Ib - Bad Apple (Music Box)

Credit to xXSingMusic4everXx for the song
I do NOT own anything of this video! Hope you enjoyed this video
Game: Ib
Song: Bad Apple (music Box Version)
English Lyrics: Cristina Vee
Pictures: Zerochan
Lyrics:
Ever on and on I continue circling
With nothing but my hate in a carousel of agony
Till slowly I forget and my heart starts vanishing
And suddenly I see that I can't break free--I'm
Slipping through the cracks of a dark eternity
With nothing but my pain and the paralyzing agony
To tell me who I am, who I was
Uncertainty enveloping my mind
Till I can't break free, and
Maybe it's a dream; maybe nothing else is real
But it wouldn't mean a thing if I told you how I feel
So I'm tired of all the pain, of the misery inside
And I wish that I could live feeling nothing but the night
You can tell me what to say; you can tell me where to go
But I doubt that I would care, and my heart would never know
If I make another move there'll be no more turning back
Because everything will change, and it all will fade to black
Will tomorrow ever come? Will I make it through the night?
Will there ever be a place for the broken in the light?
Am I hurting? Am I sad? Should I stay, or should I go?
I've forgotten how to tell. Did I ever even know?
Can I take another step? I've done everything I can
All the people that I see I will never understand
If I find a way to change, if I step into the light
Then I'll never be the same, and it all will fade to white
Ever on and on I continue circling
With nothing but my hate in a carousel of agony
Till slowly I forget and my heart starts vanishing
And suddenly I see that I can't break free--I'm
Slipping through the cracks of a dark eternity
With nothing but my pain and the paralyzing agony
To tell me who I am, who I was
Uncertainty enveloping my mind
Till I can't break free, and
Maybe it's a dream; maybe nothing else is real
But it wouldn't mean a thing if I told you how I feel
So I'm tired of all the pain, of the misery inside
And I wish that I could live feeling nothing but the night
You can tell me what to say; you can tell me where to go
But I doubt that I would care, and my heart would never know
If I make another move there'll be no more turning back
Because everything will change, and it all will fade to black
If I make another move, if I take another step
Then it all would fall apart. There'd be nothing of me left
If I'm crying in the wind, if I'm crying in the night
Will there ever be a way? Will my heart return to white?
Can you tell me who you are? Can you tell me where I am?I've forgotten how to see; I've forgotten if I can
If I opened up my eyes there'd be no more going back
'Cause I'd throw it all away, and it all would fade to black.
Requests? Leave them in the comments :)

[@prodsayth]

I see Ib and Garry more of brother and sister relationship.

[@Petrichorus-]

Exactexactly

[@makinru6178]

Faithsters and yet people is shipping them as in-love relationship. For fucks sake people, Ib is a goddamn kid and Gary is an adult.

[@tomchien4212]

Ib is like around 10 and Gary is about 20s. They are not very close age but still not an uncapable in-love relationship. They have their promise and that's all the matter. The rest is for the fans. Nothing need to fury about it.

[@camarvan]

Tom Chien old comment but Ib is 9

[@cristinamotta4471]

While Garry is at hes 20, IB IS 9

[@BlaizeTheDragon]

I dunno why people expect Gary an Ib to get married (considering Ib is 9 you perverts) their relationship is more like older brother and younger sister.

[@shaansingh4672]

BlaizeTheDragon i thought of it like daughter and dad

[@brunacastilhocuzzolino3594]

Why do you think japan created lolicon hentai and lolicon romance? :)

[@BabyBells231]

They will start a relationship when she's 18 duh

[@zuhze8416]

+BlaizeTheDragon yep those are just disgusting pedos.

[@BabyBells231]

***** Sooo...?

[@libraric7212]

Who else was singing the lyrics in their head? Ib is so much more depressing if you think about... EVERY. SINGLE. ENDING.

[@ecooper122896]

Promise Of Reunion was not very depressing… I think…… Idk I have no feelings so I would not know -_-

[@libraric7212]

Erin Cooper The one where it hurt me the most was when Garry went insane. All the others were okay but that one just made me upset.

[@GarryDumblowski]

TrainingWarriorRule WooHoo What was the name of that ending?

[@libraric7212]

Kaiser Dragon idr

[@GarryDumblowski]

TrainingWarriorRule WooHoo Was it one of the "Ib All Alone" endings or the two bad endings added for failing toe doll room under specific circumstances? ("A Painting's Demise" and "Welcome to the World of Guertena")

[@SinonSnipars]

Does anyone realize how good of a storyline Ib has? Seriously, if projected correctly, this would be an epic anime full of tragedy and action.

[@AnimeTheVampire]

- Bursts into tears while trying to sing the lyrics -

[@transmaniax2204]

*me and mary teleport next to you,giggling*

[@AnimeTheVampire]

- Looks at you with a surprised expression on my face -

[@transmaniax2204]

Miku Hatsune *Mary and I start dancing to insanity and it plays* Gary:can this get any worse?

[@AnimeTheVampire]

- Looks at Garry and sweatdrops -

[@transmaniax2204]

Miku Hatsune Me:what? Gary:*knocks self out with frying pan* Mary:CMON LIA DANCE! Me:FINEEE*we resume on dancing but this time ot caramelldansen*

[@beatricemonari8239]

Ib is not a simple game. Ib is Art. Ib is Love. Ib is Life.❤

[@dkapawoxuwny2787]

exactly the same way i feel about it :3

[@beatricemonari8239]

Anikó Szabó Yay :3

[@Mafu_Chiu00]

You're right :')

[@getgoodgetserious7699]

Lets say both touhou and IB are an art

[@U-nagi]

Ibの世界観って本当に幻想的で綺麗……

[@ForeverDreamExcape]

Oh my god guys, THIS IS NOT AN ANIME, and this SONG IS NOT FROM THE GAME! PLEASE STOP ASKING Please guys, just READ the damn Credits OR Descrption!! i appreciate and love you guys, and I dont mean to sound rude about this, but literally these are the two question comments i get the most and its getting uber annoying And THANK YOU to the ones who ACTUALLY looked at the description or credits before asking me the same two things and THANK YOU to those who went out of your way and ANSWERED those people who keep asking! Because i dont have the patience to do so, so i really appreciate ya'lls help!

[@ChaosChild1]

***** Personally im a huge fan of ib and was aware its not a anime nor is this song in it (It does sound like something that would be in it though. since it's setting) So. Without even looking at the credits or description I knew what was going on XD

[@majestic5127]

***** So... Is this a manga?

[@izzydiamond6879]

Incubator Kyuubey no its a game the pictures are just fan made

[@majestic5127]

Izzy Diamond You know... I wasn't serious.

[@izzydiamond6879]

Oh

[@raiii2030]

I cried just seeing Garry's Forgotten Portrait ;-;

[@machaontopii]

Same here...

[@user-im6tr7wf2e]

Me to...

[@user-zw2ip3xv6l]

すごいです！イラストに曲が合いすぎて泣きそうになりました…本当に感動して言葉もでないです。 ギャリーさんイケメソすぐる

[@xunniehan]

This is how I sing : MAYBE *SOB SOB* IT'S A *SOB* DREAM MAYBE *SOB* NOTHING ELSE IS *BURSTS OUT CRYING* ERMAHGAWD GARRY WHYYYYY DID YOU HAVE TO DIEEEEE?!?!

[@summerseason4925]

Wait..... Garry did not die....

[@i-am-the-niece-of-satan5886]

+Summer Season he does in one of the endings

[@thaodinh04041977]

THE FEELLLLLLLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

[@natennysecondchannel4110]

+iAkane meh, i never liked him that much...

[@goldenwolf5809]

Maybe bc it's not the good ending?

[@XxXShadowJaneXxX]

I cried when I saw Mary and Gary painting together...I just CAN'T TAKE THE FEELS

[@MaryLikesRoses]

You know what? I made my user name and didn't acknowledge the fact that it relates to Ib, one of my favorite games. lol oops.

[@TrashScoutMain]

*read's your username* First Thoughts: Mary Kill's Garry *WHY MARY!?* (Ib), Red, Blue and Yellow Rose's (Ib) ♪Red Like Rose's♪ (RWBY). Ruby disappearing out of thin air like an ender man except it's rose petals and not purple shiny floaty particle thingy's...(RWBY) *wibbly wobbly timey wimey.. stuff* Nice Username... Mary.... XD

[@kirapark3934]

So basically, you're saying that Ruby (RWBY) bursts into rose petals because that's her semblance. Yes, I watch that animation.

[@arn3107]

@@TrashScoutMain wha

[@TrashScoutMain]

@@arn3107 no idea man. I was 14 when I wrote that lmao.

[@arn3107]

@@TrashScoutMain lol you actually replied

[@TheHgy789]

THERE NEEDS TO BE AN ANIME OF THIS WTH THIS MUSIC AS THE OP AND I WANT IT NOW D:

[@TheSavvyWolf]

YAAASSSS

[@fizziecola]

I actually think there could be a live action movie for this, depending on whether the story is executed correctly, and they're careful about who would act this out, Japanese and English, along with other characters. I wouldn't mind it one bit, as long as it's accurate to the gameplay, so extra dialogue that would make sense would work out, also. (Talking to Garry under the sun and in the safe room fifty times wouldn't work out as well with the same questions and answers.) It'll be like the Phoenix Wright movie, depending on how well they stick to the story. I liked it, and it was one of the few movies that stuck to a video game's story. It was a really long game, so they only focused on the last case in the game, but Ib's short enough to be put into a average sized movie.

[@fizziecola]

***** I was saying that Ib is short enough to make a live-action film, depending on whether it would be executed correctly. (Japanese and English). If it stuck to the dialogue, and still made the characters lifelike and loveable as they are now, then it would work, plus the effects and things like that.

[@Bendingofair]

***** Yeah.I agree.

[@GarryDumblowski]

No one cares that I just posted a link to an WIP Ib anime.

[@lowcrystal4516]

sighs satisfactorily* The music and lyrics really suit this game and it tells like, a story of what Ib been through, what Garry felt and how Mary is alone. I feel bad for all three of them, its like, such a tragedy that only two will come out of the other world...

[@PhoenixFalcarius2024]

Good times with this game. It should get released for the Switch like Mad Father.

[@personwithbadenglish8469]

Is that even gonna happen?

[@PhoenixFalcarius2024]

@@personwithbadenglish8469 Probably never or maybe someday. Would be awesome if RPG horror games get console ports. Like how Mad Father got remastered.

[@personwithbadenglish8469]

@@PhoenixFalcarius2024 i hope someday they're gonna add in remastered with more endings ;-;

[@frydraws5619]

Sounds like a song I would listen to when I'm sleeping

[@raiiku360]

Same here

[@PresidentFunnyValentine]

joie del rosario I did it already :D

[@themurituri99]

Me too Lovi♥~

[@frydraws5619]

:D

[@mentlegen12321]

yeah the song is chill enough :)

[@rachelfranklin3469]

For some reason a lot of the images made me sad. It's either "Poor Mary!" or "Poor Garry!" or "D'aww that's cute!" But I love Ib and the music box version of this song, so thanks for making it I guess

[@itsabeaan1776]

Please tell me that im not the only one that thinks that Garys hair looks looks like a purple tomato

[@a.m.3412]

You aren't the only one lol

[@gloveinabox2248]

WHY WOULD YOU SAY THAT THAT'S ALL I'LL BE ABLE TO THINK ABOUT NOW WHEN I SEE HIS HAIR

[@itsabeaan1776]

Kagome Coco oml, I'm crying from laughter

[@demomotized5548]

Snooby Nooby I think two things. And upside down rose, and a fecking spider on his head

[@zzvnil]

WHY WHY FOR ALL THESE YEARS WHY ISN'T IB AN ANIME YET IT WOULD HAVE BEEN THE NO.1 ANIME

[@shutupaeryn]

eh, maybe. I think it would make a pretty good short series (like 12-14 episodes) and then there would be an Ova series showing the different endings, the last ova episode would be the all alone ending. *Shivers

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

YESS why isnt it an anime yet?? Like...It would make a PERFECT anime. I i think it should be like 17-20 Episodes long. Since it IS a pretty long game.

[@learose989]

Well... Someone (I forget who) did make a 3 part anima manga off it, but it isn't really the best thing ever... It's still good tho...

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

+Neko Noble Wow, Bravo with that name. Thats actually a pretty good name! Bravo!

[@LunaWitcher]

If I make a playlist with this single video repeated 300 times, will it count as 300 favorites? Because this is just too perfect. I wanna sing it!

[@luna092012ab]

I sang it 2 my friends and they thought I was crazy. IDC bout that, it's 2 beautiful 4 mean comments!

[@memo9]

ib is such an amazing game and this song fits it so perfectly

[@xchara6996]

Ohh dang the memories,,

[@StarlightChann]

This could make a great lullaby....

[@squidymeares]

They need to make this game a anime

[@ao1chan763]

Oh my freaking god this would be so epic

[@squidymeares]

Dark Angel IKR!? they made Kantai Collection an Anime

[@ao1chan763]

Yep

[@jasongu508]

+Grady Meares (ShadowBlade) They never even made Touhou Project (where the original Bad Apple came from) an official anime, what makes you think they will for these games?

[@dkapawoxuwny2787]

meh, they won't. and it wouldn't feel that epic to watch it, it's more exciting if you play it

[@deadnamewilson1058]

I cant stop singing it! Its too good a stress releiver!!!!!

[@TheFloatingDryad]

This just turned up back in my recommended and OH MY GOSH THE NOSTALGIA

[@Gremlynnie]

I Broke the replay button

[@thaodinh04041977]

WOW ;_; That's so sad.

[@Gremlynnie]

Kathy Trinh Yes :c xD

[@thaodinh04041977]

Lyna Gucci .R.I.P. Reply Button,I will never forget you.... Wait,who's grave is this? #BadMemory

[@Gremlynnie]

Kathy Trinh xD

[@thaodinh04041977]

Lyna Gucci​​ :3

[@lilianna9486]

The most recent comments are from 5 years ago and I’m just here to say NOSTALGIA

[@manahria]

YES

[@stellaluvs861]

I'm REALLY REALLY hoping they make Ib an anime, or at least make another RPG Horror Game of Ib. And love the work ya done on this, it goes with this.

[@jeanjaille1062]

They made a remake :)

[@hydrogeddonn]

GREAT pairing of the song's emotion and the story of Ib and the feelings and personalities of the characters.

[@oreocookie8048]

only 367,364 views?! i watched it more times then that!

[@imvolga1123]

Now 1.6M

[@HezrouDhiaga]

Wish they'd make a ending where all three get out xD Otherwise, i'll continue to throw Mary under the bus for Garry!

[@akitahonda1615]

i hate mary. >:( when i first met her, all that was going through my head was, "i can't trust her. i can't trust her. i can't trust her." i don't know what was with her that i didn't like about her, but i couldn't trust her. then when i read the page about mary being one of the paintings, i was like, 0O0 ................... I FUCKING KNEW IT!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@HezrouDhiaga]

Akita Honda Yeah, I felt the same way lol But I am curious to a good ending for all.

[@nixcleon6970]

There are a few animations out there with a good ending for all three. I originally hated Mary, but now I kind of like her because if you think about it, being trapped in a gallery as the only fully functional and human-like painting would probably be lonely. And if you found out you could get out by replacing someone else, would you do it? I mean, I personally probably wouldn't, but at the same time, I might be driven mad by isolation. I know I'm 4 years late with this bullcrap but it's whatever, you know?

[@sagefurry]

Bravo, no seriously, bravo

[@sibillalorenzon9904]

Sure,😃😃

[@jeniffermarreroortiz2231]

9

[@user-oi8zq8jf5g]

RPGmaker years are some of the best moments i've ever enjoyed

[@clinicalobsession616]

Ah, Bad Apple. My my second favourite song from Touhou Lotus Land Story. Oh wait- this isn't a Touhou video.

[@lindsey1675]

I mean, I do love Ib, but people need to get a clue this is from Touhou.

[@Cloudrunner78]

Ib is by far one of my most favorite games that I've played, and even though I've beaten it many a times, there's just something about it that makes me want to keep coming back and play again... I think it's Gary. XD

[@TheFloatingDryad]

That is so sad.....so mary is an actual human who got sucked into a painting and her dad remembered her and forgotten her and she just wants to get home and she doesn't know her father is dead......SO SAD!!!!!!!!

[@auraicarus]

the book says the painting of mary isnt based off a real person and mary is a painting that just wants to see the real world but cant without one person from the real world dying in guertena's world so she could take their place

[@TheFloatingDryad]

Lee-on Adroit And her flower is the colour of jealousy but who is she jealous of

[@auraicarus]

shes jealous of garry because he manages to get ib to care for him and be with him however she wants to be with ib

[@Arando-bs8mp]

I wish there was a way to get Garry Mary and Ib a good ending but unfortunately there's not.

[@TheFloatingDryad]

Brittney Humphrey Gary marries Ib and Mary is Ibs sister?

[@nagijuu]

I feel bad for Mary, but at the same time I didn't want Gary to die so... I just wish all three of them could've left together.

[@oreocookie8048]

well they are making a new one for the green room were you all leave but theirs one were ib kills herself and garry and mary go to the real world...

[@10101Blues]

omg thanks so much I have been looking for this song for about a year

[@akitahonda1615]

i think this song deeply resembles this game. i personally think that this song is terrifyingly accurate to the plot of the game. i like it, i love it~!

[@eos7054]

This song goes well with Ib. EXAMPLE Can you tell me who you are- Ib and Garry forgetting about eachother Can you tell me where I am- Mary Going into the real world Cause I'd throw it all away and it all will fade to black- It is the fact that Ib may want to stay in the parallel gallery.

[@sorenlover9957]

Bad Apple is one of my favorite songs and Ib is one of my favorite games making this AWESOME!!!!

[@animelover3083]

*hugs* ah im in tears, i hope everyone can find solace in life even tougth it can seem like your just a pawn. even if you are it dosent even mater. your video was pure art i was listening to this while painting.

[@t0mjuice]

(clicks on video) Ima check the comments. (arguements) oh. (drinks tea) ill just... sit back and watch.

[@crowsandshinythings9713]

Same. Ah, the KZbin comments section.

[@t0mjuice]

+The Sketch They all hate each other.

[@crowsandshinythings9713]

+FuelledByMemes V.11037 Yup

[@maryguertena2325]

Should I stay, or should I go? I've forgotten how to tell. Did I ever even know?

[@trangtrantrinh6575]

how much times have I replayed this lol I have listened to this since 2013

[@deadnamewilson1058]

I cant stop singing it, its too good a stress releiver!!!!!!!

[@hatevil8165]

I want a music box with this music...I WANT IT SO MUCH

[@ecooper122896]

Lina Utahime AAH SO DO I DDDDX

[@melodyrider]

KZbin really needs a love button...

[@arcanonymous9603]

This is just beautiful...... I wish I had an actual music box that played this......

[@justme5390]

Its like a poem that if you sing what is written in the video is... so perfect!

[@MysticalLala]

This song isnt from Ib for those who want to know. Its from Touhou Project Lotus Land Story. Look it up please Thank you

[@user-qh7lz8dg2g]

東方とIbとか… 最高かwww

[@AwkwardEspeon]

really this is so awesome! thank you for making that!

[@sleeplessstreetsandwich1770]

iVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS FOR SO LONG JESUS

[@agatherzl1382]

J'aime vraiment cette musique, elle est trop mignonne

[@Htlucy]

Ever on and on i continue circling with nothing but my hate in a carousel of agony Till slowly i forget and my heart starts vanishing and suddenly i see that i can't break free I'm slipping through the cracks of a dark eternity With nothing but my pain and the paralyzing agony To tell me who i am, who i was Uncertainty enveloping my mind Till i can't break free, And maybe it's a dream; maybe nothing else is real But it wouldn't mean a thing if i told you how i feel i'm so tired of all the pain, Of the misery in side And i wish that i could live feeling nothing but that night You can tell me what to say; you can tell me where to go but i doubt that i would care, and my heart would never know if i make another move there'll be no more turning back because everything will change and and it all will fade to black Will tomorrow ever come? will i make it through the night? will there ever be a place for the broken in the light? Am i hurting? am i sad? should i stay or should i go? i've forgotten how to how to tell. Did i even ever know? Can i take another step? i've done everything i can all the people that i see, i will never understand If i find a way to change, if i step into the light then i'll never be the same, and it all will fade to white Ever on and on i continue circling with nothing but my hate in a carousel of agony Till slowly i forget and my heart starts vanishing and suddenly i see that i can't break free I'm slipping through the cracks of a dark eternity With nothing but my pain and the paralyzing agony To tell me who i am, who i was Uncertainty enveloping my mind Till i can't break free, And maybe it's a dream; maybe nothing else is real But it wouldn't mean a thing if i told you how i feel i'm so tired of all the pain, Of the misery in side And i wish that i could live feeling nothing but that night You can tell me what to say; you can tell me where to go but i doubt that i would care, and my heart would never know if i make another move there'll be no more turning back because everything will change and and it all will fade to black if i make another move, if i take another step, then it would all fall apart, there'd be nothing of me left if i'm crying in the wind, if i'm crying in the night will there ever be a way? will my heart return to white? Can you tell me who you are? Can you tell me where i am? i've forgotten how to see; i forgotten if i can if i opened up my eyes there'd be no more going back 'Cause i'd throw it all away, and it all would fade to black AGHHH!!!!! i just notice that there was lyrics in the dep!!!!!! what the hell have i been spending my time for then?!! TT__TT ugh... whatever.. i'll just post it anyway..

[@Femwar7]

Phantastic fanarts :3

[@AnimeLoverGirl0]

at first i was like ok then it seemed like i got hypnotized. when the video stopped i realized that was a great song game and video being combined.

[@Violet343]

I have played this game five times and have gotten the "memory crannies" ending all five times XD but I love this game and I will continue to try to get the good ending :D

[@Violet343]

Well apparently you need to talk to Garry 6 times on both of the breaks you get but I didn't realize that. I also picked completely different dialogue choices the second time around and still got the same ending.

[@Ajaljayn4]

Because you didn't have the option to give the handkerchief when Garry was wounded in the hand. Because you don't have enough Bond points with Garry. You should follow those earlier replies for you to get high bond points :) the handkerchief will lead you to the good ending "Promise of Reunion".( u still need to go with Garry at the fake mother and painting frame part)

[@mimilolkins7123]

I'm going to try and get the Together Forever ending, though I'm probably going to punch myself a lot since I like Garry so much *punch* ...there's one..keep count

[@Violet343]

Oh yeah there is nothing worse than actually trying to get rid of a like able main character

[@Violet343]

Oh yeah there is nothing worse than actually trying to get rid of a like able main character

[@acaciad9232]

Why is this not an anime yet?!?! it would be sooooo good

[@inkvampyr]

I know right? !?

[@MiniFlightlessBird]

Singing along to this is so fun, but that octave drop is KILLING ME. Also, I love the pictures you put to it. Ib is so good. This is a perfect video. :D

[@saraharnold7687]

I still love listening to this! It's been months since I first watched this! I still do and always will love this song. So touching and beautiful.

[@Miku-qy4gq]

Wtf No one here really knows that Bad Apple is originally from Touhou 4: Lotus Land Story from 1998

[@PUI0]

Yeah it is litterly from PC-98 Elle’s theme

[@TreeHugger598]

Ik i late but yes

[@splotcho]

If you’ll kindly notice, asshole, the creator said that it wasn’t from in, they just used in oictires

[@harui]

To all Ib players, which one of you obtained the happy ending??? I obtained the happy ending in my first game. Garry and Ib survived and they remember each other :D (Sorry for Spoils)

[@cherylwang8904]

B-b-but, Mary...no, no happy ending for her! NO HAPPY ENDING FOR HER! NOT FAIR! NOT FAIR FOR MARY! WAAHHH TToTT

[@jkd6247]

Yes I have , and have you ever gotten to the dungeon?

[@harui]

jul kd yes I have but when I tried the two dungeon I got the ending called "Memory Crannies" and I always start a new game but I always get the "Memory Crannies" ending I only got Promises of Reunion once.

[@transmaniax2204]

Len Kagamine :/ *teleports in front of him with mary..as we have demon wings* mary:you guys had better thought twice before burning me..hehe..Me:*sings puppet as I take out two butcher knives,laughing insanely*

[@siewannielow7547]

Sorry who can told me this is what anime

[@yinyang6911]

i LOVE THIS VERSION OF THE SONG, THAT IS SO AMAZING!!!!!

[@user-qs7bu8gs4o]

Ive been listening to this song for months now n im still not tired of listening to it :D

[@ingtapoot]

I love this game and I love this video, but I must ask, why is there a seaweed growth on Gary's head? Why did the developer of the game think that was a good plan? xD

[@sapphirewolf4031]

It's not a seaweed growth. XD A common theory, likely to be true, is that Garry's hairstyle is supposed to look like a purple rose upside down (combo of blue and red). The "seaweed" just helps that effect

[@ingtapoot]

Sapphirewolf oooooh thank you!

[@sapphirewolf4031]

Lindsey Kimball No problem. Glad to clear things up!

[@dkapawoxuwny2787]

+Sapphirewolf oh my god i never tought about this before xD

[@BattlePugCrydamoure]

HEY!!.. HEAH HAY! Everyone, this is from touhou

[@sorasuzu]

There was something about this that made me cry and gave me goosebumps....Well done!

[@superyu818]

The song is very touching.I love this very much.You made a great video.

[@kibakigaming]

Am I the only one that sings along?

[@fenriswolf7819]

***** This isn't the singer... this doesn't even have words.

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

Just saying this....But....Stop shipping Ib and Garry. Garry is 16-18. Ib is 9-10. Its just doesnt make any sense shipping them. And for those who didnt know, Ib is a RPG maker game, not an anime, its not based off of an anime either. If those who read the description, thank you. But please, if you dont know whst some music/video is about, then read the description. There should be an answer. Thank you for reading this.

[@shuskiewonderland6721]

JojiKumao JOJO Ib is like 12-14 and age doesnt matter 😄

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

If it is in Japan it doesnt matter ;) Shuskie Wonderland *****

[@ghosster56]

lol i found that ib is either 8-9 snd garry 19-20 soooo yeah lol

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

Tendō Satori Alright lol

[@makinru6178]

HelpMeIAm Dying Well. Degenerates.

[@abbywampler804]

that was lovely and the tune is really pretty and the lyrics fit the music so I can sing it.

[@omegalul2062]

2 years later, this is still on my playlist and I love it.

[@lantranphuong9727]

2020??

[@-xzxzxzs--]

2021

[@lantranphuong9727]

@@-xzxzxzs-- 2022

[@-xzxzxzs--]

@@lantranphuong9727 2023?

[@lantranphuong9727]

@@-xzxzxzs-- 3033

[@-xzxzxzs--]

@@lantranphuong9727 4023?

[@NotAllCatsAreNice]

Hey the Eridan's Are watching you :::;)

[@sofievalenzuela5514]

Homestucks in 3...2...1...

[@NotAllCatsAreNice]

Sofie Valenzuela its an inside joke 8etween foreverdreamexcape and I ::::)

[@ForeverDreamExcape]

wow i literally just saw this comment XD also jordan just found one eridan hidden in the game room behind the curtain above the window!!! XDDDD it was so great, best long-term prank evvvvvvvver! on another note, the one we hid in the bathroom under the door and been ripped up D:

[@HelixAbyss]

Yesss... *shivers* mannequins are terrifying, and it's the heads that make them that way, even if it's just the heads on their own.

[@amphibiousgirly]

I seriously LOVE this! It makes me cry!!!!

[@diamondtiara2062]

From Touhou? Thought it sounded familiar. It's pretty addicting to listen to ^^

[@TreeHugger598]

yes :)

[@syazwinasuhaimi7461]

Who else singing the entire song throughout the video? 😆

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

Me ^^

[@animebrogaming8162]

Hakubi Okumura me!!!!😃

[@auraa411]

Me X3

[@trashman6996]

AAHHHH I FOUND THIS VIDEO AGAIN ITS BEEN SO LONG SDFDKJJF

[@namelessmask]

Awesome video! Ib is a very good RPG. I love it!

[@Violetstrike]

Anyone else think that Gary looks like Xerxes Break from Pandora Hearts?

[@xxxsp00kyg1rlxxx6]

57 dislikes.... I will find them. And I will make them like this.

[@cathytheanimatroniccat9346]

Oh wow

[@watashishinasai7942]

It's already 63 and I think there will be more in the future...so looks like your wanted list went up

[@dustinthecynicalassoholicb3621]

Shoving something not their interest down their throats... everyone has to like it 'cause you liked it? Hey, I didn't dislike the video, but your comment was pretty harsh.

[@IgnazioMozzarella]

Kira Lovelin Perhaps people are mad that Touhou wasn't mentioned in the description at all.

[@joycloud9487]

ME TO THAY WILL PAY

[@Pup_Mango_VOD]

there has been 6 years and i still remember all the lyrics perfectly

[@supercala17]

Rainy mood... The thunder fits in at the right times. (:

[@benwoods4178]

Ib needs an anime

[@AngelKittyKagamine]

[@terinahook4646]

This was the best vid even if it was just the pictures and the lyrics cause the pics really suit it so well made whoever did this vid >.< LOL

[@RenatoRibeiroMAker]

The awesomeness met the epicness!

[@lilip8987]

Anyone ships Ib and Garry?? 0日0~♥︎

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

+Setsuna Oh my god u again??? Or am i just imagining things again??

[@nev6086]

JojiKumao JOJO LEROLEROLERO~

[@sbgsbgkaafafksfs5537]

NOOOO Setsuna

[@chuckgizater1868]

Bunnie 977 do not lewd the loli

[@Kururu265]

Nivedha S. Krishnaraj was that a motherfucking jojo's reference Wryyyy

[@jeremyfitzgerald8140]

explanes me...

[@saraharnold7687]

I have watched it way more than seven times! Truly a touching video.

[@hercrystal02]

OMYGOD THIS SONG FITS SO PERFECT WITH THIS GAME!

[@Linkydinky00]

I came here to see an old rp in the comments and I come back to see arguments. Filthy animals.

[@lillyyoung2454]

Yeah same here.

[@MONOJKL]

OH MY GOD ITS NOT FROM ANIME ITS FROM TOUHOU -p9uh8n-rvushr^09vjhn-UHBNe-9uh0fauh

[@156coolflame651plays]

Well if you're interested in this song. It is called Bad Apple. It is a theme song from a game called Touhou. It not from Ib or whatever it's called.

[@jigokuai273]

ThankYou +ForeverDreamExcape So much