Intro to Dan Brubaker’s 20 Qur’anic Corrections - Quranic Corrections Episode 1

These talks are to help Christians who are working with Muslims, and to help Muslims deal with some of the problems with their foundations.
This particular series concerns the Qur’an, and whether it has been perfectly preserved. Back in 2014 Jay did a debate with Dr Shabir Ally in Toronto where he introduced from the front a number of corrections out of a total of 800 which had been found by Dr Dan Brubaker and included in his doctoral thesis.
Since that time that debate has been watched by over 500,000, and Muslims have responded by saying that Jay couldn’t be trusted because he doesn’t speak Arabic. That is why Al Fadi has joined with Jay in this series, as he is an Arab from Saudi Arabia, speaks not only modern standard Arabic, but speaks and works in Qur’anic Arabic, and is doing his doctoral research in this area of research concerning the earliest Qur’anic manuscripts.
Muslims have claimed that these corrections are nothing more than simple dialectical differences, or different readings, popularly known as
‘Ahruf’, or ‘Qira’at’.
Al Fadi quickly dispels this notion, noting that the corrections which we are referring to have nothing to do with dialectical differences, or differences with how someone might read it. These differences are consonantal differences, in other words, they are changes to the actual written text, known as ‘Rasm’ in Arabic. More about this will be explained later on in other episodes.
Muslims make 4 claims about their Arabic Qur’an:
1) It is un-created, or eternal (Surah 85:22)
2) It was sent down to one man, Muhammad in 22 years
3) It was compiled completely by Uthman in 652 AD
4) It has never changed in the last 1400 years
Jay and Al Fadi can’t confront the first two claims, but they can and plan to confront the last two claims, that it was compiled completely in 652 AD, and has never changed since that time.
Thus, they are asking 3 simple things of Muslims…to show them one complete manuscript of the Qur’an (114 Surahs), from the time of Uthman
(652 AD), which is unchanged (i.e. which corresponds exactly with our current 1924 ‘Hafs’ text).
What they are asking, and what they are doing is simply known as Textual Criticism, a test which every sacred or historical book has to pass (and the Qur’an, like the Bible is both). This is the same text which the Bible had to undergo back in the 1800s, but has passed with ‘flying colors’.
What’s more, no Christian would make the claim about their Bible that Muslims are now making about their Qur’an. We would never suggest that our Bible is eternal, nor uncreated, nor that it was sent down from heaven to one man (inspired by God, yes, but not ‘sent down’). We would, however, claim that the Bible was complete in its original form, and though we admit there have been changes in the Bible since the first century, we would be clear that what we have today, because of the enormous manuscript and textual trove at our disposal today, is pretty much 99.9% the same as that which was written down in the first century AD.
So, join us as we delve into the last two claims by Muslims concerning their Qur’an, and try to ascertain whether their Qur’an can be traced textually back to the time of Muhammad, or even Uthman, and whether the Qur’an they have today is exactly the same that which we can find in the earliest Qur’anic manuscripts; or whether, indeed, the Qur’an has been corrected or not over the intervening 1400 years.
Follow CIRA International:
Facebook: / cirainternational
Website: www.cirainternational.com
Support Al Fadi:
Patreon: / cirainternational

[@phillip0537]

Excellent as usual Al Fadi and Jay Smith. I am really looking forward to the rest of this series. Al Fadi, it was a pleasure and honor to meet you in person. For those who haven't met him, Al Fadi is kind, funny, and genuinely humble. Keep up the great work brother.

[@CIRAInternational]

Phillip 053 the honor was mine brother. I’ll connect with you soon.

[@aaronstaley8323]

So excited about this new series!!!

[@handayaranggen6220]

Hoping many muslims will interest to see your both discussion to every episode. Thanks for this program bro Al Fadi and Jay Smith. JCBU

[@solomonroasthead7914]

They are pitiful two children in a very pitiful state of kidding. ( 73 ) And indeed, they were about to tempt you away from that which We revealed to you in order to [make] you invent about Us something else; and then they would have taken you as a friend. ( 30 ) Thus have We sent you to a community before which [other] communities have passed on so you might recite to them that which We revealed to you, while they disbelieve in the Most Merciful. Say, "He is my Lord; there is no deity except Him. Upon Him I rely, and to Him is my return." ( 13 ) He has ordained for you of religion what He enjoined upon Noah and that which We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], and what We enjoined upon Abraham and Moses and Jesus - to establish the religion and not be divided therein. Difficult for those who associate others with Allah is that to which you invite them. Allah chooses for Himself whom He wills and guides to Himself whoever turns back [to Him].

[@hannanpakthini7221]

@Ardian ... Much more bible experts now deny the same bible. Read the comment here itself.

[@TheIlhanTheElequent_ishaq]

Jesus wasn't murdered he got Saved by Allah I’m sorry but can you please stop this utter garbage! You sound very disgusting fr🤮

[@TheIlhanTheElequent_ishaq]

Jesus wasn't murdered he got Saved by Allah do you even know what Christian means? Or your basing your knowledge on mere assumptions or what you have been told.

[@adamelmasery7723]

Great Discussion. Thanks God Bless you and all those that share to produce this work.

[@edwardarnautovic6948]

Cant wait for the next episode! Thanks brother Al Fadi. Gbu

[@tiongr]

As a muslim by birth I've been questioning Qur'an since my childhood from translations. I found so many contradictions and confusing things which I don't understand it. Thanks to Al Fadi, Jay Smith and CP for enlightening thing that muslims and scholars always fail to make me understand. At least I start to understand the concept of Christianity which it's important for muslims to do too for the sake of peace and tolerance.

[@CIRAInternational]

Thank you for your transparency and genuineness... where are you so far in terms of following Christ? let us know if we can be of help... if you prefer, we can communicate privately! Blessings. ~ Al Fadi

[@edwardarnautovic6948]

Islam is a scam

[@Stratcatblue]

Uthman admitted that most of the early Quranic writings were destroyed, eaten by Aisha's goat. Also, Muhammad plagiarized previous man-made writings, claiming they were devine revelations given him through the angel Gabriel. Google search and see why all of these stories written by humans are in the Quran and deemed to be from Allah. The seven sleepers Surah Al-Kahf 9-26 was written by a bishop in the 2nd century. Stories written in the 3rd century by Egyptian author called "The infancy gospel" and none of these stories ever existed in the true Bible. Sura 21: 51-71 the Moshnah passage is found in Rabbah Genesis, Sura:22-26 & 23: 50 are from "the gospel of pseudo Matthew," and various extracts from the Bible.

[@Stratcatblue]

@Qui Creva Sp Thanks to the information age, the fastest breeding religion is now the world's fastest shrinking religion. If you look in the comment sections below Christian Prince, David Wood, The masked Arab, Apostate prophet, and others, ex-muslims are turning out in record numbers as the hard evidence is getting out to millions of people. It's going to get worse for Islam as the army of well informed videomakers and bloggers continue to grow and as technology increases.

[@barbaroslisboa8706]

You are not Muslim you pretending to be Muslim there are no flaws in the Quran and translations can be varies in different languages but Quran is unchanged will be protected from any kind of corruption last 1400 years more intellectual people then liar atheist fadiand liar jay smith they tried their level best to prove Quran has error but they are failed will and never be successful.because Quranwas a oral revealation millions of people memorised it by heart we can bring it original even all the manuscript of Quran destroyed.the Christian they don’t have bible manuscript what they say copy 2,3,4,5 bring the manuscript bible written by different authors they corrupted the word god by their own hands.there are no manuscript of bible even from 1st or 2nd century.

[@courag1]

I am so glad beyond words to see you both joining together in this work. Excellent!

[@identification133]

I am grateful t you for passing your findings and knowledge to us. You bring on people who have great insight like yourself. Thank you and God bless.

[@jamestom2510]

Just found you guys... Love it. Just subscribed. Fantastic.

[@alfredomontealegre7132]

I am so glad this important series is being broadcast to dispel the misinformation spread by Muslims unchallenged for way too long. It's high time these fallacies were put to rest.

[@daviddick1435]

Thank you both for your courage and integrity.

[@livingwaters6828]

This is creating more curiosity than "Game of Thrones" , just cant wait to see whats coming next. Gob Bless

[@imexbd]

they are making you fool. i sympathy for your innocence

[@michaelconners8426]

Al-Fadi, God reaches certain people with unique credentials to do specific work for His glory.

[@CIRAInternational]

Michael Conners Amen...

[@hashimadenomar5611]

Alffadi is a sell out idiot who bought his faith for worldly pleasure

[@falkenauge4.0ace8]

@@hashimadenomar5611 He has eternal life :) the truth has set him free.

[@lorenzochimelis7359]

I strongly suggest you lovers of hate you sho have historically demonstrated a prejudice that has prolific in the creation of race znd religious hatred you have your your creativity to uniquely create segregation .... Jim Crow.... black. Codes .... the klu klux klan ....apartheid on South Africa ... and .....antisemitism one ☝️ of the many proofs for the destruction of the Christian version of Jesus as NOT a prophet .. NOT messiah and certainly and indisputably NOT God should know the latest victims of your hatred and intolerance will not stand by idly beading the brunt of your hate based propaganda . Dan Brubacers book is merely an effort created to feed the hunger of the intolerance that has historically Defined you But alas oh stokers of the fires of hell that will over cook you his book is garbage . Reviews are already combing out by his peers trashing the book mercilessly .... I strongly suggest you read a long review in fact of one of his Contemporaries at the university of Chicago a certain Dr. HYTHEM SIDKY a professor of molecular engineering and Quranic studies who’s specialty is the. Compilation of Quran and Arabic QURANIC GRAMAR his review is dramatic and scathing in relation to REICH minister of Christian nazi propaganda heir Dan brubockers book . He points to the negligence in relation to The Reich ministers lapses in Quranic Arabic as well weak assumptions based on no-trail Of a consistent patterns that substantiate his assumptions not to mention that he admits scribal errors while also admitting that cu h things are wide spread in all text of the ancient world while seeing that in the case of the Quran unlike the Bible scribal errors were not done to create an introduced aspect of personal theology like that of which is pandemic in the Bible that the expected scribal mistakes cid not change the theological beliefs or standards of creed that remain.Consistent in Islam the errors had no effect on meaning or message . So basically it’s just another hate drug fix for the Christians who fight now are getting ravaged by Judaic biblical scholarship on the criminality of the new excrement in tampering . changing , misinterpreting , mistranslating text foment tanahk to create a Christian theological narrative that simply does not exist within tanahk because tanahk by its nature luscious statement and mission was created with the mandate to reject.. refute ...and dismiss and expose all things of idolatry and all things therefore theologically Christian worry deeply about that and stop gorging yourselves on the futility of criticizing Islam take my advice

[@AustinOKeeffe]

If Muslims believe that the Quran is eternal, that is has always been there, written by Allah since the beginning of time, surely the fact that 'Allah' had to intervene to defend Mohammed in the Quran proves that it cannot be eternal.

[@paulaboukhaled813]

Very good show. Very impressed with the contents of the show.

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

I have Dr. Brubakers book! It will be good to be able to follow along with explainations! Jesus bless you both, and Dr. Brubaker also!

[@kafirlindaclark6148]

@luck pon you mean like a PDF? I don't know. The book has only been out for maybe 2 or 3 weeks. It is not expensive either. Amazon Books carries it. There may be a Kindle version.

[@paagalwalla9535]

@Shamoun An Here you are again trolling Sam Shamoun, who is as strong a Christian as anyone else you will find. Why such desperation?

[@benjisailo5476]

@Shamoun An thanks...Go to hell with your family

[@benjisailo5476]

@Shamoun An thanks...Go to hell with your family

[@davidford15]

"I’m ex-Christian" Who do you think Jesus was?

[@charlestee5656]

God bless you brothers for the wisdom shared.

[@ihaka439]

Looking forward to it 😁👍

[@user-ex9pc9ps8x]

Corrected: Dear Dr. Jay Smith, thank you very much for the clearification, which was told the same by Professor to me to change last name to have better future in 2016 in New Zealand. It opened new doors, changed my personality. I changed my last name from DADAMUKHAMEDOV (GRANDFATHER MUKHAMMAD) to AZIMOV. It impacted my acceptance to the western world with good intention.

[@flawedandbeautiful4166]

It's been a really long time since I've received notifications for your channel, I had started to wonder if you had stopped putting out videos. I'm going to have to check your channel from now on since you tube doesn't seem to think I should

[@CIRAInternational]

Flawed and Beautiful that’s strange... we have been publishing videos nonstop once per week... you may want to check your Notification setup

[@EgzonNikqiFB]

These two combined are the strongest duo Islam has ever faced..

[@timothytmusgrove]

Yes, very important work that you are doing. The Muslim world is in desperate need of the Truth. May God open up their hearts and minds to the Gospel of Jesus Christ.

[@nykwarti]

Huh? The gospel of Jesus was written 100s of years after he died. The people who wrote it were not his disciples and did not even meet Jesus. Please get off your high horse. By the way, jesus is dead lie all humans.

[@dyarbaker5374]

you so called yourself christine honestly you are fooling yourself , quran the word of alllaah what so ever you do islam gets stronger

[@dyarbaker5374]

peter keller in your dream to find mistakes or difference . . this is your wishful thinking just dream on it . to let you know the religion to allaah islam JESUS peace be up on him he is muslim . and for you claim give one single proof ?

[@imexbd]

Both are international lair.They are playing with foolish like you.god bless you

[@imexbd]

@Peter Keller it is easy to convince foolish like you.you are just great keyword worrier.

Congratulations on the new series wonderful to see the giants of Christian apologetics together.

[@bplhtlkkrzlf]

Al Fadi is a blessing. If you are able to then support him!

[@hindusthaniprophitprophit9530]

God bless you all fadi and jay

[@steviedfromtheflyovercount4739]

Interesting topic. I have studied, superficially, the textual criticism of the New Testament ...... fantastic area of history to study.

[@elye3701]

In this age of the new Covid religion, you two are the happiest people on this planet.

[@wn555]

Hi bro Al Fadi, I just would like to ask regarding Birmingham Quran (supposed the earliest quran, but contains only 2 folios). Does the manuscript contain the word “islam”, “muslim” or “muhammad”?

[@ajayiwale5595]

great job guys

[@peter.t.ljungman]

al-Fadi and Jay Smith delivers another lecture with solid and well documented facts.

[@lovepeople951]

God bless you.

[@thecranesthatintercede7570]

God bless you brothers.

[@nizaralyamani6773]

Dear brothers, Authenticity of Quran does not come from transcripts. It comes from hundreds of thousands of memorisers who preserved it through the fifteen centuries, passed from Muhammad(pbuh) till date. Sorry that this was not done to the holy book. But Allah preserved the holy book by including it in Quran. Toraat of Jewish brothers in the Suras' from 2 to 9. Injeel of Christian brothers in Suras' from 10 to 50. God bless all.

[@albertvanzyl4407]

S 40 53. We gave Moses guidance, and made the Children of Israel inherit the Scripture. 54. A guide and a reminder for those endowed with reason. S 2 87. We gave Moses the Scripture, and sent a succession of messengers after him. And We gave Jesus son of Mary the clear proofs, and We supported him with the Holy Spirit. Is it that whenever a messenger comes to you with anything your souls do not desire, you grew arrogant, calling some impostors, and killing others?

[@ExploreTanakh24]

if Muslims really believe in true Monotheism and are against Shirk, then they have to reject the idea that the Qur'an is divine and not co-eternal. Not only is it shirk, also when they say the Shahadah. Muhammad is NOT a Holy Prophet.

[@hmdjama]

You are better off eating your pork..stay away from debates concerning religion. Your ignorance is astounding

[@9jaForce]

CIRA studio is beautiful though.

[@markeden767]

2 great men 1 great conversation

[@skellingtonmeteoryballoon]

Awesome 😊 shalom 💖

[@solotrue45]

Hi Mr. Fadi, in terms of embryology, I have read Galen's work. It can be found by searing "AW Meyer Essays on History of Embryology Part 2". This was written by A.W. Meyer in 1932, Professor of Medicine at Standford School of Medicine. He was an embryologist and anatomist. If you look at the above essay, go to section "Viewpoints of Galen", 3rd paragraph: you will see Galen's 4 stages of embryology: 1. Geniture- the conceptus was white like semen; 2. Second stage- became a fetus without brain, liver or heart, 3. No name to this stage, but brain/liver/heart/external features formed, 4. Peur: prenatal- all organs formed and joints movable-this is late stage. This does not match with Quran stages @ 23.12-14.

[@CIRAInternational]

Solo True when did I block you? It is obvious we are interacting right now? Where you here under a different name before? I have a team and I can check with them... so which name were you under when you thought we blocked you? And when?

[@CIRAInternational]

Solo True I agree that the Quran borrowed this from Galen’s... we have a very detailed work done on this topic on the answering-Islam.org website.

[@solotrue45]

@@CIRAInternational I guess this is a private conversation, but it does not match, nothing matches with Galen. Galen never postulated that bones (Izam) occurs before muscles/flesh (Laham). In book Julia Boghner (Embryologist, The Developmental Approach to Human Embryology) , signaling of bone development occurs before muscles. Also, Galen's first stage is white like semen, in Quran it is leech and blood clot (Aqalah). That website that you referred is bogus. You can cover your ears and eyes brother, but you will be called to account by God.

[@CIRAInternational]

Solo True I suggest you do a video about it... as far as we are concerned, the evidences support the Galen’s theory... however, you are free to disagree...

[@pfanderfilms]

Solo True, is there some reason that you are trying to move the discussion away from the historical problems with the Qur'an, which this video is about, and on to the scientific problems with your holy book? Is the discussion in the video above too difficult for you to answer, and thus this feeble attempt to change the subject?

[@ganteng_ini_menyiksa]

God bless you. Greetings from Indonesia

[@jahangiralam8184]

Dear Dr. Brubaker, Sir, I am amazed by your wonderful lecture on the lacking of the Quran. I have always considered this book as a godly book, as taught by my parents and teachers. But various youtube discussions made by traditional belief thin. and I started doubting. But still I could not arrive at a decision. I was scared to read the original religious books which were too lengthy and difficult to understand. And I could not find the solution. In such a situation, a friend of mine gave me a book on Quran, well, its title was, Knowledge of Quran for the non-Muslims". It was a very small book, hardly 125 page or so and published by the Amazon.com. It was written by an Indian author, and the language used was extremely suitable for me. From the very beginning, the author told against religions, and in favor of atheism. Then he narrated why religions were created by the money hungry people. And it narrated various ways for doing the same. Then, it narrated those in case of Muslim's religion. And everything including why regimental type of five times prayer was introduced, how it in fact targeted to conquire the world in the name of a religion etc. turned crystal clear to me. The book helped me to understand numerous unsolved and difficultly answered questions about the Quran. Now when you say, the names of Allah was later added, many lines were erased and changed etc., I understand the reasons, because I now understand there was nothing miraculous or godly, but were the creations of the shrewd selfish-minded people. Thank you Sir, for your great mission. I wish your success.

[@danijelakelava6602]

I am a christian. Our bible is indeed a very ancient holy text. I do believe, that the bible is the revealed holy Word of god.

[@aemiliadelroba4022]

I have read Dan Brubaker book , His theory has flaws . I recommend ppl to read his book and decide for themselves. We can not just assume anything. his argument has flaws .

[@SomethingSophie]

Fantastic video Al Fadi and Jay Smith! PS: Answering-Islam.org like many other websites that question Islam are blocked from some countries so people don’t research the truth.

[@chesedsozo7840]

Love you, Al Fadi!

[@drittenberry1]

Thank you ✝️🇺🇸

[@amitkohan12]

Keep up the good work of sharing that truth.

[@ZaydDepaor]

Two excited people who have just established their lack of understand and their ignorance, proceed now to elaborate their faulty foundations and understanding to further solidify own their errors.

[@Marta-zm8oe]

I wish Christians approached the holy Jewish and Christian books as they approach the Quran

[@donovanburton2091]

Hey alfadi. I like your videos

[@pr7049]

According hadiths over 70% of Quran letters were lost even before Uthman.

[@alfredomontealegre7132]

Bukhari himself admits that he discarded most of the stories as unreliable.

[@RGRaj_1977]

@@alfredomontealegre7132 But some reciters were killed in battle & whole chapters were lost. That narration is there in the hadiths.

[@raymonddsilva2948]

Good debate David

[@BrianScottGameNight]

@Cira International please recommend a Quran translation for English.

[@wildernessofzinn17]

Thanks to many scholars like Jay and Dan Gibson, we are now finding out that proto-Islam originated from a form of Judaizing Christianity known as Ebionitism. There is a book out on the origins of Islam, but unfortunately, it is only in French for now. I hope it soon gets translated into English. Emmet Scott talks about it in his book, "The Impact of Islam". Here is an article about the book I mentioned: www.culturewars.com/2018/Gardinerreview.htm

[@digitalunotaryeastorangenj3639]

HELLO, I AM A MUSLIM AND HAVE DONE, AND CONTINUE TO DO INTENSIVE STUDY ON ALL RELIGIONS PRIMARILY, CHRISTIANITY AND ISLAM. I CAM ACROSS YOUR BOOK AND VIDEOS AND I HAVE MANY QUESTIONS. YOU SAY THE MANUSCRIPTS HAVE BEEN CORRECTED HOWEVER, THIS I DON’T FULLY AGREE THAT THIS IN ESSENCE MEANS THE QURAN HAS BEEN CHANGED. I WAS BORN IN DOMINICAN REPUBLIC AND RAISED IN THE US. I WAS RAISED AS A CHRISTIAN BUT I WILL GET BACK TO THAT IN A SECOND, I JUST WANTED TO PUT THAT OUT THERE SO MY OPINION WOULDN’T SEEM BIAS. I HAVE BEEN MUSLIM FOR A YEAR AND LEARNED ARABIC TO BE ABLE TO READ QURAN IN IT’S ORGINAL TONGUE. UNTIL THIS DAY, SOMETIMES WHEN I AM RECITING THE QURAN I ACCIDENTLY TAKE SOME WORDS FROM ONE VERSE AND RECITE IT IN THE WRONG VERSE. MY QUESTION IS, HOW CAN YOU SAY WITH CERTANTY THAT THIS DID NOT OCCUR TO THE SCRIBE WHO WROTE THE MANUSCRIPT? HOW CAN YOU SAY WITH CERTAINTY THAT THE INK DID NOT PASS THROUGH THE SCROLL AND NEEDED TO BE ERASED? I HIGHLIGHTED BY BIBLE EARLIER AND IT MARKED THROUGH TO THE NEXT PAGE…… SO I WOULD LIKE ANSWERS TO THESE QUESTIONS BECAUSE YOUR CLAIM STILL TO ME DOES NOT PROVE THAT THE QURAN WAS CHANGED IN IT’S ENTIRETY, BUT THERE ARE A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF POSSIBILITIES AS TO WHY IT WOULD HAVE BEEN ERASED. YOU CANNOT PROVE WITH CERTAINTY WHO ERASED IT AND WHY, IT COULD HAVE BEEN GENUINE MISTAKES FROM THE SCRIBE. TRY TO REMEMBER THE ENTIRE BIBLE WORD FOR WORD AND WRITING IT DOWN WITHOUT LOOKING AT THE PAPER, AND TELL ME IF YOU OR ANY OF THOSE MEN COMING ONLINE CAN WRITE THE ENTIRE BIBLE, OR IN THE CASE OF AL FARDI SINCE HE CLAIMS TO BE KNOWLEDGEABLE IN THE QURAN, PLEASE WRITE THE ENTIRE BIBLE OR QURAN WITH OUT LOOKING AT IT TO MAKE SURE YOU HAVE NO MISTAKES AND THEN I WILL MYSELF DECLARE THAT YOU ARE TRUTHFUL. THESE ARE PEOPLE WHO MEMORIZED 114 CHAPTERS WITH THOUSANDS OF LETTERS FROM THE TOP OF THEIR HEADS, IF YOU THINK THAT IT IS NOT POSSIBLE TO FORGET OR TO ACCIDENTALLY MIX TWO VERSES THEN PLEASE PRODUCE THE QURAN OR BIBLE YOURSELF WITHOUT CHECKING EITHER BOOK FOR ERRORS. EVEN TILL THIS DAY ANYONE CAN MEMORIZE THE ENTIRE QURAN AND STILL IF YOU ASKED THEM TO RIGHT IT WITH ITS PROPER LETTERS, VOWELS AND EVERY SINGLE DOT IDENTICAL TO IT THEY WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO DO SO. ALSO THESE MEN DID NOT COME FROM AN ADVANCED LITERAL SOCIETY LIKE WE DO, AND EVEN WE COULD NOT DO WHAT THEY DID. SO YOUR CLAIM DOESN’T PROVE MUCH UNTIL MY CLAIMS ARE ANSWERED. I THINK YOU GUYS ARE OVER BOASTING WITHOUT ANALYZING EVERY AND ANY OTHER POSSIBILITIES OTHER THAN THAT IT WAS CHANGED BY MEN INTERVENTION. AND LASTLY, YOU OPENLY ADMIT TO NOT OBTAINING THE ORIGINAL BIBLE, NOONE KNOWS FOR CERTAIN WHO WROTE LUKE, MARK, JOB, 1&2 SAMUEL, HEBREW ETC. YOU CAN ALL AGREE THE BIBLE HAS ANONYMOUS WRITERS. THERE IS NO PROOF OF THE AUTHENTICITY OF THE BIBLE, THE OLDEST MANUSCRIPT IS 500 YEARS OR SO OLD. THE BIBLE HAS THOUSANDS OF INCONSISTENCIES AND IS OPENLY KNOWN THAT IT HAS BEEN CHANGED ON VARIOUS OCCASIONS. HOW CAN YOU SIT HERE SO HAPPY JOLLY AND DOLLY TO FIND SOMETHING THAT STILL DOESN'T DISPROVE THE QURAN WITH CERTAINTY WHEN YOU YOURSELVES ARE NOT EVEN CERTAIN ABOUT WHO EVEN WROTE YOUR BOOK?!?!?!?!?!?!?! MAKE IT MAKE SENSE..... THE HATE OF ISLAM IS SO DEEPLY ROOTED IN YOUR HEARTS THAT YOU WANT TO FIND ANYTHING TO MAKE ISLAM LOOK BAD BECAUSE CHRISTIANS ARE WAKING UP AND SEEING THE TRUTH ABOUT CHRISTIANITY AND THE BIBLE. THE BIBLES WE CONTAIN TODAY ARE LITERALLY MAN MADE, BUT YOU SITTING HERE TRYING TO FIND FLAWS IN ISLAM INSTEAD OF EXPLAINING TO CHRISTIANS WHY THERE ARE SO MANY ERRORS IN YOURS!!!!!!!!!! PLEASE DO RESEARCH ON YOUR RELIGION AND ACKNOWLEDGE THE FAKENESS IN IT AND CORRECT THE MISTAKES AND ADMIT THE BIBLE IS UNAUTHENTIC AS IT'S WRITERS NOR THE WORDS CAN BE PROVEN TO BE REAL..... ADDRESS HOW PAUL NEVER EVEN WROTE A BOOK HE WROTE LETTER TO PEOPLE AND MOST OF THE LETTERS WERE NOT EVEN AUTHENTIC EXCEPT FOR ABOUT 7 OR 8.

[@ZaydDepaor]

If someone sets up a Quran printing press...and makes some mistakes in the printing....does that mean the Quran has changed? No it doesn't, as the Quran is preserved as a whole with its means of preservation. If the original and preserved transmitted text is ACCESSIBLE and existing in other books and in hearts of people....millions of memorizers then obviously the Quran is still preserved. These people don't know the difference between a mus-haf and the Quran itself.

[@dombayrieakwasi3634]

Oh groly bee to God. If we don't go back to the place of prayer we can't navigate through the end time storms

[@jace7190]

Hebrew 11:1 and the whole chapter confirms our absolute faith in Jesus and that’s one of the reasons why we don’t argue with the originality of the Bible. The TRUTH will set us free.

[@aihsanasl]

Sir your opening music is a torture to ears.

[@steviedfromtheflyovercount4739]

Agree. Volume is too loud, with earbuds on. God Bless.

[@maryumbargola5925]

god bless you all

[@solotrue45]

Mr. Fadi, how did the Quran predict the Big bang theory as well as embryology. I can send the verse location if you want. Did Prophet time travel, then?

[@paagalwalla9535]

That's easy to answer. The Qur'an simply borrowed its science from other sources. The Bible predicted the Big Bang and the creation of the universe in Isaiah 55:9; Job 22:12 and Jeremiah 31:37. And the Embryology cycle used in the Qur'an was copied exactly from Galen, a Jewish embryologist, who wrote about the same four stages in the 2nd century, 500 years earlier. Much of the Qur'an is plagiarized, so this comes as no surprise.

[@CIRAInternational]

Solo True so you believe in the “Big bang theory”! I thought Allah spoke things into existence? Amazing... and you really think the Quran talks about the embryonic development with absolute scientific precision without a single error? Ok... here is my advice to you: DON’T make a fool of yourself...

[@solotrue45]

@@paagalwalla9535 Wrong! Wrong! Isaiah 55:9, Job 22:12, and Jeremiah 31:37 only say that the Heavens are high. Nothing about expansion or being cleft asunder when they were joined (Big bang theory). Nothing Greek about this either. Try agin. Maybe Prophet time traveled? I need an answer. In terms of embryology, the 1st microscope was invented by Leeuwenhoek in 1676. I have read a summary of Galens work, nothing close. Show me the text if you are not lying. Again did Prophet time travel???

[@solotrue45]

@@CIRAInternational If you give me permission, I will briefly and succinctly present the evidence. Before I do, "We created the heavens and the earth and all between them in six days, nor did any sense of wariness touch us", @ 50.38. I will await your ok to present the embryology evidence. Thank you sir for reaching out. God bless.

[@paagalwalla9535]

@@solotrue45 The embryological cycle in the Qur'an has nothing to do with a microscope, since Galen speaks of the exact four stages, the zygote, followed by the chewed meat (the Qur'an's alaqa), followed by the bones, and then followed by the flesh. the problem is that Galen made a mistake, as the bones don't precede the flesh, and that mistake in incorporated into the Qur'an, as most modern embryologists now observe.

[@martinopoku368]

I cannot wait for the next episode.

[@dareal575]

MUSIC TO MY EARS :)

[@3laddin]

We understand everything I speak about Muslim who understands Islam correctly ... you see friend people were fighting this religion since it’s down so let them keep there act ... Allah will keep this religion and protect his final book ... we don’t need to replay ... I hope you can do more digging and research then you all will find the truth .. They aim to extinguish God's light with their utterances: [9] but God has willed to spread His light in all its fullness, however hateful this may be to all who deny the truth - Holy Quran 61:8

[@laylarahana6244]

Welcome 🙏 أهلاً وسهلاً

[@mohamadabdullah6360]

Who did the corrections? Did the man who corrected it had the true Quran?

[@onesimosaenz2286]

Driving to work with my coffee and listening to the islamic slayer

[@ZaydDepaor]

It is not 'preserved TABLETS' [alwaah ul mahfoozeen]...but preserved TABLET [Lawhul Mahfooz]....singular...The preseved Table doesn't just contain the QURAN...but also INJEEL, TORAH and ALL EVENTS, MAKHLOOQ etc. And whoever investigates what has been said about this Lawhul Mahfooz in the ahadeeth will be even more convinced that Islam is the truth, due to the amazing information concerning its attributes and was been revealed recently about maximum information storage.

[@ammarhasan9665]

I am not at all suprised with my arabic friend but he forgot to mention the point the quran is not only in written form but also learn by heart by huffaz from the time of prophet till date and its been recited in 5daily prayer and once in a year in ramazan its recited from beginning till end .so how some one changes the book which some has in his mind ? thats why Al faidi and jay is silent and will remain silent on this issue because he can only take a paragaraph from history that suits him not the actual scenario.

[@rekibbora5190]

Totally incorrect information by Dan Gibson on Petra. Petra was a palace, not Holly place. Mentioned in history.

[@friedpickles342]

That's 1 thing that I've always pondered about the trinity. Muslims and Jews deny trinitarian doctrine. But Muslims say Jesus was the rassul (highest form of prophet). Why are you spending all your time trying to destroy Islam when Jews are the real enemy of Jesus?

[@solomonroasthead7914]

( 39 ) Rather, they have denied that which they encompass not in knowledge and whose interpretation has not yet come to them. Thus did those before them deny. Then observe how was the end of the wrongdoers.

[@angelrech3941]

I'm just wondering why if you let muslim read their own resources, they don't like if you tell them about the non sense verses and scary and funny hadith. They said keep it for myself

[@CIRAInternational]

Rech y manongca Valdez thank you for your comments... for now my stance is very simple when it comes to Hadith: it was collected and written down 240 years after Muhammad’s time... as a result, I don’t even care for it since it is nothing more a collection of man... but at some point we will deal with it as necessary.

[@angelrech3941]

@@CIRAInternational I'm living in Arab country and I can how close their mind is. Some don't even don't believe that there are some Muslim woman that marrying non Muslim man. Sometimes if you told them also that this woman converted to Christianity, they will say it's fake. I just feel sad that Christians don't care and not serious about their faith much. But we need people like you brother to be an eye opener, not only to Muslims but Christians too. Specially to those who are in relationship with Muslim that even ready to leave their God in exchange of their bf's. GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS

[@akabilalkhan]

There is no doubt that Quranic dilects are different same as in every language but the context is the same. For example British write Grey and Americans write Gray but the context is the same that they both are talking about the color “Gray”. On the other hand, if you read two different versions of Bible, you gonna find out not only different context but also the different text there. So you better be worried about the book you are following weather that is preserved or not. Muslims recite the Quran in their daily 5 prayers without even looking at it. Millions of them have memorized the Quran by heart so stop menipulate people who does not has enough of the knowledge and start correcting yourself instead of the text.

[@oneandonly753]

Do one edition of Bible too

[@jesussave3220]

Wake up Mohammadians. Thank you brothers in Christ for your hard work your doing, pulling souls from hell.

[@ZaydDepaor]

The Quran has been preserved 100%. The Quran was revealed in seven 'huroof' wordings....and the Arabic text originally did not have nuqtaat [dots] nor harakaat/i'raab [diacritical marks]. This means according to legitimate readings, the voweling of some words can be different according to dialect and WORD change...and the NUQTAAT can change the word....and those wordings are VALID if transmitted as they will conform to what was revealed in the seven readings, there are many ahadeeth about the seven readings. As for MANUSCRIPTS and COPYING....Of course you can find manuscripts with a mistake here and there, but this DOES NOT mean the Quran is not preserved as the Quran is preserved by TAWAATUR, HIFZ and I'JMAA of the SAHAABAH.... that includes the SEVEN READINGS. There is also naskh [aborgation] of text that happened in the lifetime of the Prophet, and that can account for abrogation of verses... But the final naasikh [abrogating] text was preserved by tawaatur, ijmaa and in the mushafs. The Quran was memorized, collected, implemented, transmitted in the life time of the Prophet Muhammad....thousands of companions to HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of tabi'een...and transmitted ORALLY and TEXTUALLY. There are different QIRA'AAT of the Quran that must conform to the seven huroof and that which came by ijma as sahaabah by the U'thmaani mushaf. The Quran is preserved by its recitation, memorization and recitation in the prayer....which has been done publically by millions going back to time of its revelation, multiple chains transmitting from multiple chains. The text is additionally soldified by the books of ahadeeth, the books of Quranic commentary, the science of tajweed, u'loom ul Quran and books of asbaab an nuzool [circumstances if revelation] all that were widely circulated, transmitted and with chains of narration with known narrators. So there are many lines of authentication to the point where loss of Quran is impossible. This NOT THE CASE with the books of the Bible (for Jews and Christians) who have NOTHING LIKE THAT AT ALL...as they DON'T even know the authors of the Books of the Bible, Don't know when they were written, have no chains of transmission, no books of authorised commentary from the witnesses...and the books were compiled all different times and went through various changes as is admitted by various Biblical scholars. The Bible is UNDOUBTEDLY CHANGED and UNRELIABLE as a Divine Text...whereas the Quran is DEFINITELY RELIABLE.

[@mohammadgoddam]

Thanx braders in Christ. JBU and ur family.

[@jamalkhan3708]

Brother Fadi is a blessing to Christianity from God. Muslims can’t Play Arabic Games. God bless you both✊❤️

[@ercaner_buzbey]

Before watching this know that people here are not Muslim, nor their intentions are to promote İslam. Do not let your guard down because of The outlook of the spiker because he declared that he was a "former Muslim" in 2:30 and he declared himself as an "Arabist" just before in 2:24-2:27 which means he completely disregards the rule of being nonracist of Prophet Mohammed PBUH's last Khutbah. Second any talk about Qur'an's autenticity needs to throughout search of the tradition of memorizing Qu'ran as well, because Qur'an is mainly preserved that way not by writing. Schoolars are well aware of the corrections in old and new manuscripts of Qur'an but that never lead them to abandon their faith, in contrast to these people here. Hope Allah guide us to Himself, without sullying ourself with lies and deception.

[@yahayadaudu3992]

How can an uncreated tablet that has existed eternally in heaven contains earthly events that were already recorded by humans here on earth. Events of two thousands years ago and even less were eternally on this tablet and then recently sent down for us to note? Why is God repeating to us things that are already known and recorded here on earth and with so many mistakes on his version. Somebody or something must be updating this tablet. In the last one thousand five hundred years or so it must have new materials on it.

[@jayd4ever]

al fadi have you heard of stef keris you are like him he is greek that became muslim while you are arab who become christian who can read each other originally language brother rashid,father zackaria and walid shoebat are also good before you guys there was anis shrosh who was a Palestinian christian

[@azizsahil37]

How could anyone question on authenticity of the Quranic verses.... When Allah on his own has mentioned in Qur'an that -- surely we ourself has sent down this exhortation and most surely we will be it's guardian (Quran chapter 15 verse-10) Now since God himself is claiming of being guardian of Qur'an so how could we say that it is not 100% same.. Next the question says why it should be 100% correct.. because of the hifz of the people during time of prophet Muhammad (pbuh) today we see a 4 year child to 90 yr old person can memorize the Qur'an without even a single mistake so during prophet s regime it was Hazrat Abu bakar sidiqque, Umar, Uthman , Ali may Allah be pleased with all of above.. so how can they forget the verses and can even do a single mistake and all their helpers 30000 Hafiz of prophets time how can they forget these mistakes which is now being mentioned by a doctoral research...so if we argue the correctness it would be arguing with Allah verses which clearly says that the book is preserved by me and I am it's guardian...

[@solomonroasthead7914]

( 181 ) Then whoever alters the bequest after he has heard it - the sin is only upon those who have altered it. Indeed, Allah is Hearing and Knowing. ( 15 ) And when Our verses are recited to them as clear evidences, those who do not expect the meeting with Us say, "Bring us a Qur'an other than this or change it." Say, [O Muhammad], "It is not for me to change it on my own accord. I only follow what is revealed to me. Indeed I fear, if I should disobey my Lord, the punishment of a tremendous Day."

[@ahmede.1375]

We don’t believe Qur’an is eternal in a literal sense rather we say the Quran was revealed and uncreated. Allah attribute of speech is eternal and he speaks when he wills.

[@joserivera8429]

There are eternal tablets in heaven according to Islam.

[@ahmede.1375]

Some Muslims have the wrong view, the correct view is that it isn’t eternal.

[@ahmede.1375]

Jose Rivera and show me your evidence, trust me you won’t find anything.

[@joserivera8429]

Gunim Elkhebri according to Answering Islam page: “THE ETERNAL TABLET Even though it is an essential doctrine of Islam, the eternal / heavenly / well-guarded Tablet is mentioned only once in the Qur'an, al-Buruj 85:21-22: bal huwa qur'aan(un) majeed(un) fee lawH(in) maHfooZ(in) Yes, this is a glorious Qur'an on a tablet well guarded. It is thought of as containing the heavenly original of the Qur'an. Muslims in general believe that has 104 parts. The Eternal Tablet: 104 Divisions - 100 were later taken back, of these were * 10 to Adam * 50 to Seth * 30 to Enoch * 10 to Abraham - 1 to Moses (Torah) - 1 to David (Zaboor) - 1 to Jesus (Injil) - 1 to Muhammad : the Qur'an Throughout the Qur'an revelation from God is thought to be pre-existing and "sent down" to mankind at various times, e.g...”

[@joserivera8429]

Gunim Elkhebri Now you give proof that there isn’t a belief that there is an eternal tablet in heaven.

[@rudigunawan7909]

👍🙏

[@danijelakelava6602]

In Spirit the bible is the holy Word of god. I have read the bible many times and the bible contains many god's prophecies and miracles.

[@EonKarlQuit]

To destroy the Quran you have to challenge the oral history The Quran is kept in oral tradition and was completed in the time of Muhammed SAW

[@ampm8185]

Such an extraordinary claim by islam regarding their book required also extraordinary evidence..

[@LJ7000]

While this could be an interesting topic the Jay Smith is just rambling and not saying anything for 15 minutes. Get to the point! I really don't get the impression he knows what he's talking about.

[@ZaydDepaor]

Wrong, the Quran was written down in the time of Muhammad, was memorized, transmitted, recited...was an act of worship to memorize it, recite it, study it, pray with it being recited 5 times a day... Abu Bakr compiling by ijmaa' the recited, witnessed, studied, transmitted, written and memorized texts was NOT 'the Quran being written down for the first time'! And even if it was for arguments sake, the Quran was already preserved, which is exactly how they were able to reach agreement on the text....when there were thousands of reciters and witnesses and memorizers!

[@RGRaj_1977]

There were many reciters who were killed in battle before the Quran's compilation according to hadiths.

[@ahmedmuminchiif4223]

Islam will prevail, Quran is perfect

[@davidford15]

"Islam will prevail" in whose minds? The scientifically-illiterate? Apostate Prophet 1 day ago kzbin.info/www/bejne/bqqwdWxvnN6lZ5Y

[@CIRAInternational]

chiif mumin so perfect that they used patches to cover its many holes :) what a naive claim.., you should be ashamed of yourself for even saying such a thing... pull your head out of the sand and start to use your God given brain! You will Be surprised to find out that it actually works! Perfectly might I add...

[@browndauvil3657]

I am a muslim watching this video

[@user-rf9tq1ob5v]

To learn the error of this claim that the Prophet Mohammed quotes from the Bible you should know that: 1-The Prophet Muhammad did not read or write the Arabic language, and this claim assumes that he knew the language of the Greek, Syriac and Hebrew, you have to prove it and come with a documented source this information. 2-The first translation of the Bible into Arabic was in the eighth century, 100 years after the Prophet Muhammad, you have to explain logically how the Scriptures reached him en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bible_translations_into_Arabic

[@davidford15]

Muhammad heard Bible stories, those stories appeared in very garbled form in the Quran.

[@headlibrarian1996]

How can the Quran be claimed to be complete? Even if the modern Quran were 100% the same as the circa 650 Uthman Quran, we know from authentic hadith that quite a few chapters and verses were forgotten by the time Uthman got around to compiling it, and further that Uthman himself decided which verses to include and exclude. How can Allah allow people to forget? Can it really be claimed that Uthman had no personal or political prejudices that might have colored what he included in the Quran?

[@paagalwalla9535]

Why are we even looking to Uthman, when there wasn't even a complete Qur'an for over 100 years after Uthman. You are quoting material from Al Bukhari, who wrote his material in 870 AD, a good 240 years after Muhammad!

[@Veyron267]

Omg this is Christian Prince:)God bless you all brothers in christ.

[@ZaydDepaor]

There were NO DIACRITICAL MARKS originally....no-one claims there were.....the Arabs NEW THE HARAKAAT [the vowellings] and the possibilities of different recitations with different vowels and with different dots allowing for different words...and both giving some variant minor meanings yet consistent meanings....as is indicated in the tafaseer (the classical books of commentary when mentioning VARIANT READINGS of ayaat). So yet again, these so-called experts don't know what they are talking about.

[@gunawanparadongan2504]

What is Trinity? Before it, i want to say, that the Word of God always fulfilled! 1. Ecclesiastes 7:2! How to know people go to heaven or to hell! In the house of mourning. The expresion of the people who died, show it. Bad or torture expresion go to hell, peace till cherr up (smile) expresion go to heaven! 2. 1 John 5:7-9 (KJV), speak about Trinity! Three are two Trinity, In Heaven and in the Earth! God and human! (Human: Spirit, blood-soul, water-flesh ~ 90% weight our body build by water! 1 Thesalonika 5:23! According to Genesis 1:26, people is the HIS image (model, prototipe, pattern). The different are: God is Holy Spirit, Almighty, great and eternal, people is flesh, mortal and limited! God in harmony but people not. God created 3 living thing's, simple-single (plant), duumvirat (animal) and Trinity creature - living thing's (human)! We are exactly one and exactly three, with three needs! Body needs, soul needs and spirit needs! Example: when fasting, flesh-body need to eat and drink, soul need to obey the rule to fasting! Two personal-individu in one being! To know Trinity, we must see the human itself! God give U the truth!!!

[@onkarchandrawanshi6028]

Amendment on the Aasmani Book as like as the Greatest Indian Constitution by the Indian National Congress (Islamic Nomadic Community)

[@ramadaanmxd4608]

You dress like a Muslim that doesn't mean you are a Muslim and remember this religion is the fastest growing religion in the world right now no matter what allhamdullillah

[@davidford15]

"this religion is the fastest growing religion in the world right now" What percentage of Muslims would leave the cult called Islam if they could safely leave without fear of getting murdered?

[@bobertospearza8800]

Why Did Yahweh Come To Earth To Speak First With Adam and Eve and Then Moses and Give Moses The Ten Commandments (2 Eternal Tablets) then 1,183 years from heaven later pick another man muhammad to remember then rewrite the ten commandments to alter their meanings.....Like : "Thou Shall Not Covet Thy Neighbors Wife or Maid Servant....Thou Shall Not Kill....Thou shall not Bear False Witness against Thy Neighbor ....??? Why Would a Loving Forgiving God Yahweh from the Torah/ Jesus of the Bible Change That....???