Game Theory: Gaster's Identity REVEALED! (Undertale)

[@tbhcreature_69]

You didn't mention it, but the Annoying Dog has been confirmed by Toby Fox to represent him. So if the Annoying Dog stole Papyrus's special attack, that means that Toby Fox intentionally chose not to reveal what the attack was but wanted us to know that he did remove it.

[@cavecastscorch]

...That also means he intentionally took Toriel's phone so we couldn't contact her after the ruins...

[@Max7345-i8m]

fetterkeks Near the beginning of the game, when Toriel tells you to wait for her while she goes shopping. If you wait long enough, you'll get a series of phone calls from her - one of which will indicate that her phone was stolen by a dog. She only gets it back once you venture far enough onward to trigger the first original phone call that would've been made if you just walked on anyway.

[@dimez3702]

Flynn Skordor yep

[@fetterkeks2796]

+Max Dunham Woah, and I thought I knew everything about that game already haha, thanks

[@mattiswan1]

Shinigami192837 could the dog being a bomb in mettatons minigame mean something?

[@GameTheory]

Where all my left brains at?

[@Mikachu_12]

The Game Theorists me!

[@JakeTreola]

Hi.

[@bolicob]

;)

[@lunamoonwisp]

The Game Theorists HEY

[@dylansalvador5495]

The Game Theorists here

[@Ben-sx6ew]

Cool thing: in the unused song "song that might play when you fight sans" Gaster's theme appears in your left ear when wearing headphones

[@demdem7946]

and in "Dating Start!" Gaster's Theme plays in the right.

[@xon3946]

@@demdem7946 LEFT BRAIN AND THE RIGHT BRAIN OMG BRUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHh

[@3L3CTR4H34RT]

True! (The base music in your left headphone)

[@3L3CTR4H34RT]

Also, it plays in Undyne’s theme, Ngahhhhhhhh!!!

[@suleimansghk]

arpeggio: *exist* undertale fans: *GASTER ALERT! GASTER ALERT!*

[@evelynnvernaz]

there was one little thing that didn't convince me about this theory: how could gaster and sans exist simultaneously? but then I thought about it gaster was fractured through TIME and space, so maybe those half fragments ended up in a past time before the experiment so gaster ended up meeting his own halves without realising, creating that way a weird loop where sans and papyrus wouldn't exist if gaster hadn't fallen into his creation which was made with the help of sans

[@DangerVA]

Oww... my head hurts..

[@El_Nit]

We know Gaster exist in our reality somehow, it could be his mind that trascended, While his body stayed and got fragmented in the bros, sorry if my english is not perfect lol

[@peteralford7608]

😐=my brain

[@justpeachy3668]

i think that sans is just his apprentice along with alphys and the theory is mostly just about being able to prove something ridiculous with essays along with just views LMAO

[@mketcookactus1837]

Waouw that's such a clever comment... You just explained the unique thing I didn't understand in this theory !

[@frog-xy2mj]

Dark.. Darker Yet darker... Sans please turn on the lights

[@JPKjamal4243]

"nah, if i do that it will mess up the entire timeline and probably drive matpat crazy"

[@lolliii5477]

me: ugh ksdniovfymhgdnubhmoitgvhmuefrhoudtgcrhegjhrkulitmugodumhiosemfyhiurhuirsfmuhvitmujgishiuheirum8hoiiho4w,jecioktpogejfi;sjfesmvihj,gise360nonscopehuidsrnyugvenkjghkfgmhkjgcs dkjcfhkjcfhe kjlfsjlpingasjhsiodghsauifcmhaufghdmskjlcghdsulgcdhskljfhkjlgh skdcgkh,dx,mdxdxdxk,dxk,dk,dfxdfxdldfxdfldfxl.fl.dfl.fl.ofl.fl.oldtrkldrkijmejmjmdexnjmjmjjmdjdjdjdfddddjfdrjmekdjmdejdxjmdrjmdrjdrjmdrxjmddjmdrxjdrkjdekjdekdejkdkctfdexjmnjmh *BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO_@#TIGEOrpghibufthvm8ovi5fhjvdrhg8fdnsiuovtrgeJDSBDNJHT$FEHRTEHR

[@ruthymeyer4423]

Where didn't it be cool if you could change your font to wings I wanna try that

[@DonQuixoteLaSangre]

@@lolliii5477 dummy

[@bongosbongos]

@@ruthymeyer4423 Unfortunately, fonts are decided by system settings and even if you manage to write in wingdings other peple would see it as a normal font.

[@hackerdackers8832]

Toby fox is probably laughing his head off at everyone trying to make sense of gaster

[@lindadowler718]

I see him now

[@Jim_Underscore]

hacker dackers he's laughing because the plot is messed up

[@drfrnknstn]

hacker dackers His face is probably the same as your profile picture😂

[@troll-slayer]

NerdyBadger OHHH MY FRICKING,GOD

[@Zarroxius]

NerdyBadger OHHHHHHHH My God

[@andormak8402]

Also: Temmie sees another timelines. The price of the Temy Armor becomes lower when you die, but your death doesn't happen because you LOAD.

[@redender8881]

:0

[@accuratememin]

:0

[@zeldaenby224]

:0

[@ratamiauwu1724]

:0

[@Nerine98]

:0

[@Pnc531]

Sans knowing about the sun has always been a mystery to me. It’s possible that he just forgot the word for it, but none of the other monsters seem to have seen it before. Strange.

[@OllyTheLion]

First like✨

[@Popedishsoap]

That’s because sans undertale is actually sans deltarune

[@mrarticcatman]

the monsters used to live on the surface before so they probably used the same word as humans did

[@GamercatsTRUE]

@@mrarticcatmanyeah they probably passed down the name or maybe Asriel when he died told them they called it the sun

[@ahmedaroosh4671]

well the monsters know what it is just not what it looked like

[@Endershock1678]

OMG, a three parter is actually released, it exists!!! IS THE WORLD ENDING??!!!?!?!

[@theneekofficial8829]

Endershock1678 lol

[@mtoezani9753]

Endershock1678 lol

[@2Garins]

Endershock1678 lol

[@breadifies2800]

Endershock1678 nope, the universe is :D

[@queenkatara7861]

No. It will be the end of the world when Doctor who part three comes out.

[@mayevestorm7622]

One thing.... SANS' EYE. HIS GLOWING EYE ON GENOCIDE. It glows from the left side. We don't see Papyrus' "Special Attack" and never see his eye(s) glow. If this theory is correct, I believe that his special attack would make his RIGHT eye start to glow, as well as unveil a power we never truly see from him. This could be mindless deduction, but I think that I'm on to something.

[@rruzgarr97]

Remember how undyne's covered eye started to glow during undyne the undying fight? Maybe papyrus gave his eye to a dear friend. I know that he has his own eyes, but just hey thats just an idea..

[@rruzgarr97]

He also says "Wheres my special attack" so meh

[@yuuka4964]

Leah Rowbury you got the right idea, friend. You'll make a good theorist at some point.

[@idontwantahandle-o9d]

BingletonTV that's just a theory A GAME THEORY!

[@davidmiller7177]

Leah Rowbury there's a fangame when papyrus uses it on a genocide run because you kill sans

[@shadowruby7728]

MatPat: *tells a bad joke* Left Brain: *wHeEzEs*

[@_goldfish]

400th like! *WHERE IS MY GIFT CARD!?*

[@pjatm_]

600th like! *WHERE IS MY GIFT CARD!?*

[@jexilus_]

700th like! Where is my father he left to get milk 26 years ago and hasn't come back

[@randomppl6380]

I tried to pranked ma m8 with wingdings(WORKED BETTER THAN I THOUGHT)

[@fortissimoh8641]

I am the right brain I am the right brain

[@MrDandelionGraves]

One of the cool concepts that I've found myself believing is that Sans and Pap were less CREATED by Gaster's split, and more that they took on ASPECTS he lost in being shattered. That Papyrus wasn't precisely a SCIENTIST, but maybe more of an engineer, given his apparent ability to create puzzles and the bookcase with fluffy bunny and advanced puzzle making. Sans, on the other hand, seems very much a scientist by trade. I think they were the ones most compatible for whatever reason. And so in them, a piece of him was stored. An aspect. A fragment. But that is just speculation ^-^

[@OllyTheLion]

10th like😁

[@lapisdragon1237]

A game speculation!

[@RainbowBaconisballing]

you mean THATS JUST A THEORY,A GAME THEORY

[@enbysandmusic217]

Why must I be the 69th like

[@JeanBeanStudios]

One detail you missed: sans is making puns because he’s the left side of the brain, he is trying to make an attempt at feeling emotions like his ‘brother’

[@Rogue_Rouge2]

I thought it was because he is depressed

[@JeanBeanStudios]

@@Rogue_Rouge2 this is game therory my guy. . . It gets darker than that.

[@Skippymcskep]

@@JeanBeanStudios dark darker yet darker

[@JeanBeanStudios]

@@Skippymcskep ahhhyyyyyyyy

[@SixTwentyTree]

I think it's because he's both depressed and what you think that he's trying to be "happy" or feel emotion. Maybe idk my small brain cells only came to see sans

[@rangedweevil6150]

Sans has knowledge and some control over time: he is aware of timelines, saves and resets, can allegedly stop time, teleport, and knows you can "time travel". On the flipside, Papyrus is aware of space. He knows about the river person and snowman when no one else acknowledges them, he can tell you anything about the world whenever you call him; he can manipulate physics (he can make your soul susceptible to gravity, and we also see him float/ walk on air after your pacifist fight). He just seems less powerful because he has no desire to harm. Papyrus is emotion and sans is logical. Makes sense. Maybe they're just foils of each other

[@Ratigan2]

he also explains you the controls when you don't move your SOUL while battling him

[@skylarchung6681]

Papyrus’ floating was meant as a joke (I think). It’s quite a stretch. However, the rest of your theory seems completely plausible. (Yes I know this was 3 months ago and probably no one will see this)

[@rangedweevil6150]

@@skylarchung6681 I overanalyze every detail. It's kind of what I do as a theorist; if it happens in the game's canon, I consider it a notable detail whether it's a joke or not (but in retrospect it was hilarious). Thanks for seeing my mini-theory just the same

[@Advokaiser]

Wow. Could this mean that Gaster being shattered across "time" and "space" was not actually the 'time' and 'space' as we know them, but as in Sans being the embodiment of time and Papyrus the embodiment of space?

[@rangedweevil6150]

@@banditbaws in the pacifist route, when you first enter waterfall, you can go have lunch with him at grillby's. When doing so, all of a sudden, the music stops, everyone stops moving and it's just the two of you in a spotlight when he asks you if you've heard of a talking flower. People have taken this as him stopping time for everyone except you and him inside that circle.

[@MartinHindenes]

14:07 Three smiling people with the words "don't forget" Deltarune: 3 heroes who will save the world

[@RedNayl]

"Three smiling PEOPLE with the words don't forget"

[@RedNayl]

Like sure, Susie calls her self a person in the game. but just ignore that because I enjoy telling people they are wrong.

[@prodfife]

Yup. Anyone remember the last line of the credits song? "Don't forget, I'm with you in the dark." And also, the badge in Sans' drawer? Undyne was a cop in Deltarune... What if Deltarune is the timeline where/just after Gaster splits into two halves? That's why Sans has the badge and the picture of 3 people...so he won't forget that day and thus won't forget his Gaster form?

[@MartinHindenes]

@@prodfife Oh, good observation! That's really interesting. I'm betting sans shares memories across the different timelines somehow.

[@alexmcclellan7049]

Or gaster and the 2 people he was referencing in text box 17, or maybe those 2 are sans and papyrus, maybe they originally looked like that but part of gasters soul was put into them with the machine

[@jacoblee5483]

There's one more thing that makes this theory solid - the amalgamates themselves. Studying determination was not the end goal of the experiments - having the ability to merge monsters was. Sans and Papyrus, if they really are WD Gaster, would be the only monsters known who would be able to gain from these experiments.

[@OllyTheLion]

32nd like💜

[@Dr.Gehrig]

Oh that's genius! I always thought it was about keeping dying monsters alive... and I suspect some of the experiments were. But the merging experiments clearly appear to be ways to turn Sans and Papyrus back to Gaster.

[@saucempossem9335]

Undertale: *exists* Matpat: I dont need sleep, I need answers

[@lucalucian1961]

But an coffee blaster won't really!

[@JennKirkland]

any game: exists matpat: i don’t need sleep i need answers

[@princfelix6816]

@@JennKirkland and especially FNaF

[@snowflake_18]

I think that's everyone in this fandom at some point lol

[@wolfsanimated]

Oh boi

[@bigolbootay5523]

Not to mention that both sans and papyrus are the only monsters (as mettaton's a robot ghost) who don't visibly or audibly show a monster soul. Papyrus doesn't have one when killed in game and sans turns to dust without the usual heart(soul?) breaking sound. But that's just a comment! A largely ignored and disregarded comment! Thanks for reading!

[@nekomaster1000]

Undyne?

[@marcocarrasco7002]

"Audibly" yes, Sans does when he dies

[@sparks-of-magic]

Mordo no he doesn't, he walks off before we see it.

[@sinn030]

nekomaster1000 She's a fish

[@boringgamer5809]

Big 'Ol Bootay nobody shows there soul only boss monsters do and they technical do show there souls when they "die" during the asrial fight

[@yitam8375]

Conclusion: don't watch Gaster-related things before sleeping

[@w.d.gaster8881]

N̷̢̢̢̨̧̡̨̨̡̢̡̢̡̡̨̢̡̨̙̦̼͉̦͇̤̻̱̟̺̫̙͔̞͚͈̺͖͚̼̞̗̣̯̲̫̘̝̰̙͕̝̲̰̣̭̫̠̝̱̳͚̲̯̦̱̥̜̹͉̻̮̟̻͎̰͕̠̮͈̞̮̙̫̼̲̻̻͕͎̱̰̟̰̳͖͙̪̙͔͖͚͙͈̺͓̘̘̦̖͍̻̪̺̙̞̗̣̞̪͈̘̭̦̟͇̞͕̖̜̼̯͈̜̮̜̹̩͉͙̯̩͇̜̩̰̙̜̥̦͍̝̟̬̣̟͔̤̺̖̝͎̜̭͔̹͙̟̩͕̝̣̠̖̙̗̣̘̿̊̈́́͑̿̉̇̒̕̕͜͜ì̵̡̢̨̢̢̨̧̡̨̢̡̧̛̯͖̞̻͍̫̮͉̞̥͍̲͓̱̜̩͚̺̠̞̲͎̮͉̙͈̹̲͕̱̩͇̪̙̜̰̦̙͙̣̼̝̳̳͍͚̹͈̖̺͔̫̲̱̬̖̬̭̣͚̪̖̠̬̟̥͎̤̙͓͙̲̹͔͔̝̙͍̞̬̪̪͎̭̺̺̤̗̜̭͇̮̪̹͇̭͕͙͈̜̦̈̿̍͛͋̉̔͛̓̍͋̿͛͌̍͒̎͂̎̇͆͋̽̐̆͑̇̋̈́̽̐̄̋̕͘͘̕̚͜͠͠͝͝͠ͅͅͅͅg̴̡̨̡̡̧̨̨̢̡̨̨̡̨̡̢̢̛̛̛̛̥̜̦̠̗̞̞̘̦̥̺̖̥̞̣͈̹͎̲͉̯̪̣̜̥̰̖̤̬͇̰̣͇͍̥̼̰͚̣̭͈͉̦̺̮̻̗͖̥̣͍̦̣̟͙̻̲͉̞̯̤̦͎̤̦̲͔̜̠̪̭̜̞̞̼͔̘̮̞̬̭͕̥̹̗̰̙̹̪̩͖̬͎̙̩͖͉̦̭͇̦͈̬̟̮͕͓͖̘̗̜̻͙̞͈̩͉̪͕͖̣͇͖̝̭̫͍̝͕̐̐̂̀̄̊̇̓͋̉̔͆̔̇̐̾͋̽̇̑̓̿̍́͛̊̓̍̀̓̃̊̐̊̍̽̔̽̿͑̑͗̿͊̓̐͋̽͛͊͌̉̓̒̒̈́̏̇̃̍́͛̓̆͒̌̾̐̐̀͐̏̓̈̓̀̅̆̓́̅͐͋̒̑̄̆̓̇͑͒̄̀͂͛̏͋͂̈̒̋͛̓͛̓́̈̎̊̆̾̽̍̃̋̃̉͗̚̕̚͘̕̕͘͘͘̚͘͜͝͝͝͝͝͝͠͠͝h̸̢̢̨̡̨̨̡̡̢̧̨̛̛̰̩̥̮̦͈̤̳̟̦̬͎̗̺̫̮̳͇̱̹̼̗͈̙͕̦̬̻̯̣̭͎͓͈͚͓͉̥͉̻̻̗̳̥̠̠̣̞̫̺̼̣̥͖͔̣̭̮̜̪̲̜̥̩͕̪̮̞̟̗͉͉̜̺̟̠̲̖̼̬͚͇͙̗̺̝̺̲̲̜̜̲̻̙͎̳̹̗̗̣͈̠͖͎͍̬̠̙̫̙̫̼̙̭̱̙̦̪͕̥̤̯̉̃̃̔̇̃̀̏͂͂̊́̅̀̇̄͆̈́̈́̾̽͛̔̓̅̐̈̐̒̇̓̐̇̓̽͊͊͋̅͗͐̃͛̀̐̐͌̆̀̐̐̉̔̊͋̈́̈̃̓̆̋́̚̚͘̕͘͘͜͜͜͜͠͝͠͠͝ͅt̵̨̡̛͙̬̮̳̪̥͓̥̏̔͗͛̆̀̋̍̂̎̇͑͌͂̏̊͂̍̈́͋̀̈́̋̊̈́̈̍̈́͐̂͗͑͐̓̎̇͆͌͋́̾̿̽̍͆̇̐́̑̌̇̅̅̈̊̔̀̋́̋̅̽͆͘͘̕͝͠͝

[@An0nimations]

☝︎⚐︎⚐︎👎︎ ☠︎✋︎☝︎☟︎❄︎

[@yitam8375]

At least i tried 😅🤷

[@dislikeallmyvideosyoulittl5797]

@@w.d.gaster8881 let's say Nyeh together

[@nothereforeverydamnthing2346]

Come on it's not scary at all... compared to going through the True Lab for the first time. I mean it. I've just finished the game the other day and the unsettling feelings still linger after the encounters with the Amalgamates.

[@avagroves1311]

In Sans and Papyrus’ house the joke book in the corner actually contains a quantum physics book - further confirming your theory

[@bearussell2444]

That quantum physics book contains a joke book, which contains a quantum physics book that contains a joke book…you decide to stop looking.

[@Mel-oc4oe]

I don’t know if you realised this but as you can see the colour of sans’ jacket is blue and papyrus’ costume is mostly red. As some people know the two sides of the brain are represented with two colours red and blue. According to Bo Burnham’s song the right brain is represented with the colour red and the left brain is represented with the colour blue. And as Mat claims Sans is the left and Papyrus is the right brain. So this may show that Toby Fox created the characters this way so he left a hint in their design. Idk this is my theory

[@insertverycoolusernamehere]

Im two months late but thats a great theory

[@Mel-oc4oe]

Thank you （＾ω＾）

[@Mel-oc4oe]

Omg thanks for 101 likes

[@emas5511]

a brain theory, thanks for reading

[@ch-trapathii]

nice theory

[@GameTheory]

4,000 comments and 21 views? Gaster BROKE KZbin!

[@jameseckert631]

LOL! ( I know I'm slightly late but) NOTIFICATION SQUAD!

[@user-vo5ux4fi6f]

You're amazing honestly i love your videos

[@spiriiit7239]

+James Eckert same!

[@hobbokin706]

The Game Theorists Yep!! He doing it!

[@haileyquinn1041]

GOSH DARN IT GASTER!! LEAVE KZbin ALONE!!!

[@773Spair]

Asgore may also have some awareness of space and time manipulation. *You tell Asgore he has killed you [x] times. *Asgore sadly nods

[@rachelboateng7159]

T-T

[@danielwoods8263]

He also destroyed my mercy button :(

[@VivosaurACE]

Omg someone else noticed plus toriel says do you know something I dont could be her hinting at it too

[@Enr0_]

@@VivosaurACE wasnt that sans who said that?

[@VivosaurACE]

@@Enr0_ no i she said it idk if its cause i reset or skipped through her dialouge though

[@rylanthestrange146]

Honestly, if Sans truly is one half of the previous Royal Scientist, it would make even more sense as to why Toriel is the only other person he cares about besides Papyrus. I always thought it rather odd that he'd have such a strong bond with her just because she was laughing at his jokes through a door, strong enough to promise her he'd protect the player character despite us being human.

[@turtleking7772]

Can we take a moment to appreciate the fact that Sans and Papyrus look like their fonts? Sans is curved and Papyrus has sharper edges. Just neat attention to detail

[@startingriotz]

He already mentioned that lol

[@lean572]

@@startingriotzNo, he mentioned the fonts were the same

[@bxvin9788]

IM UR 666TH LIKE

[@bxvin9788]

THIS HAS ALREADY HAPPENED TO ME TWICE IN THE SAME WEEK

[@rcraw6447]

Ashura Naruto......I’m sorry my child........goodbye

[@X-SPONGED]

The annoying dog is a representation of Toby Fox, he continuously steals papyrus's special attack so the players can't know what it is

[@someonehep015]

Too late to get pinned 🙄

[@STB4G]

T O N Y F O X

[@elisabethsun7059]

It’s probably a Gaster Blasters

[@chicken5282]

Or Toby fox can’t think of a cool special attack.

[@necronlordoflawtan]

To explain one thing that Matpat missed: The creation/machine that Gaster fell into is not a Determination injection machine, but a DT *Extraction* machine. It removes determination. Now, when monsters are injected with determination, they fuse with more matter/dust/monsters, and start to melt. Naturally, extraction of Determination could split a monster soul/body/mind. Thus you'd get two* monsters and the original husk, split on personality and ability. sans having greater power, Papyrus being, as Undyne put it, "pretty freaking tough." Now, as for the Husk and journal entry, I'd imagine what was left of the original Gaster, effectively empty of determination, tried to quickly fix himself by injecting determination. He recovers temporarily (as did Alphys's test subjects), and made the final entry while talking to Papyrus and sans. Then he began to melt. Who knows what sans and Papyrus did afterwards - trying to "go back" or "fix Gaster"...but ultimately, Gaster became a melted memory. Now, Memory is a good choice of words, as there is one other monster tied to Gaster: Memoryhead. Memoryhead is an amalgamate, but the only one to not resemble any known monster. It has a faint resemblance to a Gaster Blaster fused with a brain. It's bullet attacks summon smiling white faces (Gasters?). It has no physical substance - it talks through your phone and gains health by absorbing your attack. Also, a phrase it says is "Lorem ipsum docet", while a filler phrase in code, translates to "Pain teaches." Now, how did Gaster split into more than 3? Well, there are two possibilities. Firstly, Gaster is split across time and space, leaving "memories" of himself. Alternatively, they could be the remains of a Gaster who is soulless. Either way, the three Memoryheads confirm the sans-papyrus-gaster group.

[@jonathanjaca5778]

yap

[@francescosorce5189]

Mythology Squirrel Sir... You're a genius...

[@gabrielkhalil9362]

What if papyrius tried so many times saving gaster and change the timeline that he simply forgot about most of the stuff?

[@deltastar4147]

Mythology Squirrel also that the DT machine looks like Omega flowey

[@lemon8546]

Mythology Squirrel bruh I wish I could read that but it's too long XD

[@ip0clyps92]

Its great how MatPat makes actual quality content, this is quite literally the death of most theory channels

[@ilovemeatd8469]

Game theory: has an actual theory that has like 30 essays to back it up Me: well Gaster kinda looks like a skeleton sooo....HOLY CRAP Gaster’s sans’s father :0

[@ActuallyFlamey]

MatPat discovers coincidences, but gets nothing useful.

[@The_Wither_Boss]

This what I know and not only sans but Paps too

[@cocoapowder2]

@@ActuallyFlamey sorry man, that's what a theory is.

[@AN-in4vt]

@@ActuallyFlamey You're really toxic huh?

[@funfact2186]

@@AN-in4vt I respect the pun

[@tabjl958]

7:17 Like... "Deltarune"?

[@TheManInBlueFlames]

OMG You're here too. Don't forget!

[@tabjl958]

About.. wat? @@TheManInBlueFlames

[@graysonhuffman469]

Ehhdjsfdbejdhwkdjbdueheis WHAT

[@lukemaguire9123]

Yep exact same thought was gonna comment it but you got there first. Well done Brian

[@Alex-cz3te]

You son of bitch

[@barometer5156]

And also, you might have missed sans's LEFT eye glowing.

[@raven_isnotok9928]

Our right his left

[@wariothief]

Barometer thats right but maybe thats even a part of the three episodes

[@SpiralAnimationssssss]

BUT ITS HIS RIGHT EYE anyway it doesn't connect it's just that sans is blind in his left eye

[@idk-gl6yl]

Its left not right since hes looking at you but when looks back its now left

[@SpiralAnimationssssss]

@@idk-gl6yl oooooh

[@daxdot601]

3:16 Learning from school: ❌ Learning from Matpat: ✔

[@Idontknowwhattowrite150]

( Meanwhile in the void )Gaster: Interesting theory

[@kevinsooley9674]

Gaster

[@Idontknowwhattowrite150]

@@kevinsooley9674 Gaster: ( Uses Wingdings as a skateboard cuz he has nothing else to do )

[@josemuniz5861]

True tho

[@wingdinggaster17]

…How are you guys watching me in the Void?

[@Ridham412]

@@wingdinggaster17 there is a way to get you back always be confident every dream come true the way to get you back home is...............to put all your scatterd pices in one timeline but.............ther-(:( error conflicted system reloding)

[@Ireneforsyte1]

Another thing that I found, is that Papyrus' main color of clothing is orange, whilst Sans' main color of clothing is blue. Orange and blue are complete opposites on the color wheel. That's not mentioning the fact that they are complete opposites in other ways. Sans is short, Papyrus is tall; Sans' font is rounded and small, while Papyrus' is tall and sharp; even Sans' speech is more humanoid-ish and deep, while Papyrus has a higher, more metallic sound to his diologue speech patterns.

[@rowanourboat2900]

I agree with the majority of this theory, but I've studied art and seen many colour wheels. From what I have seen brown is actually on the opposite side of the colour wheel as blue.

[@adrianortizurzua7884]

In the more colloquial, sense, orange is the opposite of blue in the color wheel without getting too much into specifics like you seemed to have done. It's meant to say on the opposite sides of the color wheel: warm and cool colors. Not DIRECTLY opposed to each other.

[@pop12Viper]

don't forget to mention the attacks of blue and orange are "don't move" and "move" in fights to add to the opposites claim

[@Cinereal12]

RowanYourBoat art or science? physical colors and light are COMPLELY different. You mix normal colors together, you get brown. You mix the colors of light together and get white. In normal color, green and red are opposites. In light, green and pink are opposites. This is scientific, so sorry Rowan, but your comment is just invalid.

[@zyronltz7494]

Da Nerd Tront chill bruh

[@huh1723]

Sans has his blue eye on the left

[@nono7120]

Ye

[@rillik527]

Yep same as Gaster's right eye is A bit or more broken and left eye is fine

[@raccoonboye5361]

And btw in depictions of papyrus having a glowing eye it is on the right but it may just be a coincidence idk

[@tylergrove3639]

Wow i didn't think of that

[@evastassi3165]

Why matpat not pin dis???

[@Faire_Natt]

I really like watching these theories, because even tho there are parts of the theory that don't really convince me, I can grab what does convince me and re-arange that into something that makes sense to me and something I like.

[@marbenmin5878]

Big info: Matpat, if you play through on the pacifist run on the Nintendo switch, in the epilogue you get something BIZZARE! If you go back to Clam Girl in the epilogue she tells you something strange, for starters Clam Girl has always talked about a character known as Susie and we never knew who the character was until Deltarune came along. So if you do this she says, "So you never met my neighbor's daughter But please don't despair. Because the time that you will meet her..." Then she turns into a Gaster follower version of herself and says "...Is fast approaching." I know it's not much to go on, but this might mean that Deltarune is gonna have some connections to the story of what happened to Gaster! People are saying that Deltarune might be a different timeline from Undertale, and Gaster has a lot to do with timelines, so this is definitely some interesting information.

[@nolabarker8751]

dang you made a really good theory so many good pieces

[@marbenmin5878]

Thank you, and I don't take ALL the credit, I saw someone doing an easter egg video on Deltarune and they mentioned this Clam Girl thing, I thought it was interesting.

[@nolabarker8751]

@@marbenmin5878 either way its really cool

[@marbenmin5878]

Yeah it is cool to know that Deltarune might have a much bigger story with Gaster than Chara (Which everyone seems to suspect because of the ending.)

[@nolabarker8751]

@@marbenmin5878 ya I'm really getting I'm to it

[@cheetodust9902]

3:22 [Bo Burnham "Left Brain, Right Brain" intensifies] Sans: I am the left brain. Papyrus: I LIKE OREOS AND P-

[@Kai-ci1ch]

-EOPLE! YES! IN THAT ORDER!

[@cheetodust9902]

@@Kai-ci1ch In that entire order.

[@ChaosEnthusiast]

pancakes?

[@theanarchistocelot1620]

Yes

[@metalkitten6665]

PASTA

[@minimighty3334]

* (It’s a poorly drawn picture of three smiling people.) * (Written On it. . .) * “don’t forget” deltarune reference before deltarune? deltarune’s main protagonists are Kris, Susie, And Ralsei. Three characters. The picture isn’t of just any amount, but of _three_ smiling people. “don’t forget” This is the final song you hear in deltarune. It’s theme is heard in many other songs. Much like Once Upon A Time from UNDERTALE, Don’t Forget is heard a lot in deltarune. The main song of each game. Sans makes an appearance in deltarune. Perhaps in chapter 2 or later chapters he will have a larger role. This could explain why these are found in the workshop at _his_ house.

[@mimikyutie696]

This seems plausible, I read somewhere that Toby even said that he was working on deltarune before undertale. Note: I just heard this somewhere, don’t know if it’s true or not

[@gooigipie4390]

@@mimikyutie696 Thats true.

[@abby-xs1jo]

I think Deltarune happens before Undertale, which is why Sans has these photos in undertale. Sans and Papyrus can't forget or they'll end up like the goner kid, and they won't remember Gaster OR their previous lives in Deltarune. Sans wants to go to a previous time where he wasn't a part of Gaster and didn't have to deal with all this crap.

[@haslindakinnies8584]

It's either Gaster, Sans and Papyrus or Gaster, Sans and Alphys I think

[@haslindakinnies8584]

But that is also somehow linked to Deltarune

[@Prepetual_Studio]

This is an amazing theory it shows how much work you put into the episodes and how much time and effort it takes to edit them for us to watch. Amazing Mattpat just amazing

[@hamzadamra02]

I clicked the video so fast, that my phone shattered across time and space 8)

[@enderallygolem]

Who typed that comment then?

[@hamzadamra02]

Gaster did 8)

[@duckyduck2082]

GDmasterRACE You shouldn't have bought a note 7 they are lethal AF.

[@hamzadamra02]

Ducky Duck RSC lol XD

[@TheTrueSpottedStripe]

I think I have your phone....inside my head, ohh look contacts.

[@debornmc]

*UNDERTALE* is spelled in **caps** while *deltarune* is spelled in **lowercase** Another sans and Papyrus reference...?

[@purpleponder]

SkyPixelMC Sans made deltarune

[@puffball2059]

also they are anagrams

[@Matt-md9oz]

Deltarune is undertale jumbled

[@rainfellforu]

That explains why sans has his own store in deltarune

[@mellow_mallow]

@@rainfellforu and why papyrus is just hiding out in the house (you knock on the door and hear the "distant trousle of bones") while sans stands out front and does all the socializing.

[@Left_Moss]

I just realised. In the basement it says "dont forget." And in the credits song of deltarune at the end of the song, the singer says "Dont forget, I'm with you in the dark." I think it is a hint twards Ghaster telling Sans and Papyrus that he is still with them.

[@littlekaro2005]

That was the most simple yet heartwarming theory 🥺

[@levelevelyn2463]

@@littlekaro2005 I’m not crying you are 🥺

[@masterbeta1089]

the main leitmotif (leifmotif whatever however you spell it) of deltarune is titled “dont forget”

[@syndromeofadown21]

* (It's a poorly drawn picture of three smiling people.) [Kris, Susie, and Ralsei] * (Written on it...) * "don't forget." [Deltarune's main lietmoteif]

[@elisabethsun7059]

Nice

[@ryotoy.w.7195]

I also think that Flowey had a little bit of Gaster's pieces, and maybe got a little bit by accident when he was revived by Alphys.

[@F4T4L3RR0R]

Toby: good luck on gaster! Game theory: hold my beer

[@raananmogensen1930]

Hold my beer nah hold my Diet Coke

[@roooo4616]

Game theory: Hold ma diet coke can

[@F4T4L3RR0R]

@Ryan Yang *goes into scientific stuff with beer*

[@theradioman5182]

"So why doesn't [Papyrus] have Gaster Blasters?" Underswap: "Let me introduce myself."

[@rabiiess]

Yeet

[@eggegg531]

underswap is still a thing??? i remember being into that in 2016

[@theradioman5182]

@Egg Egg I'm pretty new to the fandom. Also, I feel like Underswap and Underfell are 2 of the really famous AU's, which for some reason I cannot find a full version of on Game Jolt.

[@eggegg531]

@@theradioman5182 thats so cool!! im glad to see the aus that i loved are still going strong :)

[@crypticult4148]

No

[@bubblegum8845]

I literally cant even believe undertale is a thing sometimes like theres just so much content omg

[@minor4890]

same im getting back into it right now, i was into it like, 5 years ago and didnt realize how much depth it had. now getting back into it, it's like.... woah

[@sundararakuen682]

I just got into it and lately ive been getting fed well with the content

[@minor4890]

@@sundararakuen682 HELP IM RUNNING OUT OF CONTENT

[@sundararakuen682]

@@minor4890 STOP LOOK FOR MORE HURRY GOGOGO

[@justaperson4656]

@@minor4890 well I mean, there is deltarune, but it isn't as full of content

[@sminly0436]

When papyrus talks about his special attack going missing....could it be the one flowey has?

[@justvibingg-yt]

If colours are worth anything, the red of papyrus and blue of sans makes the purple of the lab

[@packrunnerjaystan3613]

Pretty Geek dis true

[@Treatkiller1]

lol yep

[@YukiShiro13]

True...

[@gjk-arts5855]

True...

[@spiffy6845]

More things that make them connected to the lab

[@guyinbluu]

I can only accept this theory if Gaster makes bad science puns and hates himself for it.

[@ruphite9521]

ShadowSpin can you imagine lol

[@torazely]

gaster: hey, why can you never trust an atom? alphys:*sighs* why? Gaster: because they make up everything! alphys:... gaster:... alphys:... gaster: if I do that again, slap me.

[@ruphite9521]

Ignatius Ultimus *alphys throws gaster into the core

[@torazely]

TyceGaming and that's how he broke apart and became sans and papyrus.

[@IsabruhMoment]

*Gaster stands at the edge of the Core.* Gaster: Alphys don't push me in! Alphys: LONG LIVE THE KING. Gaster: Wha-*shove*-AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[@itsvioneko]

"Sans and Papyrus are more than mere brothers" *FBI open up*

[@sugarcoatedlauren253]

LAW AND ORDER SPECIAL VICTIMS UNIT

[@that1guythatdrankwater806]

I was the 100th like yay

[@maro0532]

If both of them are gaster does it mean it’s selfcest??

[@itsvioneko]

Marochi 0445 Oh god OH FU-

[@pqjsmzhwdidigsbrlsyahwnwue8439]

Handplates anyone? Remarkably similar...

[@sophieyounger3682]

"Scientific with the Skelebros" Now that's a podcast I'd listen to

[@professorpicklesphd.8312]

8:48 "holds and drinks a ketchup bottle" (sin counter: 1)

[@azeezaaziz7542]

Animation/Cinema sins

[@Dragon-lv9xi]

You don’t drink ur ketchup bottles??

[@brainrunbygoblin]

whut

[@curtisleblanc5897]

I drink pickle juice. I am not joking.

[@rexeust]

ah yes, my favorite drink, kEtChUp BoTtLe

[@soluna4784]

6:53 did anyone else actually try to solve the word search and realize that "giasfclfebrehber" isn't actually in the puzzle? the first line of letters says g i a s f c l f *U* b r e h b e r in the list of words it's an "e", not a "u". sO iT's UnSoLvAbLe

[@justjamie1855]

@i kxrms a game theory! !

[@chibi5694]

(Music)

[@lemonthepogboi5351]

Ah damn it I thought I solved it until I found this comment

[@eggdog8330]

I don’t like you, I thought I solved it You ruined my accomplishment

[@jackfoster4935]

I thought he was going to mention that. If sans is the logical side of the brain, he would have more trouble getting past an unsolvable puzzle. Making it the hardest thing for him personally.

[@usernameisusernam]

I'm still wondering why flowey was talking to papyrus Edit: I am an idiot

[@CoolioStuffz]

Alright so, flowey used Papyrus to get information, for example... how do you think flowey got ur phone number at the end of true lab, Papyrus. Flowey can manipulate him easily. Also, before you fight Asriel... Papyrus said that he got everyone together because ‘a tiny flower’ helped him, meaning flowey.

[@febbledebble]

Flowey manipulated Papyrus to get information about you.

[@inkspillled]

wait, but... it's revealed that flowey has been talking to papyrus _before_ the date where he gives you his number, so..? i mean, it probably happened afterwards but we dont really hear about the flowey-papyrus communication much after that

[@febbledebble]

@@inkspillled After your "date" with Alphys that eventually ends up with you being the human for Alphys and Undyne instead (lol) you are back in the garbage dump. As you leave you receive a weird and suspicious phone call from Papyrus (you remember that one) where he says he "sent Alphys home, very home, to her lab house" it's very obvious that someone told Papyrus to call you, and that someone would be Flowey, wanting you to progress.

[@_ayoitsvic_3180]

Also, in one of flowey's after game dialogues, he mentions how Paypyrus is "one of the good ones" and how he would repeatedly talk to him and how it took him a very very long time to get bored of him.

[@blackthornejoshua2929]

I'm literally convinced. Perhaps my bias leans me towards loving any mystery long after the story concludes but man it seems too true to deny. This is Canon now

[@hecktangle6578]

papyrus when he slips up: “ah crap now matpats gonna dissect me and my game.”

[@Treviisolion]

If you ever decide to do another undertale theory, why don't you try and figure out how fights work. I've always wondered what it means as your soul moves and asgore destroys you mercy button, and not only that, but why Sans is the only one smart enough to dodge, why you can't attack back when it's not your "turn," why the monsters (including Sans) leave holes in their attacks when Sans also demonstrates with his "Get Dunked On" that he can just create a box of bones, and why they even let you have turns in the first place if they're trying to kill you and you can easily kill them. To anyone saying that this is just a game and I'm over analyzing it: First, why are you on this channel?? Second, this game is meant to have lore explanations of every mechanic used and the characters demonstrate their knowledge of your fight screen, and the date/hangout screen. Third, (insert reason here). Please upvote if you agree.

[@factualgamor3738]

I would just agree, but if the monsters didn't give you a turn the game would suck, and maybe sans knows something that let's him fill the box with an attack. Or maybe we are just overanalyzing it.

[@crystaldee7185]

Trevyn Case *third, (insert reason here)* Instant upvote

[@yasiromar888]

Trevyn Case maybe frisk let's his guard down for a moment and Sans takes the chance to dunk on them

[@Treviisolion]

+LemonLime LPs Well indeed, I also just think that there has to be an in-lore explanation, and I'm curious to see if people will come up with a satisfactory answer that covers everything, if not fine, a little disappointing, but if so, that would be amazing.

[@Treviisolion]

+Yasir Oman That seems to be likely be part of it, but I don't feel like it's the whole answer.

[@juliegriebel4077]

sometimes it freaks me out how much a game leaves untouched, how much it leaves unanswered.

[@kaysonjacobson9376]

ya pretty freaky soon there will be a undertale 2 like fnaf 2 then 3 then 4 and so on

[@oneviewer8206]

Kayson Jacobson well i doubt that there will ever be undertale 2 but it would be so exiting. also, if toby will do that, only thing i want from the game is story mode and hard mode. on story mode you go through interesting story, interact with characters and solving mysteries. on hard, you are in whole new world where fights are so much harder.

[@kobe9063]

julie g your right there are soooooooooo many mysteries

[@drscavv2661]

Funnily enough, the leading theory is that Gaster is the Skelebros' father.

[@warpey5632]

Sans: Can bend space and time Teleport Is the most difficult boss fight Is a time traveler Makes bad puns Is very intelligent Papyrus: Likes spaghetti

[@mr.monotonyofdiversity2573]

...and really strong confuses ones who trying to know more about him.

[@Moonshine346]

We clearly see that Papyrus is the best

[@warpey5632]

@@Moonshine346 Yeah he really is a *cool* guy

[@j_rikuu2123]

I too make bad puns. But I think it's pun-tastic

[@angelinadesosa2957]

Bruh papyrus knows about time and space

[@dextoxsans751]

my mind was not blown... it was shattered across time and space NICE VIDEO MAT

[@pandanat9132]

dextox sans mine got dunked on

[@oneshotdemon9649]

Who thinks there is going to be a 6 Five night at Freddy's game

[@sydneytor5303]

ayyyyyyyyyyyy

[@narunn000]

mine got burned

[@oliviasilva5041]

dextox sans Yass same

[@Jhlanedvm]

When you said,”cool dude facade” it sounded so very like Bill Cipher’s voice.

[@L4dybug]

MatPat = Bill Cipher *CONFIRMED*

[@justaloadofash]

No

[@justaloadofash]

@Hayden Jones when I comment no I meant he didn't sound like bill cipher

[@bearisthebest2777]

e

[@grubblebubble217]

OMG YAAAAS

[@carsondockery9198]

Man this TRILOGY HAS BEEN LONG but! I love this trilogy so far! Man this is a great channel.

[@124tutt2]

Sans: I am the left brain I am the left brain, I work really hard till my inevitable death brain. You got a job to do you better do it right, and the right way, is with the left brain. Papyrus: I like Oreos and pu-cats, yeah, in that order. And I cried for like, an hour after watching toy story three.

[@reenee9656]

Sarah T. Hahahaha I love Bo burnham lol

[@ilycea]

Sarah T. I AM THE RIGHT BRAIN NA NA NA NA I HAVE FEELINGS!

[@brandycurry7679]

Sarah T. Yay Bo Burnham Fam

[@drawnix7555]

Sarah T. Because my whole thinks im gay, i guess its always been that way That was a song btw : )

[@variableaxis9652]

Praise the bo burnham fans

[@ulenix]

Me: ugh another notification from that comment a week ago Notification: Game theory: Gaster's identity revealed! Me: VIOLENTLY SPITS OUT TEA

[@kmarkusmus]

hero_con your profile pic fits in

[@sharlennla4982]

hero_con lmao

[@captainnugget471]

hero_con ikr

[@greenguy505]

Ikr

[@jem_747]

lol

[@MentosCubing]

That explains why Papyrus is the way he is. Not just in behavioral preferences like the ones you mentioned, but also in that he is EASILY the most determined character in the game. When you kill Papyrus, the other characters talk about how he usually goes to every possible length to impress Undyne, always answers his phone within two rings, etc. This is also shown in his lifetime, when he is depicted going as far as he can possibly go to convince you that he has no feelings for you. Even as he is about to die, he stays determined and talks as though he is winning and you can't handle his attacks. He even sees his own body turn to dust and responds with "at least I still have my head." If he is the result of an experiment involving the injection of determination, that makes sense as a part of his personality. Sans, on the other hand, is depicted as a lazy and careless being who possesses the ability to warp time-space, but only uses it either for more extensive laziness (hey, I have a shortcut to Grillby's) or when it is absolutely necessary (like in his boss battle). He is never depicted using this ability to serve a greater purpose than himself, and he is overall a laid-back and unmotivated character. But if Sans is also a result of the same determination experiment, why does he have absolutely no determination? Well, since the mind of Gaster was split into the left and right components... all of that determination went to Papyrus. Determination itself is a right-brain trait. It isn't affected by logic and reasoning, which Sans possesses; it is an entirely emotional trait. Sans received none of the determination because it isn't really something that his side of the brain is capable of having. I don't know, I probably missed something. But that's how I understand it. I think that this might actually be something that Toby Fox put into the game completely intentionally, knowing full well that this is the origin story he wanted to imply.

[@GamerGrovyle]

Mentos Cubing What if Sans existed before the explosion and assisted Gaster together with Alphys. When Gaster fell into the determination pit he split in two. One part the logical part fused with Sans making him extremely logical (since he has two peoples worth). Papyrus however was created out of his emotional part and all of that pure excess determination which is why he’s so emotional and determined all of the time.

[@hazielpax2290]

Mentos Cubing you're absolutely right. He sold me to believe that, but he did forget to mention this little bit. Sans has literally NO determination. He doesn't care, he's laid back. Doesn't worry.. he gives up. Literally gives up, which would be the reason why Gaster isn't coming back. Because.. even if he's the smartest, the most logical, scientific.. he's not the determined one. Papyrus kept all of that.. up until his end. And on Sans' boss battle, the only thing that ever made him stop being lazy and move his behind is this Human(species he hates) killing his friends (the dogs that go to grillbz's) his brother (mostly) and.. literally.. everyone else.. I mean.. that's enough to push him. hatred, vengeance, and having the power to stop him. And.. even if he was.. "determined".. in a way, it wasn't enough. He Stopped fighting.. he got tired.. he fell asleep.. his body.. "quit" on him. that was the reason for his demise.. and honestly.. maybe also the reason why be has the least amount of defense.. he has no will to do anything.. and sorry.. I went on for too long, I just.. went I start to ramble I don't stop.. Haha! thanks for reading, if you do. But You're absolutely right.

[@Pandabair-nl2is]

I wonder...what if Sans and Papyrus were his sons, and after being split in half, those halves settled into them because they were related. That's why they would have that picture. It was a picture of the family.

[@strawberryshortcake7336]

Kalissa Bair - If Sans and Papyrus were Gaster's sons, then surely the townspeople would have known about them, seeing as Gaster was the royal scientist of Asgore before Alphys came along, and that alone is a deal big enough to be worth mentioning. But no, all the bunny lady said was 'They just showed up one day and kind of. . . Asserted themselves'.

[@Pandabair-nl2is]

It could be that with their memories of Gaster, so too did their memories of his sons vanish, due to the memories being so linked together. There's also the possibility that because they were most likely born in Hotland(the place of the lab), they would not have been known to Snowdin. Yeah, they weren't known in Snowdin, but it doesn't say anything about weather they were known before in Hotland.

[@TrueDxablo]

It all makes Sans now...

[@6shawp6tawk68]

It's also worth mentioning that papyrus is the one who tells you to go alphys lab after your date with her , saying he " only have good feeling about this" , with sweat beating of his head in his dialogue icon 👀

[@FrNSICs]

at that point i assume it was flowey guiding the events of the story by telling papyrus to send you there

[@Thechaosmaster1997]

@@FrNSICs I always thought that it was Flowey himself that called you to send you the True Labs.

[@OllyTheLion]

81st like🧡

[@toritortilla3831]

Even crazier when you think about the fact that going down there likely saved her life There’s a note in the lab in front of the elevator saying she may not come back and may do something cowardly It’s revealed that she feels guilty for the out come of the experiments done on monsters and was going to take her own life down there So papyrus sending you to the lab was something and bit more heavy

[@OcarinaOfTime]

7:17 Imagine if he wrote Deltarune

[@demdem7946]

i thought he was gonna write nutdealer and i started dying of laughter

[@AlicePCD]

I thought of that too

[@DawnsonRPGs]

Or Nudealert

[@rebelliousrenegade950]

Undertale is Deltarune re-aranged

[@OcarinaOfTime]

@@rebelliousrenegade950 Yeah, it is the joke

[@marblecakesp9307]

There are so many universes, meaning sans being ness, or being half of gaster, they’re both very possible

[@SpikeHere5241]

Then again, Gaster could also be the skelebros dad. Think about it, if Gaster was deleted from everyone's memories, his sons would never had had a family at all, so it would be as if the skelebros just, "asserted themselves".

[@1unar_eclipse]

hmmmMMmmMMMMMM

[@oldplushpanic5423]

Yes

[@iceneko9170]

That seems... Extremely possible.

[@abby-xs1jo]

But then who's the Ms. Skeleton? It seems like Gaster was never in any romantic relationships, and he was just immersed in his research of determination.

[@LS-ju5zx]

Justinkoolj YT I think Gaster created them, not by reproducing because skeletons cannot reproduce therefore I think that Gaster made the Skelebros scientifically not by having a skeleton mom and reproducing like normal humans..:

[@woodman981]

Game Theory: MATPAT IS ACTUALLY MATPAT?!?!?

[@TylerNovakYT]

No, that's not possibly true.

[@jash6557]

what if Matpat was *The Game Theorist?*

[@JohnnyCakescgty]

But hey.. that's just a theory... A GAME THEOREYYREY THX 4 WATCHING

[@zoecoombes2534]

no

[@capoliro6322]

MatPat is actually CatPat

[@imperial_scot2656]

2017: I hAtE mAtPaT 2020: He's the only creator I watch and I'm sorry

[@OrangeNOrange]

lololol

[@ihaa_]

You changed :D

[@pcs6905]

Aha why did u hate him

[@autumnishere420]

@@pcs6905 I don't know if this was their reason, but a lot of people find him annoying.

[@ActuallyFlamey]

I still hate him because people actually believe his UT theories when they are just coincidences.

[@infernogamer69]

7:18 wait... Did matpat just predict Deltarune

[@amandapettis8640]

This video is meeting all of my standards

[@Hex.A.Decimal]

Amanda Pettis But it has no redeeming qualities.

[@_anonymous_creature_]

Amanda Pettis ikr

[@achalmohandas8938]

Simcha The Pieface Lel

[@i-am-not-penelope2556]

He took his research TO THE BONE... ok that was just bad... you don't have to show me out, I'll leave...

[@jelly_bee3730]

lol

[@pryftic2147]

Wait... if entry 17 is Gaster’s entry... then wouldn’t that mean when he says you two he knows sans. This would mean that sans was not formed from Gaster’s death. Although Papyrus still could be. This could explain why sans cares about him so much.

[@DaddyCloyster]

Great point

[@sapphiregaming3057]

Although he was breaking apart as he was writing the entry. So likelyhood is he could feel himself splitting into two separate bodies . Hence the “what do you two think part?

[@sapphiregaming3057]

In short maybe he wasn’t talking to the woman at all but to Papyrus and sans

[@eth__8547]

CONFUSION!!!!

[@FreakyPin]

How did I not pick up on that?

[@embryson7766]

Actually, you forgot the Quantum Physics book in San's house (the one inside the joke book).

[@galladegamer7332]

both inside one joke book and outside another.

[@sanssans1221]

Inside the joke book that was inside the other Quantum Physics book?

[@izzy2783]

Evie Bryson oh yeah it’s like a never ending book

[@tldoesntlikebread]

like a never ending loop of quantum physics.

[@cyborgXcsun]

Bruh this game is so intense and complex i love it

[@MARSHT0MP404]

this kills the meme that sans and papyrus are gaster's sons but hey, thats just a theory, a meme theory

[@raven_isnotok9928]

Tbh that could make sense as well, a comment a bit above you explains that a bit better than I could

[@curtisleblanc5897]

It would explain why sans is trying to return G to his original state. It also works with the theory of the "other two" from Entry #17 being Alphys and sans. Because, sans was there to see his father leave forever. And he DIDN'T STOP HIM! Now we know from Genocide that: sans may be lazy, but when all hope is lost (say, somebody splitting through time[lines] and space) he knows the right thing to do, and finds it as his obligation (Like Spider-Man). So he decides to take all of Gaster's research on the DETERMINATION Extractor (The machine G COULD have fallen into) and brings it home, where he works at night (no wonder he's sleeping in hotland) to get his dad back. He does this so that next time [if there is one] he can do the right thing, and stop Gaster from making the same mistake. It'd also explain the Skelebro's sudden appearence in Snowdin. They used to live with G in the Lab, But since G's out of the picture, and there's a new royal scientist in town, they were forced to move. B U T T , it also explains how sans knows Alphys, they probably met while moving out of/into the lab (PAPYRUS was probably just already on the road ready to move on. But sans had more trouble saying goodbye, he can't express emotion very good) and sans and Alphys probably hit it off over science-talk. Also if sans grew up with a Father who was a Scientist, then it'd explain his interest in Science (specifically science, instead of some other academics, like math or history) He, being the left-brain he is, looked up to the smart male role model. All the more reason sans has a harder time letting go than PAPYRUS. After all: 1) PAPYRUS is a master of EXPRESSING EMOTION so he probably is all cried out or something by the time Frisk first appears in the Underground. While sans has trouble conveying and dealing with emotions, "right"? 2) sans probably was more close to G than PAPYRUS, and 3) sans is the more responsible OLDER BRO, so he finds it up to HIM to get their dad back. He doesn't just owe it to Gaster, but he owes it to PAPYRUS, It's partially HIS FAULT that Gaster was lost FOREVER, he DIDN'T STOP GASTER! It was HIS MISTAKE as much as it was G's. sans has to right his wrong. But hey, that's just a comment. aaaa GAMME-RELATEDDD THEPRETICALL COMMENNTTTT! Thanks for reading. Seriously thank you for reading that thing should've been a two-parter.

[@twollner9604]

They ARE his sons!!!!!!!!!

[@nuggetmaster2476]

@@twollner9604 You're right! Remember asdf movie 11?

[@user-jb6he7xv8u]

Beleive whatever,different timelines means you can think whatever you want about the game

[@desired_effect5251]

I also found something else symbolic. At around 13:47, the *left* side of Sans is visible, and the *right* side of Papyrus is visible.

[@neka_jp2070]

That's probably editing since they have the same pose they have other times yet they look different due to the shadow things.

[@neka_jp2070]

@@darko7215 hey, I agree with you now. I don't know why past me wrote it. I don't even understand it, and I wrote it!

[@decdec1269]

im pretty sure thats because its a in game sprite from the overworld

[@xXRaivenWingsXx]

There's still one thing that bugs me; in the Lab file 17, Gaster speaks to TWO characters; supposedly, as you said, Sans and Alphys. But how could that be if Sans didn't exist before Gaster was shattered and split into the brothers? I love this theory to bits and Im fairly sure youre totally onto something but... that seems to big of a gap just to pass by. Thoughts?

[@jermafitzgerald2368]

Sans is a "time traveler", maybe he went back in time to try to stop it from happening? Not sure what can and can't happen, time travel is tricky

[@OmaiGrundles]

Could have been alphys and asgore. I mean it is the Royal lab after all.

[@BURNTtoast04]

Mel Meyer It is said in a video before on why it would be Sans. Its said that Alph wrote all of the files, but if you look closely you can see that some files where written by Alph and the others written by someone else. Alphys have a good grammar with no mistakes. But there are some that are only written in small latters and who else only speaks in small letters? Sans. Hinting that Sans must be a scientist, also hinting to the fact that he was most likely to be the second person. But that is also not clear because he could have become a scientist after Gaster dissappeared. My theory is that it either is Sans or Asgore, seeing that Asgore didn't only hire Alph and Gaster as royal scientists, but also because he is desperately trying to find a peaceful way to get out of the underground.

[@terrahatvol7960]

I thought I read that Asgore didn't know anything about the True Lab though because he was also questioning Alphys about what was going on (3 calls of questions and 1 about something cute he saw or something like that)

[@Pineapply_Queen]

Terra Hatvol it was 4 calls about the missing monsters and one about a teacup he found that looked like her.

[@KrazyK707]

These theories were so beyond mind, before I started looking up theories and I played through the game for the first time, I started breaking some stuff I noticed down and came up with this. I thought flowey (considering he knew about saving and loading) used to be a player. Which is why he knew how to save load and all of that was in his boss fight.

[@OllyTheLion]

2nd like💛

[@maracozzzz]

FUN factor: Fate of the Universe Number

[@canguiwa3686]

maracozzzz, could it be Undertale's Fate Number? :P

[@coreypatton6290]

maracozzzz Clever Toby........

[@torazely]

Functional Universe Number

[@tempo4760]

Fictional Universe Number

[@caffeinatedpossum]

All of you say Functional Universe Number, even if it's the canon line, I like Fate of the Universe Number.

[@Windmelodie]

Mat!!! What about the theme songs?! Papyrus' "Nyeh heh heh", Sans' theme and "Megalovania" (not sure if it's in there too, though), and also the unused (but still existing) "Song that might play when you fight Sans" which feature a part of Gaster's Theme? You can find Gaster's theme mixed into the themes of Sans and Papyrus!! Now if THAT isn't a hint then I don't know what is xDDD (Not to mention the similar melodies found between "song that might play when you fight sans" and Papyrus' themes and the same song with Sans' regular theme) Please like so he can see this, I'd love to hear his thoughts on that!!

[@Windmelodie]

Yeah I didn't mention that since Bonetrousle and Nyeh heh heh are overall quite similar. I get what you mean though, I was partly referring to that video that took the 4 notes from Nyeh heh heh and Gaster's Theme and compared those. But yeah, I didn't consider those 4 characters in context with the 4 notes....who knows, maybe 4 has another, deeper meaning?

[@cavecastscorch]

4 frogs...

[@Windmelodie]

Illuminati confirmed.

[@spaceyeen]

Megalovania isn't Sans' theme, though. I thought that too for a long time, but his theme is actually "sans." (shocking, i know). Anyway, that's really cool that Gasters theme can be found in those songs. Relly interesting!

[@Windmelodie]

What Shuttering-Flutterflies said^^ They have more than one song, although "theme" may have been misleading. I'm not a native speaker so I'm sorry if I didn't get the right word for that^^

[@nithishminecraft]

In log 17, gaster was the one who said "what do you two think", while he wrote that log he was still present and hadn't yet fallen into his creation. Then how is it that the two people he was referring to could be "sans" and alphys. Weren't sans and papyrus created after he fell in, doesnt that mean the when he was said you "two" he was probably referring to alphys and someone else. Maybe asgore or toriel. Also there is a wierd connection between sans and toriel as we can see that they both know each other through talking throught the door and haven't seen each other yet. The second person might be toriel... but who know. I know im like super late in pointing this out but hey, quarantine brought me here lol.

[@RedYoshiGamer2]

That’s exactly what I was thinking! Like, how could it be sans?

[@justjoshin956]

Lol same.

[@afridnishad6617]

Gaster after falling in is now a space time traveller; hes not completely dead you can meet him in a very specific location meaning he still exists and can interact and exist in the physical world as he pleases so its completely possible that he wrote that after falling in- The rest of the logs were written by alphys(you can notice her style of panicking) because if gaster existed then he wouldve been the cheif royal scientist assuming alphys wasnt recrcuited after he vanished and it wouldve been him writing all the logs (or most of the logs along with aplhys and the third person) what i meant was if the logs were before falling in then why start with number 17 wouldnt he be writing along from 1? and im pretty sure the blue prints were provided by sans to alphys or vise versa cause alphys mentions the blueprints in her logs and sans has one in his secret room- all leading to conclusion that gaster and sans are related (but i think the right brain left brain theory is far fetched lmao)

[@chrishebert9062]

Its highly possible that it could be sans and papyrus. I mean, they could have been working with him or something. Also when it comes to sans and toriel, sans didn't know it was toriel on the other side of the door.

[@sagesmith1377]

Well sans and alphys know each other so what if when gaster split he didnt split into to different people but simply split through different times

[@lelescarlet7184]

I remember, I think it was several years ago, I took a picture of a light at a movie theater because it looked like a Gaster Blaster. I remember at the time I was both creeped out and super excited at the same time. Those things are so creepy looking.

[@124tutt2]

This is an interesting take on the Sans and Papyrus personalities. As a writer I thought the opposite personalities was a writing tool and I still think it is. The opposite personalities tool is sort of like the smart/dumb or fat/skinny tool. Having two opposite things working together and bouncing off of each other makes a story more entertaining and dynamic. It's a very smart decision on Toby Foxes part to use this tool to make you love Sans and Papyrus even more.

[@zionj104]

So I'm kind of confused about something. If Sans is half of Gaster, how was he working with Gaster?

[@chrishebert9062]

I guess it would be similar to the amalgamates in the sense that its multiple beings combined.

[@NguyenTran-rb8by]

Same question with alphys, she only is working as a new scientist after Gaster's disappearance. But remember back, we knew Gaster shattered across time and space so there's a high chance that Gaster encounter the two by using this method.

[@ShadeRulez]

Gaster has a part of him IN sans.

[@zionj104]

​@@ShadeRulez Finally a reply that actually answers my question. Thank you.

[@lolliii5477]

MatPat, here's one more question

[@AntenneaChan]

this is by far my favorite gaster theory

[@glitchy777]

mattpat: *literally shatters everything you thought you knew about a video game* also mattpat: OH WHATEVER

[@crybabyphan2263]

Sans: I am the left brain, I am the left brain. I worked really hard till my inevitable death brain. I've got a job to do, I better do it right and the right way is with the left brains might. Papyrus: I LIKE SPAGHETTI AND PUZZLES! YEAH! IN THAT ORDER! AND I CRIED FOR AT LEAST AN HOUR AFTER TALKING TO FRISK ON THE PHONE! I AM THE RIGHT BRAIN! I HAVE FEELINGS! IM A LITTLE ALL OVER THE PLACE BUT IM HOPEFUL, HAPPY, AND I PERSONALLY THINK THAT IM GREAT! *whispers* I'll join the royal guard! Sans: Here comes a human, here comes a human. Shake their hand and trick them with a whoopie cushion. All of my puns are skeleton related and they're great, so grab a treadmill and trick people through time and space. Papyrus: UNDYNE, LOOK! I THINK I MIGHT BE THE ONE! THERES SOMETHING ABOUT ME, I JUST CANT DESCRIBE IT! Sans: great Papyrus: YOU ARE THE EARTH I AM THE GLORIOUS SUN! I WANT SOME SPAGHETTI, I JUST WANT FRISK TO BE MY BEST FRIEND. BE IT! Sans: alright now, Papy, you're acting crazy. Papyrus: NO BROTHER, ITS CALLED BEING PAPYRUS. YOU SHOULD TRY IT, YOU MIGHT LIKE IT Sans: i work hard to not break my promise to Toriel, you are worried about the things that Frisk is scared about. I'm punny and laid back, while you talk loudly. I am the calm one, you are supreme. Papyrus: YOU THINK THAT CROSSWORDS ARE HARD WHEN THEYRE FINE, YOU THINK YOU KNOW EVERYTHING BUT YOU DONT KNOW ANYTHING AT ALL. HALF OF THE PUZZLES WERE SUPPOSED TO BE MINE, BUT YOU FORGOT EVERYTHING. I KNOW THAT YOURE LAZY, BUT IM SURE NOT.

[@seanfahey3159]

Crybaby Phan #226 but nobody came.....

[@crybabyphan2263]

Grammar Nazi I feel honored because the Grammar Nazi didn't correct me on anything XD

[@lemon_lime9396]

that is amazing wow

[@neonal18]

+Ethan Clews It's a parody of comedian Bo Burnham's song "Left Brain, Right Brain." The original's a bit more...colorful with its language.

[@CupcakeMagee]

how long did that take you

[@amilcarfuentes9064]

Gaster isn't referring to Alphys and San when he says, "What do you two think?", but Sans and Papyrus as the transformation occurs. He sees himself breaking into two, so he leaves the message to the monsters that would soon become the only memory of him (save his followers).

[@paigesalazar5968]

*GASP* That's a cool thought!

[@tdark987]

I agree. It wouldn’t make sense for “you two” to refer to both an existing person presumably working at the lab (Alphys) and one who doesn’t properly exist yet (Sans, given that Gaster still exists as he writes his message); they wouldn’t both be able to respond. Alphys can’t tell Gaster what she thinks after he vanishes, and Sans can’t do anything at all before Gaster disappears, given that he doesn’t exist yet. Even if we assume that he’s writing the message as he’s starting to dissociate completely, it would be “you three” if the message was also directed at Alphys (who AFAIK didn’t even have that job at the time).

[@thealientree3821]

And thus Memoryhead was formed. Why do I say that? Note that one of the faces looks like Sans's face, and another face looks like Papyrus's. And the unreconizable faces, 3 of these are these unreconizable people Sans has sawn.

[@lucasgibbs7400]

Btw you said san not sans

[@mlgepicbanana69]

Wow, that makes a heck of a lot of sense, after all why would he say "shadows are cutting deeper"? Probably because he is splitting apart... I would also assume that sans have a connection with alphys because she is the new royal scientist so sans gave her some information about the whole idea... Also notice the name of the attack: "Gaster's blaster" saying that it is gaster's invention, so it make sense that only papyrus and sans would be able to use it...

[@TheTabascodragon]

you didn't touch on this, but the game resets if you name the fallen human Gaster. i was wondering if it actually does something to affect the game that nobody has noticed, like doing a RNG "reroll" for the "fun value" or something.

[@Honorary121]

TheTabascodragon wow never knew that happened

[@senpaicg2839]

Waaaaaaaaaah

[@hakon2345]

sorry about this but what would happen if papyrus and sans had baby? would the baby be gaster?????

[@TheTabascodragon]

they're both dudes. plus they're brothers. that'd just be weird.

[@Alivekuso]

TheTabascodragon he actually did talk about that, but in a different episode of this trilogy.

[@DivineLeeYT]

Me just now watching this years later: but wait, wouldn't sans and papyrus have some signs that they have some sort of determination powers within them since Gaster was contaminated with immense determination which made him shatter into pieces? Each piece would contain some determination I'd assume. Oh well, it's all theories till Toby tells the truth, if he ever does. Either way, love the hidden Stories within Undertale.

[@dwaynethecockjohnson3700]

Also, in the fight with Papyrus, he prepares a "non-bone attack" and then "spends a minute fixing his mistake".

[@user-ft8ci9xu2t]

TheAlbinoRhino he might of Been wanting to use a gaster blaster

[@ethancoble2953]

While sans, on the other... HAND!!!!!

[@ourmirauniverse7335]

Trainer Sans you guys are very PUNny (I suck at making puns ;-;)

[@andrewzheng4038]

+Galaxy Senpie we must PUNish you for this

[@kingblue4796]

Zheng Of the Zen wow this is PUNfull (get it painfull PUNfull haha I'll leave now...)

[@vexedninja9101]

Ayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

[@ThatGuy-vw6gc]

Trainer Sans BA DUN.......* symbol falls off

[@AnthonyFlores-jc7xk]

Wait. How was gaster talking to sans And Dr. Alphys if he IS part sans?

[@ElisatheNerd]

I wondered the same thing XD

[@nikoozen6049]

_imagination_

[@giorgosgiorgos2374]

In the entry 17 he sais that the darkness's cutting deeper. This could literally mean being cut in half(two seperate selves) and the process is slow, so he can feel that now there are other 'selves' inside of him.

[@Jackgalaga]

Bruh poor Matpat

[@microbabebrown3392]

Well, he was shattered across *time* and space. The part becoming sans was probably sent to before he was shattered, causing sans to be present during the experiments

[@karkavwi]

I've never played or seen Undertale before. I've heard of the cool music track, but that's just it. Listening to your three part series on Gaster's Identity has really gotten me interested in this game

[@Happy_doggo]

Oh welcome to the community Note: i am don't like new music i like being in my box but when i heard undertale them, OH boy My favorites: spider dance, last hero, water fall

[@cyborgXcsun]

@@Happy_doggo mine is stmpwyfs, battle against a true hero, waterfall, and spear of justice

[@unxiled555]

*Watches video (almost done)* Me: Damn my mind is blown MatPat: BUT HEY THAT'S JUST A THEORY A GAME THEORY! Me: GOD DAMN IT!

[@snowykaze]

Ryuuji Takasu same

[@SuperNicktendoEntertainment]

Ryuuji Takasu I get that feeling far too much!

[@samumohacsi]

Ryuuji Takasu your mind is blow indeed

[@FabioniMacaroni]

I wish my brain was a drug :(

[@MelodiCat753]

I don't get it.