How China Targets Muslims for 'Re-Education' Camps - and Spies on Their Families

The goal of China’s so-called re-education camps in the region of Xinjiang is to assimilate long-marginalized Muslim minorities, mostly Uighurs and Kazakhs, into Han Chinese culture. The government says the centers have expanded development and helped prevent terrorism. But the internee records reviewed by VICE News reveal that the vast majority of people sent to the camps were detained for mundane and legal behavior, including wearing a hijab, having “thick beards,” visiting a foreign website, applying for a passport, traveling abroad to a “sensitive country” or having family members living in one, or being part of a “religious family.”
Subscribe to VICE News here: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE-News
Check out VICE News for more: vicenews.com
Follow VICE News here:
Facebook: / vicenews
Twitter: / vicenews
Tumblr: / vicenews
Instagram: / vicenews
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
#VICENews #News

[@VICENews]

The vast majority of people were interned for mundane behavior like wearing a hijab, having “thick beards,” visiting a foreign website, or applying for a passport. WATCH NEXT: China's Vanishing Muslims: Undercover In The Most Dystopian Place In The World - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rGikiqyLpteAq7M

[@HarshSharma-uf8jc]

You haven't made a video on recent issue with Kashmir. Let me know when it's coming. BTW this video was amazing. Keep up the good work.

[@kennyng2289]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJeXio14npmIisU

[@kennyng2289]

@@HarshSharma-uf8jc kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJeXio14npmIisU

[@kennyng2289]

@Senri Shiki kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJeXio14npmIisU

[@jakelaw9768]

As long as religion is not politicalized, it is allowed. The problem in Xin Jiang is about separatism and terrorism, not a religious issue.

[@hanagreg]

This journalist is everywhere and can speak every language.

[@kayilla6413]

Shes wifey

[@chancemitchell4147]

She’s the god damn Batman.

[@dsmith8643]

@@kayilla6413 Tell her. That her God is calling out for her to come

[@maxmfilms]

I love Isobel

[@onlythestrongsurvive4454]

Isobel yeung❤

[@IFAMILYIH]

THE FACT NO ONE SPEAKS ABOUT THIS IS A DISGRACE TO HUMANITY

[@jackieadad4815]

No its not

[@riheg]

I FAMILYIH I’ll tell you whats a disgrace: Isobel works for Murdoch. Google it. I guarantee you that CIA mouthpiece VICE is not gonna give you context, around 20.000 chinese jihadis and family members are now based out of Jisr al Shugur in Syria. Their goal is to get experience in the future fight for a caliphate in China. Authorities crack down hard on islamic fundamentalism as well as regular muslims, but the deep state don’t want people to know context about jihadism and the syrian war. I guarantee you that CIA mouthpiece VICE is not gonna give you context, around 20.000 chinese jihadis and family members are now based out of Jisr al Shugur in Syria. Their goal is to get experience in the future fight for a caliphate in China. Authorities crack down hard on islamic fundamentalism as well as regular muslims, but the deep state don’t want people to know context about jihadism and the syrian war. www.nytimes.com/2019/10/10/business/media/james-murdoch-vice-media.html?0p19G=0038

[@effycurtis9735]

There’s literally a thousand news network and papers blasting these propaganda in for the last 6 month, are you blind? China is not against Muslim or Xinjiang, they are against extremists and separatists. If China want to do ethnic cleansing bad they wouldn’t allow 55 minorities has as many kids as they want or social benefit.

[@alexfrank5331]

The fact that no one speaks about this is a disgrace and a hypocrisy: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Gong_practitioners_in_China

[@tytube3001]

yes like Pakistan

[@shahzebwasheybro3333]

I feel ashamed as a Pakistani that my government is completely silent on this issue. Sadly, billion in Chinese investment is more important than our morals.

[@Gazalamunu]

China is your "papa".😜 now turkey want to impress you.

[@isaachussain607]

I feel you Imran Khan has let me down big time same for Turkish gov and Saudi gov and all muslims governments apart from Albania i think Albania is the only muslim country that stood up to China i think

[@EdoHP]

Nah I would say your government is smart to not trust american propaganda. The same propaganda that is whitewashing Israel atrocities in Gaza but suddenly care about Muslims in China.

[@basedgodstrugglin]

This is the Vice we want and the Vice we need.

[@brendenhickman2488]

Indeed

[@chinesejesus6737]

SheepIe

[@brendenhickman2488]

@@chinesejesus6737 TRUMPSTIEN NOOOOOOOOOOOOO we need u building that wall fren, not here on the internet

[@ericcartmann]

@@chinesejesus6737 Go back to your factory and build me an HDMI cable.

[@riheg]

Whats wrong with you? I guarantee you that CIA mouthpiece VICE is not gonna give you context, around 20.000 chinese jihadis and family members are now based out of Jisr al Shugur in Syria. Their goal is to get experience in the future fight for a caliphate in China. Authorities crack down hard on islamic fundamentalism as well as regular muslims, but the deep state don’t want people to know context about jihadism and the syrian war. www.nytimes.com/2019/10/10/business/media/james-murdoch-vice-media.html?0p19G=0038

[@estebannemo1957]

Kudos to any news agency reporting on this issue. Other news outlets are afraid or indifferent.

[@traplover6357]

@darwinianmenace ah yes. Authoritarianism to combat religous extremism instead of the free marketplace of ideas where we can battle out the best ones.

[@Rocmax417]

darwinianmenace you realize they do the same to Christians too right?

[@-green-405]

@darwinianmenace 'low iq individual' Imagine being this much of a simp

[@brendenhickman2488]

@darwinianmenace You my dude, should have never been shown the internet

[@josephk1342]

@darwinianmenace nice projection

[@daphne1065]

HOW IS NOBODY TALKING ABOUT THIS WHILE GENOCIDE IS HAPPENING BENEATH OUR NOSES :'(

[@PratikLatne]

How will they get those tasty chinese investment if they talk about it?😋

[@rhanz5748]

bcos we are humans, we are not some marvel avengers

[@hamzafarooqui6753]

because its benifiting them

[@xuhan1981v]

It is Anti terrorism campaigns. Terrorism is like virus, quarantine is necessary.

[@hassan571]

@@xuhan1981v That's not anti-terorrism. The Chinese government is training them to hate the Hans. Just wait for their revenge.

[@AssassinYTLive]

This becomes funny when you realise that Pakistan is their allie

[@idtechcelestial6507]

money play a important rule in this world ... not even GOD. So Chinese Gov can do whatever they want with their citizen a not a single country will help.

[@hsnjml]

Pakistan is a covert Shia estate controlling Muslims.

[@dwiranu5394]

That's only for facing India.

[@thekillers1stfan]

Pakistan's corruption runs deeper than their faith lol

[@HassanAli-kx6tm]

Pakistan is their allies because pakistan is stranded by other muslim countries other than turkey just like iran. So they don't have any other choice but to ally with china.

[@cyin974]

Good job Vice, but please be vigilant and stay safe. The world needs more voices like this.

[@ap283]

@darwinianmenace stop liking your own comments you facist

[@TheWaleedKhalid]

@darwinianmenace 🇨🇳=🐷

[@riheg]

I guarantee you that CIA mouthpiece VICE is not gonna give you context, around 20.000 chinese jihadis and family members are now based out of Jisr al Shugur in Syria. Their goal is to get experience in the future fight for a caliphate in China. Authorities crack down hard on islamic fundamentalism as well as regular muslims, but the deep state don’t want people to know context about jihadism and the syrian war.

[@BERSERK263]

@@ap283 Vice doesn't know the meaning of the meaning of "objective journalism"

[@evano5635]

Cheah chung yin vice will be safe because China isn’t doing anything in humane to these people. It’s just like sending white supremacist to reduction camp. Pls stop spreading imperialist propaganda

[@MidniteSan]

Ironically now they whole country is the world's largest isolation camp.

[@JewTube001]

the whole world is an isolation camp. only way to leave is to die.

[@alonewanderer5688]

@Thomas Shelby Leader of the Peaky Fookin Blinders Allah is pig

[@mustaphasamsam3257]

@Inw KZbin yeah china would 100% win against almost 3 billion people and a millenial ideology, just like they did with tibet and taiwan

[@mustaphasamsam3257]

@@Blt435 sure. I don't who's dumber, racist incels or islamists

[@kennyng2289]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJeXio14npmIisU

[@suhani551]

And then they say Indian Muslims are oppressed. First come to India and see the reality. How their population is constantly growing.

[@syedubair]

I'm in Kashmir. Illegally occupied by India. And I can see your oppression in every moment of the day. Not just in Kashmir but outside of it as well. Don't come up with a false narrative.

[@saltshakerchris2878]

@@syedubair Both India and China are responsible for oppressing Muslims

[@anisahs2110]

“They must be breeding so they can’t have it all bad” lmao GTFO of here man. India is literally building a concentration camp and you’re so busy with how many babies people are having 🙄

[@itr8247]

Move to pakistan then. ​@@syedubair

[@syedubair]

@@itr8247 your intellect 👌

[@jibannayak7]

I'm sure no Pakistani will comment here.

[@yungcrescent]

Whatsup

[@darshanshettigar2710]

They know where to close their eyes and speak when there is no necessary they won't speak because technically China is their godfather

[@tannietae2093]

@@darshanshettigar2710 Hey. Seem like my neighbour missed me. How are you guys? As a Pakistani I am really ashamed our government ignored this issue. Many people don't even know about that because our stupid media is busy covering unnecessary political drama. I am trying to educate people whom I know, about what China is doing. I really want to help them but sadly we can't do anything. Pakistan is under developed country. If Pakistan spoke anything against these so-called superpowers then they will do what they have did to Syria, Afghanistan and many other Muslim country. Sadly, no other Muslim country will help us like what they are doing for Syria.

[@romaisahuzaifa722]

why? i just did!......

[@dankistani9552]

Hello there

[@Hart501]

I’d say the ex husbands story is very typical of threats by secret police organizations. Both East Germany and the Soviet Union used extremely similar and often more brutal tactics, he’s lucky he wasn’t tortured into compliance.

[@wheresmyeyebrow1608]

@Profit Mohamad Who cares lol we're talking about China right now

[@williamhackett5713]

It’s recently came out that the Uighur Muslims were trained and radicalised by the CIA in Syria and Afghanistan as a way to try and use propaganda against western civilisation to gain support for the USA and the west to go to war with China, I urge you all to seriously be very careful about your thoughts when western mainstream media outlets start to report on “the Chinese oppression of Uighurs”. Never forget what our western leaders have tried against us these last 2 years. Make love not war

[@16watch]

Wow. Some of the comments on this video are scarier than the video itself. We are doomed to repeat the mistakes of our ancestors over and over again.

[@nathanremix5800]

@@chinesejesus6737 hey , stop invading their country and problem solved.

[@Msn-bo8tm]

Trumpstein Thats hilarious but didn’t the US fund early terrorism and give it a platform from which to expand? (During the Cold War)

[@europai1793]

I still wonder how these people are able to walk freely and be counted as members of society with violent and insane thoughts and beliefs.

[@danv3004]

I can understand Uighur woman when she speaks in her mother tongue. I am a Kazakh. I can feel her pain losing a touch with her sister. My uncle who survived a Nazi concentration camp cried every time when he told us kids stories about the WW2 horrors. RIP uncle This is oppression of Uighur and Kazakh people. I really think something is going to happen and people will be freed.

[@LalaLa-ze7kv]

@@Lilhajxjk274 they should put all han chinese people in there so in china there would be no crime👍

[@Lilhajxjk274]

@@LalaLa-ze7kv The thing is that they aren't punishing all uyghurs. They are just Punishing the ones with terrorist connections

[@ahmadnaser8172]

@@Lilhajxjk274 nothing is justified commie, you wouldnt be talking like that had it been your family

[@Lilhajxjk274]

@@ahmadnaser8172 My family isnt terrorist so it wouldn't happen to me.

[@seaofroses8888]

@@Lilhajxjk274 If so, why are there former CCP members appearing in hacked documents? Almost like it’s an ethnic genocide

[@jaa89623]

VICE is doing some of the most amazing journalism I've ever seen. Immense respect to these reporters, producers, and camera people for doing dangerous work and telling stories that the world needs to know.

[@arbs3ry]

【世界一周】No.38新疆ウイグル自治区・ウルムチ kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3yWcpaZhLOMb9U 中国旅行、ウイグル自治区ウルムチ、China travel, Uyghur, Urumqi, from Japan. Night walking view kzbin.info/www/bejne/hJDJeJucd5qdf5I Above are by oordinary Japanese travelers traveling the region last year！ There are tons of them on KZbin by travelers from different countries around the world! Vice= lies

[@sherazaziz1869]

Absolutely right

[@hwawihwawi3607]

This is stupid. Vice and the left is a joke.

[@jaa89623]

@@arbs3ry I don't know what those videos are supposed to show, but they certainly don't refute VICE's (or any other credible) reporting on China's human rights abuses.

[@jaa89623]

@@hwawihwawi3607 You're attempt at parroting Chinese gov't talking points is a joke.

[@xenmafia2041]

You know the video is gonna be good when the comment section is extra cancerous

[@tc5372]

@IMxYOURxDADDY true

[@nithishkumar1010]

As Indian Only thing I agree with china . China u made right decision hats off. India is afraid to save their majority itself.

[@ellaassa4799]

Please keep the testifier's faces and names covered for their own safety, we never know what might happen to them once you leave. These are extremely dangerous governments. It's ironic how the extremists are creating "re-education" camps for so called while they are practicing extremist behavior, on seemingly harmless people. Prejudice can be a scary thing.

[@supremereader7614]

Wow, a news organization that realizes there’s other things happening in the world non- Donald Trump related.

[@ischaq.]

I pity for your small world.

[@Mike-bt3ki]

Lol it's a news organisation they write garbage and opinionated articles just for profits and attention

[@user-eu8dt1bl8b]

Acctualy i think that this is a question of poilitic not religion

[@jude4400]

Gasp. Never seen before

[@MrSpecialhacker]

Quran 22:40 "Those who were unjustly expelled from their homes for no other reason than their saying 'Allah is Our Lord'.

[@clevernduruza8624]

Isn't Israel doing the same to Palestine?

[@fasiistyrer]

It's rich coming from a muslim. There isn't a single muslim country in the world that isn't actively discriminating against it's minorities.

[@MrSpecialhacker]

@@fasiistyrer Quran goes further in protecting the rights of the followers of other faiths by obligating us Muslims to protect anything dear to their religion. A muslim country is not the quran! Once you start poking the bear or in this case 'muslims', you'll expect the same faith to those as they have imposed on ours.

[@ductuvlog3658]

@@clevernduruza8624 yup they fight back and they define the act against oppression as terrorism. Similar, don't u think?

[@omarsabry9489]

@@fasiistyrer Explain Egypt

[@nicoledonald3858]

"Do you want revenge?" Covid-19: *hold my bag*

[@rayclm]

Oops, USA covid 19 just past 6 mil by end of Aug 2020.

[@jude4400]

and chinas covid is getting better, in the sense that it’s lessening

[@alisonmak8361]

Look at who’s suffering now

[@Neuvari]

well do you still want revenge now? LOL

[@importantnazriya9136]

Hi 🌷✋

[@mohisinas4286]

May Allah grant them ease and protect them and us 😭 Ameen❤️ 😭😭

[@manalasad3598]

@Mike T what do you mean?

[@sumanmajumdar7884]

@@manalasad3598 r u Indian?

[@sumanmajumdar7884]

@Mohsina Seikh r u Indian?

[@mohisinas4286]

@@sumanmajumdar7884 yes

[@sumanmajumdar7884]

@@mohisinas4286 can u tell what do think about Uighurs issue and do u support Indian govt if they raise Uighurs issue seriously and what's your muslim community think about it plz reply me and if can then contact me on Instagram "18402suman" it's my Instagram id

[@tbn1996]

Isobel Yeung is doing such an AMAZING job!! Shes every damn where and is so good to listen to. Her questions are on point as well. Really appreciate you Isobel!!

[@chinesejesus6737]

lsobeI is a biased b1tch Long live Gaddafi and old green Libya

[@tbn1996]

Trumpstein calling her bi*** says a lot about yourself tbh..

[@FirdausIsmail1]

chinese ccp bot absolutely rampant in YT despite being banned in China lmao

[@yass123]

I love her. I was surprised she speaks Chinese. What is her ethnicity?

[@rickiex]

@@yass123 she is mixed, her last name yeung tells me she's Hong Kong, most likely her father is Hong kong and her accent tells me she's also British, so her mother is british. She's actually and probably trilingual, speaking English, manderian Chinese, and Hong Kong. I honestly wouldnt be surprised if she can speak 4.

[@Serenityfor1]

Really sad to see this happening to anyone, after the Holocaust we can never look away again when a people are singled out and imprisoned for their religious beliefs!

[@FixedFace]

yeah, mslms are known for their support of the jewish people all over the word

[@leavesinautumn5959]

@@FixedFace About as well known as Jewish support of Muslims ..

[@chinesejesus6737]

@@leavesinautumn5959 Yeah of course IsraeI are in love with wahhabist saudi arabia

[@leavesinautumn5959]

@@chinesejesus6737 Extreme ideology and oppressive governance, relationships are built on finding common ground. Israel should keep an eye out for China though, it also shares that appeal and has been making eyes at KSA lately.

[@clevernduruza8624]

They should just stop believing how hard can that be

[@rupakmandal305]

China's future looks peaceful

[@themercifulguard3971]

A totalitarian rule and fully monitored people is one way of looking peaceful to outsiders

[@moralezfamily3047]

Biden 2020

[@thesimpledude186]

by peaceful, you mean everything is destroyed and noone is alive in china?

[@rupakmandal305]

@@thesimpledude186 peaceful means no religious bs

[@thesimpledude186]

@@rupakmandal305 but at the same time, no single human alive means it is peaceful too right?

[@thenutbrothers8726]

Uighurs, Uighur Turks!!!! And some thousands Kazakhs, Uzbeks and kirgizs too ,Turks. Hui - ethnic Chinese muslims thrive in China as they share the same land and language and culture.

[@natsumi1120]

Here before the Chinese bots 🤖

[@chinesejesus6737]

China gives MusIim youth free Education = EviI and lnhumane USA/NATO bombard MusIim countries = Freedom & Democracy!

[@chinesejesus6737]

China bad All hail the central bank..Oy Vey!

[@ap283]

You said it and they arrived

[@smellyvirgin5579]

@@chinesejesus6737 Being a Chinese bot must be the most boring job in the world.

[@TheWaleedKhalid]

@@chinesejesus6737 🇨🇳=🐷

[@dave_riots]

I wonder how long it'll be before the Chinese propaganda bots show? 🤔 EDIT: I didn't know there were Islamophobe bots here too.

[@DrJames_YT]

Now lol

[@SansTheSkeleton-tb9jv]

Lmao

[@supernovanotp1938]

Don't call them Chinese... they r CCP bots. Chinese r good people altho they have lil prejudice against Muslims. But they mean no harm. I know coz I'm Indian.

[@mastersonogashira1796]

Super Nova NoTp not all of us, when your government kidnap your country, and patriotism become evil, you will understand

[@riheg]

David isobel is working for Murdoch. Google it

[@SiRasputin]

What is the update on uyghur "genocide" in 2024? How many uyghurs have been killed?

[@SatyaJanta]

*HOW ISLAMIST COUNTRIES TARGET NON-MUSLIM MINORITY. WHY DIDN'T MAD ANY VIDEO THIS TOPIC.*

[@BoogieSpiderman]

Great job! Shows that main media isn't afraid of touching. Be safe always.

[@CoffeeChai]

Every now and then something like this kind of extremist party activity happens often that people don't know or make awaresss even for those who knows. Here, nearby our state too we had no idea about the Myanmar militia torture of the Rohingyas.So glad that their voices were heard throughout the world 🙌🏽 Vice and its journalism works are priceless!

[@desi6158]

I'm a pakistani and a muslim and am heart broken

[@bill_tan]

you can go to xinjiang to have a look, then you know the truth.... only hear from stories....naive

[@sunnyrajput1912]

I salute china for solving extremist islamic Invader problem.

[@TheBlackei1]

This is the kind of stuff we should be reading about more on frontpage news. It's too bad that in order to find videos like this you practically have to look for it.

[@lordsoffilm5459]

"Big brother is watching you."

[@jsdev4454]

"little brother coronavirus is watching you."

[@philiposborne982]

@@jsdev4454 actually we do both. It's not big chef little chef... It's a totalitarian control structure pit in place by all the intelligence agencies in earth. We got fed up of managing all the bullshit. So we locked you all down for a few months. Recondition your silly little asses. Didn't really work in the USA but who cares about them. China are the boss country now.

[@tommyzty1089]

Great reporting as usual. I just hope people can differentiate between the Chinese people and government, the issue is with the government, not the people who didn't get to choose.

[@Mitchery]

Are you Chinese?

[@user-yo3ux6ch7s]

Agree. Indeed Han Chinese are suffering from CCP regime as well. Latest Ata-Jurt Human right video testimony from ex-prisoner indicates there were Han Chinese in concentration camp as well.

[@creditcard3466]

The spectator and the executor are no different in this stance's

[@hanjoshitmata5602]

MsSunhappy that’s true but there are so many chinese people (ik since my parents immigrated from China) that KNOW and ACTIVELY support or encourage this. I won’t generalize the whole population but chinese blind nationalism is so strong, especially on the Internet

[@isaachussain607]

@@hanjoshitmata5602 I agree but not all Chinese people have that disgusting mindset and mentality so you cant group them all together thats the very thing that got the muslims thrown into the camps, the fact that chinese government thinks all muslims are bad

[@jarnaraphoto]

I didn't skip any single ad. Thank u so much for this coverage 🙏

[@BabaJaga]

please keep posting on this topic, it has to stay in the public eye. The Chinese people and especially those in concentration camps must not be overlooked

[@saltshakerchris2878]

@Xun Gu Aren't you brainwashed by your own government?

[@saltshakerchris2878]

@Xun Gu Plus, CGTN is a propaganda channel, just like Fox News

[@saltshakerchris2878]

@Xun Gu You want the truth? Here: theintercept.com/2018/08/13/china-muslims-uighur-detention/ theintercept.com/2019/12/29/why-dont-we-care-about-chinas-uighur-muslims/

[@qingli6476]

@@saltshakerchris2878 lol anything you disagree with is being called brain washed then who is the real person got brainwashed question mark. One tiny problem may be you know recognize is, no matter what language the report speak and the people they interview speak, they can understand each other without translation. Some word they say I can not understand, how can they understand better than me. I believe having heart for justice and real human rights should be encouraged but don’t let this kind of desire destroy you and led to the opposite side of what you wish. I am not say this report is fake or real. I am also not saying Xinjiang concentration camp is true or not. I just feel sometimes we get to judge but ourselves and really think. Otherwise how can you or me know I am not being brainwashed.

[@ap283]

These racist comments all say yes continue doing this but if this were to happen to them they'll be screaming for their lives for help.

[@chinesejesus6737]

Say that to the poor non MusIims massacred by the Jihadists

[@FixedFace]

islm is not a race you victimhood fetishist

[@ap283]

@@FixedFace half of the world doesnt know that but blame eveything on muslims lol you idiots are the ones who called it a race

[@sultantheconqueror969]

@@chinesejesus6737 all these extremist you talk about they dont even practice the religion of islam properly so shut up

[@sultantheconqueror969]

@@chinesejesus6737 you just say whatever comes to your head eh. Go bend over for xi JINPING

[@furai-ingfalc-kuru8149]

What an incredibly brave reporter. It's so saddening to hear what the Chinese gov't is doing. Despicable. Western gov'ts are doing the similar no doubt with refugee internment camps such as Naaru Island, Mexican border camps and the like but this is on another level in line with what Communist nations have done over and over again. I dread the next 50 years on this planet. Everything is gearing up for nothing but despair and horror with no beauty, no serious hope for an enlightened future in sight. I hope we get some visitors from outer space (I know, I know) but just something major that forces those horrible, sociopathic rulers to realise that we are all human and all together on the same team. Planet Earth

[@ChinaCommonSense]

What a shame of western mainstream medias like this . making such a fake news to cheat people! It is a lie! Every news about accusing China oppressing Muslime are make somebody talking .Always a people of unknown origin talking .So many years ,not any photos or videos transpired that can show China goverment mistreating ,battering Muslim people ?Why ?because western medias are lying! They are cheating people who've never been to China,They demonize China ,They want to make people believe that China is evil ,so that peopele will always believe that the western goverment is good and they did well ..Look at the truth about XinJiang,look at the truth about china! dont be foolished and brainwashed! 1.The original “evidence” of 1 million Uyghurs being sent to concentration camps original stems from US propaganda outlets: thegrayzone.com/2019/12/21/china-detaining-millions-uyghurs-problems-claims-us-ngo-researcher/ 2. The Keriya Aitika Mosque that was claimed in 2018 to be demolished is actually still there. They were merely renovating, albeit most buildings surrounding the mosque was replaced with newer/bigger ones as Xinjiang is developing incredibly fast. medium.com/@sunfeiyang/the-case-of-the-keriya-aitika-mosque-efa29e456339 3. The often used picture of Uyghurs dressed uniformly lined up sitting in a re-education camp actually comes from an early 2017 picture of regular prisoners in Xinjiang listening to a public speech in a regular jail. It wasn't just prisoners who listened to the speech. web.archive.org/web/20180820154817/ baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1564669932542581&wfr=spider&for=pc (scroll down to the middle to see the picture). 4. The video of a supposed Uyghur being beaten for having a copy of a Quaran, was actually an Indonesian police beating a pickpocket. The police was discharged afterwards. factcheck.afp.com/no-not-video-chinese-soldier-beating-uighur-muslim-having-copy-koran 5. Some pictures of Uyghurs in Chinese detention camps, including that of a crying child, are pictures edited from protests, people rescued from human trafficking, and Uyghurs protesting outside in 2009 as a result of a riot that killed 156 people. factcheck.afp.com/these-photos-show-protests-istanbul-and-xinjiang-and-migrant-shelter-thailand 6. Claim of a Chinese police officer strangling a Uyghur woman caught praying is actually a video of the police officer restraining a violent drunk woman in 2018. factcheck.afp.com/video-shows-police-officer-pinning-down-drunk-chinese-woman-his-knee-hotel-shenzhen 7. Picture of “forced labor” of Uyghurs, first published by Forbes, originally came from a factory in 2010 Brazil. i.redd.it/20mzu89zo1d51.jpg 8. Picture of an “uyghur” with his eyes/mouth/ears sewn shut, is actually a picture of Abas Amini protesting the UK’s treatment of asylum seekers in 2003 i.redd.it/9zixb3ukmad51.png news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/nottinghamshire/2941780.stm 9. Rushan Abbas, who claimed that her sister/friends are locked in Chinese concentration camps, is actually a participator of Guantanamo Bay in 2003, which has verifiable human rights violations against Muslim prisoners. When confronted she claimed she was only a translator, but also justified Guantanamo Bay. www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/e9ad4n/i_am_rushan_abbas_uyghur_activist_and_survivor_of/ 10. Much of BBC’s visit to a Uyghur re-education center have words mistranslated or taken out of context by BBC in order to fit a certain narrative. Nevertheless, BBC did make a second unannounced “surprise” visit late at night, only to see Uyghurs leaving the center, supposedly for the weekend. medium.com/@sunfeiyang/breaking-down-the-bbcs-visit-to-hotan-xinjiang-e284934a7aab 11. Sayragul Sauytbay first claimed that she did not see any violence, only hunger and that they never had any meat. However, later her story changed, claiming that they were forced to eat pork. She also added a new story that she saw police raping prisoners in public, and anyone who showed facial expressions or couldn’t watch was taken away and disappeared. www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/world/article-everyone-was-silent-endlessly-mute-former-chinese-re-education/ www.haaretz.com/amp/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-a-million-people-are-jailed-at-china-s-gulags-i-escaped-here-s-what-goes-on-inside-1.7994216 12. Adrian Zenz claimed that according to 2015 and 2019’s Health and Hygeine Statistical Yearbook, 80% of all new UIDs in China were performed in Xinjiang. A check of the source (pg 228) shows that it’s actually 8.7% not 80%. UIDs are also reversable and is the preferred method for most people in Xinjiang, while more extreme, non-reversable methods for birth control are relatively more preferred in other areas of China (most notably Henan). web.archive.org/web/20200712091001/s2.51cto.com/oss/201912/05/1822362d5f7ccc8ff5d87ecdba23e64c.pdf The real Xinjiang vlog! kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaeolYijad58sNk kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHmoeqtoidGXobs kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHTLeomOn8lohK8 kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYCwkoh_eJmCo5o kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHmuk2mIarKfZs0 kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6bGq6OOhd-merc kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3KVfqmXeseEbq8 A XinJiang native youtuber kzbin.info/door/Rc63ZkXuzAWGzaJVEe_hxAvideos Another Xinjiang native youtuber kzbin.info/door/BuJWLhR0VJfR79YhWus_Ewvideos These youtuber are telling the truth about China, Brarrett Cyrus Janssen China Teacher Brand Gweilo 60 THIS IS CHINA The China Traveller Nico Blondie in China Rachel Meets China Sweetlichek Vlog Miriam In China Daniel Dumbrill The Map Pinners the JaYoe Nation Reporterfy Media & Travel Alex Absolute snarkyguy Austin In China Usman Aryan Michelle Zhang Brennasphere numuves Shy Guy Travel Stef Hoffer Nick in China by Kaja 凯娅 Wandering around Ruchi in China PandaBeijing Travel Xinjiang: Far West China Shashi4xNew

[@Lilhajxjk274]

The Chinese government is killing terrorists

[@charu917]

Every country has Correctional Units/Centres for de-radicalization. Most of these are located inside prison complex, few of them have separately like China and Soviet Gulags. Similarly when PRC was established they also had a plan to combat counter-revolutionary extremism. West needs some or the other party who oppose CCP to capitalize on their opposition for destabilizing China. Here they've found East Tusrkestan Islamic Party (ETIP) - an Islamic fundamentalist group which has an aim of separating Xinjiang from China and establish an Emirati or Caliphate system. Western strategies are outdated now. All of these are failed propaganda. We've seen what their so called human tights defenders/freedom fighters were in Afghanistan. So we all should undoubtedly reject these allegations.

[@terraadventures6734]

So nothing mentioned about the terrorist attacks against the innocent local people?

[@chinalandofmongoloids1227]

Karma is coming hard for the CCP 🙏🙏🙏

[@ischaq.]

Stay safe Isobel!

[@seanmikaeel90s50]

Pray for the people !!

[@ZZ-ug2bp]

EeastCcoast 993's Free Uyghur!!!Die China !!!

[@josephguo6256]

are u sure this video is not a fake one?

[@Palafo1AkO]

You are doing a wonderful job! Please, make more investigations like this, so that more people are aware of what is actually going on. If there is something we can change is to acknowledge those people´s pain and suiffering and not be indifferent.

[@user-op9dy7tr8p]

Are terrorists in your country legal? Chinese marriage contradiction = government's fault, Chinese school = brainwashing education, Chinese street police = control people, people kill people, police arrest them = bullying people, everything China does is wrong of. They may be terrorists' family members, actors, or forces of other countries, but they cannot be ordinary people. I have been to Xinjiang where people have been happy and free. The western requirement of China is that our police cannot arrest criminals because it is barbaric. But as far as I know, as long as there is a little interest in the United States, the United States will ignore the global pursuit of the law.()translation()

[@saltshakerchris2878]

@@user-op9dy7tr8p Your arguments for saying that the repressions in East Turkestan are necessary are literally the same arguments the US uses to wage war on Muslim countries as well

[@user-op9dy7tr8p]

@@saltshakerchris2878 If East Turkestan is peaceful, China will not control them, just observe their movements. I think East Turkistan killed someone. Is it okay to catch it? Don't tell me that it is legal to kill Chinese. You should understand that certain ethnic groups like to wage jihad and must prevent them. We are already kind enough.

[@ChinaCommonSense]

What a shame of western mainstream medias like this . making such a fake news to cheat people! It is a lie! Every news about accusing China oppressing Muslime are make somebody talking .Always a people of unknown origin talking .So many years ,not any photos or videos transpired that can show China goverment mistreating ,battering Muslim people ?Why ?because western medias are lying! They are cheating people who've never been to China,They demonize China ,They want to make people believe that China is evil ,so that peopele will always believe that the western goverment is good and they did well ..Look at the truth about XinJiang,look at the truth about china! dont be foolished and brainwashed! 1.The original “evidence” of 1 million Uyghurs being sent to concentration camps original stems from US propaganda outlets: thegrayzone.com/2019/12/21/china-detaining-millions-uyghurs-problems-claims-us-ngo-researcher/ 2. The Keriya Aitika Mosque that was claimed in 2018 to be demolished is actually still there. They were merely renovating, albeit most buildings surrounding the mosque was replaced with newer/bigger ones as Xinjiang is developing incredibly fast. medium.com/@sunfeiyang/the-case-of-the-keriya-aitika-mosque-efa29e456339 3. The often used picture of Uyghurs dressed uniformly lined up sitting in a re-education camp actually comes from an early 2017 picture of regular prisoners in Xinjiang listening to a public speech in a regular jail. It wasn't just prisoners who listened to the speech. web.archive.org/web/20180820154817/ baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1564669932542581&wfr=spider&for=pc (scroll down to the middle to see the picture). 4. The video of a supposed Uyghur being beaten for having a copy of a Quaran, was actually an Indonesian police beating a pickpocket. The police was discharged afterwards. factcheck.afp.com/no-not-video-chinese-soldier-beating-uighur-muslim-having-copy-koran 5. Some pictures of Uyghurs in Chinese detention camps, including that of a crying child, are pictures edited from protests, people rescued from human trafficking, and Uyghurs protesting outside in 2009 as a result of a riot that killed 156 people. factcheck.afp.com/these-photos-show-protests-istanbul-and-xinjiang-and-migrant-shelter-thailand 6. Claim of a Chinese police officer strangling a Uyghur woman caught praying is actually a video of the police officer restraining a violent drunk woman in 2018. factcheck.afp.com/video-shows-police-officer-pinning-down-drunk-chinese-woman-his-knee-hotel-shenzhen 7. Picture of “forced labor” of Uyghurs, first published by Forbes, originally came from a factory in 2010 Brazil. i.redd.it/20mzu89zo1d51.jpg 8. Picture of an “uyghur” with his eyes/mouth/ears sewn shut, is actually a picture of Abas Amini protesting the UK’s treatment of asylum seekers in 2003 i.redd.it/9zixb3ukmad51.png news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/nottinghamshire/2941780.stm 9. Rushan Abbas, who claimed that her sister/friends are locked in Chinese concentration camps, is actually a participator of Guantanamo Bay in 2003, which has verifiable human rights violations against Muslim prisoners. When confronted she claimed she was only a translator, but also justified Guantanamo Bay. www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/e9ad4n/i_am_rushan_abbas_uyghur_activist_and_survivor_of/ 10. Much of BBC’s visit to a Uyghur re-education center have words mistranslated or taken out of context by BBC in order to fit a certain narrative. Nevertheless, BBC did make a second unannounced “surprise” visit late at night, only to see Uyghurs leaving the center, supposedly for the weekend. medium.com/@sunfeiyang/breaking-down-the-bbcs-visit-to-hotan-xinjiang-e284934a7aab 11. Sayragul Sauytbay first claimed that she did not see any violence, only hunger and that they never had any meat. However, later her story changed, claiming that they were forced to eat pork. She also added a new story that she saw police raping prisoners in public, and anyone who showed facial expressions or couldn’t watch was taken away and disappeared. www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/world/article-everyone-was-silent-endlessly-mute-former-chinese-re-education/ www.haaretz.com/amp/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-a-million-people-are-jailed-at-china-s-gulags-i-escaped-here-s-what-goes-on-inside-1.7994216 12. Adrian Zenz claimed that according to 2015 and 2019’s Health and Hygeine Statistical Yearbook, 80% of all new UIDs in China were performed in Xinjiang. A check of the source (pg 228) shows that it’s actually 8.7% not 80%. UIDs are also reversable and is the preferred method for most people in Xinjiang, while more extreme, non-reversable methods for birth control are relatively more preferred in other areas of China (most notably Henan). web.archive.org/web/20200712091001/s2.51cto.com/oss/201912/05/1822362d5f7ccc8ff5d87ecdba23e64c.pdf The real Xinjiang vlog! kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaeolYijad58sNk kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHmoeqtoidGXobs kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHTLeomOn8lohK8 kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYCwkoh_eJmCo5o kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHmuk2mIarKfZs0 kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3yWcpaZhLOMb9U kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6bGq6OOhd-merc kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3KVfqmXeseEbq8 A XinJiang native youtuber kzbin.info/door/Rc63ZkXuzAWGzaJVEe_hxAvideos Another Xinjiang native youtuber kzbin.info/door/BuJWLhR0VJfR79YhWus_Ewvideos These youtubers are telling the truth about China, Brarrett Cyrus Janssen China Teacher Brand Gweilo 60 THIS IS CHINA The China Traveller Nico Blondie in China Rachel Meets China Sweetlichek Vlog Miriam In China Daniel Dumbrill The Map Pinners the JaYoe Nation Reporterfy Media & Travel Alex Absolute snarkyguy Austin In China Usman Aryan Michelle Zhang Brennasphere numuves Shy Guy Travel Stef Hoffer Nick in China by Kaja 凯娅 Wandering around Ruchi in China PandaBeijing Travel Xinjiang: Far West China Shashi4xNew

[@asafuddinahnafchowdhury4128]

It's always so nice to see the magic of journalism by Isobel.

[@sumanmajumdar7884]

R u Indian@Asaf Choudhury

[@starmoonlight4607]

Hi, are you Muslim?

[@Bedroom_Musician]

Since we started to began this new year (2020 A.D) Everything seems so wrong in each and every corner of the world... Don't knoe what the world be like at the end of the year... Where is the love?

[@arthurmorel1943]

Humanity needs to die

[@blaze1420666]

I agree

[@pranaygurnule5666]

@@arthurmorel1943 we will end up killing eachother soon

[@davidzoe612]

@playlists I agree. Are u also a technological pessimist btw? There shouldnot be a War at all,but ideally the world needs Waring to reset the humanity principles of humans.

[@nuclearweapons3226]

In Kazakhstan, have so many Kazakh students from XinJiang, and they over 3-4 years haven’t seen their parents because of China ❗️❗️

[@hayatmir9307]

This is sheer evil .I can't believe world has such humans...can we call them humans! Salute to these victims who have not given up their belief even after being subjected to such atrocities.

[@henlo9690]

I'm waiting for the internet CCP fifty sens army to show up (On another note, this is depressing.)

[@pale_saint]

Well Communism and Yidslam both are oppressive and evil ideologies

[@chinesejesus6737]

@@pale_saint So is Christianity

[@ayahisthename7498]

@UCcQgEx-TeHkQ4S-BfeTCCug they should replace those innocent Muslims with people like you 💀

[@BERSERK263]

@@ayahisthename7498 Innocent Muslims?🤔

[@hdeng727]

Well, I don't support these camps. Just present to you a fact. No more Uyghur kids picking people's pockets on the street. What do you think about that?

[@Suicide_is_cute]

Legend once said"You can't send them to concentration camp if they don't exist"

[@muhammadnorikmal8718]

@Profit Mohamad the problem is not about ISIS/Al Qaeda but due to Islamophobic and Islam growing as fastest religion in the world. Nevertheless it will continue to growth despite all the attempt to halt it

[@uranuuss]

@Profit Mohamad isis isnt a ethnicity nor any terrorist activity is connected to any. Maybe you should re educate your brain that doesnt even have first grade education.

[@tysk5729]

@Profit Mohamad isis are not muslims jihad means strugle so marter luther kings jihad was fighting for black peoples rights...

[@bodybag22]

@@tysk5729 That's a pretty significant misrepresentation of 'Jihad' it can be any struggle, religious, physical, psychological. It can pretty much be used to justify any bullshit and Islam certainly has a history of oppressing 'others'.

[@abidmehdi6103]

@Profit Mohamad use half of your brain at least and google it this is about the silk road all wars are created for the rich to get richer and your like are just blinded by hate so you can help em stomp on the poor

[@oscarchute5702]

According to Stapleton Roy, American ambassador to China (1991-1996), there is no 'genocide' in Xinjiang in his speech at Pomona College in September 2020.

[@massive_d]

Why did you not blur her face, or crop out her sister's name. Don't you think that will bring worse on her sister

[@lizardchosimbastedanko3077]

Trolls: vice did a goob job :When vice reports on something that triggers the trolls Trolls: 😠😡

[@fcam77960]

I don’t think you know what a Troll is online.

[@umbradumont5077]

What an inane comment

[@BERSERK263]

@@50nerds Agreed, usually only report on the version that suits their narrative best.

[@umbradumont5077]

@@50nerds shut up ccp slave

[@chinesejesus6737]

@@umbradumont5077 shut up ClA sIave

[@GregoryMcCarthy123]

I can’t believe we are allowing this to go on...

[@plc3653]

its time to get political active

[@clevernduruza8624]

All religions must be banned

[@asdfghjkl92213]

It’s the Grobel elites, bill gates get Replacement organs from Muslims

[@jaimedelgado7529]

How about minding your own business for once??

[@ibuprofen-noodles]

@IMxYOURxDADDY corona chan started the fire, now it's up to the chinese people to do the rest

[@mansoor6678]

“I want them to face the same pain and suffering their inflicted upon us” I really can’t blame him. Anger and desire for revenge is a natural human trait. At least he admitted he won’t go the terrorist route, but who knows. He would just be called one by the Chinese govt regardless.

[@nubs2696]

Coronavirus is the definition of karma.

[@ragnarlothbrok8629]

Yes, it has killed so many people who live in a democracy. No North Korean is killed

[@Snagabott]

Since obtaining the Karakax list, work on this story has not been a small matter. Analyzing and verifying these documents has required a collaboration between: Aftenposten AP Al Jazeera BBC CNN Deutsche Welle Financial Times Le Monde NDR Süddeutsche Zeitung SVT The New York Times Vice Wall Street Journal It is important that stuff like this is not ignored. Thank you Vice (and the rest) for your good work documenting this story.

[@debajyotibhowmick9391]

Kudos to Vice.. Am impressed... So far have been following Vice, I haven't come across any reason to either question authenticity or integrity of their reporting. A rare quality these days...

[@srinjoyghosh7273]

apnar ki mawt byapar ta niye?

[@annat1676]

Well I really want to be a minority in China since they enjoy privileges over the majority (Han ethics) Did you check the population growth of Uyghur? The data shows a 25% (1017 mio.-> 1271.8 mio.) increase of Uyghur across 2010-2018 while the Han ethics has only 2%. And please also checked how many mosques China built in comparison to the amounts in US England and Canada, the suppression is towards Han ethics. Please educate yourself and come to visit if you have time and money, rather than follow the xenophobic media

[@TheLatiosnlatias02]

China has a lot more mosques than others

[@sayaankhan3484]

May Allah bless their souls. Poor people.

[@sayaankhan3484]

@@siddhantsinghnegi9608 I ain't from Pakistan lad. Im from England. And it ain't right. We can't be saying something is bad just cause of the belief. Especially if that belief brings peace & love like Hinduism & Islam. Also Pakistan use to be a part of India anyway so Muslims & hindus use to live side by side. It's important that we don't associate any kind of Political laws to our religions mostly because no human now has the right to speak on behalf of the religion cause no is a Prophet. China though is actually taking Muslims & hurting them and abusing them and killing them which is extremely bad and should be stopped immediately. I don't even think Extremeist Hindus is a real thing. Just some people made that up just to hate on the religion. Even though we all should respect each other beliefs. So it isn't right. But that doesn't mean Islam is bad. That just means the person with that mind set is Bad. And Pakistan hates China.

[@ayyylmao101]

@@sayaankhan3484 Extremist Hindus are a thing just as extremist Muslims are also a thing. The Partition exacerbated animosity between Indians and Pakistanis (which was already at a head because of how Muslims were oppressed in India) and India has a literal member of a Hindu extremist group for a leader. Muslims suffer at his hand, and so do any groups other than the mainstream sect, upper caste Hindus. But that is not related to this matter. Pakistan does not speak out against China out of fear for the economy (since China contributes massively to it). The Pakistani people are horrified for their Uyghür brothers, as is the rest of the Ummah. What are we to do when no country is willing to risk their economic stability to oppose China? And when the countries that can risk their economic stability refuse to? May Allah deliver the Ummah from its trials... surely He sees a solution where I cannot.

[@sumanmajumdar7884]

@@sayaankhan3484 do u support us or India if they raise Uighurs voice seriously reply me

[@sayaankhan3484]

@@sumanmajumdar7884 Not completely. But some mutual respect will grow.

[@jamesliu6532]

May allah eat pork with you

[@rohanghosh1499]

Please make a Video on the Condition of Non Muslim in Pakistan.

[@Alf258]

Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere - Martin Luther king jr -

[@user-nk1rv5iv4x]

General Chinese people would not or can not afford to take their family photo in front of WHITE HOUSE in 2012 as video 6:19. As a human, I feel sad for the “Jihad” massacre incident on the streets of Urumqi, Kashgar and Kunming during 2009-2014. Ordinary people lives were used as someone’s political bargaining chips, which made me more sad.

[@Wk18thala]

This type of thing should be done in India to contain peaceful community.

[@rauhaan.]

Watching this hurts my soul.

[@siddique57]

Thank you vice for sharing this. You step real humans. The world is blind to what is happening as the people who are being persecuted are Muslims. May the almighty ease the suffering Ameen.

[@sangamshet]

What about others persecuted in Muslim countries

[@SurauNurussobah]

WHAT ARE WE LOOKING FOR IN LIFE .... ??? . We live in the mountains longing for the beach. We live on the beach yearning for the mountains. When we are dry, we ask when it rains In the rainy season we ask when is the dry season Stay at home want to go After leaving he wants to go home Quiet time looking for a crowd When busy looking for peace When I was single I complained about wanting to get married, I was married, glanced at the neighbor's garden, complained of not having children, after having children complaining about the cost of living and education It turns out that SOMETHING looks beautiful because we don't have it yet When will happiness be obtained if we only always think about what doesn't yet exist, but ignore what we already have Is it possible for a small leaf to cover this vast earth ?? Covering your palm is difficult ... But if this little leaf sticks in our eyes, then "EARTH" is covered with leaves, Likewise, if the heart is covered with even the slightest bad thought, then we will see ugliness everywhere. The earth will also look bad ... Don't close our eyes, even if only with small leaves ... Don't cover our hearts, with a bad thought, even if only the tip of a nail ... Thank God for what we already have, as capital to GLOVE HIM ... Because life is; TIME is lent, and property is a trust that is entrusted ... All of which will be held accountable, Be thankful for the breath we still have. Be grateful for the family that we have. Be grateful for the work we have. Give thanks and always give thanks in everything ... Hurry up and compete in goodness from now on. Good luck on this day and so on ... Self reminder😊

[@najialqhfa7231]

When I pay attention to Chinese system he make me good Muslim, may Allah bless this great nation

[@condelgizzlo1445]

Thank you Vice for exploiting this, thank you for showing the truth, thank you for this channel and thank you for having the bravery and courage to show the real truth.

[@evano5635]

Sile 75 Do a video on America prison industry complex and how prisoners are making 25 cents an hour doing labour , talk about how America makes money by creating war, also make sure you do a video on how America destabilize other country’s in the global south wether democrat or republican. Pls make a video on America putting children in cages. But suddenly American care about human rights when it comes to China

[@leonjuric2486]

Sta je Srbine, sto si se okrenuo alahu? Aha zato sto su turci mucili tvoj SRPSKI rod.

[@user-zz9ik5mn9v]

truth?amazing。

[@ChinaCommonSense]

What a shame of western mainstream medias like this . making such a fake news to cheat people! It is a lie! Every news about accusing China oppressing Muslime are make somebody talking .Always a people of unknown origin talking .So many years ,not any photos or videos transpired that can show China goverment mistreating ,battering Muslim people ?Why ?because western medias are lying! They are cheating people who've never been to China,They demonize China ,They want to make people believe that China is evil ,so that peopele will always believe that the western goverment is good and they did well ..Look at the truth about XinJiang,look at the truth about china! dont be foolished and brainwashed! 1.The original “evidence” of 1 million Uyghurs being sent to concentration camps original stems from US propaganda outlets: thegrayzone.com/2019/12/21/china-detaining-millions-uyghurs-problems-claims-us-ngo-researcher/ 2. The Keriya Aitika Mosque that was claimed in 2018 to be demolished is actually still there. They were merely renovating, albeit most buildings surrounding the mosque was replaced with newer/bigger ones as Xinjiang is developing incredibly fast. medium.com/@sunfeiyang/the-case-of-the-keriya-aitika-mosque-efa29e456339 3. The often used picture of Uyghurs dressed uniformly lined up sitting in a re-education camp actually comes from an early 2017 picture of regular prisoners in Xinjiang listening to a public speech in a regular jail. It wasn't just prisoners who listened to the speech. web.archive.org/web/20180820154817/ baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1564669932542581&wfr=spider&for=pc (scroll down to the middle to see the picture). 4. The video of a supposed Uyghur being beaten for having a copy of a Quaran, was actually an Indonesian police beating a pickpocket. The police was discharged afterwards. factcheck.afp.com/no-not-video-chinese-soldier-beating-uighur-muslim-having-copy-koran 5. Some pictures of Uyghurs in Chinese detention camps, including that of a crying child, are pictures edited from protests, people rescued from human trafficking, and Uyghurs protesting outside in 2009 as a result of a riot that killed 156 people. factcheck.afp.com/these-photos-show-protests-istanbul-and-xinjiang-and-migrant-shelter-thailand 6. Claim of a Chinese police officer strangling a Uyghur woman caught praying is actually a video of the police officer restraining a violent drunk woman in 2018. factcheck.afp.com/video-shows-police-officer-pinning-down-drunk-chinese-woman-his-knee-hotel-shenzhen 7. Picture of “forced labor” of Uyghurs, first published by Forbes, originally came from a factory in 2010 Brazil. i.redd.it/20mzu89zo1d51.jpg 8. Picture of an “uyghur” with his eyes/mouth/ears sewn shut, is actually a picture of Abas Amini protesting the UK’s treatment of asylum seekers in 2003 i.redd.it/9zixb3ukmad51.png news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/nottinghamshire/2941780.stm 9. Rushan Abbas, who claimed that her sister/friends are locked in Chinese concentration camps, is actually a participator of Guantanamo Bay in 2003, which has verifiable human rights violations against Muslim prisoners. When confronted she claimed she was only a translator, but also justified Guantanamo Bay. www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/e9ad4n/i_am_rushan_abbas_uyghur_activist_and_survivor_of/ 10. Much of BBC’s visit to a Uyghur re-education center have words mistranslated or taken out of context by BBC in order to fit a certain narrative. Nevertheless, BBC did make a second unannounced “surprise” visit late at night, only to see Uyghurs leaving the center, supposedly for the weekend. medium.com/@sunfeiyang/breaking-down-the-bbcs-visit-to-hotan-xinjiang-e284934a7aab 11. Sayragul Sauytbay first claimed that she did not see any violence, only hunger and that they never had any meat. However, later her story changed, claiming that they were forced to eat pork. She also added a new story that she saw police raping prisoners in public, and anyone who showed facial expressions or couldn’t watch was taken away and disappeared. www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/world/article-everyone-was-silent-endlessly-mute-former-chinese-re-education/ www.haaretz.com/amp/world-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-a-million-people-are-jailed-at-china-s-gulags-i-escaped-here-s-what-goes-on-inside-1.7994216 12. Adrian Zenz claimed that according to 2015 and 2019’s Health and Hygeine Statistical Yearbook, 80% of all new UIDs in China were performed in Xinjiang. A check of the source (pg 228) shows that it’s actually 8.7% not 80%. UIDs are also reversable and is the preferred method for most people in Xinjiang, while more extreme, non-reversable methods for birth control are relatively more preferred in other areas of China (most notably Henan). web.archive.org/web/20200712091001/s2.51cto.com/oss/201912/05/1822362d5f7ccc8ff5d87ecdba23e64c.pdf The real Xinjiang vlog! kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaeolYijad58sNk kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHmoeqtoidGXobs kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHTLeomOn8lohK8 kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYCwkoh_eJmCo5o kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHmuk2mIarKfZs0 kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6bGq6OOhd-merc kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3KVfqmXeseEbq8 A XinJiang native youtuber kzbin.info/door/Rc63ZkXuzAWGzaJVEe_hxAvideos Another Xinjiang native youtuber kzbin.info/door/BuJWLhR0VJfR79YhWus_Ewvideos These youtuber are telling the truth about China, Brarrett Cyrus Janssen China Teacher Brand Gweilo 60 THIS IS CHINA The China Traveller Nico Blondie in China Rachel Meets China Sweetlichek Vlog Miriam In China Daniel Dumbrill The Map Pinners the JaYoe Nation Reporterfy Media & Travel Alex Absolute snarkyguy Austin In China Usman Aryan Michelle Zhang Brennasphere numuves Shy Guy Travel Stef Hoffer Nick in China by Kaja 凯娅 Wandering around Ruchi in China PandaBeijing Travel Xinjiang: Far West China Shashi4xNew

[@williamhackett5713]

It’s recently came out that the Uighur Muslims were trained and radicalised by the CIA in Syria and Afghanistan as a way to try and use propaganda against western civilisation to gain support for the USA and the west to go to war with China, I urge you all to seriously be very careful about your thoughts when western mainstream media outlets start to report on “the Chinese oppression of Uighurs”. Never forget what our western leaders have tried against us these last 2 years. Make love not war

[@dayonpanyalai8583]

stand up and fight for your own believe ,future and culture....dont wait others to safe you...Indonesian would not be free if our fathers and mothers not fight....350 years under the dutch occupation...we fought for our freedom

[@Unboxing-xk9ed]

Why does no big media speak about this

[@herasean5720]

This is the real life 'model citizen' by dead sound

[@abuhajjar7730]

Where is the CCP cyber army？ 中共的网评员在哪？

[@leavesinautumn5959]

Mostly absent, there's plenty of Islamophobes though.

[@booba4189]

mostly their comment deleted by you guys ... this is brainwashed video and media btw .....

[@DZ477]

Oh you mean the wumao? They are all in South China Morning Post.

[@booba4189]

@@DZ477 if that channel is China's brainwashed media then this is Western's brainwashed media ... this is how i view because i dont support both side ...

[@leavesinautumn5959]

@@booba4189 Because media in the west and in China is run the same, subject to the same laws and controls, Come off it.

[@babylove15cute]

Thank you for reporting this even though I knew what’s been happening for years. I’m just glad someone is reporting this!

[@TheLatiosnlatias02]

You sure believe their bullshit

[@adamhendrickson512]

The problem is none of this means shit because UN isn't gonna do SHIT.....

[@iamsheep]

I love that Vice did a documentary on deradicalisation in Indonesia and that was a “school”....

[@TheLatiosnlatias02]

Vice is another corporation that pulls another WMD bullshit

[@-Yahiko-]

And Pakistani think that China is their friend 😂😂😂

[@saltshakerchris2878]

Well if Pakistan decides to support the Uyghurs, then China will decide to cut their support of Pakistan. Pakistan is really dependent on China

[@gwynpaladin8553]

Pakistan is a poor, failed, disgusting economically failed country, CCP says Imran jump, Khan says how much?

[@aliadnan5781]

@jay pitch mut piye ga mera 😂😂gao ka mut pine wale ab ham pr batein krein ge

[@aliadnan5781]

@jay pitch aaa ja mut pilaonn healthy hota hai tumhare liye or ham bikhri keh rahe ho 780million logon ke pehle toilets bnalo 6millions jobs jali gai corona ki waja se india mein wo wapis leo o phir bat krna😂😂😂

[@aliadnan5781]

@jay pitch www.google.com/amp/s/www.soschildrensvillages.ca/news/poverty-in-india-602%3famp

[@junayedahmed1183]

I wish every journalist could be like her. Wish you all the best👍

[@sumanmajumdar7884]

R u Indian plz reply

[@junayedahmed1183]

@@sumanmajumdar7884 why?

[@abdulghafoor823]

Why are all Muslim countries turning a blind eye!!!! Where are we when our fellow Muslims need us please my fellow brothers and sisters help fellow Muslims

[@locust1536]

Why would you ask those dumb questions Do you want revenge? Would you get involved in terrorism GTFO with the loaded questions

[@patardaniel8949]

What a good reporter question

[@Dylan-kb5wp]

This is the type of vice I needed

[@ClipsMGM]

I'm Muslim, and watching these makes my blood BOELD I can't wait for the avenge for everything they did to our PEOPLE!!! And TRUST ME karma WILL CATCH UP!

[@Alex_McFarland]

People rip on Vice so much for their clickbait social media content - that's just to keep you engaged, and for amazing content like this to show up on your feed.

[@zf5249]

Damn bruh, just lie and say your not a muslim

[@Citlaly00]

That would go against their religion. As silly as it may sound, people are willing to die for what they believe in.

[@ImagineWagonss]

@@Citlaly00 then goodluck dying. I salute.

[@atomnous]

ikr, like i thought muslims were allowed to lie anyway.

[@atomnous]

@@Citlaly00 it doesn't go against their religion

[@nonstop7255]

@@Citlaly00 actually it doesn't go against our religion in a life or death situation but it's not the case here coz the Chinese government detain every uyghur regardless of religion

[@anaskhader9837]

thank you Isabel.

[@kumarprateek1061]

Sad but .. ethnicity cleansing after Myanmar,China it seems have begun in India with the Delhi 2020 riots. World Islamophobia is at its peak and shame no one is talking about this .

[@user-sv6vh4tm4h]

Same happened to my XInjiang friends and they are Hui Muslim ethnic people . Government takes them fathers and threatened them to get back in China. Send Han government officers living with them moms. No any messages form them fathers. And police keeping ask my friends everything and force them to back said ( is good to your father in the jail if you guys come back .

[@Tr4sh_can34]

This is the Vice everyone wants. Glad to see you guys doing reporting when everyone else refuses

[@TheLatiosnlatias02]

It's because Vice is bullshit. The West/Israel/India/EU/Australia created the Uighur problem in Xīnjiāng by sponsoring terrorists there-the same tactics it used in Cuba, Venezuela, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria and Libya. Faced with the grave challenge of terrorism and extremism, China has undertaken a series of counter-terrorism and deradicalisation measures in Xīnjiāng, including setting up vocational education and training centres and boarding schools. Uighurs, just like the other 9 Muslim ethnic groups in China, are entirely free to conduct their religion, with active state protection of their culture, and strong Affirmative Action measures which drastically benefits minorities. The vast majority of Uighurs are perfectly happy to be part of China, especially with recent drastic rises in standard of living, employment, and wages. It is only a tiny percentage of extremists in Xīnjiāng with ties to Daesh, funded by the CIA like the Mujahideen, and indoctrinated by Wahhabi extremism, who are agitating for independence and the establishment of “East Turkistan”. Instead of you being one-sided, why not look at the other side of that western bullshit? kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqeplaKkgZWkkMk kzbin.info/www/bejne/rmqcmGehqsZoqZI unitedworldint.com/18208-Uighur-genocide-is-an-imperialist-lie/ ifmagazine.net/the-vocational-education-and-training-centers-in-Xīnjiāng-are-by-no-means-so-called-concentration-camps/ kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5yaapt7br6gedk kzbin.info/www/bejne/h4W6gnyne8mXnMk kzbin.info/www/bejne/d5fGmah-lpd_mKs&lc=UgwuiV2fzvWPq8zOHIF4AaABAg.9RzwvnwDVOA9S-pdFln0wc kzbin.info/www/bejne/aKWmpo2rlLpsqM0 kzbin.info/www/bejne/jmPUhHl_jNd6iLM kzbin.info/www/bejne/eneTY6uNnNB0gJI kzbin.info/www/bejne/an-WaWisgM2Lj7M kzbin.info/www/bejne/gn26dWN7m7WMl7s kzbin.info/www/bejne/d5LMpYuJmc95hpo challenge-magazine.org/2021/04/05/foreign-diplomats-deny-lies-said-about-Xīnjiāng-by-the-west-after-trip/ www.helsinkitimes.fi/china-news/19019-witnessing-the-real-Xīnjiāng-foreign-diplomats-debunk-lies.html www.curacaochronicle.com/post/main/beautiful-Xīnjiāng-should-not-be-smeared-by-lies/ uwidata.com/16769-us-lies-about-chinas-Xīnjiāng-debunked/ www.manilatimes.net/2021/04/04/opinion/columnists/another-big-lie-by-the-west-Xīnjiāng-genocide/859909 apnews.com/article/china-government-and-politics-religion-3d8fa6aee61268d105610ebc92ed1b55 medium.com/@leohezhao/Xīnjiāng-facts-vs-fiction-bdc2aa403c91 www.thestar.com.my/opinion/letters/2019/12/12/truths-about-Xīnjiāng-the-western-media-wont-tell

[@truthsupporter4119]

@@TheLatiosnlatias02, You keep running away because you have no argument.

[@Jim54_]

Warning, Xi Xingping bots in the comments section!

[@jakelaw9768]

As long as religion is not politicalized, it is allowed. The problem in Xin Jiang is about separatism and terrorism, not a religious issue.

[@TheLatiosnlatias02]

I hear you.

[@rimmiyong6793]

I traveled in Xinjiang, China for one year. The real situation is not exactly the same as the video tells. It is a fact that access to foreign websites is prohibited, and the others are due to the new crown epidemic.

[@klm2639]

Fact: The Chinese approach to Islamic insurgency has saved lives. Re-education or war, one path lies death and destruction another path lies social cohesion

[@vgetginas4736]

*vice wouldnt report that because vice never reports the truth. Its always biased*

[@30secclips35]

I didn't wasted a sec after the notification popped up... What i am actually here for News:20% Isobel: 80%

[@ImagineWagonss]

Desperate boy

[@badvibez2629]

Simp

[@traplover6357]

@@badvibez2629 rather be a simp for Isobel than for Muslims.

[@UsernamerAlreadyTakn]

10/10 would smash

[@30secclips35]

I just adore her that's all! Not tryna be mean by ignoring the news ! It's just! Idk

[@dasbroisku]

I think the western world should learn from this

[@mynameis634]

Good job. China not Vice