Makita VS. Festool - Comprehensive Comparison & Review - Toolsday Track Saw Review

[@katzmosestools]

*Support What We Do at The Katz-Moses Store* lddy.no/stih *K-M Dovetail Jigs are on sale. USE CODE INLAY10 for an extra 10% off in my store* *Cheapest Place I’ve found the Makita* (no affiliation) www.toolnut.com/ It also looks like they’re running some good promos on Makita. *Festool requires their vendors to have the same prices and doesn’t allow discounts but you can also find them at the link above for the Makita*

[@yishaicampbell308]

Could you do a video comparing these to the kreg track saw? at least the makita one to kreg?

[@CarlosFernandez-lr3uc]

Jonathan Great speech!! Love your stop Block! Best addition to my table saw. Also o recently purchased the dovetails jig for my son to help him cut dovetails. Thanks again. Carlos

[@brandonwinter1456]

Hey Sir I love your content. You should check out Torch Paste on Instagram @torchpaste You can use it in conjunction with a heat gun and stencil to burn a pattern on any wooden project. I think it would make a great video. Keep up the great work

[@handymadness]

I did! Bought a stop!

[@RedcarWW]

Johnathan the link to Toolnut is broken. Could you provide an updated link in order to help support your work?

[@whiskeywoodworx2854]

In a world with no integrity, there is Katz. I applaud you for not selling out. We need a place we can go for honest reviews we can trust. It’s the only reason I watch your content. You are not afraid to admit your mistakes and I learn so much for your experience. Just like when you injured your finger on the jointer. Please please please DO NOT EVER SELL OUT!

[@steppedon]

It's hilarious that ONLY the reviews that don't have Festool coming out on top are the "honest" reviews. Maybe you can create a playlist of those reviews so you don't have to go out hunting for them too much.

[@garrydye2394]

I didn't even know there was a single woodworking channel that was not a sell out to paid advertising. 99.9% of content (think Bents Woodworking) who have not sold their sole for the mighty dollar.

[@reverandbigshow8171]

The first Tracksaw I ever used was a workmates Festool, I was sold on it but couldn't afford it at the time but Makita came out with their affordable version shortly afterwards, So I purchased it. I have never been let down by my Makita and have always been able to produce work at the same quality that Festool saws deliver without any feeling of being held back by some small inconvenience in the way the mechanisms work. In fact, My Makita has always powered through cuts that I've seen Festools stall and ruin a cut due to its inability to push on. Value for money? Makita by a long Margin!

[@TheGlobalMind]

I have the corded Makita, bought it about 2 years ago and love it. For the money, I find it to be an awesome addition to the shop and for my small space, it's been incredibly valuable. I certainly looked at the Festool but couldn't justify the extra cost. So far I haven't regretted my decision. I've recently added a hose for dust collection, which without any modification otherwise sucks up nearly everything. The bag was ok, the hose is even better.

[@bret9741]

When I bought the Makita at ACME tools, it was $499 with 4 batteries, 2 55” one 36” track and of course the cases. The Festool at the time was $1200 similarly equipped.

[@Surmoka]

And the Makita is actually better than the Festering Stool. See: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZbdoWCVeciInck

[@CrimpKeeper]

Possibly the most honest, and true display of integrity I’ve ever encountered in a KZbin video. Subscribed.

[@NitFlickwick]

One feature you missed (among the many you taught me) on the Makita is the scoring setting. There is a little knob you can push in that limits the cut to just a millimeter or two for scoring, and, with that cut done first, you can get absolutely perfect cuts. On particularly brittle material, you could use that and pull the saws backwards to climb cut, similar to a scoring blade on an industrial table saw. An advantage to not having a riving knife? I’d still rather have one.

[@espressomatic]

Festool has eliminated the knife on their new saws. I've used the same Makita for about 3 years. It doesn't have a riving knife and I've never had one instance of kick back - you can also use its anti-tip lock which will prevent the saw from coming up off the track. On the other hand, I used a Kreg saw yesterday for the first time and TWICE I forgot to set its anti-kickback knob and both times it kicked back and nearly screwed up the cut - it damaged the track both times. If you watch this video how Moses plunges the Makita on the first cut - this is impossible on the Kreg without kickback on everything except maybe particle board. Needless to say, I'm sending that POS saw and track back to Kreg ASAP.

[@Ashton351]

@@espressomatic Why do you think you got the kickback on the Kreg? Was the wood binding up on the back of the blade?

[@SpyridakisSpearfishing]

Extremely in-depth and honest review. The festool's bluetooth is for connecting it to a vac with bluetooth technology. Meaning that when it turns on the vac will kick on as well

[@hallowed45]

i decided to buy a track saw little over a year ago. i read plenty of reviews and watched plenty of videos.i bought a corded Makita and love it. dust collection is awesome put some blue tape over side hole and hook up a hose and it get rids of almost all the dust. i didnt need a cordless saw and i really saw no reason in spending alot more money on a saw thats almost the same.

[@Ham68229]

I went the Kreg track saw, love it, it does everything I need it to. Cheers :)

[@kizzjd9578]

You can buy 3d printed dust covers for them

[@bertaboy]

The window is super helpful when not using the track, like using the plunge saw with a speed square because the track is too long to use when lopping off a 2x4

[@zacharyyoung1083]

I do the same. Don’t see the point of a cordless track saw for my purposes. I use my track saw regularly and exclusively to break down sheets in my shop and it’s always tethered to the vacuum anyway, just zip tie the cord to the hose and save yourself a couple hundred bucks 🤷🏻‍♂️. Festool stuff is great, extremely well engineered and designed. Take advantage of the Makita clone that is 90% as good and costs 40% less.

[@littlejackalo5326]

@@Ham68229 really? I just got through writing a long reply to another comment, about how bad the Kreg track saw sucks. It's possibly the worst took I've ever used. The "shoe" attaches to the base plate of your saw with metal clamps that are screwed into the PLASTIC shoe. So you can never get the plastic Kreg shoe to tighten to the baseplate of your saw, because the plastic just deforms. There is so much slop in that system that it defeats the purpose of it. It's just a poorly designed, engineered, and manufactured tool.

[@TheBstadz]

Hey man love your stuff but there was one thing that was not accurate about this. You were comparing the cut quality of the off cut, not the keep piece, and if you are worried about a nice clean cut on the offcut, then that little green piece that you weren't sure what it was for, is for exactly that. It's a zero clearance for the offcut side. Just my 2 cents. Overall great stuff :)

[@adamkrtek9004]

I’m coming late to the video but I’m glad to see someone pointed this out. I felt like this was a comparison video of a tool that Jonathan has been regularly using and one where he hasn’t taken the time to understand all the benefits. I own the Festool track saw and I love it and it’s ability to replace my table saw doe 80% oft workflow. I also love my makita cordless tools

[@kirkhamlett]

That's a fair point if it is simply an offcut, but if you're cutting multiple pieces you'd want both sides of the cut to be pretty clean.

[@TheBstadz]

@@kirkhamlett yes and that’s why I mentioned the little green foot that’s for exactly that purpose.

[@PierreJennihey-taxi]

Why do the Festool need this extra piece to be precise ? Just wondering...

[@TheBstadz]

@@PierreJennihey-taxi it’s not about precision it’s a zero clearance piece so there’s no tear out.

[@capti443]

I applaud your professional integrity for refusing sponsorship and maintaining your independence. Bravo! That is why I have and enjoy a set of your dovetail guides and apron (so far)! ... Plus, they really are great products.

[@vlmiele]

You don’t have to install a new splinter guard on the Festool when cutting a 45 degree bevel. It’s engineered to line up perfectly with the existing 90deg cut.

[@bourkey07]

This comment is 100% spot on.

[@forestrall3454]

Same goes for the Makita as well.

[@pau1phi11ips]

@@forestrall3454 Yeah, was thinking that. "I'm sure I've made bevelled cuts and not replaced the guide!?". Thanks for the sanity check.

[@mitchOrr1]

@@forestrall3454 I've found that the Makita does end up cutting more off the splinter guards when cutting bevels. Really frustrating.

[@chrishopper7588]

but the back bevel on the splinter guard would create a cavity for blow out to occur. at least that's what I think he was saying

[@JustTony72]

Jonathan great video as always. Few things to add, because I'm a festool nut. The Bluetooth is to connect to festool Vac, wireless Auto start stop. Makita also have a similar system but both systems only work with their own brand vac. The tracks aren't 100% interchangeable. The Makita T slot is a fraction smaller which means a festool saw dialled in for a festool rail will have slop on the Makita rail. Peter Millard did a really long comparison for this and I've also tested it on mine. Having said that, The slop is usually acceptable for most applications. The piece at the front is cut though. So the first time you install the little green zero clearance you should run it on some scrap to score it can create the zero clearance. Not sure on the Makita but the festool has a blade offset adjustment which let's you line two saw up to use the same rail. This means that if you have established a zero clearance with one saw, Makita, Bosch or another festool, you can match that zero clearance with a new saw. Dialling in multiple saws for one track. And finally if I'm not mistaken both saw are design to pivot around the track when making beveled cuts. By that I mean cutting at 0 and 45 back to back will not change the zero clearance on the track.

[@stevenbalaz8308]

I don’t normally comment on KZbin videos, but to stumble upon your channel & have such a clear & to the point review makes it incredibly convincing as someone invested in the makita lineup. But most importantly it’s the integrity that’s got me hooked & for that I have to subscribe

[@als4817]

Same 1st time here, and the intro was very gratifying to view. Love the integrity and honesty, I subbed for that alone.

[@edwardwilson990]

The distance from the Festool splinter guide and the blade is adjustable to you can set it up to run several different saws on the same tracks. Also the Festool bevel feature is designed so that when it's used, it cuts on the same line and doesn't re-cut the splinter guide. The pivot point was designed specifically to address that issue.

[@EdwardT9]

The Makita does the same on the bevel, it cuts on the same line.

[@mitchOrr1]

@@EdwardT9 Are you sure about this? I have the Makita and when beveling it actually does cut off more of the rubber strip. Rendering the 90 cuts inaccurate afterwards.

[@johndonson1603]

@@mitchOrr1 I've got both, I use the Makita on a Festool track, I don't find that after 45s the 90 degree cut is affected on either machine.

[@chrisdemeglio7983]

Great integrity and honesty. When the Festool guys looked this video I bet they cringed when you recommended Makita!!!

[@Russ0107]

That is some rare integrity.

[@katzmosestools]

I person is only as good as their word. I wouldn't be where I am today if it wasn't for the support of my viewers. I could never violate that trust.

[@Sulkanator]

@@katzmosestools Love that JKM.

[@midagedman2719]

Interesting ,if you ask me ,that a tool company is willing to hand over said tool and accessories, plus a disclosed sum just to do a review. Could it be the explanation for said companies prices ? Any chance of seeing the offering from mafell in comparison? Peace ,and cheers.

[@myfinalheaven9590]

@@katzmosestools Ah man. That's so awesome to value your integrity for the sake of your viewers rather than companies hoping to use your platform to sell a product. Subbed.

[@xinixxagnix201]

Makita payed 12k :)

[@CoffeyCustomBuilds]

I have the Festool but agree with every one of your points. I had the Makita. It was fantastic and a great buy. I just wanted the Ferrari. If doesn't matter which one you get. Just get a track saw. They are game changing tools.

[@1320crusier]

check out AvE's tear down of the festool ;)

[@CoffeyCustomBuilds]

@@1320crusier I own the tools and am happy with them. I don't really need someone else to tell me if I'm happy with them or not.

[@1320crusier]

@@CoffeyCustomBuilds thats fine. Still worth seeing how Festool actually constructed and designed it.

[@CoffeyCustomBuilds]

@@1320crusier fair. Solid point. I will get it in queue. Thanks!

[@matthewphillips5483]

Festool isnt a Ferrari lol.

[@danielscott4514]

Hi there ... nice review. A few comments I would add ... As someone who owns the corded version of this Festool saw, I think Makita's additional lip on the top-side T track of their rails to stop the saw tipping over when it's bevelled is a really great idea. The corded festool definitely wants to fall over when it's bevelled at 45 and you really need to have a hand on the base plate while you're making those kinds of cuts. Secondly, the green consumable "splinter guard" on the festool is actually a really important feature if you plan on using the offcut side of any brittle material you might cut. The gold standard is whether or not you can make a cut in a sheet of Melamine and be happy to use that finished cut in a piece of cabinetry. Those green splinterguards (and a blade that's kept free of gunked up resin and glue from previous cuts) are *critical* to being able to cut melamine well. You buy the green splinterguards in packs of 5, and I tend to label mine by maximum depth I'll use them for - so there's some zero clearance across the blade teeth as well. Surprised to see that the makita saw doesn't have that feature - it's really important if you work with fussy material. Finally, the riving knife on the festool is also useful for keeping the saw on track if you're working with slippery material (pre-finished plywood, or melamine) and you are using the rail without clamps. Generally they're pretty good at staying in place, but if you're not careful it is possible to have the rail slip a little mid-cut and the riving knife helps prevent that to some degree. Plus if you've ever tried making a bevelled rip cut in hardwood timber with one of these saws ... well ... I wouldn't want to do it without a riving knife on the saw (not with the festool's less forgiving design for bevel cuts anyway .. the makita probably does a better job of keeping itself upright on those cuts). Moderately interesting story ... I had a secondhand TS55 EBQ for a while, before stumping up to buy a brand new saw ... the rail it came with (which I still have) came to me with a really nice set of teeth marks across the rail where the last owner had obviously had a decent kickback. I'll wager it was on a bevel cut ... I've had mine kick at me on a cut like that - even with the riving knife ... would have been a lot worse without one.

[@maisummarceneiroumdemuitos8037]

Makita uses a different system to melamine material, you make a small first non through cut in first run and a second cut through to main material. Here in Brazil most of high quality cabinets ate made in MDF with melamine tops so 99% of portable saws are Makita ones. You can't get a perfect finish with one way cut, this is why industrial precision saws have two saws, on in top and another one in bottom so the saw is always entering the material and never leaving the material so you get absolutely absence of splitters. Local market here differs from USA where I saw a lot of plywood being used for cabinets. Interesting differences!

[@RedcarWW]

This was a timely and valuable vid. I originally purchased the Accu-cut from Kreg to go along with my Makita circular saw. Almost 9 months later, and while I still use the Accu-cut, I am ready for a system. I purchased the Makita circular saw based on the recommendation of the local hardware store and that they were always a favorite of my dad's. My current router is a Bosch. While I like Bosch, today I purchased the Makita XTR01T8J cordless router. The fact that Makita's track system also works with their routers is a major plus. Now I can leave the Bosch router in my router table. The one thing you didn't touch on was the lack of integration between the vacuum systems and the cordless track systems. I guess there really isn't a need as it's obvious. Thanks for this comparison.

[@martinruszkowski9152]

Thanks for the honest take on this matter...bought the corded Festool but then realized I like the "freedom" of cordless...going with the Makita as it is significantly less expensive and certainly offers an accessible and versatile cordless tool platform.

[@fk6536]

Jonathan, the markings with hare, turtle and x is the position where the battery is and how the expected functioning of the saw will be. Both in --> full power, bottom one in --> slow or half power, top one in --> not functioning. Keep the independent opinions, hugely appreciated!

[@SSBailey77845]

Great review Jonathan. I have learned to trust your opinions because, well, they seem honest....and your explanation at the outset was very important to me. I have to say I was surprised about your recommendation of the Makita. A lot of the wood working content creators I watch are “all Festool, all the time” but dang...that’s a daunting price point for most of us. What I also see is some creator that has a shop full of the top 1% of tools..12” jointers, $5,000 CNC machines...and they are all because of paid product placements. But not Mr. Katz-Moses, no sir. You’ve made restoring an old machine or buying on a budget cool...so thanks for that. I thought for sure you’d go with the Festool because of the riving knife if not just for the “Festool mystique” thing. Thanks for your integrity my friend.

[@als4817]

I too have seen all the Festools users posted videos, and did not realize the company was paying so much money to these KZbinrs to review, and a free tool !!?? Pretty shocking how much money they are making, just doing the video and being given a free tool. Thanks for posting !! I'm buying makita.

[@SSBailey77845]

@@als4817 You won’t be disappointed. I own several Makita tools along with DeWalt, Bosch, Jet, PowerMatic and SawStop….not a Festool - or Woodpecker for that matter - in the whole shop and I don’t think I’m missing anything. I’ll pay for quality when I can see that it’s there but I don’t need to pay for a PR campaign!

[@als4817]

@@SSBailey77845 Thanks for your comments !

[@terrybollenbaugh7622]

Thank you for the review Jonathan. I've used Makita for years and have always loved their products. I've been looking at tracks saws for a long time and I'm glad to see such a well done comparison between the Festool and the Makita. Than you again.

[@crill3682]

You forgot to talk about how makita track saw has a scoring option which comes in handy. A lot of people don’t know about that.

[@Hoodalump]

Just set the depth stop on the Festool to 1/8 inch or so and you have the same thing. I know, not really Festool-ish, but it works.

[@jacobbrown1690]

Yep

[@ericolejkowski8748]

I prefer corded version due to a fact that it will trigger the vacuum. Also Festool has this clip that attaches itself to their track and prevents the saw going backwards,great when doing plunge cuts. Also it has a guard that attachés itself to the back of the track and it prevents the hose or the cord being caught on the sharp edge ( minor thing but it works) Also you said Makita copied Festool, but the truth is Festool copied Mafel first. So long story short I use corded Festool saw with Makita tracks , and have tons of Makita cordless tools.

[@danielscott4514]

@@ericolejkowski8748 As the rails are the same (apart from a small lip on the top T track of the makita rails), you could very likely use the festool stops with a makita rail and saw (and if the stops didn't work out of the box, then provided you've got a second rail or a straight edge then you can run your track saw down the makita rail and cut off the offending lip ... which you would need to do if you want to use makita rails with some of Festool's Jigsaw and Router attachments I believe). That said. The small lip on the makita rails is something to stop the saw tipping over when it's bevelled: as the owner of a festool TS55 which tips very willingly when bevelled, I think it's actually a superior design to the festool rail and a feature you'd probably want to keep on at least one of your rails if you were the owner of a makita saw and rail combo.

[@ThekiBoran]

@@danielscott4514 The anti tip feature on the Makita is nice but if you need a perfect miter it's still possible to booger it up a bit if you let it tip as the track will flex a smidgen.

[@dustinvinci345]

Please make more videos like this. Always interested in real, true, unbiased opinions on tools because I can’t afford to make mistakes buying the wrong tools.

[@Jeremysoccer45]

Use to have the corded Makita SP6000J and upgraded to the Festool TS75. The power, cut quality, ease of use, and cutting depth are all significantly improved on the festool. Cut a slab >2" with both and you'll see/feel the difference. Also, the TSO GRC-12 are hands down the best rail connectors.

[@maisummarceneiroumdemuitos8037]

I never get a perfect results with connector on long wood pieces I only solve this issue buying a 3m makita rail.

[@lorenzoucce3903]

so is it ok to cut hardwood with these saw?

[@mpmacd]

Haven’t even finished the video. Complete respect. Even if the Festool turns out to be the better of the two, the honesty is appreciated.

[@ThisTall]

I’ve had both of these and love them both. In my experience the Makita blades are better for chipless cutting, but the bevel hinge mechanism isn’t built quite as robust as the Festool so it began to become a bit sloppy after about 2 years. Also, the Makita can be made to be square, but on mine and 3 others I checked, the mitre gauge wasn’t accurate, so when the stop and mitre gauge indicator is set to 0°, when I then set the bevel over to 45°, in reality it was only about 43°. So the bevel gauge itself wasn’t accurate and you can only really trust the stops you set and can’t trust it to make random angle cuts accurately.

[@saiiiiiii1]

My Festool gauge also isn't accurate. I dialed in perfectly 90 degrees once and clamped it down with the force of a thousand suns. Gauge shows 0.5 degrees. 😉

[@SlaviJordanov]

Very good review on both of the saws. I have had both and the Makita is great. I have also read somewhere that you can adapt it to use a standard 5/8 arbor blade. I have other cordless Festool tools and a vacuum with bluetooth, that's why I switched to the Festool one. Also Festool makes a rail with 32mm spacing for shelf pin holes, if you need that feature later on.

[@1589cam]

Great review. Best on KZbin. One thing: I believe the Bluetooth function on the Festool saw pairs with the Festool vacuum, so that you can can have wireless auto-start/stop. Great Video, Thanks!

[@troyqueen9503]

Saves a lot of steps.🌴🇨🇦

[@gidgemo1869]

Mad respect. Top 5 favorite KZbin channels. When I’m able to start my woodworking journey, you’ll be my inspiration. Thank you!!!

[@michielvandorsser7691]

The Bluetooth is for when you want to use a cordless tool with a shop vaccuum. The tool can be linked to the vaccuum using bluetooth which then automaticly switches on when you start cutting.

[@jonathanwiggill8242]

Respect your commitment to objective reviews. Thank you Jonathan.

[@jasongregory89]

Great toolsday comparison, thanks! The tracks are quasi interchangeable. The saws will run on either, but I found some of the Festool router accessories won’t attach to the Makita track. The T-tracks are different widths.

[@cornflake73]

Nice breakdown of comparable features of these two track saws. Every tool has its place in a shop setting, and cost typically dictates budget constraints. Over the years component tools for specific tasks were being sought, but that gets expensive and takes lots of space. Today, space is more valuable, and compactness is now being sought.

[@jxk7712]

Thanks, I almost drool looking at the Festool but the battery range of the Makita tools makes the choice for me. I have the trim router and the ability to swap out the batteries is nearly priceless in the moment. Thank you

[@jamesrichards3000]

Hi, the little plastic tab that you didn't use on the Festool prevents tear out. The Bluetooth batteries sync to the Festool dust extractors and turn them on and off when operating . Too bad you didn't show a cut with the anti tear out feature on the Festool.

[@mattywho8485]

As far as Makita blades, I have a corded 10" compound sliding miter saw and the Makita factory blade cuts smoother than any other blade I have ever bought !!!

[@markr1142]

The makita efficut blades are awesome, they come stock it most higher end tools.

[@DirtbikeXpeditions]

For my budget and application, I went with the Kreg Accu Cut and use my old skil saw.....I know it’s not the same thing but it allows me to breakdown sheet goods just fine and then do the final cut on the table saw. I realize it is nowhere close to the same league as any dedicated track saw, but it works for me at the moment and it was only $80......just throwing this out there for any new woodworker who might not realize there is this option. Another great video by the way! Thanks for your expert opinion. Love my Katz-Moses apron and jigs!

[@thomasarussellsr]

I have the clamp on straight edge from harbor freight and it only requires the extra math of adding/subtracting the offset of the base-plate of your skill saw. Under $20 including a pair of 2" c-clamps. Same thing, processing sheet goods, then table saw. All of us can not afford the track saw, just yet. So this is my affordable option at the moment. I sure would love to get the track-saw at some point though. Guess I need to add another coffee can to the "special savings" shelf in the shop. (A lazy susan with labled cans for each tool I am saving to buy.) Rotate each week the subsequent can gets something added. With a running total lable on the can so I know when that goal has been met.

[@jaxwagen4238]

Totally agree about the Kreg Accu Cut. Maybe he will cover it in his $1200 workshop series

[@dfs7979]

Hey nice review. I was in the same boat a few months ago although I didn't want a battery powered saw as I will use it rarely and want to keep the tool for the next 25 years not having to worry about which battery platform I'm on. I first tried out the Makita corded and while the saw was just OK the tracks were not. One of them had a significant bow to it. I read this is a common problem with the Makita tracks so beware. I ended up settling on new Kreg track saw. It was a tiny bit cheaper than Makita and has more safety features such as anti-kickback, generous cord length, dust bag, chip guard, and a riving knife. The riving knife was very important to me - I just can't say enough about how much safety that adds especially when straight-line ripping rough boards. The bonus feature is the Kreg saw is blade-left so it is much more natural to use for right handers. Now this tool is fairly new and Kreg isn't known for making power tools so who knows what the future holds. The build is not quite as nice as the Makita but it is close.

[@dusbus2384]

Pretty sure they are the exact same track with different colors. Festool, Makita, and triton all have the same track

[@MichaelBrown-kk6ck]

Have heard of a lot of folks getting the Makita saw and Festool tracks. Aside from this quality issue my understanding is the tracks are very similar and compatible but not identical. I believe the Makita has an extra lip/ridge/whatever that works with their anti-tipping feature, which may not be needed on the Festool with its different weight distribution.

[@dfs7979]

@@MichaelBrown-kk6ck well now I have to eat my words as I ended up switching to the new TSC55 K. The Festool tracks are nice and straight and I love the TSO self aligning connectors. Now with the new 40v Makita with kickback control being released I kind of wish I would have waited and gone all Makita. At least there would be more uses for a Makita battery vs the festool.

[@MichaelBrown-kk6ck]

@@dfs7979 40v Makita? Is this different from their 18/36v LXT gear? Got a model # for the new saw? What new anti kickback feature on Makita? It would be ironic if Makita adds a riving knife while Festool removes theirs.

[@davetynan561]

My comparison was with video reviews only, and I selected the Makita track saw system about 3 years ago. Factoring in the range of tools that use the same batteries, Makita is IMHO, the best value out there regarding cordless tools. Your video did explain some features that I was not aware of also. Thanks.

[@liedjesvanjelle]

9:12 Well that’s the game changer for me. I have the ts55 now for 4 years and there are many moments where I switch between the depth while working on a project. It is very very nice to be able to put the saw on the lowest depth and switch back to the dept I’m working on. And what the promotion video shows isn’t a joke, you can actually fine tune so precise, that your blade won’t even hit the desk you’re sawing your piece on. I have also used the saw to make joints in timber frames, I make multiple cuts next to each other to cut away to a certain dept. I just need to know that 30mm is exactly 30mm and I want to be able to come back to that same setting when I’m continuing the job the next day. I never would have thought, but that knob is gold!

[@shanemelville]

Thanks for the extensive review, I have not seen anyone that has reviewed these 2 saws/tracks go through all the features that each one has, it helps to purchase them. Most tool comparisons just touch the surface than when you buy the tool you find out all the features some you don't like & you have buyers remorse especially when your dealing with larger amounts of money for tools. Thanks Johnathan

[@Curious_Skeptic]

WOW! I'm so happy to see honesty! I wonder how many channels do reviews for cash!? That is just horrible! You happen to be reviewing to amazing tools that need no applause to be sold. Two of the top track saws for years. Most shops have told me, get the Makita! Festool just isn't worth double the price! The amount of money I'll save vs quality improvement, no brainer to stay away from Festool. Plenty of very nice alternatives these days. When I had my Festool track saw, I bought an after market off brand. It worked GREAT!

[@maximillianzorn6085]

The Bluetooth connects to Bluetooth nodes on the dust extractors. Allows you to only have to deal with the hose. Saw turns on, extractor turns on.

[@katzmosestools]

Good to know. I think Makita has one of those as well. That would be a huge benefit! I need one.

[@woodpecked3D]

what hes trying to say is that why is the bluetooth on the batteries and not on the saw itself

[@HeadBroski]

I have never heard of this channel and I follow several woodworker channels, but that opening segment earned my subscription.

[@sprayfe]

I’ve got the corded makita and it has been rock solid for me. As I get more and more green crack in my shop I find myself wanting a TS75... tell me I shouldn’t

[@katzmosestools]

Hahaha they're great tools but the Makita does the same thing for way less. Up to you to decide what best suits your workflow. In fairness I haven't tried the 75. Seems like a beast.

[@espressomatic]

Most channels will say they're un-sponsored but then state that they were sent the tool free of charge (and the tools can range in price anywhere from $50 to upwards of $10000). When someone send you something and you don't have to send it back, whether they have a say in the content or not, that's a sponsored production. I wish more creators were forthcoming about that instead of trying to brush it aside. I like the situation in New Zealand now, where creators have to state openly and plainly that the content is considered a paid advertisement whenever they've been given any product by a supplier.

[@markbongers9641]

You forgot to mention the service of Festool. Even when you damage to tool in the first 3 years, Festool will repair free of charge. As for the bluetooth on the batteries, when used with the right Vacuum it will kick on when you start the saw, as with corded versions. Further more you can check condition of the batteries in an app. Rest to say you did a great review

[@thomasarussellsr]

Thanks for the bluetooth info.

[@davidmckenzie5]

One of the main reasons I bought the Festool was for the service. I've been told it is second to none which is a comfort if something happens. They tend to fully recondition the tool when it is returned for repair.

[@LDBecker]

The Festool TS75 that you mentioned is a cord-only option (and not available right now), and has an 8 1/4" blade. It was my first track saw from back when no one else was making them. It changed the way I handle sheet goods completely, and gives a great edge on the cuts. It was a bit heavy for general use, so I got the TSC55, which is cordless and has a 6 1/4" blade. Paired with a Bluetooth-enabled battery, it will trigger my Festool CT 36 vacuum (with the Bluetooth upgrade). Thanks for the review - usually when someone compares a Festool product to something designed to be just a little better and cheaper, Festool gets run down. Thanks for not doing that - Festool has a LOT going for it as a company and with their tools.

[@MrSpeederi]

Nice review. The Festool will make a splinter free cut, when set up properly. No doubt the Makita will too. Reasons why I chose Festool are quality and to support the R&D so they can get innovations to the market, which other brands then copy..

[@truthserum9157]

LOL, that’s the best answer I’ve heard so far (R&D), I love my Festool sanders and dust extractor.

[@tonyimperial5323]

Two videos in two days. This makes me so happy.

[@julianweiser9985]

I had both. The festool is made in my country, the build quality is very precise and stiff. However, it (cheapest corded version 550 $) was loud for my ears and heavy at the same time. The cordless makita was quiet, light and cost me only 320$ +80 $ for 1 5Ah battery. The batteries on the makita also cut a lot more material, somewhere around 200m. Let's say you wont run out. However, the makita also doesn't feel as extremely stiff as the festool saw. My tip: home users and contractors who rarely use the device but want equal results: Makita. (made in UK, btw) Professional and all-time users: Get the festool cordless saw with Kickback protection. That feature alone is worth a lot.

[@DenHvideHund]

Perhaps a bit late on the show, but I did enjoy the comparison and being a Makita multiple tool owner myself I can safely order that tracksaw to my collection, after watching this. I applaud your honesty and integrity not to fall into the easy "sell off scheme".

[@terryduprie6313]

Jonathan, I really appreciate your opinions and the fact that you keep it real. That's why I'm a fan. Keep it up and we'll keep supporting your channel. Great job!!!

[@Tommy-fx4iu]

The makita also has a bluetooth option. I see most people with the standard one, but there’s two different options when buying. The bluetooth one is AWS (automatic wireless start) and a little more pricey, it’s a small chip you insert.

[@BiggMo]

I’m actually a Dewalt track saw user because of the slides built into the blade guard I can undercut doors in place - but other than that, I don’t have an option

[@lukaspaul4293]

Have a look at Mafell. also a german brand that produces at a even higher standard than Festool. they have some awesome specialty saws such as a 185mm cutting depth circular saw tilting to upto 60° and a tracksaw that runs along the track on its own and then returns. also their railsystem is superior when joining multiple lengths of track as the connectin piece is self alining. (bosch licenced their design)

[@jfgreen1959]

Yeah if Festool is the Ferrari, Mafell is the Rolls-Royce.

[@jfgreen1959]

Unfortunately, Mafell lacks a service/distribution network in the US.

[@lukaspaul4293]

@@jfgreen1959 yes thats a very important aspect of any quality tool. Sadly i dont see them expanding anytime soon as they seem contempt with the european market. the rather do something specivic very well rather than trying to sell as much as possible all over the globe

[@PatriotPaulUSA]

Excellent review/comparison! I have used Makita's lxt 18-36volt system since its introduction well over 10 yrs ago. Makita's motors seem to be some of the smallest best balanced in the industry. I own and use about 25 of their tools, mostly 18v, However, I don't own the track saw but I have bought 3 sections of track, the track connector and the Makita track adaptor for my 18volt 6.5" saws! (a poor mans/homeowner version of a track saw ) It works spectacular. I just purchased the XSH06PT , 7 1/4"- 36v saw with 2 xtra 5.0ah batteries totaling 4, from the Home Depot, for 249.00! this week. I will check to see if it will work with the system perhaps, or if Makita makes a track adaptor for it. The lack of plunge, and a few other features I give up, but its been really great for Baltic birch, and other veneer plys and just regular cdx. Hopefully we will get some lumbermills built this year to replace all the burned down ones and be able to buy 2 by wood and plywood again. Until then I'm not building a lot sadly. New Sub!

[@JARMade]

I literally just got my Makita track saw last month, and put it to use last weekend. i love it so far.

[@ArpadBuildsThis]

I have been looking at both of these track saws and have been deciding on which one to get! Thank you!

[@thomasarussellsr]

$6k + a $900 kit? You have that rare integrity, sir, and I appreciate that. Yeah, availability of additional tools, and more batteries that come with larger collection of tools and chargers, would be a strong pro (vs con) for the Makita lable. The $100+ difference alone wouldn't be as big of a factor by itself. The fact that you can amass a larger collection, and therefore likely add stand-alone tools without batteries and save some money that way, is a big plus to the Makita brand as well. The track catch/lock for hold into the track on a tilted bevel cut is a great feature too. I believe that with your no-nonsense and honest review, the Makita would be the smart choice as well. After all, the only real world plus to the Festool, machine wise, for me, is some features make adjustments slightly easier, and of course the riving knife. The "fashionable" name brand being a status symbol may play into it for what Tyler Perry's Madea would call a "Label Ho", but I don't really care what label is on something. What really matters is if it works well, does the job, and has real longevity. Thanks for your real compare and contrast review.

[@als4817]

I'm surprised not more comments here on that $$ issue. Thanks for posting !!

[@driftwood4625]

We just got the Makita track saw at work, works like a charm. We also got the Makita battery HEPA vacuum to go with it, the static shocks are insane! I just plug it to a regular shop vac now.

[@wildtwindad]

I luv tracksaws. Found my first Makita sp6000 at the repair shop with track for 240$. It paid for its 2 replacements.....and save me so much time.

[@brucewilson3170]

Very nice work. I have a corded Makita track saw and love it. I don't recall you saying much about the scoring cut, which helps a lot with making clean edges. When working with plywood, I pretty much always make a scoring pass first. I also have a 4x8 work surface and I lay down a sheet of 1" foam insulation under whatever I'm cutting. Using that and the scoring cut, I get great, clean edges. Powertec also makes rails that work with these rail saws, and I like the way the Powertec pieces join together better than I do on the Makita rails. I also have the Dewalt clamps for track saws, which work well and were less expensive than many other options.

[@als4817]

Great comment and information, thank you for posting !!

[@skyypham]

Trusted tools reviewer. If I need a advice prior buying a tool, it's Katz

[@streetkombativesystem4704]

I purchased a Makita 36v because I just couldn't justify the Festool cost, I LOVE IT! I got the saw and container, twin rapid charger and two batteries with separate container, a 55inch track AND a 18v makita jig saw all for less than the Festool kit that does not come with track. Festool is an amazing brand, but this Makita performs just as well if not better imho, just wish Makita would design a loose tenon tool equivalent to the Domino, as that thing cost me my first born LOL! Great vid once again, thanks.

[@riba2233]

@boogiedahomey how soon?

[@larrymclean2148]

RR Buildings already does “Toolsday” reviews. Not insinuating that your coping but just wanted to make you aware before the internet trolls try to cancel you. Thanks for all of the educational and philanthropic content you’re producing.

[@Zaneo-i1e]

The Bluetooth on the Festool batteries is so that they can control dust collection

[@woodpecked3D]

what hes trying to say is that why is the bluetooth on the batteries and not on the saw itself

[@billystray7007]

I can only speak to the festool but when I change the setting to 45° it doesn't change the cut on the splinter guard In fact it pivots right on it so I can use it to line up my cut ..

[@BernhardMarchhart]

Same on Makita.

[@alexeychernenko2096]

@@BernhardMarchhart any tracksaw, actually

[@Otterlimits]

@@alexeychernenko2096 I've read that the Mafell pivots out from the cutline, but don't know first hand.

[@ryanm2214]

I appreciate the honest review. Somehow carpentry made it this far without over priced Festool and I will do my part to keep it that way.

[@tellthemborissentyou]

If you haven't bought a Katz-Moses dovetail jig yet then buy one. I made a mess of some dovetails I cut then I got the jig and now my family think I am a real craftsman! It is a lot of fun to use and with a bit of care it makes the job so much easier.

[@thetallcarpenter]

First 1 minute and 45 seconds was great to hear.😎 I have just got the Makita for pretty much all the reasons you mentioned. Everyone knows how good the Festool gear is, but it also needs to fit in with the stuff you already use. Cheers.

[@philippseif2855]

Great video! I love your honesty and integrity on your review. You point out the most important features and compare them. Helped a lot.

[@crisantechris]

Love this review! Personally own the Festool, but the Makita is such a great saw. I Appreciate the integrity so much, I may just have to buy 150 Dovetail jigs...oh wait...I spent all my money on my Festool track saw...

[@johnjrambo5827]

Excellent video, I was 85 % makita before this video I’m now 100 % going to order one tomorrow. . Thanks mate ...

[@KevinBrown-xo7jr]

It’s always really nice when you see a fellow carpenter that you respect come to the conclusion that you were hoping they would. After much deliberation and back and forth in my crazy-tiny-mind I’m going with the Makita for all the reasons JKM mentioned at the end. Thank you

[@dlevi67]

One important difference between the two rails is that the anti-tipping implementation is different and not compatible across saws/rails. It's not that one is better than the other, but the rails aren't a perfect replacement for one another, and safety is affected if you run bevels with a Festool saw on a Makita track or vice-versa.

[@alexhguerra]

now i can mind why festool misses that small button. do you have any links for the anti-tipping mechanism?

[@dlevi67]

@@alexhguerra There isn't much to link - it's just the way in which the sole plate of the saw and the rail profile fit into each other. You can see the difference between the two rails quite clearly at 6:00 in this video: the Makita rail (flipped upside-down) has a T-shaped part, while the Festool has a C-shape. The sole plates are shaped so that both rails will fit, but only the 'correct' rail will hold the saw fully. When the blade is vertical, it (almost) doesn't matter; if the blade is set at an angle (bevel cut), the presence of a horizontal hook that prevents it from tipping on either side becomes much more important.

[@zerofiz]

Great video, love the honesty and integrity! I went with the Grizzly track saw, mostly because of the price point and the fact I had never used a track saw before. I'm certain, now, that I'll upgrade at some point and the Makita is the one I've been eyeing the most, although I'd love to see a comparison between the Makita and the Dewalt (invested in Dewalt at this point, too).

[@Sir_Pants_Alot]

Dewalt and Makita track saw relationship is the same as makita and Festool. Everything is 10-20% better on the makita. I had a dewalt. Sold it and do not regret it one bit. IMO it’s the worst track saw on the market from a major company.

[@danielscott4514]

Just looked it up. That grizzly saw looks very like a tracksaw that was released several years ago under a few different brands, including Sheppach (who re-badge tools and machinery from a variety of sources). By all accounts it's quite a reasonable saw and very good value for money. As with all budget tool purchases, sometimes you can overcome the little niggles with a bit of tinkering. Search youtube for Sheppach track saw if you're finding any frustrations with your Grizzly - there were several very good videos a bunch of years back from a guy who owned one and had made some modifications to get around things like accuracy limitations and not-so-good dust extraction. He managed to tune his up pretty darned good.

[@littlejackalo5326]

Imagine how much money you would have saved by going with the good saw from the get go. I never understood the whole "I'm going to buy the cheaper HF/Grizzly version to see if I like it, and then I can upgrade later on." That just seems so counterintuitive to me. There's so much info on KZbin, that you can know with a very high certainty if you'll use/like the tool. You'll almost always either end up upgrading and losing it on the cost of the cheaper version, because you'll never use it and no one will want to buy it, or you'll end up suffering with the cheaper version because you don't want to lose the cost of the cheaper one.

[@zerofiz]

@@littlejackalo5326 How bout you don't worry about what I spend and mind your own damn business?

[@H0kieJoe]

​ Comparing the quality of Harbor Fright with Grizzly is goofy.

[@JkCanvas]

Thank you for the review and your honesty. When I make a big purchase especially tools, I look for reviews from content creators I trust.

[@garybecker4490]

First off, bought stop blocks and gave some as Xmas gifts. This couldn't have been more timely and may be long winded (links below too)... 1. I bought the Makita recently. Home Depot has had some great buys with free planer or sander, charger, 2 batteries and a 55" rail. Just bought the 118" rail this morning at the best price Ive ever seen. 2. I've been in the Milwaukee 18v platform since my construction days, but they still haven't announced a track saw. Ive always liked Makita, since their tools fit my smaller hands (ergonomics, what a concept!). The most important features of the Makita were the scoring feature, cut quality, anti-tip (which you left out), lower cost, and, as you said, way more tools. The good, the bad, and the ugly... The good: Cut quality My buddy is a Festool dealer and he was impressed. The bad: The rails. Apparently, its hit or miss on how straight they are. I'm getting deviation of 1/16" per 2+ feet, depending on the rail. I have 2 55" and a 39". You may say its my technique, so i checked with my expert cabinet maker and we checked each rail against known good straight edges and (woodpeckers) squares. I replaced the cut strips and clamped both ends. Only one of the 55" rails cut straight and true. I'm getting replacements as we speak and there is supporting chatter in the forums. Additionally, not all match fit clamps fit in each rail. I have new and old ones. I have TSO connecting rails and they had issues with the rails. I checked my TSO rail square and the cuts were off with multiple rails. The ugly (not really): Accessories. Between the TSO square, TSO connecting rails, longer tracks and parallel guides (which seem to be out of stock, regardless of brand), I'm spending a lot more money than i thought, but still cheaper than Festool. He who dies with the most tools... ;-) One thing Festool has vs Makita is better rail adapters for routers and other power tools. The LR32 rail is cool. I think Ive gone on long enough. Links: Home Depot Makita Saw Kit: www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-18V-X2-36V-LXT-Brushless-6-1-2-in-Plunge-Circ-Saw-Kit-5-0Ah-and-55-in-Guide-Rail-with-bonus-18V-LXT-3-1-4-in-Planer-XPS01PTJ-194XPK/315697723 Home Depot Makita 118" Rail: www.homedepot.com/p/Makita-118-in-Guide-Rail-194367-7/203297529 TSO Products Connecting Rails: tsoproducts.com/accessories/grc-12-self-aligning-guide-rail-connectors/ TSO Products Rail Square: tsoproducts.com/tso-guide-rail-squares/grs-16-pe-parallel-edge-guide-rail-square/ *Festool sells a duplicate in Australia.

[@jcsrst]

I have the corded Festool saw and the one thing that makes me mental about it is cutting a 45 because the saw wants to fall over!! Makita is so smart to put that little foot to hook the track. I love all my Makita tools, they just work so well in a professional setting. If I had it to do over I'd buy the Makita.

[@TheOutdoorEthos]

So much respect man for turning down that offer. This is why I watch and trust you!

[@dustinfeher2111]

Dude, he made more money from posting the email than taking the money...

[@OGStr8UpJack]

Same decision factors for me lead to Makita. I owned a Festool and sold it because I love my Makita cordless tools. Makita frequently runs promos where you get 2 free 18v batteries with a 36v tool ( so 4 batteries total ). Whenever they run that promo for a tool I don’t own.. 💥 I own that tool :) I have also switch all my saws over to Makita steel when it comes to blades. They simply make the best blades on the market IMO. They certainly supply the best factory blades even if you don’t agree they make the best blade.

[@elkaddouriismail5591]

beautiful video! festool is just great !! and as far as the Bluetooth is concerned, eh is to connect to your festool vacuum cleaner every time you use your TS55 or use a festool machine with Bluetooth battery then your vacuum cleaner will start automatically!

[@AndrewSzeto]

love this and juuuust what i needed. going with the makita!

[@jonasf4065]

Thank you . Just confirms why I am a Festool fan and will continue buying from them.

[@stuff6218]

The Bluetooth on the Festool connects to their hoover and turns it on/off when the saw turns on. Super handy.

[@niftygriffty]

Quick tip if your friction strips on your track stop being grippy: use some masking tape to “pull” the dirt/dust off them.

[@rickmorrison7535]

Wow. A man with integrity that will NOT be bought. Impressive.

[@billybarghahn]

Thank you for holding strong with unbiased reviews! The amount of Festool influencers is ridiculous. Sedge, Bent, and 731 must all wearing lime green tights under the costumes they wear in KZbin. It’s cringey how they try to be subtle. Festool makes great products, for sure. I have some. But whenever I try to research tools on KZbin I mostly see those guys peddling the green juice.

[@ClintonCaraway-CNC]

Thank you so much for this video. I am currently finishing my retirement shop. It is at my house and incredible BUT it is 60% smaller than the shop I've worked in for the last 30yrs. Going from a 30x30 shop with a separate lumber storage and finishing room to a 12x28 well organized shop made a tracksaw a must. I no longer have the ability to comfortably break down sheet goods with my cabinet saw. I was leaning towards the Festool but after this I'm going with Makita.

[@seanmccaffrey6378]

Great video,I’ve got the mains festool and Makita 36v ,I always grab my Makita! Cheaper does exactly the same without the massive price difference,don’t get me wrong the Festool is excellent quality but is it worth the difference in cost ? No ,and I run all Makita cordless so alway have plenty of spare batteries!

[@Siderod]

Great content as always, Jonathan! Peter Millard over at The 10 Minute Workshop is an avid Festool user, and has done a few videos comparing it to cheaper saws - they're really spoiled for choice in the UK, with several available for right around 100 pounds. I also appreciate the honesty, made even more genuine by the fact you bought the Festool, admit that it's better in several ways, but would still rather have the Makita because its a better fit for you. Thumbs up all round!

[@jnewmy14]

I'm pretty sure the Bluetooth feature is for integration with the dust extractor, it tells it to turn on when you squeeze the trigger on the saw. Of course you have to have the Festool dust collector with that feature.

[@FLPhotoCatcher]

I refuse to buy stuff with Bluetooth spy abilities embedded. They may, or may not use them to spy - *currently,* but it's coming. With fewer people who believe in God, I think 'they' see the need for being able to have an all seeing eye to prevent society from spiraling down into chaos.

[@MisterAristos]

@@FLPhotoCatcher as long as they don't connect to the internet it's all local. Just think of how far you can move away from your Bluetooth music box with your phone before the music begins to stutter. Same thing with this system. 🙂

[@FLPhotoCatcher]

@@MisterAristos That assumes that the gov doesn't have any way to listen-in from farther away. But I'm sure they can. And things will just get more and more connected unless we take a stand against the intrusion. And I don't think we need all the conveniences that some of those things bring - I think that we Americans are too soft already.

[@scottc3626]

@@FLPhotoCatcher so.... the bluetooth on a track saw is spying you? as you type this into your computer or smartphone....right....

[@cuebj]

@@FLPhotoCatcher You're confusing bluetooth with Internet of Things wifi. I agree with some of your concerns about the latter but, for practical purposes and because they, whoever they are, have many ways to track me, I still use smart phone. Bluetooth has very limited range and purpose

[@DmytroLutsenko]

The reason why Makita has two step blade change (as far as I know) is for optional usage as a regular circular saw without plunge. Sometimes it may be handy cause I needed this feature on TS55 couple times, but don't have it, obviously.

[@riba2233]

Nope

[@SeanFoushee]

I looked into buying both of these last year and decided on the Festool cordless TSC 55. One of the things that really sold me was the dust collection without a dust extractor. You mentioned it just in passing, but the dust collection with just using the bag on the Festool is fantastic. I cut all of the hardwood flooring for our upstairs using the saw with very little mess and use it all the time in the shop and don't feel the need to hook it up to the shop vac. Great review!

[@Pepe-dq2ib]

90% of the time, people who use these tools indoor have a vac, so i can understand why its not important to him.

[@julianweiser9985]

The makita dust collection is on par, trust me. Do you have the KEB version? The K=Kickback protection is a killer feature to have.

[@gd5043]

I just bought the Kreg version after doing some research and talking it over with the reps from my favorite local wood store. Note sure I'm sold. I have a Festool dust extractor for my sanders and of course the port is a different size than my Festool hose. Also, the first cut on your Kreg it tells you to plunge cut on scrap plywood or MDF to cut the plastic guide, so I did. Wow....what a mess, now I have little plastic shavings all over the place and a rough edge guide. Not real happy about that part, but once I got it dialed in and tuned, I was happy with the quality of cut.

[@Weirdusername01]

Beginner Budget Friendly me went with the Kreg Accu-cut with a corded Makita saw and it's be pretty reliable thus far.