Is Organ Donation Allowed in Islam | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi | Q&A | July 23, 2019

[@farhanapatel5404]

Thank you for clarifying this matter

[@gootam7542]

Thanks for the initiative.

[@SaSa-sd2ve]

Jazakhallah Khairan

[@ramazanhoxha4265]

thanks for video

[@musafabureh2959]

Thank you for helping the Ummah. May Allah continue to bless you.

[@alhazenmediax]

There is no restrictions as such, however, one must beware of donating for $ or establishing a business out of it!

[@Jorjina.hayatt]

Apart from the rulings and conditions described, We also have to see analysis of success of kidney transplant which is very low, less than 30 % at times, as most of kidney transplant can fail or death is caused during the operation or soon After, so it's not an easy organ to donate for transplant, all is not so perfectly achieved in the transplant operations. With the rise of kidney disease due to poor lifestyles & diets, diabetes and hypertension, awareness and emphasis should be on preventing these diseases and prevention of severe outcomes like kidney failure, instead of confirming and looking towards radical solutions of organ transplant which do not significantly improve health, and may cause more complications in some cases Most people with kidney disease have a cause in their body due to which the kidneys fail, medical science still does not identity or remove that cause, and the third kidney also eventually fails because the cause to that failure is still there. Just informing here as a health professional as most people do not get to know how many failures occur in transplants hence the islamic condition is not so satisfactorily fulfilled when the % of harm is more than the percentage of good in kidney donation, it can work fine for a few yrs and then, third kidney is also lost which is very depressing for the patient and donor as well. Liver transplant fare much better though. Heart transplants change your entire personality, if successful, so muslims shouldn't get heart transplant or organ donation of non muslims or hearts from bad character people. Same for all other organs.

[@s.elh.3281]

Such input is very important to the discussion ,thank you for sharing. Unfortunately, the way the question of organ donation is usually put (both to potential donor and to shuyukh) is creating false expectations and therefore also shaping the answers. When people think of the question "is it halal to use the organs of a dead person" it is rarely mentioned what was said towards the end of the video: it is disputed even among physicians when the death occurs. Before making any decisions or passing fatwas in this regard, one should investigate the notion of "brain death" and also hear the critics if it. I am not from the medical field, but many first hand accounts of relatives of organ donors, of nurses etc who have worked in this field, make me really doubt the concept of brain death as something which would be seen as death in the islamic perspective. That's why I would not accept an organ for myself (may Allah protect me in my organs) nor would I consent to my organs being taken. I am a blood donor alhamdulillah. That's the only think I can see for me without a doubt as halal insha'Allah.

[@sickid41]

Thank you . People were telling it is haram. To give my kidney to my father. They were telling me it is against Islam. Sucks that I fell into shadans trap. My father passed away without receiving a kidney.

[@epicmasjidclips]

So sorry for your loss. May Allah grant him jannat ul firdous.

[@DarioHaruni]

That's why sometimes, just sometimes, you need to follow your heart, not your clerics.

[@arieltheisen9325]

May Allah have mercy on your father.

[@tymzay4417]

@@DarioHaruni definitely catch yourself self in shirk with that thinking

[@Batman.-]

Let this be a reminder to take fatwas from scholars, not just from the people around you إِنَّا لِلَّه وإِنَّا إِلَيهِ رَاجِعُون

[@watiszadyr6492]

Thank you to clarify this matter 🙏

[@yasminenazarine1629]

Another thing shouldn't be problems after dead body 💔 our body doesn't exist after death turns to ashes to ashes

[@munaadem667]

If the person doing it by his or her will that is ok. But if the system of the country does it that's called injustice. I guess some counties does it . people who do it any way there is no way of going out from the Almighty in the judgement Day .

[@Hafez1961]

The answer regarding donating body parts after death needs more clarification. To benefit body organs, they need to be removed while one is alive! after one is dead his/her organs will be of no use since upon death certain chemicals are released rendering body parts useless.

[@sfgdragoon]

Dont speak without knowledge. There are many ways that organs can be done safely when one is passed away. Wallahualam

[@Hafez1961]

@@sfgdragoon Right back at you, give some examples then

[@AnimeCritical]

​@@Hafez1961 Organs can be removed soon after death and preserved till transplant. It is a common practice in many western countries.

[@tonym8731]

@@Hafez1961 in car accidents many organs are usefull even after the death of the person, if the organs arent demaged they can be used for medical purposes

[@Hafez1961]

@@tonym8731 I keep asking for examples, yet to see one presented. Also, do you mean braindead? meaning, the heart could still be working/pumping! Merely cause brain appears dead doesn't make one dead!

[@mikeb995]

Offering your organs to those in need when you die is a good thing to do. And Allah wants us to help others. How is this even a question?

[@s.elh.3281]

It's a very important question, because (as indicated towards the end of the video) the 'modern" medicine (dominated by the non religious West) has a problem as to when to regard the patient as dead, i.e. when to take the organs (vital organs like heart e.g.) out of the donor. Critics say , that the so called "brain death" was invented exactly for this reason. A brain dead person is breathing with the help of a machine, is moving his / her limbs, is warm. If it is a person who will be an organ donor, this "dead" person will be given anesthesia during the organ explantation and there is numerous first hand accounts of relatives of such a person who will tell you, that if conducted without anesthesia the donor has signs of pain in his/her facial expression. The donors blood pressure raises during the explantation, the so called "dead" persons is clearly reacting to the taking of the organs and if it is (as many critics say) the donation which ultimately kills the person, then the question of halal / haram has to be examined in this light. Overall, it is fair to say, it is a quite complex question.

[@yasminenazarine1629]

It saves millions of people waiting for the organ of humans even Muslims in western countries are refugees poor they are waiting for organs or came by visa for treatment of kidneys I saw a guy in hospital from Kurdish Iraqi waiting in hospital for two years on n off for the organ of human kidneys He is still waiting in hospital 🏥 Why can't we give specially men 🤨

[@ahmedyousuf966]

Its haram to to sell body organ as it belongs to Allah Azzawajal but its okay to donate not for money . who does it belong to at that point of donation then? If the reason for not donating is simply it belongs to Allah Azzawajal or could there be other reasons ya sheikh?

[@user-dy1ji6by7n]

А где доказательство, что нельзя приведите доводы, достоверные хадисы.

[@yeahbuddy4712]

So how do you train as a doctor?? How do they look at body parts for scientific research??

[@lapatissiere]

Corpses

[@ahmedyousuf966]

​@@lapatissiere thats what the question is about.

[@abdallababikir9154]

"For scientific research" is a dark industry, read about it.

[@tymzay4417]

U use a Kaffir body don't fight Allah's judgement

[@sweettea1193]

@@tymzay4417 what if it'san Islamic nation so there are no non Muslim bodies...so what then? Do we just throw our hands up and say, oh well, we can't advance anymore because it's not permissible...

[@HH-bi7yk]

How about the Hadith A dead person feels the same pain if his part of the body is missing?

[@m.b5777]

Fake hadith

[@shifnafaleel3229]

Sheikh ; what about Breastmilk Donation???

[@4k3el]

So if autopsy and research is forbidden so how would science know how to do organ transplant?

[@rockh1993]

" research is forbidden" lol. You must be such an ignorant dim

[@hylianlegends]

It's a mute point now, isn't it?

[@emeraldradiancemadinamunawwara]

Non-Muslim people have already done/doing that kind of work. Muslims can use that information.

[@Omgirrl]

@@hylianlegends Only to you.

[@raspberrymuffin9997]

"But we don't do it willingly with no reason."

[@himansusekhardas4526]

I am surprised why this question is raised at all in islamic world, whether organ donation is allowed in islam or not. No other religion has ever raised such question. I have heard many islamic scholars on this issue. Just to save image, few scholars say it is allowed with many ifs and buts. Donating dead bodies is simply not allowed, then how will medical students study?

[@ibrarali9369]

So is it allowed or not. Why not keep the answer simple

[@hylianlegends]

As he said, Yes in some cases, no in other cases, and there's a gray area. Fiqh of modern issues is not that simple. Watch the video on 2x speed if you're impatient

[@MrDrezzy007]

Bro its not yes or no question, he gives a complete answer so watch in no rush at your free time.

[@MilitechCorp]

There are two scholar opinions on donating your organs after death. One is it is permissible and the other is that our body is sacred and it’s not permissible. There isn’t one opinion, like yes or no. I believe the second opinion.

[@mdkhan3928]

The opinion I follow is that after death, no one can mutilate the body & remove organs. To the best of my understanding the body can still feel pain after death, so that is why having to cut a body to remove organs for transplant purposes is unnaceptable. I'm quiet surprised the Fiqh Council didn't take this point seriously enough & instead focussed on the maslaha of the recipient.🤷🏿‍♀️🤔 If I donate an organ like a kidney or an eye while I am alive then this is fine - obviously not something without which I would die if donated.🤷🏿‍♀️😇

[@user-cu6is1dk8z]

have the ummah lost his mind ? you all declaring it is halal, but differ on the details, one say even after death is halal others not, yet it is declared in england as halal. And you say it right, our body is from allah, so you say lets abuse it by cutting it open and then donate organs? so when we are raised what then? and one claims it must be a muslim or one close to muslims.. what is all of this happening with the scholars and imams? do you not think anymore? why do the persons who wash the bodies of the death, do it very carfefully? and not try to let him fall to brake his bones or hurt him in any way? why dont they use hot water , nor cold water? but in between? and now you and those english muslims come along and claim it is halal, to then cut them open, take out everything we need, if he gave permission for a body which is not his according to you, and then give it all away.. you are making a new islam. if you do a little research, you would know that the prophet said ; that inovations will be less better than what was before it right? so do you think this was there all the 1400 years ? they begun with little parts of the human body, and when they got a new and a new and yet another new invention, they came to the organs, and now you telling us it is halal? no muslim here is giving up his name for the last 20 years to cut out their hearts and livers and bodyparts to donate. yet you want to stamp it into the next generation, know that you shall be answered and asked for your proof for this

[@breakbeat9229]

So a father can't even sacrifice his life for his kids?

[@tymzay4417]

No we all go back to Allah

[@breakbeat9229]

@@tymzay4417 So you are telling me that if you could save your child at the cost of your own life you would let your child die on the basis of your subjective belief there is a god? That's insane man. If there is no god you let your child die for nothing, or better said your own selfishness.

[@hasan-basridurmusoglu5876]

But there is a God, Allah and he is the creator and owner of us. We belong to him and he decides who has to die and when. We Humans can not give life or take it. So that might be sound harsh but if the child has to die so he has to die. Dead is nothing negativ, its actually positiv for a true beliver. We belive, that this world is a test and with dead comes the freedom. We all want to be free but we have not the alawness of Allah to make our own decision when we have to die. We belong to him and to him we go back.

[@tymzay4417]

@@breakbeat9229and if not u go to hell let's what play if u jack ass

[@breakbeat9229]

@@hasan-basridurmusoglu5876 Basically you are saying you can't take medicine or cut out cancer because Allah has to decide who dies not us. I hope you realise this makes no sense right? "There is a god" is just your subjective belief. God could also not exist or exist in a different form than Islam says. So you'd let your kid die because you think there is a god while you could be wrong. And even if there is a god, for him to let you just stand there and not save your kid while you could is not only harsh, it's insane.

[@HB-bd7iz]

Is circumcision also mutilation?

[@user-sc3gn6be3h]

He mentioned “ gray areas” so many times. Therefore, I think it’s time for Allah to appear himself or send a new messenger to clarify confusion regarding all the modern concepts. Islamic teachings can’t explain the modern world. God: please send a new messenger, or let us directly text/what’s up you without a middleman/messenger. Allah needs to adapt to a new technology of direct communication. We don’t need these mullahs who can’t explain the “gray areas.”

[@gafoorgichhi]

Assalamu alaikum respected Sheikh Yasir Qadi & EPIC can you please share the link or URL of the fatawa issued by the Fiqh council about the opinions you have shared on the matter of organ donation. Hoping to see the evidence that was used to form the opinions on the matter from the respected scholarly Fiqh body. Jazakallahu khaira

[@childaisha5098]

Is physics, chemistry, biology, oncology, synecology, computer, space science, aircraft science allowed in ishlame....... wait i will refere quraane........ how long this nonshense will continue

[@Logan-zf1ft]

LOL lindu

[@childaisha5098]

@@Logan-zf1ft Muhamuds way of checking maturity of child Aisha, before rapping her 1. He asks dear child are you mature enough to take my bangs day in day out. Aish replies " Granpa I am mature , u can bang me as you wish" 2. Muhamud the pedofile child molestor, puts his finger and checks whether hole is large enough ( from 6 yrs to 9 yrs ) and marries her.

[@Logan-zf1ft]

@@childaisha5098 Lindu is mad because I love beef

[@Logan-zf1ft]

@@childaisha5098 You should become Muslim and enjoy beef with rice and steak 😋