How We Make Oatmeal Pie - Simple Ingredient Cooking - Mama's Old Fashioned Southern Recipes

Indulge in the delectable taste of oatmeal pie with Mama's old-fashioned southern recipe. Learn how to whip up this scrumptious dessert with simple ingredients that will leave your taste buds craving for more.
Welcome to Collard Valley Cooks! Have you wished you could make your pies taste like Mama made them? You can do it! Come sit at my table and watch my cooking videos. You will learn how to cook Southern-style dishes with my mama's techniques and recipes. You will become a great cook, so stick around and don't miss a post by clicking that subscribe button today! Please leave me a comment if you like this recipe!
We have 4 large print cookbooks for sale! Purchase Collard Valley Cooks Cookbooks through our website: www.collardvalleycooks.com/co...
We have over 700 Printable recipes on our website. Use our search bar on the home page of our website to find any recipe. You can go ahead and print it or save the pdf to print later. Go here to find this recipe under a food category here: www.collardvalleycooks.com/so...
To use our website search bar go to the top of the home page here: www.collardvalleycooks.com/
OATMEAL PIE (Future cookbook recipe)
Beat 4 eggs until foamy Add:
1 CUP SUGAR
1/4 CUP MELTED BUTTER
1 CUP MILK
1/4 CUP DARK KARO SYRUP
1 TSP. VANILLA EXTRACT
1 TSP. MAPLE EXTRACT
2 TBSP. FLOUR
For the full printable recipe visit our website at: www.collardvalleycooks.com/pi...
Subscribe to Collard Valley Cooks: / collardvalleycooks
Link to enter our current Giveaway: www.collardvalleycooks.com/gi...
See our Latest Video Tutorials: www.youtube.com/@CollardValle...
See our Most Watched Video Tutorials: www.youtube.com/@CollardValle...
Shop Tammy’s Amazon Favorites: amzn.to/3TSRbsx
Check out our website: www.collardvalleycooks.com/
Shop our Kitchen Best Sellers: www.collardvalleycooks.com/to...
We are Chris & Tammy Nichols and we are sharing our love for Southern cooking, passed down through generations and seasoned with a whole lot of love. Come sit at our table, where biscuits rise golden brown, collard greens simmer soulfully, and laughter and good times always bring back memories. We'll be showing you how to whip up classics like fried chicken and cornbread, explore hidden gems of Southern cuisine, and even throw in a few surprises along the way. So, grab your kitchen tools and get ready to cook up some memories with Collard Valley Cooks!
#oatmealpie, #oatmealrecipes
Swaggerty Sausage Sponsor: www.swaggertys.com/
#collardvalleycooks, #oatmeal #pie #oatmealpie #desserts , #southerncooking,

[@stevevernon5038]

My wife makes a pie with karo syrup and oatmeal no coconut or nuts and she calls it poor man's pecan pie. Fabulous.

[@clydeblanton8244]

Ovd😊

[@autoharpangie3303]

You had me at oatmeal ❤ you mentioned lunch room ladies. I grew up in South Carolina and many of the lunch room ladies were neighbors and went to our Baptist Church and boy could they cook. They were like mommas at school. They took great care in all those wonderful meals from scratch they made… I was lucky to have great homemade lunches for 12 years. My kids and grands are not as lucky with the so called school Lunch nowadays . It’s like they done away with hot lunch at many schools . They get junk food(pizza,etc)and cold lunches🥲 Some of our kids would benefit today with a great home cooked meal. I wish it was mandatory. It was in the south when I was in school not sure about other parts of the country. God Bless all the wonderful lunch ladies . We were so lucky❤

[@laserbeam002]

Yeah, I grew up and still live in South Carolina. I went to a small elementary school that only went to the 6th grade. The ladies who worked in the lunch room were all local ladies, friends and neighbors and yeah they could really cook. The very best turkey dressing I have ever ate was what the lunch room ladies made. This was in the late 60's to early 70's.

[@Mister_Listener]

I am lucky to have the time and resources to cook and bake almost everything i eat. You are lucky to have such delicious childhood memories! Hugs.

[@donaldcalloway4558]

Yumm.😊

[@recoveringsoul755]

Grew up on the west coast and we had the option to buy school lunches in elementary school. There was a full kiisnd they made the food there. We got a schedule ahead of time so if u liked what they had I could buy lunch And other times I brought from home I'm pretty sure in junior high and highschool we could still get school lunches. When my kids were in school they had the food brought in.

[@melaniecravens7240]

Oatmeal pie is very good and lunches were so good back in the day the old school still smells like those homade rolls

[@debragreen7272]

Lifelong Texan and this was staple years ago but I had forgotten about it! I was young and loved it! Cant wait to try it tomorrow when our son comes by! He wants fried salmon and Mom’s creamed potatoes and cornbread! I saw your fried okra post and decided on that! He loves what i call dish pan salad ( you cut it up in an enamel dish pan and use all veggies in fridge) and homemade sweet cornbread! May not be proper healthy food but he doesn’t get to come often! I was thinking I would make a chocolate pie and now I’m in a quandary! I want to cook this but chocolate is his favorite and our hen eggs make such beautiful meringue! I guess I will wait until Wed to do this one because he will take leftovers home! Lol

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Make him the chocolate pie

[@Mister_Listener]

Your measuring cup is huge! And your theme song is EPIC. 😊

[@MrsBrit1]

Mix the sugar and flour first and skip the lumps! This pie looks tasty!

[@Crystal_Blue_Persuasion]

Cooks at St. Peter's Hospital in Helena, Montana were baking this back in 1976. It was a favorite with staff and visitors to the cafeteria. I had gotten the recipe from them but somehow it was lost. Thanks so much for printing it here!

[@laurametheny1008]

Thank you lady! Me and my granddaughter love pecan pie. And oatmeal. And coconut. And maple. So weird this showed up because I've been planning on pecan pie. This looks so yummy! God bless and take care🙏🏼💗🥥🌰🥞🥧

[@harrywilson404]

This is one of the best look6 pies I've seen in a long time!

[@tinamiolen8009]

I’m wondering what would happen if you put just a handful of chocolate chips in the mix. It may not go with the molasses but to have oatmeal, coconut, pecans and chocolate chips sounds heavenly.

[@KathleenCalhoun-em6ys]

I have made oatmeal pie before but do not recall putting coconut into it (although I could be wrong since it was a long time ago), but everything else sounds the same. I believe the recipe I made was a request made by a reader of Gourmet Magazine from a restaurant he ate at which served it, and the restaurant obliged. It tasted very good, but the one you demonstrated sounds even better. I am surprised that you didn't have this recipe yourself already. Hey, Tammy, Cal & Marie from the Southern Country Living channel mentioned that you were in their neck.of the woods recently, I think to attend a festival, and you gave one.of their relatives a free cookbook that you compiled and that your mother was a professonal baker, something I didn't know before Your gesture was a very nice one and one that was appreciated by them since they drew attention to it. I envy them for getting such a treasure!

[@karellarsen939]

I have to make one of these! Looks fantastic! ❤️❤️😊. Thank you 😊👍

[@henrycooks1883]

Southern living has some of the best recipes.

[@JackieNoey-zl7nh]

You can mix together sugar and flour before you put in mixing bowl. It's faster.

[@dorisscott3133]

Good find....looks like a winner

[@sharondoan1447]

Your pie meets all my requirements! What a wonderful recipe .I had to edit my comment to say ,” Thank You “ for putting the recipe right there where I could easily copy it!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

They are all printable in pdf on collardvalleycooks.com

[@marykahn5384]

My mom made this pie years ago! It tastes just like pecan pie! Thanks so much for this recipe!!❤️

[@scrane5500]

Looks great--love coconut! Going to try this plant-based as I have a family history of Cancer so need to avoid the estrogen and possible BLV in dairy and choline and lead in eggs. Thanks for sharing

[@Allenmassageguy]

Lead in eggs? What the?

[@laurakaszuba6785]

I know where Center Tx is, right outside Kerrville, Tx and Fredericksburg, Tx. I think , that was an old Home Economics recipe.

[@sheriecochran5849]

Centerville I believe is what your thinking of by Fredericksburg Texas. Center Texas is maybe about 30-45 minutes from Louisiana. I grew up in Hemphill which is about 30 minutes South of Center. I may be off on the exact times, because I have not lived in the area for over 35 years, but I visit several times a year.

[@laurakaszuba6785]

I don't think we're talking about the same place. Fredericksburg Tx, and Kirrville,Tx are located north west of San Antonio,TX. Not close to Louisiana at all.

[@christysbutterfly1612]

Its says theres almost 190 views but only 50 likes, people hit the thumbs up 👍!!

[@juliecarter7337]

Amen Christy!!

[@waynehajek6346]

@christysbutterfly1612 If you watch it and don't like it, why thumbs up the video? Why comment at all?

[@christysbutterfly1612]

@waynehajek6346 This comment was made during the livestream. It's a simple reminder so us fans of the channel can help get the video out in the algorithm so others can enjoy. If you don't like the content, don't give it a like, no biggie 😊

[@waynehajek6346]

​@@christysbutterfly1612 👍

[@jadedeyes5286]

What is Kirk syrup ?

[@ksmill09]

Those little white spots in eggs are stabilizers that keep the yolk in the center of the egg. It’s normal, google it. I love your cooking videos, you cook like momma did.

[@hollypetrey2166]

She's talking about the little dark spot. Mine did that but I had a rooster and it was the start of a baby chick!

[@christopherbright1048]

My garsh that's quite a stove I have a wood burning cook stove no where near the knobs & burners you have but can't wait to try

[@tonyaadams5304]

Oh, Shazam!!! Big ol' Texas Oatmeal Pie!! I love it! It's so good with unsweetened strong iced tea!!! Thanks Tammy. I'm gonna make one this week! Tonya from Dallas....Texas that is!!

[@patriciagraves8824]

I which you would show your kitchen I’m always looking for ideas

[@wendimccain8580]

Looks delicious. What brand of stove is that. Looks very nice.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Forno

[@wendimccain8580]

@@CollardValleyCooks Thank you

[@michaeldougherty8344]

Great pie video, thank you

[@karensheart]

I really appreciate every time you share tips! Thank you!❤

[@short-hand4312]

must be from WV. only place I have heard milk pronounced like that.

[@rogergraves242]

HuH, Never heard of Oatmeal Pie. Buttermilk Pie is Good.

[@paulavalentine242]

I wonder if there’s a substitute for the corn syrup? I prefer to avoid corn syrup.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Use brown sugar

[@KD-mv8uf]

thank you, I was wondering too. same amount?

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Yes@@KD-mv8uf

[@manzettameadows3291]

I sure could use a slice with some ice cream, yummy.

[@Margar02]

Mmmmm butter pecan ice cream, or vanilla....

[@laurreneberry3480]

Ive wanted to make this pie for some time .thankyou for the recipe.

[@jadedeyes5286]

What is the Kiro syrup ? Is it like molasses ?

[@CollardValleyCooks]

No, it's just corn syrup made with brown sugar. I guess instead of regular white sugar it is not as strong as molasses

[@dorisscott3133]

It is cane syrup

[@jadedeyes5286]

Ok Thank you . I don’t if I can get that in Canada .

[@user-nj1ni6iz7v]

How long did you bake? Temperature too?❤

[@teresaertman4687]

1 hour at 350 F 😊

[@CollardValleyCooks]

The written recipe is in the description for you

[@pamspradlin8768]

Good. Morning. That. Pie. Look. So. Good. Never. Hear. Of. It

[@marymagmartha7453]

All my favorite ingredients ❣️ I love Oatmeal Cookies and I love Pecan Pie, so why not😊 The only thing that worries me...I'll end up "hurtin' myself" 🥧 Just a thought...what about topped with Chocolate Whipped Cream?

[@lawanadrummond8995]

Tammy, I made this for dessert tonight. My family loves it better than a pecan pie! It was a hit.

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Fantastic!

[@revabrown2288]

It looks amazing, and I'm sure it taste delicious.

[@callende5942]

That looks delicious! ❤I'm going to try it. Just curious, what year was the cookbook published? I hope I didn't miss it in the video....update: hi Tammy never mind... found it online.🎉 Recipe from 1968!! Wow!! Older recipes are the best!! ❤🎉❤🎉❤ thanks for sharing!!

[@renabuckner8]

Where is the ice cream! Yummy 😋

[@belindadunne4312]

Pecans, coconut & oats ... a few of my favorite things! Thank you for sharing this recipe. I'm loving these old random cookbook recipes you're sharing. 👍🏻 Your butterfly shirt is super cute on you. 😊❤

[@glendaakers7528]

That pie looks delicious!❤

[@snowangel6332]

What a combination 😍 I can't wait to make this incredible pie that looks so delicious 😋

[@margaretchaney3572]

Hi Tammy. I have made this pie years ago. I love it. So yummy. Time to try it again 😊

[@foxydancer54]

I don't really like oatmeal but I do like oatmeal cookies so I think I'll try this. As usual when I'm trying a new recipe I'm already thinking of ways to improve it before I even start. I'll let you know how it turns out. btw, I think if your pie had completely there would not have been that liquid at the bottom

[@sandralouth3103]

My much loved DIL has diverticulitis and cannot eat nuts. She loves pecan pie so I make Oatmeal Pie (no nuts, no coconut) and she gets to enjoy a very close-to-pecan pie experience. Hmmm. Maybe next pie I will add 1/4 c. Chocolate chips.

[@caronstout354]

If you toast the oatmeal gently it will give them a nutty flavor for the pie.

[@teresalee9997]

Thank you for sharing❤ I will have to make this weekend for my husband❤

[@janicescott6569]

This is a must. I have to purchase the dark kayro though.

[@eudorasalih4004]

I love oatmeal I have to try it from Philadelphia

[@saraphim100]

Thank you for the pie crust tip 😉 Can’t wait to try this! It looks so divine!!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

You are so welcome!

[@bcny2700]

How was that giant scoop one cup of sugar ?? LOL OMG looked like 5 cups

[@blayne2029]

Never had this. Sounds awesome.

[@dejonscales5217]

I really appreciate you every time you share one of my favorite recipes .again, I want to thank you .

[@gloriajohnson8762]

I used to make the oatmeal pies but I didn’t use coconut. That sounds very interesting. I must try it.

[@luciabriseno4065]

😱Ohhh my Gosh!!!! That looks Amazing!!! And not hard at all to make. It’s a winner for Me😜👩‍🍳👌🏻👩‍🍳😋😋😋

[@patiencekates5975]

1000 likes!!!!😍

[@karenzurek9141]

Mama use to make Oatmeal Pie always.

[@BigShirley_MsGigi_FP]

This is a unique and awesome recipe I can’t wait to make this one ☝🏾 I wonder how would it taste 👅 if you would use a cup of Buttermilk or carnation milk instead Thanks for sharing this quick a easy recipe

[@karensees4462]

Is there a place where the recipe is printed out? Looks wonderful 😊

[@CollardValleyCooks]

In the description

[@anthonydolio8118]

That was to pretty to slice into. Thanks for sharing it with us.

[@timothyhays1817]

For some reason, I want raisins in it instead of coconut.

[@missellie6581]

Hi Tammy. Looks absolutely fabulous. Thank you 😊😊😊😊 Gonna try it this weekend when family comes over. I’m so excited.

[@mariepalkiewicz852]

Looks DEVINE!

[@judycolson6047]

Anything with oats, pecans, and coconut has got to be scrumptious! Gotta make this pie! 🥧

[@barbarawilliams6978]

I’ve never heard of this pie but you can bet I’m going to make it as soon as I can get some coconut. Thanks, Tammy, for sharing this recipe! I’m late in seeing this video but I hear on one of the latest ones that you have COVID again. So sorry this has happened to you. Take care of yourself. Sounds like Chris is doing his best to look after you! You are blessed to have a husband who can cook!

[@coretmanus4688]

Thank you 😊 I just followed your recipe after watching a couple times. You give me a warm feeling of down home Texas but I am far North of there. I had to substitute for the milk I didn’t have but used yogurt. And the Karo I used pure Maple syrup instead and nixed the maple flavor as that was built in but wish me luck it’s in the oven now so I should know in about an hour. Thanks again!

[@blackcatlover7028]

Looks delicious!

[@rhondabutler4172]

I’ve never had this but those are all ingredients I like so how could it not be good!!😊

[@hermalisa]

Yum!!

[@melissaphillips3088]

As soon as you say it has pecans I am all in!! Love this recipe Tammy. It looks so good😋Thanks so much💕

[@kittycall2358]

Did you use regular oats or quick

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Quick

[@tonytherf-mb3dg]

Dang Tammy, you done it again!👏👏👏

[@loriannperry5302]

We used to have this pie twice a month and my mom would use leftover oatmeal from breakfast we used stone ground. I miss that pie we had it this way to thank you and god bless !

[@godisgood678]

Yum

[@classicG342]

YUM, YUM! I love this recipe!

[@marthab255]

Those look like Georgia pecans. I have real maple syrup from my friend in Wisconsin. I will use that with a little flour.

[@judycolson6047]

I just made it and it is so delicious! It is like a cross between a coconut pie and a pecan pie. I made a mistake though. On the recipe page, I didn’t notice that the eggs were listed way above the rest of the ingredients. So I missed out on the eggs, but it turned out really well anyhow. I used Marie Callender frozen piecrust for convenience because hers are pretty flaky. This is a good easy pie and I would make it again. Easy peasy! 😊

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Sounds great!

[@karenzurek9141]

Mama always made Oatmeal Pie.

[@gailcrews8606]

This looks Delicious 😋🥰❤️

[@user-ci6ng1yu8t]

This pie looks awesome! I was wondering how long do you wait for when baking the pie before you put the pie crust guard on to keep the edges from getting too brown? Have a blessed day!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Once it is a brown as you want add the gaurd

[@juliecarter7337]

Hi everyone, this looks yum!! ❤ hi Tammy!! Love it!!

[@michellehale8962]

Thank you for finding this recipe, Tammy! I’m thinking I’ll add 1/2 c chocolate chips to it. Been wondering about your chickens, how they are doing. I can’t have chickens so I just have to ask about yours!😊

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Very well thank you!

[@myboibill]

Tammy, this one looks like a winner. I have a recipe for oatmeal pie but it doesn’t have coconut or pecans in it. I am going to bake this one late this week. I just took half a dozen mincemeat tarts out of the oven. I was using a frozen mincemeat from Christmas. I love your channel

[@pegsmith1110]

I have never heard of an oatmeal pie! It looks sooooo good! Im going to make this the next time my six sisters get together!😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@marychamplin5807]

It sounds similar to a derby pie😁

[@norafox4789]

YUMMY 😋😋😋😋

[@jefffischer3585]

Reminds me of oatmeal cake!

[@joanndeland7969]

I love your recipe for the pie 🥧

[@harlanfreeze6002]

Thanks

[@lonaphillips9617]

Looks good! Need some ingredients before I can make it!

[@sfish6676]

Hey Soda!

[@brigidacroes5731]

I am for suregoing to make it❤

[@sharonroberts397]

Oh my goodness tammy! I got a birthday coming up on Monday the 12th.. I have got to make this for my birthday. I love pecan pie, and I also love coconut pie! Girlfriend I'm definitely making this one for sure. Thank you sweetie for the recipe . Many blessings to you and your family!

[@CollardValleyCooks]

Hope you enjoy

[@THE-COOL-GIRL-CHANNEL]

OH*

[@jabez9710]

Yummy. ❤ I like every recipe in southern living. They also put recipes in magazines and the news paper.

[@jabez9710]

I love everything oatmeal. Make a pot of homemade oatmeal. Put it in your bowl make a little nest in the middle add sugar and milk. Yum. Yum. Also syrup is great on oatmeal. Thanks for this video Tammy❤

[@marlavancannon1096]

❤️🤟🏻🧇looks so good . I have to try add that oatmeal and coconuts

[@barbstocktons9338]

My Mom used to make the pie

[@DianeC.]

Hi Tammy!!! Your pie looks super yummy!!! I will be making this one day soon. Im sure I will like it. I have never had it...Thanks for this recipe... YUMS!!!...Nice Video!!!...🦋

[@patriciahartless2095]

Thanks for sharing Oatmeal and coconut pie recipe . Looks just like a pecan pie . I know I'm going to enjoy this pie . I love coconut and pecan pie. Tammy and Chris hope your staying warm .❤❤❤❤❤