Does the Talmud agree with the Apostle Paul's interpretation of Hosea 2?? - The Case for Messiah

In this episode of Case for Messiah, not only do Dr's Soref and Postell respond to the objections that Paul ripped Hosea 2 out of context in Romans 9:23-26, but also show that the Talmud offers an interpretation of Hosea 2 that is remarkably similar to Paul's!
Want to go deeper? Check out more resources below
For further reading, see Dr. Postell’s chapter in The Moody Handbook of Messianic Prophecy: www.oneforisrael.org/wp-conte...
www.oneforisrael.org/answers/
Help us bring the Gospel back to Israel again.
www.oneforisrael.org/arise-on...

[@donkratos5627]

As a Christian Gentile (Italian American) w/ no Jewish roots whatsoever (but for Christ) I genuinely find it TRULY Beautiful, & an Honor, to be used by God as a means to provoke Love & Jealousy in His 1ST True Love, the Jewish People… Just one more example of my Gods unyielding Love for those whom He desires to be w/ Him forever 🙏

[@mimig123]

Me too. I am so grateful to have found the Truth of our faith and to be aligned with G-do’s chosen people.

[@NabsSpeaks]

Praises to the Most High! You are an Israelite now! Bought with a price. Ephesians 2: 11 Wherefore remember, that ye being in time past Gentiles in the flesh, who are called Uncircumcision by that which is called the Circumcision in the flesh made by hands; 12 That at that time ye were without Christ, being aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, and without God in the world: 13 But now in Christ Jesus ye who sometimes were far off are made nigh by the blood of Christ. 14 For he is our peace, who hath made both one, and hath broken down the middle wall of partition between us; 15 Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances; for to make in himself of twain one new man, so making peace; 16 And that he might reconcile both unto God in one body by the cross, having slain the enmity thereby: 17 And came and preached peace to you which were afar off, and to them that were nigh. 18 For through him we both have access by one Spirit unto the Father. 19 Now therefore ye are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellowcitizens with the saints, and of the household of God; 20 And are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone; 21 In whom all the building fitly framed together groweth unto an holy temple in the Lord: 22 In whom ye also are builded together for an habitation of God through the Spirit.

[@marilyngilley5565]

Yes, praise the God almighty! My feelings exactly ❤

[@ambuman]

Beautifully done, love this explanation of Hosea 2, blessing to the both of you and your ministry team. Shalom from this messianic gentile in NZ.

[@S3140741]

What a blessing this guys!. Blessings from Mexico 🇲🇽

[@marianhoover8206]

Wonderful teaching! A gentile believer in Virginia 😊

[@julinsansinaga8689]

May Lord Jesus Bless One for Israel , i'm from Medan North Sumatra Indonesia 👍🙏❤🇲🇨

[@pmarkhill519]

Bless you, dear one! 🖖🏽💖

[@gracesalva8428]

I would like you to write to me about Christians life in Indonesia. As I heard and saw in media Chriatian's houses are burned, and Christians badly persecuted?

[@ennisel]

11:19 Marvellous! Baruch Hashem for teachers like yourselves who bring out these pearls that show the unity that others have not dug deep to find.

[@neilrobson8426]

Paul was guided by the Holy Spirit, who is the author of and the true interpreter of the Scriptures. Thank you so much for your work.

[@supertrucker99]

Ya right.he called himself zealot many times

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

Paul is the Man of Lawlessness and he preaches the Anti-Christ. He also violated Deuteronomy 23:15 by returning a runaway slave to Philemon. So the new argument that Paul kept the Law of God is a lie.

[@RabbiMordecaiGriffin]

Yeah not so much.

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

When John the Baptist sends disciples to ask Jesus if he is the Messiah he says "tell John what you see and hear- the blind recieve their sight." There is nothing more opposite of restoring sight to the blind than blinding someone who can see. I've never heard of being blinded as being a miracle until Paul came around...

[@danielmdennis]

“Author of and true interpreter of the Scriptures.” Hmmm… Sounds like Paul’s your Messiah.

[@maggief1095]

Wonderful job as always. Praised be the Lord for his mercy. May the Lord bless you, your staff, your ministry, and your families.

[@magicLA1980]

So happy to see you guys back!!! I hope everything got resolved with the fires and everyone at 1FI are okay. Love you all and God bless. I’ve missed your Pod for Israel vids a lot 💙 🇮🇱

[@gnd884]

Thank you so much. It warms my heart to see your excitement and almost childlike joy when you find another truth❤. Greetings from a saved gentile in Germany

[@Mairiain]

As a Gentile follower of Yeshua, thank you from the bottom of my heart for posting these videos, my dear brothers. I am so grateful to God to learn these things and thankful for your faithfulness to Him.

[@phineas8532]

There is no more jew or gentile. Only Christian or non Christian

[@sialohootnielsembiring292]

Thankyou so much brothers. You make me cried. So greatfull for paul's statement, its from God by holy spirit. Love israel 🇮🇱 from indonesia🇲🇨

[@johansen2bfree]

Shaalu Shalom Yerushalaim! Thank you my Jewish brothers for a brilliant exposition of the Scriptures. You never disappoint!

[@KobieVanheerden-no4ul]

Amen!!! Thank you so much for making the Bible more understandable😊for us gentiles. I love to listen to you on 'One for Israel' - thank you Jesus🙏

[@KalliBella1]

Wow! What a wonderful and beautiful and biblical explanation of the passage. Thank you! Many blessings to you.

[@DouglasIRL]

This was so good , it’s great to see how deep and how truly educated Paul was.

[@nunyabeeswax9463]

The more I learn from people who know the old testament the clearer the New Testament becomes. Thank you for the education

[@andyguillory7810]

Thank you again our brothers in Yeshua Hah Mashiach, for bringing another great lesson. Blessings and Shalom.

[@7Barukh]

Wow. Never heard it explained so plainly, and it matches Bible AND history. Baruch HaShem. Thank you Brothers.

[@blackeyedturtle]

Thank you for producing and posting this. Context is everything when it comes to understanding scripture. The damage one can do (like John Calvin) when they do not understand the context.

[@mafasami7593]

Praise God for both You and your Ministry ❤and prayers from a Christian 🇼🇸 and NZ.

[@dawnchristine1344]

Very enlightening. Always blessed by your videos.

[@stumpy31952]

Father of Mercy and Lovingkindness

[@miriamvered6321]

My awesome online Jewish bible teachers, Dr. Seth Postell and Dr. Erez Soref!!! Case successfully delivered and approved! :)

[@savedwretch8711]

I love you guys and I pray our heavenly Father bless you and your ministry😁👍

[@marilyngilley5565]

What a great episode. So blessed to study and learn from you. Thank you so much! God Bless…

[@blessedinchristjesus7106]

Thank you Lord Jesus. I feel so blessed and overjoyed for opening my eyes about the truth... Once a lost sheep, now found. Thank you God ❤ God bless your ministry.

[@dennisburdick682]

Our LORD has been a master at subverting expectations. In my walk with the Holy Spirit, I've discovered it is best to let go of self. Embrace our LORD and trust HIM.

[@Texasstyle66]

I asked the Creator to open my eyes. Spiritually so that I may see what I was not looking at. And then it popped up on my screen. And I want to dive deeper into it enable to learn more. Thank you for this podcast my eyes are slowly coming open.❤

[@julietabraham476]

God bless you brethren for this awesome livestream.

[@davidstuchly9792]

Thanks for sending me a calendar I was touched to receive it from y'all. Thank you guys 😊 it's beautiful

[@grouchomarxx2217]

It always touches my heart to see how you love Jesus and cherish Moses💝💝💝💝💝

[@jewelssylva3738]

I can't believe that I followed your conclusions. Much more indepth study than I expected. TY

[@ceddebruxelles]

God bless you ❤️‍🔥It gave me chills! But it also made very sad for the Jews who kept themselves away from the God of their Fathers for so long 😢

[@darylhoyt5012]

Sound scholarship. Thank you brothers!

[@rebeccawright2038]

Love these teaching sessions!

[@taylorwhite7522]

If I could somehow display a standing ovation, I would. This was a fantastic job guys. Overcoming one more point on anti-Pauline rhetoric. Great job!

[@timcoil6224]

Our father brought us in to love and rejoice over the Messiah's grace, acceptance and forgiveness all while provoking our brothers, the Jews to jealousy over the cornerstone they rejected. Hallelujah thank you my Lord.

[@martinacassidy2438]

Thank you for digging out these wonderful truths

[@baibaandersson9454]

Glory be to God Almighty for your work. So important your comments Dr Soref. Your comments brother Soref touch very deeply in heard. Glory be to God Almighty only for this canal.

[@robertbennett5929]

We love you guys.Greetings from Atlanta, GA. We pray and support you.

[@Lottieloves287]

I love these so much 🙏🏼 please keep them coming! I feel I learn a ton!

[@zoomfin]

A wonderful short study. Much appreciated.

[@pablososa9444]

I have been following your interpretations for some time now and i am glad to say that what never ceases to amaze me is the coherence of the bible as a whole. The deeper you go into the old testament, the clearer the new testament becomes. Thank you for that

[@voymasa7980]

Years ago I was having friendly discussions with a couple Jewish men and one of them said his normal response to the new covenant was citing from Jeremiah 31:31-34. While looking into that, there was the obvious ordering of events in Acts that is was at first to Judah and Israel at Jerusalem, but was expanded to the Gentiles. I discovered these two sections in Romans 9 and 11, and their link to Hosea and Deuteronomy, back then. It was amazing

[@Corinna_Schuett_GER]

Question: were these Jewish men believers in Christ then? Because since Acts 17 ALL men are commanded to believe, this is a COMMAND since 2,000 years, also to them obviously. Acts 17:30-31: "And the times of this ignorance God winked at; BUT NOW commandeth ALL MEN every where to repent: Because he hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained; whereof he hath given assurance UNTO ALL MEN, in that he hath raised him from the dead."

[@voymasa7980]

@@Corinna_Schuett_GER no. It was a defensive response against Christian views.

[@angelasoderstrom3736]

Love these teaching sessions be blessed

[@samuelsuisso4887]

Amazing! God Bless you guys.

[@SteveFirefly777]

Lovely teaching. Thank you very much!

[@lgrantnelson2863]

I think that a Pharisee's Pharisee who had a personal encounter with Jesus would give a proper interpretation. Thanks for the insight.

[@charliechambers9074]

Loved the discussion. Thank you ✝️

[@alvinvaughn6531]

This was awesome! Thank you

[@jannaiw2773]

So good! Thank you, gentlemen!

[@TheMannangel]

Just found this site and wow thanks, I’m trying to get to Isreal next year for a holy tour. Suzi 😊Melbourne Australia

[@titicoqui]

always learning from these videos

[@Scot7t7t7]

Thank you so much for all you do

[@lorrainehuff2703]

Love this. Thank you

[@L_Jan_Turner]

Terrific. Thank you for making the Bible more clear. God bless all of you who are getting out His Wird.

[@lidahill6401]

Thank you dears brothers! (Shalom from Maranatha Chapel San Diego CA)

[@Mark4Jesus]

I really enjoy these episodes with Dr Seth sharing his studies, thank you so much. It's refreshing to find someone with this much authentic research and breadth of coverage. I wonder if y'all could do a video about Jesus' genealogies. Thanks!!!

[@bennettjudi1]

I love these explanations in detail. I always learn something.

[@raptorm1789]

Very very enriching discourse. KZbin has alot of teaching and ministry and I had started to follow some America Jewish minister but soon started to notice the criticism about Paul on that platform was literally troubling and baseless. Anyway, thanks for bringing out the Talmud verses and exposing the pollution in it in comparison to the NT. Ecc 4:11-12.

[@graceantonio3573]

THANK YOU, GOD BLESS YOU!

[@deshardiman8808]

You guys are amazing, God bless you all ❤

[@PUSH2Tim]

I love you guys!!! Can’t wait to be with you in our Father’s house!!!

[@Sidharth.Pratap]

I'm so blessed with all your videos ❤️

[@revam360]

Wonderful teaching!

[@helenalexander1215]

Thank you. This is an excellent teaching.

[@petereriksson7166]

The best on youtube is one for Israel.

[@davidlerner6911]

God used my non Jewish Christian wife and One For Israel to bring me to Messiah. Thank God for them.

[@graceantonio3573]

OH DEAR SIR, YOUR WORDS "HE'S GONNA DEFEAT OUR STUBBORNNESS" IS GOOD TO HEAR, GLORY ALELUAH! BRINGS TEARS TO MY EYES. HOPE FOR HUMANITY! NOT JUS FOR THE LAND OF ISRAEL, THE MIDDLE EAST, BUT ALL HUMANITY.

[@Skookman]

Praying for Israel.

[@brisnwinters8161]

No matter how great the sinof Israel or the Church God's grace is greater.

[@aleyammajohn9809]

Amen.God bless you 🙏

[@shanehepburn2528]

Great insight,God bless

[@abedejong6799]

God's FAITHFULNESS lasts FOREVER, halleluja

[@akhash9659]

Israel is the original olive!. We gentiles are the wild olives who rejected god before but through Christ blood, we are grafted in the original olives.

[@KingDavid1979]

Christian change the word Alma mean young women/ out of the context of being virgin before get married to a child born without a man 🤨 and misunderstood the negative printed into the shroud of Turin as the sign ! The New Testament begin with such a misconception 🧐; Jesus came from David but Mary was virgin?! Jame Tabor, Ken Johnson talk about Yeshuah Ben Yossef family ( children) Ezekiel 37-19 Jame explain Esdras 12-10 ( Daniel dream was not interpreted as Ezra ( Esdras) Esdras 31-32 talk about ( offspring of David) never mentioned Jesus ( saying David not Jesus by the prophets) resurrection and virgin doctrine is a simple deception! Like Jesus return from a cloud ☁️ with aerodynamic wing across our firmament 🤨 we didn’t ear recently about an another magic virgin birth!

[@putragabriel2716]

Amen, haleluyah.

[@albusai]

​@@KingDavid1979Mary was descendant of David. And the promise to Eve was fullfiled

[@lolliabs]

Not grafted into Isreal but into Christ, as not seeds but seed. Through the promise, the Spirit. No replacement theology...

[@DanNaim400]

@@KingDavid1979lol if you understood the Hebraic lineage then ul realize that the line of Yehudah all children will be considered as Sons..Mary came from the tribe of Yehudah..Same as Yoseph..Yeshua will automatic fit in the line of Yehudah since her earthly mother was from Yehudah and also through his adoption father Yoseph..plus the word Almah (עלמה) can be used also to a young virgin ..so ur point is baseless

[@mike4769]

I love this ministry. God has put a love for his people on my heart. The time of the gentiles is over and the return to his people is soon. As a gentile I'm happy to see that he's gathering his people like he always wanted to do since he walked the earth 2000 years ago. Without God's chosen people we wouldn't had a savior or the saints from the old testament

[@baibaandersson9454]

Glory be to God Almighty only Living God Lord Jesus Christ and Holy SPIRIT.ALL Scriptures is inspire from Holy spirit. Paul was farizey from farizey,deeply knowing Scriptures. Blessed be you brother's, for your deeply presses work. So beautiful and amazing and important. I have so much from Lord God Almighty to think about. God bless you brothers. So beautiful be together in Christ, our Lord and Saviour.

[@ddzl6209]

Fantastic discourse thanks

[@emanuel_deusconosco4856]

Maravilhoso, estou emocionado 🙏👏

[@Mo-bc8nm]

May God bless you and continue to give you such wisdom! This last year the Holy Spirit has made it clear to my heart that He is seeking to restore the Jewish people who still reject Jesus to Himself. I feel it in my spirit that He is fervently seeking them. I am a gentile myself, and it has brought me to tears listening to this teaching and hearing that He has said that my faithfulness and belief will help for more of His people to be restored unto Him. This is my deepest desire, that He would receive that which is His ❤️❤️I pray that God’s will shall be done and all of His people will come to Him ❤

[@melindakoehler5647]

Excellent bible study! Thank you

[@heidihager7288]

Love the Case for Messiah series! Thank you One for Israel!

[@larryg7109]

I have no doubt that Paul knew the Hebrew interpretation as well as anyone in his day.

[@baibaandersson9454]

God is so Amazing. I love so much your comments brother

[@jazzmaan707]

Excellent explanation and analysis of Hosea 2.

[@mattaikay925]

May Adonai bless and keep you - By the by, From Qumran - 23 I will sow her to me in the earth; and I will have mercy on her who had not obtained mercy; and I will tell those who were not my people, ‘You are my people;’and they will say, ‘My God!’ ”

[@divyaa155]

I vaguely remember having this question about Hosea too, even though I am a gentile believer from India. Because I had read Hosea too. Then recently I found this text in Isaiah 19:25 - "The Lord Almighty will bless them, saying, “Blessed be Egypt my people, Assyria my handiwork, and Israel my inheritance.”" So I thought maybe the reference to "my people" is sometimes more universal than Israel only.

[@TSSouza85]

Very good. 👏👏

[@6870boardman]

Thank you

[@stumpy31952]

He will circumcise our hearts....

[@finalaccuracy7695]

Just watched this. God has a huge sense of humor. I just read Hosea and the Song of Moses today. I knew the passages were related but I forgot about Romans.😂

[@borneandayak6725]

Christian from Malaysia. Yeshua bless us all ❤❤❤

[@stumpy31952]

Hallelujah! Thanks Hosea....!

[@livingwell5892]

This was eye opening. Thank you ♥

[@olgaortiz4693]

Beautiful

[@elizabethiloveelohim137]

The old testament and new testify to each other. All Israel will be saved, 12 tribes who put our trust in Yehoshua Ha Meshiach. No longer Jew or gentile, male or female, free or slave, all are one in Yehoshua Ha Meshiach.

[@b_uppy]

Absolutely. It is only our understanding that may be flawed.

[@rockytopbritt]

Amen

[@UnTotal1-Requess]

Please…PLEASE go deeper into the teachings of Paul and his use of the OT. I have heard so many claims of Paul misusing or misinterpreting the quotes he uses and the OT as a whole. So many claims that he is a liar or a fool and I don’t know what to believe anymore. 😢

[@davidjohnweaver126]

Zechariah is being fulfilled today! AMEN

[@gabrielacastillo2423]

All it takes is a careful reading of the scriptures. Thank you for guiding us. 🙏🏻

[@nathanhine286]

The Spirit of God helps us in our weakness, (our understanding)

[@chrismoyler]

I am so grateful for the faithfil ministry of One for Israel. It is the no 1 ministry within the land of Israel that I support, because it is Jews speaking truth to Jews, in their own language. And.....as a blessed by product of this outreach, we Gentiles get to hear this wisdom in English! Thank you and God bless you dear One for Israel. May He not only bless you, may He greatly increase you. Chris. UK