Happy New Year

The plaintiff claims his 19-year-old son threw a New Year’s Eve party that got out of hand. His son ended up with stitches from a fight, and the house was trashed. He’s suing one of the partygoers for property damages. The defendant claims the damage isn’t his fault, because he was actually trying to break up the fight.
Case # 28-386
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court
Subscribe to our channel:
/ @peoplescourttv

[@Ferf3o]

Should be split 50/50! Son is liable not to mention he lied to the judge about inviting them… I’m sure the defendant wasn’t the only one drinking!

[@mesepareed9819]

Dad thought his son was having a NYE party till 12a. Bruh NYE parties START at 12a!! 💁🏽‍♂️🥳

[@cassandra6710]

Right. The dad's a liar.

[@stephaniehowe0973]

This depends on how old you are.

[@mesepareed9819]

And his son is barely 21

[@KemoneArmstrong]

My NYE party ends at 1230 lol

[@savannahstarr5114]

Son should help pay something, tf you invited him knowingly your friends had beef with his friends

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

"You're all very intoxicated, I don't want any trouble" isn't the same as "Get out of my dad's house. You're not invited. I'm calling the cops if you don't leave." Easy peasy. Be courageous. You've already got some liquor in you... let it work for you. Call the cops and report these trespassers. Period. 🤷🏾‍♀️ Edit: turns out the plaintiff TEXTED the defendant an invite. Wow. Both of these guys are entitled babies drinking liquor they can't handle. 🙄🙄

[@k0chana6]

FR 😂

[@MyPOVvlogs]

The fact that you actually believed him…. I knew it was a lie. It was a small party and they were friends. Of course he was invited he just didn’t think a fight would of occurred.

[@scotthewitt258]

Let the son pay. He invited people to the party, which the dad knew was happening. And there were people from both sides in the fight. Plus, the plaintiff's side had MORE people in the fight.

[@karenwalters1211]

I feel like the dad was stupid to leave the kid home on NYE to have friends over. You should be home!

[@brawnyjk]

​@@karenwalters1211Yeah, but the son is not a child. Why would the dad need to be home to watch an adult?

[@jesnrbrt4evr11]

​@@brawnyjkand the son is an adult.

[@jesnrbrt4evr11]

The son asked them to leace as soon as they got there, plus the defendant admitted fault and that they should of left.

[@clays8374]

The plaintiffs son should pay too. He lied and said he didn’t invite him. Judge Judy would have dismissed the case. Dad seems greedy. Just my opinion

[@yung1717]

We don’t know that the son doesn’t have to pay. He’s just not suing him

[@claudettesands6578]

I realize that son had to have staples in his head… But he is as much or more to blame than the other kids. I hope dad is holding him accountable for his fair share.

[@mikieanthony777]

The plaintiff lied about inviting the defendant. He should be 75% responsible.

[@latoyiab79]

Exactly

[@yung1717]

75%? Just for inviting him. Pls be calm

[@tiffany6914]

The attitude these kids have is ridiculous! I see many more issues coming there way very sad

[@themermaidstale5008]

I’m glad she found out the father’s strategy; I believe it changed her ruling. Also,she called him out twice about the scope of the outdoor repairs to include a new pathway which was not damaged.

[@cindymann3673]

Immediately, I knew the son P was not truthful.

[@Daydream355]

The defend is definitely zooted.

[@righttoouropinionthanks4710]

Seems like the Dad is holding everyone responsible except the one person he should be - his son!!! (Unless of course he is punishing him privately & that’s fine, but seems like he should have at least said that in court so it doesn’t look the way it does!!! (I do like the way JM calls people out when she catches them trying to cash in more than they should!!!!

[@rosechardonnay5351]

The son should have been held partially liable too. I can tell he's far from innocent and based on his demeanor was probably an aggressor in the fight. He also straight up invited these dudes.

[@MsCassie272]

My parents would never have gone to court. They would have made ME pay....my decisions , my friends. ..period.

[@Cougar4u]

Saaame

[@stratfordbaby]

$2000 only because she knew daddy was already being greedy with the overestimate on the damage for work that was NOT relevant.

[@inukoko2012]

The defendant is crazy. He’s acting like him and his friends didn’t do anything wrong. 😂

[@humaneleaguelancPA]

And smirking the whole way through the case.

[@Damnsaburna]

He was too chill for real. He told the judge “right on” 🤣

[@PoodleHead2005]

I remember Oliver and his haircut. 😄

[@lorirogers9304]

No more parties for Jr. 😅

[@mickm6309]

Is the drinking age 21 in all States, I thought at least the cops could have arrested some of them for underage drinking.

[@MrsMeeker0328]

A lot of the times it's just a citation and release to parents if

[@mickm6309]

@@MrsMeeker0328 Wasn't sure because of all the tv shows from America showing underage drinkers being arrested. Legal drinking age here in Australia is 18.

[@shaydaslays]

Yeah Americans are strange. I can sign up for the military, gamble, and smoke tobacco at 18 but can't drink 😂​@@mickm6309 the tobacco age is now 21 in my state. Change a couple years ago. But you can still sign up to fight, at 17 with parents consent

[@MrsMeeker0328]

@@mickm6309 there are usually additional charges involved in those scenarios, lol. They do detain them, then release to parents, but they're never truly arrested and booked into jail. Legal age here is 21 in all states 😅 you can fight in the military for your country at 18, but by God you can buy a beer!

[@bryanhenderson9637]

Dad suing each person individually for 5 grand is nuts. No way is that 25 grand worth of damage. This was a case of the dad trying to circumvent the small claims court limitations.

[@joela.4279]

As Judge Milian said during the hearing, that is a strategic decision the father made in hoping to collect for the full amount of damages, which exceeded the statutory cap of 5k. The defendants can be held jointly or severally liable. Which means one can be liable for the damages of all, or all for the damages of one. In this case, the father can choose to bring separate litigation for each person of the defendants group, but in this melee idk how he's planning on being successful in arguing who broke the railing and who pushed whom through the sheet rock, etc. The concept of joint and several liability is born of the thought that each person of the defendants party acted in orchestra, and it's not the plaintiffs burden to prove who damaged what. The defendant can choose to bring litigation against his friends if they don't see it fit to share the responsibility of damaging the property.

[@scotthewitt258]

Why is she surprised the son lied about inviting them? The dad already got caught in a lie. At first he said he did not know there was a party. Then later, he said he did know.

[@Prettypinkpolish_]

Oh yeah especially since his son uses the N word 😒

[@Julie-sl8ul]

THE SON NEEDS TO KICK IN A 5th OF THE COST. HE DID INVITE THEM

[@zoorenard1101]

2 bad judgments in a row.... time to go watch Judge Judy 😂

[@natture812]

Look at the bald guy behind the defendants... so scary stare...

[@NotAllButMost]

It looks like he’s staring directly at me!!😂

[@tesstickles1280]

The son looks like that now ladies! But he will look like his dad in 30 more years LOL

[@darienwilliams6070]

Don't go to parties where you're not invited. If you do, dont get smashed and damage property 🤦🏾‍♂️🤷🏾‍♂️

[@k0chana6]

The defendant was invited. However, the defendant should've known right away that his own friend wasn't invited , since that guy had beef with the other guy. What a mess !!

[@scotthewitt258]

He absolutely WAS invited. She read the text out loud.

[@perfectlyimperfect9129]

He was invited remember the judge read the text

[@LivingforJesusaGodisGood74]

Unfair ruling

[@stratfordbaby]

The son must be adopted. Doesn't look like the father even 1%.

[@elainevankat5353]

The son has a mother too!🤷‍♀️

[@plainwhitepaper3898]

They could have fixed it. Didn't look like much. 2000 should of covered the whole thing and then some. Judge MM is the best, Rough justice.

[@Damnsaburna]

I liked the defendant. He tried to do the right thing at first. Hopefully he learned to always follow through he could have avoided the lawsuit by performing labor and buying materials.

[@thisravenhasflown010]

Lol dad is still at his party 10:30 next morning, kid is at Home Depot getting materials to fix the remains from their party.... sounds like this is normal for this family 😂 Well, a confession and acceptance to pay means the defendants wrote their own sentence 😊😂

[@adrianknight1406]

Nobody wins in a situation like this. Neither the plaintiff's son nor defendant's were mature enough to have a party in my opinion.

[@Meister_de_Nicts]

Too bad you've never been invited to one.

[@adrianknight1406]

Ignorant comment.

[@6341mike]

Plaintiff dad got greedy

[@jojobee42]

No, he wants justice.

[@jvillebil13]

The Ball dropped in the square in NYC at midnight and the table dropped on the son's head at midnight.

[@tdacosta520]

I love how 18+ men are being called kids and boys

[@kimberlyadorno280]

If you have children, you know 18 is far from being an actual adult/man. Legally, yes, mentally, definitely not.

[@perfectlyimperfect9129]

18 is a still a kid like it or not

[@thisravenhasflown010]

When they stop acting like it, we'll stop using it😂

[@mycrownfitsfine]

Completely unrelated: The defendant’s barber (yellow shirt) did him dirty and left the little patch on his taper 😂

[@kimberlyadorno280]

😂

[@LivingforJesusaGodisGood74]

Completely Related It isn't cool to be a bully. But as they say, the ones quick to point out other people's flaws are usually the ones that are insecure

[@stratfordbaby]

11:05 Y'ALL. She's never been that Southern before. WOW.

[@nekasmith3192]

I like both! I need the everyday look and need the glam look on other days. I can't do eyeshadow for poo.

[@VirtualLunacy]

Sound like he made a bad parenting decision and he should make his son pay for all that s***

[@erinwhite276]

The producers pay the winners of the case, so I don’t get why they make it seem like the loser has to pay. I guess it’s because it’s reality tv lol

[@deannazandi1797]

SIMPLE 21 YEARS OF AGE, ADULT JAIL, NOT AN 16 YEAR OLD KID.

[@rocktramp]

'adult party' ;-)

[@godzila100]

They met up to watch the ball drop? Sounds like the party was at Diddy's house!!!

[@roshepvids5513]

Oop

[@Dapperbugbear]

Defendant came to court with a shower loofah on his head

[@Julie-sl8ul]

I don't believe the son. If he was injured that badly the police would have called EMT. He was hiding the fact that there was underage drinking, etc

[@BXPOSSETV]

Why are you all using the n word. Neither of you are black. The plaintiff got exposed and lied.

[@roxane7432]

Doesn't sound like Dad is going to hold his son accountable. The plaintiff lied to JM, he invited trouble, he got trouble, should have had to pay 1/2, the very least 😢

[@julianneg5051]

I think the Judge should have taken the estimate, divide it by 4, and that’s what they each owed. I think the son was partially responsible because he invited him. However, he didn’t invite the friend whom had the problem. So more liability was on the defendant for bringing the uninvited guest.

[@mikadre12]

So the son does not have any liability? His son had a party, his son's friend had a hand in it. This should not have one person responsibility.

[@jesnrbrt4evr11]

I think it's ridiculous that the defendant thinks the plaintiff's friends should be partially responsible! The defendant brought a group of inebriated people to the plaintiff's house they were asked to leave as soon as they got there, they refused to leave and had to be escorted off by police officers, then after that they decided to come back and cause drama! that's 100% on the defendant and his friends. I also think that the plaintiff and his dad were entitled to the walkway, and the reason I say that is because if they don't make that specific pattern or brick anymore whatever it was and the entire walkway needs to be redone then that's what needs to happen the plaintiff is entitled to a matching walkway just like he had prior to the incident, as the judge always says they deserve to be made whole and put in the exact same position that they were before the incident happened, if that happens to cost way more than that's on the defendant he should have thought about that before he caused all of this drama.

[@tonybluestar4954]

Just let them kiss and make up! 🙄

[@finally97]

Soooo we're going to gloss over underage drinking? I would sue the parent for improper supervision and providing alcohol to underage people. Petty, but come on. The plaintiff's son lied from the beginning. I want to see what's on the editing floor.

[@deborahlindsey9369]

Judge Milian. My question is about Season 1 Episode 50. Did you give an update.??, I hope the defendants list their licenses and went to jail.

[@jennifer_mertens]

Cripes, doesn't he understand what "don't use pronouns means"?!? "He got hit, by his friend, and they got into a fight with us---they started fighting". Who did what to whom now😂?!? Also, the Plaintiff shouldn't have embellished that the Defendant's weren't invited. The Plaintiff had a pretty good case, especially after the Defendant handed over his phone(with the texts apologizing for causing the chaos).

[@charliemack3073]

Hey!! Fast food fight in the kitchen!!💀

[@user-wm8no6kz6s]

The plaintiff's😅 son is cute!

[@KAKE-26]

DEFO!!!

[@JaiB-xr9fl]

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder I guess.

[@denyol2846]

most basic plain white bread, but okay

[@stratfordbaby]

He is the typical douche look. Not attractive.

[@marthafloresss9200]

Que pague el hijo tambien 🙄

[@gregshell8570]

Yeah, what about the son's friends?

[@cdplayz2417]

I don't know whether the judged ruled correctly because she should have a rule there Both are at fault so got him to pay half and the son to pay half as he was an invited guest

[@Lenasevilla-yb4ei]

She’s the one with the law degree 😴🥱

[@cdplayz2417]

@Lenasevilla-yb4ei so has Judge judy, but she said the opposite, that's why I'm confuses .

[@davidperez5089]

The defendants hairdo!- wtff?!???!😂😂😂

[@stormcrider17]

Aired 5/13/19

[@butterflyroho6470]

What year was this? What’s up with the hair?

[@stratfordbaby]

2018 approx. They are from the Tristate area. They have bad hair.

[@butterflyroho6470]

@@stratfordbaby 🤭It’s like he was transported from the early 80s.

[@glenncurley680]

They go on these reality court shows because the program pays for everything win or lose. I have seen people bragging about their fake case and splitting the settlement. That's a shame. These people totally concocted a story got to split $5000 Entertaining tho.

[@cassandra6710]

I have heard this before.

[@NotAllButMost]

Wait till you see the new show…terribly obvious actors! I’m so disappointed cuz I love the real cases

[@milesandemilyrock]

The showrunners don't care as long as they can air it. Better than the new trash show.

[@marys4565]

​@@cassandra6710I gave heard that the courts pay the winner but the one who loses has to repay the court.

[@MrAlienmagnet]

Watching Harvey play Yank-the-Mic is so annoying

[@deannazandi1797]

.--- NEW FRIENDS NEEDED --

[@denisgauthier9191]

New Year’s was 3 months and 3 days ago

[@leetakamiya]

So?

[@Queeni_3e]

Rerun

[@sheisme2]

This episode is many years old lol

[@LHS427]

Gobbless🙏

[@apeshitclothing]

🥂

[@batmang9014]

This is why i never dont and wont party ever

[@timjohnson1806]

Present ‼️‼️

[@christopherbako]

The Judge said "Don't use pro nouns" Thats a Judge?

[@leddoandroidgirl]

She just wanted specifics since she was cross examining him.

[@adwallace021938]

She wanted the son to use the names of the people involved when he was telling her about the fight, not just "he" and "him" so she could understand which person did what, so she could figure out their responsibility to assess the damage amount to award to the plaintiff.

[@christopherbako]

@@leddoandroidgirl ok

[@heidithompson6895]

@@adwallace021938the boy doesn’t know what a pronoun or proper name is

[@MrMatteNWk]

Well she is from Florida...

[@gregshell8570]

I LOVE boys!

[@Bebedollie]

Ewww

[@hotlikem3]

I don’t agree with the judge ruling - Cz if this was Judge Judy - the homeowner will be responsible- Cz 19 year old isn’t an adult

[@stephaniehowe0973]

Yes it is legally

[@kimberlyadorno280]

Unfortunately, legally, 19 is considered an adult. But I agree, definitely not mentally mature enough.

[@nismoj14]

This is an old Case I have seen it before

[@MaryBenjamin-n4r]

I agree, this isn't new

[@meatandcookies2674]

Well they’re not making new ones anymore so what did you expect

[@perfectlyimperfect9129]

Ok....

[@santyclos1302]

Just when we thought we were getting a streak of new videos this channel releases yet another recycled video smh

[@cassandra6710]

There are no more new videos. The People's Court is over. It's on a different court channel now.

[@misfit_pets5731]

They have decades of videos to choose from. They really shouldnt be repeating episodes. ​@@cassandra6710

[@santyclos1302]

@@cassandra6710 I meant on their KZbin channel not the show itself

[@Fleefromsin]

One of the greatest experiences in the world is when you get baptized in the name of Jesus Christ, your sins are washed away! Nothing can compare, there is only one way to be baptized and that’s in his name: Jesus!

[@christopherbako]

Is this a real Judge? 😊damm

[@LoveChild71]

Reload..... boring x2

[@positivemanda]

My God, he's fine. On the left.

[@stratfordbaby]

Just a douche kid. Don't get wet.

[@mikeyh0]

First?

[@daniela36849]

Good for you. Finally you got something accomplished in your life👍

[@mikeyh0]

@@daniela36849 Yes, thank you. I want to thank all the people who helped me on this difficult but fulfilling journey. Hugs.

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

🪅

[@mikeyh0]

@@daniela36849 Yeah, after 73 years of struggle.

[@Micknkeithable]

Sue your son

[@184876ela]

WHO CARES LEARN TO PACK YER MUD

[@callmeonkeshiasphone]

it was a Gang war

[@perfectlyimperfect9129]

🤣😅😂No !! These seem like a bunch of spoiled kids with Ritch parents, doesn't look like any type of gang iv ever seen.

[@Cougar4u]

If my kid was an idiot and had a party that ended like this - it would be MY kid paying for all the shit because he shouldn’t have done that.

[@scotthewitt258]

Wow. She definitely made her mind up ahead of time. BOTH the dad and the son got caught lying, and she is still acting like they are in the right 100%. 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎

[@kimberlyadorno280]

Believing they were right 100% would be a judgment of $5000. The defendant was definitely liable for a portion of the damage.

[@LivingforJesusaGodisGood74]

Unfair ruling