“Israel Does NOT Want To End This War” Deadly Gaza Hostage Raid

[@ahmadzeiad3748]

The fact that people are debating about weather Palestinians deserve to live and not get bombed is disgusting

[@1234singer]

They discuss how to end the war. Don't dramatise

[@ahmadzeiad3748]

@1234singer they were literally saying "did israel go too far" even after killing more than 40,000 people

[@kroubian]

@@ahmadzeiad3748 Please ask if Hamas went too far, why are they still threatening Israel, saying that Oct 7 will happen over and over again? Is this not enough to eliminate Hamas? Yes, there are casualties, but first, the number is supplied by Hamas, who said it is to their advantage to have civilian deaths, how accurate is it, and how many were killed by errant rockets which about a third land inside Gaza, and how many are actual Hamas fighters?

[@NAStheNomad]

@@kroubianHamas is bad but why seek revenge on innocent people? Did the women, babies, aid workers attack Israel?

[@kroubian]

@@NAStheNomad Nobody is targeting civilians intentionally. Please stop drinking the Hamas supplied koolaid

[@MrShenanigans_01]

'I also want to adress that America did not give the land back'. Wow

[@edk484]

Israël gave the Gazastrip back in exchange for peace. Look what Israël ' received'....rockets, rape, hatred

[@suesue8882]

Exactly, she actually thought that this would speak for Israel & Israel has the right to commit the same crime ?

[@johnstaples8214]

@@suesue8882 Wars have consequences. Sorry.

[@AbdulRahmanAbdullah-yy6ml]

So funny

[@avacigar5502]

@@suesue8882 When you choose to fight a war and then lose it bad things happen

[@TantzAerine]

Emily lost the debate the moment she accepted the analogy of Israel being like the Americans pushing natives out and said 'well the Americans never gave the land back so...'

[@avacigar5502]

She was suggesting that Americans have no right to point fingers at Israel about occupation because their own country was 100% stolen from its indigenous peoples. So why should anyone listen to what they say? They have no credibility whatsoever Give your own country back to it’s rightful owners and return to Europe Then let’s talk !

[@waterthroughyouropenhands]

She lost it way before that point in my opinion :]]

[@luisortega3090]

​@@avacigar5502 Do you think that South Africa should not have been the one to bring about the genocide case to the ICJ because they have a history with apartheid? That isn't them "pointing fingers", that's them seeing the same horrors that tainted their country's legacy playing out on a more violent scale in Israel. Countries which have an explicitly violent and oppressive past have a moral duty to be the first ones to call out other rogue states. Same thing with the US, this is the largest colonial project that has existed in history and we pretend like it is completely justified. As Americans, we are funding this war and should be the very first ones calling the Israeli government out for it's blatant disregard for human life.

[@avacigar5502]

@@luisortega3090 As Americans you should be setting an example to Israel by vacating your stolen country and returning to Europe Until you do that then all you are doing is blowing hot air

[@avacigar5502]

@@luisortega3090 As Americans you should be setting an example by returning your stolen country to its rightful owners which (ironically) is what the (wh1te) European South Africans eventually did !! Until then your words mean absolutely nothing

[@Bell-uf9fn]

I could listen to Dave all day. This is the best discussion on the Gaza war you’ve had on your channel to date. Dave should be a regular contributor.

[@Hoppelite]

Dave is the most consistent mf you know! I adore him. He’s the most solid political influencer in the online scene

[@redcrow5607]

This is the kind of civilised conversation you can have when you dont obsess over whether a guest condems hamas or not.

[@reginaekl8290]

Hamaz is a terror organisation. Full stop, there is no question about that fact.

[@shirelove1928]

What about fake condems of evil Isreal side of media and human trafficking settlers in Gaza

[@stormz761]

Israel has committed crimes against humanity, but you can’t admit that ever, why??

[@LC12345]

Do you condemn this conversation?

[@markhill1066]

Lol so true

[@Footballmoments-b5z]

Did anyone saw Emily's face when David said Israel has been occupying Palestinians since 1967?

[@barflytom3273]

ML-engineer. yes ı did, pitiful.

[@COBYKOEHL2]

It's a lie. Palestinians decided they were Palestinians in 1963

[@COBYKOEHL2]

SHOW US PALESTINIAN COINS FROM ANY CENTURY.

[@vinasel96]

Of course, because it's a lie.

[@dani-ks9cg]

Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad speaking on Al-Hekma TV said in March 2012: “Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians…”

[@matthewkeane4599]

Wow, finally a debate on this issue where no one spoke over each other 👏

[@RadiantStar8997]

The Izrli bottle-blonde spokeswomen probably got a ticking-off for their smirking, rude interuptions and lack of empathy for Palestin civilian casualties. The lying spokespersons like Elon were kicked out by Izrl or simply lost the debate. That leaves the Palestin spokespersons who've been calmer than their opponents and brought their history to the forefront leaving the Izrli propaganda biting the dust.

[@melmokmo]

Because there are no zionist witches and demons

[@johnstaples8214]

Not quite accurate, but whatever.

[@zodwareeby279]

True even our Piers Morgan seems to act like a gentleman today.

[@Freeisraelfromevil]

Not true bald guy intervene Emely

[@saz_94]

I could listen to Omar Baddar & Dave Smith speak on this topic all day. Emily, go read a few books.

[@evgenyvdovin2812]

As if you’ve read at least one.

[@hectorgrand7813]

Piers has a very selective memory. Wow. It's incredible how lasting his moral quandary is after so many months.

[@kenfigg2871]

It’s because he’s a useless individual full of his own importance & supported Isreal 100percent at the start of this genocide no he had his eyes opened by this evil state he’s coming around to see who’s right it is to live in Palistine without evil Isreal

[@abiodunbilesanmi5803]

It is rather a longstanding moronic quandary

[@NF-ru8on]

Piers is a Jackal. He is very intelligent. He is very twisted.

[@hectorgrand7813]

@@NF-ru8on I don't find him intelligent AT ALL. Did you watch the one with Prof. Mearsheimer? Half the show was Piers not understanding anything. It was SO frustrating.

[@timmcdraw7568]

Its just his factory settings. He’s a nothing, its all a schtick. His voice, his tone, his ideas, his “quandaries”. All just nothing more than his show asking as his personality.

[@MA-rq6ye]

Omar is such a calm and smart

[@jakeybonz]

Hahhaah

[@taraldomland8657]

True

[@nouramirdamadi4511]

yes indeed. Excellent debating skills.

[@ACogloc]

The contrast with the typical pro-Palestinian debater is striking.

[@Starsky1413]

He doesn’t mention the rockets fired at Israel in 2014.

[@zeinjaber6923]

Look who’s back! Piers moral quandary Morgan

[@HARLEYSees]

Kunna morgan

[@larryl164]

Piers in aximoron condition.

[@etherspin]

As opposed to people who take a polar position quickly as possible?

[@mcm6660]

😂😂 So true, it's his favourite nonsensical statement, which has replaced, "Do you condemn Hamassss?"

[@smulin01]

🤣🤣🤣

[@Danny-os6ci]

Omg finally a panel of people capable of having a meaningful discussion without arguing over each other. Amazing. Never thought I would see it on Piers Morgan

[@user-ef5ro4xd8y]

Piers still has moral quandary about war crimes though, should he support them or not? A very hard question for him, obviously.

[@howardhavardramberg333]

Agreed, please never again bring back James or Hasan if you’re going to debate things seriously, they have no sense of curtesy.

[@boukezzoulaomar]

If they have no moral courtesy to you ... does it mean they have none to us ? (Pro Palestine ) Isn't that a disgusting racist supremacy ?? ​@@howardhavardramberg333

[@MrMabloom]

Yes one of the more respectful debates. Good job by Piers and the panel. We can’t get anywhere if we just talk over each other.

[@gs123]

I appreciate that, for the most part, the guests were able to speak without it degenerating into a shouting match

[@blackbeard6099]

💯

[@zigalisjak]

even Piers lmao...

[@Jake-jr2zh]

That blonde woman is clueless.

[@seashell4910]

No she just evil

[@karinpowers1018]

She's also dumb. She even completely misused the word "equivocate." Not once but twice.

[@Straight-Outta-Nottingham]

Did you really need to say blonde woman 😅 theres only one woman there mate

[@anonnymous31]

She's a proper NPC. One word and she gets triggered like a robot.

[@colinpeck8257]

Not clueless but extemely one sided, pro Isreal...

[@hayahasan1559]

Who the hell is that Emily ? She is been given air time multiple times and she clearly doesn't know enough about what she's talking about. Why they keep bringing her back?

[@maya4291]

It’s because she’s pretty

[@beebeebee7000]

Are you jewlous that she is Jewish, smart, educated, eloquent and GORGEOUS?

[@Santinal-iv8ze]

​@@maya4291 ah no she isn't

[@AssassinsCreedTop]

@@beebeebee7000😂 good joke

[@HarryMah]

@@beebeebee7000 Let’s not get carried away . Jews may own a lot of wealth , but you certainly don’t own beauty !

[@tb.ayyub24]

See how piers humanises Israeli hostages by giving them a story but nothing about literal innocent children…with that he still has a moral quandary. Bloody monster.

[@n3roc]

It was refreshing to hear a debate that guests listen to each other and wait their turn to speak. As Piers eluded many times, without this the debates are worthless.

[@BonnieHaynes-gg4nk]

Most of his debates are annoying shoutfests

[@lilyannal5159]

Does winner always rule? Israelis won the war for the land, fair and square. No Palestine state exist in history--occupation 1967 Arafat coined up Palestinians name. They simply were a misfit Arab tribal that belong to Jordan and Egypt.

[@Sam-mw4lh]

People like Emily don't need to be listened to, she's nothing more then a propogandist.

[@ChrisAlbertH47]

I personally don't see the need for "debates". None of them are policy makers, the only thing they're litigating are their positions in the court of public opinion. Morgan does a terrible job moderating when the guests don't behave themselves, so the proper format would be to address each person separately, allowing them to make their case in full without interruption from other guests. He has started to do that in some of his shows, and it's been better for the audience in my opinion.

[@Chrisrock-g4l]

@@Sam-mw4lhand no one needs to hear your comment so stfu

[@1848revolt]

Palestinians do not have the same rights in israel.

[@malvolio01]

Right. They get to choose whether they serve while Jews just have to go. So true.

[@ifterock4931]

they are na zi hiding behind jews ,,

[@amazoniablue7572]

Ohh no really! Such a shame. They have their rights in palestine dont they? Thats where they live. Did you know Palestinians are not allowed to buy a house in lebanon or own anything? Did you know they are labeled refugees forever, did you know palestinians are not allowed citizenship in the arab countries? Omfg you clearly have no freaking clue about anything. Such a shame. Luckily you are not down there fighting for palestine.

[@deforetime3094]

They can vote, work in high positions, be doctors, surgeons, politicians, teachers and more The difference is that they get to choose if they want to serve in the army whan jews must

[@deecypher5284]

What rights are they lacking under the Israeli government? Clown

[@earthspirit516]

Piers speaks of Noa's plight and that is rightful, but does he feel for Hind and her mother or the families of mortally wounded children?

[@rubytuesday4564]

Zero reason to raise their value. This is a WAR. Try to get that through your biased mind. Bleeding hearts set the stage for Oct 7. Hamas was supposed to be positively responsive to that rubbish. They told you to take a hike. Button up your lips and watch the price being paid for this rubbish.

[@Zarab923]

Sure he does but those families voted Hamas into power and they stay there and do the bidding of Hamas and there is no way that we should just let a hostage rot with the enemy to protect the people that are holding them because Hamas won’t.. you can’t just do what the terrorists want you to do

[@Someone294dk]

@@Zarab923great job. Blame the children’s families. Similarly, I can blame IDF families. After all, every one there serves in the IDF so are they really innocent?

[@PatriotGal]

@@Someone294dkhamas started the Slaughter on Oct. 8th. Every death of Gazans is Hamas faults! Hostages were held in private homes! That makes them combatants not innocent people. It also shows how Hamas hides within the people because they r cowards!

[@tomaofdonewelll7810]

@@Zarab923 By that logic, does Noa bare responsibility for her situation by accepting and "doing the bidding" of her government and their crimes? Did you see the most recent UN report that has blacklisted !$r@El for crimes against children more prevalent than in the Congo?

[@zohircherifi5616]

The fact that people still watch Piers Morgan and trust him is a astonishing

[@mediii8057]

I love Dave Smith!!! He is so calm and collected yet so direct and intelligent

[@ins3rtc0insdungeonofgaming24]

I really enjoyed this debate. No ranting, no screaming. Actually refreshing to hear all 3 guests talking calmly and with respect. You should keep this panel Piers . Great show

[@jorgealexandrerodriguesmai5048]

Even if two were regurgitating propaganda garbage?

[@peachrocker9716]

that's because cenk's crazy ass wasn't there

[@Gizz101]

​@@jorgealexandrerodriguesmai5048 it's the fucking news if they ain't spreading propaganda something is wrong

[@MyEars-oz1zx]

@@jorgealexandrerodriguesmai5048😂😂

[@devorahacts]

Well it was heavily weighted to Piers' opinion and the opposing (Israeli side) was only one person who wasn't that good. And Piers is kind of a powder puff and is unable to call out falsehoods which there were several.

[@laughingbehelit]

Dave Smith was excellent in this discussion : clear, precise, factual

[@duaneabrahams-b5n]

MY MORAL QUANDARY- The Autobiography of Piers Morgan

[@LifeinAmerica2022]

Do you condemn hummous? Rethoric

[@mahaaljefri]

When Emily said “and America never gave the land back…” really just exposes her colonial mentality. Unhinged.

[@LifeinAmerica2022]

I think she does not think when she talks anout america

[@orhun2049]

Omar and Dave was the highlight of this debate. They nailed it

[@hafsaahmed5941]

Wow Dave Smith!!! u Nailed it....❤❤❤

[@1976shoegal]

Well said Omar & Dave 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 hitting Emily with the truthful facts! Emily go educate yourself!

[@euaggeliakladi4260]

I must say its very nice that nobody talks over each other.

[@tommybyrne5745]

It’s very telling when Emily smiles at points she knows to be true , and she clearly knows herself she has nowhere to go .its almost an embarrassed moment for her .

[@belltolls1984]

Dave Smith is a badass.

[@ZBspicey]

Dave ran circles around Emily. Its not as complicated as people make it out to be.

[@jakeybonz]

Thats true. But not for the reasons you think.

[@mohamadalkotob8326]

@@jakeybonzhow?

[@jakeybonz]

@@mohamadalkotob8326 because obviously israel is 100% in the right.

[@mohamadalkotob8326]

@@jakeybonz also don’t tell me hammas started it because hammas only came to power 30 years ago and reports of rape and tunnels under civilians have been proven fake

[@JohnMartin-pjasca]

@@jakeybonz Wrong. Both are in the wrong.

[@usmankabir4331]

It's so refreshing to hear Dave and Omar.

[@ibiameze7371]

Until Israel treats Palestinians like human being, the conflict will never end!

[@Nutritionsiv]

There’s 2 million Palestinians living respectfully is Israel, they are in politics, laws, they are business-man, doctors, teachers. You are spreading lies of ISIS’s Jew hate machine. I bet your foot never landed in Israel nor Gaza.

[@Nutritionsiv]

There’s 2 million Palestinians living respectfully is Israel, they are in politics, laws, they are business-man, doctors, teachers. You are spreading lies of ISIS’s Jew hate machine. I bet your foot never landed in Israel nor Gaza.

[@Nutritionsiv]

There’s 2 million Palestinians living respectfully is Israel, they are in politics, laws, they are business-man, doctors, teachers. You are spreading lies of ISIS’s Jew hate machine. I bet your foot never landed in Israel nor Gaza.

[@Nutritionsiv]

There’s 2 million Palestinians living respectfully is Israel, they are in politics, laws, they are business-man, doctors, teachers. You are spreading lies of ISIS’s Jew hate machine. I bet your foot never landed in Israel nor Gaza.

[@Ndrangheta.M5]

Piers Morgan does not know where to stand.. Piers Morgan is the type of guy who goes to the movie theater and decides to move every 10 minutes to get a better position but never to take a seat.

[@fulaniyyah]

He is clearly seated in zionism.

[@patobrien4854]

this has been the most civil debate i have seen. no one talking over each other. the best way to debate.

[@gilbertopicinich1607]

Dave Smith crystal clear reasoning

[@Fayssal207]

Stupid

[@lf9341]

He's a clueless buffoon. Since Arafat, The Palestinians have received 1.1 trillion in aid. They spent this money on 3100 miles of tunnels underneath Gaza, to store weapons and train troops to attack Israel and America. If they instead had given the money to the population each person would have 2.3 million dollars including newborns. Instead they only want to kill Israelis. Hamas, Abbas, Arafat prior continue to offer their children up for sacrifice, imprison and torture their own dissidents. It is in their financial interest to continue the conflict.

[@ShlumpGaming]

This was actually a good job by Piers on asking and allowing both sides to explain their views, and not letting Emily live in her alternate reality world which she likes to do.

[@thyownshadow]

Thank you Dave, and Omar. Cheers.

[@mkj-3313]

Remember the little child Hind Rajab

[@razabadass]

Appreciated the guys letting each other talk :)

[@matt96920]

Dave Smith frames the Palestinians that held the hostages as "innocent" and "not involved." In what world is a jailer innocent and not involved? They were complicit -- very, very complicit. You cannot be complicit and also the victim

[@asb09715]

So you're saying 274 people holding 4 hostages in 1or 2 buildings?

[@tobinator999]

The children are always innocent my dude

[@steveanajafi734]

Damn the amount of Mossad agents in this comment section is ridiculous! Free Palestine 🇵🇸 really made a mockery of Benjamin Mileikowsky and his genocide! 😂

[@lucianbirlan5726]

Palestine was not free sincer around the 15th century, you are just trying to fool little children in the West.

[@alexndg5260]

Conspiratorial thinking eh?

[@redunbiased8417]

@@alexndg5260it’s called agent provocateurs! Lol everything is conspiracy to you eh

[@llamaobama-dt7wi]

AIPAC is the foreign agent 😂

[@alexndg5260]

@@redunbiased8417 You are literally spouting a conspiracy theory in your comment, I'm the one saying that they are spreading a conspiracy theory You wrote one of the dumbest comments I've ever read

[@dianedack2141]

This poor girl thinks this started Oct. 7th. She missed the first 74 seasons

[@tonycoxall7370]

No, she doesn't. She just knows that the events of October 7th are crucial to the current situation in Gaza.

[@refaeatkabir3663]

@@tonycoxall7370Oct 7th happened because of 74 years of Israeli tyranny & occupation.

[@saposapo1]

Piers, please see photos of this "refugee camp" - it is a city, apartmentbuildings, a mall etc

[@garyg8036]

They use the term "refugee camp" as a propaganda tool / term with the useless U.N. help. Those with a 🧠 know it's no longer a refugee camp.

[@PriSharma-ix3gd]

Devastated by Israel

[@spycsalmon28]

With walls surrounding the perimeter, the most heavily surveilled area on Earth, heavily armed by IDF, electricity , water and calories controlled by Israel. But sure, it's a city with a mall and a beach so it must not have been an open air prison 🤡

[@rimab5894]

Really? I was imagining the videos of people living in tent and broken building?

[@rosetteswed9054]

Who keep sending rockets ?

[@sheep.herder]

we have an intelligent sheople here 🤣🤣

[@ganggang3788]

Wait…Hamas has an iron dome?

[@CowneloAlvaroid]

@sethblank3139 what rockets?? Talking about those small, POS trash glorified fireworks that NEVER end in unalive Israelis??? Lmao So tell us how.many deaths via tiny rocket fireworks??

[@wastedmalice]

@@ganggang3788 Why do you think Israel needs to have one?

[@dsadik666]

Israel

[@ahmedd320]

The world will perish, but Piers' moral quandry shall not

[@calmingcrist4515]

" In the end, We will remember not the words of our enemy, but the silence of our friends "

[@paulinadsouza7329]

Recent information is that the home from which the hostages were in was of a AlJazeera civilian worker.

[@lookbovine]

That’s propaganda.

[@suzannenobel6809]

Emily if Palestine wasn’t occupied, no Hamas.

[@philipskalla4312]

Wrong. Hamas is a branch of the Muslim Brotherhood which was founded before the State of Israel.

[@natigolden-l6s]

1921 jaffa pogroms,no occupation. 1929 hebron and safed pogroms,no occupation. 1936 jaffa pogroms,no occupation. 1938 tiberias pogroms,no occupation

[@lidalid3318]

Wrong

[@veenacriddle1207]

There is no occupation, a lie to hate Jews.

[@qualthos1]

The Palestinian ministry of health numbers do not discriminate between fighters and civilians.

[@suncaseen489]

not the palestinian. it's the ministry of health of gaza. there's a difference. It's a real ministry in west bank, elected by palestinians. there are no elections in gaza. it's all under hamas control. and yes - they count all casualties as civilians. they make an exception only when some higher ranking member is killed. than they call him a martyr and they make some kind of public funeral. every other death they count as civilian casualty

[@AndyBacklund]

Piers, I have listened to a lot of your panel discussions and they have definitely had a setup to your questions… but I appreciate this interview. I felt like you were far more balanced. I appreciate that. Thank you.

[@snotwurfit]

For such an extremely complex and emotive issue, it was good to see these guests - on opposing sides - debate the issue without shouting over each other and insulting each other. They all made their points respectfully, acknowledged the wrongs on both sides of the conflict, but were able to argue their positions. Bravo to the panel. Shame the politicians can't do the same.

[@ellistitheridge3851]

Emily is a class act..

[@1inktube6]

No.

[@sea_ellef]

Emily wants to dial world peace laws all the way back to 1846 when USA colonised Mexico so that it's ok for Israel to colonise Palestine. That's her justification for war crimes and mass murder. She is not a class act.

[@lareineii]

She is full of empathy but anyone who hears Israel or Jew will let any logic go through their ears. They wont listen.

[@Hillary_duff134]

@@lareineiinice victim play

[@MrEgymariner]

Why did no one mention Palestine state before 1948? And all old immigrants to Palestine were Palestinians? You just listen to golda meir, The Israeli PM in 1973 when she admitted that she was Palestinian

[@johnwiersgalla3801]

Very simple calculus. If the innocent civilians that died in order to get the hostages back were Israeli (or American for that matter) instead of Palestinian, would anyone be calling it a win?

[@tyler-mariedann7192]

How come the world is not hearing about these poor hostages.... How many might still be alive? Are they being properly taken care of?

[@1inktube6]

It's all we've been hearing about because the West seems to value Israeli life over Palestinians..

[@hgmore7106]

Do some research yourself there are a lot of hostages that spoke about their experience said positive things about hamas and Israel silenced these hostages. the israeli people even turned their backs on these hostages who spoke positively about Palestinian people, you can even find videos of hamas being friendly with the hostages and vice-versa.. just do some research. 🤷‍♀️

[@samuraijosh1595]

Already 6 million have been eradicated. This is just a small number c'mon

[@ShatzMatz]

It is Hamas who put a higher value on Jewish lives vs Palestinian lives. In this war itself it exchanged 1 Jewish hostage for 10 Hamas terrorists. In the past it demanded 1100 terrorists in exchange for 1 live Israeli soldier.

[@ranney757]

Hamas have said they wanted to repeat Oct 7th again and again, what other choice does Israel have but to get rid of Hamas. Why is there no accountability on Hamas to stop their committed violence against Israeli and Palestines

[@ralphzoombeenie2330]

The choice israel has is to abandon the apartheid and treat others humanely with justice and equality. z10nism is an evil cult.

[@juststop2047]

You clearly did not watch the video then. Israeli government made it very clear way before Oct 7th that there will be a greater Israel that involves war and grabbing more land. What do you expect Hamas to do at that point? Nice try though

[@jonjo6tie]

The fact that Piers keeps regurgitating his self proclaimed moral quandary this late in the day speaks volumes.

[@SoakDisko]

The human shield argument is stupid when you have people packed that close together. Gaza is basically a million people standing on a few miles of rubble. If a bird shits in the air its gonna hit a "human shield " when it lands

[@dani-ks9cg]

Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad speaking on Al-Hekma TV said in March 2012: “Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians…”

[@SoakDisko]

@@dani-ks9cg And? Thats the same as saying " half of the Americans are Europeans, the other ones are Africans Italians and Mexicans, who are Americans??" Its just a nonsense statement.

[@rimab5894]

You know when Columbus found America , no one was living there, right?

[@HR-op2cq]

So, in that case, gazns should think twice before abducting civilians from another country..

[@SoakDisko]

@@rimab5894 Great point, What happened in the US was a massacre and a genocide upon the native people. It was also 500 years ago. Now when we try to be more civilized and consider ourselves more advanced, Israel wants to pull out the stone age fucking bible card LOL

[@Phoenixevolve]

The question is what are hostages doing in a refugee camp(supposedly harboring innocents)

[@Jack-uy7ie]

2 million people crammed into a 25 mile strip by 5 miles wide forced south. What the fuck do you think would happen

[@Phoenixevolve]

​@@Jack-uy7ieso pig head that is a justification for taking hostage.just like saying I robbed a bank,because money was kept there

[@muylocko292]

@@Jack-uy7ie Because they elected a terrorist group as their leaders and now you think they can FA without FO?

[@The_Voice_of_Reason748]

RIP Hind Rajab 😢💐

[@majesticcamels4198]

RIP Arnon Zamora

[@Onlyme2015]

So Israeli is very accurate when targeting Iranian targets such as militant, e,mbassy, and others... but for some reason all of a sudden it loses its accuracy when it comes to Arab childern

[@OmarGuy-sn1cm]

Dave smith is a HERO our society has drifted so far from normality that a "comedian" thats his profession altho hes very smart and educated speaks the most amount of sense

[@lf9341]

Oh please. Since Arafat, The Palestinians have received 1.1 trillion in aid. They spent this money on 3100 miles of tunnels underneath Gaza, to store weapons and train troops to attack Israel and America. If they instead had given the money to the population each person would have 2.3 million dollars including newborns. Instead they only want to kill Israelis. Hamas, Abbas, Arafat prior continue to offer their children up for sacrifice, imprison and torture their own dissidents. It is in their financial interest to continue the conflict.

[@JoshuaP222]

In a lot of things he does except for this topic lol

[@OmarGuy-sn1cm]

@@JoshuaP222 yes sure buddy and you probably think talk tv Fox News and CNN are actual news networks and don't have financiers that want to show only a certain perspective lol.normie

[@JoshuaP222]

@@OmarGuy-sn1cm lol nah im saying i actually do listen to dave and think he has some great views especially on covid and mass media in general but when it comes to israel and this conflict his view aint it

[@ajny7740]

Most civilized conversation i heard on this show.

[@yaya-mq5su]

Dave smith is so good at debating!! The guy is smart.

[@Deebo277]

"They keep blaming the IDF for all the casualties" Hamas doesn't have tanks, fighter jets, iron dome and smart bombs as well as the backing is the U.S...... Israel has all those things, that's how they can inflict so much harm. I condemn hamas and now i condemn Israel for their atrocities.

[@laplanchaqma]

The Pro-Israeli guest, although I disagree with her stance, was respectful and professional. No one talked over the other and agreed to disagree with respect for the other. If Leaders conducted their business like this in this conflict, maybe, just maybe, Peace can happen. My GOD! Something has to! So many suffering. It's heartbreaking for me to watch and I'm in the U.S.

[@supernova7848]

This same woman got into a shouting match with Hasan Piker when he was on the panel

[@lf9341]

Since Arafat, The Palestinians have received 1.1 trillion in aid. They spent this money on 3100 miles of tunnels underneath Gaza, to store weapons and train troops to attack Israel and America. If they instead had given the money to the population each person would have 2.3 million dollars including newborns. Instead they only want to kill Israelis. Hamas, Abbas, Arafat prior continue to offer their children up for sacrifice, imprison and torture their own dissidents. It is in their financial interest to continue the conflict. ...

[@laplanchaqma]

This is the first I've seen of her. Part of my shock is that most Israeli supporters are usually shouting and condescending towards anyone else talking. Lol

[@mauganra2589]

I came to see Dave, but I couldn’t even stand listening to Piers for a full sixty seconds.

[@Andrew-fy9wu]

How many German citizens were killed during WW2?

[@AzimHazeez-jj3qi]

IF YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT DRESDEN OR HIROSHIMA OR NAGASAKI OR ANY CIVILIAN BOMBARDMENT.- ITS A WAR CRIME COMMITED BY WORLD POWERS IN THE NAME OF FREEDOM. THE OTHER COUNTRIES / NORMAL PEOPLE DINT HAVE ACCESS TO THE INFORMATION NOR THE POWER TO CRITIZIZE THESE ATTROCITIES UNTILL THE BOOM OF MEDIA. AND ITS DISGUSTING WHEN ZIONISTS BRING UP THE WAR CRIMES OF THE PAST TO JUSTIFY THE ONE CURENTLY ISRAEL IS COMMITING.

[@Alexpolitikin]

To Emily's point, the reason Jordan and Egypt occupy a piece of Palestinian land is because Egypt is an American puppet state. Even if you study the war in detail its very strange how Egypt lost the war and numbers don't add up. Actually an Israeli professor Ahron Bregman specialises in Israel's wars that have occurred and even he mentioned this point in his detailed military research . The point is America told Egypt to create an excuse to justify Israel's existence so the public can not retaliate. Henceforth, Egypt utilised that war and till this day utilises that war as an excuse to its public that they can not help their neighbours because Israel too strong. Same went for Syrian regime which had close coordination with the US till early 2000s. And same goes for Jordan which went on from being a British puppet to an American puppet. Point is America manipulates all these players against each other according to its national interests. If it needs to it will establish friendship between Israel and these nations and when it wants to it will create conflict and division. Because at the end of the day the global currency is in dollars all military comes from the US and all global institutions are American and the whole post 1945 world order created by America so, it gives it the power to play carrots and sticks with others. I don't think the US political elite give two hoots about Israel its just a strategic pawn. As for Israel domestically speaking well the atrocities speak volumes about the government and even a lot of people on what they really think of the Palestinians as peoples.

[@ameramohamed4453]

Its hard to hear people speak with so much empathy for Israeli lives and not Palestinian - what about those who's families have been murdered in front of them, trapped under rubble for days, starved, tortured, imprisoned, pushed into refugee camps and then attacked. Children orphaned, dismembered - do you not think they are scared? Do you not think they deserve empathy too?

[@lawrencewinter]

@GretsGarbo Read the amnesty international reports. All of them. The picture becomes very clear. Israel has all the power, all the military might, all the control. How dare you make Israel the victim again.

[@DavidLangford-v9s]

Again,"journalists" don't hide hostages in their homes.

[@theundertaker5963]

Can't believe Emily did not turn this into an outrageous shouting and talking over other guests debacle like she does all the time. This was a very constructive, well behaved, nicely elaborated, and informative debate by all those involved, including Pierce. More of such debates can certainly bring more understanding to this issue.

[@youtuber_00786]

Piers probably spoke to her before the show and told her to cut it out or she won't be allowed back on anymore loll

[@theundertaker5963]

@@youtuber_00786 I don't agree, given the fact that Pierce is a ratings whore if anything he would have tried to rile her up to be even more savage than she usually is on these shows. Personally I think it was the weight of the other panelists that caused her to withhold her nasty side as everyone was sane, well spoken, had very valid points and polite despite disagreeing with her points.

[@letthesunshinethru2355]

Yes, too much shouting would make the botox in her face crack, especially on her upper lip.

[@saints16o5o87]

Only 1000 dead or injured including one of the hostages and 4 rescued, by allegedly using humanitarian aid trucks with no humanitarian aid inside but human special forces soldiers hiding behind humanitarian aid. Israeli military rescue operation =274 dead, 696 injured. 4 hostages rescued, 1 more murdered by their saviors. Ceasefire and negotiation = over 100 innocent Israeli hostages released, 100s of innocent Palestinian hostages released, no one dead. Ceasefire permanently = all illegally held innocent hostages released and Netanyahu tried and jailed. That's why its not happening. As for Piers, if you are made to look after hostages or comply with terrorists under threat of your own family dying are you also a terrorist, and does that mean you cant allow these people to have political solutions? If so why was Menachem Begin or Ben Gurion, Shamir, Peres, Arafat etc all who have innocent blood on their hands allowed to be political leaders, because its the only way for peace. I say this because this is what the I.R.A done yet eventually the reality meant these "terrorists" can only be stopped by allowing them to have a non violent political future.

[@adishahar5838]

Why are there innocent gaza civilians near the hostages?

[@sherylgreenberg3540]

Yes, why are there gaza civilians keeping the hostages and why do people believe the information that comes from the terrorist group hamas with a leader that states they don't care how many civilians die for their cause and their personal benefit.

[@ButtasUK]

​@@adishahar5838apart from the very obvious fact that there literally is nowhere else to go. And the fact of the size of the population, in such a small area

[@Alex-cl9zi]

The pro-palestinian side for months have been saying Israel should be sending in special forces and now they have they're just as outraged. IDF went in to rescue hostages and dozens of Hamas terrorists descended on them with a barrage of gunfire and RPG's which undoubtedly caused alot of the palestinian casualties. The IDF did exactly what people have been asking them to do by going in on the ground for this operation and Hamas, as per usual, sacrificed their own people for their own selfish, murderous aims.

[@Lurch685]

As usual, you blame Hamas for Israeli indiscriminate fire.

[@seanbland7493]

They sent in special needs forces...

[@Alex-cl9zi]

@@Lurch685 do me a favour and log off for today champ. You clearly aren't intelligent enough to engage with the argument properly.

[@Davidlevy8]

Its a extreemly dificult situation when terrorists use civilians a human shields and dont value life. G.d help us!

[@BertGraef]

surre....the old human shield nonsense. Where do you go when 3 million are crammed into hellls half acre and a hellish barrage of US bombs and missiles are targeting you?. And you run off to a "safe designated" place, only to find yourself in the midst of another bloody massacre? Just please kindly grow up.

[@zfontain1975]

The whole world will be gaza soon.

[@MoeMaganis]

David, get over that one, it's way used and abused. Find a new excuse....

[@Jesse-mt2ri]

All hail Piers for giving all of us a sane platform of free speech. Excellent debate. The cycle of violence can only be broken in the Middle East by discussions like these.

[@frolyhorn1426]

The woman is the most logical among these

[@mamdohyounis4308]

Her logic is as bleached as her hair..go home

[@JUST1CE-hq1jb]

illogical in hasbara means iogical

[@stefancamilleri4072]

HASBARA ALERT

[@redmanmr2]

And savage looking

[@macb1452]

She said she is not a monster?😂😂

[@seashell4910]

I kno that’s a joke

[@llamaobama-dt7wi]

AIPAC is a foreign agent

[@vikkideedrick]

How many innocent civilians have been killed in Ukraine? Nobody is hating on Russia over it. And Ukraine has ZERO civilian Russian hostages.

[@chingis83]

What? Have you never followed Russian or Ukrainian media or social networks? Russians constantly talk about Russophobia in Western countries and how much they are hated by the West.

[@88Wardah]

What are u talking about. Russia has been banned from almost every world event.. they have sanctions on them and arrest warrant issued from the icc

[@MelleFrimousse1]

Why do Hamas has the right to put hostages in the middle of civilians population?

[@carolindalancaster7334]

Israel is not the occupier!

[@estellemartinson730]

In South Africa, the ANC agreed to lay down their arms and then talks to hand over power could happen. Why is it so hard to expect Hamas to agree to stop all their aggression towards Israel and how can anyone not in the first place want the hostages back?

[@mbonisenimutaheli1204]

Offspring of apartheid goverment in south Africa that has killed lot of people before 94

[@MGold00]

The problem is Isreali doesn't want to talk to Hamas. For talks to happen The National Party (Which was the ruling party) had recognize the ANC

[@opz7554]

What aggression towards israel?

[@ChantelleGous]

Are you seriously comparing the ANC with Hamas? I am South African and not a fan of the ANC but they are not even close to the calibre of Hamas. These are brutal, evil terrorists.

[@natigolden-l6s]

@@MGold00 when has hamas recognized israel?when have palestinians agreed to recognize israel as a jewish majority country and give up the right of return (turning israel into a muslim majority nation) ?

[@benjimorris1312]

There are American citizens being held hostage by Hamas in civilian populated centres. You don’t get to say you refuse to put boots on the ground and then condemn the people who go to rescue your citizens because you don’t like the way they did it.

[@politefan8141]

There is no moral clarity to their arguments. They oppose air strikes but now oppose ground invasions which shows that any type of retaliatory response would be condemned and their appeals to morality are disingenuous.

[@elziebtasogno8421]

Lady is absolutely right in all she said bravo

[@isaacjena2610]

You shouldn’t have people to your show that doesn’t have context on this conflict and can cause more damage. The very first invited said that hostages should have been negotiated. Israel have years on this conflict where negotiations don’t work. No civilians should have hostages on their houses. Period!

[@yournewdadq9782]

Yes, people are to dumb to understand that if you cant talk and negotiate with someone, then you have war. Thats the definition.

[@OrbiTiZZeD]

so wait.. did Hamas surrender?? no?? why is this on Israel?

[@CantdoitWontdoit]

Simple, the world holds the smallest violin. And we’re done playing it.

[@chasingthesun-bi6cx]

That's not how peace negotiations work

[@wheres_bears1378]

Because if Israel wants to be a sovereign state they have to act like one and follow rules of war as agreed upon by all sovereign nations around the world. Hope that helps with the confusion

[@sues3218]

The Hamas war propaganda machine is working full time.

[@StephanMeinhardt]

Problem with debates like this is the rubbish, lies and non sense spelled out … so obvious … Terrorist being arrested are considered as being kidnapped ?? My goodness …

[@nafatikhalil6565]

They hold 1000's of children under 15 years old in jails are they terrorists they are under fucking occupation since fucking 1967

[@ljmolly4029]

5 year old terrorists???? Souless ghoul

[@jrushing1972]

Yep.. there's no moral equivalency between Israel arresting and holding terrorists to hamas and apparently Palestinian citizens holding innocent Israeli citizens.. these people are sick..

[@harnessriscallous7466]

Terrorism is a criminal charge. None of these ppl are being tried. Makes you the terrorist sympathizer 😂

[@mahdizaker1773]

Do you know how many of them are kids? How many of them are kept without charge? Check Beth Salem Israeli human rights organization When you kidnap a child without charge, arent you the terrorist? And this is legal in israel btw. It's called "bargaining chips".

[@febiwhafk]

This was such a great and informative debate, Omar Baddar and Dave Smith had such perfect deliveries of their very important points and Emily Austin was so respectful and actually addressed different points than we always hear. I still don't see how some people don't see how black and white this war is. The so-called leaders of our world should take notes

[@Jjude222]

To break through a prison, a concentration camp in which you have been held captive for more than two decades, to bypass one of the most advanced security systems in the world, and to bring prisoners back to the prison is the real heroism and ultimate bravery. Sad defeat. If you failed to release one prisoner for nearly a year from the underdog, and if you had the power to cut off water, food, and electricity, and if you ended up killing numerous prisoners you were attempting to save, then such an outcome would represent the ultimate defeat. Does this scenario suggest that these individuals are residing in a different reality? Shame.

[@philipskalla4312]

It is a very unusual class of concentration camp that has shopping malls with restaurants, toy shops and beauty salons, and that is so desperate for medicines for its people that it actually turned away lorry loads of medicines from Israel three years ago. And it is a very strange kind of concentration camp that could afford to turn down 15 billion dollars in economic aid 4 years ago because it was not prepared to give an assurance that it would stop murdering Jews.

[@gad7336]

Hamas claims all deaths are civilian meaning no Hamas fighters were KIA the last 8 months, ... and Mr. Dave just takes it as hard facts... kinda lazy isnt it ?

[@muhammadaquil2256]

There are no moderate in Israël war cabinet & there are 70 % israelis who support the occupation of Palestine for greater Israël, Israeli adalt hostages they are most of them are for greater Israël, so they are n't innocent, there are IDF soldiers among the hostages. When it comes to Palestiniens, they are fighting for their independence since 70 years!

[@royilany-xd3je]

These numbers are not correct. About 30% of the Israelis want a greater Israel. About 40% are afraid of negotiating with the Palestinians. And the remaining 30% want a two state solution.

[@Irishpenguinirish]

Someone must mention that these four hostages are in such good condition; they were respected and CARED FOR during these eight months, even while the Palestinians in Gaza have been STARVED and deprived of water! Clearly, the Palestinians caring for these people were making SURE that the hostages had adequate food and clean water, even when their OWN people did not! No one is acknowledging this FACT!

[@fats3973]

Yes hamas did kidnap those hostages, but israels brutal occupation is the only reason, how long do they expect palestine to put up with the atrocities they experience for 76 YEARS. put yourself in Palestinians shoes, what would you do.

[@tbnone2501]

Israel's occupation of Gaza? The place they left years ago?

[@danielbell8679]

Ha, ha, innocent Gaza civilians.

[@jacobvandijk2184]

The debates are becoming less shouty...There may be hope after all!

[@ChrisGtek]

Her smirk says it all 23:58

[@HonestlyNow4Real]

Might be time for Hamas to quit attacking Israel.

[@63mdeen]

Yeah! Just shut up and stay occupied, oppressed and starved