Is Music Allowed in Islam?

[@AlMiftahulIslam]

*Copied it from the description* 00:00 Introduction 01:30 The three types of music & singing 03:04 The first type - permissible music & singing 14:54 The second type - prohibited music & singing 16:10 The word ‘makrooh’ according to the salaf 28:12 A summary of the first two types 28:57 The third type - music & singing to get closer to Allah 32:42 Why are using ijma’ and not the Quran & Sunnah? 41:45 Evidence from The Quran that music is haram 45:55 The unanimous agreement of the companions 47:19 What is ijma’ as-sukooti? 55:44 Music takes you away from your religion 58:28 The famous hadith in Sahih Bukhari prohibiting music 1:01:29 Is this hadith authentic? 1:12:55 Is Hisham ibn Ammar a reliable narrator? 1:29:22 What can we understand from this hadith? 1:30:44 What is dalaalatu al-iqtiraan? 1:39:22 Are you misunderstanding this hadith? 1:51:06 More evidences from The Quran that music is haram 1:56:02 The dangers of music in the 21st Century 1:57:31 Is the evidence against music clear cut? 2:01:30 But, didn’t the Prophet ﷺ listen to two slave girls singing? 2:14:52 30 scholars have transmitted ijma’ that music is haram 2:17:23 Is it a valid difference of opinion? 2:21:39 Summary & breakdown of the discussion 2:24:21 Not every strange opinion should be considered 2:27:43 Is it permissible to eat at a restaurant with music on? 2:28:36 Can we give da’wah through poetry and music? 2:30:33 What if the content of the permissible type of music is questionable? 2:30:47 Can you recite Quran in a musical tone? 2:31:17 Sincere advice to the listeners

[@Northphilly-wu4oq]

inshaAllah can the brother start translating the hes naming during the talk inshaAllah

[@0095raza]

akhee may Allah bless you

[@thepalestiniankufiya]

May Allah bless you for helping the people

[@Soulkollextor]

Thank you so much for this

[@navidahmed7922]

@Abbas Abdullah all these ikhwani are exposed by our brothers in sudan المنهج السلفي بالسودان

[@QuranicRemembrance]

I can confirm that Music can actually push you away from practicing the deen. I found that it is impossible to pray five times a day consistently while listening to Music.

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp3913]

Same here akhi

[@FULAN]

@@seeyalater3510 Abdullah ibn Mas’ud, may Allah be pleased with him, said, “Verily, the believer views his sins as if he were sitting under a mountain, fearing it will fall upon him, while the wicked one views his sins as if they were a fly passing over his nose.” Source: Sahih al-Bukhārī 5949 and Imam ibn al-Qayyim رحمه الله said: “When the heart dies, it doesn’t feel the sin that it is doing.” ● [Al Fawaid | pg 384] Take control of your heart and repent to Allaah. It is a serious matter, even if you don't realize it.

[@Abb-ve1me]

@@seeyalater3510 SubhanAllah I apologize for any wrongdoing and mistake i have done against you. Allah is my witness and sees if this is out of arrogance. You have to assume that the intention of your brother is not in arrogance.

[@seeyalater3510]

@@Abb-ve1me my brother I forgive you and hopefully you forgive me if I done any wrong to you. May Allah guide both of us and have us meet in Jannatul Firdaus al Alaa. Ameen

[@Abb-ve1me]

@@seeyalater3510 ameen

[@amgadragab6584]

I love the recitation in the beginning ماشاء الله, بارك الله لك, تبارك الله

[@Muwahid999]

I suggest you to watch this soothing Quran recitation by Raad al kurdi kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z322fHRsrLx7f8k

[@fahim7153]

Do you know which surah it was brother?

[@ranonymous27]

@@fahim7153 Surah 13 Ar’ad verse 5

[@mikyasbaheru]

This channel is the sebeb that is bringing me back to Islam and being really content with it. All of you who are working to bring us this content, may Allah multiply your good deeds and grant you janatul firdaws Ameen.

[@SuperBallashotcalla]

the host does a great job of pushing back without taking over the argument

[@abdlldajani3528]

Yes he makes sure that Ustadh AbdulRahman explains his evidences and he does so clearly.

[@pearlsofadaab]

Just know brothers and sisters, that if the filth of music is present, you cannot have the love, nor taste the sweetness of the Quran in your heart

[@truthoverfalsehood__8757]

Thats because the music you used to listen to is filthy filth seeks filth

[@truthoverfalsehood__8757]

@@zaid4785 the dude was making claims of scholars he delibratly didn't mention all the scholars of the salaf who clearly state that music is allowed inclufing instruments, and he doesn't mention the scholars of the sunna from Saudi Arabia and the arab penensula who clearly state that music is not confirmed to be forbidden and that there is no consensus that it is forbidden. If you chose to follow 1 man instead of getting all the evidence go ahead you will suffer the consequence everyone who forbids what God made lawful will get a punishment out of it.

[@truthoverfalsehood__8757]

@@zaid4785 i dont know who you are but you enjoy the social media freedom of speech with your blind belief in statements by single men. Abdullah bin Ja’far bin Abi Talib (al-Aqd al-Fareed 6/12) Sh. Abu Hamed al-Ghazali (vol. 6 pg. 1150 al-Ihyaa’) Imam al-Shawkani (Ibtal da’wa al-Ijmaa ala mutlaq al-Sama’) Imam ibn Hazm (Al-Muhallah) Imam Abdul-Ghani al-Nablusi (Idaahat al-Dalalaat fee sama’ al-alaat) Sultan al-Ulema al-Iz ibn Abdul-Salam (Rislat al-Sama’) Al-Qadi Ibn Qutaiba al-Daynoor (al-Rukhsah fi al-Sama’) Imam Ibn Tahir al-Qaysirany (pg. 31 al-Sama’) Imam al-Thahabi (al-Rukhsah fil-Ghinaa wa al-Turb) Abu Talib al-Makky (Qoot al-Quloob) al-Qady Ibn Al-Araby al-Makky (Ahkam al-Quran vol. 3 pg. 1494) Sh. Yusuf al-Majishoon the prominent Muhaddith (#3399 ibn al-Khuthayma) Ibn Daqeeq al-Eid (Iqtinas al-Sawanih) Sh. Jad Ali jad al-Haqq (fatawah #3280) Sh. Mahmood Al-Shaltoot (pg. 375 fatawaah) Then go to the scholars of saudi arabis from who amongst many tell you that music is permissble and of wich NOT 1 SINGLE 1 will tell you it is a consensus that it is forbidden. You have 0 proof that music is forbidden only opinions of people other than the Prophet.

[@truthoverfalsehood__8757]

@@zaid4785 Exactly you have 0 education of the religion, 0 knowledge and repat claims like a parrot and you can copy statements like you want it doesnt make it true. I warn you not to make statements against the religion with 0 proofs because God punishes the one who does that. No saudi scholar says it is a consensus , it is not a consensus and hundreds of the salaf scholars were of the opinion that is is allowed and the burden of proof is on you for the principle tha everything is allowed till proven not allowed. Do what you want.

[@truthoverfalsehood__8757]

@@zaid4785 You give one example, show me everything shawqani said , and yoj dont know you just assume that shawqani didnt allow it. There is many many scholars who have not forbade it not made it allowed because the beginning is that everything is allowed except with evidence or natural disposition. So you have 0 evidence you just follow the statements of some scholars and lie about that its a cosensus who are you again? No saudi scholar says it is a consensus non of the great scholars of today wich are not many anymore say it is a consensus so again WHO ARE YOU ? Stop talking about the religion with no authority , everyone who comes from the point position that it is allowed comes from the default position, you need to prove the opposite and not only did you not do it but you accuse those who do not accept your claim with 0 authority.

[@abzdapoet]

I came for the poetry question and he didn't disappoint. May Allah reward these brothers with khayr. Aameen

[@saniissa3651]

Allahouma Amine

[@MrBobDug]

Ameen

[@daijadivine3393]

I’m half way through and still haven’t heard anything on this. What did he say?

[@RakhtanQ]

wa alaykum as-salam wa rahmatullah May Allah reward you immensely Ustad for making these podcasts Dont think I can express how much I have benefited from this channel An excellent source for contemporary issues

[@MuMu124]

I love how respectful they are to each other

[@deenislam178]

By Allah, Ya ustadh! I love these podcasts. May Allah increase your knowlegde! I benefit allot from you! I love you for the sake of Allah

[@anesjemal8873]

@@boejiden.11 It’s a comment which he might see it or might already had.

[@qari.abdullahi]

jazakumullahu kheyr, subhanallah listening to Ustadh Abdulrahman is always a pleasure, fasinated by his knowledge and his love for it

[@hassanalialqadiri]

alhamdullilah i have already stopped listening to music and any sort of beats or instrumentals months ago. it's always good to remind yourself of these actions i feel so you dont fall into doubt from the whispers of shaitan in the future. In Shaa Allah this will help us to stop listening to music and being involved in things that are prohibited as muslims

[@Bendy-sp8oj]

Well I'm 14 now I can't pray or read the Quran as my father never teach me the rakaat and timing of prayers and the Quran uses Arabic language so I need to learn Arabic then I can read as my mine languages is Malay and English. I'm slowly learning from my ustaz from madrasah.

[@hassanalialqadiri]

@@Bendy-sp8oj just be careful about this youtube channel brother. it's a wahabi, pseudo salafi one that is against us muslims having a connection with our prophet muhammad saw. they claims it's shirk and bidah so be careful who you listen to. anyone can dress a certain way, talk a certain way and focus on topics that every muslim can agree upon. but when i comes to the aiqidah, these people are corrupt and against sunnis.

[@Bendy-sp8oj]

@@hassanalialqadiri so corrupt people are who? Is it Shariah?

[@hassanalialqadiri]

@@Bendy-sp8oj it's a matter of aiqidah. the ustadh in the video believes that we have 0 connection with muhammad saw when in fact, Allah swt has given muhammad saw the ability to pray for his ummah and love each and every one of us. how can you love someone without having a connection with them? Allah swt has granted muhammad saw the knowledge. however, this ustadh claims it is shirk (Allah forbid) and thinks that asking waseela for our prophet which the companions did is a bidah! this same ustadh claims that there are so called conditions that are required for doing istigatha when in fact it states no one in the Quran and sunnah. i suggest you stay far away from him. this man is a pseudo salafi/ wahabi

[@yd5698]

@@hassanalialqadiri Dua is worship. Dua is only for Allah

[@muktarmohamud506]

Alx, I have benefited a lot from these podcasts

[@cabdiraxmanxirsi7092]

Watching from Hargeisa, Somaliland!!!

[@أبوشغل]

I remember the Ustadh saying that when music was prohibited, the music that was done at that time was then considered impermissible. So what about the music today, which has lyrics which promote zina, drugs, prostitution, calling women slang words for prostitutes, describing their bodies like objects and other sorts of shamelessness?

[@sweetcoffee2458]

I agree. Top charts music is humiliating to religion. However if underground music has benificial lyrics is it okay to listen to it? I haven't watched the podcast yet cause it's long

[@أبوشغل]

@@sweetcoffee2458 The messenger ﷺ prohibited musical instruments in general. The only exception that I know of is the daff during certain occasions. islamqa.info/en/answers/20406/when-is-it-permissible-to-beat-the-daff

[@RaihanShaheed]

ما شاء الله His memory...🔥🔥🔥

[@alihourag5070]

Allahumabarik, thanks akhi, i didnt know about al minshawi and al hussary. woow its amazing. May Allah swt reward every person thats involve in bring us content like that. Baraka Allahu fikum

[@zeea3500]

Magnificently clear and resoundingly indisputable... JazakALLAH Khair

[@anouaressanoussi]

Is there like a Playlist of the reciter in the beginning where he recites so calm and on a normal speed without making his voice go up and down? Maa shaa'Allah, Allahumma Baarik

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp3913]

The reciter is usatd abdurahaman himself

[@thetruebeliever3292]

@@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp3913 Link?

[@anouaressanoussi]

@@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp3913 Does he have a Playlist reciting so calm?

[@marufibrahim2950]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/g6rOp6asgs-Vn6c

[@Abu_Abdullah790]

Ya ikhwan, can you brothers do the beard next in sha Allah? JazakAllah khayrun

[@HM-ey3yj]

I feel that they can't do a hot seat 2 hour session on that topic. It's so clear, but it's a important topic, maybe they can have it a shorter format. Like the Q&A vids.

[@Abu_Abdullah790]

@@HM-ey3yj Allahu alim ya akhi, of course it is clear that it is Fardh, but there is difference of opinion on the length Perhaps you are right that it cannot be 2 hours tho

[@Abb-ve1me]

@@Abu_Abdullah790 Big part of turkish muslims believe that it is sunnah and no sin in shaving it. I have noticed morocon/arab/somalian brothers ussualy know it is fardh

[@lilsomething8905]

@@Abu_Abdullah790 According to the Shafi'i madhab, it's makrooh. I believe the Ustadh follows Shafi'ism.

[@shahee6579]

@@lilsomething8905 didn't imam nawawi say it's permissible to shave . He says it makrooh as opposed to haram to shave or trim . That's why a podcast would be good

[@busufyan]

I love how you brothers limit the time you spend on tangents. May Allah bless you.

[@MohammedAlSharif2002]

Make one about celebrating festivals such as: Christmas, thanksgiving, Halloween, and the likes. There are some modernists that claim the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم allowed his companions to celebrate an Arab festival and have taken this as proof that celebrating other festivals other than Eid is allowed as long it’s not a religious festival. May Allah bless you.

[@QuranicRemembrance]

I know the brother Imran made a hot seat video specifically on Halloween: kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5bZgWaEr75lhJY

[@Urbro_meast]

Also Easter and Valentines , just to name a few.

[@Ha_shah]

Also birthdays

[@kinguzi24]

Salam. Easter, Halloween, and Christmas have evil pagan origins so those are obvious haram celebrations, but birthdays and Thanksgiving don't have any religious ties whatsoever, so how are they haram to celebrate?

[@Urbro_meast]

@@kinguzi24 they are Haram to celebrate, because the disbelievers in Islam celebrate them.

[@AnswerEasy]

Question pertaining to the part 1:01:29​ Is this hadith authentic? Are there other examples from Al Bukhari where al Bukhari uses 'An and Qaala without the full isnaad for other sahih ahadith or is the hadith prohibitng music the only one where Al Bukhari says Qaala without the full isnaad? Jazakumullah khayran and barakAllah fikum for the completeness and the academic rigor, that has boosted my iman by itself subhanAllah. Salam

It would be beneficial if the references are displayed on the bottom

[@dheadzana]

thank you my own experience by in purpose stop listening to music since 2022 due to self realization because listening to music make me feel worst and now i choose Murotal / recitation of Quran instead to listen it bring me tenderness also i don't have tiktok, and rarely open reels / youtube short that have short content contain viral song / clip with music i also stop watching video clip of music like i used to before 2022 alhamdullilah Allah guide me and it bring tranquility for me

[@asha4102]

More importantly we should be worried about other topics for discussion.

[@bintjamiel2873]

Please make a full discussion about movies as well. May Allah increase you all in knowledge and preserve you and protect you all from all kinds of evil plots. Ameen

[@ObscureServant]

The fact that movies religiously include music in almost every scene is enough proof against their permissibility, and then comes all the lewd elements almost everything contains, along with free-mixing of non-mahrams, etc.

[@mustaquerabbani2142]

There’s too much mixing of Arabic and English it’s very confusing for someone who has no knowledge

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

@@thehourglassfan3515 Learn lol.

[@ahmad.maghdid]

جزاکم الله خیرا وبارك الله فیکم 🌹

[@javidseyadahmed6917]

I love this adorable turban. Looks really beautiful.

[@no-handlleee]

the intro is so calming

[@abuhasanal-athari5152]

Ma sha Allah Intro + voice 👌👌👌

[@Hornscope]

Ordinary Brother and sisters of today can't comprehend nor even understand what this brother is talking about. What he's talking about is a higher level of Islamic knowledge for those who understand Arabic language based on religion

[@rabbi619]

He is talking shit which many people know.

[@Hornscope]

@@rabbi619 I don't blame you, because you belong to deviant sects that allows music and Bid'a to spread among the muslims

[@Supermama786]

This seems like the most nuanced video on the issue of the permissibility of music . Allah humma Barik.

[@kimabunuh6762]

Brother you mention the عنعنة of Humayd at-Taweel and Qatadah and others are not accepted, but there is a difference of opinion between the scholars, at least in regards to their عنعنة in hadiths in sahih albukhari, so some say they are all accepted because it is in the sahih of albukhari, others say we treat it like it was any other book. It is important to mention these things. Even ibn hajar has the approach that the عنعنة is not just accepted just because it is in sahih albukhari.

[@nabeel8194]

Ma sha Allah good topics

[@khandokerasiqurrahaman7330]

Barakallahu feek our brother Abdur rahman

[@Usaid.Mithani]

جزاکم الله خيرا وبارك الله فيكم

[@kimabunuh6762]

Anyone interested in this must read shawkanis chapter on instruments in his nayl al-awtaar, things are not black and white on this issue.

[@zaag5997]

Please keep making more and more hot seat podcasts.

[@rm7250]

Music makes some people crazy … they start imagining like they the person in the music video were that be the model/rapper Some form of possession definitely involves after I stopped listening to music I feel more in tune with reality and not to mention more humble music defo makes you feel as if you have ego …

[@strivinglad8749]

2:05:00 Shahid has good acting skills you know!

[@Nagasyari]

I wish when they use arabic terms, they would describe what they mean.

[@xrussian1x545]

Salaam Alaikum. I am a revert to Islam Alhamdulillah and I have a 1 year old baby girl. My family are not Muslim and they like to play nursery rhymes, play music to my baby. I understand that this is haram however how do I make my mother stop playing music with my baby and what can she replace it with? JazakAllah Khair

[@Ayattl]

No music nasheeds perhaps. kzbin.info/www/bejne/b6eyi6WPp66Jm5I

[@IrnBrummmmmmm0]

this man can talk as fast as ussein bolt can run

[@abdalrahmanhasan6150]

Ma shaa Allah

[@Mofamisa77]

Masha allah i love watching this,jaza,akumullh.

[@FluffyPancakeNinja]

Who does the intro? Masha’Allah those are some smooth background sounds. 🙃

[@sahihtamil2375]

Assalamualaikkum ustadh, please make an episode of the feminism, it's of the dire need in todays world. The western idealogy have corrupted the Muslims.

[@perilouslambasting6816]

Daniel Haqiqatjou has a lot of good content on this subject as well as secularism and pornography etc

[@hasana8427]

The western ideology has not corrupted our religion, rather it has corrupted us and we corrupted ourselves. I don’t want to blame it on the western ideology rather I want to blame it on ourselves because we are responsible to learn ( talking to myself first), and know what to do in these type of situations. والله اعلم correct me if I’m wrong

[@sahihtamil2375]

@@hasana8427 assalamualaikkum, yes you are absolutely right, I mean our religion as in the sense, us Muslims, we all know our religion the deen is the best way a person can lead a life, we affirm it. But I should have been clear in that comment, anways changed jazakkallah khair.

[@skyinuri8868]

UP

[@oladoyinraheem1482]

There is a podcast about feminism with Ustadh Tim Humble. It’s recent

[@MyKatarzyna1]

it is still not very clear what is the difference between permissible and impermissible singing

[@Farad-uw2sn]

There’s no singing in Islam

[@haych6782]

Music is a disease, you will find that when you see someone start practising in deen they will tell you that the first thing they did was quit music. May Allah azawajal guide us all and have mercy upon us.

[@pearlsofadaab]

Your account will be with Allah regardless.

[@tidianehaidara3907]

Jazak Allahu Kheir

[@kimabunuh6762]

Please read this from nayl al-awtaar: وقد اختلف في الغناء مع آلة من آلات الملاهي وبدونها، فذهب الجمهور إلى التحريم مستدلين بما سلف. وذهب أهل المدينة ومن وافقهم من علماء الظاهر وجماعة من الصوفية إلى الترخيص في السماع ولو مع العود واليراع. وقد حكى الأستاذ أبو منصور البغدادي الشافعي في مؤلفه في السماع أن عبد الله بن جعفر كان لا يرى بالغناء بأسا ويصوغ الألحان لجواريه ويسمعها منهن على أوتاره، وكان ذلك في زمن أمير المؤمنين علي رضي الله عنه. وحكى الأستاذ المذكور مثل ذلك أيضا عن القاضي شريح وسعيد بن المسيب وعطاء بن أبي رباح والزهري والشعبي. وقال إمام الحرمين في النهاية وابن أبي الدم: نقل الاثبات من المؤرخين أن عبد الله بن الزبير كان له جوار عوادات، وأن ابن عمر دخل عليه وإلى جنبه عود فقال: ما هذا يا صاحب رسول الله؟ فناوله إياه فتأمله ابن عمر فقال: هذا ميزان شامي، قال ابن الزبير: يوزن به العقول. وروى الحافظ أبو محمد بن حزم في رسالته في السماع لسنده إلى ابن سيرين قال: أن رجلا قدم المدينة بجوار فنزل على عبد الله بن عمر وفيهن جارية تضرب، فجاء رجل فساومه فلم يهو منهن شيئا، قال: انطلق إلى رجل هو أمثل لك بيعا من هذا، قال: من هو؟ قال: عبد الله بن جعفر فعرضهن عليه فأمر جارية منهم فقال لها: خذي العود فأخذته فغنت فبايعه ثم جاء إلى ابن عمر إلى آخر القصة. وروى صاحب العقد العلامة الأديب أبو عمر الأندلسي أن عبد الله بن عمر دخل على أبي جعفر فوجد عنده جارية في حجرها عود ثم قال لابن عمر: هل ترى بذلك بأسا؟ قال: لا بأس بهذا. وحكى الماوردي عن معاوية وعمرو بن العاص أنهما سمعا العود عند ابن جعفر. وروى أبو الفرج الأصبهاني أن حسان بن ثابت سمع من عزة الميلاء الغناء بالمزهر بشعر من شعره. وذكر أبو العباس المبرد نحو ذلك، والمزهر عند أهل اللغة العود. وذكر الأدفوي أن عمر بن عبد العزيز كان يسمع من جواريه قبل الخلافة. ونقل ابن السمعاني الترخيص عن طاوس. ونقله ابن قتيبة وصاحب الامتاع عن قاضي المدينة سعد بن إبراهيم بن عبد الرحمن الزهري من التابعين. ونقله أبو يعلى الخليلي في الارشاد عن عبد العزيز بن سلمة الماجشون مفتي المدينة. وحكى الروياني عن القفال أن مذهب مالك بن أنس إباحة الغناء بالمعازف. وحكى الأستاذ أبو منصور الفوراني عن مالك جواز العود.

[@romioz9982]

Is there a digital copy of nayl Alawtaar

[@Religions.of.fandom]

BarakAllahu Feek

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp3913]

Me:*shows friend music is haram* Friend:starts beatboxing Me:🤦🏻‍♂️

[@Lockeditin]

BRO HAHAHAH

[@MrBobDug]

Lol that's hilarious crazy thing is it gets into your heart and makes you halfway majnoon. So that sounds like exactly the correct response

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp3913]

@@MrBobDug ok

[@Lockeditin]

@Bilal Demede You right

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

@Bilal Demede this better akhi? Lol

[@Mybackisbr0ken]

Is it possible someone could elaborate on the point made at 2:30:47 please. I listened to a reciter who’s recitation and melody sounded lovely to me and he to my knowledge seems to do the tajweed right. And I try imitate him in 2 of his recitations and would like to what type of recitation is to be avoided.

[@AH23232]

I haven't watched it yet but I know that there's a specific type of Qur'an recitation which is prohibited where the reciter/shaytaan recites to the tune of real music (!). I'll update you once I've watched the whole episode inshaa'Allah

[@Mybackisbr0ken]

@@AH23232 JazakAllahu khairan. So do they recite the Qur'an in a way where they compromise tajweed to make it match a made up melody?

[@AH23232]

@@Mybackisbr0ken Yes, they do from what I know. Wa iyyak akhi

[@Mybackisbr0ken]

@@AH23232 is there any recites who you'd recommend that dont fall into this category my brother?

[@AH23232]

@@Mybackisbr0ken Tbh, I'm unsure of who really recites the Qur'an properly nowadays. Most of the really famous ones do way too much emphasis on their voice and not enough emphasis on the wording. The Ustadh is really good masha'Allah but he hasn't released recordings of the whole Qur'an unfortunately. Mishary Rashid is a fairly safe bet, but he still does a lot with his voice that some would view as maybe slightly unnecessary, but not haraam. Check out Mahmoud al-Hussary - scholars have recommended him and said that his recitation was close to that of the Salaf masha'Allah, I believe he is dead now, may Allah have Mercy on him. Hope this helps. You should be able to figure out what's ok by listening to Ustadh AbdulRahman and Al-Hussary and figuring out a guideline from there. If worst comes to worst, ask someone knowledgeable. I'm just a baby when it comes to knowledge, so my help is very limited.

[@grantmedical]

As-salaamu 'alaykum... I am content with the quality of this discourse... It truly fulfills the needs of the advanced student of knowledge... And Allah SWT knows best... My concern is that this method of discussing the topic may be distracting for beginner students of knowledge... I think it would help if the Ustad would be allowed to complete his entire argument and THEN the proofs can be challenged... by challenging the proofs directly each time as they are mentioned may cause the listener to become lost... However as for me - I look forward to further discussions by you brothers (of this type) on all contemporary issues... May Allah richly bless you and accept your efforts... Ameen

[@kimabunuh6762]

Brother in the niqab debate the interviewer mentioned ibn abbas status and that the prophet made dua for him, you chose another sahabis ta’weel of an ayah then, now you are saying about ibn abbas what the interviewer said maybe because it fits with the qawl you follow?

[@wolf4302]

Who is doing the recitation of the Holy Quran in the beginning??

[@mikailbaruwa9036]

I understand from this lecture that music is implicitly/technically haram....

[@justabrother356]

@@thehourglassfan3515 Follow the salaf; then it's clear.

[@lear.6052]

I would like to know where can I find the evidences brought to the table in this discussion. Could someone please guide me to it? English or Arabic doesn’t matter.

[@Goodborni]

Jazakallahu khair brothers, I was wondering where to we send questions to? I was wondering regarding to our stance (Muslims) towards non Muslims, are we supposed to feel indifferent towards them, hate them, love them or what? Barakallahu feek

[@AH23232]

We must hate the non-Muslims, as they disbelieve and are arrogant and ignorant towards Allah. We must hate them, and everything associated with their religions and disbelief. "You will not find a people who believe in Allah and the Last Day having affection for those who oppose Allah and His Messenger, even if they were their fathers or their sons or their brothers or their kindred. Those - He has decreed within their hearts faith and supported them with spirit1 from Him. And We will admit them to gardens beneath which rivers flow, wherein they abide eternally. Allah is pleased with them, and they are pleased with Him - those are the party of Allah. Unquestionably, the party of Allah - they are the successful." 58:22 Therefore we can see it is not permissible to befriend and love the Kuffar. JazakAllahu Khayran. As for asking questions, I believe the email is [e-mail] so feel free to send questions there. May Allah bless you.

[@Goodborni]

@@AH23232 Barakallahu feek, however I want a student of knowledge or scholarly answer, because that verse could be specific for people who attack Islam only, because when the prophet went to the Christian King, I do not know of a hadeeth or proof of him hating them, actually opposite was said.

[@AH23232]

@@Goodborni This general explanation is taken from Usool al-Thalatha by Sheikh Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahhab, and a Sharh of it by Sheikh Haytham Sarhan and Sheikh ibn Uthaymeen. We must hate all disbelievers, however we must treat them in this world with mercy and kindness, but you must show displeasure towards their disbelief and actively disapprove of their religions and celebrations. This ayat is clearly general and encompasses all disbelievers, and you can clearly see that. There are also, as far as I am aware, other evidences for this, but none come to mind. If we have a general ayat, then we cannot restrict it until another evidence comes which restricts it.

[@Goodborni]

@@AH23232 Jazakallahu khair

[@أبوشغل]

{{You already have an excellent example in Abraham and those with him, when they said to their people, “We totally dissociate ourselves from you and ˹shun˺ whatever ˹idols˺ you worship besides Allah. We reject you. The enmity and hatred that has arisen between us and you will last until you believe in Allah alone.”.....}} (60:4)

[@sabeehakausar55]

Who recites the Quran at the beginning of the podcast , name plz

[@Ha_shah]

The ustadh himself

[@abdulsamadrabiu2171]

Assalamu Alaykum Ustadh...Please I need to know if it is permissible to imitate the Adhaan of the Muadhin of Haramain. Jazakumullah khairan

[@mutakaakulu7398]

Can anyone please tell me who is recurring Quran in the introduction

[@admin202]

sum: why do u want to listen to music when you have Qur'an? So if we really have Qur'an in our life, music will automatically be far away.

[@shokzz1532]

Is it true that Imam Abu Haneefah was also very harsh against music?

[@Ahmed-ll4dq]

Assalamu Aleykom, it seems to me that the word "Ghina" refers to singing but also music, is this true? Because in some parts of this podcast the word "Ghina" translates as singing and in some parts you translate it as Music.

[@peanutbutter4726]

I have a very important question PLEASE answer; so it was said that even reading Quran in a studied melodious way is haram... I currently memorize it from qari mishary al afasy which is very melodious if you are aware of it and this helps to memorize so I try to do it exactly the same way and copy the tone,,,Is this okay??!

[@nasirosman96]

Answer Praise be to Allah. Making one’s voice beautiful when reciting Qur’aan is something that is prescribed and was enjoined by the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) listened to the recitation of Abu Moosa al-Ash’ari and liked it, and he told him, “You have been given a melodious voice like that of Dawood.” (Muslim, Salaat al-Musaafireen, 793). On this basis, if the imam of a mosque imitates a person who has a beautiful voice and recites beautifully in order to make his own voice and recitation of the Book of Allaah more beautiful, this is something which is prescribed for him and for others, because it moves the worshippers praying behind him, and makes them focus, listen and pay attention to the recitation. Allaah bestows His bounty on whomsoever He wills and He is the owner of great bounty. Source:www.google.com/amp/s/islamqa.info/amp/en/answers/26196

[@peanutbutter4726]

@@nasirosman96 jazakAllah kheir that clears it up👍 what he said really confused me but he must have meant something else.

[@syedsaad1594]

@@peanutbutter4726 He was talking about those who go into ghuloo, with the "maqaamaat", and to raise or lower voices specifically at specific moments etc., (not to be confused with tajweed, this is something entirely else) and these people are very strict in teaching their students these. This is what is not allowed, and Shaykh Ibn Baaz (rahimahullah) has a fatwa on it.

[@peanutbutter4726]

@@syedsaad1594 ok thank you that makes sense now never heard of something like this before! May Allah guide the Muslim umma

[@sm5033]

Can you explain music in documentary’s ones that are educational bit movies of no be fit like for example a animal documentary that’s if use to you etc

[@AH23232]

Assalaamu alaikum, I would say that it's best to avoid these things; they are a waste of time and not beneficial enough to justify the music within them. If you want to watch these things, either mute the show so the music cannot taint your heart and put on subtitles, or go to the park/outdoors and contemplate on Allah's creation there inshaa'Allah. But I would recommend doing beneficial acts of worship instead (eg. seeking knowledge, watching Islamic discussions such as these, reciting/learning Qur'an etc). In saying that, none of us are perfect and I myself waste time on non-beneficial things. May Allah forgive us our shortcomings and help us to improve

[@sm5033]

@@AH23232 say for example I’m in a class and I’m watching a video in that topic but the person that explaining the topic uses music in this case what should I do many don’t have subtitles although some do and those that do I do read rather than watch

[@perilouslambasting6816]

@@sm5033 it's a good point my brother/sister. Like the commenter above already mentioned, if possible, mute things and use subtitles. Otherwise, a lot of the time I've found it's possible to lower the volume to the extent you can get the speech without really hearing the music. Also you can look for alternative vids, or use KZbin subtitles /subtitle mods for deaf people. There are always ways alhamdulillah and Allah makes ways for those who fear him. May Allah allow us to practice what we preach :/

[@sm5033]

@@perilouslambasting6816 ameen and thank you

[@perilouslambasting6816]

@@thehourglassfan3515 not movies lol, they've got their own issues. But with documentaries etc you can still reflect on Allah's creation without listening to the music etc. Movies is a different kettle of fish completely, there's issues other than music like uncovering of awrahs and suggestive clothing and stuff too

[@kimabunuh6762]

Bukhari did make tadlees of his imam ath-thuhali according to imam ath-thababi. Allah knows best.

[@BritishCableTV]

It's just today's music that's bad but music in general is not actually haram

[@ahmedbilal760]

please someone tell me the name of the guy reading the quran in the into.

[@iftekherhossain4338]

Its Ustaadh Abdurrahman, the teacher in this video.

[@strivinglad8749]

2:05:00 Shahid has good acting skills you know! Lol

[@technologylover121]

Isn’t the duff permissible?

[@MuslimahForLife27]

Yes but only in certain situations

[@M313-u8d]

@@technologylover121source?

[@dustyzbrick9510]

@@M313-u8djust watch the video he addressed it you guys click on the video and go straight to the comments I don’t get it

[@nayemrahman80]

music is not haram if it is not contain bad words

[@masterlol8258]

mashallah ya sheikh. this guy's opinion transcends the consensuses of the 4 imams.

[@afeefbinabbas2000]

Assalamu 'Alaikum Can you please share the notes of Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan. Can I can get to those references and statements of scholars.

[@tawheed1st316]

Make a discussion like this on reliability of the ahadeeth !!

[@hassansheikh8544]

This is not related to the video but its a question i have. Since it is allowed to do the marriage contract when a girl has not reached puberty. Just like Aishah RA did. Although, consummating that marriage is only when she has reached it. So if a man divorces a girl like in this situation, will there be a iddah of 3 months? I would think that the answer would be no because in in the Quran 33:49 “O believers! If you marry believing women and then divorce them before you touch them, they will have no waiting period for you to count, so give them a ˹suitable˺ compensation, and let them go graciously.” But then in surah 65:4 “As for your women past the age of menstruation, in case you do not know, their waiting period is three months, and those who have not menstruated as well. As for those who are pregnant, their waiting period ends with delivery. And whoever is mindful of Allah, He will make their matters easy for them.” When Allah says “and those who have not menstruated as well” who is this talking about? Is it the women who have reached puberty but do not have they’re cycles because of some problem or is it the girls who have married that are still immature?

[@MyKatarzyna1]

also did i understood correct that singing without instruments and recitation of the quran comes under he same category that is permissible

[@gaziz3225]

Melodic singing for rhyming like todays music is not the same as Quran. He said singing like to a baby, animal or singing yourself for motivation quickly is. But not todays music type

[@MyKatarzyna1]

Salam alaikum I wonder what about humming or making noise with beat boxing called what is ruling on that

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

Haram

[@shaans2822]

I havent watch the video but its already clear that music is haram. I want to say to those who listen to music and to those who debate about music - fear allah. Dont you know one of signs of judgement day is music being halal ( as far as i remember ). Music is haram.

[@Halaloutdoorkitchen]

SubhanAllah these pods feel like ghey are 10 minutes long. It goes so fast. I need more off these pods Allahuma barek

[@imanabdikarim803]

Please please can you guys upload the podcasts onto the apple podcasts app

[@AMAUofficial]

As-salaamu 'alaykum warahmatullahi wabarakaatuhu. The Hot Seat Podcast is now being uploaded onto the AMAU Podcast platform. You can access it from the links below, in shaa Allah: iTunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/al-madrasatu-al-umariyyah/id1524526782 Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/08NJC1pIA0maaF6aKqZL4N

[@gbedetemitope]

Jazaakumullahu khairan

[@binthsabeer7573]

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmathullahi wa barakathuhu Doubt 1 : if prophet( saw )allowed those two women to do what they are doing,( Beautifully rising their voice), then is it allowed in islam to beautify women's voice in front of non mehram. Or is there any exception?! Doubt 2: Allah ajja wajal use the word كره for the probihibited things. So, ulamaul muwaddhimeen has used in the same way. So, what is the evidence for the mutha'akhhireen usage "disliked(not completely prohibited)" for the word كره، in the islamic sciences??? Why they dont mean complete probition by كره ? Jazakumullahu khairah

[@romioz9982]

Doubt 1 the word used for these females was جارية (jariyah) that basically means small girls. So they justify it by saying it's ok because they are kids. Doubt 2: I don't really have knowledge about that

[@ferdousahmed5159]

Which surah is it in the intro??

[@SIGSEGV1337]

Surah Al-Ra'd, ayah 5

[@fauziajasia2548]

Is the recitation of Omar Hisham Al Arabi considered as musical tone like that you mentioned lastly?

[@maryamnoor8764]

Yes, he uses autotune as well.

[@fauziajasia2548]

@@maryamnoor8764 his recitations were one of the factors that brought me closer to Islam (ofcourse by Allah's will) and my iman increases whenever I listen to his recitations with translation....why would something haram bring so much benefit in my life??

[@AH23232]

@@fauziajasia2548 I'll rewrite this - you can't use the ends to justify a means. For example, on this basis one may argue that you can steal money in order to give sadaqah, or lie to someone about Islam in order to get them to take a Shahadah. This is not the basis upon which you can say something is permissible. Hope you understand inshaa'Allah

[@aatif7518]

@@fauziajasia2548 just because Allah guided you through him, doesn't mean he is invincible

[@fauziajasia2548]

@@AH23232 I am not actively stating that something is permissible, rather I am questioning the prohibition of that thing. There's a difference. And with all due respect I DON'T think your COMPARISON of "giving sadaqa by stealing" to my "increasing iman by listening to a certain kind of recitation" is RIGHT !! WHY? Because, if charity is given through haram money then that charity is NOT charity at all or it's not inherently good. But when I feel closer to my Creator by listening a certain kind of recitation then can you claim that my "increase of iman" here is inherently bad/wrong?? How can the increase of iman be wrong just like a false sadaqa with haram money? So according to that my increase in iman is false too??!

[@nidaeshaque]

Regarding reciting Qur'an like music which is impermissible, the example of that is Omar hisham al arabi. Please stay away from listening to his recitation. He has gone way overboard and his recitation sounds like music wallah

[@Shehryarzaheer112]

With due respect, It's quite unfortunate to see when somebody trying to prove Ijma for which he doesn't have any daleel, tries to alter the meanings of words of Quran to satisfy his belief. When somebody is speaking more arabic than english and as soon as he starts commenting on Quran, he doesn't even knows the meaning of the words of the Quran himself, rather he tries to get the meaning of the words of the Quran from a scholar which supports his beliefs. I pray we accept the authority of the Quran to differentiate between right or wrong rather than trying to prove the Quran from the Ijma.

[@technologylover121]

Is free mixing permissible then if the prophet watched the slave girl dancing?

[@immortalxsoul]

I wonder if Prophet(pbuh) and his companions sat and talked about music being Haram or not for almost 3 hours.

[@المجرتيني]

why would they? the companions obeyed the prophet SAW without question, so they already knew music is haram. nowdays people will argue with hadith so it needs to be clear.

[@RayB432]

​@@المجرتينيIf it's not in Quran its not haram.

[@المجرتيني]

@@RayB432 Allah says in the Quran to obey the prophetﷺ. If you disobey the prophet, firstly you are not a muslim anymore. secondly you are directly going against the command of Allah to obey him.

[@RayB432]

@@المجرتيني Quran never says to obey the Prophet, it says to obey the Messenger. The Messengers duty is to deliver the Message, the Message is the Quran. Obey the Messenger by obeying the commandments in the Quran. Obeying Messenger is not separate from obeying the Message. Every Messenger is to be obeyed. Every Messenger mentioned in the Quran was to be obeyed. Obeying Messenger is obeying the Quran.

[@المجرتيني]

@@RayB432 prophet muhammadﷺ is a messenger and also a prophet. same thing, obey him. and the prophetﷺ was given the Quran and he also taught us through his words. and Allah says in the Quran, prophet muhammadﷺ doesnt speak from his own accord. he speaks from wahi. “every messenger is to be obeyed” yes thats true, but your messenger is muhammadﷺ and you disobey him by rejecting his words and his teachings. you cannot take part of this religion and leave part of it. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment. Quran 59:7 the sahaba took this verse as a general commandment by Allah, and they took the orders of the messengerﷺ the same as they took the orders of Allah all mighty.

[@SalmanMalik-zf7lc]

What about reciting morning and evening athkar in the way you recite Quran, is this permissable?

[@ابوآسيةالسويسري]

did the prophet ﷺ do that?

[@DefplayMustapha]

Salamualaykum warahmatullah. Please upload on the podcast platforms. The last few Hot Seat podcast episodes have not been. Some of us live in countries where internet data is a luxury. KZbin eats a lot of data, so the podcast is a better alternative. Jazakhallahu khayran

[@imanabdikarim803]

Yeah I just said this it’s been a long time since they uploaded on the podcasts app

[@AMAUofficial]

Wa 'alaykumussalaam warahmatullahi wabarakaatuhu. The Hot Seat Podcast is now being uploaded onto the AMAU Podcast platform. You can access it from the links below, in shaa Allah: iTunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/al-madrasatu-al-umariyyah/id1524526782 Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/08NJC1pIA0maaF6aKqZL4N

[@redman6790]

Salam, does the host play devils advocate or is he sincerely challenging Ustadh? (I’m just curious, so not claiming the brother is doing anything Haram btw its great cos it helps extends each conversation and disseminates common arguments that may be used)

[@farasatlatif1301]

Devil's advocate (for want of a better word(

[@alisaeed4129]

Please tell me this brothers name. SubhanAllah he is so well informed.. Does Anyone know his Name. InshaAllah. Jazakullah khair

[@studentofknowledge6431]

Abdulrahman hassan

[@muhammedsharookh8912]

What did ibn hazm said about music?

[@26nurhakim]

www.dar-alifta.org/foreign/ViewFatwa.aspx?ID=4866

[@haych6782]

Please do one on khurooj or the beard. Hayakallah

[@mrnazirkhan]

Brother I sincerely don't accept your opinion, But wallahi Allah has blessed you with alot of knowledge. To call yourself ustad shows are humble you are as a brother

[@sweetcoffee2458]

Can I ask what your opinion is? Because I still doubt the ruling of music

[@mrnazirkhan]

Schlors like shaukani have said it is fine to listen to music

[@evilhunter8542]

@@mrnazirkhan when قال الله and قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم and the understanding of the Ashaab is mentiomed, you bring the opinion of later men? Really?

[@mrnazirkhan]

Brother you have to understand difference of opinion, hadeeth is a science schlors have their own interpretation on this. Bring me one sahih hadeeth without any issues in its isnad on music, NOT entertainment. I personally don't like Music, but I won't say GOD said it's haram, I don't have the audacity to say that.

[@sweetcoffee2458]

@@mrnazirkhan I share the same views. But because I'm scared to fall into sin I stopped listening to music

[@irmeen]

Is daff playing allowed on eid and marriage?

[@sweetcoffee2458]

I think yes

[@limitedquantitysufiyyahexp4905]

@@thehourglassfan3515 What game are you playing man? 🤔

[@umarfaridi6230]

Please do a video on taking / paying interest in the west

[@GhulamMustafa11111]

Islam is for the East and the West my bro

[@AH23232]

@@GhulamMustafa11111 I think he's trying to say this because there are certain cases in the West where you can't really avoid Riba, although the only case I'm aware of where it is genuinely permitted because of necessity is in the case of car insurance/medical insurance if your company requires you to have it. Other than that, there are generally ways around eg. paying university out of your own pocket etc. Also, lots of deviated speakers in the West are now permitting Riba in student loans etc so there is a lot of confusion within the Muslim community, and lots of people are falling into it because of this. There isn't such confusion in the East really.