How Many Animals Did Noah Have to Bring on the Ark?

[@level98bearhuntingarmor]

I appreciate the responsible approach to evaluating this event

[@PortmanRd]

Creationist/Geologist perchance?

[@PortmanRd]

@user-ld6ot3pw1s My bad. Just so many videos of creationists claiming scientists and geologists have proven this, than and the other only to find out that the said experts are Creationists. No offence meant.

[@2loudway2much]

I have some questions. 1. How did the salt water creatures survive with all this fresh water mixed in? How did the fresh water creatures survive with the salter water mixed in? 2. You need at least 500 individuals (gene pool) to produce a population. Offsprings by just 2 individuals will result in extinction within 4 generations. 3. The many carnivores would have required thousands of cows to survive the year. How?

[@coleedward9642]

1. The creatures very well could have been more adaptable back then, thus they were able to survive. Or the oceans weren't as salty, etc. Or, more plausibly, considering 95% of fossil's we've found, are marine creatures. Likely, a lot of them died, and the ones left adapted. 2. The Bible says the flood occurred when Noah was 600 years old, and it also says he died when he was 950. The Bible also says it was eight people, not two. Noah and his wife, his 3 sons and their wives. My parents had 4 kids within 5 years, so even if it's 2 people to start, assuming each pair had 2 girls 2 boys, within 340 years(17 generations of 20 years), there'd be 524,286 people. We both know it would be safe to assume that they had a much higher birth rate back then, after all they had to populate the world. After all, Abraham, had 8 sons, and it would be fair to say, he would have had a similar amount of daughters. So taking into account, Biblical life expectancies, immediately after the flood, as well as an increased birth rate. It is very possible to repopulate the world. After all, Adam and Eve did it. 3. Modern zoos, in times of disaster use meat substitutes. There's also been carnivores, who survived without eating meat, such as Little Tyke, a vegetarian lion. They could have brought plenty of meat with them. Or they could have ate fish, especially if a ton of salt/fresh fish died, there would have been plenty to eat.

[@dandare2520]

Grasping at straws much

[@coleedward9642]

@@dandare2520 Until you actually provide a constructive criticism, then there is no valid evidence that I have grasped at any straws.

[@avi8r66]

@@coleedward9642 1) While some water critters can deal with brackish water that's not the majority. I do like though how you say "considering 95% of fossil's we've found, are marine creatures". So you admit fossils are a thing, you accept that science at least. But when you find out the age of those fossiles, like the chalk deposits which are one example of those ancient dead sea critters, you most likely would balk. Limestone is similar, and these deposits have been around for over 100 million years. 2) I suspect the 2 he was talking about was adam and eve. Regardless, 8 people expanding to 8 billion plus today would require an amazing birth rate and infant survival rate that just has never been possible. And just becase the bible says he was 800 years old doesn't mean he was 800 years old. How did they count years? Did that get translated correctly? Most likely those were lunar cycles, months essentially. 13 of those per year would make an 800cycle person 61.5 years old. And this is vastly more reasonable. And dying at 950 would put him at 73, which was a ripe old age back then. 3) Regarding the meat alternative, they didn't have that back then. And remember, they had no idea how long they would be at sea. Logistically 8 people could not have cared for even 1,000 animals on that tossing boat. It had a window at the top, that's their access to the outside world. Every single day they need to provide fresh water and food to every animal. They also need to haul all the waste OUT and get it overboard. They also need to butcher animals to divide them up among the various obligate carnivores. And they need to keep the air inside breathable. All those animals and the CO2 levels in that boat would be stifling, potentially lethal. 8 people absolutely could not have managed even a small group of 1,000 animals. Go to any zoon with 1,000 animals. Even the ark encounter itself has a small zoo. They will absolutely have more than 8 people tending the animals. And they have all the modern tools and fresh air. At some point to make this story work you have only one option. GodMagic. You guys try to claim plasible explanations but no, there aren't any. So eventually you arrive at 'through god all things are possible'. And if you are going to pull that trigger then the ark itself was simply not needed. God had every other option for solving this 'problem' of 'evil' people. A couple of easy ones would be 'reprogram the evil people' or 'delete the evil people'. But, God being a merciless and abuse drama queen, the writers stole the epic of Gilgamesh and crafted a monogod story from it. And that gave you the story of Noah's ark which for some reason people still think is true.

[@truthgiver8286]

@@coleedward9642 You might as well have said all creatures could breath underwater back then you make it up as you go along.

[@sgt.grinch3299]

I’m enjoying this series. Thank you.

[@keithgutshall9559]

How did the animals get from the Americas to the middle east where the ark was??

[@stevenanderson3673]

In Noah's day we had Pangea. The continents were divided in the days of Peleg.

[@keithgutshall9559]

@@stevenanderson3673 according to scientist that makes the timeline all wrong,as the Bible says the earth is only 6000 years old

[@private_channel11]

@@keithgutshall9559 1) there are old earth creationists 2) catastrophism explains well how we get modern continents from pangea in little time

[@lingsang_in_the_trees]

Berringian land bridge

[@davidgardner863]

@@stevenanderson3673, Continents don’t move that fast. If they did enough heat would be generated to melt the earth’s crust. Try again.

[@georgemccreadyprice8195]

The difference in numbers is caused by the flood story being made up from two similar stories woven together. Ask here for more details.

[@rodericgurrola1745]

Good point I like the three things he pointed to for doing created kinds I’m praying about being a zoologist and maybe a degree in paleontology and barimology.

[@georgemccreadyprice8195]

@@rodericgurrola1745 I’d prefer palaeontology myself. Not sure what you mean about the three kings.

[@Ricksbookshelf]

Interesting series! Although I think you're overthinking this too much. I personally think all of the animals on the ark went into some kind of dormancy or hibernation which would eliminate the herculean task of feeding and cleaning up after the animals.

[@georg7120]

How did all the marsupials know the way to the ark? And how did they go back to Australia?

[@Jewonastick]

***MAGIC***

[@MeatBall57]

Where did the water recede to ? After the salt water mixed with fresh water, killing the fresh water fish, how did iit seperate again ?

[@georg7120]

@@MeatBall57 Who cares, the answer to all questions will be "God", end of discussion.

[@MeatBall57]

@@georg7120 Which one ?

[@georg7120]

@@MeatBall57 The god of your choice of course, all other ones are false.

[@kevinmwaza-vr9oc]

Ù really enlightened me I thank you for that😇🙏

[@marcusmuse4787]

Was every species on the Ark? No. Species is a term used in the modern classification system. The Bible uses the term “kind.” The created kind was a much broader category than the modern term of classification, species.

[@Bomtombadi1]

So define it. Draw your lines with your nebulous term.

[@potatoxgaming9466]

@@Bomtombadi1 Kinds is like bird, dog, horse, elephants. There are different species of dog, horse and elephants.

[@Bomtombadi1]

@@potatoxgaming9466 define it. Don’t give an example. Birds: Is it by ornithurae? Aves? If Linda can only “bring forth” after each other, then not all birds are the same “kind,” which makes whatever definition you try to make useless. Dogs: we talking Canidae? Because you realize not all can “bring forth after their kind,” right? Again, your definition is useless.

[@potatoxgaming9466]

@@Bomtombadi1 kind: group of people or things having similar characteristics.

[@Jewonastick]

@@potatoxgaming9466 characteristics like this? ; relatively large, complex brain forward-facing eyes with overlapping fields of view that allow depth perception eye sockets with a ring or cup of bone surrounding and supporting the eyes grasping hands with long fingers to curl around objects opposable thumbs and/or big toes (able to touch the other digits on the same hand or foot) flat nails (rather than claws) on some fingers and toes sensitive pads under the tips of the fingers and toes containing special touch receptors called Meissner’s Corpuscles a well-developed collarbone (clavicle) two nipples on the chest (in females, these supply milk to the young) penis and testes that permanently hang down from the body (in males) long childhood that extends well beyond weaning

[@loricalass4068]

Great breakdowns.😊

[@YohanisNhial]

Thanking for telling people about the ark of Noah

[@RaptorBlue2004]

Cool, in this video cover image, there are prehistoric animals and dinosaurs, heading towards Noah's Ark, along with the other animals. 🦣🦖🦕🦤

[@throckmortensnivel2850]

Right. Tell me how to determine which "kind" an animal is. We can start with elephants, manatees, and hyraxes. They are more closely related to each other than to any other animals. An elephant you already know. A manatee, also called a sea cow, is a marine mammal similar to a large seal with a bulbous head and nose. A hyrax is a house-cat sized furry mammal that looks a lot like a rodent, but isn't. Now, according to your rules, are they the same kind, and if not, what rules do you follow to determine "kind"?

[@JoshDao-h4e]

this was the work of God anything is possible

[@Zripas]

So basically it's true because book said so?

[@pedalandpop783]

That is such a pathetically inane answer..

[@inquisitive_stranger]

Tell me that you makes stuff up, without telling me you are making stuff up...... And this guy says it with a straight face....

[@avi8r66]

Even if there were only 1,000 animals, not kinds, total animals, on the ark, an enclosed rocking boat with no worthwhile windows to speak of, the workload on 8 people would have been impossible to maintain. They would need fresh water for all the animals every day, all day. They would need food, which includes raw meat for the obligate carnivores, and they were need the waste removed. Go look at any zoo where they keep 1,000 animals. They won't have a staff of only 8 people.

[@Creationadmiration]

God's involved....

[@avi8r66]

@@Creationadmiration Sure, that's ultimately where the explanation must go, but if God is just going to work some magic then what would be the point of the boat ride to start with? There were tons more options open to a being that is all powerful, all knowing, omnipresent, etc. Delete the evil people, just make them not exist. Or, more benevolently, reprogram the evil people. Those are just two options, both less ridiculous than flooding the planet and killing all but 8 people and a boat load of animals. In reality this story is just a direct steal from the epic of gilgamesh so it was fiction from the start.

[@Creationadmiration]

@@avi8r66 gilgamesh was after Noah's time....

[@avi8r66]

@@Creationadmiration The epic of gilgamesh was written prior to the noah story. Epic: 2100 BC Sumeria. Noah: 1300 BC at the oldest.

[@Creationadmiration]

@@avi8r66 do your research again, and look into Noahs living timeline not when his story was written....

[@JaneSmith-n2k]

It was the mix of species that made so many different kinds of animals.

[@jasonscott6640]

I enjoy the Videos keep ‘em coming

[@stevetakacs849]

So according to you after the flood we had evolution.

[@sesmoney1]

This is a tuff one... Cause what about the carnivores.... You would have to take triple the pray for them to survive.😎

[@blackholeentry3489]

Prey

[@philiprobinson2011]

So, Noah only had to accommodate the land creatures, which contradicts what you have said previously. In a previous presentation you claimed that evidence of the flood could be established due to the large number of fossils of sea creatures found high up in mountain ranges. If sea creatures perished in the flood, evidenced by these fossils, then surely the flood killed them and Noah would have had to accommodate sea creatures as well. Then there is the question of creatures that live in fresh water. A flood would have caused a mixing of salty sea water with fresh water which would definitely have caused the extinction of all fresh water creatures. Do you believe therefore that Noah had to carry fresh water creatures on the Ark? Surprisingly, your explanation of animal kind supports evolution. You say that the variety of species we see today, "developed" from those Noah took on the Ark. The term developed that you use sounds very like the term evolved used by scientists. Perhaps if you disagree that developed means evolved, you could explain the difference. However, as you seem to be open to the concept of development, I presume you are open to the possibility that all life has developed over time from primitive life forms? Finally, the story of Noah is all about the destruction of all life on the Planet, apart from those on the Ark and those like the creatures of the seas as you infer, plus I imagine anyone else at the time who had a boat. Why then did your God feel the need for Noah to sacrifice some of the animals he had gone to so much trouble to save? Why does God even require animal sacrifices at all?

[@arkencounter]

answersingenesis.org/media/audio/answers-with-ken-ham/volume-149/why-the-sacrifices/

[@philiprobinson2011]

So why do Christians not sacrifice animals today, or do they. The reference you give suggests animal sacrifices are not good enough because the blood of animals is different to that of man. Is this suggesting that to absolve sins Christians need to sacrifice people? @@arkencounter

[@philiprobinson2011]

Exactly, how could the spilling of blood atone for a sin. It is just committing one sin to atone for another. At best it is barbaric and at the very least evil. What does that say about God or his followers?@@arkencounter

[@davidgardner863]

Not only that but some require cold water, some warm water, some deep water, some shallow water. Corals would be exterminated, Krill that breed under floating ice sheets would be exterminated. Plankton would die. All these form the bottom of the food chain all other sea life depends on.

[@philiprobinson2011]

Very true. I find all these pseudo scientific explanations to justify stories like the flood to be nonsense. They are just trying to convince the gullible that these stories are true and hence the Bible is true. For me it just proves they are charlatans. @@davidgardner863

[@calyx74]

Not sure how any of that made any sense? That was a very poor explanation of trying to convince me that this event happened. You lost my vote.

[@wayneterrell7039]

B

[@Ohmy1956]

If you actually cared to understand you could visit the ark and engage them with your reasoning and teach them how none of this would be logical. But I know you won’t

[@christianpulido8360]

Thank you for your opinions.

[@stanb990]

He's not even remotely trying to prove that a flood happened at all He's simply explaining how the proposed number of animals would have fit within the dimensions of the vessel as described

[@christianpulido8360]

@@stanb990 Thank you for your opinions.

[@jasonscott6640]

I am fascinated by all this 😃

[@HarrisChapman-xi9oq]

I believe the Bible is the word of God! I believe Genesis as it is written! I have Faith in the Word of God! I also enjoy the mental exercise in explaining all about Noah..... If it brings one person to Christ! All the better!

[@SPsounds100]

Nice Fantasy movie 😂

[@richardjphilpott]

Did Noah take seeds and plants onto the Ark ?

[@blackholeentry3489]

Nope....Noah took a prayer mat, slept on it and then let God perform the magic!!

[@andrewmazzer]

What did the animals do to deserve this ? God loves the world, is all-knowing and powerful, but this is the best he's got ? Allow the worlds innocent animals to drown a horrible death ? Wouldn't he have known at the very beginning that his creation was going to fail due to sin ? But he does it anyway, knowing that innocent humans and animals will suffer ?

[@sjl197]

Even a five year old can tell that if you dump a penguin in the baking hot Middle East dessert it’s going to roast to death in days. The rest of the special pleading here is just simply nuts. I’m not going to give any respect to such absurdity.

[@bigwaterblue]

There is a high probability that there were no penguins taken on the ark. Weather conditions could have been totally different than what it is today. So many variables to consider. I choose to believe the Bible and what It teaches. That is the easiest, although there are many things that we never could understand fully, because there is just not enough information given. On the other hand, the world wants you to believe in evolution and all that crap, because then you would have a reason not to believe in God. Evolution theory has raised far more questions than science could ever answer, so it is either faith in the Bible, or faith in evolution. I choose faith in God and his Word. My reward would be everlasting life. What is your reward?

[@JamesRichardWiley]

Noah did not bring any animals on the Ark because Noah is make believe and so is the Ark and the animals. But make believe is fun to play.

[@potatoxgaming9466]

how is it make believe when all the world has thier own version of story like it. Your delusional.

[@Jewonastick]

@@potatoxgaming9466 How did the entire world end up with a story about the same flood if it killed all the different society's that lived back then? Floods HAPPENED all over the world throughout history! And it those days people barely did any traveling. So yes many different cultures have flood stories.... There never was a global flood.

[@potatoxgaming9466]

@@Jewonastick the same story about a big boat and somehow animals follow in the boat?? And somehow they knew when the sudden flood ia going to happen?They are all been tampered with from generation to generation just like chinese whisper so the story is a little different from others but they all have big boat, animals, they know when is the flood and chosen family.

[@potatoxgaming9466]

@@Jewonastick because we are all decendant of the people who survive the great flood thats why it spread whe we multiplied from generation to generation.

[@philchiu1711]

i don't think noah was a zoologist god took care of sending him what he needed and he maybe added to that number. in the end it all worked out.

[@Zripas]

Can you prove any of this to be actually true and not something you made up in your head?

[@philchiu1711]

@@Zripas don't need to prove anything i have faith and that's enough for me and mine.

[@Zripas]

@@philchiu1711 So you don't care if it's actually true, you just like sweet lies?

[@stevenanderson3673]

Another thing we need to consider is the animals were babies. For example a 10 month old elephant weighs about 250 pounds. A newly born giraffe is about 6 feet tall. This makes it much more doable.

[@Zripas]

Except that baby animals require more care and more specialized food... So you are not solving issues here, you are creating bunch of new ones.

[@davidgardner863]

@@Zripas, And many need one or both parents until nearly full grown.

[@dandare6865]

God botherer-"but they were the same kind and became other animals later". Hmm sounds like evolution which people of "god," say doesn't exist😮

[@andrewroman1337]

But how the animals from the americas get to Noah

[@tonywalters9436]

Wow that went over my head of understand So I’m thinking after this guy broke it down of how many animals was on Noah Ark saying there was 1400 kinds in reality he didn’t know and history has not fingered it out either. I’m thinking God has left this a Mystery

[@ankyspon1701]

This has not helped, grouping animals together does not solve the time problem. 4,500 years is not enough time for those few kinds on Noah's ark, to breed and give rise to all the other members of their particular family. Added to this, when the flood subsided, all those animals were dumped in one part of the world, from there they had to find safety away from the predators who needed food and then begin breeding to increase their own numbers. Unless you also believe in evolution, two wolves don't suddenly give rise to jackals and other distinct wild dog breeds. The same goes if it was two lions on board, two lions would struggle to reproduce their own kind in enough numbers, let alone breed so well that on just a few thousand years they produce other kinds of cat that live all over the world such as leopards, pumas, cheetah's, Lynx, ocelots, jaguars and tigers etc. Even evolutionists would struggle to pull off such a theory in just over 4000 years. Having enough food ( and varieties of food) onboard to feed every creature, removing all the waste, then preventing them killing each other immediately upon release, they are some serious problems. I hope the next video solves these problems. Up to now, the only way we can believe the ark story, is if the flood was local to Noah and just a few animals were saved.

[@davidgardner863]

A lot of those animals were known in ancient times as they are now, so they didn’t have anywhere near 4000 years.

[@ankyspon1701]

@@davidgardner863 I'm a Christian really struggling with the global flood theory, so what are you saying Dave? I can appreciate that dinosaurs could have existed 4000 years ago (we have coelacanths alive in the see), but my point was, it would seem impossible for the ark to contain the number of species necessary to produce all the 1.2m (estimated 8million) species, we currently have on Earth today. How could the Ark possibly have two of every kind? What about all the plants, insects and animals with specific temperature or dietary requirements? And even then, how could they breed and where did the new species come from? I dispute evolution and know that 99% of animal species cannot interbreed, because even those that manage it, always produce infertile offspring. Once released many animals would also have been killed by all the hungry predators,. leaving even fewer creatures to breed. So it's difficult to comprehend where all the species came from, how they got to Australia etc.

[@davidgardner863]

@@ankyspon1701 , You pointed out some of the reasons why the flood story is totally impossible but there are many more. All dinosaurs except those that evolved into the birds we know today died out 66 million years ago. Evolution of species is a well established fact despite what the creationists tell you. It is driven by changes in the environment and if there is little change there is no need for a creature to evolve into something else as in the case of the coelacanth.

[@blackholeentry3489]

Have you ever wondered where enough water came from to flood the entire earth above all of its tallest mountaintops, but even more important, just WHERE did it all disappear to afterwards? Noahs Ark is a great fairytale, but quickly breaks down when analyzing just how it could have happened. BHE

[@davidgardner863]

@@ankyspon1701 , Evolution over hundreds of millions of years answers all of your questions and it’s the only answer unless you believe in magic. You don’t have to give up Christianity though. In fact most Christians look at the flood story as well as others as metaphor, a teaching device used back then.

[@peterrue2612]

Read the Book of Enoch. The animals brought the new born To the Ark ,and then defend the Ark from the zombies. Read it!

[@tonywalters9436]

Only God knew all the details of the ark and the animal that was on it

[@SPsounds100]

Great and, God won't share the details of how they took care or how the animals could get along?

[@oscarmudd6579]

You can't make lies become true by repeating them.

[@brucenassar9077]

so they evolved in a year...

[@johnspartan98]

A.I.G. needs to get a documentary on Discovery and History Channels. I just watched a terrible documentary about the flood and was thinking how bias and prejudicial it was towards the Biblical account.

[@fordprefect5304]

The Biblical Account is considered a fairy tale. Why because it is.

[@johnspartan98]

@@fordprefect5304 How do you know what you said is true? Are you absolutely certain?

[@fordprefect5304]

@@johnspartan98 Yes I am 100 % correct. If you are over 12 and believe this fairy tale get help.

[@fordprefect5304]

@@johnspartan98 Question how dumb to you have to be to believe his story? Or any story in the bible? Would you explain why not a shred of evidence has ever been found to support a single bible story?

[@fordprefect5304]

One last thing any story that contains magic is considered a fairy tale by science. Have a wonderful day

I suggest there wwre very few kinds. We creationists should strive to squeeze things into fewr and fewer kinds. so cats are joined with civits, weasels, and loads of other living or extinct. Wolves, bears, s eals and loads of others into another kind. i don't agree there wre dinosaurs but they are members in kinds in greater spectrums. i say there wwre few kinds on the ark or for adam to name on creation week.

[@nickyl9040]

I think that it was grossly irresponsible for god to put the fate of life on spaceship Earth on a vessel that wasn't seaworthy which had a captain and crew that had never been to sea before

[@alphaomegasurvival9315]

Obviously it was seaworthy or we wouldn’t be here…and it’s surprising that you would believe you know better than Almighty God.

[@avi8r66]

Even more terrifying that adults in this day and age think this actally happened.

[@bigwaterblue]

@@avi8r66 Science is catching up with what the Bible has taught all along. It is just difficult for most of us to change our paradigm and realize evolution is not how life began on earth. Believe the BIBLE !! Believe in GOD who created this earth and the heavens just as the Bible teaches.

[@avi8r66]

@@bigwaterblue The bible fails to describe things accurately from the very beginning. Example, it says the moon rules the night. Well, the moon is not always up at night. Sometimes it is up during the day. Nor is it a light source, it simply reflects some light from the sun. It also describes events that never happened, like that flood. Sorry, but the only way to believe the bible is more accurate than what we have learned through science is to simply ignore reality.

[@davidgardner863]

@@bigwaterblue , The origin of life is abiogenesis, not evolution.

[@jasonscott6640]

That’s what I can glean from the separation of clean and unclean animals Humans were recognized as birth likeness animals Using Virtues Noah would observe the Villagers through interactions Then separate the people with virtue 😶😶😶 That was my take 😬😬😬

[@GooberStomper]

Yup - Calves, newborns and even Eggs take up a whole lot less room than a full grown adult animal & eat a whole lot less too

[@itsjustnotrue]

so they had incubations back then ?? mmm

[@PortmanRd]

Unlikely to get an answer to that one. Brushed straight under the carpet.

[@davidgardner863]

How did newborns nurse?

[@jasonscott6640]

Can we do the Ark dimensions 😃 I was thinking since Noah’s Ark was in the Beginning I always thought the Ark was a reference of time 30 days a month 50 weeks a year 300 working days Each post and beam was 6 x 1 representing six days of creation and the sabbath. 😃 I guess I was way off 😃

[@malcolmbeeton1822]

Experimental archeology would be a good way to test if the ark could be proved. Float that ark, the one your mate Ken had built. Get an old bloke and his missus, plus 6 younger people. 3 women and 3 men. Gather your kinds together and see if they can look after them for, say a year, on this boat on the ocean. Don't worry about dinosaurs though, maybe take a few more crocodiles, alligators, pythons and monitor s to make up for the dinosaurs.

[@Vekren]

They found the ark in Turkey although lying google is saying they mistakened it for a vein of iron lol even though dredge stones ancient boat anchors were found all around the site. They did not need millions because no animals ever evolved just adapted into different kinds eg ancient wolf would cover all types of dogs, including perhaps coyotes and other dog like animals, insects could probably survive on floating debri, no dinosaurs in my opinion as they were possibly abominations created by the fallen angels when they fell long ago.

[@davidgardner863]

You’re talking about drogue stones, not dredge stones and those were made from the local rock so you think the ark landed in the same place it left from?

[@georg7120]

Creationists have rebuilt the ark. Take 8 volunteers, the appropriate number of animals and food and lock them up in the ark to prove that it works. That would be creation science.

[@Zripas]

That's just cruelty against animals...

[@georg7120]

@@Zripas Do you really think they would take the risk to prove themselves wrong.

[@davidgardner863]

But where can you find a 600 year old volunteer?

[@georg7120]

@@davidgardner863 Don't make it too hard for them. The first step is to prove that you can keep all this animals for one year in the ark.

[@davidgardner863]

@@georg7120 , Maybe a small flock of sheep for a month or two.

[@fordprefect5304]

Who carried the brain eating Amoebas? Was it Noah or his sons. Nah they gave it to one of the women

[@illadvized7623]

Amoebas are sea creatures. He didn't collect anything from the sea

[@lanabowers5332]

The flood happened in c.10,800 BC. The historical 'Noah' was Uta-Napishtim/Ziusudra. He was told by Enki to take the SEED of living things, not actual animals. The ark was not an aircraft carrier sized floating zoo.

[@lewiscarey1593]

I'll believe Bible over your wisdom, ANY DAY!!!😮😮😮

[@moss17dale]

Where did he store all of the seeds of all the plants in the world. Because all plant life would have died, and how were those seeds distributed around the world afterwards. Don't worry I'm not expecting an answer, because it can't be answered.

[@JaneSmith-n2k]

There were only 22 kinds of species.

[@robbieogle8622]

All over the place.

[@walkergarya]

No animals were brought onto Noah's Ark because it was NEVER anything more than a fairy tale.

[@RRV-o9e]

I

[@scunnym]

Only 1 explination needed. IT DIDNT HAPPEN!

[@jasonscott6640]

So the separation of Animals was about Virtue and Sin In Christian tradition, the seven heavenly virtues combine the four cardinal virtues of prudence, justice, temperance, and fortitude with the three theological virtues of faith, hope, and charity.

[@TheGuitarReb]

The story had been around in several cultures for a while before it was plagiarized and put into the Old Testament.

[@jasonscott6640]

@@TheGuitarReb it’s recorded as the Epic of Gilgamesh too It wasn’t plagiarized Noah’s Ark is just a different linguistic rendition of a supernatural event It’s quite possible most of these old creation tales are different linguistic renderings of the same events

[@TheGuitarReb]

@@jasonscott6640 Linguistic rendering? What's the difference in taking someone else's writing adding stuff and changing the story up a bit. I used to do art renderings of buildings and they looked just like the buildings. Didn't change a thing, not even a flag pole.

[@jasonscott6640]

@@TheGuitarReb what’s the difference Intention That’s the difference We can write the same thing and have two different intentions

[@jasonscott6640]

@@TheGuitarReb 😶 metaphysical creation is about intentions 😶 Let’s say I’m upset with you and you’re not listening 😶 Let’s say you keep going down the road of perdition and I’m sick of watching over you because you’re not listening 🤨 You’re just doing your own thing 🤨 Not listening 🤨 Now let’s say I call you on the phone and I’m yelling at the top of my voice and it sounds really ominous because I say That’s your last warning ⚠️ Now Everything is about intention So What is the warning ⛔️ I’m not going going to do anything Nothing You’re not listening So I’m not going to help you out You’re on your own You won’t listen So you’re done here I’m moving on to salvation You’re stuck here until you can forgive and move on Stop dragging this stuff into the National Media

[@jasonscott6640]

Clean and Unclean Animals were referring to Sin and Virtue 😶 Noah was observing the village Interaction between upper middle and low class Using Virtue as a guide line Noah was separating Good and Evil 😃 That’s my take 😃

[@Drum1965]

Clean = Edible UnClean= not Edible by God's food laws. This is why he took 7 pairs of the CLEAN ANIMALS, for meat to eat , they were in the Ark for over a YEAR!

[@jimpassi349]

TWO OF EVERY KIND // NOT EVERY ANIMAL //NOTICE KIND //SCIENCE SAYS DNA BANK // OK JUST YOU ANS 8 OF YOUR FAMILY MAKE SOMETHING OUT OF IT // I CANT CAN YOU

[@Ghostface634]

It would had been a blood bath LOL

[@jasonscott6640]

The Flood was Wisdom 😶 Water meant wisdom Animals were human beings 😶 You’re not looking at this as a metaphysical experience It’s a fantastic video Don’t get me wrong But Animals were villagers and the Ark was a metaphysical experience

[@alphaomegasurvival9315]

Evidence for a physical flood is everywhere…the Bible contains stories of real events, not “metaphysical experiences.” If you believe everything is symbolic, you will miss the point when the end of the age comes.

[@fordprefect5304]

*How Many Animals Did Noah Have to Bring on the Ark* None since fairy tales can't hold animals. Ok it can hold Mickey Mouse, Donald Duck etc

[@anttisalminen1110]

None, they were allready spread all over the world

[@kukuipupule4415]

god miniaturized the creatures... if you believe

[@romishmajidov1205]

IS IT ME OR IS HE SAYING HE BELIEVES IN EVOLUTION

[@alphaomegasurvival9315]

It’s you

[@waynegoin5534]

No he is not let's say the Dog kind the dogs on the ark would have had all the genetic material/info present in them for all the breeds we have today. mutations never add new DNA or information

[@DucNguyen-ek4vq]

Evolution is not necessarily in opposition to the Bible. Remember that creation accounts in the Bible were written in poetry form - it is not a science book. It might just be an interpretation of what actually happened, with evolution being one of the possibilities.

[@benjaminavick6455]

A lot of ifs ,,could,,,buts,, maybe,,, ands in here,,,, nobody was there so nobody knows,

[@jasonscott6640]

“Clean Animals” may have been a train of thought. Clean might fall in line with chastity as a Virtue Maybe Noah was observing the Seven Virtues? “Clean” may have fell in line with Chastity Unclean may have fallen in with seven deadly sins So Clean and Unclean would’ve been separating Good and Evil 😶 Separation of Good and Evil using Virtue to separate the two states

[@jasonscott6640]

Probably during each day of Creation 🧐 Virtues were used to separate clean and unclean.

[@tommason4073]

Hi

[@BrendonSchaferCT]

I'd suggest the title is misleading. The correct answer is ZERO. God brought them onto the Ark. :-)

[@rodericgurrola1745]

It’s was just a question of the title that people have cause skeptics sometime says millions even though there including plants and marine animals and invertebrates it just shows how confident they are that there right even though they didn’t study it at all. God bless my guy.

[@oreally8605]

Very true 👍

[@sgt.grinch3299]

Slick

[@jasonscott6640]

I was thinking Noah’s Ark was about the seven days of creation Using Virtue we were consolidating language having Interactions with each other 🤷 I guess I was way off 🤷 Who knew

[@TheGuitarReb]

No! It was about an old Jewish guy and his family that built a big boat. They loaded it with sheep cows and chickens. (no pork allowed) God told him to do this because He was pissed off and was going to Kill EVERYTHING on Earth! He sort of liked Noah, so He sent an Angel to warn him with directions on how to build a big boat.

[@jasonscott6640]

@@TheGuitarReb never mind

[@priscellamiles6122]

People are always trying to find ways to discredit God using their learned science and knowledge. Failing however to acknowledge that it is God that allows them to have and acquire the knowledge. If you believe you do, if not you don’t, stop trying to make since of it. You never will.

[@Zripas]

Care to actually prove it and not just assert it?

[@sjs9354]

God didn’t need that big boat to replenish the animals on earth. How did they get here in the first place? Where did the flies and locusts come from in Egypt? Did God say, “all ye frogs within 100 mile radius, hop on down to the palace in Egypt. After the Ark settled, did God say, “ok kangaroos, get on down to Australia?” God is the creator. But He gives man something to do and be a part. He uses events for examples and tests of our faith. Gods ways are supernatural and above our finite understanding.

[@georg7120]

Why this heretic nonsense about "kind"? Genesis 6 says "sorts! [19] And of every living thing of all flesh, two of every SORT shalt thou bring into the ark, to keep them alive with thee; they shall be male and female. [20] Of fowls after their kind, and of cattle after their kind, of every creeping thing of the earth after his kind, two of every SORT shall come unto thee, to keep them alive. Genesis 6 : 19-20

[@peterrue2612]

The earth is FLAT! Read your Bible. May God have mercy on your soul

[@arkencounter]

answersingenesis.org/astronomy/earth/falling-flat-earth/

[@Zripas]

@@arkencounter It's always fun to see two bible believers argue opposite points by using some old book as evidence... C'mon people... And just FYI earth is a globe, but bible in multiple places points to it being flat, so both of you are wrong here.

[@peterrue2612]

@@arkencounter Ken, God said he put the sun, moon and stars In the firmament ,that separates the waters from the waters. Joshua asked God to not let the sun set, and it did not for 6hrs. A spinning ball coming to a stop would be catastrophic according to your world view

[@pinguy2334]

0 because it never happened. In the story it was two of each.

[@alphaomegasurvival9315]

Maybe you should crack your Bible open and reread the story…

[@pinguy2334]

@@alphaomegasurvival9315 I rather not. Not my kind of story.

[@nickroberts-xf7oq]

​@@pinguy2334 I'm glad you won't be in heaven ! 🎉

[@pinguy2334]

@@nickroberts-xf7oq Im glad you realize Heaven does not exist.

[@nickroberts-xf7oq]

Noah didn't have to bring any...... they came to him and God shut the door.

[@Zripas]

Even sloth's?

[@nickroberts-xf7oq]

@@Zripas Yep ✔️

[@Zripas]

@@nickroberts-xf7oq At 0.27 km/h while sleeping for 15 - 18 every day and living on different continent from this magical boat?... Just do some basic math here how long would it take for sloth to travel this distance not even taking into consideration of issues with route or food supply... This is one of the most obvious false stories in entire book which was actually proven to be false. No need to try invent some silly explanations for it, as at the end of the day it will remain false anyways.

[@Gtrseller]

Why these people continue to say that the Ark has never been located is a mystery to me. Do a little research, because it most certainly has been located and identified in Turkey.

[@waynegoin5534]

No it has not

[@Gtrseller]

@@waynegoin5534 Sorry Wayne, but I have to respectfully disagree with you. There is a ton of data and proof that it has indeed been located. kzbin.info/www/bejne/r2TTiWV8fshrj7M

[@FirstLast-il6ok]

@@Gtrseller that video has neither data nor proof.

[@FireWallthefts]

Why Noah's ark was made because those who broke the heart of the ocean Sapphire 10 commandments September will try to escape they must repent forgive all who broke September only God who isn't on earth can judge each of them pray for there souls because I can't Judge on earth But in Heaven I can judge each case with facts not my options

[@FireWallthefts]

Why it will cost Asians and gorilla's everything because they did a war twice in Israel there considering calling them Terrorist in the United States September 6 1972 I still forgive the Asians and Gorilla's I pray for there Terrorists souls hope they don't go to hell

[@brucenassar9077]

seek mental help

[@FireWallthefts]

@@brucenassar9077 making fun of the Torah or rabbi s was a bad decision you just made the star of David is not rainbow

[@TheGuitarReb]

A big flood, a big boat and lots of animals had nothing to do with Jesus because He was born many years later. A follower of Jesus (Christian) You don't have to believe in Noah's Ark. Jesus said I am the way, the truth. so follow the "New Testament" the new covenant. The teachings of Jesus of how to live your life.

[@Jewonastick]

Typical cherry picking Christian.... The new testament actually claims that Jesus mentioned Noah!

[@TheGuitarReb]

@@Jewonastick YES, That's me alright! I pick cherries! They are good eating!

[@paulsevers7740]

Very helpful arguments, but I do wish your RIDICULOUS visual of the ARK - word means BOX not boat - could be amended, as it does NOTHING for your credibility. The ark was built to FLOAT not navigate, and though I am sure God gave Noah detailed design instructions, I am certain that they did not result in a Viking longboat as you depict - remember all the land was one continent, and there is no evidence of boat building prior to the Flood., i.e no fossilised boats ANYWHERE amid the sediment layers anywhere in the world.

[@Zripas]

And there isint remains of Noah boat either... So what is your point? And no idea how is all landmases beign one 200+ million yers ago is connected with this fictional story which supposedly took place 5000'ish years ago.

[@jasonscott6640]

Noah’s Ark was probably a location. 😶 A Village. 😶 It’s a Metaphysical Experience. 🤔 Look at the History of Sumer Iraq. 🤔 Also look where Uruk once stood. 🤔

[@HannahsCats-zp6rb]

Animals on Noah's Boat? Sounds made up.

[@jasonscott6640]

Again Animals were people So separating clean and unclean would have been done through interactions Using Virtue as a guide line.

[@jasonscott6640]

The Animals were human beings and the Ark was Metaphysical Animals were symbolic of human beings Think of descriptions about people Sly as a Fox 🦊 Strong as an Ox 🐂 Graceful as a Deer 🦌 Birth Likeness Animals 😊 Animals were symbolic of human beings 😃

[@dimensionexo.]

1400 is an astronomical amount 🐊🦖🐸🦂🕷🐍🦍🐻🦕🦘etc *