He Claims She Started It | Judge Mathis

The plaintiff let the defendant move into her home. She claims the defendant was always drunk, and one night after a music festival, the defendant attacked her and busted her tooth out. She’s suing for dental bills. The defendant argues he was never mean to the plaintiff. He admits he hit her, but only after the plaintiff attacked him first.
#JudgeMathis #Court #Mathis #RealityTV
Subscribe to our channel below:
/ judgemathis

[@tamekamccrayhayes6904]

Her husband is weird. How can u allow a man treat your woman that way

[@fundifferent1]

there's 100% more to the story becuase things just aren't adding up here.

[@TheanswertolifeisNO17]

I dont care if you have a baby you come in my house and mistreat me, you got to get the hell up out my house

[@millissentflemmings2216]

😂😂😂

[@mom2babygkaterad946]

Quick, fast & in a hurry! “You gots to GO!”

[@giovannanewman5361]

Keep pushing, you got this!! For anyone that needed it today❤

[@loribryant884]

Thank you 😊 🙏 I need to hear that about 10xs a day 😢

[@giovannanewman5361]

@@loribryant884 You Got This, keep pushing💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾

[@kristenrock7783]

@@loribryant884 same . We got this !!!!! ✌

[@angelanisa19]

Thank you!

[@britmax5341]

Thank you love you

[@dance4life1208]

This whole case is weird

[@marleonetti7]

that woman attacked that defendant and the plaintiff's boyfriend knows it , thats why he didnt do anything to the defendant when the incident happened . the judge got it wrong .

[@YAHsaves777]

Too much alcohol does that

[@eliaa.8814]

why is he staring the plaintiff down like that? 😭

[@jamescatalao2607]

Because he's a PREDATOR!

[@opulence_prime]

Contempt

[@Ayo_Bruh22]

He's a thug

[@YAHsaves777]

The defendants girlfriend pretty much admitted to the judge that he does have some anger issues

[@mom2babygkaterad946]

Trying to intimidate her obviously. Little man has “little man syndrome. He wants to feel “BIG”.😒

[@vonyorker4482]

Calling me names in my home and drinking will have you homeless. Very disrespectful, I'm with JM, this definitely wouldn't happen in my house.

[@laterriasgilbert469]

Wait the husband just let this shit happen tf

[@hevinamber]

He's her boyfriend

[@karendorsey4780]

I understand helping people, but some folks you can’t help! It’s a bad idea to allow folks to live with you! Period!

[@marleonetti7]

but if u do happen to help someone then dont become angry that resentful that u helped that person and then take your frustrations out on them and thats what i believe happened . if that defendant was beating up on that woman then there is no way that her larger boyfriend would have just stood there and did nothing to the defendant . the plaintiff's boyfriend knew that she attacked the defendant because his behavior at the time of the incident supports that , and i dont know how the judge missed that . also that woman is larger and heavier than the defendant and i think the description of what he had to do to stop the attack made perfect sense . this judge is off his rocker sometimes .

[@hevinamber]

AMEN ❣

[@MrLenroc82]

She better get a new husband......I guess money trumps a man standing up for his woman......

[@sereneamani1713]

"A" husband. Jeff is her boyfriend

[@Ayo_Bruh22]

😂😂😂😂

[@MrLenroc82]

@@sereneamani1713 same scenario.....you know they been together long enough to be married

[@hevinamber]

It's her so-called boyfriend

[@MrLenroc82]

@@hevinamber same scenario.....at their age its definitely the same scenario

[@marsha-madness-super-badness]

I see skinny Fabio hasn't run into the right one yet 🤔

[@MrLenroc82]

The husband definitely didnt teach him

[@Ayo_Bruh22]

​@@MrLenroc82he's a old drunk himself

[@fundifferent1]

@@Ayo_Bruh22 Right. I think that's the missing key. THe husband is probably emotionally abusive and she puts up with it. He sides with the boy when they all get drunk and they all pick on her because she wants nothing to do with them

[@msarmstrong410]

Lol

[@silethaking279]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jessanne427]

I don’t think people should put their hands on each other period…no matter what gender!

[@YAHsaves777]

Sometimes you have to defend yourself if there is no way to avoid a confrontation

[@jessanne427]

@@YAHsaves777 ​​⁠I understand that it just irritated me that they kept saying at the end he shouldn’t put his hands on her because she a female…no if she puts her hands on him then he should defend himself. Being a female doesn’t save you from getting your ass put in place if you can’t keep your hands to yourself

[@Biggtahj202]

They are all weird

[@lotusgsxr750]

They're all high

[@jacobestevez7570]

why is the defendant standing there posturing and staring down the plaintiff ?

[@supremeclientele1356]

Right! I think he was trying to intimidate her. 🫤

[@Ayo_Bruh22]

He's a thug it's thier nature

[@chrissygoodrich1856]

As an adult that age, why would you allow a grown friend, of your daughter’s, to move in with their significant other??? Definitely more to this…

[@adrianknight1406]

Cases like this continue to show why it's a bad idea to do roommates. This kind of thing never works out. I've been talking about it for decades.

[@PSensei717]

This is true, you wanna test who your real friends are, let them live with you

[@loribryant884]

You haven't been commenting for decades. That's a lie troll 🧌

[@loribryant884]

9th

[@brionna8466]

I agree with you on this comment adrian

[@sereneamani1713]

You see on JM and in other like-areas the situations that don't work. How does that prove that roommate situations NEVER work? Even as high as the divorce and/or separation rate for marriage is in the U. S (some estimates say 50%), that means 50% do work. Keep in mind, my problem with your statistics is use of the word "NEVER".

[@maryoaks3228]

Plaintiff’s husband and defendant’s girlfriend seem to live with volatile partners

[@rushyc9283]

That's really sad that she had to take up for herself.. I don't believe I'd have enough strength in me to respect my fiance if he couldn't protect me from abuse of another man. 😢 So sad

[@damianu4082]

"I will never attack someone who is sharing their home with me....." fast-forward "I told her to shut her mouth in a very choice way...". So, the defendant will never attack someone in their home but he simply defend himself getting her under restrain from the balcony all the way to the bed and keep her pinned down. The plaintiff better take him to criminal court and have him narrate his story once more and see how he fares there.

[@chrissygoodrich1856]

Thank you! That is THE point🙌

[@BlackShogun]

His gf is definitely scared of him.

[@simonsez1787]

The cross examination be tearing them up 😂

[@wehappyducks8554]

I'm five seconds into the show lol the judge need to tell the defendant to sit up

[@amandasaunders3493]

I wonder how many people who say "just until we get on our feet," actually use the opportunity to really get on their feet.

[@shannonbrown6032]

This case was kinda crazy

[@illgoat]

Something is off about this case, there's something both parties aren't revealing.

[@hatman_vl8156]

Watching the end shows how he acts on the regular

[@SuperCHERISHED]

The defendant’s hair looks amazing!

[@brandonray4379]

I didn't mean to laugh at her grin on the picture 9:14 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lizhiggins4805]

She don't make sense why would she walk out as the defandant and judge said she shouldn't have walk out why not throw him out if she didn't like drinking she sounds like she made it up

[@naterriebracynebblett4435]

I'm here My Beloved Favorite Judge ***ASHAY ***

[@JerzChozen1]

I don’t think he did it. I believe the defendant was telling the truth.

[@jameekagillis]

I agree

[@Kingvon908]

Putting this case aside ..To women out there if you’re punching a guy repeatedly be ready to get hit back while you’re doing that .. For any women to just automatically assume all men is just going to let you keep hitting them is crazy. Just be prepared if you’re if your going to do that is what I’m saying.

[@sereneamani1713]

It's interesting that so many in the comments keep referring to Jeff as the plaintiff's husband when she specifically said that he's her boyfriend. This is a weird case with a number of completely opposite testimony. It appears to me that there is a lot of drinking, arguing, disrespect, and violence going on and not solely caused or indulged in by the defendant. (not excusing his actions though).

[@WarGrowlmon18]

They spent the previous night together and they couldn't even get their stories straight before court.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jacquelinecassidy7672]

This guy wouldn’t be in my house. His abusive period and a liar

[@hevinamber]

STOP disrupting Your peace by moving folks into your home. They have to come up with their own plans on what they're going to do. They brought two adults, a child and a fur baby into This Woman's peace! 😒🙄✌🏼

[@lorettamcclain5995]

Judge Mathis has become a new version of Judge Joe Brown 😮

[@bella_saysitall]

I can't help but believe the defendant partially too, I believe she put her hands on him first. She is always keeping up drama which even her husband didn't deny.. Also if a woman doesn't want a man to hit them you shouldn't hit him either.

[@junemoore1379]

okay, so for whatever amount of rent the defendants were paying, the plaintiff's dude allowed her to be disrespected. I hope she put him out or moved after this case.

[@G-PAT]

Disrespecting his wife like that something is wrong with this picture, there's no way you would come in my house and disrespect me and my mate get the f*** out

[@mrpitts15]

Now if the women hit him, the court and JM would have laughed and joked about it

[@williamgolston5399]

Plaintiffs sound like liars lol

[@user-ne2df1ro5c]

The husband gives me "push over" and I bet his wife does most of the thinking for him

[@fundifferent1]

This was a weird case and there's definitely more to the story. I think the husband is probably emotionally abusive and she puts up with it. He sides with the boy when they all get drunk and they all pick on her because she wants nothing to do with them when they're drinking.

[@swilson1133]

Crazy weird

[@MaryjaneLove]

&&&& ii don't care how sad your situation is noooo uu can not stay with me at alll . . . . 😢😢😢

[@silethaking279]

💯

[@christinabryant6836]

Sooooo you watch this man talk to your wife and PUT HIS HANDS ON YOUR WIFE and you did NOTHING????? Girl leave.

[@baptistangel3]

i disagree with the judge in this one 😮 she attacked him and he did what he felt he needed to do

[@phaldaz]

12:12 what a weird defense she said, you really and truly hear this when a woman is an aggressor at first and they get SHOCKED when the man fights back. Anywho, they tolerated each other's foolishness from day 1, no wonder it escalated. Yall be safe out there!

[@jacquelinecassidy7672]

This woman is lying.

[@pictureofmyjunk2279]

I got really jo sympathy. The defendants brought it on themselves. 4 adults, a young child and a dog in a two bedroom apartment 🙄.

[@user-hs1zr6mc5d]

Judge don't listen past her being a woman that got hit. She said she was mad that she got left. I believe she was drunk and I believe exactly what the defendant said.. Women better remember their hands belong to women before they hit a man. I don't condone violence but if you throw a lick you can receive one. The defendant didn't lie about them not getting into arguments it was eatablished that she was arguing by herself with both sides saying it was said they're surprised he didn't go off. But they need their own place anyways to avoid stuff like that.

[@-newhope7687]

تصوير فيديو عندما تتجادل مع امراة افضل حل حتى لا تشتكي والكل سيصدقها وواضح من تصرفاتها انها كارين وتحب مشاكل 😢

[@Fluffyy808]

I believe the plaintiffs husband and the defendant have a private sexual relationship.

[@madmaxofspokane1691]

She started it! 😉😅😂😂🚓🚓🚓🚓

[@marleonetti7]

yup , thats why the plaintiff's boyfriend did nothing to the defendant at the time of the incident , because he knows how she is . judge mathis got it wrong again .

[@DiorDiamond-st4pp]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@mrchocolate-tk9kf]

First 🎉🎉🎉💪