Gaziano & Girling Dress Shoe Review - Black Cap Toe Oxfords | Kirby Allison

[@robioavion]

Kirby, the quality of your videos are now better than ever. Great vocabulary, impeccable fashion and the beautiful crisp images make videos like this hard to watch on such a small laptop screen. If only I had a wide flat screen television to fully enjoy your content! Thank you!

[@Anti-Taxxer]

Please review shoes from Yohei Fukuda or Stefano Bemer.

[@kirbyallison]

Jaeger-LeCoultre Reverso Classique Would love to! Adding these to my list. I could literally spend every day for months reviewing shoes...

[@simi9222]

@@kirbyallison Orban's are the best bang for the buck. Good year welted for 250 CAD

[@dominiks7159]

Fantastic choice. I would add Antonio Meccariello and Masaru Okuyama to that list.

[@roskes]

@@dominiks7159 my vote for Antonio Meccariello as well!!!!

[@yacovlevi]

I am not a fan of G&G at all. The quality is good, I agree but the look of them are dull and just like any other shoes. Now, Yohei Fukuda are something very different. Yohei shoes make G&G shoes look like a Walmart Shoe.

[@JamesMilliganJr]

I shall certainly have to order myself a pair of these. Excellent video. We need to do all we can to advance the cause of quality in dress for men these day.

[@russ9921]

Great video, Kirby, and beautifully scripted. I met Dean and Tony for the first time last week - lovely, down to earth guys. One thing you forgot to mention - these shoes do not need breaking in. They are as close to perfection in comfort from a RTW as I’ve worn (which backs up what you say in the video). And to those with budgetary qualms - it’s worth stretching to buy a pair of G & G’s even if one every few years only, because you’ll have a work of art as well as a functional item which will give you pleasure every time you hold or wear it. My G & G’s get more comments than any other shoes I wear.

[@nbourbaki]

Kirby, I would like you to check out Vass shoes. Their shoes, and Meermin's Linea Maestro line, are the only ones I know of that are both mass-produced ready-to-wear products while also being handwelted.

[@r.mercado9737]

Another outstanding presentation and commentary! Thank you so much.

[@markoking4529]

They are the most beautiful captors I ever have ever seen!!!

[@KMaybach1]

Dear Mr. Allison, I would love to see a review on Vass shoes and the Crockett and Jones Main Collection. It would be great, if you could compare the shoes that will be reviewed in the future with each other and explain, what one maker does better than another. Many thanks

[@furdiebant]

Would be great to see reviews of mid range English shoes!

[@furdiebant]

Mid range as in mid range price ~GBP 400

[@arnoldarnoldsson9572]

Question... I dont see why one wouldn't go for a black oxford wholecut instead of a captoe? Whats the benefit of the Oxford? Its unparalelled when compared to the silhouette of a wholecut? At least in my opinion! Would love to hear your take on it Kirby!

[@RevJamesCostello]

Perhaps review the Consul by Church’s and the 202 Chelsea by Edward Green.

[@sclick8219]

Would love to see a review on Antonio Meccariello and Enzo Bonafe 👍

[@MBGLS_500]

and Paolo Scafora too

[@CasusBelli1000]

Just got myself a pair... delivery in 3 month. Cannot wait ☺

[@Jim58223]

This is a great idea for a series Kirby. I would personally like to seem a review of a Carmina Balmoral boot, Chelsea, or Jodhpur with a rain last or chiseled toe. I've been meaning to buy a pair of Carminas but cant find a single video review of their boots. Thanks

[@PradiptaD]

Hi Kirby, I love your new “shoe review” series. Very thorough and yet concise coming from a channel I have come to trust for my wardrobe needs. By the way, where can I find the schedule of GG’s trunk shows?

[@Teethingpains]

This is certainly a desirable pair of shoes, excellent review video, Kirby and thank you for bringing such immense knowledge and insight to your viewers. I would be keen to hear your thoughts on the C&J Connaught Vintage Calf shoes at some point.

[@Wongheichi]

How does this pair of GG compare to Edward Green Chelsea or John Lobb CIty II?

[@AT-oj7of]

How about an outfit description? In particular, I’m wondering the color and specs of your suit (material, make, weight, etc.).

[@ralphwilliams8083]

Thanks for another great video, Kirby! Appreciate your explaining UK to US shoe sizes! Will you review the "Holden" G&G black captoe oxford model? Thanks!

[@PickingProfits]

Black Cap toe oxford worn with jeans? That may be the first time I ever heard you say something I disagree with.

[@DavidSaintloth]

Not every one can make it work. It's ok. First, there are many high quality designer jeans that dress up perfectly with shoes. Second, and often over looked... a Man has to recognize when his body plan makes sense for a given combination of clothing. Larger Men necessarily have to accept different proportions and cuts for all their clothing and shoes as compared to more svelte Men...this is going to modify what looks best on a Man across this range of sizes and shapes it's just physics. Third, Confidence....the inner light that people just know when they see it goes a huge way toward allowing an outfit or ensemble that is being sported as a dandy experiment to make that particular combination work. Forth, context... as ever the social situations in which you find yourself define another dimension of modulation for what combinations make sense. Consider this 4 dimensional landscape as a massive combination of possibilities for Men to express *their* unique style across the landscape and though you may not be able to deftly span your optimal portions of the landscape ...it doesn't mean that others are not more adept at doing so, revel in their success and learn how to apply it to make yours.

[@tabishumaransari]

It can work with dressier jeans if you experiment with casual shoelaces

[@kirbyallison]

Not my personal taste, but with a nice, dark pair of jeans, it could certainly be pulled off at night.

[@TS-yn9ey]

Agreed! 💯✅

[@karldelavigne8134]

They are OK with jeans that are not blue, something which should not be worn anyway by a gentleman.

[@JonasHavens]

Kirby, thank you for this fascinating series on Black Cap Toe Oxford shoes. It’s incredibly informative and has piqued my interest into possibly investing in a higher quality shoe. I know this question is difficult, complicated and extremely personal but if you had to choose between purchasing a Gaziano & Girling oxford or an Edward Green Chelsea, which one would you chose.

[@johnlittlewood4527]

Another well made and informative video. Thank you.

[@dylantran2319]

Would you recommend these shoes for someone who has just started getting into gentlemen’s wear such as myself?

[@henrikjohansson6629]

How about reviewing something more budget friendly next? Something from the Loake 1880-range perhaps? I find the Loake Churchill to be an interesting take on the classic oxford shoe.

[@АлексейСавченко-э5ф]

Absolutely superb video as usual. I especially like the way you speak and the fact that you tell us the information no other KZbin creator would. I’d highly appreciate it if you could review any pair of carmina shoes. I feel like this brand is the best alternative to Allen Edmonds at the price point. Thank you again for the content.

[@edf2953]

Very informative video Kirby. I am pleased to hear that you will be reviewing various quality shoes on a regular basis. I look forward to future productions. If I may be one of the first to suggest a possible shoe for one of your upcoming videos, I personally would enjoy seeing a review of one of Allen Edmond’s shoes, perhaps either the Strand or Fifth Avenue. Whichever shoes you decide to review, I will anxiously await your next video in this new series.

[@roskes]

Brilliant idea!! My vote for your next review, the George Cleverley Churchill.

[@JasonAnthony1979]

Please do a review on Loake shoes. Especially the Holborn series. Thanks

[@chowychow]

Kirby would you consider reviewing Aldens?

[@karlailin]

Ohh the stitching.. I dunno how they do it.. it's beautiful.. Also, love to see more Daniel's made shoes.

[@MikeFreesinger]

Kirby your presentations and subject matter are truly unique and 5 star. I only wish you could be cloned and Kirby II brought the same care and expertise to clothing 😎

[@dechalertsumitkul8066]

Can you please review on Balfour in vantage rioja or black calf

[@olu665]

Beautiful shoes on my way on purchasing them

[@AD-dq5vo]

Hi Kirby! Great videos and great work. I have a question regarding the "V" gap in closed lacing shoes. Should there be one? If yes, how big of a 'V' gap is considered to be fine? Thanks. Antonios.

[@sem1174]

Have you ever reviewed Paul Parkman shoes?

[@tabishumaransari]

Any chances of reviewing more affordable handmade British shoes such as Paul parkman, Loake etc. ?

[@kirbyallison]

Tabish Ansari We already have a review on Allen Edmonds. I’d consider Loake. As long as I can stand behind the quality, I’m happy to review.

[@TrojanMars1]

Yes, Paul Parkman 👍

[@paulcastellano1747]

Could you review J. Fitzpatrick Roosevelt

[@ktgordan]

Really enjoy your content! :) Would be great to see reviews for mid range shoes such as C&J and Carmina etc. Thank you very much!

[@johnyvannijlen4070]

I visited the website of Gaziano & Girling. Beautiful shoes but not on my budget. For now I am happy with my blacks and browns from Giorgio 1958 and Evita's from Spain. Thanks to your video's I can keep them shiny and well maintained with Saphir Medaille d'Or. My next pair might be Meermin from Mallorca.

[@thanhbinhnguyen5683]

More of these plz! Maybe next time will be Saint Crispin's rtw black cap toe oxford

[@kirbyallison]

thanh binh Nguyen Yeah! Would be interesting to review everyone’s black captoe oxford!!

[@dechalertsumitkul8066]

Nice review. Saint Crispin and Gaziano & Girling. Can you do a review on both brands? G&G is coming to Thailand soon and I have an appointment with them. Both have excellent qualities and design but which is the better investment? Thanks

[@cyriledwin7394]

Hi Kirby, thank you for the great work. May you please review the Alfred Sargent Armfield?

[@giacomoserra4240]

Hi Kirby, what about reviewing some italian brands such as Fratelli Borgioli or Harris? I'm very fond of them, they make a very high quality ready to wear at a very reasonable price. Also could be interesting reviewing the Spanish brands of the Almansa and Mallorca regions, such as Meermin, Berwick 1707 etc, or even portuguese like Carlos Santos. Thank you for the good work!

[@elsanch8675]

Can you recommend a good leather moisturizer?

[@zvik9291]

Great vid as usual 👌🏾 please keep them coming. I will be great to hear your take on the famous ‘foster and sons’ / ‘Henry maxwell’ grain brogue oxford - “ranger”. Trusted partner for a chilly weekend in the country

[@KMaybach1]

I would love to see a video, where the Goodyear-welted Santoni Shoes are being reviewed.

[@glenngray6859]

Once again Kirby your big brother Glenn is envious. Lol

[@johncas1]

Can you review samual windsor shoes there handmade and goodyear welted but rearly cheap arround £50 mutch less than say Crocket and Jones because there made in India but are they worth buying is the quality there

[@samuelbatth4317]

What do you think about Berluti

[@roychefets1671]

what is their shoe made in conjunction with a shoemaker in Brussels?

[@wilhinds8144]

Thanks for another excellent video!

[@NikitaVinogradov-pd2ch]

Hi Kirby. Please review Berluti shoes. Thanks

[@augustmay444]

Could you please review a pair of Saint Crispin's?

[@olu665]

Do they have a store in New York?

[@davidfelkai5770]

Kirby: Please review LodinG, this French brand has produced some extremely elegant shoes that defy any logic as it relates to price. I think it would be an eye opening experience, there is no one else quite like them today. Thanks, love you work!

[@georgel2093]

They are no longer the most recently opened factory - Foster & Son have a brand new factory as well! I would love to see coverage on any information you have on that.

[@kirbyallison]

George L I just saw that! Would love to review some of their new shoes.

[@kirbyallison]

George L I was thinking about this while reviewing the script for be next G&G review. They were, and still are, the first new shoe factory to open in 100 years. Fosters is the second, and indeed as you pointed out, most recent. But it shouldn’t diminish the risks Tony and Dean were taking or how groundbreaking it was at the time.

[@111ImNumber1]

Please review Edward Green shoes.

[@hichamelharrouchi4742]

Thank you Mr Kirby Allison

[@wilsongoalie1]

Can you please review their churchill model and see why it is 580£ compared to 900£

[@wearenotlonely]

Love your videos. I understand that your channel is oriented more towards the wealthy; but I hope to see reviews of perhaps more affordable items that still come from a certain degree of heritage and might have caught your attention. Interested brands: Grenson, Timlittle, Tricker's, Alfred Sargent, Crockett and Jones, etc.

[@wearenotlonely]

Also Carmina customize

[@kirbyallison]

Absolutely! We’ve got years of content ahead of us, but our goal is to try to review as many of these shoes as possible!!

[@woodypaq]

Very well crafted. I thought Magnanni brand was a standard to achieve. Whew.

[@fritzguye]

Second video i'ved watched of yours that claims to have the gaziano factory tour in the description but cannot be found...

[@kirbyallison]

If you look at the description now. you can see the link is there. Alternatively, go directly to the video here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWHTp5mvd7N5g68

[@CreamJockey]

Love that suit color!

[@FederalNetwork]

Please review John Lobb's Becketts

[@general1911]

Where is the link for the Gaziano & Girling Factory Tour? The link in description just reloads the current video.

[@kirbyallison]

Apologies, not sure how that link wasn't correct. It is fixed now, so the link in the description is correct. Here is the correct link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aWHTp5mvd7N5g68

[@general1911]

@@kirbyallison Great! Thank you!

[@olu665]

Beautiful shoes

[@shimenga1]

I'm a Cheaney man myself. These are out of my budget ! Perhaps one day !

[@SoXFireBlade]

Watching this and wearing a meermin black cap toe oxford.

[@nub915]

Hi Kirby, where can you get these shoes in the US?

[@enzovilladolid4613]

Gaziano and Girling New York showroom

[@kongmw]

C&J reviews please!

[@KeenanModica]

Why can't Allen Edmonds build last like these? These are so beautiful!

[@kirbyallison]

The difference isn't really as much of the last design as it is how the shoe is manufactured. Take a look at our Gaziano Factory Tour video. You'll see that Gaziano takes additional steps to pull the upper around the last in order to give it the sculptured definition. A significant amount of additional work goes into creating a shoe on this level, which is why they are 3-5 times more expensive. For the price, AE does pretty good work (for the price).

[@aerolord]

Yohei Fukuda. Please.

[@王泽楷-o4d]

I have a question why Italian shoes are wider than British shoes

[@nelsonnaiding3094]

I am in india,please tell me how to get it.....

[@bradle4162]

Kirby, I think all of us in the comments would REALLY be interested to hear you criticize some shoes. Am I not the only one who wants to hear a rant?

[@orionmok5724]

nice glasses

[@marcocastro5921]

Greetings from. Costa Rica

[@olu665]

Tomford cap-toe shoes

[@chazgurrero3090]

WHARE can I go to have someone measure my feet so the shoes are made to perfection?

[@BumagatBactol]

I have a question hout the video

[@abdulkhafidsulaymaan]

Man... I don't know.. At this point I may have to stop watching these videos- at this point its becoming torture for me to see these delicious treats while knowing I will never have a taste...

[@abdulkhafidsulaymaan]

I just went to this site and designed a pair of shoes, they ended up costing $1700 shortly thereafter my computer crashed I assume the site was simply to rich for my simple computers blood... lol

[@JollyGoodJewWitch]

I am not a fan of Tom Ford in general but I must say TF Black Gianni cap toe is more elegant and better looking than this G&G one.

[@hyungsup2]

근데 구두가 불편했을것 같네요 잘 안맞는거 가지고 구겨 넣은 느낌 ㅠㅠ

[@ivanwong1304]

Haha hope not too many bespoke black cap toe!

[@Loki-sk7bi]

Nothing wrong with black shoes