a chaos demon who manipulated him.

[@DoMorrMusic]

LET’S GO MORR GRAVITY FALLS!

[@theforgotten4295]

Gotta love the new content Gravity Falls has gotten

[@duke7037]

​@Joseph1441-u1e :I

[@Guestmc8YT]

​@Joseph1441-u1e bro thinks he is drake now 💀

[@Guestmc8YT]

@TheCoolDude4 bro definitely plays cart ride into 17 pregnant diddys ( its a Roblox game)

[@hamburgerman1390]

Delivery costs 100$😢

[@MiniMe0w]

hey everyone, just wanted to let people know that some of the info and theories were taken from the r/gravityfalls server to a point its word for word. Please give us credit where credit is due as its super unfair our hard works been taken without credit

[@IdentityVibes]

He also hasn’t given credit at all to RemGames

[@Eclipse.300]

@@IdentityVibes yeah man rem games has been cooking

[@IdentityVibes]

@@Eclipse.300 and not even a mention when I know for a fact they HAD to have seen his videos

[@Eclipse.300]

@@IdentityVibes fr they went over alot of things he did

[@justacuteonigiri]

womp womp

[@duyphanle8290]

9:21 I don't see many people talk about the Mabel part yet. "Constant nightmares of unable to save a dying pig" could just be a callback to the Time Traveller's Pig episode or worse, Waddles is dying ever since it got to California.

[@tortugatoontown]

I thought wendys dreams were super dark

[@FizzyPopVevo]

The thing that makes Gravity Falls so Memorable is how Alex Hirsch himself was the one who decided to cut it in its prime, usually, whenever a show is cut, it’s either due to publishers or corporations deciding to cut shows in their prime (See Owl House/OKKO/Inside Job) but Gravity Falls is a weird case of the creator saying “Enough is enough” and I greatly respect the amount of restraint, he could have milked this IP to the ground but he knew what story he wanted to tell and when he wanted to end it, plus, by cutting the show way before people got tired of it, you get a fandom that constantly thirsts for more content, I mean, It’s been 12 years but the fandom is still going strong (Even with the confirmation of no season 3)

[@catticus6637]

credit the people that did the work to figure out the book

[@haleybrown8197]

description, susie from deltarune, description.

[@l1lyBEAMS]

Please credit the people in the server who discovered alot of it please!

[@wanderfullgames8210]

then it takes ages

[@Andytheartist]

Description

[@sweetp285]

Description... 💀

[@haleybrown8197]

description fur-

[@tumishofortune1992]

Bro's voice impression of gran uncle Stan is undefeated.😭🔥

[@NateTheGrate8604]

@jimmyyfga-k2q we found you, please keep commenting, it only helps us

[@ccerroo]

@jimmyyfga-k2qthis is why your a failure in life 👊

[@Quartz_Featherz]

@jimmyyfga-k2qwhat in the name of cheese

[@Draedon126]

@@Quartz_Featherzspam bot, don’t reply, but do report because at this point ignoring does not work

[@Sl33pParalysisDemon755]

Ngl, why am I not shocked that they didn’t mention Billford? I kinda expected it and was mad before the episode even started?? What kind of deja vu is this 😂

[@freyrapollo]

21:50 was it not obvious to other people that the love bill avoids talking about is ford?

[@Liamguy999]

Because bill and ford were not dating

[@freyrapollo]

@@Liamguy999 something was going on between them, you just have to know how to read subtext. or just text really, cause what else could "one thing led to another" mean

[@Liamguy999]

@@freyrapollo bill is an evil triangle. End of story. He would not date ford.

[@fgag-cl]

@@Liamguy999 did you fail literature with the lowest mark? or are you in 4rd grade

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@freyrapollo Something not romantic. At least not from Ford. A hint at Bill potentially liking Ford yes, but not the other way around. Bill was a friend/muse/God to Ford. A lot of adoration with little personal attachment.

[@Harukami]

You know that Ford is also one of Bill's exes, right? Feels a bit relevant. (For example, "Divorce" etc.)

[@eucalyptusplant4324]

Please credit the people who actually found some of this evidence!! I have friends on the r/Gravity Falls server and they poured they're hearts into this and to see their stuff get taken without credit kinda sucks :/

[@themrlupo3591]

To discover something doesn’t make it yours, obviously to word for word it is, but they never said that they found it, almost all theory channels do this and non give credit

[@Ebtihalalhosani]

@@themrlupo3591the title quite literally says “I solved the book of bill” the title saying HE solved it all on his own which is blatantly incorrect

[@LeN-ix2du]

In the description!

[@Zappysteel]

Fun fact: according to the poem written by the axolotl, Bill technically did die at the end of weirdmegetn, he just got transported to the theriprism, technically alive, but having experienced death

[@persephone6457]

How have you could have forgotten to mention anything about how homoerotic Ford and Bill’s relationship was when you were talking about his past partners?!

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

Bill probably felt something. Not Ford. Dude cut off the relationship and then proceeded to do everything to keep bill out of both his mind and physically, with Ford pointing his crossbow at Stan and then checking his eyes implying Ford actually had to take care of beings that Bill possessed to keep Bill out.

[@MYSTERIOUS-r9n]

Maybe that was just not their interpretation. Shocking,I know. PEOPLE'S INTERPRETATIONS CAN VARY DEPENDING ON THE PERSON.

[@s1llysunnyyy]

​@MYSTERIOUS-r9n i see you replying on all billford comments, if your so mad abt it just leave it alone man 😭

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@MYSTERIOUS-r9n That Billford interpretation is not even accurate. At most Bill had a crush on Ford and took advantage of his inferiority complex to fuel a toxic relationship. Ford never liked Bill that way.

[@Dragonlord13]

​@@MYSTERIOUS-r9n yeah when I read it for the first time I got the feeling of typical close friends, and even after reading all these peoples weird interpretations I still feel the same.

[@o.r2308]

0:07 “Actually no you’re not” Me who can’t decipher to save her life: Oh thank god

[@Flesh-wl7bb]

Who's life?

[@CoolScratcher]

@@Flesh-wl7bb it's an expression that just means "I'm really bad at something"

[@kabeeeeeee]

"Heh, a girl?" *I paused, looking her up and down.* "We don't typically get a lotta females out around these parts." *I continued, running my hands through my head of hair. I gently bit my lower lip and narrowed my eyes.*

[@BimodalTurtle36]

@@kabeeeeeee rizz?

[@andrei283]

​@@kabeeeeeee L rizz Bro

[@ominus_potato]

How’s you get through this entire video without mentioning Bill’s relationships with Ford ONCE?!

[@Sammywammyx3]

REAL

[@ijustseeme]

THIS!!!!

[@Liamguy999]

Because they didn’t happen.

[@ominus_potato]

@@Liamguy999 someone hasn’t read the book of bill

[@Liamguy999]

@@ominus_potato nah I read it. It’s just that that’s not what happened, and this is a theorizing video. So you can just stick to your weird bill and ford kissing videos buddy.

[@pigidinedits]

you are SO oblivious to billford that it's actually kinda sad😭

[@Figaroma]

(Is that a ninjago pfp?) Real like did they even read the book

[@teapartytaIes]

KAI AND COLE?!??!?!?!??!?!?!??!?!?!?

[@Liamguy999]

Why are people acting like this book is titled “the book of billford”? Here’s a fact: NOBODY CARES ABOUT BILLFORD. ITS JUST SOME DUMB SHIP SOMEONE CAME UP WITH THAT PEOPLE ARE TAKING TO THE NEXT LEVEL. GET OVER IT.

[@Chiales]

@@Liamguy999 Sure. Get a life, buddy!

[@JamietheEmperor]

​@@Liamguy999tf?

[@anriavantonder5264]

22:26 I honestly love that Ollie came up with this theory on his own which is shocking for a 6 year old! Truly taking after his father

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

Smart kid. I hope it sticks. It'd be awesome for Ollie to end up making more theories and to flex his brain muscle that way.

[@cardboardcutout]

The billford erasure is crazy 😔

[@Ahki.Asadullah]

22:29 ignoring the axelotto in the drawing is criminal because it shows she got ties

[@LemonQueenTM]

Lee: …and his ex-girlfriend, THE ORACLE! Stanford: Am I a joke to you?

[@ST4RFIREOFFICAL]

Credit the people in the Gravity Falls Discord/Reddit.

[@fruityhobi]

not a single billford mention im crying

[@fruityhobi]

THIS THEORY WAS SO GOOD THO ILY LEE

[@itisitheoneandonlyravxa]

whats billford

[@Siulas_10]

Bill Cipher x Stanford Pines

[@Liamguy999]

Because it’s not canon, and has no point in showing up in a theory video. It’s also weird.

[@fgag-cl]

@@Liamguy999 it WAS canon, like, in past tense,,, theyre exes

[@obsidion_sings]

Please give credit where credit is due! As a member of r/GravityFalls it hurts my heart to see the theories of people i know taken and given zero credit to. We have poured our hearts in this, DAYS spent together in calls LOSING OUR MINDS AND SLEEP trying to figure out what Alex Hirsch wants us to find. And to see a channel many of us look up to, to just- what? take credit for our findings? I'm incredibly disappointed.

[@justacuteonigiri]

womp womp cry

[@natz3284]

Oh shut up this isnt a womp womp moment this is legit plagiarism, matpat always credited sources (see him crediting the community fot fnaf theories or crow 64, etc) so its hugely disappointing for lee to drop the ball like this ​@justacuteonigiri

[@TGPDrunknHick]

@@natz3284 and while entirely possible for Film Theory to have independantly solved things, it seems they've straight ripped quotes and other things from the subreddit. It's not a who solved first but, indeed seems to be plagarism.

[@natz3284]

@@TGPDrunknHick exactly !!!!

[@j.r.tomlin4265]

​@@natz3284I agree if you guys put in this much effort and the film Film theorists have had it in the "background" then you guys need some credit for solving stuff

[@Zappysteel]

19:06 Deciphering words from COFFEE RINGS is probably the most "Team Theorist" thing you can possibly do

[@iheartmygf-zf3em]

They straightened our homeboy Bill😭😭🔥🔥

[@mario_cipher933]

Real he's so fruity😭😭‼️

[@Shroomish_Art]

Brother wears mascara and says his gender is triangle. There is no way that he even LOOKS at a woman!

[@Figaroma]

How did they straighten him so hard 😭

[@sleepdeprivedduckwithmenta7793]

MAN'S AS STRAIGHT AS THOSE SILLY STRAWS LIKE 😭

[@sleepdeprivedduckwithmenta7793]

​@@Shroomish_Artonly woman this guy loves is his mama 💥💥💥💥

[@asperstar4044]

credit has been give thank you film theory team

[@hunterd.6658]

GIVE THIS COMMENT MORE LIKES 🗣️🗣️‼️‼️‼️

[@tastyeyes7]

Fr!!! Disappointed they haven't mentioned that in the vid heck

[@TRULYBIZZARE-d5k]

there’s a high chance he won’t see these comments but if he does I’m pretty sure he will fix the mistake if he doesn’t he probably never checked the comments to the video

[@LeN-ix2du]

It's in the description now!

[@haleybrown8197]

READ THE DESCRIPTION

[@Marissaiscool53]

Please credit the people who solved it

[@c_rex3309]

Bro did an entire theory on the book of bill without mentioning how bill and ford explored each others metaphysical bodies as if the Disney censors were right behind him 😔😔😔😔

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

You people got Owl House (awesome show and I loved Luz and Amity btw). Get over yourselves. Why can't normal stay normal? Why must everything that wasn't rainbow be rainbow? It's almost as infectious as the Book of Bill itself honestly. 😑

[@rainestorm6029]

@@Wendeta-hq2cp"now I'm not a homophobe or anything, just discard all of my comments where I called it degeneracy, but must you guys read into barely disguised subtext? It's Hannibal all over again"

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@rainestorm6029 Even degeneracy can be made artistically beautiful. Read "Une Charogne" by Charles Baudelaire and you'll see my point. It's disgusting, yet it also manages to be beautiful. Also phobia is a big word? Why would I be afraid of people that chose not to reproduce? An argument could be made that all the diseases spread could be frightening, but medicine had made them manageable. Nothing to fear anymore. Thanks for your politically charged comment. This is exactly the reason nobody likes rainbows anymore mate.

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@rainestorm6029 Even degeneracy can be made artistically beautiful. Read "Une Charogne" by Charles Baudelaire and you'll see my point. It's disgusting, yet it also manages to be beautiful. Also phobia is a big word isn't it? Why would I be afraid of people that chose not to reproduce? An argument could be made that all the diseases spread could be frightening, but medicine had made them manageable. Nothing to fear anymore.

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

@@rainestorm6029 Btw if you wondered why anything promoted by rainbows loses money, it's this: nobody wants to pay to be insulted with slurs like homophobe or other rubbish like that. Grow up.

[@interpolationz]

this would be an incredibly cool video if only credit were given to the users and communities that did the work to make these discoveries. as someone who used to be a massive fan of the channel this is something that has driven me away as a viewer over the years :( edit: glad to see credit added to the description, hopefully in the future it can be included in the original video itself :)

[@jacecurtis1090]

Description

[@mxth_114]

yooo, give credit to the people from the reddit and discord theories

[@jensrs]

14:22 also the bird singing in the background of the gravity falls lo-fi video that disney dropped a few weeks ago is a western meadowlark

[@dark_hood7]

yeah but the theory falls, you can see a bird landing on the statue's hand for a short moment in the last episode, and nothing happens and in a page on the site Ford says not even birds will come near it, a bit of a inconsistency there.

[@k.m.186]

Mm I think oracle just betrayed him canonically, I don’t think she’s his ex. There are two other likely candidates for the ex section based on the rest of the book. Firstly, it’s pretty clear he dated the void based on the interview paparazzi photo early on, and a code on a heart that says something like “missing the void” or smth off the top of my head. And his complicated relationship with Stanford is a pretty big theme of the book. Whatever “dimension” (haha) you think that it had, it’s still framed like a toxic relationship and breakup, with Bills meltdown at a bar after, the dating advice coincidently describing what Bill did to Ford, Mabel calling Bill a clingy ex, etc. While Ford is finally making steps to move on and find his own happiness, Bill is still obsessed and was forced into therapy. I don’t think it’s any of his exs hiding the codes, but it could be oracle, I think I like the lost souls better

[@evidence2839]

21:44 "ex girlfriend" that's just stanford pines, Jessie is obviously just a red hearing !!

[@piscestheaquamarinedragon1088]

XD no kidding. He literally got drunk and had a full weekend bender over Stanford. Not to mention all the strange "subtext that's not really subtext" in weirdmegedon (looking at you chain scene!). He's a clingy ex girlfriend who calls you in the middle of the night over "car trouble" and tries to get you to come over to help

[@yrreoaa]

the oracle or “jessie” just used to be a part of the henchmaniacs. i highly doubt that she’d, or he would be with someone like that. she most likely just left the group after seeing his and the others true side

[@dx.feelgood5825]

LITERALLY

[@haleybrown8197]

yall dumb, that would be BOYFRIEND. not girlfriend

[@dx.feelgood5825]

@@haleybrown8197 I beg you to look up the definition of a joke

[@hades6354]

I knew it was only a matter of time

[@BookApocalypse]

Time is dead and meaning has no meaning- bill.

[@theforgotten4295]

@@hades6354 You have alerted the hoard

[@kimmyko4207]

reported you so I hope you get off this platform​. Joseph1441-u1e

[@mephones_husband]

And jail is just a room

[@TheGreyShaman]

Time is just a 4D construct that stitches together 3D moments after all. It was literally only a matter of time before we found our way to these moments, I would hate to think of the alternatives I've left behind.

[@dubsthelongone213]

It’s disappointing that this man who matpat trusted and entrusted film theory to, blatantly ripped the script and info from the people who actually solved it with no credit. I know it’s happened before it’s just, disappointing.

[@backparker9264]

Honestly I had been avoiding the Theory channel because I knew something like this would happen but I’m a big GF fan so I gave this video a chance. Sorely upset that my presumption was correct. Is this just Film Theory though? How are the other theory channels doing?

[@TheVerdant01]

The description sites the Subreddit, at first glance

[@callmebrody]

@@backparker9264all the other channels have been doing fine

[@Moleje1337]

Nearly everything about the title thumbnail and video takes credit for solving the book. There is no real intention to share credit or site sources. We as an auidiance should expect better, this video is a hard example of blatant unapologetic plagerism.​@TheVerdant01

[@Matheus1234-k4n]

​@@Moleje1337Hi! They finnaly added credits look at the description!

[@TopEye64]

Not the straightification of Bill Cypher

[@awesomenova09]

Can you please credit the discord server members who solved so many of the codes? Thanks

[@haleybrown8197]

description

[@blobfish7109]

Please credit your sources!!! You make it sound like you and your team figured all this out, when most of it was taken from r/gravity falls and the gravity falls discord!

[@JohnDoe-hj9fh]

How do you know they didn't also figure it out?

[@plutoniumthemenace]

@@JohnDoe-hj9fh because theres literally video clips taken from people that solved it, and put in the video with no credit

[@JohnDoe-hj9fh]

@@plutoniumthemenace I don't know what video clips you're referring to but usually in a videomaking process, the script is already written before any editing is done so that doesn't prove they didn't also work it out

[@Bladedflame1]

@@JohnDoe-hj9fh direct quotes are taken word for word from the subreddit

[@blobfish7109]

@@JohnDoe-hj9fh the video clip they are referring to is the montage from the silly straws cipher, which was directly stolen from the discord. Not the idea to make a montage, but that exact video was what was taken.

[@Fukuzatsunayume]

It's pretty clear and obvious who bills actual ex is, like c'mon bro, did you read the book with your eyes closed?

[@Fukuzatsunayume]

It's like the book kept smashing us in the head over and over again on who's bills actual ex, and then still getting it wrong, it's on purpose at this point.

[@angel4174]

@@Fukuzatsunayumewhose his gf

[@Fukuzatsunayume]

@@angel4174 read the book

[@sarahtoninmg]

I mean people can have more than one ex Also a part two was mentioned in the video, it might be brought up then

[@Fukuzatsunayume]

@@sarahtoninmg i agree actually, but i feel like the second video is going to be more about the website.

[@elf0n]

I’m getting my Book Of Bill on the 7th of November :D

[@cowboydallas8208]

Thats great!

[@valhersa29]

Lee: “Bill’s ex-girlfriend!” Me: Me: You mean Ford????

[@Selpi_97]

Pensé lo mismo

[@gbaii_]

dead internet theory

[@ZelpyZap]

​@@gbaii_What is blud yapping about

[@hope.world.mp3845]

Honestly yall should’ve given credits to all the people who found the codes over on r/Gravityfalls before you got to make the video.. also the billford erasure is wild😭 ngl the Oracle being an ex gf really doesn’t make sense either

[@LeN-ix2du]

In th description :)

[@hope.world.mp3845]

@@LeN-ix2du I’m thinking they only did this after everyone started asking to give credits cause it wasn’t initially there

[@myloriv]

Lee made a post on Reddit addressing the credit issue

[@Purrtoes]

please credit the people who did the work

[@thelegendarytoaster8909]

Description

[@Purrtoes]

@thelegendarytoaster8909 yeah it didn't use to be like that. I think he also made an apology on reddit

[@DarknessGuard]

If there is a "Bill" multiverse, could there also be a "good Bill" helping out somewhere?

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

REVERSE FALLS COULD BE REAL!

[@cosmiccenter224]

"don't let Bill cipher steal your information " is kind of ironic when the information in this , word for word in some cases was stolen. while this video is great it does deserve to credit the community for coming together ✌️

[@Wendeta-hq2cp]

MatPat takes a step back and the mice already came out to play fr. This would have almost never happened were Mat still here.

[@CancerCell-n6g]

Also his ex could be Ford as it is hinted out through the whole book

[@FourteentheSkinEater14]

Hey, not to be rude, but most of this information wasn't cited by the theory team themselves, the lovely book of bill decoceders over on r/gravityfalls actually figured this out, but yet no credit is expressed in the video, it's incredibly important to credit the people who figure things like this out, instead of just blindly copying their own findings. Not just this video, but many of the theory videos this channel and the others have posted have stuff almost directly copied from orginial sources and slapped into a video with an audience of thousands so the orginial authority doesn't get credit where credit is due. I'm not saying that the nice people over at Game Theory and the other channels are liars and cheats, they just need to credit people, instead of blindly copying what others have already pointed out and regurgitating it to appease the algorithm.

[@thelegendarytoaster8909]

Description

[@hotsquidsummer]

no billford mention is crazy 😭

[@haleybrown8197]

*cricket noises*

[@_M.San.]

Hey, fine video but it'd be great to acknowledge and list credits for the various discoveries

[@laytonspuzzle]

Please credit r/gravityfalls and whatever other sources you used in the second part. Solving the book was a community effort, and designed to be as such, with more codes and cryptograms than could be picked apart by one person alone. Thank you.

[@TrimpOfRedwall]

you gotta love how so many comments are asking for credit that even the bots are stealing them. the cycle continues

[@demonpokemon13]

I now have a head cannon that the reason Bill is haunted by his dead family/friends is because they are a part of him. Like that would make sense to me based on the story of the square that learns about 3d space from the sphere. What if Bill tried to demonstrate 3d space but accidentally awoke a new power that amalgamated his friends and family into him to become the "faces" of a 3d form? O:

[@LakeGameCreepr]

Not giving credit to people on the subreddit and discord who solved all this stuff on day 1 😒

[@themrlupo3591]

Welcome to the internet, isn’t it great!

[@Andytheartist]

Description

[@captainsprinkles6557]

The description bruh

[@coItywoIty]

@@captainsprinkles6557they updated it after the comment

[@nightmarenikko]

Hey, where's the credit to the decoders at 18:03?

[@jazzlady9]

They are in the description

[@PersonYayyy]

The “ex” is Ford, they drop so many hints and lean in to the relationship between them HOW DID YOU NOT GET THAT

[@captainphantasma]

LITERALLY

[@ChaseVaccaro-ge3gk]

Right. Bill's idea of how to pick up a date? The ever iconic "We'll meet again" scene in the tip, described as the love cage.

[@raidahblossom]

Heteronormativity strikes again honestly-

[@haleybrown8197]

oh no this video doesn't have my ship i support that's obviously canon and not alot of people like! I need to comment right now!!!