What to know about Punishment in dog training? (oooh hotdogs!)

[@guilherme.k9]

Amazing! Thank you all for so much information and answers to so many questions involved in behavioral modification!

[@walkingwithwalterdogtraining]

Great stuff! I can only imagine the depth of the entire seminar.

[@joefish6546]

Very complicated, but i think in a nutshell, punishing such as an e collar nick won't overcome a behavior that has been established. But redirecting the behavior to something else will. For example train your reactive dog to come to a strict heal when they see another dog to try to override the explosive barking response.

[@hamseyasaad5363]

Its about breaking down that previously learned habbit to say react to other dogs by training new behaviours instead. And then when the dogs done it enough it and learnt the new behaviour "pavlov kicks in" which means the behaviour is conditioned permanatly. And once the new behaviour is learnt and understood by the dog thats when you can offer punishment (like an e coller stim) if they ever deviate away from what you taught them

[@CCOREY5]

And what if your reactive dog doesn’t want to redirect to come to you? Competing motivators…then what are you left with? Nothing. Your dog had just learned he doesn’t have to listen to you.

[@philipbriney4430]

Some k9s require a harder line, I kept mostly working line guard breeds most of my life including 18 years with a Timber wolf/ east german working line german shepherd cross and while you had better not abuse them these dogs need a harder hand. I am old now so keep Catahoulas, scent hounds and pitties because they are easier to handle.

[@nordics834]

very illuminating stuff, any way to get a hold of the full lecture anywhere?

[@LisaSimpsonLiberal]

great video!

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

Study the man's words don't say anything

[@skinnydogkew]

🤝

[@eliseholton9284]

🏁🎵

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

This stuff is basically p0rn to me 😂

[@bobbyabs2]

Too many $5 words. Lost me 45 seconds in

[@skinnydogkew]

Learn the words

[@logansilva8017]

I agree it doesn't need to be overcomplicated to such a degree that it sounds like nuclear physics or something. These guys totally geeked out on this one.

[@susanashley8454]

Sorry...it just can't be this complicated. I'll continue to follow Cesar Millan methods. They have worked time and time again for me.

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

What are u training ur dog to do?

[@susanashley8454]

@@CharlieTheCaneCorso Sit. Come. Stay.

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

@@susanashley8454 good luck

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

​@@susanashley8454Michael and Stewart are maybe 1 or 2 levels above the basic sit and stay u speak of

[@dereckgriffin3092]

This is high level highly specific professional dog trainer material not intended for people at home or even many dog trainers training well behaved dogs to pass AKC Obedience and Rally. So by all means stick with whatever method is currently working for you as there's no need for this material if you aren't dealing with in-depth dog training concepts revolving around reactivity.

[@rosscookson]

For a couple of guys who clearly interested in how a dogs mind works and how they (and people) learn - they are awful communicators. This was all too erratic with too much if their own language to follow. The main presenter was pausing expecting his audience to answer his questions and they weren’t responding, so I guess they were confused as well??

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

Genius isn't always easy to understand

[@gaileverett]

It appears to me that this is part of a workshop for professional dog trainers.

[@CharlieTheCaneCorso]

@@gaileverett professional dog trainers or just dog trainers in general me myself I'm just a obsessive hobbiest

[@andriano22]

Punishment for the own happiness¿?????? Positive or negative what for, do you wanted to make a soldier for invade Mars¿??????? You don't need to condition anyone