Long GOP VS All-I (Can YOU Tell The Difference?)

[@JoshCameron]

Could you guys tell the difference between Long GOP and All-Intra?

[@adolphemusanga3319]

I personally wasn’t!!! It could be the KZbin compression too!!!

[@jayforcinema]

Yeah.. some of the places with high movement seemed a bit mushier in Long GOP. With my GH5 it was definitely noticeable so I would use All-I for fiction projects and Long GOP for documentary work. Difference is minimal, though, so you can definitely get by using Long GOP for most regular work

[@andersistbesser]

Long gop is heavily compressed all i is much more easy on your computer also

[@007silverwings]

I wish I could spot the difference 😂I guess the KZbin compression doesn't help, either that or my eyes aren't as good as I thought

[@Ulrich.Bierwisch]

My understanding is, that this is about the original footage coming from the camera. When it's processed, it is Long GOP anyway. Re-watching it from KZbin is even more destroying any differences. I also think that a lot of movement typically is blurred by 180° shutter angle. So there isn't much to see where All-Intra shines other than in the advantage while processing the footage. My expectation is that: if you have a detailed background that is in focus and you have an object in front that is out of focus that moves out of the frame, All Intra might show visible artifacts for a few frames in the areas where the background comes into sight. (A train leaving the station, revealing the scene with people behind the train). It might be interesting to see if this is clearly visible in the original footage and if the difference survives the KZbin-compression. All-Intra might be a huge advantage if you use very short exposure in action sequences like sports and you want both - video and extract frames as stills.

[@zhongjiezheng4646]

been wanting to see all-i vs long gop comparison on the s5m2x for a while and my man came through with the perfect video

[@JoshCameron]

Keepin it real since 2020

[@kevinforget549]

I think you'll still be waiting as KZbin compresses the video so you cant see a difference.

[@zhongjiezheng4646]

@@kevinforget549 so you do see a difference on monitors then? How big of a difference would you say it is?

[@like-san]

literally satisfied my demands.

[@kevinforget549]

@@zhongjiezheng4646 you should as it isnt compressed as much. Ive never actually used all-I before and my s52x is still on backorder but ill definitely be testing it out, especially the 6k raw from the Atomos recorder which is the same as 4:4:4:4 vs the 6k 4:2:0 from the internal.

[@alihammad6318]

Excellent video! I'm planning on doing a deep-dive codec analysis video when my S5iiX comes in, comparing BRAW, ProRes RAW, internal and USB SSD codecs. Plus quantifying noise levels.

[@DennisSchmitz]

Where you can see an actual difference is with external BRAW. Fixes gamut clipping, green shadows and banding issues and almost one extra stop on top with highlight recovery enabled.

[@KallusGarnet]

Thanks for the info

[@MikeSimpson1]

Thanks for answering this since the creator of the video didn't really show images for comparison purposes

[@alina9757-v2x]

Thanks for the input. Do you think for a wedding is worth the effort to shot in Braw compared with long gop or external prores on a ninja V?

[@DrWNoLs]

This was great. I'd love to see a video comparing 4:2:0 10 bit vs 4:2:2 and raw (4:4:4 theoretically) in specific color resolution tests to see if there is any situation where you can actually see a difference. I suspect that the only real difference that's detectable is 8 bit vs 10 bit vs 12 bit. And chroma subsampling never is noticable, even after editing, since delivery on KZbin is 4:2:0.

[@JoshCameron]

I'd love to make that video for you! It's always frustrating when I make videos comparing codecs etc for KZbin because it looks great on my 4K monitor, and then once it hits KZbin all of those subtleties disappear !

[@thrillsandmagic]

I've had a unique case use in shooting roller coasters to be slowed down in post. All-I is superior but fps becomes the limiter at around 50mph/80kph. Beyond that speed, motion clarity starts to break down and I've had to use S&Q at 120 or 150fps (10bit/All-I/422/30fps).

[@Circharles]

All-i is sharper and cleaner read out. Colors look better to my eye as well. S5 iix for me.

[@JoshCameron]

Nice one dude - the S5IIX is a great camera, in fact it's the best camera I've ever used :)

[@Samhertzog]

I spoke with Panasonic's codec developer a couple years ago, he was 100% confident that there is no difference in the quality of shots, it's merely a matter of saving space vs ease of editing. Unless it's uploaded on tv, then Long gop has more issues

[@MarcelloMOV]

Source: Trust me bro

[@driftwoodtv]

The best test Josh is trees and forests. Lots n lots of detail. Or use a death chart to check the PQN between codecs.

[@formatthitech]

Great video Josh! Really brilliant & clear explanations.

[@IainAnderson]

Thanks for doing this test. KZbin output is always heavily compressed, so anyone making content just for that can use LongGOP; it looks great almost all of the time. Of course, if your computer can't handle it, try All-I, but with 4K and larger All-I takes up a lot more space and requires higher-bandwidth storage for multicam too. One note is that the comparisons on the slower Mac were flawed. By letting the timeline render, Final Cut Pro is creating a ProRes version of your timeline, and it's no longer decoding All-I on the fly. That older Mac was struggling with ProRes. All-I does have its uses, on particular machines under particular circumstances, but if you do need it, I'd definitely shoot straight to ProRes as it's All-I with much better acceleration, in hardware on all current Macs. Regular HEVC All-I might perform better on specific PC/NLE combos but not on a Mac.

[@coin777]

2:15 Do You see a difference before youtube compression? and how big is it?

[@PavSZ]

visually there is zero difference to the naked eye, especially on KZbin. Great video Josh!

[@cmxpiipl]

That totally depends on what you view this with. On a 85 inch 4k tv there most certainly is a difference, the long gop looks mushier at times.

[@PavSZ]

@@cmxpiipl absolutely! from the original files but not from KZbin. That's not only long-GOP but also heavily compressed. Also how many people have 85" 4k TV?

[@cmxpiipl]

@@PavSZ I meant I can see the difference from the youtube video. But you are right that an 85 inch screen ain't the norm but a proper stress test

[@marsastronaut3736]

Hi Josh ...Thank you for producing great videos on the Panasonic Lumix S5-iiX ... CODEC's and cage build for starters... .....it's a fantastic camera, which I am using on a feature, that I'm DOP on .... keep it up 👍👍👍

[@JoshCameron]

Thank you very much! Hope you manage to make the most of this incredible camera :)

[@MicroFourNerds]

You so clever. That was really well explained thanks Josh!

[@MartinAaberge]

That USB-C cable all crooked on the side there almost killed me :) good video. I didn’t know that was how GOP behaved :)

[@KevinvanDiest]

hahah same here ...that was the first thing that caught my eye

[@JoshCameron]

Hahaha since this video i've got a new cable that works a bit better :)

[@KevinvanDiest]

@@JoshCameron okay, great ..now I can sleep again😛

[@zeneyes]

You have some of the best tech reviews out there but I would enjoy seeing a short film or vlog from you using the S5ii and Lumix primes. You make epic work. Cheers.

[@JoshCameron]

Appreciate this so much , thanks man! Will defo make something of that sort in the near future :)

[@adolphemusanga3319]

Hey Josh! Great video as always. Would you please make a video of the s5iix with blackmagic raw ? Thanks

[@JoshCameron]

It's on my to do list! Thanks dude :)

[@adolphemusanga3319]

@@JoshCameron you’re the best!!

[@patrickmoutal878]

Thanks Josh. Excellent, like usual

[@JoshCameron]

Thanks Patrick, I appreciate it!

[@sacmoto]

Super helpful! Thank you!

[@alfiolora3446]

Thanks Josh, great video. question, which one would cause the camera to overheat easier?

[@joeensley3912]

Thanks for the vid! It is an interesting debate on price do you spend more money on the better laptop and save all the $$ you would spend on SSD’s? I’ve had no problem at all with Long GOP on the M1 Pro it handles it so easily and my clients have been happy to save the hard drive space bc they back everything up on the cloud and THAT gets even more expensive than hard drives.

[@BlindeEzel]

There is no way to change the GOP parameters in these cameras, but is there at least some information about how good the video encoder is in detecting scene changes. Recording only differences when the entire image changes will not be efficient, so the video encoder normally inserts a new I-frame when this is the case, it would be interesting to know how the Panasonic video-encoder is programmed in that regard, and how long the GOP-sequences are by default.

[@reviewerorg8040]

After watching your video I switched all the format to LONG-GOP, The minor differences in quality (if they even exist) is not enough to compensate the 3X file size differences.

[@lewisadamsproductions]

Making me wanna buy the lumix s5 sharpie edition 🔥

[@b.r.c.v]

Second 🎉 Love your videos about Lumix cameras always very informative and helpful content 👍🏻 Please make a video about ‚the perfect settings for video‘ for the s5iix Keep up the good work Greeting from Germany

[@JoshCameron]

Thanks for the kind words, really appreciate it! I'll put that video idea on the content list. Thanks and all the best!

[@MrAntpre]

Hi, tks for the video. Can you make a video testing the steaming (wired and wireless) capability of the sii X. The streaming capacities are the only one that would make me choose the x over the s5ii. I better be sure there working OK because so far the reviews are so so on this point. Tks

[@darealphantom]

Great video as someone that just moved to Panasonic and got the S5ii and have no choice but to use long gop & have a MacBook M1 Pro chip also so this video was perfect not sure if I will upgrade to the S5iix I have to use my S5ii for a few months first since I’ve used the canon eos r & used ALL-I mostly this is good information to know thanks for making this comparison video

[@jayclas4023]

All-I definitely looks better but is it worth it for people on tight budgets when i comes to storage?

[@DiscoverSRQ]

Amazing. Thank you!

[@CO8848_2]

Not sure I understand what the conclusion is? Of course it's a tradeoff between quality and size/processing time. But, can you tell the difference or not?

[@Zyrk01]

Sorry new to this system. But how do you choose between h264 or h265 on the s5iix menu?

[@HGQjazz]

I compared them at 24fps on my S1H and didn't notice any difference. Im sure theres a difference but i didn't notice them in my samples.

[@mantenbrink]

I would've liked if you explained and pointed out a little more of these artifacts. I was barely able to see them and confused if I was focussing on the right thing especially considering youtube compression. Maybe zoom in and show where the differences are? Also the conclusion about editing on an older machine that you might need upgrading is missing a part where you'd consider a proxy workflow. I'm not sure if FCPX even has that option but for most people proxies would be the more economic option

[@hhankx]

All intra looks so much better!! I’ve been waiting for this!! Great work man, thx a ton

[@snapshot_ie9730]

Hi Josh for 6k or 4k all-I video would the SABRENT SD card 256GB V60, SDXC card UHS-II, memory card SDHC, Class 10, U3, Full HD & 8K UHD card, 270MB/s Be ok

[@gurugamer8632]

On my GH6, when I turn on the display - WFM/Vector scope it disables the Histrogram why?

[@pedrinhosari]

Pleasse make a version comparing this with proress

[@JoshCameron]

It's coming!

[@toofy7253]

And slow motion zoomed in at 400 percent on a detailed fast moving image

[@hhankx]

I have a little hope they will bring all-I to the s5ii version. If not I’ll have to figure out how to sell the s5ii for a decent price and get the x. Everyone says they won’t, but I don’t see why they wouldn’t

[@marionxah]

There is an update for 200$ for the s5ii and i think it includes all intra

[@hhankx]

@@marionxah that’s would be sick if it was internal! I think it’s for raw to external :(. Correct me if I’m wrong

[@marionxah]

@@hhankx idk haha but i am thinking of selling my S1 and get a S5iiX

[@nickyesteban1010]

Can you use All-Intra with a v90 card? or do you need an ssd for that? Thanks! Btw great video!

[@AurelianIrimia]

I have tested large videos in 4K All Intra 400mbps with V60 from Sandisk and never had any problems.

[@daniellrodriguezs]

For some reason I'm seeing some artefacts on all S5II and S5IIX videos including my own S5IIX when recording internally. I come from a Canon C70 and I did not have this issue or even in sony cameras. However, for what I see it does not happens in all videos recorded in BRAW. Does anyone have tested this?

[@joeensley3912]

Would also LOVE to see a video on RAW vs Long GOP V-Log!

[@DennisSchmitz]

RAW is way superior. Trying out BRAW at the moment and it almost looks like a completely new camera.

[@joeensley3912]

@@DennisSchmitz Always superior RAW but just wanted to know how drastic of a difference. What do you like about BRAW more than VLOG RAW?

[@DennisSchmitz]

@@joeensley3912 quite drastic tbh. No green tint in darker areas No banding in shadows No abrupt shadow crushing No gamut clipping with super saturated reds and purples Better texture and detail No temporal NR slow motion looking noise patterns

[@DrWNoLs]

@@DennisSchmitz Better color science too (I know people love to dismiss the importance of a good starting point). Ive noticed since my S5, that the Prores raw isnt as good as BRAW, because prores raw keeps the same color science while BRAW adds their usual flare to it. The skin tones and cyan blues ive grown to absolutely love.

[@DrHansBrewery]

I would be more interested in seeing the difference when keying green screen for example.

[@gurugamer8632]

I shoot weddings on my Pansonic GH6 should I use Long GOP or All-I

[@Xzvsc]

Hi how much memory size is for 5min video of all intra 24fps 4k 10bit 4:2:2?

[@Alexrocks1253]

Honestly I’d just use BRaw since I’d be using an SSD anyway. I do wish I got the S5IIX though but couldn’t wait for months since my original S5 would depreciate and not get me enough money for the higher end one.

[@VideoProAcademy]

Really helpful, thanks! How about 6k Long GOP footage though on that m1 machine? Would love to get my hands on some sample footage to download and test myself.

[@JoshCameron]

Works beautifully mate, you have nothing to worry about there. The M1 machines handle every codec from these cameras very smoothly :)

[@tellsulli1148]

how do i convert long gop codec to display my video in davinci not only showing an audio cause when i record on hlg on lumix gh5 it dont show in davici

[@aiseurnae5976]

I use All-I everytimes on my GH5, GH6 but I don't mind using Long GOP on my S1 and S5II, the differences are most of the time neglibile. However the detail rendering is much more important for me (no noise reduction nor oversharpening). In this area, the S5II is a big disappointement with the standard profiles (rec 709).

[@filipmichalsaffray441]

Thanks for your Video, Yeah it is more a question if you need S5iiX or S5ii is enough...nice choice of music by the way Yours Fil big fan of your channel😊

[@JoshCameron]

Thanks! Hahaha yeah I love the 80's kinda synth vibes!

[@AnthonyRodriguezz]

Thanks for making this!

[@JoshCameron]

My pleasure :)

[@KHANGFU]

Any difference in low-light? Might be worth it if it's less noisy.

[@JoshCameron]

Same noise performance I'd say !

[@rabahfdoul4844]

You are showing the nitrate with MB instead of Mb or mb. There is a huge difference between those mate. Cheers.

[@dragonslayer8027]

What about prores raw?

[@swashyhimself]

How old was the old mac?

[@TechMixr]

The only issue I have with this video is that on the older machine rendering was completed where on the M1 machine it wasn’t. I don’t think long GOP would have scrubbed that easily on the Intel machine had it not finished rendering.

[@thatsreallyamoon]

long gop is the way to go. The file size trade off for the performance loss (I mean is there really any loss), is more than worth it. In my opinion, if you’re shooting all intra for “performance” reasons, you’re mis-spending your money. I mean who the heck has a camera that can do crispy 4K 60 10 bit in all intra but their computer can’t play it for editing, AND it has tons of extra storage to manage those more than double sized files? All intra is only for professionals who are explicitly asked to deliver all intra contractually.

[@JoshCameron]

Yeah I get what you're saying and agree with you. All Intra is great and I do use it quite a bit on my client shoots now, but Long GOP is incredible as well, and the smaller file sizes make it easier to manage :)

[@randomstuffman01]

Good video. Thanks. toronto canada.

[@director-estudiomw8233]

What's the point of having 4k 60fps in crop 😢?

[@andersistbesser]

Whats the problem? Just use a wider lense if you dont like it.

[@obarovft314]

does this camera shoot in 24fps?

[@JoshCameron]

If you switch to the correct region for it :)

[@smartyarts]

Hi Josh, the speed units are incorrect, they should be in Mb(it)/s and not MB(yte)/s (kzbin.info/www/bejne/jJaQamyIgdKVj5I) - I have the exact older Macbook Pro like your are comparing to in this video and if you go to an intermediate workflow or with proxies, the old Macbook just works fine. Nevertheless I still haven't found out how to tell if a h.264/h.265 encoded MP4 file is intra or interframe encoded, do you maybe know? Mediainfo will not show any indication...

[@PSORIK]

Нужно было также приложить пример минимального битрейта для 4к разрешения, которого для большинства случаев более чем достаточно

[@JWS1968]

I think it's diminishing returns at this stage. I think a few years ago ALL-i was a big deal but now computers are better at handling the Long Gop. You don't even need to top spec, just half decent will do. But this all depends on how intensive your editing is. Are you a professional editor doing very intensive work with many layers and effects or do you do the odd video for fun. I think if you're a pro get a pro machine to edit on AND get the ALL-i to make your work flow as fluid as possible. If not update your machine as it will probably be doing more than just video editing and more power is never a bad thing.

[@AurelianIrimia]

Sorry but I don’t see any difference, here on KZbin. Basically no difference in image quality, no difference in editing. So, I will keep using Long GOP. Great comparison! 👍🏻

[@JoshCameron]

Thank you very much! Glad this was useful :)

[@MaxoticsTV]

Great stuff!!! Great explanation with PRACTICAL implications! However, at 3:29 you hypothesize a reason for slower editing, between GOP and Intra-I, based on file size... Why? If you follow your OWN logic about how each compression approach works it's obvious that in Long GOP the computer has to go backward and forward to assemble each frame. That's what slows the computer down. In a sense, for each frame of image it works on it need to manipulate the data of 30 images, say. If you scrub ahead one image, it may have to go back 30 frames to construct it. In Intra-I, as you point out, each frame is compressed on its own. There's no need to go back and forth through other frames. Also, and I speculate here, JPG compression is built into the hardware, in a sense, of most computers these days--and they optimize the __ out of it. And I believe Intra-I is basically that. So your speed benefits from that too. Again, great video!

[@thebentzenable]

I have seen bigger differences between a good and a bad narrative

[@Aviciiz]

I was gonna say the example footage looks so much better than your usual work, those phantom luts are actually pretty good then

[@angeloros7538]

The skin tones are more natural in All-i than the long-gop shot.

[@A1Bokeh]

looks like all i is a tiny bit cleanerin terms of image

[@JoshCameron]

In some cases definitely :)

[@nickalot]

real world difference is the storage you need to pay for shooting flowers and grass in he mothers backyard. hahaha. anyway, i think green screen footage would benefit a lot from all-i.

[@Hotrodcameras]

GOP = Group of Pictures (not photos)

[@JoshCameron]

Same difference :)

[@kennethgooswit3697]

It must be possible to record blackmagic Raw to SSD, the problem is the patents of the stupid Red company. If they were my neighbour i would know how to thank them, perhaps by sending them a rusian cocktail.

[@owlmostdead9492]

Don’t forget to make it extra spicy

[@jessecumberledge4530]

Looks like Nikon vs Red is going to help with this. I would love BRAW internal, just the best codec I have used easily.

[@Filmsimulation]

@@jessecumberledge4530 lets make panasonic sue red! lets ask NIKON for the sauce of their victory! FOR RAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

[@kalumander]

I must disappoint you, my friend. PCs have always been faster than the Macs. I'm fairly certain my 60-pound PC does the job faster than your cute laptop ;) Ps. My PC plays perfectly smooth 4k videos in real-time as well as it converts them to H264 in around 10-15 sec per 1 min of 4k footage, so we PC users are good :D

[@ValerioCata]

I must disappoint you, nobody cares 😅

[@kalumander]

You certainly do care enough to reply to my post, or was it just a small ego trip? I thought so 💓 @@ValerioCata

[@DroneStories]

Sorry but pc users are probably more than mac users. In my country an m1 Mac pro laptop (2021) costs around 3,500 euros today. With 4000 euros you can have a pc, with i9 13900k + rtx 4090 + 64gb. What I want to say is that only from a price of 3,500 and above, you can say that you can use log gop files !!! But with all-intra or proress, YOU CAN ALSO WITH AN OLD pc (5 years old). Bottom line if you want panasonic the s5iix IS ONE WAY.

[@stephanschmitty]

Sorry dude but why you speak at Doppel time? Information should be understood from the brain. I really wish I could keep looking because you're a likeable guy. but sorry i'm out

[@JoshCameron]

Hey dude, I’ve had a lot of people in the past say that I talk quite quickly in my videos and it’s something I’m actively trying to get better with; but I actually speak at this speed in my every day life too 🤣😂 so I think it’s something I have to train within myself unfortunately. I appreciate you leaving this comment and I apologise for the speed of my speech, but please know that I’m working on it 👍🏼

[@spacesoundmusic]

Is this limited to a certain type of SD cards? Or you can only shoot ALLI directly to an SSD? I’m interested in shooting something to compare this options. Btw, lumix is the best camera 🤌🏻

[@HaterGonnaHate]

That means no difference cause both quality have lowest bitrate from exporting default fcpx setting. Higher bitrate = higher resolution quality Of course nobody know this, use custom output settings from comressor