Agree esp on the Dayeon one. I don't know why people discredit her so much when she holds her own with her skills and has great leadership qualities.
@gianinanutshell11662 жыл бұрын
Because she don't have talent
@gagsdoublej42542 жыл бұрын
Excuse me Sir/Madam Are you saved? If you died tonight are you going to heaven? Jesus loves you
@Akai7042 жыл бұрын
Idk but she seem pretty normal
@sthp92142 жыл бұрын
@@Akai704 if she is normal, then some of the other kepler members are below average. She is solid in every skill area, not just average, so I wouldn't say she is normal.
@gagsdoublej42542 жыл бұрын
@@sthp9214 God has everything under control Watch Sid Roth’s KZbin
@wonwoop2 жыл бұрын
you're spot on with the visuals opinion. i was always intrigued with nct because i see people saying they have really good choreo and are talented, but i only fully decided to get into every respective subunit with visuals like xiaojun, jaemin, jaehyun, and yuta, even though they are very talented. kim taehyung got me into bts with his stunning visuals. san got me into ateez. visuals play a huge role in attracting fans
@wonwoop2 жыл бұрын
@Tina it’s true 👁🫠🫠
@wonwoop2 жыл бұрын
@lemonssssssss4 literally. they find a way to complain about everything
@missluna___2 жыл бұрын
Yep. K-pop idols in groups are colleagues first and potentially friends second. It takes time to build a relationship with each other and being in a group together requires a ton of trust that takes time to build. As far as idols leaving the idol life, it happens. People get tired of being scrutinized left and right, performing with impossible schedules, and it's okay. Naeun left Apink for acting and as sad as I am that she's no longer with the group, I'm happy that she's following what she wants. Stage presence varies because of the many different concepts that groups have. I'm a Kep1er stan and the fandom popped off about their album sales but initially, digitals were low as hell. I'm glad they improved but you're very right about how popularity truly means that both physical and digital somewhat match. I hope that Kep1er's comeback makes those numbers at least a bit more even. DAYEON IS A QUEEN. I don't make the rules. She's such an ace. She does NOT deserve hate (nor do any of the other girls, thank you very little. stop it.) and she's a vital member of Kep1er. Kep1ians, I'm BEGGING you to find a way to coexist civilly otherwise this will ultimately crush the group's potential. We all have favorite members, we all have members we don't really vibe with, and that's okay. Also, it needs to be said that some members won't get as many lines as the others (Lightsum comes to mind with this one). That is on the COMPANY and not anyone else's fault, so direct your anger properly. We do not need to attack each other over who our bias is or who we don't necessarily like. For the love of all that is holy, please calm down already. P.S. Lightsum is having a comeback on May 24th at 6:00pm KST. Please support them and give their music a listen. They're super talented and we all know Cube is only going to give them crumbs. Thank youuuu. ❤
@Sammmm852 жыл бұрын
very well said👍
@jigeumbutteo16412 жыл бұрын
I really agreed with the Minju part! There were rumours that HYBE tried to 'chase' Minju like they did to Sakura and Chaewon so that they can debut Minju in Lesserafim too. But it was said that she rejected their offer so possibilities are shes either not interested in HYBE, she doesnt wanna debut under them or she just doesnt wanna be an idol anymore
@aamna51062 жыл бұрын
honestly in my opinion, yes having GP support is gud, but having a larger fandom is a lot more beneficial when you think about it in the long term
@reyanime2 жыл бұрын
Especially when general public's opinion can rapidly change, where in most cases, the fandom is in it for the long haul.
@OGseoulite2 жыл бұрын
Not for most groups it’s not because yeah it’s great having fans in the long run but if you DOMESTIC fanbase isn’t supporting you there’s really no point in a group existing if they’re not selling in their own country which is the targeted audience in the first place and international second
@Kay-zu5hc2 жыл бұрын
@@OGseoulite I guess target audience differ from company to company …. Usually big3 and Hybe have target audience in SK because we know they’ll listen to them no matter what and even if they have weak debut. Smaller companies can’t afford it, so groups like Dreamcatcher, Everglow and Ateez etc have target audience internationally, they chart very well in other countries and have huge fan bases
@jabajbajjabajbaj56642 жыл бұрын
Regarding the point with digital and physical sales i'd say 'yes' ... and 'no' at the same time. Yes - physical sales are not the sole factor deciding group popularity. But no - Korean GP is also not the one. You talked about 4th gen bgroups which are the best example of being very popular and successful groups without having Korean GP interest. They simply have huge international fanbases (and many times not only just fans but other ppl too - they may not follow them but still listem to their songs). Plus Korean GP focus more on gband - that's why gbands generally have better digitals than bbands (it's not the rule ofc but it's clearly seen which groups GP favors with even not very big gbands having better digitals than some big names within bbands). Even today i saw an article about K-netz being shocked about Ateez popularity during their world tour. They're not that big in Korea (and definitely not that popular within GP so they usually have weak digitals) but they still held a successful world tour at really big venues. And yes - this means they're successful.
@howyoudareh0wyoudare8862 жыл бұрын
agreed just because they dont chart as high as others on kcharts doesnt mean their unsuccessful!
@BhaktManomandirVihariniUma2 жыл бұрын
Agreed
@bangtanisation85072 жыл бұрын
The issue of physical sale is the reason why girl groups lack longervity, because most gg only have digital, korean gp won't buy physical albums, merch, concert tickets, fansign, fanmeet tickets etc these are what pays the idols and keep them afloat.
@justshar58122 жыл бұрын
The dayeon part!!! Totally agree, i know ppl hate her bc of how mnet put her in a lot of screentime plus showing her family but even before that happened she already attracted many viewers bc of her leadership and versatility especially on that ice cream performance She's so awesome on that round, being able to lead the lower rank girls and making them rank higher after the performance made me realize more how talented she is, she knows what she's doing and really smart At first ppl felt sorry for her bc she hasn't been ranking up but after she got more spotlight ppl starts to hate her. Its not her fault
@arstan80922 жыл бұрын
I somewhat agree with the stage precense one and somewhat not. While i agree that stage precense is very subjective, it is for sure also a talent in itself and is more complex. It is absolutely not as subjective as beauty since it is something multiple idols directly train to get better at. San from ateez is for example a example of someone who consistantly trains to get better precense. It is a skillset and can be somewhat measured (ofc just because something can be measured does not mean it will be true to everyone). It is more subjective than vocal rap and dance, but even vocal rap and dance is subjective but can still be measured. I am not the greatest at explaining stuff, but if you want to look more into it i would recommend EverglowUps videos on it. She explains it pretty well.
@kpoppuzzy2 жыл бұрын
agreed on everything except the charting one and album one and I believe that some groups have higher album sales because they have a large international fan base who listen to them while the general public might not be as supportive but a bigger fandom actually benefits groups more in the long run that gp
@some_random_person15272 жыл бұрын
all of these are true and im going to speak on the stan attractor thing and yes its true i hate when people deny it like?? if you dont know them yet the only thing you can get attracted to is their visuals not talent while stanning them you will learn about their talents but before that their visuals really matter because it makes you wanna take a deeper look at them
@ce50982 жыл бұрын
I agreed with everything except the stan attractor one. Of all the groups I stan/stanned or just a casual listener of, NCT is the ONLY group I stanned because of visuals (thank you, Johnny
@BhaktManomandirVihariniUma2 жыл бұрын
It's not only about you just like you Stan only NCT for visual many other might have Stan other groups for visual..
@ce50982 жыл бұрын
@@BhaktManomandirVihariniUma Exactly… that was literally the point I was making. NCT was the only group I liked because of visuals first, then music… everyone else was talent/music first.
@daychild_2 жыл бұрын
Exactly. I didn’t stan a single group bc of visuals, i just heard one of their songs, liked it, listened to their other songs, also liked those, and then learned the members’ names. The groups I stan have really unique looking members but even then none of them rlly caught my eye at first, mainly bc I don’t pay attention to the members of the group until I’m sure I wanna stan them lmao
@aizen33472 жыл бұрын
Finally someone talks about physical sales !
@candacescorner31412 жыл бұрын
Thank you for the first one, as I feel like people act like idols are all either best friends and the interactions on camera are completely organic or they are being bullied or hated by other members. It’s not that black and white, and it’s just a job, really.
@RiRi-ku6xz2 жыл бұрын
Dayeon is amazing…I didn’t watch the show I only watched some of kep1er stages..and she stood out to me and proved herself…and not bcuz she got most lines I don’t even stan her or the group..even i know she gets so much hate..it makes me angry..bcuz she’s top 2 most talented members of the group yet I barely see any praise for her in the comments I can’t help but imagine myself in her shoes she must have worked rlly hard for her skills and she’s clearly capable and responsible and that takes work…she’s literally doing everything right she can do yet stupid kep1er stans decides to hate on her for no absolute reason
@Moonlight298ergh2 жыл бұрын
International fan the one who always discredit and undermine her talent. Glad that most of kfan appreciate Dayeon.
@Sammmm852 жыл бұрын
i don't get into groups for visuals lol..and i'm not even lying..i got into kep1er bcz of dayeon..they appeared on a variety show -maybe weekly idol or idk bcz it was written in korean and dayeon were doing a freestyle dance in the song peaches and then she catched my attention.. i decided to know her more, so now i'm a fan of kep1er.. especially chaehyun, dayeon and youngeun..they are very talented..i'm a big fan of chaehyun and youngeun's vocals.. these 3 are my biases..
@mingbing79462 жыл бұрын
Same here. Vocals is what attracts me to certain groups. I know he's not kpop but I fell in love with the amazing voice of Dimash, while watching his videos I noticed some kpop videos and thought maybe KZbin recommended for some reason. First video I ever clicked on was EXO 'Universe' it was one of those color coded or whatever you call them videos. I fell in love with the vocals. Yes, they have great visuals but to me, it's the vocals. Same thing with Mamamoo vocals, vocals, vocals. Friends have tried to make me stan groups they love, telling me they sing good,, they a cute, they are popular but, for me, the vocals just don't do it.. I'm not saying they are bad because they aren't. They are talented but hey we are all attracted to something for different reasons. Did I make any sense? Jajajaj
@cysusa2 жыл бұрын
I just found your channel and I've been binge watching your videos. You are a breath of fresh air - you say a lot of the things I'm thinking. You're candid and very funny. Thank you!
@jAyBCD12 жыл бұрын
I agree with the Stan attractors, but for me, I don't really Stan groups because of their visuals. I just find a group, or know about them and check them out. I try to check out any group that comes my way (big or small), and I only like them, if Their debut song is good/future songs
@ree60422 жыл бұрын
i agree, in physical and digital sales shoud match. for example is bts they can match both sales and streams, can top both domestic and international chart. i also agree abt dayeon, i actually thought she'll be the leader of kep1er cuz she really has so much potential. she's not greedy, she motivates the members and she's very talented.
@reyanime2 жыл бұрын
Sales are a better indicator of popularity though compared to YT views. So many think their favs are getting popular when in reality their company is using heavy ads. Yes, groups can have high physical sales and still be pretty unknown to the general public, but they are still successful. International popularity is keeping a lot of groups around.
@ursa_._minor2 жыл бұрын
imo, both physical (album) sales and digital (yt, streaming) sales have their own pros and cons cause both can be done right and wrong. with the culture of bulk buying albums to join a fansign lottery, it boots the sales the same as watching mv or streaming on repeat…
@reyanime2 жыл бұрын
@@ursa_._minor Yeah, i've always been against bulk buying.
@sky_aiko2 жыл бұрын
YES U SPEAK FACTS!! its so hard to find a k-tuber with an actual brain these days, you’re so underrateddd
@jane80562 жыл бұрын
1:33- it is OKAY to miss idol minju and when she was on stage, of course we should accept the fact that she doesn’t want to be on stage, but obviously people will miss when she was on stage and that does not make them assuming what an idol wants
@alluzhin89522 жыл бұрын
The talent thing is so wrong for some of us idc how good looking they're if the music is bad I'm not watching anything they do
@BhaktManomandirVihariniUma2 жыл бұрын
It can be said about Groups who have better chart but not physical sales .. That shows only casual listener/Gp are listening to your music That doesn't guerantee a longetivity in career .. Gp will just move on next popular thing
@tsuchan58282 жыл бұрын
I like Tsuki, but Haram's stage presence is su much better imo. Her facial expressions are always on point.
@nowrinmostafa75832 жыл бұрын
Dayeon is the most talented member in the group in my opinion. Even if mnet pushed her they were right this time. Kepler fans don't want to credit her it's so sad. Xiaoting, Bahi can get praise for minimum thing but Dayeon can't even if she rocks the stage. These kpop fans are the same people who claim that they stan only talent. Such hypocrites.
@missluna___2 жыл бұрын
As a Kep1ian, I will agree that the fandom is an absolute mess. I wish that this crap would stop and we could just support them as a whole. People need to understand that when you refuse to support the group as a whole but only "support" one member, it hurts the group and therefore hurts their supposed favorite member. Make it make sense. I agree it's horribly hypocritical.
@moonchilds13532 жыл бұрын
Idk why you have to bring down the other girls just to uplift dayeon, like if u want to praise dayeon do it without mentioning the others
@nowrinmostafa75832 жыл бұрын
@@moonchilds1353 I am not bringing down anyone. It's just describing the situation. It is happening in the fandom.
@Sammmm852 жыл бұрын
@@moonchilds1353 that person didn't even bring others down.. other members stans always do this. i think you haven't seen those shit things . they always discredit some of the members .some members will get praised just for breathing and some of them will get hate even for their talent and hard work..
@gbmnbm41542 жыл бұрын
@@moonchilds1353 They’re bringing down their stans, learn the difference
@ayoidek65712 жыл бұрын
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING UP THE VISUALS ONE, more often that not, people excuse mediocre idols and even hail to god that they’re the most talented beings on this planet just bcz they’re attractive, while idols who aren’t as visually appealing have to be immaculate in whatever they specialize in to even get a fraction of the praise, no matter how hard people try to deny it it’s true, even the companies themselves cast people based on their visuals and not as visually appealing idols have to be out of this world talented in order to get casted.
@daychild_2 жыл бұрын
I only stan a few groups but here are the reasons why I stanned each of them lmao Verivery - idk my sister told me abt them about 7 months before I stanned them and one day I just got bored and decided to stan them Dkz - ik this is a rlly stupid reason but one of the members covered tag tag tag by verivery and I stanned them bc it’s rare to see other idols covering verivery lmao Vixx - I rlly liked chained up so why not stan them ig N.flying - they made an ost for lord of heroes and it was extremely good so I decided to stan them So yea I don’t stan groups bc of the individual members but I do pick biases based on visuals at first, i either choose the most good looking member or the most eye catching member, then once I get to know them I change them to the members whose personality I like the most lmao
@Faraizeru022 жыл бұрын
Bro, your sisters such a queen! Tbh it's rare someone who talk about Verivery and promote them TwT
@daychild_2 жыл бұрын
@@Faraizeru02 ikrrr lol
@nawelkahloul39882 жыл бұрын
i agree with everything except the stan attractor opinion because i care about talent 😁
@isasangelicstereotypebridg51952 жыл бұрын
About the minju one,source music. actually asked her if she wanted to be in lesserafim but as we know she declined. So I think she just doesn't want to be an idol anymore. If she did she would have accepted the source music offer.
@hiteshsolanki84142 жыл бұрын
So you are the camera women where source music begged in front of minju You find happines in degreding source music Hybe never begged for any idol
@isasangelicstereotypebridg51952 жыл бұрын
@@hiteshsolanki8414 bish calm down 🙄
@hiteshsolanki84142 жыл бұрын
@@isasangelicstereotypebridg5195 i m not bish i have d**k 🤣🤣
@essavanz2 жыл бұрын
Fact: Snsd was and is still the best kpop girl group. They had everything and them some. To this day I still dont see anyone surpassing them. So happy that all 9 members are killing it in their respective life choices.
@rareandco2 жыл бұрын
we all know that most of physical sales are made from stans who wants to win a videocall so they buy like 10 each one of them............
@jeremiahgoard20662 жыл бұрын
That’s the worst excuse ever. Most physical album sales are made from Stan’s who want to financially help their group. This is why most boy groups last longer than girl groups because y’all aren’t buying their albums.
@rareandco2 жыл бұрын
@@jeremiahgoard2066it was a fact not an excuse
@jeremiahgoard20662 жыл бұрын
@@rareandco How Was it a fact? Lol it is an excuse to make up for low album sales. Girl Groups Usually Get more views and gp attention while Boy Groups get Fanbases Actually Dedicated to them.
@rareandco2 жыл бұрын
@@jeremiahgoard2066 nah girl, mostly bg stans are the ones who buys a lot of albums just to get a video call with the members (completely ok to do it) it’s literally known
@Yellow6.62 жыл бұрын
To me i got attracted to lisa rapping style which is a talent ofcourse and second lusa blonde hair i was really into coloring my hair And most of the time nowdays i feel talent is necessary and personality too because i love tzuyu but prefer jihyo as my bias for her dance , vocals and personality
@forgivenessmphulo22602 жыл бұрын
I agree with your opinion about physical sales, I also think that having a primarily international fan base is not a bad thing I mean bts had a world tour in 2014 in sold out arenas worldwide and their music was charting internationally but they were practically unknown in South Korea, what I'm saying is a strong international Fandom is important to keep the group going and for them to keep doing activities and build their name, but a Korean fan base is also important because at the end of the day these are Korean groups they sing and perform in Korean so I would think that they would want to chart and have concerts in their own country, and be nominated and win prestigious Korean awards and that all happens with a stable Korean Fandom not even the GP but the fans are really important to the longevity of any group, and we can all admit that some international fans are really fickle, so again the k-fans are key
@myriamtouil33472 жыл бұрын
SOOO TRUE FOR SALE ALBUM THINGS ABOUT BOYS GROUP IT MEANS NOTHINGSS THANK YOUUUUUUU
@nemeuseiquemeusouquemdirav74162 жыл бұрын
4:36 I agree sm with this one, not exactly about the beauty part but yes. For exemple I got in Itzy after I saw a video about how charyong
@RiRi-ku6xz2 жыл бұрын
Not all fandom can reach the same album sales Gp popularity is good..but i was in a group i’d rather have those million album sales rather then digital chart..bcuz MONEY..also GP interest can easily shift from u and u would be left with nothing…while sailing alot means u have dedicated fans that would follow u and support
@BhaktManomandirVihariniUma2 жыл бұрын
Exactly
@babyanie46732 жыл бұрын
Yes! Minju only wanted to continue if Iz*one continued. Hybe wanted her and she turned down the offer.
@sofarsh52712 жыл бұрын
honestly haven't really heard that much of dayeon's vocals but she is certainly a great rapper and dancer! also wanted to say that the one thing that kpop stans never admit is that sometimes stan attracters are just not talented enough as other members so no wonder the line distribution is so short on them. they are as well important in the group, just not in the way stans want them to. however i still don't get it why in some successful companies they put the artists with no skills compared to other members. in my opinion it's obvious that others will stand out more and shade the stan attractors...
@Vosee-k5d2 жыл бұрын
,,Evey fandom can mass buy" why they don't do it then? Why they don't hit those numbers, why only specific ones do it? / srs
@nevereverigoteyesonyou83772 жыл бұрын
Not just physical sales but even other kind of achievements should not be considered as ultimate measure of success ..... Brand rankings, concert sales, YT views, esp. digitals , everything can be manipulated or bought by the company......and general public listening their faves on korean apps are also huge no. of fans streaming night and day just like KZbin..... These parameters should be used as a relief that their fave's bills are payed unlike some really unlucky flop artists, but kpopies use it to downgrade other groups
@jeremiahgoard20662 жыл бұрын
So then how would you determine popularity then if you take away everything?
@hj64312 жыл бұрын
@@jeremiahgoard2066 point, but probably group who scores in all areas or whoose numbers are match in all area like album sale, yt views, streams, charting, concert sales ets all can't manipulate at same times
@meilindajoycesitompul92822 жыл бұрын
i got into billlie bcs flipping a coin played while i listen to shuffle play........
@p0rnany0ne2 жыл бұрын
What’s the video playing at 0:20 & 6:25?
@mikkydorri10152 жыл бұрын
Some people really put group like TXT and enhypen like to see their songs they are so good looking Like i already listened their songs I didn't like it that much that their fandom overhyped them with using so superior words I don't Listen artist song based on how good they look I just listen on Spotify 😐😐
@KOOKlEDOUGH2 жыл бұрын
can i just say with sales and popularity? what good is charting high and getting good streams if the people listening to your music isn’t willing to buy it? idk ab mass buying or whatever and i stan bts so like they’re both, but i can’t say i agree popularity means having the general publics support, sure it’s one form of popularity but ultimately you need a lot of fans who are willing to actually spend money on you to do well, charts isn’t worth anything if you can’t sell the music you’re supposedly charting so well with
@Tarikkb2 жыл бұрын
I think yeseo from kep1er has one of the Biggest potentials in the group , she’s 16 and can be on the dance , visual , vocal line and is a natural center
@siu5422 жыл бұрын
I'm last 😂
@aprajitasikdar17502 жыл бұрын
intro song name
@fryeji14232 жыл бұрын
Dayeon was the main character of girls planet and we all know it
@del__2 жыл бұрын
I have one fact for Dayeon Saying she was pushed to enter the lineup or had favoritism from MNET doesn't mean she is untalented and she sucks, Dayeon is super talented and important like you said and accept the fact that she got favoritism doesn't change that
@RougeLino2 жыл бұрын
They meant to say that some idols are not there for the music... Just the fame boost. - hyewon
@RougeLino2 жыл бұрын
Well I'm proud to say that I like many many grps but I ONLY STAN TALENT AND QUALITY MUSIC
@juicyjisoox2 жыл бұрын
dayeon wasn’t gp999’s og k01 for nothing💅🏼
@missluna___2 жыл бұрын
Nothing but facts here.
@user-ui4dj2jz3m2 жыл бұрын
I agree on the dayeon one but I don’t think it’s a fact. We don’t know it but maybe kep1er would be fine whiteout her.
@sejaljustin72322 жыл бұрын
If gp is soo imp why do girl groups disband at a faster pace. Albums sales are the ones that pays an artist
@Assunta_capozzo2 жыл бұрын
another fact: zoom dance cover are better than the original version, i fell that Jessi isn’t a great dancer and she didn’t give the right energy (sry for my grammar)
@monicac6172 жыл бұрын
you wouldn't have a big fandom if you weren't popular ?? the gp is really not as important as people want them to be. anybody(artist or business) would rather have a group of people that supports them than people who might check them out every once in a while
@RougeLino2 жыл бұрын
I disagree with the tsuki opn. She's not the best but there's clearly a rank bcs no... It's not THAT subject. And she's not the standard bcs she's above the standard
@mariaferreirasilva66842 жыл бұрын
Dayeon isn't an ace, most idols aren't, kpop stans just call that their fav idols that, also, I like her but she isn't fundamentel
@maryg38792 жыл бұрын
Third;)
@chimeyoon602 жыл бұрын
I'm sorry but your whole idea about the physical sales and the GP is stupid 😂
@butnamjoongunshot25102 жыл бұрын
What is gp?
@chimeyoon602 жыл бұрын
@@butnamjoongunshot2510 the general public non fans
@butnamjoongunshot25102 жыл бұрын
@@chimeyoon60 ok thanks💜
@maristelmalco7212 жыл бұрын
Im sorry but for me you speak too fast ,im not a native english speaker 😊
@ayoidek65712 жыл бұрын
It’s not their real voice it’s an AI (robot) voice that’s why