How Different Are Standard German and Bavarian???

In this video I compare the Bavarian dialects of Bavaria, Austria, and South Tyrol with Standard German. *Check out the excellent German course "German Uncovered": ▶ bit.ly/Uncovered-German ◀
See Uncovered courses for all languages: ▶ bit.ly/3fYI1uo ◀
Special thanks to Robbie for his Standard German samples, and Simon Bun and Robert Kalem for their help with Bavarian samples! And thanks to others for their suggestions, including Benedikt Peter.
These amazing people support Langfocus at / langfocus :
Nobbi Lampe-Strang, AmateurTextualCriticism, Anjo Barnes, Auguste Fields, Bennett Seacrist, Brandon Gonzalez, Brian King, Clark Roth, Fiona de Visser, Georgy Eremin, Jacob Madsen, John Moffat, Karl-Erik Wångstedt, Kenny, Leon Jiang, Marcelo Loureiro, Matthew Etter, Michael Arbagi, Michael Cuomo, Paul Falstad, Rosalind Resnick, Ruben Sanchez Jr, Sebastian Langshaw, ShadowCrossZero, Victoria Goh, Vincent David, Yuko Sunda, 19jks94, Abdullah Al-Kazaz, Adam Powell, Adam Vanderpluym, Admir Soko, Alen, Alex Hanselka, Alexandre Smirnov, Ali Muhammed Alshehri, Alvin Quiñones, Andrew Woods, Anthony Peter Swallow, Aous Mansouri, Ashley Dierolf, Atsushi Yoshida, Avital Levant, Bart Atwood-Ebi, Bartosz Czarnotta, Ben, Benn M, Brent Warner, Brian Begnoche, Brian Morton, Bruce Stark, Chelsea Boudreau, Christian Langreiter, Christopher Lowell, David Eggleston, David LeCount, Debbie Levitt, Diane Young, DickyBoa, Dieter Raber, divad, Divadrax, Don Ross, Donald Tilley, Ed B, Edward Wilson, Eric Loewenthal, Erin Robinson Swink, Evolyzer, Fabio Martini, fatimahl, Fawad Quraishi, Grace Wagner, Greg Boyarko, Gregory Garecki, Guillermo Jimenez, Gus Polly, Hannes Egli, Harry Kek, Henri Saussure, Herr K, Ina Mwanda, Ivan Cristi, J Yang, Jack Jackson, Jaidyn Workman, Jakub Krajňanský, James and Amanda Soderling, James Lillis, JAMES ORR, Jay Bernard, Jens Aksel Takle, JESUS FERNANDO MIRANDA BARBOSA, Jim Wink, JK Nair, JL Bumgarner, joanna jansen, John Hyaduck, Justin Faist, Klaw117, Konrad, Kristian Erickson, Krzysztof Dobrzanski, Laura Morland, Lee Dedmon, Leo Coyne, Leo Barudi, Lincoln Hutton, Lorraine Inez Lil, Louize Kowalski, Luke Jensen, M.Aqeel Afzal, Mahmoud Hashemi, maiku, Margaret Langendorf, Maria Comninou, Mark, Mark Grigoleit, Mark Kemp, Markzipan, Maurice Chou, Merrick Bobb, Michael Regal, Mike Frysinger, Mohammed A. Abahussain, Mário Pegado, Naama Shang, Nicholas Gentry, Nicole Tovar, Oleksandr Ivanov, Oto Kohulák, Panot, Papp Roland, Patrick smith, Patriot Nurse, Paul Shutler, Pauline Pavon, Paulla Fetzek, Peter Andersson, Peter Nikitin, Peter Scollar, Pomax, Raymond Thomas, Renato Paroni de Castro, ReysDad, Robert Sheehan, Robert Williams, Roland Seuhs, Ron McKinnon, Ronald Brady, Saffo Papantonopoulou, Scott Russell, Sergio Pascalin, ShrrgDas, Sierra Rooney, Simon Blanchet, Simon G, Spartak Kagramanyan, Stefan Reichenberger, Steven Severance, Suzanne Jacobs, Theophagous, Thomas Chapel, veleum, Vinicius Marchezini, William MacKenzie, William O Beeman, yasmine jaafar, Yassine Ouarzazi, Yeshar Hadi, Éric Martin, Merrick Bob, Michael, 晶 羅.
Music: "Actually Like" by Twin Musicom.
Outro: "Devil Cut" by Coyote Hearing.
The following images are used under Creative Commons Sharealike 4.0 license:
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi.... Author: Willcom.
Still images incorporating the above image in this video are available for use under the same CC Sharealike 4.0 license.

[@Langfocus]

Hi everyone. I hope you like the video! There's a little mixup in one part of the video starting at 7:47. The word-for-word translation says that "heute" means "hot" and that "heiß" means today, but it's actually the other way around: "heute" means "today" and "heiß" means "hot". Check out the excellent German course "German Uncovered": ▶ bit.ly/Uncovered-German ◀ See "Uncovered" courses for all languages: ▶ bit.ly/3fYI1uo ◀ Disclosure: If you upgrade to a paid course, Langfocus gets a small referral fee that helps support this channel.

[@FernandoPerez-fp7pd]

Hi Paul I love your channel

[@uwezimmermann5427]

both constellations of the sentence are common: "heute heiss" und "heiss heute"

[@otakuofmine]

even hoping more for a video on low german as language video ;)

[@JRondeauYUL]

Viele Danke, Paul! Es macht mich denken über die Québécois und die Franzosen.

[@Yussalim]

Please do Swahili and Comorian next!!!

[@huawafabe]

I'm a Bavarian and once went to Berlin into a restaurant. I forgot to speak standard german, and accidentally ordered in Bavarian. The waitress asked "Do you speak English please?"

[@nirfz]

Ah, great to see that it's not just us Austrians who have to rethink before talking in northern germany :-D Every couple of years i have to go to cologne for some refresher course needed for my work, and i always have to be carefull with my wording. (The only people outside my language region i have to communicate with for work, usually require the use of english, so i seldom use high german in spoken form). But the nicest thing in cologne was once, when noth thinking and asking the waiter "Kaun i bitte a Wosser hobn?" He grinned from ear to ear and said: "Österreicher? Ich hab einige Jahre in Wien gearbeitet!" and then added in "perfect vienese": "Wüßt a lautes oder leises?". 😃

[@huawafabe]

@@nirfz wundaboa :D

[@majedal-baghl4917]

@@nirfz Zwei jungen Koellnern habe ich "heuer" gesagt, und die haben das Wort nicht verstanden. Die haben geschworen, dass sie das Wort nie gehoert hatten. I said "heuer" to two young guys from Cologne, and they didn't understand it. They swore that they'd never heard it.

[@nirfz]

@@majedal-baghl4917 :-D

[@Humpelstilzchen]

A secha Heigeing 😂

[@Sleeping_Insomiac]

I once was hiking in Scotland when I was approached by two guys. They asked, in the most germanic accent imaginable, where the nearest campsite was. I asked "Are you german?". When they said they were, I said "Na, dann können wir ja auch Deutsch reden!" (Then we can talk german!) They had such a thick Bavarian accent, I had to go back to English. I am german.

[@Fabii2000]

Sleeping Insomiac Schöne Story

[@Sleeping_Insomiac]

@@Fabii2000 Und wirklich so passiert... 😂 Die sind wahrscheinlich nach GB in Urlaub gefahren, weil sie neben Englisch nicht noch Deutsch als zweite Fremdsprache lernen wollten...

[@jankajanke]

Aber... Lernen sie kein Hochdeutsch in der Schule? Ich wohne jetzt in der Schweiz, und alle Leute können da Hochdeutsch reden, trotzdem die sehr stark Dialekt.

[@lenaganslmeier2641]

Rein theoretisch kann ich Hochdeutsch reden, aber es hört sich an als würde ich jemanden nachäffen + Hochdeitsch ist zu anstrengend, deswegen lasse ich es gleich bleiben😂

[@peterlustig6888]

@@jankajanke Kommt aufs Alter an

[@DeepWater-rm8vo]

Bavarian here who grew up in rural Ireland. I once had German tourists pull over and ask me (In English) for directions (I was wearing my school uniform so they assumed I was local). They had a northern German licence plate so I figured they wouldn’t really understand Bavarian, so I gave them the directions in Bavarian. They said they were sorry but that they couldn’t speak Irish Gaelic. Won’t ever forget that.

[@FullmetalChuunibyou]

😂😂😂

[@ameliejelden2987]

😂😂😂

[@jhyncedavicbertiz767]

😂

[@rippspeck]

And then, everyone clapped. Echt traurig, dass man sich in Bayern so einen Bullschiet ausdenken muss, um interessant zu sein.

[@TheLumberjack1987]

I'm Austrian and my fiancé is Dutch, she says our dialect sounds like "farmer's german". I find that description to be annoyingly accurate.

[@kabakaprime5127]

I think that's how it is for most dialects though as city dwellers tend to speak high German and more formal and the further out into the harsh and wild hinterland you go the more dialect is still spoken. The Franconian, Hessian, East Frisian or Swabian dialect also sound very much like farm although there might be slightly different agricultural associations respectively (hop plantations, vineyards, cow farms, etc.). At least I have never met anybody that sounded more intelligent or educated by speaking dialect.

[@sebandi2549]

Break up with her as soon as possible

[@Ideophagous]

It's just a matter of perception and mentality. If some dialect became commonly used for high level endeavors (news, books, articles), the stigma would start to disappear, especially if it's officially adopted into the administration of a state. My mother tongue is Moroccan Darija, and I find it annoying when my countrymen try to mix in words or expressions from Arabic or French just so they can sound "educated" and "sophisticated". I prefer to use my language in its purest form, and only borrow words when there's no other choice.

[@TheLumberjack1987]

@@Ideophagous sure that's a possibiliity, but there isn't even an official Austrian dictionary, so you'd need to define the syntax first. And then you'd run into the issue of Austria having a good number of different dialects in different provinces, some of them are so different from each other that I can't understand a big chunk of my own fellow citizens if they chose to go full in on their own dialect. The good thing about having "High German" taught and used throughout the country also means that we can by default communicate with ~100 million people from Germany and Switzerland instead of just 9 million in Austria. It's not a bad thing in my opinion. I'm in my 30s now and so far I haven't seen any criticism of my dialect which wasn't made as a well meaning joke. :)

[@Ideophagous]

@@TheLumberjack1987 I understand that that's the case for High German, which actually spoken by actual living people in casual as well as professional situations. High Arabic (Standard Arabic) on the other hand is practically a dead language, if we go by the number of native speakers, it has exactly 0 native speakers. People at home and on the street only speak their respective dialect. And the situation you describe is what we have within Morocco, since Moroccan Darija itself can be broken into regional dialects, some of which are not easy to understand for other regions. Furthermore, Standard Arabic, and the ideology of pan-Arabism associated with it, have been used against our unity as Moroccans, by creating division among so-called "Arab" Moroccans and "Berber" Moroccans.

[@xwolpertinger]

I give this the highest form of approval in Bavarian: "basst scho"

[@DeslazDeslaz]

geh, basst scho

[@stupot8413]

Jo, genau oder?

[@AJ-xe3kt]

I work in a certain Bavarian Bierhall chain in the US that's based in Munich. I'm the only German-speaker there. I had a couple of guests from Germany (im assuming Bayern) answer with "basst scho" and I had no idea what they meant 😅

[@Zeis]

@AJ@@AJ-xe3kt literally means "it's alright" but can be used as "don't worry about it". If you transpose it into an American dialect, it would be: s'coo'

[@domsjuk]

@@AJ-xe3kt basst scho = passt schon. :D

[@Slash18622]

German: „Dieses Essen schmeckt mir außerordentlich gut!“ Bavarian: „Zum scheißn glangts.“

[@faunina669]

LOL that actually made me laugh

[@Gwynbl31dd]

I varreck 😂

[@Uuodan42]

"Nix g'sagt is g'nug g'lobt"

[@DrHouse-zs9eb]

Da frag ich mich: gibt's auch Österreicher die Fäkalhumor ablehnen? Oder ist das Teil der Kultur?

[@Slash18622]

Dr. House glaub mir, des ist zu hoch für Dich...

[@oddaardvark7733]

Kind of fun story: I learnt 'German' from my grandparents, who grew up in Austria, speaking Bavarian. I didn't know that that was totally different to Standard German, so I rocked up at my secondary school German class super confident. 11 year old me tried to impress the teacher by having a conversation with her in German, only for her not to have much of a clue what I was saying because I was speaking Bavarian. That sent my brain into a bit of a vortex for a while there.

[@Fabii2000]

poor kid

[@whohan779]

If it consoles you somewhat: if she honestly couldn't grasp your speech you either learned a really thick variety of Austrian and/or the teacher wasn't really eloquent. I myself am from a dialect region near Bavarian, but closer to Swabian, general Franconian (Hessian or Kurpfalzian) and can understand most dialects other than thick Saxon, Platt or Northern German. Knowing a lot of dialects also seriously helps when learning closely related Germanic languages such as Dutch or Yiddish.

[@jk-jl2lo]

@@whohan779 i was thinking the same thing. the teacher might not have a lot of experience with stronger dialects like bavarian. i remember my old german teacher, who starting learning german in high school, telling us he studied abroad in graz and started to doubt his own fluency because he couldn't understand half of what anybody said to him for the first two weeks. it wasn't that he couldn't speak german, he just couldn't speak that form of german because he'd never been exposed to that dialect and accent before. i think there's a good chance the teacher in this comment also had never heard a bavarian/austrian dialect before.

[@isaac4273]

Would it be a good idea to learn Bavarian or any other dialect when studying German for the very first time? It's odd, but I find it (at least the little bits I got from the video) somewhat easier and even more pleasant to the ear than standard German, idk there's something to it that I like

[@oddaardvark7733]

@@isaac4273 Honestly, you're better off learning Hochdeutsch, which is standard german, and then if you really want, you can try and learn dialects. People won't understand you if you try and speak a southern dialect, especially if you go somewhere where another dialect is spoken, for example schwabische. It's really cool to learn the dialects though, and I'm glad you think it sounds nice!! It can certainly be a more relaxed version. But if you're a beginner, you definitely need to know the basic grammar rules, which are going to be a lot harder to learn if you're trying to learn a separate dialect as well. Good luck though, and have fun! :)

[@giubob1862]

It's interesting that the word for ''hello'' in Bavarian it's ''servus'', which is like latin (the person who serve). In italian the word for hello is ''ciao'' derived from Venetian ''sciavo'' (schiavo) which means slave. serve and slave (servo e schiavo) were pretty much synonims so i spotted a correlation. Both word (servus, ciao) are the short form of ''i'm at your service''

[@chcomes]

to be more precise, it is " servus humillimus, domine spectabilis"

[@TheGojibogyo]

Also maybe interesting that in Hungarian they also use szervusz, but they have an abbreviation for it, too: Szia, which sounds really close to see ya. And when talking to several people, you put it in second person plural form, so it becomes szervusztok/sziasztok. And they use it for both greetings and when you leave each other. You also can use hello for both, which really needs some getting used to.

[@christianstiegler1347]

In german Servus can also be used to say goodbye

[@guzziwheeler]

There is also the (southern-) german farewell salutation "stets zu Diensten" ("allways at your service").

[@rubinfriedman3429]

Widely used in Austro-Hungarian Empire and in Catholic areas in the past.

[@phis7230]

As a south-tyriolian i can say that every village has his own dialect.

[@hcassells66]

Their*

[@dieterh.9342]

@@hcassells66 Es wäre am besten mit 'its' verwendet; doch 'his' ist OK: every village = singular, d.h. singular possessive adjective.

[@lapidarianmoraine3870]

​@@dieterh.9342 Eigentlich ist nur 'its' richtig, weil natuerlich auf Englisch gibt es keine maennlichen Substantive, die nicht Personen oder selten Tiere sind. 'his' stimmt nur mit 'villager,' nicht 'village' (Englisch ist meine Muttersprache). Aber niemand soll beschaemt sein, der Unterschied in diesem Fall zwischen singular und plural ist schwierig auch fuer Muttersprachler. Im Alltag sind die grammatische Regeln nicht streng: es ist haeufiger, 'every group of people has *their* own dialect' statt 'every group of people has *its* own dialect' zu sagen, obwohl 'its' Oxford-grammar richtig ist. Ein singularisches Kollektivum wird oft als Plural behandelt.

[@zwidawurzn9423]

lol i always say in Austria every valley has it's own dialect, you can actually struggle to understand people who live 50km from where you grew up. "hwwh hn shwwwm hnghh!" "wos?" "hau den scheiss am Hänger!" "ah, ok"

[@brennerbahn-laferroviadelb9179]

@@kasknedl1710 Gut - Besser - Gösser

[@Slash18622]

German: „In diesem Aspekt kann ich Ihnen in vollen Umfang zustimmen!“ Bavarian: „Scho.“

[@user-pt4zp9dg6l]

Me, a Russian : * trying to understand, why you wrote Ukrainian "what" like a German word *

[@Slash18622]

Владимир Винарский “scho” is “what” in Ukranian? Nice! :)

[@user-pt4zp9dg6l]

@@Slash18622 yes, though Russians and Belorussians also know and sometimes use it. P.S. шо ("scho") is a informal, as I got, form. In Ukranian the formal form is що ("schtscho". If you heard such soups like borscht or schtschi you'd hear the correct sound).

[@damschu23]

Oder „Jo eh“

[@MahmurdSahara]

vollem*

[@windshieldlaugh7411]

My sister once was in German class and they were asked by their teacher how they call apple core, btw this was in Bavaria and my family is from Saarland but we speak standard German/ Hochdeutsch, so everybody said automatically „Butzen!" and my sister "Apfelkerngehäuse" then everybody stared at her. It’s kinda funny because the standard German has such a long word for it, typical German word. Yeah little anecdote

[@waltergro9102]

My mother is from the Lower Rhine region, my father from Swabia. They spoke only Standard German to me. But I got understanding of both dialects when I heard them talking with their respective relatives. Nevertheless I'm a Standard German speaker, but I never heard or said Apfelkerngehäuse, we said Kitsche (I don't know the Swabian word) and I always regarded that the correct standard word. Standard German has official spelling rules, there are dictionaries and lexicons for everything, and there are many academics who try to prescribe everything. But ultimately also Standard German is what people make of it and many statements about pronunciation or grammar or what is the correct word are illusory.

[@martinn.6082]

Windshield laugh haha, that’s great! You can have hour long discussions about these kinds of words. Like what do you call the rest of the bread? My boss is from Swabia and they even have two words for the ends of the bread, one for the first cut and one for the last. Another example ist: how do you call slippers? Hausschuhe, Schlappen, Latschen, ...

[@Menta_]

@@waltergro9102 I grew up near Hannover with only Standard German and next to no dialect and have never in my life heard the word Kitsche, seems to be a local thing..

[@elecrom_9757]

@@Menta_ That's probably because Standard German is heavily based on the Hannover Dialect^^ so people from there would have the most "pure" Standard German

[@grauwolf1604]

The shortest wort for Apfelkerngehäuse is Kernhaus. But it is not quite correct.

[@Resomius]

SG: "Als ich ankam, hatten sie noch nichts gegessen." Bav: "Warum is´n no soviel vom Leberkas do? Is der schlecht?"

[@wrob0710]

a bissl a wörtlichere Übasetzung: " wiari kema bin, hams no nix gessn ghabt" (kein "als" sonder "wie", mit einem Verbindungs-R: "als ich" -> "wia i" -> "wiare". und natürlich kein Imperfekt: "wie ich gekommen bin, haben sie noch nichts gegessen gehabt")

[@josipohn]

Eher Warum hobtsn ihr voikoffer nu nix gessen bist du deppad

[@sskuk1095]

* Lebakas

[@dontrunlikethat]

Der Kollege der die hochdeutschen Wörter einspricht ist viel zu motiviert

[@Leotique]

war das sarkasmus ? xD klang eher depressiv am anfang, aber danach recht gut

[@ciberflash6648]

YES

[@angeloelimelech6346]

Finally my language! I speak it most of the time, even though I live in Munich and it's not really common to speak/hear it. Mostly the elderly people speak it in the city, but in the rural areas it's still very widespread. But I don't know what the future will bring. Kids aren't able to speak it even there anymore. It's kinda sad that my local Munich variety will die out... But I have no doubts that austro-bavarian will survive in Austria.

[@sandrowederb1275]

@@angeloelimelech6346 In München stirbt er wirklich aus , da immer mehr aus dem Rest der BRD nach München kommen. Aber im Rest von Mittel,Ober und Niederbayern kenn ich genug jugendliche , die noch bairisch sprechen.

[@akari8168]

XD

[@true_perplexeus]

Paul: Bavarian can be hard to understand Swiss: Hold my cheese

[@ichbinhier355]

I'd say cow instead of cheese lol

[@true_perplexeus]

@@ichbinhier355 Or cash (to keep the initial c consistent)

[@AJ-xe3kt]

Schweizerdeutsch ist ja abgefuckt

[@andyjay729]

More like HOLE your cheese. ;)

[@eddgrs9193]

In my case it takes a while until I get their rhythm, but then I get caught in it, and I start to involuntarily mimic them :)

[@adriansroka8576]

I‘m a polish guy living in the deepest part of Bavaria called "Niederbayern" and I love when they say " Es ist mir Wurst" which exactly means "This is sausage for me" BUT they use this expression for "I don’t care 🤷🏼 or it doesn’t matter" .

[@mstrmren]

I think that‘s not only Bavaria. I‘m from Aachen in NRW and people use that too.

[@marekjanuska8367]

@@mstrmren we use the sentence with the same meaning in Czechia, translated to czech of course

[@petergradisnik5007]

Wurscht in Ö.

[@JonathanArcher100]

Wuarscht in Wien

[@leobelens]

Same in Berlin.

[@Shutterbeetle]

Thank you for this lovely video I just re-discovered! I grew up in Bavaria, left at age 19. Spent the next 38 years living in English speaking countries (Australia, USA and Scotland), speaking VERY little German, and forgetting more and more of my mother-tonge! I arrived back in Germany very recently (along with my Aussie husband), nervous about sounding like an idiot, because apparently, my Bavarian still sounds 100% flawless - nobody detects an accent. However, my language skills are still that of a very young person, (i.e. I'm not entirely familiar with many "adult" terms (such as regarding taxes, insurance, mortgage, health issues, etc etc etc), and on top of that, 38 years have changed the German language A LOT!!!! As a result, I must sometimes/often come across as a "local" moron :-( Anyway..... I still understand nearly everything, and speak it well enough - especially Bavarian. I am now re-disccovering my roots and upbringing. I have developed a new appreciation of my native dialect - it is so rich, so full of nuances, so much deeper, funnier, and richer than standard German! There is so much humour and amazing detail that can't come across in "Hochdeutsch". I feel blessed that I understand and speak this wonderful dialect! Thank you very much for not poking fun at us "Bauernfünfer" (the "Preissn" like to portray us as simpletons), but to simply state differences without judgement.

[@THOUGHTCRIME_No1]

Hochdeutsch doesn’t sound nice. Perhaps because it’s an artificial language, originally only introduced for writing reasons. But it’s based on Oberdeutsch (thus the former Southern German languages). Since the Northern German languages were completely different (more like Dutch, Old English) the population was later forced to give them up and adapt Hochdeutsch. For South Germans there was no reason to adapt since it was the template. In a few decades most of the still somewhat present German dialects will likely extinguish.

[@rizzogelato]

How am I supposed to understand German when Germans can’t even understand German

[@DennisTrovato]

...not...

[@JustinG1057]

Don’t worry, most German people don’t go out of their ways to learn the Swiss dialect or Bavarian. Because you speak English, you should definitely be able to learn German with some practice.

[@jadenk1409]

Most English speakers have hard time understanding Jamaican English or south African English you know...

[@mccardrixx5289]

Ich bin aus Bayern

[@HesseJamez]

We use high german as lingua franca. Not all of us can speak it, but will at least understand.

[@witch5878]

Standard german: Wie bitte? bavarian: Ha?!

[@huaba8804]

Wos?

[@Ultrajuiced]

People from Berlin also tend to just say "Hä?", right?

[@boahkeinbockmehr]

Platt: Watt?

[@tiganupaleru1880]

Formal Norwegian (bokmål): hva? Kan du si det igjen? Every single Norwegian person alive: hæ?!

[@ErnestKaltenStalin]

Wos wüst?

[@kosinusify]

Diese Kommentarsektion ist nun Eigentum der Bundesrepublik Deutschl- ah na, Moment... Der Kommentarbereich ghead iaz unsam Kini Ludwig II. und am Freistaat Bayern!

[@krisv533]

Nein gehört Markus Söder

[@mijp]

Whow, immer derselbe hirnlose Kommentar. Habt ihr dafür ein Tastaturkürzel eingerichtet. Ich frag mich, wie ihr das macht. Habt ihr einen Suchbot um solche Videos zu finden, nur um den Kommentar drunterzusetzen, oder lasst ihr einfach die Katze über die Tastatur laufen? Oder schreibt ihr das überall, irgendwo wirds schon passen. Euer Leben muss ja ganz schön langweilig sein, wenn man den ganzen Tag nichts andres zu tun hat.

[@kosinusify]

@@mijp Alter, chill doch. Ich wollte nur einen Witz machen, weil es eben eine Parodie auf diesen ewig gleichen Kommentar sein sollte. Und für das Video habe ich mich natürlich interessiert. Ich verstehe wirklich nicht, warum du da gleich so in die Luft gehen musst.

[@mijp]

@@kosinusify weil der Witz langsam so nen Bart hat, dass man drüber stolpert.

[@kosinusify]

@@mijp Dann heul doch.

[@drmasroberts]

Great analysis Paul. My mother-in-law left Vienna in 1950 as a war bride. Twenty years ago we traveled across Germany to Vienna with my son and his German friends. Our companions were from Hanover, but my mother-in-law spoke only English to them until we got to the eastern edge of Bavaria. There one of our companions’ brother-in-law who spoke her dialect joined us. Suddenly she became lively and talkative. She explained later that she had not spoken Standard German since leaving school at age 14. Now I understand a bit better her language difficulties.

[@asmraxel9060]

As a bavarian/franconian speaker: More beer -> more dialekt.

[@hughjazz4936]

Is halt so, wol? Is im Pott net anders, weisse? Machse dir zwei, drei Bierchen auf, da geht dat aber los hier.

[@Playyugiohonpc]

Hello there!

[@ashtray4757]

Kannsch als Saggse nur beschtätschen

[@thoralfschmidt1472]

nich lang snacken, Kopp in' Nacken

[@fabianreusch4870]

Is überall so glaub ich 😂

[@abwehrschlacht9694]

0:27 Most Germans find it difficult to understand it Swabian: Am I a joke to you?

[@maxw1567]

endlich sagt's mol einr

[@percyreiling]

Same ! Schwäbisch ist aber auch unterschiedlich genug für ein eigenes Video. (würd ich gerne sehen lol)

[@maike0597]

@@percyreiling so wahr😂 jedes Dorf hat n bisschen n anderen Dialekt und andere Wörter

[@snaffers9309]

Exakt. Als Schwabe hat man keine ernstzunehmenden Probleme mit Bayrisch. Auch die grammatikalischen Besonderheiten, die hier aufgelistet sind, sind für uns normal.

[@Oshibananen]

als odenwälder versteh ich schwäbisch sehr gut, finde es aber schrecklich mir anzuhören, womit ich wesentlich mehr Probleme hab is sächsisch

[@melz6625]

I’m sorry but WHY is the standard German speaker so totally passive aggressive like someone dragged him out of bed at a Sunday morning and put him in front of a mic and said he doesn’t get coffee until he finishes this?

[@chaosof99]

Because he is german.

[@Braamsery1992]

He sounds so much like we walkt in Norhtern Germany. Exactly as you described. We dont want to talk about suff we dont want to talk abou, so we do it slightly annoyed without noticing :D

[@sobrecoxadealface6745]

thats how germans normally talk

[@DrShedslow]

Maybe because he got dragged out of the bed... I was annoyed by his way auf speaking. He is just a bad example, most germans don't talk like this.

[@maikstrecker6995]

​ @@sobrecoxadealface6745 "thats how germans normally talk": Maybe to you because of such an attitude... Cause, honestly, that assumption is really insulting. I could hardly endure this passive aggressive, utterly bored pattern of speech of the SG- example Speaker and I speak Standard German. If I talked to people with such a pronounciation in daily life they would hopefully assume I am retarded and not downright hostile.

[@Deckzwabber]

I learned to speak German mostly through my relatives in Tyrol, Austria. Of course in school here in the Netherlands we learn Hochdeutsch. My German teacher told me off for writing the first month of the year as Jänner. I was confused, I had never known another way to spell january in German. After spending the Christmas holidays in Austria I brought my teacher a calender from Austria. It was his turn to look confused. This was such an interesting topic for me. I'm a quite a language nerd, so I like anything linguistic. I've been exposed to standard German through school, German TV and books, to Bavarian through spending time in Austria and to Lower Saxon dialects by growing up close to the German border in the north of the Netherlands. Although I'm fluent in German, I've always had difficulties keeping Bavarian/Austrian and standard German apart and I speak a weird mix of them when I speak German. To answer your question: yes I find it very difficult to follow conversations in Tyrolean and other Bavarian languages. Even though I have no problem understanding standard German or the Lower Saxon dialects. And yes, I've spent a lot of time in Austria, but that helps surprisingly little. Usually my friends and relatives there speak a mix of Tyrolean and standard German to me and my family (for quite a few of them, this means they try as hard as they can to speak Hochdeutsch).

[@ulrichhille5241]

Thanks for sharing your story. It took me years to realize that Jänner was real German , as it is :)

[@07Flash11MRC]

@@ulrichhille5241 "Jänner" is used in Switzerland, Austria and South Tyrol. Germans are the only native German speakers of those 3 groups (linguistically speaking South Tyrol belongs to Austria), who use "Januar". So I'm not really sure what you mean by "Jänner" being "real German".

[@YIIMM]

*Hey, I don't say it that way!*

[@mccardrixx5289]

SERVUS

[@PewPewPlasmagun]

@Han Boetes Jo is des woar?

[@TheBadassTonberry]

Wos wüsst.

[@PewPewPlasmagun]

@@AndersGehtsdochauch I HAU DIR DE RANZA VOLL

[@rogerabc6880]

I studied german for 4 or 5 years and I find amazing that there are so many dialects and germans can speak both SG and their own dialect, changing from one to the other naturally. Living in a big country where everybody speaks the same language, that sounds amazing to me. Once when I was in the train from Vienna to Venice, I couldn't understand what one family was speaking to one another and I felt so sad that I had spent so many years and money learning german and couldn't understand a word. Then a good soul told me that they were probably talking dialect. That saved my day. Deutsch ist die Sprache, die ich als eine dritte Sprache ausgewählt habe zu lernen. Sehr stolz dass ich ein bisschen Deutsch kann.

[@etuanno]

What's really hard regarding the German dialects is that it's not easy to learn because everyone writes them a bit differently. My friends and I speak the same dialect (Berndeutsch) and we grew up not more than 20km apart, but we write it differently. Different words and with many words you can use E and Ä because the the real sound is somewhere in between. Long story short you have to decide which dialect you want to speak and live with the advantages and disadvantages of it (culturally speaking).

[@SmilyXDDD]

@Fern Ansley USA dialects and Australian ones aren't nearly as strong as german dialects are. The British ones come closer, but as far as I'm aware they don't have as much trouble understanding each other. That being said I couldn't understand my own family (grandparents, aunts and uncles) when I was younger because they speak a different dialect. It's a 2 hour drive from where I live to their homes. And both dialects still belong to the same dialect group.

[@moosesandmeese969]

@Fern Ansley The varieties of English are usually much closer together. It's hard for me to even call them dialects (except for whatever the hell they speak in the southern US). I can adjust my speech to match someone's accent but I don't typically because that would be very weird.

[@WunderWuzzii]

@Fern Ansley no idea where you get your 12. Austria alone has about 9 dialects, and if spoken properly, a person from the next state can't understand everthing.

[@rvdzst]

There is strong dialects in every major european language. If not anymore (e.g. in France) than it´s because governments have suppressed them over centuries. Compare real deep Scottish with Standard British English or Sicilian with Standard Italian or Catalan with Castilian.

[@plainText384]

"Your opinion is a scrambled pancake dish" - Me to everyone I disagree with

[@miriamredinger]

I'm Tyrolean (Western Austria) and I want to stress two things again: 1. This dialect is really a spectrum. So the dialect described in the video would be the "pure form" (of one specific variation within the Bavarian dialect group) but hardly anyone actually speaks like that, most people mix it up with Standard German to various degrees. I for example do use the Genitive sometimes and I never use double negatives, I also (like most Austrians) don't roll my R. 2. It's important to know that there's a difference between "Bavarian Dialect Group" and "Bavarian". The different Austrian dialects (except the one in Vorarlberg, it is in the same Group as Swiss German and the dialect spoken in Baden-Württemberg) belong to the Bavarian dialect group but aren't Bavarian. The word Bavarian is usually only used to refer to the dialect spoken in Bavaria specifically. Within this group there are many, many variations and usually within the variations there are variations again, so basically in every town people will speak a bit differently (and as I said every person speaks a bit differently too). And while all those dialects belong to one group, they're really, really different. In my opinion, people from Vienna/Eastern Austria don't sound like (actual) Bavarians AT ALL. People like me from Western Austria speak more similarly to Bavarians, but there's still a significant difference.

[@ChritachY]

Host rechkrcht xD

[@quuaaarrrk8056]

@@ChritachY Innsbruckkkkkkkker?

[@tickrob991]

I would say people from Salzburg and Oberösterreich sound more like people from Ober-, Niederbayern and southern Oberpfalz. Oiso, obwoi s Boarische ned imma gred wiad bei uns in München, hob I des Gfui, dass de Leit vom Attersee beispuisweis s'Boarische vui ähnlicher redn wia mia. Wenn a Innschbrucka Deitsch redt, hob I des Gfui, dass des Schwobe san de Boarisch redn wuin. Und wenn a Wiana redt, klingts fia mi scho Boarisch oba fuuui langsamer und nasaler (iwie französischer Akzent). Es ko sei, dass nur i des so empfind. Bin Brasilianer und zum Doi mit ner ondern Sprach afgwochsn. Servus und pfiat di aus München

[@danielsanabria6770]

whereabouts exactly people tend to roll their R's?

[@JulianAllescher]

@@danielsanabria6770 Southern Oberbayern I'd say. I grew up in the Berchtesgadener Land and a lot of people here and the surrounding regions roll their R's - however, not all of them! Also if you cross the border to Salzburg (Austria) less people seem to roll their R's in my observation.

[@ConlangKrishna]

As a child in Luxembourg, I watched "Meister Eder und sein Pumuckl", a Bavarian childrens' series about a red-haired gnome who could become invisible. That is how I learned to understand Bavarian quite early. When I visited Bavaria with my Dutch husband, who speaks Standard German very well, I understood most of the daily conversation, but some slang words were difficult to get. My husband understood next to nothing. So I had to translate ;-)

[@jakob1095]

Beste Sendung :)

[@HomoAlone]

I loved pumuckl

[@oJoJ777]

It tooks me ~20 years to realise, that Meister Eder speaks a hard bavarian dialect :,D Just when i went from the middle of nowhere in bavaria (i mean... RLY the middle of nowhere) to Berlin i realised that. It was mind blowing. (And no i had no problems over there, because i have absolutly no accent or dialect while speaking standard german. Gamers live, yay )

[@teriampuls9356]

Kobolt!!! :-D Hahaha - ein Gnom sagt sie :-D

[@oJoJ777]

@@teriampuls9356 well, thats what you get out of her message? a "mistake"? you´re so german my friend. rly ^^

[@arthur_p_dent]

Standard German: "Was meinen der gnädige Herr?" Bavarian: "Wos host g'sogt?"

[@thwt1974]

Standard German: "Ich hätte gern zwei Brötchen."; Bavarian: "I wui zwoa Semin ho'm!".

[@Carewolf]

@@thwt1974 They dont' have konjuktive either?

[@DJKooorl]

I think you mean "Wos host g'sogt, deppata?" ;)

[@varana]

@@Carewolf They do, this is more a joke about the Bavarians' image of being grumpy and impolite.

[@run4me2fast]

@@thwt1974 Bavarian: "I wui zwoa Semin ho'm!". vs Austrian/Viennese: "I wüh zwa Semmen hom."

[@RetiredRhetoricalWarhorse]

I'm pretty sure this will not be that interesting to anyone outside these regions, but now I'd really love to see a comparison between Bavarian, Swiss German (pick one) and Austrian.

[@elonmush4793]

Austrian technically is part of the Bavarian dialect (although Austrians probably will always insist on the differences, oida). Especially diphthongs are different when I think about it. And Swiss German is indeed completely different (but also shares some commonalities with the upper German dialects).

[@DerJuvens]

Swiss German is basically Bavarian and Dutch mixed together with a little french to spice it up.

[@rosomak8244]

Swiss German could safely drop the German and be called just Swiss. It's a completely different language. Someone speaking German will not understand a single word.

[@RetiredRhetoricalWarhorse]

@@rosomak8244 People in southern Baden-Würtemberg and even some Bavarians understand us well enough.

[@ulrichhille5241]

@@RetiredRhetoricalWarhorse I guess with lots of good will and patience this can be possible. I come from the region of Augsburg, where a mixture of Bavarian and Swabian is spoken. This region is close to the Swiss border. Many years ago, I went to a skiing resort in Switzerland near the city of Chur. When I went sightseeing in Chur and asked a group of local teenagers for the way round, I didn't understand a single word when they answered me. They seemed to be helpful and I was a teenager myself. So there was no generation conflict or so. I felt embarrased and suspected that they were taking me for a ride which was not the case, as I later learned. The Swiss-German dialect (Schwyzerdütsch) is really hard to grasp for non-speakers; and Swiss people speak it until they drop dead after a very long and fullfilling life :)

[@evadobreva5788]

I am Bulgarian living in Austria and I have been struggling with the local dialect ever since I moved. I must admit I am getting better and it feels as an achievement :) Lots of love to Austria and everyone who speaks this beautiful dialect 🇧🇬❤🇦🇹

[@denniszimmermann5176]

I was waiting for "Alter" to "Oida" during the whole video. Very important word. Ask a german.

[@DeslazDeslaz]

Oida, mochs eana ned no kompliziata wia`s sei muass - de tuan se so scho schwar gnua, moanst ned?

[@Atantuo]

Yeah, dude.

[@mccardrixx5289]

Oder digga!!!

[@ancientpear6780]

@@mccardrixx5289 na, digga sogn nua di deitschn

[@kianseibel9305]

Alter, du liest meine Gedanken :D

[@mursie100]

As an Arabic native speaker, we have exactly the same dilemma as German, our dialects vary wildly, and we end up switching to Modern Standard Arabic to easily understand each other.

[@TommyTheWalker]

I guess you can say that about any language, in my case Sicilian was spoken before Italian even existed. Btw we borrowed a lot of Arabic words

[@kmkalabed]

My father in law tends to speak with me in MSA trying to make himself more understandable, on the other hand my mother in law doesn't give a single damn and leaves me in bewilderment every time a French or a frenched Arabic word makes its way in her think unedited Algerian dialect. 😂

[@user-wt8pr6zn7j]

@@TommyTheWalker Нет. Как носитель русского языка я могу смело заявить, что в русском языке нет никаких диалектов.

[@AmirSatt]

​@@user-wt8pr6zn7jпотому что большевики их уничтожили. Даже украинский и белоруский, которые настолько же далеки от московского русского, как баварский и нижненемецкий, потеряли свои позиции. Хорошо ли это или нет я не знаю, с одной стороны все друг друга понимают, с другой меньше разнообразия

[@althelas]

The thing is that Bavaria has 5 different dialects, Fränkisch, Oberpfälzisch, Niederbayrisch, Schwäbisch and the one you focused on, Oberbayrisch. I grew up with the dialect of the Oberpfalz in Northern Bavaria. I moved to Oberbayern (to a town about 100km south of Munich) when I was 18 and thought I would be fine, since I was still in Bavaria. How wrong I was. For the first few months I barely understood my co-workers and they had the same problem with me. Those two dialects located only 300 km away from each other are so different that one could not understand the other. Dialects often change from one village/town/city to the other. One of my co-workers later on came from a small viallge about 8km away from where I lived at that time and she used some words I have never heard before like "gummara" for cucumbers (Gurke in German). that word came from the french concombre and was a left over from the time when Napoleon's army ihad invaded the area on their way to Russia.

[@HansDampf5]

Dass Bayern fünf verschiedene Dialekte hat ist so nicht ganz richtig. Auf den beiden Sprachkarten am Anfang kann man das relativ gut sehen. Grob gesagt gibt es in Bayern, wie man auf den Karten sieht Bairisch, Schwäbisch und Fränkisch, wobei das Bairische hauptsächlich in Oberpfalz und Ober- und Niederbayern gesprochen wird. Kleinere bairischsprachige Gebiete in anderen Regierungsbezirken mal ausgenommen. Das Bairische kann man dann nochmal, wie auf der anderen Karte ersichtlich in diese drei Gruppen aufteilen. Dass dein oberpfälzische Dialekt so unterschiedlich ist zu dem Dialekt in Oberbayern ist der unterschiedlichen Gruppierung dieser Dialekte geschuldet. Nördlich von Regensburg beginnt das Nordbairische und südlich beginnt das Mittelbairische. Ich wohne zwischen München und Regensburg und spreche deshalb Mittelbairisch. Ich würde sogar behaupten, dass der Dialekt in Niederbayern fast deckungsgleich ist mit dem in Oberbayern und auch mit dem in der südlichen Oberpfalz. Tut mir leid für den langen Roman, aber ich wollte das mit den 5 Dialekten nicht so stehen lassen. ;)

[@tongobong1]

Interesting "gummara" is similar to Slovenian word kumara. Maybe this word came from Slovenian language that is south from Austrian-Bavarian.

[@TheofficialPr0]

@@tongobong1 That's what I thought as well or maybe it's from french too

[@johnnwako2488]

There're no languages/dialects called "Oberbayrisch"/ "Niederbayrisch"; neither "Bayrisch"! Bairisch is the correct word/spelling!

[@Magdalena-qv3mc]

I think my most typically Bavarian interaction was ordering beer at the local "Volksfest", trying to get the waiter's attention. me: "He!" waiter: "Ha?" me: "Zwoa Mass, bitte."

[@christophpaessler8444]

Hahahha, ned schlecht! Und nachads, sans dann kemma, d´massn?

[@Flauschi981]

a bidschen gibts fast nia, ea a merce

[@TheMrGameszocker]

Standard German: Entschuldigen sie, was haben sie gesagt? Bavarian: Wos

[@lube6966]

Wie bitte?

[@Aetherguy-cb9bu]

Watn

[@hyenalaughingmatter8103]

Wat was nord deutschland, wir im norden sind nicht höflich wie die aus bayern glauben

[@RoterZwerg]

Kölner hier, wir sagen HÄ? :)

[@Erik-jl7ns]

Hm?

[@jaredweber6721]

My girlfriend is Austrian. Anytime we visit her parents, and everyone switches to dialect, I'm immediately lost. I have scoured the internet in search of this exact material! thanks for finally being the one to post a definitive video for this!

[@henrykaspar3634]

I am in awe how well researched and accurate your videos are.

[@NoName-cs9ce]

I remember in German class my teacher called my accent atrocious. Little did she know my grandmother is Swabian and thats how I learned the language.

[@Warentester]

So she was right?

[@NoName-cs9ce]

@@Warentester Considering i was using it to speak high German she was right. But for a teacher who thought she was a German expert, she somehow couldn't recognize one of their languages or dialects.

[@Warentester]

@@NoName-cs9ce you didn't say she didn't recognize it, you said she called your (Swabian) accent atrocious and as a native German I wholeheartedly agree with her.

[@NoName-cs9ce]

@@Warentester Weird, must be that swabian hatred I've heard about. Most Americans I know think Swabian sounds far nicer than high german. But thats probably because we associate high german with guttural noises and the 3rd Reich. Whereas Swabian sounds more French which we consider more elegant.

[@katherinegilks3880]

@@Warentester There is no such thing as an atrocious accent. All versions of a language are equally valid and beautiful.

[@flokopter]

As an Upper Austrian I can say, it is sometimes very hard to understand people from every other state or even district in Austria. 🇦🇹🇦🇹🇦🇹

[@dogetea]

Na oida, außa tirola und gsiberger haha

[@danielholowaty2648]

Muiviadl is gaunz ondas ois' zB in Wean oda a Graaz

[@miriamredinger]

@@dogetea Ich denke, jeder österreichische Dialekt ist in einer sehr starken/extremen Form schwierig zu verstehen. (Bin Österreicherin, auch wenn man es meinem Geschreibsel nicht ansieht). Also die Wiener Umgangssprache (eig. Standarddeutsch mit Wiener Einschlag), die man z.B. von den Politikern kennt, ist natürlich sehr verständlich, aber ein richtiger Wiener Dialekt kann einem, wenn man ihn nicht gewohnt ist, schon Schwierigkeiten bereiten.

[@shikkithefirst5393]

Owa voi! Und i wohn jt scho 8 joa im auslond oiso hea i jt netta die mühviertler mundoat die mei familie redt und sunst nix. Wiad oiwoi schwara das i die ondan dialekte vasteh...

[@Kameliius]

Ois aufrichtiga Steira kaun i nua song dass du recht host gö

[@_Killkor]

2:30 Standard German: Regen Bavarian: *Squidward sounds*

[@panzerofthelake506]

Hahahaha

[@hhemingw4y]

O M G i'm crying !!!

[@cannonballbob6949]

Spongebob auf Deutsch

[@elecrom_9757]

@@cannonballbob6949 Squidward ist Taddäus ;)

[@Delibro]

Hahaha I was crying when I heard it in the video, but now I lay on the floor

[@lindacowles756]

I remember a German Christmas carol "Es wird schon gleich dunkel" from a record of my husband's, but have seen the title also represented as "Es wird scho glei dumpa" (Austrian/Bavarian). Your video explains why it is different from the SG wording. I always wondered how they got "dumpa" from "dunkel".

[@davestrasburg408]

This was fascinating. l never thought that Bavarian was so different from Standard German. l remember when as a teenager, l saw on television a German film, which was set in Munich, Bavaria. l remember that l imagined that the language heard the movie was Bavarian German, and l remember that l found it clearer, and easier to comprehend, than most German accents. l now realize that it was actually Standard German spoken with a Bavarian intonation.

[@samjhylton]

I'm an American living in München (a Ami z'Minga) and I learned Bavarian from my flatmate, who apparently knows words that only her family and people from her village on the Austrian border know. Not super applicable in every day life, but tons of fun to learn.

[@NIKSEEN]

A Zugroasta, welcome! I'd love to hear some of those words if you don't mind sharing :D

[@Njordin2010]

Oaschkatzelschwoaf

[@vogelvogeltje]

Im a Mexican American learning dutch since Jan 2020. Same. Not practical but so much fun to learn..

[@tinaselka8155]

@@Njordin2010 Eichhörnchen 😁

[@klugscheier1644]

@@tinaselka8155 schweif(Schwanz)

[@justink5000]

1. The woman has a beautiful pronunciation of Bavarian. 2. Everything is legit - thank you for all the effort Paul! 3. Ich liebe dich for making a video about my native dialect. I heard that you were making another German video, but I literally freaked when I saw it was Bavarian.

[@willwu7929]

Hi Justin, may I ask you a question? How do definite articles of different noun cases(der die das die, dem der dem denen, etc) change in Bavarian? Is it the same as standard German? I've seen somewhere "das" being replaced by "des" in Bavarian so I am curious about it. Thx!

[@justink5000]

@@willwu7929 That's a tough question! You are definitely right that das changes to des; as far as I get it, that's the case if das is being used as a demonstrative pronoun. If das is a definite article, it can also be "as" or just "s". It is really hard for me to think about that! I only picked up Bavarian by listening to my parents and grandparents. In school we only got taught on how standard German works. I think the articles stay roughly the same as in SG, while obeying the rules Langfocus explained in the video.

[@justink5000]

Der is da Die can be di or de Dem stays dem Denen is dene

[@willwu7929]

@@justink5000 Okay, thank you for your information! That helps a lot

[@DDKKAY]

Was ist los mit dir alter? ....bist du Verrückt allder......😂😂😂🤣🤣A Bisla Spaß....Allder....Das Geht Vay nieer.....

[@boernsnnn]

I like the fact that "I" - "a" and "is" both in bavarian dialects and in standard english mean exactly the same.

[@hauptmann25]

Pronounced very differently tough, except for is.

[@vinctendo_tv]

"is" is used in most other german dialects too. For me(living in Mecklenburg-Voropommern) when speaking we always shorten words but that's a whole other story. So "ist" becomes "is" as well.

[@mikaelvilhjalmsson6068]

I really like your videos, and I absolutely love this one. Being German myself and having learned several languages, it is very interesting for me to work out similarities and differences, for example between Swedish, Norwegian and Danish, or between German and Dutch. Doing this within a language, between standard version and regional variations, is really interesting. I sometimes have to deal with such issues myself, coming from the Rhineland (near Düsseldorf) and having moved to Berlin. Carry on!

[@solaireofastora5432]

if you go into a restaurant and you say "Grüß Gott" instead of "Hallo", everyone knows where you are from

[@beastwulf1165]

"Grüß Gott" is just formal. But I think you mean Austria? Well at least I hope so

[@ThisisFerrariKhan]

@@beastwulf1165 It’s an instant signifier that you have some connection to the Bayrisch/Austrian footprint altogether.

[@poppyseed890]

@@beastwulf1165 It's becoming kind of old-fashioned these days. I still sometimes use it, but only when I'm talking to strangers, older people....."Hallo!" and "Servus!" are the most commonly used words by younger people now.

[@vinctendo_tv]

Or if you go with "moin" -but properly pronounced and not doubled because it would mean goodbye, like in Finnish where you have "moi" and "moi moi"-, but it's a bit more interesting bc most people ask me if I'm from Hamburg when they hear me speak but I'm from Mecklenburg, so yeah... I mean it's around the corner, so not to bad :)

[@ReaperCH90]

But then I arrive, say it that way for the fun of it and throw you a curve ball

[@evan800]

Me: Learns German to go to Germany and speak German. Bavaria: Omae wa mou shindeiru Me: WAS???

[@mccardrixx5289]

Servus!

[@qutondalfiss2712]

Evan Jones NANI?

[@DeslazDeslaz]

wos soin des hoassn? Omea wa mou shindeiru - sounds more than Australian English spoken way down the Billabong, mate

[@Carewolf]

A cashier in Switzerland spoke Swiss-german to me, and I looked confused for a while, then she repeated it in Italian.. That didn't help :D

[@rick0201]

Evan Jones Bruh that looks like japanese

[@dingus_doofus]

There's also "heuer" in Standard German for "this year", but it's basically out of use.

[@oinophilos2109]

Known worldwide now because of Austrian heuriger Wein. At least if you follow wine stuff.

[@sparkybonobo6196]

Is it out of use in Bayern? My relatives in Vienna use it all the time! They'd probably never even use "dieses Jahr" :-)

[@grauwolf1604]

I say "heuer" in standard german.

[@peterholzer4481]

Heuer is regional (common in the south, uncommon in the north). I don't think its use has changed much over the last decades.

[@grauwolf1604]

@@peterholzer4481 it is as you say. I come from Schleswig-Holstein. There "heuer" is unknown since 70 (!) years. I live in Bavaria. There it is commonly used since 70 years.

[@berzerk1450]

As a native speaking bavarian i am really impressed by the accuracy of this video. I searched something like this on YT because i wanted to describe a foreign friend these differences and this video did it better than i could explain it to him in english.

[@peachie7950]

I’m in 3rd year German at school and this really cleared up why my (BAVARIAN) teacher sounded different than when I heard German outside of school lol

[@SoiledWig]

Two of my German professors in college were Austrian. Good or bad, it definitely made a difference.

[@NIKSEEN]

As a Bavarian, my Bavarian English teacher also sounded quite different to any native speaker .... ;D

[@user-bl4oq7fd8d]

@@SoiledWig It actually sounds kinda funny to me if people learn German in Switzerland or Austria/Bavaria and then speak Standard German. To me as a Northern German (with dialect very close to Standard German) it sounds like a double accent. They have the Southern accent on top of the accent of their country :p No offense btw, normal German dialects can also sound very funny to me... The first time I met someone from Saxony in person I actually had to turn away from the group to hide my smirk.

[@powidlkm]

@@user-bl4oq7fd8d Well, exactly the same happens also the other way round. For example, many german turks speak this kind of mixed northern german/turkish accent.

[@FrozenMermaid666]

Edit out the misused fruit term peachie that only reflects me the pure being (the opposite of wom’n / hum’ns) etc - it’s beyond disrespectful to food / fruit / flowers etc when wom’n / hum’ns misuse such Holy terms in the name or yt name, and all wom’n / hum’ns are the exact opposite of such terms!

[@andrayas.]

As someone from southeastern austria, styria to be exact, what you said about ''everyone may not say it this way in their dialect'' is 100% true Even though austro-bavarian has next to no rules already, we somehow manage to have even less, with words like ''heiß'' changing into ''haass'' instead of ''hoass'' or completely changing words like ''wäre'' into ''waarad'' To answer the question you posed at the end of the video: It's like flipping a switch inside your mind, I rarely talk austro-bavarian in public, not even with most of my friends but as soon as I come home or I get a call from my sister, I immediately switch to full on austro-bavarian haha Aynways, great video !! It's nice to see this dying dialect get some exposure !

[@sternenhimmelfotografierende]

Vovel changing form 'o' to 'a' One (1) Egg: Bavaria: Oa Oa Estern Austria: Aa Aa (or kind of)

[@jonasgrunberger3381]

@TheShiningEmiru griaß di vo oberösterreich guade erklärung,... ko net a jeda so guad auf englisch erklären

[@bendover2684]

Euer Problem ist, dass ihr immer Berge hoch und runter lauft. Diese Höhenunterschiede sind nicht gut für euch. Ich brauch ein-zwei Kaminwurzen um mich dagegen abzuschirmen

[@moveslikemacca]

südsteiermark eyyyy

[@TheBadassTonberry]

@@sternenhimmelfotografierende Wiacht da Wiacht wochtn oda wocht da Wiacht net.

[@igel10]

Bravo Langfocus, gut gemacht!

[@karimatz]

These videos are so good, so to the point. Echt wunderbar erklärt.

[@vegetarianmeat]

For a quadruple negation: 'I moan bei uns hod no nia koana koan hunga ned ghobt'

[@richard--s]

a ned noch zwanzg knedl.

[@andubarosanu6897]

Romanian can have 4ple negation as well “Nimeni nu stie ca el nu are niciun ban” Nobody knows he has no money

[@nickduch6214]

Andu Barosanu isn’t that just double negation?

[@michaelgrabner8977]

Na wenn nia koana koan hunger ned ghobt hot oda hot daun brauchts es oba a nix essn

[@Ninchennase]

"I mean with us, nobody has never no hunger not had."

[@grafdracolyny3703]

As an Austrian i am very happy someone finally cares for my language! Thanks Paul!

[@lukas7307]

oida wir sprechen österreichisch und net bayrisch

[@gonzo2495]

@@lukas7307 Österreichisch is ka Sprach'. Bairische Sprachfamilie.

[@lukas7307]

gonzo wir reden trzdm nt bayrisch🤦🏻‍♂️ wir mögendes bayern aber wir sind keine bayern und reden nicht wie sie

[@gonzo2495]

@@lukas7307 Wir sprechen einen bairischen Dialekt, bis auf die Vorarlberger die zur alemannischen Sprachfamilie gehören. Ich find deinen Lokalpartriotismus ja süß, hier ist er aber einfach nicht angebracht.

[@lukas7307]

gonzo girl ich hab keinen “lokalpatriotismus” i was born and raised in america bby. Bin halb americaner und halb österreicher und in österreich gibt es verschiedene dialekte und es is mir auch egal zu welcher sprachgruppe wir gehören man spricht in österreich deutsch mit österreichischem dialekt. Aus

[@lisakrenn712]

Props!! This is actually a great explanation/representation of Bavaria/austria and how different we are to the rest of Germany Thank you :)

[@brunoleonardo929]

I'm an American from California. I moved to Germany for my girlfriend who is Bavarian. German has been going fine until I met her parents and they pretty much only speak Bayerische😆. Going to dig into Bayerische after my B1 exam. This video was very helpful!

[@zwidawurzn9423]

Yes Austria, the country where every valley has its own dialect, i drive half an hour in one direction and struggle to understand people even if i grew up here.

[@beastwulf1165]

Sei doch ned so zwida

[@MorgorDre]

Oida wos?

[@FakeJamesHolden]

Answer to the question "How long you need to finish the pojekt?" Standard German: "Ich brauch noch ungefähr 3 Tage, 7 Stunden, 20 Minuten und in etwa 30 Sekunden um alles fertig zu haben." Austrian: "Dauert nu a bissal"

[@foxytungsten8195]

"Boid fiate" oder "woat a weng"

[@OnkelJajusBahn]

Or Was ned schaumamoi

[@ollehellemaa4789]

can someone translate? Ich spreche kein deutsch

[@OnkelJajusBahn]

@@ollehellemaa4789 Comment from Zero Zero was: Standard German: "I will need 3 days, 7 hours, 20 minutes and 30 seconds to get everything done." Austrian: "It will take a while." foxy love wrote: "done soon" or "wait some time" Jerrad Wiliams wrote: "shit ...." the second word I don't know. I also don't know what he means. I wrote: "I don't know, let's see"

[@Avi-rn6ei]

My best bro comes from the way southern part of austia and I'm from north germany. It's hilarious if one of us switches to original dialect instead our middle way. Tho I need to say that even his real accent is more understandable than the Bavarian accent... ugh 'deutsche sprache, schwere sprache'

[@Adson_von_Melk]

Thank you very much for this brilliant video! It has been very interesting and useful for me.

[@Rosenrot0eme]

Even in the standardized dialect, most people tend to use the perfect tense more, at least in speech. You might use imperfect tense when you're telling a longer story, but in a regular conversation you'll come across as really stilted/posh.

[@pianissimist]

I'm an American with only basic German. When I was with an acquaintance in Vienna, he asked what I might want to eat for lunch, and I happened to mention Klopse. He immediately put on a great act of alarm, warning me never to say that word in Vienna: "It's Knoedeln! If you say 'Klopse', someone will think you're German!"

[@Landsknecht89]

Incredibly funny :)

[@Slash18622]

German: „Das hast Du wirklich außerordentlich super gemacht!“ Bavarian: *ned gschimpft is globd gnua.“

[@ascaniusvotan2319]

Das sagt man im Schwabenland auch!

[@ashtray4757]

Franken sagen das auch

[@cebillon]

@@ashtray4757 Nein, die Fraggen speziell die Närmbercher sagen Bassd scho" das ist das grösste Lob das ein Franke ausspricht.

[@joedeefoster6792]

Das sagt man auch hier im Norden. Und das ist das oft auch das Einzige, was man gesagt bekommt. Im ganzen Jahr.

[@uinsel]

Austrian version: "Jo eh."

[@chrisvickers7928]

52 years ago I enrolled in a German course in first year university. Since I had taken beginner's German in grade 12, I was placed in the honour's German course. It was a small class with 9 students. Our teacher, from Edinburgh spoke German with a Scottish brogue. One of the students in the class, Kurt was from Vienna and occasionally the teacher would pause and say, "How would you say that in Vienna Kurt?" After a while I got used to his accent but it seemed to me he elided more like French without the glottal stops in high German.

[@manmanman4825]

3:24 "müssen" is "miassn" in Bavarian, "muass" is a conjugated form, e.g. "I muass wos essn."

[@NoEntertainment]

I just think it's interesting that these regions of Europe speak fairly different languages from each other, even though they're in the same geographic region as a much more widely spoken language, in this case, Bavarian being used in a "German-speaking area". Even though the usage of Standard German is starting to outweigh the use of these dialects and most people know the standard German anyways, it's hard to believe not super long ago you'd drive for about an hour by car in these areas just to hear people speaking something fairly unintelligible. And these dialects get left in the dust a lot. Thanks for covering them!

[@Lia-uf1ir]

We have to preserve local dialects and languages that either have not many Speakers anymore or are in danger of becoming extinct through the use of the official Standard language of a Country.

[@jadenk1409]

'Cause Germany wasn't "unified" (rather centralized) for most of its history. Thus the dialects were kept alive for long times. Italy was the same but thanks to great Florentine poets,writers such as Dante, Florentine dialect was spoken(or at least read) throughout Italian states.

[@Lia-uf1ir]

@@jadenk1409 Even if countries aren't unified, there can still be a City or capital that influences how People speak or read (think of your Italian example). Germany didn't even have that, it didn't have a capital like London or Paris where all the influence came from.

[@mccardrixx5289]

@@Lia-uf1ir Servus!

[@jadenk1409]

@@Lia-uf1ir yeah Rhine regions were full of microstates and eastern regions weren't really focused on cultural uniformity.

[@christophbichlmeier4085]

Different ways to express "Sorry, could you repeat that please?" Standard German: "Entschuldigen Sie, könnten Sie das bitte wiederholen?" Bavarian: "Ha?!?"

[@svan9263]

Wos host gsogt

[@MellonVegan]

Pott: Wat?!

[@DieAlteistwiederda]

Ist glaube ich in Deutschland generell auch of einfach irgendwas ähnliches wie "Häh?!" einfach nur mit regionalen Ausprachen. Habe das mittlerweile in fast jeder Region schon gehört.

[@alexanderpraehauser5115]

Wos sogga?

[@mcburcke]

Now, that's funny! And so true...

[@EmmaPeelman]

Excellent, very educational and very entertaining. Also helps me make more sense of the lyrics from D Speida Mürfi Geng aus Minga!

[@GeorgiosMichalopoulos]

Great video!

[@JacobOvergaardMadsen]

In dialectal Danish, a genitive form similar to "the man his house" is also frequently encountered. "Schmeissen" is also a cognate to Standard Danish "smide" with the same meaning "throw".

[@Hvitserk67]

Many people in Norway say "the house to the man" (directly translated) although "the man's house" is grammatically more correct. Some also say "Peter his bike" instead of the more correct "Peter's bike" (similar to your example from danish). I think this shows some of the flexibility many languages have, including Danish/Norwegian and German.

[@sztallone415]

well, as Paul said, Bavarian maintains a stronger similarity to the Middle-Ages' German, so by extension, also to the granddaddy of all Germanic languages, so it's not surprising that other Germanics can understand it better than Standard German.

[@thwt1974]

@@Hvitserk67 You can say that in German, too. ("Das ist dem Peter sein Fahrrad!" instead of "Das ist Peters Fahrrad!"), although it's considered uneducated.

[@Hvitserk67]

@@thwt1974 In a Norwegian context, your example is quite interesting. In Norwegian, one would normally say "Peter's sykkel" (Peter's bike), but as mentioned earlier, "Peter sin sykkel" (Peter his bike) is also used. Originally, this form came from the city of Bergen on the west coast of Norway. The city was part of The Hanseatic League and many German immigrants came to the city. I believe that the phrase "Peter sein Fahrrad" was therefore directly translated into "Peter sin sykkel" in the local dialect in Bergen. This form has spread to other parts of the country over the years, but as you also point out, it is considered uneducated.

[@Rebecca-vg2ef]

@@sztallone415 it's not so much "older", it's mostly a different sub-branch. Standard German is actually more similar to northern varieties

[@wachuku1]

That’s so interesting that “Ich,” “ein,” “dich,” and “ist” are “I,” “a,” “di,” and “is.” It’s parallel evolution, I think. That’s kind of like with English “I,” “a/an,” “thee” and “is,” but without the vowel shift in Bavarian “I” and without the voiced dental fricative in Bavarian as in English “thee.”

[@letozabalmaty]

yea, according to the Great Vowel shift I must be an AI diphtong in the future just like in modern English)))

[@Leo-uu8du]

And "they" is "dej", "after" is "åft", "to kindle" is "-kentn", "rain" is "reing", "ear" is "earl", "to hear" is "hearn",... But "Butterfly" is "Summervogal", which is more similar to Swedish.

[@siphu]

@@Leo-uu8du Butterfly in swedish is "fjäril". How is that similar to summarvogal?

[@KUAN0540]

i found it's also funny how the "a" and "an" is used if the word starts with a vocal for example: an apple / an opfe/i a banana / a banane though in bavarian there are exceptions where only an "a" is used instead of an "an".

[@nirutivan9811]

Kuan0540 I don‘t speak bavarian (so I could be wrong), but I think the a/an is more cause of the noun gender and not cause there is a vowel. In my dialect (Swiss German) it is „e Banane“ and „en Öpfel“ and in Standard German it’s „eine Banane“ and „ein Apfel“. Apple is a masculine noun in German, therefore it needs the masculine articel („an“ in bavarian, „en“ in Swiss German, „ein“ in standard german), while banana is feminine and therefore need the female article („a“ in bavarian, „e“ in Swiss German and „eine“ in Standard German).

[@jpcgordon]

I commented on another but this one deserved another so I could tell you that you absolutely nailed it. Everything you said was so accurate. If I'm honest, I was expecting there to be some false clichés and stereotypes here but you couldn't have done this better. So good. I am bilingual in English (UK) and German (but learnt German a lot later) and, living in Munich, do switch between high German and Bavarian with varying degrees depending on who I'm speaking to.

[@pattiskidmore8792]

When I went to my first store after arriving in Austria (having studied German in school), I was greeted with "zgot." I had no idea what kind of greeting that was. When I left she said, "schaun." Again, I was clueless. Later I learned that "zgot" was short for "Gruess Gott" and "schaun" for "auf wiederschauen." They never taught me either of those in school!

[@emanuelbaldissera6510]

OMG Paul! I wish you had made this video 8 years ago, before I moved to Austria. At that time I was really confident in my standard German and I thought that dialects were just a slight change in the pronounce. BIG MISTAKE! I was shocked that I couldn't understand anyone talking to me. It took me 6 months to learn these aspects you just presented now. Anyway after 2.5 amazing years, having a daily contact with Austro-Bavarian and almost no spoken standard German, I moved back to Brazil. Even though, for me it is still much easier to understand standard German than Austro-Bavarian. Very nice video!

[@mikek.692]

@Emanuel Baldissera It's exactly as you say. Everybody learns, reads and (hopefully) writes standard German but (almost) nobody speaks it. When talking with friends we always agreed that standard German is very hard to learn for a non-native speaker. If you finally manage to understand and speak German and come to Austria/Germany you're screwed because nobody talks the language you've been putting so much effort into learning. On top of that: everybody will understand you but you won't. Must be very frustrating. Hope you had a nice time here anyway, greetings from Austria - "Servus!" or "Serwas!"

[@herbertkattner4097]

Austro Bavarian? are you complety NUTS. Bavarian is Bavarian and NOT Austrian

[@Leo-uu8du]

@@herbertkattner4097 Austro-Bavarian is the correct linguistic term. Same reason why Serbo-Croatian (spoken from Serbia to Croatia) and Indo-European (spoken from India to Europe) are a thing.

[@herbertkattner4097]

@@Leo-uu8du oh its so nice everyone is right but not the German I am Bavarian and i tell you nobody say Austro-Bavarian not in Germany not in Bavaria and not in Austria

[@Leo-uu8du]

@@herbertkattner4097 Yes, that's true. Austrians say that they speak "Austrian" (like Croats think they speak "Croatian") and Bavarians say they speak "Bavarian" (like Serbs think they speak "Serbian").

[@chrismath149]

I've been speaking this dialect for twenty-six years and now I might just have unlearned it upon noticing how complicated it actually is. No wonder nobody in Germany understands me.

[@johnathanlewis2049]

Wow! That was an awesome and educational video

[@jaimiejust7365]

Would love to see a video on the Oberfranken dialect of northern Franconia in Bavaria. I’ve spent the last 20 years learning and loving its special characteristics (my husband is from the Kulmbach region) and it has a lot of differences from Austro-Bavarian. Fascinating!

[@blogbusty]

I am from this town/region as well. You have to consider that the Frankonian dialect is NOT a variety of Bavarian but belongs to a middle German group of dialects including Thuringia, Hesse and the Rhein Area.

[@barbaral8973]

Hi fellow Franconians! I grew up south of Nuernberg, my family are refugees from Berlin after WW2. Thus, I became somewhat of a "translator". But yes, indeed, it would be interesting to have Franconian analyzed. Even though it is part of Bavaria nowadays, it used to be its own entity with a fascinating history.🌍

[@Artur_M.]

Fun fact: 'servus' actually means servant (or even 'slave') in Latin. It became a greeting through shortening phrases like "your humble servant". It is (or was) used in several European languages, for example, it used to be popular in colloquial Polish, although it's falling out of use.

[@varbalvarbal]

Also in Hungarian. Szervusz/szerbusz was the greeting used by higher class people who used the informal form because of belonging to the same professional caste (civil servant to civil servant, doctor to doctor, etc.). It is still used today. I was taught it was the contraction of the Latin (the official language of the Kingdom of Hungary until 1844!) "servus humillimus sum" - "I am your most humble servant," just as you say.

[@karliikaiser3800]

Fun fact: Ciao is Venezian dialect for Servus...

[@leonazar]

Tjänare in Swedish too

[@empyrionin]

Servus is still being used in Transylvania among Romanians as well.

[@Alias_Anybody]

The perfect translation is "at your service", although it's ultimately about as literal as the American "how are you?".

[@mizapf]

"Heier" is the Bavarian pronunciation of the German word "heuer", which is indeed only used in Bavarian. It is an analogy to "heute", coming from Old High German "hiu tagu" ("this day") → "heute", and "hiu jaru" ("this year") → "heuer".

[@familieblumbergers4052]

I actually do still use "heuer". But only while speaking Allemannisch...

[@TheAidanvr]

Heuriger!

[@camillobernardi925]

Familie Blumbergers also I säg „hüt“ und „hüür“

[@loganroy3381]

And Swiss German "hür"

[@mottmatt7844]

Heuer is also used in the Austrian Standard German.

[@quuxjn2452]

I still think valais-swiss-german is the highest league of german dialects, even as a swiss-german speaker you sometimes don't understand them.

[@aleksanrusyan]

Thanks Paul, excellent summary of the differences between High German and Bavarian. As a language enthusiast I always enjoy and learn from your very well researched videos. As a Spanish and Portuguese speaker (who also has a good understanding of Russian and Ukrainian), I see the differences between Bavarian and High German much alike, prompting the question whether we are really talking about different dialects or even languages (the difference mainly being marked by politics, not linguistics - e.g. Low German, characterized as a German dialect is much closer to Dutch, characterized as a different language, than to High German). As a German from Saxony (Dresden) I understood very little Bavarian until I moved south. Now I don’t always understand everything, but most of it (just like a Spaniard would, when he moves to Portugal). Many of the grammatical differences between High German and Bavarian that you describe (e.g. the substitution of the Genitive by the Dative) also apply to the Swabian/Swiss German speaking continuum. So they are not unique to Bavarian, but mostly South German.

[@roatskm2337]

I'm native Bulgarian speaker who is very interested at learning German now! Ich bin Bulgare und ich will lernen Deutsch! My level is still very low, but I'm practicing and improving more and more! I wish all German speakers from all Germany a nice day! Prost! ;) ️❤️

[@blablak9942]

Dark gamer Shadow Danke ich wünsche dir ein schönes Wochenende und viel Erfolg beim Erlernen der deutschen Sprache. ^__^

[@domsjuk]

Großartig, viel Spaß beim Lernen! :) Ein Tipp für den Anfang, wenn es um Personen und Nationalitäten, Orte etc. geht nutzt man Substantive = "Ich bin Bulgare".

[@theultimatefreak666]

Did you just use prost as bye? Prost is cheers, and I can't speak for everyone, but I don't drink while watching educational content. If you want to know Tschüss is goodbye (tschau being the shortening like bye) and (auf) Wiedersehen is "meet again" some people use it as standard farewell, while some only use it when they actually plan to see the person again (to friend and co-workers)

[@natterbrot]

@@theultimatefreak666 perhaps a false analogy from english cheers also being used to say bye? :D though i kinda like prost as a variant on hau rein.

[@domsjuk]

@@theultimatefreak666 He can answer for himself, but without knowing Bulgarian myself I assume he just literally translated "nazdrave" ("na zdrowie" in Polish etc.) which we might know as a toast as well, but I think has more various meanings in many Slavic languages, too. " Zum Wohl" might be a good equivalent in German.

[@Trashplat]

I love going to Bavaria, because you've left Austria but haven't quite reached Germany yet. ~ Bruno Kreisky, former Chancellor of Austria

[@Rauschgenerator]

Für Nichtbayern ist es immer so witzig, wenn man in Bayern aber so tut als sei man irgendwie besonders, oder als habe Bayern irgendwelchen Sonderstatus unter den Bundesländern. Da wird im Radio offen über die "Staatsgrenze" geredet wenn man die "Grenze" zu Hessen oder so meint, auch die Landesregierung wird "Staatsregierung" genannt und informalle Treffen der Landesregierung mit (wirklichen) Staatschefs werden dann z.B. "Tschechisch-Bayerisches Gipfeltreffen" genannt. Habe ich selbst so auf Bayern 2 gehört. Wenn denen doch nur mal einer erklären könnte, dass "Freistaat" einfach nur ein historischer Begriff ist, der sagt: "Wir haben den Adel davongejagt und sind nun eine Demokratie".

[@MMadesen]

@@Rauschgenerator Naja, Bayern ist ein eigenständiges Land. Es ist eher so, dass die anderen Bundesländer viel zu zurückhaltend sind und sich nicht als eigenes Land sehen. Es sollte jedes Bundesland so stolz, wie Bayern sein. Nicht Bayern so bescheiden, wie die anderen.

[@Rauschgenerator]

@@MMadesen Es ist nur ein Bundesland... niemand stirbt wenn man die Tatsachen sieht. Und "stolz" kann man sein, aber auf eine Verwaltungsebene...?

[@MMadesen]

@@Rauschgenerator Die BRD besteht aus 16 deutschen Ländern. Das sind keine Regionen, wie in Italien, sondern in der Mehrheit wirkliche Länder, mit eigener Kultur und Sprache. Klar sind sich alle ähnlich, aber dennoch Bayern war wie Preußen, Österreich, Sachsen usw lange Zeit mehr oder weniger ein eigenständiger Staat, sogar mit eigener Armee und Grenzpolitik. Andere deutsche Länder tun sich schwer, auf ihr Bundesland stolz zu sein, weil es unhistorische Grenzen hat. Bayern existierte lange vor der BRD bereits in dieser Form. Aber NRW zum Beispiel sind zwei Bundesländer in einem, Nordrheinland und Westfalen. Das ist wie in Belgien. Du wirst kaum einen stolzen Belgier finden, denn die Leute dort sind entweder Flamen oder Franzosen, aber keine Belgier. Du kannst nicht Salz und Pfeffer zusammenmischen und dann zum Salz sagen, du bist jetzt Pfeffalz.

[@d4n4nable]

@@Rauschgenerator Is doch nicht der Bayern Schuld, dass die Preißn alle anderen regionalen Kulturen ausradiert haben!

[@roasty247]

I'm currently learning standard German while living in Vienna...this explains a loooot! Thanks :)

[@Fabii2000]

remember big cities speak High german and no dialect

[@ekesandras1481]

@@Fabii2000 the real old Viennese city dialect, which is prominent in hundreds of movies, TV-series, Wiener Lieder, literature, etc. is clearly Bavarian - even a very prestigious form of Bavarian. Kings and Emperors and Nobel prize winners spoke it. A lot of people in Vienna though don't speak it anymore.

[@Fabii2000]

@@ekesandras1481 yea when I was in Vienna I didn’t hear any dialect. Only an auuustrian aaaaccent :)

[@mori.kurogawa7936]

OMG you could never imagine how funny it can be to watch such a serious and accurate analysis of BAVARIAN. Us in Germany, we probably all love it but do not take it seriously. It is often kinda made fun of and enjoyed at the same time. Bavarians are quite proud of it, as far as I know them. I learned it with a crime story podcast series povided by German state media. I'm honestly sad that there isn't a bigger part of "real Bavarian" in the media - because even what people often take for it, is really more standard German with Bavarian "accent". When it comes to "real Bavarian" - the German words get so much slaughtered that I get why it is considered it's own language - it gets hard to understand even for native Germans then. I've seen Bavarians give interviews with German subtitles added :D and I still have to listen with focus to dig everything. Always imagine an ambitious student, having worked his ** off to learn propper German, and then arriving in Munich... XD Can't stop laughing...

[@highdelbeere]

By the way: The word "heier" is used as "heuer" in written German in Austria.

[@theraven8459]

This video made me realize that the dictionaries in Germany probably don't have the word "heuer". I'm an Austrian and I don't really speak a dialect, though I still sound very Austrian even when speaking standard German. But I thought I sounded like everyone in Germany until I actually went there. And that's how I decided to learn more about these interesting differences.

[@justink5000]

I am from Bavaria and I always assumed "heuer" was the SG version of heier. But I guess not … There are just so many words that I would confidently use with non-Bavarians until I see they don't get what I'm saying hahaha

[@TheRavenir]

@@theraven8459 I'm Swiss and I'm not familiar with that word. It seems to be restricted to Austria and Bavaria.

[@stefanreichenberger5091]

The word "heuer" is also in the Standard German dictionary (Duden), albeit marked as Southern German / Austrian / Swiss. I think it's perfectly correct to use it in writing.

[@highdelbeere]

The word "heuer" you can find in the Duden www.duden.de/rechtschreibung/heuer. The next link is from the "Atlas zur deutschen Alltagssprache" where you can see in which regions it's used www.atlas-alltagssprache.de/r8-f4d-2/.

[@amadeusmza]

We missed you Paul. 💖

[@Langfocus]

I never left! 🙂

[@amadeusmza]

Yes, but I ever wait for you next video. Best regards. 😌

[@mccardrixx5289]

@@Langfocus Servus!

[@fabiankohring1440]

Thank you very much for the Video it’s nice when Dialects are treated in a respectful and linguistic way. Please do some other variations as Plattdütsch or Lëtzeburgisch. Thank you 🙏

[@mr.strawberry13]

I never realised how many of the german words commonly used in informal czech are actually just found in bavarian. Afterall, we were under austrian rule for a long time, and in the southern Sudetenland where i live, bavarian used to be the main language.

[@ekesandras1481]

Czech conservates a lot of old Austrian dialect words, that don't exist in Standard German, or only in a different form. My favorite one is: hajzl

[@mr.strawberry13]

@@ekesandras1481 i love calling people toilets. I will probably start to use that word more.

[@xxmountaindewxx7893]

German: Könntest du mir zum Geburtstag mit der Gitarre was vorspielen? Austrian: Kunast ma zan Geburtstog a bissl af da zumpfgeign amanoundfudln?

[@alexanderpraehauser5115]

Mega Oida! I glaub I hob mi grod o'gsoacht😂

[@Facemanfitzpatrik]

in my area the same would be "Kuntast ma zam Burtzltog wos mit da Klaumpfn heaspüün?"

[@timg.5400]

This »ma zan« is in Slovenian »mi za«…

[@oJoJ777]

@@Facemanfitzpatrik Würde man in meiner Gegend fast genau so sagen. nur das "üü" anstatt dem "ui" verrat, dass du auf der anderen Seite der Salzach bist ^^

[@ExtremeDeathman]

Kahnst ma zum Burzldoch a weng aaf da Zupfadn firrspülln?

[@susannebeier6997]

Servus, Great video Paul. As an Bavarian girl I can answer your questions. Luckily I am in a position right now where I can speak Bavarian all the time- with my family and at work. But during my schooltime I almost lost my dialect, because our teachers came from all over Germany and so we couldn't speak dialect at school because they wouldn't have had understood us (sorry if my grammar is wrong). Strangely during my time at the university I started to speak more Bavarian. Maybe because we spoke English with the professors and at the mensa nobody cared how we spoke. But still when I meet somebody from northern Germany I swap into standard German but when I meet an Austrian I keep speaking Bavarian. By the way: I love Austrian accent it's so "leiwand". Pfiats eich ;-)

[@Rakso-bq1lb]

Servus! I’m a native Swedish speaker but I also speak German (High German) quite well because I studied it in school for six years. I would say that I understand Bavarian just as good as I understand standard German. Certainly, the pronunciation, words, sentences, etc. can be very different but I’m mostly able to put these details into a context along with the words that are similar in standard German and create myself a good understanding nevertheless. My German friends sometimes call me a language genius because I seemingly understand Bavarian better than they do despite the fact that I’ve never even visited Bavaria, but I don’t know if that is true ;)

[@kahnfatman]

Actually even in standard German (Hochdeutsch), people would use the English present perfect to express the English simple past in daily speech. However, for the same purpose German simple past is used in 2 scenarios: - Written/official stories - Special non-modal verbs or modals: 1. sein -> war, haben -> hatte, kommen -> kam, denken -> dachte... 2. wollen -> wollte, können -> konnte, müssen -> müsste...

[@elonmush4793]

I think that's also very common in some English speaking countries. "I was thinking" instead of "I thought" in spoken English.

[@nirutivan9811]

Is speak a Swiss Dialect (from Zurich). I understand bavarian most of the time quite well. And I just realized how similar the grammar of my alemannic dialect is to the bavarian grammar. We also only use the perfect tense to talk about the past and we also use a dative instead of the genitive.

[@richard--s]

yes and it is the same as in Bavaria - and Austria: The standard German forms sound so.... so uncomfortable, unrelaxed. That is also why most of the (German) Swiss TV ads are either produced in Swiss German or are the standard German ads with Swiss German voices. That makes them much more familiar, I guess, not so unrelated, "from over there".

[@RayyMusik]

The use of the perfect tense is common in every spoken German variety. The past tense is nearly exclusively used in written German. The same is valid for preposition + dative instead of the genitive. As a Westphalian I would *say*: „Gestern habe ich den Hund von meinen Nachbarn gesehen“ (yesterday I have the dog of my neighbors seen), not: „Gestern sah ich den Hund meiner Nachbarn“. This is what I would *write* in a formal context only, not even in an email.

[@nirutivan9811]

Rayy‘s Musikladen Yes, I know the past tense and genitive is used less in standard German as well. But the difference is, that it isn’t even possible to form the past or a genitive in my dialect.. „Gestern habe ich den Hund von meinen Nachbarn gesehen“ would be „Gester hanni de Hund vo mine Nachbare gseh“ in Swiss German. There is know way to exactly translate „Gestern sah ich den Hund meiner Nachbarn“ into my dialect. My dialect has only two cases and two tenses (Akkusativ, Genitive, Past, Past Perfect and the future tenses don’t exist).

[@eugenekrabs945]

-Bavarian is surely an interesting dialect, gei? -No, i'm straight

[@tjmieczynskyj3393]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sehabel]

Many Bavarian dialects pronounce the "gei" without an "i" at the end.

[@zoria2718]

@@sehabel Like "geh!"? ("The weather is good today, go away!")

[@drecksackblase2011]

@@sehabel ja ge

[@alexsupertramp4907]

@@zoria2718 no, more like "gä" like in the first "e" in "everything"

[@tatoaravena]

Sos un genio man! Congrats & Danke