Is The Sharia Barbaric?

The Hot Seat Disclaimer: • The Hot Seat Disclaime...
Sign up now to AMAU Academy: www.amauacademy.com/
0:00:00 - Introduction
0:02:43 - Linguistic definition of the word 'Sharia'
0:04:20 - How is the word 'Sharia' used in Islam?
0:06:24 - What are the prescribed punishments in Islam?
0:09:19 - Why does Islam punish people?
0:11:18 - How can you save peoples lives through retribution?!
0:13:38 - How do non-Muslims see the concept of "punishments"?
0:20:56 - The system will not get better through human intervention
0:26:15 - Don't judge the hudood of Allah based on your limited life experience
0:29:25 - Hudood are not implemented when there is doubt
0:31:43 - What is a discretionary punishment?
0:33:08 - Does the Sharia put off non-Muslims?
0:34:48 - Is stoning a prescribed punishment?
0:39:53 - Why is stoning for adulterers a deterrent?
0:46:24 - Can't 4 male witnesses conspire to blame a person?
0:49:28 - Why is the punishment so harsh?
0:57:57 - Is love a crime?
1:02:42 - Why can't we update these hudood to give mercy to the criminals?
1:04:03 - Do people witness the punishment upon the criminal?
1:05:44 - The hudood expiate the sin
1:07:32 - How could this be implemented in the West?
1:10:43 - Other crimes that have stoning as the punishment
1:11:54 - The punishment for unmarried people committing zina
1:17:15 - The punishment for theft
1:18:56 - Conditions for the punishment to be applied
1:27:40 - What if someone does not regret what they did?
1:29:55 - What happens to people who steal small amounts?
1:32:00 - How to rehabilitate a criminal?
1:38:04 - What is the punishment of murder in Islam?
1:41:11 - Degrees of murder in Islam
1:46:44 - Can we take the law in our own hands?
1:54:26 - How does the Sharia avoid miscarriage of justice?
1:58:34 - Do witnesses play a part in Islamic Justice?
2:00:59 - Are witnesses really reliable as an evidence?
2:02:13 - Why is apostasy a crime?
2:04:33 - How would you explain this to a non-Muslim?
2:07:42 - How do you reconcile this punishment with ayaat which seem to go against this?
2:11:24 - What is the punishment for insulting the Prophet ﷺ?
2:18:00 - Does Islam give too much power to the leader?
2:21:50 - Is Islam a bloodthirsty religion?
2:23:36 - Why did Islam not abolish slavery?
2:28:14 - Why were the whole tribe of Bani Quraydhah killed and enslaved?
2:33:53 - Why not modernise the laws of the Sharia?
2:38:10 - Did classical scholars call for replacement of hudood with financial punishments?
2:39:49 - How can laws from 7th Century Arabia be applicable today?
2:43:16 - Shouldn't we consider the customs of today?
2:44:50 - Do Islamic punishments apply to non-Muslims living in a Muslim country?
2:45:35 - Do you advocate for Sharia law in the UK?
2:46:15 - Summary
You can also find us on:
AMAU Academy: www.amauacademy.com/
AMAU Junior: amaujunior.com/
Instagram: / amauofficial
Patreon: / amau
Telegram: t.me/amauofficial
KZbin: / amauofficial
Twitter: / amauofficial
iTunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/08NJC1p...
Get in Touch: amau.org/getintouch
BarakAllahu feekum.
#AMAU #TimHumble #TheHotSeat

[@zayd8801]

May Allah bless the people behind this channel.

[@bouabadahamid]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bJqcc5R_jK-Kd6M

[@Wakobear.]

Aameen

[@safiasaleh7322]

Ameen

[@rizwanrasheed8649]

Aameen

[@abdullahiomar6561]

Ameen

[@Urbro_meast]

On the next Hot Seat Podcast In shaa Allaah, can you guys talk on Nationalism , Patriotism and Tribalism.

[@bouabadahamid]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bJqcc5R_jK-Kd6M

[@alghuraba2120]

That would be really interesting

[@saint8709]

@Dhuku .10 ur not Muslim

[@elmiroble4608]

@Dhuku .10 what did you know about Khilafa ?

[@hkr1986]

@Dhuku .10 A Muslim would never say this unless he/she is misinformed

[@shahmianas8512]

One of the most amazing things about the Shariah is how it puts the benefit of the greater society above the individual. Western and modern law is so obsessed with the individual where even a child rapist can make a case for himself by saying he wasn't mentally stable or in the right frame of mind or some rubbish of the sort. The well being of such a sick individual is more important than the safety of children who could be his potential victims! How messed up is that!

[@hassanalialqadiri]

exactly. the victims safety is completely disregarded. i was watched a video where a child predator was actually exposed and without a doubt a child predator. but he was let free with the excuse that he is trying to warn of the children from people like him.

[@shahmianas8512]

@@hassanalialqadiri Subahanallah. That is just insane. With laws like that they still have the audacity to accuse the Shariah of being barbaric without knowing anything about it.

[@hassanalialqadiri]

@@shahmianas8512 while the sharia is not barbaric in the first place. they simply are the enemies of islam. sharia will of course contain punishments for those who cause mischief. without punishment, people will kill, rape and steal with a slap on the wrist. it falls bellow us to even answer the enemies of islam in such way. they clearly understand what is sharia but purposefully do it to misguide.

[@shahmianas8512]

@@hassanalialqadiri you get people of all kinds to be honest. Some are genuinely ignorant, some purposefully chose to stay ignorant, and the others like you said are the enemies of Islam who know very well its the truth but are in denial and want to spread discord.

[@hassanalialqadiri]

@@shahmianas8512 that is true. what i find alot is that islam presents un deniable truth to these people yet they are too stubborn to accept it.

[@MissMrqz]

I really enjoy these conversations and I learn so much. Thank you for having these discussions and the thoughtfulness in the responses. I say all of this as a Mexican American Christian woman with an interest in what the Islamic faith is and what it offers.

[@ER_Sane]

D

[@abigailnoemimunozmartinez3096]

May Allah guide you

[@mystiqur1148]

May Allah guide you and grant you understanding. I really enjoy them as well and expand my way of thinking as a Muslim

[@Gemsofafghanistan]

I pray to Allah (the Deity Who has the right to be worshipped alone) that he guides you to Islam (the religion of full submission to Allah) and that He may give you tranquility in your heart. I pray that he blesses you with the good in this life and with the good in the Hereafter and that He saves you from the Hellfire.

[@faraaq]

I wish the best for you

[@Lion_Heart14]

The content,production,set,quality everything is so top notch.Just shows the honest niyyah and hardwork all the brothers at amau are putting in just for pleasing Allah and helping the ummah.Also,notice how no video has ads,Allah will immensely reward you guys in sha allah.

[@shahmianas8512]

Couldn't agree more :)

[@shahmianas8512]

@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud no worries bro. Sorry just had to clarify.

[@shaharyarahmad8477]

Say Allahumabarik if you like their production

[@Lion_Heart14]

@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud Brother,I love ustadh arh and have listened to almost every podcast of his for more than 24 hours (in total).I take knowledge from here,hajji,ali,hijab,hamza,mansur,hashim,yasir qadhi (Yes,surprisingly,yq as well.I try to remain impartial,I listen to what yq says,analyze cross check and take knowledge.NO ONE IS INFALLIBLE,I do not agree with everything that he says but that doesn't mean he is a jahil.I watch his seerah series,descriptions of jannah,fiqhi rulings etc.He quotes quran,hadith,sunnah,the salaf, and doesn't call to bid'ah.Khalaas,this is enough to seek knowledge from a person.If he gets it wrong,I leave it,and if he gets it right,I take it.Similar to how we as salafis,treat imam Nawawi.He was right about other things,but got the names and attributes wrong,so we leave it.) Zeeshan,Adnan,musa rashid but not imran (ibn mansur). Imran is very arrogant,irritating and I honestly cant stand him for a minute.The very first video I saw was of him in hyde park with Adnan Rashid calling sh.haitham an ikhwani (not to mention the controversy regarding sh.tahir wyatt).I tried watching his other videos to get a picture of him,but like I said,I couldn't watch him even for a minute,with his absolutely irritating and non sensical hand actions,over acting etc like its some sort of a drama video.(Him shouting in the masjid had infuriated me and many others,although he apologized later) I know he is a student of Ust.arh but man does he need a personality check.I also have to point out his absolute obsession with innovation,and refuting groups.The avg.muslim who doesnt know what deobandism or asharism or salfiyyah is,doesn't want to watch 10 groups being refuted in 10 minutes,rather he wants to know the authentic sunnah,imaan boosters,and the way to attain firdaus.For knowledge about aqeedah,there are ppl much more knowledgeable and reliable than imran like ustadh arh right here on this channel.Please note that I appreciate imran for all that he has done for dawah and do not completely disregard it. I am aware of ust.yasin,abu taymiyyah and do not hold the same view about them. When I watched yq,arh or others I was hooked onto it and wouldn't know how hours went by,it is because of their akhlaque and piety that one could easily sense.Another good example would be,ust tim humble and brother shahid hassan. I am 17,have my exams after 2 weeks and I have been living in India since 2019 (was in jeddah for the rest of my life) and I have nothing to do with the uk dawah scene (just have been following it for a long time) 😂 . I dont agree completely with Bro hajji,he is disrespectful, and arrogant as well but I do see a point in his videos.I see your videos of refuting him as well,and try to judge things impartially.I am a huge fan of ust. arh and condemn bro hajji for his disrespectful attitude towards ppl that are much higher in knowledge than him like sh.fawzan or ust. arh etc I attribute myself to salfiyyah,but not ikhwani blaming,mubtadee',khariji tagging extremesim (super salfiyyah,madaakhilah).Spubs,Shamsi is the other evil we have.Do you know that they have small channels on yt with names like "creed and methodology of the salaf" and their content is literally picking bits and pieces of the lectures of some big names like zakir naik,yusuf estes,mufti menk,and every other daee and making them look like they committed errors and sometimes even kufr.According to them only abu khadeejah who cant read the quran,abu Iyaad,and shaykh rabe'e are upon the sunnah and the salaf.Know that this was not the methodology of the salaf and it never will be.Truly as it is in the hadith our actions depend on our intentions.May Allah reward you,abdul hamid and everyone (including imran) for the good that they have done.Indeed the truth is clear from falsehood.

[@Lion_Heart14]

@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud Nah mate,like I said no one is an actual threat to muslims.Be it hajji or yasir qadhi.I believe everyone who doesnt call to bid'ah like istigaatha and other non sense can be taken knowledge from.Take the good and leave the bad. There are however two threats to muslims and that is the tekken character Abu layth and the spubs cult who are apparently the only ones across the globe on the sunnah and salaf 😂 As for the debate,yes I am aware of it.I am a fan of ust arh and his struggles in his journey of seeking knowledge and I consider him to be both knowledgeable and reliable,am also excited to see what hajji brings to the table as he is the underdog.Looks like am on everyone's team 😂.I have to do my research on khurooj , najdi dawah and have to read Al-durar-Al-Saniyyah before I pick a side.I am a neutral observer and am rooting for both of them. And honestly I don't get the issue of criticizing the ruler as I myself have been born and spent 16 years in jeddah and this never intrigued me and I used to criticize the saudi diplomacy sometimes in family discussions.But its logical to stay away from it since the ruler will not remain a ruler on the day of judgement.

[@MohammedAlSharif2002]

You guys really bring up amazing and the most needed topics. 👍🏻

[@Wakobear.]

May Allah reward them

[@penguinman38]

Please donate, a salafi brother from India is getting threats. The police don't help him because he is poor! So help your brother my brothers and sisters: www.gofundme.com/f/support-small-indian-family-harassed-with-poverty Indeed Allah is a witness over me, I have spoken to the brother. He really needs the money to pay the debt!

[@mewzi]

@@Gog3453 What's that?

[@pearlsofadaab]

Short answer, no it isn't. It's JUST and the ruling has not only come from the Most Just, but has come from The One who knows the creation the best!

[@faiza9895]

Correct! If only the creation realized this how much better would our world be! May Allah guide us!

[@thelegendarychechen]

@Dhuku .10 Yes it has, these things don’t happen (as much) in Muslim countries where they apply these punishments.

[@thelegendarychechen]

@Dhuku .10 Stoning for adulterers is completely justified because of how disgusting the crime is. Cheating on your spouse has not only effect on the spouse who is cheated on but also the rest of society. Also as explained, this almost never happens because there are extremely strict conditions that need to be fulfilled. There cannot be any doubt or there has to be a confession.

[@Cartouchai]

This is your opinion. Its subjective. Where do you derive your morals from. Do you have an objective morality or objective moral landscape? Or are you just speaking from your own emotion and perception. Dont give me the "I am speaking for the general public" garbage, just answer my questions. Objective or subjective?

[@pearlsofadaab]

@@Cartouchai Are you referring to my comment? Because I am coming from an objective perspective [the Quran and Sunnah].

[@HussainFahmy]

*_Islamic Shariah defined for those who seek Divine guidance for this limited life. An absolute essential clip for humanity._*

[@Ocean_38]

Humblest guy on earth: Tim HUMBLE. We love you sheikh and I love to watch all your lectures. Pure knowledge flowing, Allahumma barik.

[@osman.s1405]

You havent met everyone on earth

[@user-bq3cw3bw8t]

@@ytuser9948 True but it still seems like an inappropriate exaggeration of the Ustadh's humbleness

[@shnadeem2000]

Subhan Allah, Tim humble answered the questions brilliantly and excellently explained. I loved the most was how proud he was of Islam and Allah laws. May Allah Subhanahu wa ta’ala bless you, raise your ranks and increase your knowledge Ameen 🤲

[@tanzila2568]

May Allaah bless Ustaadh/Shaykh Tim Humble. He's so polite and well spoken. May Allaah honour him and his family. Aaneen

[@arabiyyah7965]

mashAllah, this is the best English podcast I've ever listened to so far! May Allah SWT bless you, and make this podcast as a sadaqa jaryah for you.

[@alaqeeliah1]

Excited to watch this. so many good topics on this podcast. They’re lengthy as well which is great, may Allah reward you brothers for your hard work.

[@cabdiraxmanxirsi7092]

Please speak about tribalism, nationalism, racism in the ummah

[@RK-nt1jz]

Fax

[@Veritas-dq2hs]

the interesting about tribalism and nationalism, is that it seems God intended for there to be nations and tribes. I would also like to hear about this topic.

[@user-ny9kc4lm6p]

I don’t know why would they make a podcast about these topics because they’re all haram...

[@Veritas-dq2hs]

@@user-ny9kc4lm6p prove that they're haram. In the Quran itself, Allah says He made us into nations and tribes. Q49:13

[@user-ny9kc4lm6p]

@@Veritas-dq2hs Yes but you misunderstood me what i meant to say is that taking pride in nationality or tribe is haram. Because you should only be proud of one thing and thats islam. One second ill link you the video of fatwa of sheikh saleh al fawzan he talked about this topic.

[@faraaq]

As Muslims, it is very important for us to watch and understand this. Jazakallah Khair for this.

[@faiza9895]

May Allah reward you brothers for discussing these important topics in this day and age!!

[@sb_1389]

Very beneficial, jazakallahu khairan for all your efforts, guys. May Allah (swt) accept them from you and weight them heavily on your scale of good deeds. Ameen. One major point that Br. Shahid touched on briefly that I think bears repeating is how the whole of Islam is set up to discourage crimes and safeguard communities. It's not as though people are told "don't commit zina!" while lingerie billboards are everywhere, bars and free mixing on every corner, etc. Islam is consistent from start to finish.

[@muatasimahmed2343]

Jazakallah for time stamps saved me lot of time

[@daniah5427]

I love this podcast so much may Allah bless your team immensely!

[@penguinman38]

Please donate, a salafi brother from India is getting threats. The police don't help him because he is poor! So help your brother my brothers and sisters: www.gofundme.com/f/support-small-indian-family-harassed-with-poverty Indeed Allah is a witness over me, I have spoken to the brother. He really needs the money to pay the debt!

[@adilbadsha615]

Wallahi we need such contents to protect our iman very good job by Al Madrasatu Al Umarriyyah

[@QuikArabicLessons]

Much needed vid. Allah reward u

[@A-Pro100]

MAY ALLAH BLESS TIM HUMBLE AND AMAU TEAM. That is all.

[@amadali4036]

mashallah Great video i really like brother Tim could you have him on more often he is very good at giving evidence and explaining

[@basil9633]

This is truly a great discussion

[@pollychowdhory4945]

May Allaah honour, bless, forgive and guide all the people who support, and are involved with, this gem of a channel, ameen.

[@hasannaqvi7430]

May Allah reward you all, this was very beneficial.

[@lizzytranovmccoy9787]

ชอบมากที่แบ่งเป็นนาทีๆ เป็น chapter ว่านาทีนั้นๆพูดอะไร thanks for time index. jazakallahu all of your team.

[@khadizamrs6048]

This is so exiting

[@Wakobear.]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@betsenatashenafi607]

May Allah swt shower his blessing upon the people in this channel aameen ya rab This was one of the most beneficial videos I have ever watched allahumma barik, keep it up inshaallah

[@rafayshakeel4812]

This was an awesome video. May Allah ﷻ reward you for your efforts. Ameen!

[@RaihanShaheed]

سبحان الله What an excellent podcast..Jazakh Allah for this❤️

[@amgadragab6584]

بارك الله فيكم. جزاكم الله خير

[@fauziajasia2548]

Very important topic and an interesting discussion. Jazakallahu khairan

[@penguinman38]

Please donate, a salafi brother from India is getting threats. The police don't help him because he is poor! So help your brother my brothers and sisters: www.gofundme.com/f/support-small-indian-family-harassed-with-poverty Indeed Allah is a witness over me, I have spoken to the brother. He really needs the money to pay the debt!

[@mobheda2292]

shaykh tim humble full of knowledge mashallah.

[@arcanumviator]

Wasn't expecting. Much to many of us a surprise I think :)

[@hehehheheheheh2765]

I think it will be extremely beneficial if you do one on slavery expecially the controversy around the whole 'right hand possess' there's a lot of people (non-muslims) who attack us for it.

[@faraaq]

I second this

[@princessmohammed3194]

AsSalaamu alaikum could you all do a hotseat podcast on the one who leaves off the salah

[@hamzafarah4417]

Asalamu alukum sheik I was hoping you would cover the topic regarding riba and student loans and what to do with the debt and how to settle it even though it is a huge amount and does it stop someone doing hijrah guys pin this one up we need this is in the west pin this guys come have commented for this last few videos we need solutions inshallah !!

[@InfinitesimallyInfinite]

BaarakAllaahu feekum. Very informative. However, I advise akhi Shahid to monitor the comments section with some people spreading misinformation on our scholars like Shaykh ul Islaam.

[@abdullahiomar6561]

I do agree totally controlling comments section some people bringing unjust criticism which is oppression to the scholars and name calling I don't think that criticism it is insult . That should not be allowed.

[@abdullahiomar6561]

@@TheOneLogic69 ok I understand you and where you are coming from . I do allow criticism to come and I will address but am saying criticism and insult are two different things. Any person can say his point view by been respectful . U can criticize like educated civilised person . Am against insults not criticism . And also my religion is complete is not open for debate and opinion . I take my religion from revelations the Qur'an and sunnah . I don't care about others opinions they don't weight anything . Am saying be respectful in your comments I have the right to have that opinion because it is freedom of speech right .

[@kemohersekovich9817]

SubhanAllah

[@ismailmartinez9401]

Barakah'Allah fiqhm for the ilm

[@The.muslim_wojak]

BarakAllahu Feek

[@zeeshanarafath4116]

I saw a comment saying to talk about when to do jihad, please make that happen insha allah ta'ala

[@zeeshanarafath4116]

@Moin Uddin lol and I got my comment off of your comment, barakallahu feek

[@mdidris4414]

That's a bit of a risky topic to discuss on social media. It doesn't take much for the government to lock you up for terrorism these days!!

[@zeeshanarafath4116]

@@mdidris4414 true but it is called the hot seat

[@moradlouhbab3351]

there are two types of ahadith one that precises and the other one that resumes it. There are 4 or 3 narrators who Heard directly the prophet saws bring the same hadith (whomever leaves the religion and qui the community, aka "the nation", kill him). But Ibn abbas who didn't hear the prophet directly resumed it without the community. Plus at the time of the prophet as there were many apostates but they were poilitical ones and even the quran talked about the ones who believe in the Deen and then leave it at nights. For example many such as Ibn Sarh did the same, and Uthman Ibn Affan didn't apply the hadd on him and the prophet forgave him because he believed again. Another story is when Umar Ibn khattab shouted why their companions killed an apostates without putting him in prison to verify whether he did apostate for treason or just because he left islam. Then the prophet also said to people who apostates among the sahaba that He as a prophet he can't kill someone who leave islam. That's a personal Choice as Allah told. cuz we can't force anyone to believe in something wheteher it be in islam or in another things that would be creating hypocrites

[@RakhtanQ]

For the algorithm

[@user-xg1kj5wf9s]

the answer is @ 10:00 : ‎by giving sharia Laws ﷲ‎‬ ‎ﷻ‬ saving you from the punishment of the Jahannam which is nothing in comparison to this Sharia punishment ...so there’s (laws) his mercy...and non of the mercy can be Barbaric.

[@user-xg1kj5wf9s]

Dhuku .10 When you were in your mother’s womb did you know that world exist? What your science teaches? They teach that everything that occur has a reason and it happens through a process...nothing is there for no reason or doesn’t happen randomly...You and us in comparison to the universe is nothing! Your brain capacity is very very small! You’re not able to even stop yourself from dying...Don’t be arrogant...No proof who said? There’s thousands of proof..Read Quran in order to know not to argue...think of your limit and size before you say “I can’t see it”...you can’t see many things but you can read the speech of the one who created you before you were nothing!

[@user-xg1kj5wf9s]

Dhuku .10 We aren’t deceived. We have read it and found many proofs that was more than enough. Don’t just think you are the only one who has brain...I would suggest Read the Holy Quran from start to the end you will see the proof (existing of Allah subhanahuwatala). If you have anything to say then read Al Quran the proof is there not here. Bye.

[@shahabsaif01]

@Dhuku .10 Science is not perfect. It explains how things works but not why did they occur in the first place.

[@mohamudahmed6554]

@Dhuku .10 " There is no concrete proof a god exists nor is there proof that that God is Abrahamic." - Really? So how have you found this to be true when you can't observe God or anything that is believed to be the external cause of the Universe in this case, the Abrahamic God? "And yes the universes creation was random and so was the development of life." - Where is your evidence for this claim? You are making unscientific claims in the name of Science? Also, the ignorance in your speech: You rather choose a irrational claim that the Universe and life formed RANDOMLY rather than being created and caused by a intelligent, powerful, conscious being. How irrational, Atheism is truly irrational. You made a baseless claim (And yes the universes creation was random and so was the development of life.) and you need to prove it since there is absolutely no evidence for this claim, none. You might go back and refer to Darwinism, but its one evolutionary mechanism which is promoted among many. I can bring proper refutation from Secular Atheist evolutionary biologists, but before that, prove you claim from peer-reviewed scientific papers.

[@mohamudahmed6554]

@Dhuku .10 First of all, i never claimed anything nor did i say i believe in X or in Y. YOU made a claim and it is upon you to meet the burden of proof, do not try to shift it. Secondly, No one cares about your subjective views on what this Creator could be or could not be. Thirdly, you claimed that " And yes energy can be created from nothing in an absence or vacuum." What? A Vacuum is SOMETHING, not NOTHING. There was no Vacuum before the Universe since a Vacuum is in the Universe, it has physical and tangible particles in it. It is not metaphysical. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum Also, Energy can't be "created" or destroyed in an isolated system, this is the FIRST LAW of of thermodynamics. Do you know what this even means ? Ridiculous claims. Also, the absence of everything does not exist in the physical world, so you are claiming the Universe could possibly come form NOTHING which is refuted by even the Atheist Scientist Lawrence Krauss in his book "Universe from nothing". When there is literally NO-THING, this does not exist in the physical world (Inside the Universe) so how can the Universe come from this? Nonsense. So by far, you made false scientific claims which no one utters. So now, bring the evidence for your claims, simple as that.

[@ameerhussain5405]

Is it conceivable to have alternative forms of punishments eg: Death by hanging rather than chopping the head, stoning to death etc.? Disclaimer: I haven't watched the full video.

[@MuhammadAli-mz4pq]

Then watch the whole video.

[@aatif7518]

We shouldn't change Allah's law The stoning shows the seriousness

[@aatif7518]

@Dhuku .10 two consenting adults? Immorality has spread so much !!

[@aatif7518]

@Dhuku .10 seriously?

[@aatif7518]

@Dhuku .10 that's why the world is corrupted leading to suicides, bastards, etc

[@ahmedsaif6110]

Why the time on the clock never changes?

[@fauziajasia2548]

the judge needs to be very pious or mumin in that respect

[@HasanIbra]

Who is the reciter in the beginning? Can anyone tell that please?

[@HasanIbra]

thank you brother!

[@rafayshakeel4812]

Who's the reciter in the beginning? Where can I find his recitation video? Thank you!

[@alm1279]

Please ponder on the meaning of verses 6:114, 42:21 $ & 9:31 and ask yourself WHO is dictating your religious laws.

[@arabic-englishhadith4828]

Start Memoring Hadith Today!!! Insha Allah

[@moradlouhbab3351]

Continuing from my first comment: To have a clearer Proof from quran that the haidths that says to kill a muslim might be weak ... it contradicts the quran 4:137. Allah clearly said: those who believed then disbelieved and THEN disbelieved (so they had the chance to disbelieve or they would have been dead and couldn't have the chance to disbelieve) and the Aya finished that Allah will just not forgive them.

[@Soulkollextor]

Is that Surah Ra’d in the beginning?

[@aaronaaron2405]

yes

[@sb_1389]

Just verse 5, reciter is Ustadh AbdulRahman Hassan. No full version. :(

[@Youtubber1980]

Dear Brothers and sisters, Can someone please share the name of the Quran reciter at the beginning of the clip? May Allah bless you all!

[@kissmybeard2378]

Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hasan.

[@ST-ug6ky]

@@kissmybeard2378 May Allah grant you jannah!

[@kissmybeard2378]

@@ST-ug6ky Ameen. Please make dua for me that right now I'm COVID-19 affected

[@fklotaloi]

May Allah bless Ustad Tim n other guy. I fear for him how he completely hold the rope of Islam being in 100% western environment. This guy is a NOOR in the dark all arnd. 😍

[@adilbadsha615]

Yeah May Allah reward him

[@mohamed64753]

2:04:38

[@meghdirlynda5366]

Why is the punishment for adultry in Quran 100 lashes and hadith stoning? Can it be both? Isnt Allah's law absolute?

[@kissmybeard2378]

If the hadith clearly contradicts with the Quran, then the hadith is surely Mawdhoo.

[@M7md-3la2]

You simply don't understand A married person is stoned Single person is lashed It is both

[@talibahmuslimah1535]

Hadith explains Quran, how do we make Wadu ? How do we pray ?

[@conservativemuslim]

Sigh it’s both and Allāh’s law is absolute. Stoning is for a person who has been married. Lashes is for a person who has NOT been married. Got it?

[@meghdirlynda5366]

Why is there no punishment for apostasy in Quran but hadith killing?????

[@nisarkarim1580]

Young peoples hearing or Daef can swearing to me and all peoples will never good life

[@housse51]

Ustadh.. What is the ruling of mocking other prophets?

[@kissmybeard2378]

If it's proven that they are real islamic prophet. Like if you mock Isa ibn Mariyam may Allah bless him, then it's equal as kufr. And evidence for this is that it's a pillar of Iman to believe in all the prophets.

[@abukitten]

2:00:00

[@mrinnocent1115]

can you please say me the inros qaree

[@r.m.k.1974]

What about abrogation ?

[@fuzbeatboxern5714]

What is that?

[@erTalhaKhan]

Highly problematic take on apsotasy. No proofs were provided in support of the argument. I would disagree with Ustad Humble.

[@evanfreshman2450]

There is no crime in Islam punishable by stoning and adultery is not a capital offense. Zina is according to Allah (SWT) and His Prophet (SAW) punishable by public shaming and corporal punishment of no more than 100 lashings with a switch. Stoning where it has existed has only ever been a local custom, not a divine commandment. Stop misrepresenting the Prophet and the faith. Stoning an adulterer is a sure sign that you are an innovator and defending the practice is a sign you are a kafir. Again, adultery is punishable by corporal punishment. Murder may be punishable by death or a monetary penalty. Theft may be punishable by amputation. Read the Quran, read the Muwatta. Think critically.

[@Imayebrook]

What type religio-

[@r.m.k.1974]

Stoning isn't anymore Islamic

[@rafayshakeel4812]

Stoning is definitely part of Islam. Don't sugar-coat Islam.

[@AzalDaniel]

23:10 crimes have actually exponentially decreased in the US since 1990s and Europe too. In fact, in Europe, homicides have decreased extremely rapidly since the Middle Ages. Anyone can look up the stats on Google.

[@Urbro_meast]

But then again , it is starting to skyrocket back to how it was and even worse as the future keeps coming .

[@Veritas-dq2hs]

crime in the US is still at a disturbingly high level. The amount of murder, theft, and petty crime is completely unacceptable for a supposedly 1st world country.

[@Veritas-dq2hs]

@@TheOneLogic69 it is currently going back up, and the US is the developed country with the highest rape, murder, and theft.

[@Urbro_meast]

@@TheOneLogic69 Why don’t you send this as a question to AMAU’s email or Mufti Uthman’s email or call assimalhakeem or call Karim AbuZaid or send this question to islamqa.info . In fact , send this question of yours to everyone of them.

[@Veritas-dq2hs]

@@TheOneLogic69 all those countries are spiritually dead.

[@mysticia4582]

Well, this video has answered the question for me, just not in the way they intended. Infact, now I'm even more convinced that Sharia is barbaric.

[@conservativemuslim]

Who cares about your ignorance? You are just a defected piece in world of perfection.

[@meghdirlynda5366]

Allah is merciful Hadiths bring roughness and contradict Quran It is time for a shakeup of hadiths Urgently

[@user-lo9rp1oo9i]

First here

[@Ocean_38]

May Allah be pleased with you akhi

[@penguinman38]

Please donate, a salafi brother from India is getting threats. The police don't help him because he is poor! So help your brother my brothers and sisters: www.gofundme.com/f/support-small-indian-family-harassed-with-poverty Indeed Allah is a witness over me, I have spoken to the brother. He really needs the money to pay the debt!

[@rememberpalestine-uyghurs-2918]

To me personally sitting like this and looking at each other in straight opposit directions and talk is a little awkward. Anybody else has the same thing?

[@n.a3642]

Lol a lil bit. But who cares.

[@rememberpalestine-uyghurs-2918]

@@n.a3642 hhha

[@okbrostartcoping5835]

honest jihadis but still sugarcoating some of the laws/

[@rafayshakeel4812]

Learn the definition of Jihad, then speak. These punishments will keep societies in their boundaries. If you cross the boundary, then suffer the consequences. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is a mercy to the World. Watch the entire video, then give your comments. The Western World is filled with homosexuality, pornography, mass murders, genocides, etc... And Islam offers a solution. These laws will deter those people from committing these heinous crimes, mate! May Allah (SWT) guide you to Islam. Ameen!

[@Fozykeno]

Like which one? Please provide one example

[@conservativemuslim]

Like what? If you don’t know - we DO NOT sugarcoat islam. We present most orthodox and traditionalist position. Do you even know the meaning of “jihad” like bro start coping now.

[@user-dx5ie3uv8m]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@penguinman38]

Please donate, a salafi brother from India is getting threats. The police don't help him because he is poor! So help your brother my brothers and sisters: www.gofundme.com/f/support-small-indian-family-harassed-with-poverty Indeed Allah is a witness over me, I have spoken to the brother. He really needs the money to pay the debt!