The Mandela Catalogue Vol.4

[@freyaschenberg1225]

god, that monologue from stanley revealing that adam has been an alternate that FORGOT he's an alternate almost his entire life, starting when stanley replaced him as a baby was so cool and well made, will never get enough of it

[@cornucopiac1088]

That was the Intruder, not Stanley

[@jillreyerma7592]

@@cornucopiac1088 I kind of thought they're the same. He says "Do you remember my face?" and Stanley's face flashes briefly over his, but I don't know.

[@cornucopiac1088]

@@jillreyerma7592 Stanley's face flashes over his, yes, but there are also the TV-man's face over his. I don't think the hoodie guy is stanley, I think it's the Intruder. I think the flashes are just callbacks and explanations to previous volumes

[@Memes_Confirmed]

@@cornucopiac1088 In one way, what you're saying does make sense. Stanley helped manifest a friend for Adam, and out of it came the intruder. It does make a lot of sense. But the only problem is, Stanley has been credited with a voice actor, even though we don't see him in this volume. And nor does the intruder have his own voice actor credit. So they honestly might just be the same person

[@BreedableVaporeon0978]

WAIT I'M SO DUMB HOW DID I NOT PICK THAT UP

[@whydoistillexist5033]

27:02 The first thing normal people do after seeing their friend dead: being sad Adam: stealing the car, going home, deleting them from his contacts, saying that “at least I hot killer footage, pun intended lol” Everyone: wtf Adam

[@TablestandTM]

I think this “sound familiar” is more lore then it first seems (49:00), the alternate talks about a “scared boy with a gun” and then frames to a house with a window highlighted, I have to think that this is Mark Heathcliff’s house because he hits all the things. Scared? Most definitely Boy? Arguable today Mark was a “boy” but still was pretty young. With a gun? Most definitely. This might also lead to the police code that we saw before, maybe when Mark was calling the cops Thatcher was the one to get the call and as the code says, he left Mark there to die giving Thatcher guilt over this, that or I’m completely wrong and the alternate is just talking about Thatcher time in the Murray house where he lost Weaver, who knows?

[@matth3760]

Huh I didn’t think about that, I just assumed it was referencing Thatcher’s encounter with the alternate where he tried shooting it

[@SMILE-guy_OFFICIAL]

It was mark you would see the house image in interlude and that same house is from vol.333 which means it is his house and the only boy with a gun is mark because he is only 17 years old

[@spiceo2]

Yeah it's def referring to Mark. Mark's case was being handled by Thatcher when nobody else wanted to, and the alternate is taunting him for essentially becoming the thing he was trying to investigate and bring closure to

[@Ignas_]

"Boy" can be used in a derogatory/insulting way to refer to someone weak, weak-minded, or not mature (mentally or physically), regardless of age.

[@TablestandTM]

@@Ignas_ Did not know that, would you say that Mark was “weak minded”, I would say so myself, when trapped in the room, it toke 3 days for Mark to give up everything in his religion, and ask “who’s he been praying too”, but I’m also not a pro at psychological torture.

[@heyocherrio]

A lot of the characters have biblical names. Ruth, David, Adam, Eve and I’m sure more than I can think of currently

[@yhd_skeetsy]

bit of a stretch, but "eve"lin ,O probably counts too esp since adam was supposedly w her for a while ^^

[@mrwrigh]

Sarah is another biblical name as she was Abraham's wife

[@Radio_Tempo]

Jonah is also a biblical name!! Seeing as how the bible Jonah has bailed from saving a burning town and then being eaten as fish food in the ocean when he was trying to get away by boat

[@pastelastrx]

@@Radio_Tempo thats actually basically exactly what happened to him omg

[@brenjmorris]

Sarah as well, she gave birth to Isaac apparently

[@normalguycraig]

I find it really amusing that I 100% watched the Christmas story animation from overthrone in primary school. it makes me giggle every time i see it like "hehe 10 y/o me doesn't knowwww"

[@normalguycraig]

It's called "The Nativity - Beginners Bible" its on yt

[@funky_littleclown]

yeah i used to watch it in sunday school

[@Eztli__Void]

I’ve definitely also seen it in school

[@toxic_195]

I love bible fan fiction

[@snekyninja7579]

Aaaaand comment of the year award goessss toooooooo...... THIS ONE ☝ Congratulations 👏

[@Devino7]

This is so underrated lmao 😂❤

[@MorningLamb]

yes hidden Bible lore

[@Sour-the-silly]

Omg same-

[@the_GreatesT_EGG]

hazbin hotel and Mandela catalogue are the best example of it

[@MeThatGuy_]

I enjoy seeing Jack watch all these analog horror series not only for the horror aspect but him trying to figure them out too

[@pothly]

it is a good series. i watched it not long ago and it was actually really good

[@bagelbombs1343]

i love how clueless jack is on the lore, but knowing more than him is driving me insane

[@aceywacey_]

im so glad i watched this. at night. when im going to be home alone for the entire weekend.

[@toxic_195]

Lol, just did the same. Don’t worry, someone is always watching for you /jk

[@noneknowstheswagger]

good luck my man o7

[@Subnootical8497]

Don't worry, I'm already inside the house and I won't let anyone else break in :)

[@aceywacey_]

@@Subnootical8497 thats so kind of you 🥺

[@frid7434]

@@Subnootical8497 i am in your walls

[@7greentears]

Hey, I'm the artist that drew the fanart that you used in your thumbnail. I would appreciate it if you credit me. Thank you.

[@xZephyrHillsx]

This!!! 👆👆👆

[@JackManifoldVODS]

So sorry about this! Credited now! -gek

[@7greentears]

@@JackManifoldVODS Thank you! I appreciate it!

[@Zeronetworkk]

I haven't been able to find anything on KZbin but as soon as I saw this notification I was like " alright i guEsSs I'll choose this one " these monologues and your reaction is just so funny I loved the last one . Now I can finally focus

[@imasstraightasacircle2347]

I just wanted to point this out for anyone who didn't notice- Adam (Adam) and Eve (Evelin) I think that the start of this revolved more about Adam and Eve because it the video also revolves around Adam and Evelin. It also mentioned that Adam followed the "angel" or whatever and then returned to Eve and stood above her and she was afraid. Evelin mentioned that Adam said some things to her the she wishes he had never said, and she seemed pretty scared. I can't think of a complete idea, however, we can generally assume that the "god-like" alternate wants to create a new world, with Adam and Evelin being at the start of it. Edit- This may also be a stretch, but, if Adam is the only one who saw that friend video, maybe Evelin is the friend he imagined. Eve was created to keep Adam company.

[@caralinehorton1038]

I’m glad I could catch this live!

[@caralinehorton1038]

Ngl it’s scary

[@horrorterrorharvey]

my theory is that the whole god/spirit parallel with stanley in the creation story at the start is not a moral thing, but that stanley is using humans as the material to create creatures in his image, as his own 'children'. maybe previous alters were like the animals in the biblical story, not perfect or in his image but the first 'lives' he created. and adam is the first of something else, something closer to him, something he seems to love in a different way, the way god is portrayed to love humans differently to the rest of his creations. so adam is not an alter in the same sense as the others that we've seen before, but something new/more

[@imalwaysmelancholy]

Basically how the four victims died if anyone has forgotten. Victim one i think was Mark, he shot himself because of aan alternate. And i think Victim two was Cesar, he was killed by an alternate or became an alternate, thus him being the one who drove Mark to s*icide. [according to some theories he was the one who killed his mom] Victim number three was Adam, he evidently died in the basement by verbal torture or just killed by the man in the TV [the intruder]. And Victim four being Jonah, he was driving with the GPS but all of a sudden he stops the car and gets out and dies from suposedly the man in the GPS [the intruder] this was for anyw who forgot the deaths of the main four victims or just didn't watch the other Vods.

[@CORPRAUST]

adam didn't die

[@genericIRentity15]

adam isn't dead

[@Gothicc666]

18:42 he’s so pretty, that’s my takeaway

[@saffrxn]

AYYYYY I SUBBED ON THIS STREAM! I WATCHED THIS ONE START TO FINISH, THANK YOU FOR THIS GREAT CONTENT!

[@ezoV_01]

watching this at home alone rn and my wall just knocked. my dog is barking. really fucking scared right now but cant stop that manifold gr

[@devilish9033]

I think that Gabriel is inside Adams head and making Adam do things he doesn't want to do or say (like masky from marble hornets' situation). Stanley who is then Adams 'friend' seems to be trying to stop Gabriel from reaching whatever goals it may have and trying to get Adam in control of his own body again. I've never seen Mandela catalog before tho so idk 😅

[@TheBlueCat69]

so basically an alternate?

[@devilish9033]

@@TheBlueCat69 no, like being controlled by one, but not one himself

[@TheBlueCat69]

@@devilish9033 ohh I like that theory

[@majinally3527]

no he was inside daves head remember?

[@sqftmilk]

i thought adam was the baby that was taken 17 years ago from stanley and was turned into an alternate ever since. and then his mother obviously… yeah, and his dad must’ve been taken as well. maybe adam was an ‘experiment’ for the alternates to try and replicate human manners in a better way if one of their own was raised by humans. maybe after adam witnessed another alternate for the first time in a long time, something in him clicked or something. which is why everything spiralled after adam went into that lady’s house. stupid theory but meh. 🤷‍♀️

[@qrzt2000]

Why is this exactly what I'm thinking?

[@theflash6487]

The intruder took Adam I think

[@gingerninja137]

oh it just now occurred to me that the stuff Jonah told Evelyn was an alternate messing with her. oh no bro

[@Xxperias]

Good video, Jack. Mandela catalogue is a great analog horror series

[@aerbearbaby]

I always thought that when Adam sent the wrong file and responded to Sarah with “huh” was that he was surprised she was still alive (???). I dunno, like he did send the wrong link but he intended for it to go wrong

[@LeeFiiCo]

1:21:03 what was that thud sound during Stanley’s monologue?

[@Idk.2103]

Gabriel overthrew God in this universe and Gabriel is the first alternate

[@Tsbrumati]

man i love jack many folds

[@funky_littleclown]

a bit of a theory also i may have missed bits (i was reading heart-stopper for the first half) (most of this is based off of what jack said at) 1:29:39 (also rip my spelling ayyyyyyyyyy) (may change/edit my theory/idea later) it would fit that Gabriel is Satan and that doesn't mean that hes not an angel still cause Satan is a fallen angel. also in Gabriel's mind he could still think hes an angel because it all depends on perspective cause always from your own perspective you are on the good side and thats probably what Gabriel thinks Edit 1 i also think that Gabriel would fit being Satan since in one of the earlier tapes he says "i am your true savoir" (or something like that) and he thinks hes like above god and Satan believes that in the bible. Gabriel also says "you still followed the shepherd" and who is known as the shepherd in the bible Jesus/god so Gabriel might mean that you still follow god/Jesus, Gabriel also seems upset when saying this. Edit 2 so do you remember that most of the disappearances where from children? well i think that most of the children disappeared because gabreil (maybe or stanley) took them then swapped them out with alternates, i think this because adam forgot that he was an alternate when they replaced him as a baby. maybe that is how alternates grew and spread lots (and more disappearances).

[@funky_littleclown]

This is when it’s good that your parents forced you to be a Christian for ten years of your life

[@plainlyabrick]

it stresses me out so much to not be able to tell jack what hes trying to look for

[@djcorneliusbingleton]

It’s pretty cool that the top comment that gets shown under the thumbnail for the entire video in non-full screen on mobile is just a massive spoiler (no hate to you, just to the KZbin algorithm and design)

[@V_Phobia]

i was so confused why Jack was talking so fast then realized "ohhhh i forgot! i sped the last video up bc it was better sounding"

[@frankieface11]

34:09 just rewatching this vid and relaxing that he was listening to Olivia Rodrigo Specifically HAPPIER

[@teckhbug9481]

Finally someone in the comments who noticed

[@limen_ade]

ironically jack's reaction streams to this is my comfort series

[@PYSCH0.SH4RK]

I JUST WATCHED THIS VIDEO ON THE MANDELA CATALOUGE ITS THE ONLY ONE I WATCHED WHAT THE FUCK IM PETRIFIED-

[@Homesicktraveler]

It's ok bestie we're gonna be ok

[@joneyisbigfunny]

Jack I needed this one

[@starshinegroup3047]

"The Intruder is God" is an absolutely piping hot take

[@TheGrippler09]

i guess they didnt know about my posessed crt tv that is indestructible and immovable from my basement yes i live in wisconsin

[@dipfish1427]

AAHH this is so confusing, but so clear at the same time

[@VoidMcNoid]

The first biblical story, if anyone sees this, is likely based on the JEWISH telling of the first two people. Basically Lilith is the first woman, who is not made from Adam’s rib. He tries to “sleep” with her, but she refuses to let him. She refuses to let him be on top of her because they are equals. He casts her out and, in some telling, Lucifer (the devil) takes her as his bride. She becomes the queen/mother of demons. In this retelling, I think I could be about Adam, or mankind, taking advantage of her. It seems, by the line about her being scared, that it wasn’t consensual. Maybe the entities are her children coming to avenge their mother against the descendent of Adam, all people.

[@THATSASTEAL]

i know this is like a year ago, but you should totally watch the macabre experiment!! its a really good analog horror

[@coconot2971]

before i genuinely thought this 7:42 was a sapnap meme

[@aerostorm_]

1:25:53 In Christianity God is divided into the trinity of The Father, The Son, and The Holy Spirit. We can assume then that maybe its a parallel to Adam being The Son. As in "Awaken, my Son". Gabriel has taken the place of The Father. The Holy Spirit oversees creation in Genesis as the embodiment of God as both a force and an individual. I am unsure if The Spirit is yet in the grasp of the alternates, maybe it is who Gabriel mentions as "The Shepherd". If so does that add to the theory that The Intruder is The Spirit of God? As he shepherds the children he stole? So is he on the side of Gabriel or not?

[@Laura-dh7gn]

When will you be watching more marble hornets? I’m dying I’ve been left on a cling hanger

[@Krow_Kid]

Anyone else watch this live but rewatch it anyway ✋

[@aratthatgainedsentience7553]

YO TEENAGE DISASTER PLAYS THATCHER THATS CRAZY! Good for him.

[@sophvamp]

jack manifold

[@AngelGabrielOffical]

*HELLO JACK .*

[@ezapp-2025]

1:01:18 A thriving society of followers of the true savio-. [in a faster, lighter tone] A mess of tangled/mangled(?) limbs danced around my bedroom. I held my breath and waited for it to stop. I was too scared to- [The text-to-speech glitches] True-tru-tru-ruth."

[@theofficalseoinjeon]

Let's go Mandela Catalog!!!!

[@Gaming_Roses]

19:07 YES THATCHER!! This guy who plays Thatcher is so attractive 😍 Leon Kennedy vibes 😳 43:22 and his voice 😍 I’m so distracted from the actual content 😂

[@phoenixfl4me_728]

Can’t believe I’m seeing someone talk about Leon here haha

[@genericIRentity15]

I am going to say some not so nice things

[@imalwaysmelancholy]

Ya know, people for some reason always think Satan is some red guy with horns and a tail. The thing is, Satan can be beautiful because he is a fallen angel and he was once God's favorite. So this supposed 'Gabriel' character is actually Satan. He's the mastermind behind the alternates. He made them because he's mad at god for throwing him out of heaven without a second chance. In the Bible it says that Satan can disguise himself as anything, a good example of this is the serpent. He is Gabriel. And he probably won't stop until he rules earth or heaven. Respect.

[@helloagain.andagain.andagain]

Ive seen you on one of your shorts ages ago, weird to find you here

[@imalwaysmelancholy]

That's pretty cool.

[@emmalassam908]

Adam and Evelin are Adam and Eve

[@samraw8300]

nice headphones

[@liamoshea5774]

Mandela magazine has drawn

[@Buddy3222]

the intruder from inside the television looks like chris pratt

[@IL0VEMYBA3]

“The light would be divided by the dark” if ykyk

[@anthophilis8202]

I saw the thumbnail and am now no longer sleeping ive alrdy been trying for 5 hours But fr i get jack with the messed up like distorted faces i hate them

[@_Internet_Troll_]

Jack, the creatures aren’t demons or anything, the cursed Gabriel angel was satan, the devil is the one controlling alternates this is confirmed because he obviously keeps saying “I am your true saviour” implying satan will make an army to rise up against god or possibly take over the world, i dont know for sure but all we can do is wait for the next upload, thanks for reading :D

[@avocado-kun8581]

Currently killing some random ass guy pretending im jesus Cant stop that jack manifold grind tho

[@soulovenn]

LETSSSSS GOOOOOOO I SAW IT LIVE

[@-periwinklle-]

Exciting

[@the_GreatesT_EGG]

in the beningging

[@poostack2115]

I love your lapras plushie

[@Crystal_Marbles]

Early gaaang 💪 MANDELA TIME

[@Sloopithesleepi]

YOOO JACK IM SUPER EARLY I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS ❤❤

[@RikuIsLost]

Nothing has scared me on the level that this series does and I love it

[@Raphaelogram]

YO I WATCHED THIS LIVE

[@Luna-yz6tm]

i want there to be a mandela catalog face studio 2 game

[@RealTerraWorld]

Does anyone know the intro music to this video? It’s a real banger to me.

[@gabyanderson723]

stronger monsters - toby fox

[@bobbytwinklestoes1234]

Sarah is pretty uhh quite intelligent because her job is based on the paranormal and she doesn't seem to want to get in involved with it

[@moongirl9914]

Hey jack I love your video

[@ahoro4201]

Minecraft police department

[@Walt_ADJ_Walt]

the intro cam's quality is already scary enough

[@koifluff8141]

Hi jack! I made some fanart of you! Also I love these series! Tysm for posting!

[@samanthuel_]

You havnt seen Markiplier's thing?? You should! It's similer to this sort of vibe but it'd be awesome to see you react to it.

[@lonersdreamworld]

RIP DAVE

[@bobbytwinklestoes1234]

I have used most of my brain power to try and think of this I have learned that she just wanted to get out of the place I know another thing but I am to lazy to type it

[@lovelybigman9571]

play omori jack oh jackie boy please play omori more omori mmmm jack jack omori please

[@emrilbennett8704]

Have any of you watched Catalist yet?

[@bobbytwinklestoes1234]

I can't stop commenting

[@wolfieolfie]

god i am actually trying to wrap my head around it- so, adam is an alternate. he’s shown being a pretty crappy person. i theorized that “oooh maybe it’s cuz he’s an alternate” but clearly that’s not true cuz evelin said he was so nice beforehand? you could say it was similar to what stanley did, have a nice friendly exterior to get someone to do something but i have no reason to believe that’s the case???? other than he’s an alternate???? but even if adam has been fairly “normal” up to this point what does that imply?? can an alternate “forget” their orgins? their form? so many questions 😭😭 edit: i realize now that adam was a victim to M.A.D., but that just gives me more questions!!! how can an alternate get M.A.D.? i guess if it’s caused by people getting knowledge they don’t wish to hear… and adam doesn’t remember that he’s an alternate… then i guess ????

[@Penxldy]

Mark was scared so he kill hiself

[@princeless7486]

Such a good video jk haven’t even seen yet but hope y’all enjoy 😂❤

[@xyrkzes]

This is pretty cool, but there's a lot of immersion breaking stuff, like camera positions. for example, why is there a camera in that "emo" guy's cabinet? also the jump cuts in the footage really breaks the immersion for me cause why would there be editing in found footage? if it's supposed to be that someone added in creepy footage from this one guy, why would they take time to edit out the boring bits of the footage? idk, i liked mandela catalogue more before vol 333 came out.

[@dray379]

I don't think it's supposed to be found footage. I think it's supposed more like an arg. It logically doesn't make sense for it to be found footage as you have stuff from police, a video of O'Brian and Gabriel even though neither has a camera and even just the Stanley portion. I believe it's an arg where we are trying to solve the mystery about what's going on with all the videos strung together

[@averagedumy]

U look like the scout from TF2 or at lest remind me of him

[@evanr9643]

Only in Wisconsin

[@meeri_meepuduu8772]

Tere finland!

[@bobbytwinklestoes1234]

I might go play GTA 5 Story Mode again and attempt to complete it for the third or fourth time so I can stop commenting

[@GhostFlakke2]

i love yhou

[@gumilikesgummies527]

How was I so early??

[@danicaperkinson1960]

Hey man, credit the artist for the thumbnail

[@awsomeRich3009]

He has now

[@Str4wb3rri_Sw3et13]

Hi💅💅

[@Deckerusernet]

Lol

[@lazyinspaceoutlaw]

Hey!

[@kulekasper3603]

Dab

[@fwjxlian.]

early gang wooooo :D

[@meax3685]

bro jack at least care abt this series and do some research

[@Kasutops]

nah its funny we get to see the 3 mcyt brain cells clashing

[@Shythalia]

What do you mean? Did you not watch the video? He's actually paying attention. When he forgets something, he has Chat to remind him and he even bothers to look back at the previous episodes. He's actually enjoying this series and has said a few times that he really likes this series. It's obvious that he's a fan. It's fine if he says something that's a little wrong because of confusion. The series still has a lot of unanswered questions. And we can just tell him what he got wrong. Edit: If he doesn't care, he wouldn't be theorizing or even think about the plot this much.

[@pastelastrx]

@@Shythalia yeah and honestly, his theories aren't far off from mine. ive been a fan for a while

[@notsofestive]

cringe

[@dray379]

He does care but he wants to solve it himself

[@sonder1341]

Hello first

[@LiD0349]

12:41 wow…. Nothing gets passed you…

[@giantjellyfishleader1399]

Please credit the artist who’s art you used for the thumbnail. Next time maybe ask for permission first too, artists are having a rough go of it recently as it is. The artist is @7greentearz

[@ix9280]

Hey, just a suggestion, you should credit the artist for the pic in your thumbnail. @7greentearz