THE HUNT FOR GOLLUM - (Redux) Tolkien Fan Film

[@RileyDia]

This fan film is about to get a lot of well deserved attention 🔥🔥

[@JulieMoran1832]

Enjoy it while you can … I’m willing to bet it will be taken down soon.

[@2ChainZsensai]

@@JulieMoran1832 WB just tried it and get embarassed themselves kkkk what a joke.

[@stevenblankenship9814]

I was so surprised to see how old this is being the new movie is about just this. It's very well done 👍 I hope it blows up too these people deserve credit for their work

[@mvaughn75601]

All I can say is... WOW !!!

[@owenjenkinsofficial]

Yes, I just found it. Very interested.

[@acolyte06312]

This film is so accurate to the novel. They did such a good job, especially considering how this is fan made. Also I love Aragorn just stuffed Gollum in a sack

[@IndependentOnlineCinema]

We’re so glad you enjoyed the film. Thanks for the kind words.

[@visionist7]

@@IndependentOnlineCinema my only question is, how does Aragorn feed & water Gollum in tbe sack 😁 Also what happens when Gollum needs to take a dump 👻

[@IndependentOnlineCinema]

​@@visionist7 we shot a deleted scene showing how Gollum was fed (in the BTS kzbin.info/www/bejne/pIbHln1padNgabM). But I don't think we can comment on the other questions... ;-)

[@123munter]

@@visionist7 you answered both questions yourself hehe

[@roberthousedorfii1743]

I'll answer. Let him poop in the sack. throw the sack in a river. Let him thrash about for 30 minutes or so. muahahaha *POOF* Clean Gollum, clean sack. is that so hard to figure out? he sure didn't give G TP as needed...

[@robertlukacs4954]

The acting in this is very good for a fan film.

[@iceicejay9569]

this acting was good better then most modern actors

[@LisaAnn777]

Yeah I can't believe I have not seen this. Why isn't it more popular?

[@Astroviking_]

Wow Thanks to these guys who made this I love it!

[@sapphirevilya]

Way better, It is leagues better than Amazon's billion dollar series.

[@ChrisCloudStaringAtFire]

@@LisaAnn777 Original upload got 13 million views. This is the redux

[@williamtear1319]

When you see things like that made by fans and with a low budget, you can't but wonder how the big studios with so many means at their disposal fail to make a good, enjoyable movie. Well done to all that worked for this movie.

[@one_man_community]

Imagine what these guys could do with a big budget and IMAX.

[@jaroslaval9159]

Agreed!!

[@Liamnerfdude1]

Rpm Nothing better then what they did here..It's not that easy..You saw this with star Wars theory's fan film..It sucked..

[@pbluma]

@@KZbinTookMyNickname.WhyNot wow what a useless analogy.

[@einarabelc5]

Become complete morons like the rest of Hollywood, such is human nature. Necessity is the mother of creativity and invention. Wonder why Hollywood is just all CGI and rehashed garbage now? There's your answer: big budget and IMAX.

[@einarabelc5]

@@pbluma Insecurity.

[@theerkenbrand1358]

Here after the announcement of a new film with Gollum as the main character, also titled _Hunt for Gollum._ Andy Serkis is set to direct and reprise his role.

[@brandocalrissian3294]

Without Viggo as aragorn it's gonna suck.

[@Tahnee-69]

They try to get rid of this one... Saying that it's copyright 😅😂🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😂..

[@Tahnee-69]

​@@brandocalrissian3294 they are way too old... And he's at the age of Helms where he's 87...

[@kennytheawkwarddonut9137]

​@@Tahnee-69they actually removed it already, said it was an accident, and then revoked their copyright claim to let it appear online again.

[@JCO2002]

Bigger budget, poorer quality. This had love - the next one will be all about making money.

[@Eyelohim]

No words can describe how much of a masterpiece this is, for a low budget movie. The atmospheric ambience and background are so good made. Hats off.

[@MrMrCJulez]

german?

[@thestarkknightreturns]

Whenever I revisit the Lord of the Rings Trilogy, I also re-watch this movie, alongside "Born of Hope" and now "Horn of Gondor". That's a testament to how well made this movie is. It's part of my personal Tolkien cinematic canon.

[@egor.cleric]

Thank you, man

[@rechannel864]

The best

[@willu842]

Wow thank you for those name drops. Had no idea they existed.

[@thestarkknightreturns]

@@willu842 I aim to please my friend. By the way, did you know that an actual "Hunt for Gollum" movie is coming out in theatres in 2026?

[@willu842]

@@thestarkknightreturns Yes, looking forward to it!

[@matteopinamonti1867]

I watched it again after many years, and it's still so beutifull in its simplicity. No overly ambitious epicness, as little CGI as possible, only good acting and a focused narrative on a compelling story. The "sack trick" is simply brilliant ;) it avoids having too many close-up shots of Gollum, it fits the narrative and its still very expressive. The sack and Aragorn have more chemistry on screen that many hollywood actors XD

[@Tk421Clone]

The way they worked around showing Gollum and saving money on the CGI was really good. As someone who has some experience film making this was really well done. I truly believed the actor who played Aragorn was Aragorn the same as in the Peter Jackson movies.

[@ComedyBros5]

That's exactly what I thought. Adrian Webster was top-notch as Aragorn...the voice, the look, the stoic-ness. The soundtrack was phenomenal as well

[@oliverstrid4545]

the acting is good, the fight scenes were over my expectation. hats off!

[@Kobra39]

I do hope that Peter Jackson takes notice of this. Maximum effort with minimal assets. I am impressed. You definitely deserve a larger budget.

[@archi4226]

That was basically was he did, on a larger scale of course. if whoever made this ever read it, great one btw

[@Oscareuh]

@carny do you mean that in a negative or positive connotation?

[@Kobra39]

@@Oscareuh Positive. I am praising this fanfilm and everyone working on this.

[@Oscareuh]

@@Kobra39 no I know. I meant positive or negative about Peter Jackson. “Take notice” as in learn from or “take notice” as in becomes aware that it exists?

[@Kobra39]

@@Oscareuh I see now. The latter. 😊

[@MR_THINQ]

I can guarantee that this didn’t cost 500 million. It’s not about the amount of money, it’s about the passion and love of the franchise - this proves that fans should be involved in the making of hollywoods movies. WELL DONE.

[@draigygoch]

Make a ' fall of Gondolin' now that would be epic..and expensive!

[@johnk5398]

I expect that a primary storyline for the new Lord of the Rings Amazon series will likely be The Rise and Fall of Numenor, I think the fall of Numenor is far more epic than that of Gondolin.

[@fucheduck]

impossible. too. you don't make movies like this anymore! the hate is too strong from mainstreamers!

[@fucheduck]

@@johnk5398 amazon "originals" PAH! another Hollywood censor!

[@davegrenier1160]

When I read the complete story of the battle for Gondolin, I thought, "This should have been integrated into the Silmarillion." Christopher T. probably thought it would have been too much to integrate large parts of the story of Gondolin, or Turin, or the Lay of Leithian into the Silmarillion, but he underestimated the fans' appetite for his father's works. The Silmarillion twice as long still would have been too short.

[@pepebabushki9376]

@@fucheduck don't know why you included quotation marks, anything you make is original unless it's plagiarised. Yes, they're amazon originals.

[@Wanderlust598]

I loved this. Movie makers of LOTR have a gem on their hands, if they only just follow the spirit of Tolkien's writings and remain as close as possible to the letter of it.

[@giulioaprati338]

We need more middle earth movies

[@Greetling]

wait for that series.

[@fucheduck]

not Hollywood insipidness either!

[@Greetling]

@@fucheduck pointless hollywood bashing....

[@pepebabushki9376]

After the hobbit.... Idk lol

[@petergould406]

I just saw this one: The Horn of Gondor. It was shorter but very well done kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYeppYaLhtJgoLM

[@mariaravandiel1209]

well done! I love how he just stuffs gollum back in that bag and slings him over his shoulder. The orcs look so realistic!

[@Covarr]

You got someone who, on the face of it, neither looks nor sounds like Viggo Mortensen, but his acting is so good and so on-point that I instantly recognized him and didn't even think about it while I was watching. You got composers who are not Howard Shore, but they captured his style so well that if I didn't know better I would've thought it was him. The writing, the acting, the cinematography, the direction... all of it comes together so absolutely perfectly! Amazing job to everyone who worked on this!

[@lakobe24captain]

How in all that is holy is this better than ROP. Bravo!

[@Sionnach1601]

That was REALLY excellent!!! Far, far surpassed my expectations of an amateur film. Very well-shot and well-directed, the two most important aspects of ANY film. This is something which is sorely missing in many a high-budget film. Excellent acting, costume, makeup, set design, LIGHTING was really lovely too. Also excellent choice of scene locations - really wonderful to see so much of the wilderness scenery which is quite lacking in the big-budget films. Apart from pure entertainment value, it was nice to see some of the detail of the Rangers and Aragorn's travels in the Wild. So all-round, my highest salutations to everyone involved and thank you SO very much for gifting us with this.

[@caseynorman20xx]

The casting is spot on. Be proud of this.

[@historyholic9528]

This short movie is far more better than whole RINGS OF POWER SEASON… good work

[@eliezersalazar4361]

FREAKING BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!! Aragorn’s casting was just incredible! I’m glued! MOREEEE!!!

[@Pedro8k]

If I had not known I would have thought this was an official short story the quality is so good well done

[@JesusFriedChrist]

5 minutes and I already think they did a good job recasting 12 minutes in and I’m impressed with prosthetics and costume

[@Autisticguywithacamera]

Man, this and Born of Hope were made back in the golden age of KZbin. You don't see as many of these kinds of films made anymore.

[@Brembelia]

This is a fan production? Amazing. Awesome job, guys. Triple A+.

[@burnedsmackdown4209]

This feels so right as it feels like it is connected to the films and the actors here acted like the film's ones so well and even looked similar enough to them

[@daviddjerf2856]

Amazing for a non-profit film! I even enjoyed this more than the last two Hobbit movies.

[@fucheduck]

that is because if it were for profit they'd have to go by some insipidly lain "guidelines" and it isn't done today. maybe in 1987, maybe in 2040, not today.

[@janminiajluk3964]

'Course you did! It was made by Bagginses, not some blockheaded Bracegirdles from Hardbottle.

[@pepebabushki9376]

@@fucheduck bruh, what "guidelines" did the hobbit movies follow? "use more cgi"?

[@grunztiertransmutator770]

@@pepebabushki9376 "do more Legolas stuntystuff!"

[@nickolausafon5458]

I wish the Hobbit was a two-part movie totally about 5 hours more than 3 movies with too much filler jibe. The scenes could be downright awful. I think the fighting was too drawn, it had to be shorter if they did want that "Dwarf-Elf glory" drama. Nice as it was but way too excess.

[@Batmandu25]

5000 £ budget and yet far better than any 100 mil $ Rings of Power episode… thank you for this lesson

[@woufff_]

That was awesome, very well done indeed. Strange that as an old Tolkien fan and YT addict, I never came accross this video until now...

[@Enerdhil]

I know what you mean. I only found out about it because someone posted a link to it on a comment board.

[@BulgyBoar]

I only found out today that this existed - why is it not more widely publicised? Tremendous stuff - kudos to all concerned!

[@zacharybackauskas6645]

What a wonderful way to bring some of the context for The Lord of The Rings to visual media. It was exciting to see a new piece of film from Tolkien's universe after so long. I can't believe I didn't find this sooner. Thank you and amazing job!

[@elboxeo403]

Give these men an Amazon contract FFS. Great job

[@imsokage]

Halfway through I forgot I was watching a fan film, this was done extremely well. Congratulations!

[@aquaterrafootage9547]

This was excellent. In the Peter Jackson movie Gandalf says “I looked everywhere for the creature Gollum , but the enemy found him first”. I forget how it happened in the book

[@TheArcticSpartan]

I what happened in the book? Sorry I dont have time to watch this whole video but I'm really curious

[@mx_klsk]

As Gandalf said, the enemy got ahead of them. Aragorn and Legolas couldn't catch him in time

[@Minzalin]

Gollum strayed into Mordor and got caught there.

[@jonesjones6279]

@@TheArcticSpartan Gollum was captured and tortured for info about the ring in Mordor, he is released (I think), Aragorn tracks him and captures him, Aragorn takes him to Mirkwood, and while being held by the elves escapes when orcs attack or something to that nature. Sorry it isn't super specific, but it's been so long since I read the books. Then the next time he is seen is when the Fellowship goes through Moria like in the movies.

[@orlandoacosta2631]

Gollum was left under the guard of the Mirkwood elves after Aragorn captured hi. But Mirwood was attacked by the orcs of Mordor and Gollum got away during the scuffle

[@readdescriptionforanaughty3344]

As someone who grew up watching Peter Jackson's directors cut edition over 30 times, this film was great!! I love the idea of capturing all middle earth lore that the movies just couldn't add.

[@milanliam9979]

Why the hell does it only have 11000 views, it's an amazing movie!

[@darthkek1953]

It took the web by storm a decade ago. This version has few views as it's a new uploaded with some cleaning-up of fx and sound.

[@mikimiyazaki]

If i wish it to surpass the number of views, then ill make it so, but for now. "YOU SHALL NOT PASS 11,000 VIEEEEWS!!"

[@Segegerstadt]

As stated, "redux" means "remade". This film was well known and appreciated a long time ago. Its story is appealing to veterans. It clears out lots of why's. Aragorn, for example, as a decendant of "the Dunedain" has magical powers. When he in this film lays flat with an ear to the ground he can hear approaching enemies. Fine things like that was missed and forgotten in Peter's saga.

[@ginnymoore5652]

According to the epilogue, this film has at least 10 million views, so it may be only that this particular post has so few.

[@zaandarbrow]

cuz if it aint a reaction video it dont get views but damn this was amazing for fan made!

[@priscilaundomiel3264]

You are the ones who should make all the Tolkien's projects! Amazing guys! ❤️ 😍 I'm so happy to watch this movie!

[@CaptainFalc0nPunch]

Found this unexpectedly, as a long time LOTR fan, this is great! Even though it has different actors(for obvious reasons) it feels like the same universe in writing and visually! Great work!

[@johnt.inscrutable1545]

It’s still as good as it was when first made a decade earlier. I like the additions that help bring the story back to the fellowship. Thank you again, Yours in Middle Earth, InscrutableJohn

[@MrAaronmatthew]

Throughly enjoyed. This actually honors the source material. Bravo.

[@paulalexander2928]

Of Scots heritage and a Celt at heart the Trilogy touches my heart. May we all find our way to the Isles of the Blessed and dwell forever in peace.

[@rubenskiii]

This is litteraly "Lord of The Rings At Home" but damn it is actually really good. Glad to see that WB understood taking down this movie just shows they only care about money and not the fans. Glad i can see this movie on KZbin again. Warm greetings from the Netherlands🇳🇱.

[@omicroneridani7456]

I' m glad I've found this. Appreciable, to say the least. This Aragorn, what's more, looks very very credible!

[@mictaylor9531]

That was more watchable than the entire first season of the rings of power!

[@deviandrianto]

this fan movie a great. thanks for making this ❤

[@mfelix3511]

This was fantastic! The best fan film I have ever seen by far.

[@joeatkinson9321]

The fight scene in the woods was so good! Very impressed with the film overall

[@danm3573]

The production quality here is amazing

[@feanorian21maglor38]

Amazing movie, I've watched it many times and always surprised at how a great film can be made even with a tiny budget, when lots of hard work and love goes into the project.

[@Sol_Invictus-]

To me what made the LOTR movies so good , was that it was a slow burn with beautiful music , felt like nothing was rushed.... Which is why after seeing the Amazon series trailer I was disappointed . You guys did a fantastic job , thank you.

[@LemonyTang]

amazing, fair play o everyone involved. thoroughly enjoyable.

[@comeondown12345]

99% sure this is better than the upcoming WB movie remaking this film

[@davidguerra9163]

People said that for lotr and it turned to be the best movie in cinema history…

[@jwebber1667]

Wow imagine if WB decided to make this exact movie with Andy Serkis directing it !!!

[@davegrenier1160]

The locations are terrific (congrats to the location scout) and the atmosphere of gloom and of a gathering threat was really very well realized.

[@Truesight333]

Wow blows me away how the stories continue thus,awesomeness

[@CINEPR]

I remember watching the original versión when release in 2009. After the announcement of the new movie with the same title I comeback to rewatch this classic.

[@jamescombridgeart]

Wonderful. You can feel the love for the source material

[@FlishaMcArenington]

This. This is the real Strider.

[@johnk5398]

I think a really good interpretation of Hurin could be done with a modest budget.

[@VPortho]

The Children of Hurin would be so amazing put to film

[@jorislemoine1488]

I'd love to see it done, but considering Túrin's tale requires so many strong actors (Túrin, his mother, his sister, Thingol & Melian, Beleg Strongbow, the petty dwarf Mîm, Gwindor, Orodreth, Finduilas...), and takes place in so many stunning settings (Dor-lómin, Menegroth (!), Nargothrond, Amon Obel, Amon Rûdh, the Springs of Ivrin...), it would be quite impossible to do it on the cheap.

[@CaptainFirebolt]

Wow! Just incredible work, I absolutely loved it. So true to the lore of the LotR. It was awesome to see Strider's tracking abilities and how he is able to see things. The Orcs looked straight out of the movie, hats off to the wardrobe and makeup dept. Just brilliant work all around. I am so glad I got to see this fan film!

[@Enerdhil]

I totally agree. I am shocked that not even one of the dozen or so Tolkien KZbinrs I subscribe to has ever mentioned this film.

[@johnord684]

Way better than what Amazons fan fiction series will be ,at least this is made with love.

[@desenhoerpg]

Totally.

[@AzraelCaptain]

This comment aged far too well.

[@Starchilddancer14]

This is so creative!! Loved it! The part with Aragorn carrying Gollum in the sack honestly had me doubled over laughing at times.

[@chrislee3861]

This was so well done. Can’t believe I’ve never taken the time to watch it until now.

[@rachieocho]

Wow, this is truly amazing! Y'all should be so proud of yourselves for creating such an epic depiction of the literature. Great job!

[@coldmoonlight6361]

I'd be absolutely STOKED if this were made into an entire series of films. And with a bigger budget? Who knows how far that would go, it would be incredible 😊 But for real, only having(what I've read...) 3-5k as your budget? This is extremely well done. Actors, setting and CGI scenery, not to mention it's other uses, make-up, costumes, etc 👍 You all did a fantastic job 🤘☺

[@RorytheRomulan]

*Aragorn looks into Galadriel's mirror* Gandalf in the Shire: "I looked everywhere for the creature Gollum" Aragorn: "Dude...!" I think the Gollum-talk could have done with a redraft. He could have become more intense and expressive of his anger when reliving his memories of Bilbo and losing the Ring. The smile makes him seem self-aware of his villainy, as though he has an advantage or knows something other people don't, but at that moment he has no advantage at all. He has to stalk the Fellowship and just hope to find the ringbearer isolated. He can't gloat until he's given the task of leading the ringbearer into a trap. A twisted hateful grimace would have fit better. And the CGI was painful. Orc costumes and makeup were well done! Not sure if the fight scene would survive an autopsy, and I think Aragorn could have used a partner to believably take on a roving band of orcs. That other ranger, or Glorfindel, or even Legolas, who seemed to act as though he met Aragorn before the council at Rivendell, in the movie. Enjoyable regardless. Hats off to everyone involved!

[@jasonnicholasschwarz7788]

I watched the LOTR movies on DVD while living in Ypres in Flanders. At that time I was very deep into WW1 and practically lived 90% of my life in the past, immersing myself in all the horrors and incredible stories of that war. I wrote two screenplays during that time, both set in WW1 in and around Ypres. It was very fascinating to watch (and later also read) Tolkien's work against the backdrop of the Great War which imo inspired him a lot when he wrote the novels. I even sent the scripts to Wingnut Films, not really expecting any feed-back. However, they got back to me, but only to tell me that Peter's agenda was full for the next decade or so:( But to even get an answer alone was just amazing. I sent another war-related script to Richard Attenborough (he was still alive back then) and was told that it had been received. Not much later, unfortunately, his PA ran off with half of the scripts and stuff she was working on ( I never got her name, I only spoke to his secretary on the phone) and they couldnt get hold of her. :( I tried to produce a short version or teaser myself, but couldn't raise the funds and kind of tried to forget about the whole project. So, seeing what you were able to do here on nothing much more than a shoestring is really mindblowing and gets me thinking...

[@bigbattleslittleworlds]

An awesome job, first class for a low budget and so accurate to Tolkien's work.

[@auntlynnonline6206]

Wow! Just outstanding work! Thank you so much for this. 🥰

[@user-mt4zr5kp7h]

@GeeksandGamers sent me looking for this after they announced the original one, which has been up for 15 years or so, and garnered something like 13 million views, was copyright-striked by Warner Bros Because someone else had their idea before they did. Thanks for uploading it again! So very well done!

[@radiohostalastor]

They didn’t reupload it

[@radiohostalastor]

WB just removed the copy strike due to all the hate they’re getting claiming it was striked due to an “error”

[@user-mt4zr5kp7h]

@@radiohostalastor oh awesome! I thought it was a reupload since it said redux lol

[@markgregorygacosta531]

typical WB! If their new LOTR movie gets any hint of wokeness or pondering, I'm see myself out.

[@rumeysayazar1049]

Never heard of this movie until I saw the news WB removed it. I just watched and quite liked it. Think it's more succesfull than not only ROP but also the entire Hobbit trilogy. Thanks to everyone involved in this beautiful production. Felt like i was in the Middle Earth one more time.

[@jaroslaval9159]

Wow! What a gorgeous actor to portray Aragorn and so well played! Completely believable! I would love to see him in more films!

[@Asgard2208]

Gotta say: well done! A lot of this stuff can be a bit 'awkward', but I thought they did this really well.

[@iceicejay9569]

Tisms I call Tisms. Voice acting: Solid Acting: Solid Costumes: Solid Story: Could have been better but at least we got a Aragorn LSD trip nice throwback of Frodos LSD trip.

[@samwallaceart288]

Tisms you say? You speak as one of them

[@iceicejay9569]

@@samwallaceart288 indeed I follow the longman

[@samwallaceart288]

@@iceicejay9569 May the Don smile on you

[@MoonlightDawnMoolightDawn]

Rewatched this 3 times recently -- I so love this fan film!

[@guillaumezendjebil7143]

I guess, if I ever wrote books, that I'd love indie prodction to make them!! Not a lot of money instead of Hollywood prodtions, but it is amazing :D I really love Tolkien and HP fan communitie!! You're the best and keep the lore living :D

[@margaretalbrecht4650]

Aragorn describing his journey with Gollum, "Nothing more did I ever get from his mouth than the marks of his teeth. I deemed it the worst part of all my journey, the road back, watching him day and night, making him walk before me with a halter on his neck, gagged, until he was tamed by lack of drink and food, driving him ever towards Mirkwood."

[@Davymac55]

A truly epic fanfilm that doesnt disappoint..sits well as a link from Hobbit to LORT. everything you want and left me wanting more..annoyed i hadnt seen before now .. great acting script scenery soundtrack and done with volunteers and no budget..amazing

[@sandracarlson7986]

Brilliant movie!! Music would make Howard Shore smile. Always helpful to have a ranger on your side. MORE PLEASE!!!

[@OstfrieslandFilmStudio]

Verry, verry nice work! You got my honorable respect for this!

[@pedroibanez8013]

BRAVO!!! Amazing job... Who says that 1B can be better that love for Tolkien eternal creation...

[@einarabelc5]

Reminds me of Central and Eastern European movies where they replaced "resources" with creativity and writing. The Gollum in the sack idea is great! Inveitably followed by the sword's hilt and the boot.

[@Xevos701]

27:18 This portrayal of Arwen looks so beautiful. I can definetely see why Aragorn fell for her :D

[@VARAKIENEN]

Surprisingly good. BRAVO.

[@JannikPitt]

I am really looking forward to see this masterpiece in this improved version again!

[@jebby0606]

It's truly incredible, what a difference you see when there is love behind the work, unlike Rings of Power... this ... this is beautiful

[@andrewporter3118]

Just disvovering these fan films. Wow, just wow. Jeff should have given you the billion dollars, as i already enjoyed this more than Rings of Power. Perfect storyline for a short.

[@oldkefka]

Well time to watch this before Warner remove it

[@tomcazzaniga9768]

Wow, from a LOTR fan huge thanks for such an amazing work! Very good casting, photography, music, fight choreography were amazing and in service of a nice plot.. Really impressive!

[@lobearden5723]

This is absolutely amazing.

[@sandracarlson7986]

The Nazgul scream sends chills down my spine. When I first saw The Nine leave the black gate I was spooked. Black hooded caped riders on black horses what could be better. Really enjoyed this movie. Thank you.

[@aaronstone8147]

Really good cinematography!

[@aaronstone8147]

Score and sound is excellent as well.

[@aaronstone8147]

Happy with the casting too!

[@jrk9372]

Outstanding. I really enjoyed the way the it was played out. Coming from a long time LOR tragic. Keep it going.

[@Sophia.]

A definite improvement over your first one, even if you cut only small bits, they were the right ones, I think! Thank you for the repost :)

[@Theelby33]

My imagination loves middle earth more than anything that has ever been put to paper and screen. I,for one would love a tolkien universe of the first and second ages put to screen. Thank you, JRR Tolkien sir, for the hrs days months and years i have had with your secondary world. Also, congrats on making this. It's so well done and very good.

[@Dorkyorcy]

A very well made fan film, very impressive guys, thanks!

[@benmarino1913]

The Score is GREAT!!! Enjoyed this very much! Well done!

[@HomespunWisdom]

Well, that was certainly a loving dedication to Peter Jackson's LOTR trilogy. I wonder what they could have created if they weren't paying an homage to another director's style of filmmaking but rather created an original vision as inspired by the author and the literature. Great job on the music!

[@GullibleTarget]

That would be great. I was actually quite disappointed when Del Toro pulled outof the hobbit movies. I was looking forward to a non-Jackson Middle Earth. But I'm not complaining with what we did get.