Our First Time Playing Five Nights at Freddy's 4

This is fricking scary my guys
SUBSCRIBE: smo.sh/Sub2Smo...
WEAR OUR JOKES: smosh.com
WHO YOU SEE
Shayne Topp // / shaynetopp
Amanda Lehan-Canto // / filmingamanda
WHO YOU DON’T SEE (usually)
Director: Spencer Agnew
Editor: Rock Coleman
Director of Programming, Smosh Games: Spencer Agnew
Producer, Smosh Games: Alex Tran
Assistant Director: Zoe Moacanin
Art Director: Cassie Vance
Assistant Art Director: Erin Kuschner
Art Coordinator: Alex Aguilar, Josie Bellerby
Audio Mixer: Scott Neff
Audio Utility: Dina Ramli
Camera Operator: Jon Wong
Director of Photography: Eric Wann
Director of Design: Brittany Hobbs
DIT/Lead AE: Matt Duran
DIT/AE: Levi Villalpando
CEO: Alé Catenese
EVP of Production: Zoe Moacanin
EVP of Programming: Kiana Parker
Executive Coordinator: Rachel Collis
IT: Tim Baker
Operations PA: Katie Fink
Post Production Manager: Luke Baker
Production Manager: Amanda Barnes
Production Coordinator: Marcus Munguia
Operations & Production Coordinator: Oliver Wehlander
Production Assistant: Ovsana Tsaturian
Senior Manager, Channel & Strategy: Lizzy Jones
Social Creative Producer: Peter Ditzler, Tommy Bowe
Social Strategist: Erica Noboa, Mallory Myers
Editorial Coordinator: Kim Wilborn
Talent Coordinator: Selina Garcia
NEW SMOSH VIDEOS:
Watch Something Is Wrong With This Junk Food...: • Something Is Wrong Wit...
Watch The Tell All Episode | Smosh Mouth 40: • The Tell All Episode |...
OTHER SMOSHES:
Smosh: smo.sh/Sub2Smosh
Smosh Pit: smo.sh/Sub2Smo...
El Smosh (Spanish Dub): smo.sh/Sub2ElS...
SmoshCast: smo.sh/Sub2Smo...
FOLLOW US:
TikTok: smo.sh/TikTok
Snapchat: smo.sh/OnSnapchat
Instagram: / smosh
Facebook: / smosh

[@GennyEffler]

Amanda getting legitimately good at this game is the BEST possible outcome of this whole series

[@furygeist]

I need her to start being introduced to more scary games. Maybe do backrooms style games, Amnesia, Slenderman, phasmophonia would be absolutely hysterical.

[@day9811]

@@furygeisti second this!

[@versaii5519]

It’s genuinely very impressive

[@z_stuartoliver]

SERIOUSLY THE NON-GAMERS (ANGELA & AMANDA) ARE BECOMING PRO PLAYERS OF SMOSH GAMES AND IM LOVING IT

[@naomistading8673]

@@furygeist Bro the smosh crew playing phasmophonia would make my DAY

[@krisskrosssss]

I don’t know what I’m more shocked by. Ian and Anthony coming back, Shayne and Courtney dating and now married, or the fact that Amanda is actually about to finish the entire FNAF game series before I do.

[@samanthanicklin8130]

Okay the Shayne and Courtney getting married has got to be a new joke 😂 Which episode/channel did it start on? Or is it kind of an evolution of people always mistaking them for dating over the years?

[@aubreydierking]

it's not a joke :))@@samanthanicklin8130

[@tossthekj3839]

​@@samanthanicklin8130 they are actually married, wedding and proposal pictures and all. They have been keeping there relationship away from social media and just recently decided to go public with it

[@yuyunited]

@@samanthanicklin8130 iirc courtney actually confirmed it

[@superswagmimi4237]

@@samanthanicklin8130 No they posted pics from their wedding on April 1st so fans didn't know if it was a bit or not😭 Then Court posted more pics the next day with the caption "Happy April 2nd" and did an interview with People Magazine. It's real, they got married March 29th.

[@JStrangerDanger]

Chanse and Angela look strange today.

[@matthewbeard8860]

Underrated comment

[@Trabs_indmind]

Amanda almost looks like she just came from a wedding or somthin 🤨

[@JAXXNCREATED]

iykyk

[@Venomonomonom]

Can't believe Angela married Chance

[@maem7462]

It would also be really fun to see them play FNAF or some other horror game

[@miscchant9076]

“Alex and Spencer got us to night five” AND YOU DIDNT SHOW US??? I WOULD LOVE TO SEE THOSE TWO PLAY A NIGHT

[@andresrojas1589]

I bet they used the C D and + trick for the PC versions of fnaf

[@libsybum3591]

They used cheats to get to night five

[@zack-pn6oe]

@@andresrojas1589 Lol ive been following FNAF since 2016 and how did i not know this

[@jennifermatthews8691]

I feel Amanda has gotten braver over this series while Shane has plunged deeper into a put of despair and terror

[@Rebesag]

Trueeee😂

[@hrvbox]

He said he plays it up for the camera but yes haha

[@P0rk_Sinigang]

It honestly tracks with how Amanda described her upbringing and the way that her mom would push her to confront things that make her uneasy. Meanwhile, Shayne just really doesn't like horror games lol

[@ST-kb1xc]

This is Shayne's true horror, in the previous games he had watched run through and stuff so had that to boost his confidence, this time around he was going in blind...

[@lifeisstrangerthingsfr]

@@hrvboxwhen did he say that

[@grimacet3321]

Another classic by Courtney’s Husband from iCarly

[@milkymoo1525]

another banger by shayne topp from courtney’s wedding

[@truestbluu]

oh shoot they're actually married? i thought it was a joke 😭@@milkymoo1525

[@gooeygaster30]

HAHAHAHHA

[@pichaelhunt5449]

Dear god I hope we get an update of the cat meme about the wedding for who memed it, and it’s treated like the two types of gays meme where all four choices are Trevor. This is now just a homework assignment for Trevor, I want this on my desk by Friday

[@Venomonomonom]

The punk dude from The Goldbergs married the Vine chick?

[@jillianwilber237]

Obsessed with the fact that Shayne and Court ended up on PEOPLE. Amanda must be absolutely thrilled.

[@wolffisu]

She probably had NO IDEA until she read that article 🤣

[@slartibartfast7861]

I BET it was done deliberately, this is genius!

[@Alleyhellcat4Ever]

I didn't even know that it was on PEOPLE magazine! 👀

[@jillianwilber237]

@@Alleyhellcat4Ever I happened upon it earlier!!! Courtney did an interview!

[@Alleyhellcat4Ever]

@@jillianwilber237 I just read it! It made me so happy for them 😍

[@J4Cinema]

Their confusion at the cupcake was hilarious. The sequel to “is Chica a baby or a woman”; “Why was that thing hot pink and where did it come from?”

[@paqap]

I never played these, where did the cupcake come from? What could they have done to prevent it?

[@ShadowReaper695]

​@@paqap if you check for eg behind you and let's say chica was at the door chica will send her cupcake to kill you ( to prevent this you have to go at the door to close it and then she will be gone from the door and you can go back to checking other thing )

[@enixma820]

@@paqapIt’s just chica’s jumpscare if she gets in when you’re not at her door.

[@queeenie]

like game wise did she always have it? i don’t remember the fnaf1 video that well but i think it wasn’t there? i could be totally wrong though its been a while

[@awesumtoast97]

​@@queeenie i think it became a thing in fnaf 2

[@asuwannabe2015]

I love the way Shayne closes his eyes when they get jumpscared but amanda's eyes open as WIDE AS POSSIBLE before she screams AFTER the character is gone

[@PatrickGreen3512]

Thousand Yard Stare.

[@Emily-tv1iz]

Ironically it's the best survival instinct. Don't stop looking at the scary thing and do not get its attention

[@g-mon3y593]

Dude, I still can’t believe that Freddy Fazbear and Matpat got married

[@jesssam7384]

wait. Freddy Fazbear and Markipiler broke up???

[@maem7462]

Such an obvious couple we should’ve seen it coming the whole time

[@L33W1NT3R5]

It was probably a shotgun wedding

[@L33W1NT3R5]

The really had to bite the bullet

[@annikabakkumekern]

Gosh I love the comment section today

[@Cynoate]

Just two married people playing FNAF

[@rxplyzx]

i love this comment

[@Idk_My_Name]

Not by the time they recording i think

[@exnmr]

THIS IS SO GOOD LMFAO

[@lemon_hd]

the way i thought you meant shayne and amanda were married to each other😭😭

[@mae_ljn]

More like two married people being scared

[@jabbrwok]

i want amanda and shayne playing horror games to be a permanent addition to smosh games. their life spans may get shortened but so is the cost of art

[@KhoiV]

NOT THEIR LIFE SPANS 😭😭

[@ElsieMJoseph]

😂😂😂

[@MarleyGompel]

hearing Shayne say "You know the first night is pretty chill" gives me flashbacks to "You know the first night is never really that hard"

[@realtehen]

yess omg

[@SophieGrayTV]

*insert chica jumpscare*

[@IcyCubey]

"Okay, so the first night is never usually that in any of the games, so-"

[@YourWARD]

"The first night is usally not bad in any of the games so I'll just play through the-"

[@ParzivalTheThird]

Everyone misquoting, it’s: “Okay so the first night is never usually that bad in any of the games so I’ll play thro-“

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

I can’t wait for Amanda to meet the recently retired MatPat

[@faeri_]

Hi bestie!

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

@@faeri_ hiiii!

[@ninjaltofficial]

Imagine he comes as a guest on Smosh Mouth

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

@@ninjaltofficial omg yes

[@zuzzzied]

​@@ninjaltofficial or flashback

[@PurpleBiscuit]

"We're literally trapped in a room, this is actually a nightmare" Amanda cracking the lore

[@AleGuerrero94]

😂

[@Mukiukiuki]

Fr

[@RaisinBrandon3]

I really find it funny when something scares you, you are either Amanda who keeps her eyes WIDE OPEN or Shayne who blocks the scene with his hands and shuts his eyes.

[@tyraoqvist350]

the definition of fight or flight lol

[@OCS_Studios]

WE NEED AMANDA DRESSED UP AS SARAH CHRIST BREAKING DOWN AND EXPLAINING FNAF LORE!!!

[@W1es]

THIS IS A LEGIT DEMAND AT THIS POINT

[@dulce9797]

YESSSSS

[@freckledginger]

shut up that would be SO GOOD

[@wonderpotter2674]

Ooo yes

[@ivemcfallen3416]

@@freckledgingermy vision just went black after I read ‘shut up’ and was like “that’s so rude😂😭

[@meghannicole1474]

41:00 When the work wife and the actual wife join forces to support their husband.

[@lionofdemise]

You I like you

[@vaderwalks]

And to think, Courtney was once the Work Wife.

[@coralievandongen9503]

Courtney is the literal work wife now ..

[@norapallen984]

I still don’t believe it

[@JCBug555]

I didn't either. I think the Damien confirmation was what I needed to believe it. I don't think Damien would troll like Ian.​@@norapallen984

[@emilecaron6976]

Have Shayne and Amanda play "Papers, Please" I would love to see their chaotic energy trying to make sense of everything!

[@alisaishere]

I didn't know I needed this, but now that mention it, yes! They would be great at "Papers, Please"

[@mythicalmim]

Yes!! I love that game, they’re personalities are great for it

[@reginaldpatrickflores4820]

Yes please!

[@Sofia-wh9jr]

Agree, hope they see this!!

[@dimak1561]

+++

[@PXLVI]

Amanda barking orders at Shayne out of sheer stress followed by the flattest "well done" is freaking hilarious. But it's hard to argue with her when she legitimately has a knack for these games. Amanda's "DOOR!" and "WE'RE OUTTA HERE!" at 36:56 had me in stitches 😂

[@and.desist2171]

Her stress-yelling reminded me of learning to drive with my parents

[@yoniH2001]

Hello even tho this comment is unlikely to be seen or noticed im still gonna leave it here as a response to shayne asking for a proper guide and just incase anyone else is interested in this information Bonnie/Chica: You two pretty much got the hang of it . You approche the door listen for like 4/5 seconds the breathing is gonna be very clear . If they breath u close the door for like 5 seconds and then open and flash. If they are not there simply flash. It is importent to note that closing the door while they are not there instead of flashing is actually REALLY BAD it could accelerate them to your door and in later nights doing that is pretty much a death sentence so make sure that what u are hearing is breathing and not some random stepping or backround noises. Freddy: Overtime freddy will summon his little freddles on the bed (3 max). If they are left there for too long u die. All u need to do is remember to check on them every so often and flash them untill they all go away. Foxy: Foxy can be a little tricky at times but pretty managable. He starts of as a little plush in the closet but the more time u leave him there the more he will get closer to the closet door (first standing then crouching then full face then jumpscare). Whenever u check on foxy if he is a plushy ,great u can go check on other things , if he is in any of his other states u should close the door pretty much the same way u guys did with chica and bonnie for like 5-7 seconds depending on how close he is to the door. If u continuasly open and close the door the same way u guys did in your attempts its gonna take forever to get him back to his plushy state. And last nightmare Fredbear/night 5: His mechanic is quite diffrent from the others and it took me a while to get it tbh. You are gonna wanna stand in the center of the room and listen fredbear will run from the left hallway to the right hallway continuasly untill eventually stops at that point u gotta run to the side that he stoped on when u get to it DO NOT FLASH simply shut the door. When u hear him starting to run again go back to the center of the room and rinse and repeat. If fredbear laughs at any point there is a chance he is either behind u on the bed or in the closet. If u hear him stepping even after the laugh it means that he is gonna be in one of the halls same as always. if the footsteps stop after the laugh he is likely either on the bed or in the closet. If he is in the closet shut the door untill u hear running again. if he is behind u on the bed flash him and he will disapear and continue his left to right running. And thats pretty much it. just in case anyone out there was curious how things worked and in the case of u guys trying it again i hope i was of use and could answer some quastions :) Keep up the awesome work u guys have always been doing and thanks for the awesome video!

[@ericataylor7618]

I hope they read this.

[@silver6071]

Interacting to boost this

[@darkymakenzy]

Hope this gets more likes & gets bumped up

[@dalayneejo]

even if they never see this, i did! you’re awesome for this

[@grey_tracer5283]

Interacting to boost this gem!

[@missaprilfool120]

Amanda: "Night 1 in cursive?! Oh we're fcked" I dunno why I find it funny 😂

[@Panda-eu1zd]

Literally was looking for a comment about it 😂

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

Such a nonsense thing that also made total sense to me, haha

[@EpicRandomness555]

When a horror game has cursive you’re screwed lol

[@Hi-lu5vf]

it's like the baby vs. a woman thing

[@furygeist]

Well considering most of the fonts were reminiscent of DOS and suddenly you get this fancy lil cursive font..it's like it's m9cking you and letting you know in the most sacchrine sweet way that you are about to have a bad time.

[@clartblart3266]

They sound like they're doing a surgery lol Amanda just going "light" "shut" "good job" it's like she's an experienced surgeon training a newbie

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

Oooh, good point! Their teamwork was great and this is exactly the dynamic!

[@toadfukawa5947]

can u imagine them doing surgeon simulator 😭

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

@@toadfukawa5947 Ok but that could be amazing! Or any other co-op games!

[@PheebsTheLu]

@@toadfukawa5947That’d be awesome omgggg 😭😭

[@neo_nathan]

@@toadfukawa5947 THEY NEED TO PLAY SURGEON SIMULATOR

[@st.lucient4755]

39:29 Amanda and Shayne with the "tired cop duo who've been 'round this part for yeaaars" energy LOL

[@DaveYognaut]

I didn't realise how *_in_* the game and jadad they were until 40:04 and 40:22 when Amanda said "you can still react, it's okay" lol

[@sourpatchstarkids]

“I think people are way scarier than evil entities” - Amanda Lehan-Canto (2024)

[@bunnyellabell]

me with social anxiety

[@sweetmother2406]

Thank you for quoting her on that 😉

[@PhilVaive]

lol yuh, this week the stalker shippers proved it lol

[@MemesAreFriendsNotFood]

She’s so real for that

[@highdefinition450]

wasn't this last year in a reddit video lol

[@rae5602]

I love Amanda vocalising "wasd" like it was relating to the characters crying

[@camaire]

i immediately thought of dan and phil naming characters Wasd lmao (pronounced Wazz-d)

[@alisaishere]

She does it every time and it always makes me giggle. I want to hear her explanation of what, or who, she thinks WASD is.

[@zamalamahama4894]

Clearly the reason Scott never gave us the child’s canonical name is because it’s Wasd

[@rae5602]

when are we getting Amanda's lore breakdown, evidence board with red thread and everything????

[@Unknown22885]

I’m just imagining the “ITS THE NUMBERS” guy

[@Soon2BGhost]

OMG seeing Amanda’s interpretation of the lore would be amazing 😂😂 I need a red string episode where Spencer and Shayne are just watching the madness

[@panic5343]

I need to see her Charlie Day red string plot board moment

[@anitajankowski1580]

okay but it's kinda wild how she's ACTUALLY picked up on some of the lore ?!

[@rae5602]

@@panic5343 yes!!

[@Jabersson]

5:06 - "Maybe the first night is chill like that." You could almost say....... .................... that the first night is never usually that bad in any of the games, so they'll play throu-

[@notjelo]

shayne and spencer tricking amanda on smosh mouth leading to smosh games having a series of amanda and shayne playing fnaf is such a good sequence of events

[@m00nrac00n]

The good timeline. Amanda's openness to experience and natural curiosity is great.

[@mosquitopyjamas9048]

That was a great moment... I really wished he'd let her look up Matthew Patrick's true crime theory videos before telling her the truth.

[@jenjenjenxxvii]

that's sum butterfly effect right there

[@versaii5519]

I agree fully it’s so organic

[@nicole-xx8xi]

and what makes it better is amanda carrying and shayne progressively regretting it more and more

[@gintokisakata69]

A series of just Amanda and Shayne playing horror games would be sick. I can already see Amanda trying to figure out the plot for it while Shayne is terrified of what's to come.

[@jd7507]

They should play RE7 and Village

[@ky_piece]

i badly need her to play re2 & village & also tlou 1&2

[@_Tozzie_]

The Final Girl & The First Guy Who Dies duo

[@danielalicea5960]

RE7 or Outlast would be awesome

[@MaryanneDSouza-n3q]

Fears to Fathom would be amazing to watch them play

[@Shredderrr]

Here's a pitch: real life FNAF with Shayne and Amanda at Smosh office. Have rules similar to the game and have other members dressup and try to scare them and grab them (but if flashed with a flashlight, they must hide again, etc.)

[@Dani_marie_]

Ur a genius

[@6022]

It's an excellent idea, but which cast member would best play each of the characters?

[@eternallustformedusa4844]

@@6022courtney would slay as chica

[@puppa1998]

We need Peter as that child who just comes into your room and just stands there

[@PrincessBird]

@@puppa1998 Balloon Boy? 😂

[@nikkorocksalot5254]

I'm sure someone else has said it, but Amanda's horror scream is absolutely perfect for a horror movie

[@z_stuartoliver]

34:05 is where we witness Shayne regretting to lie to Amanda which ultimately led to the gameplay of FNAF which now traumatizes Shayne himself every episode

[@sorekcazimi]

Just like with Eat It or Yeet It, Shayne created his own nightmare 😆

[@dotapark]

The way he creates his own nightmare and jokes for himself, it’s impressive 😁

[@nachofast6144]

I NEED Amanda and Shayne to play Phasmophobia together

[@_Ducky_]

Shayne would leave the van haha

[@toriwong8363]

Yeeeessss

[@LusterDust]

Oh god I could only imagine, she's been clueless as to what "WASD" is for multiple games now

[@benfletcher8100]

But make sure they’re in separate rooms so they have to use the proximity chat

[@jacegarcia3255]

I genuinely believe that this game is the scariest in all of the franchise. No call, no sounds, no anything. Just your ability to hear something and a prayer!

[@hatstephla1769]

I agree. There’s nothing else to focus on and kind of keep you calm. It’s very effective horror and I praise Scott cathown for him making such a good game, and franchise.

[@coolboss999]

You are absolutely correct. This is the peak horror of the FNAF series.

[@alexg1693]

although the nightmare designs are scarier

[@oscarm4095]

Being a child and moving around to access mechanics up the horror tenfold too

[@jacegarcia3255]

@@oscarm4095 Yes! Also just the thought of you having to ACTIVELY run towards the unknown unlike the other 3 where you can just standby and be in a chair. This game makes you think about your actions carefully.

[@veethorn]

for night 5, all you need to know is to only move when you dont hear any more footsteps (just wait till he stops somewhere), dont keep the door closed for a long time, and his laugh indicates he's either in the closet or the bed, unless he laughs and then walks somewhere, then he's not in the room

[@milhamalfarisi4112]

He can be in the closet or bed that seems impossible what do you do if hes in the room with us

[@veethorn]

@@milhamalfarisi4112 same mechanic for everything else. bed - flash him, closet - close the door

[@coviegray4409]

5:09 “maybe the first night is chill like that” markiplier flashbacks omg

[@caralenalindberg6098]

I’m so happy everyone picked up on that too lmao

[@HelpImStuckInaWell]

I was thinking the same thing lmaoo

[@catalina5175]

Yeeees and while playing the same game too😭😭

[@lyss010387]

His chair jump when his headphones fell off, was the thing that popped up in my mind 😂

[@hexacomb4946]

We were all thinking it

[@agrv1999]

43:06 the contrast between courtney giving shayne support and amanda saying “spencer you ARE a jumpscare babe” lmaao

[@hellobubble]

My fav thing about thing about this video is Amanda just stumbles into accurate lore. She makes an off-handed comment and it's like "well... Yes!"

[@furygeist]

I need her to do a Smosh Mouth episode with MatPat as a guest after she and Shayne finish the games. I need her to find out how much she guessed right.

[@heavenekvods]

When she knew the photos on the wall in the hallway were scott cawthons family photos 0-0

[@Jagger-Tyr_13]

That really just means it's not that complicated, and even someone who never games can figure it out. Still fun to watch though.

[@aaroncho4922]

I wonder how shayne feels everytime he gets told that the like record he set to get to next game has been beat in the first 24hs 💀

[@anitajankowski1580]

21:10 - Shayne using the force was actually NUTS 😂

[@konstelacjabzu9926]

some would say.. Impressive

[@Idk_My_Name]

@@konstelacjabzu9926 brutal...

[@fpcooper95]

The Chosen possessed Shayne once again for that moment without his conscious bidding

[@emilycochran4944]

Amanda and Shayne: beat the first night on the first try Markiplier: "So the first night is never usually that ba-- AEEGGGH"

[@sunsetlilypad]

15:05 "I hear footprints, I hear footprints!" has to be my FAVORITE quote from Amanda! 😂

[@Saebub]

LMAOO I didn’t even notice

[@Amo_is_loco]

36:09 is so funny 😂 Shayne’s Rant about the cupcake cracks me up! “Sorry I forgot to look on the ceiling!!” 🤣

[@headlessteddi6207]

Sorry to bother you but what was that cupcake and where did it come from?

[@Amo_is_loco]

@@headlessteddi6207 tbh I honestly have no idea but I just thought his rant about it was funny

[@headlessteddi6207]

@@Amo_is_loco Ahhh okay. I am currently re-watching all the FNAF content, and your comment made me question that cupcake thing. Thanks for answering so fast)

[@pony6630]

​@@headlessteddi6207 if you are still wondering, its chica's cupcake! I think thats just the jumpscare animation for when she is in the room

[@headlessteddi6207]

@@pony6630 I was still wondering haha. Thank you)

[@franciscoreyes1039]

5:48 * Shayne visibly uncomfortable * Amanda: "you're getting too comfortable Shayne" 😂😂😂

[@The_Asexual_Gamer666]

*AAAWWWUUUUUUUGGGGGHHH*

[@Jacob-eq4ld]

so cute that courtney helped her husband and her mother-in-law play!

[@SufferingGradStudent]

Amanda calling Shayne babe out of pure anxiety is too good

[@Bluluvver]

That’s literally me💀 I literally call everyone babe it’s starting to become a problem😭

[@quiz5954]

My favourite part is 35:24, when they hear Chica and just wordlessly close the door while exchanging knowing looks

[@rachelhesketh94]

41:00 I love how Courtney looks like they're having a jolly good time getting a lil' scared meanwhile Shayne and Amanda are *stressed*

[@n1c2c8]

Just a wife supporting her husband during some spooky times

[@moonriverinc7896]

Shayne and Amanda acting like seasoned war veterans 💀😭

[@rhettmitchell]

That’s Courtney the lore connoisseur for you

[@darkymakenzy]

Jumpscare list cuz my anxiety is through the roof: 5:58 Amanda’s scream 15:26 Bonnie 25:31 Plushtrap 26:33 Chica 28:48 Bonnie 30:21 Chica 31:35 Foxy 33:38 Foxy 35:50 Foxy’s head in the closet 36:10 Chica’s Cupcake 36:56 Foxy’s head in the closet 38:30 Bonnie 41:34 Foxy’s head in the closet 41:53 Bonnie 43:01 Foxy (Spencer clicking on the jumpscare button) 44:39 Freddy 46:45 Freddy 49:40 Courtney jumpscare lol Please tell me if I missed anything I’ll keep updating as I go through the video

[@linnbaardsen9459]

A tiny one at 5:58

[@helmi7923]

thank you so much!

[@Tundraatea]

30:21 for the Chica scare

[@serenity1116]

thank you so much i was looking for a comment like this!!

[@samfiles8909]

Amanda a veteran at 43:01. Everyone jumps and she barely flinches

[@GcNaxsus]

43:09 I love how Courtney is so genuine with this gesture "you're ok Shayne" with just a simple shoulder rub and how happy it made Shayne. We all need people in our lives like that romantic or platonic.

[@brennahaggs]

you’ve missed a lot

[@janidu8799]

Oh man have I got the story for you

[@GcNaxsus]

No I know about them but that doesn't mean every comment about them has to be about a romantic relationship or gesture. They are also friends and that moment came from the heart that's all I was saying.

[@fairlysleepy]

@@GcNaxsus ur so true girly

[@vavigirI]

@@GcNaxsus yes girl clock that tea

[@mudfish6861]

Honestly super impressed by how good Amanda is getting at fnaf games! I’d love to see them play Sister Location, since it’s such a different experience from the first 4 games. As for strategies, the first nights were going well. The closet doesn’t need to be checked until you see Foxy get in, and when he’s there just hold the closet closed for a while before checking again, otherwise it takes too long to clear him and the other 3 can get you. For fredbear, it seems like Amanda & Courtney understood that he would only be at the doors, which makes sense given how the game worked until that point, but Fredbear works unlike anything else in the game so you need to check every possible location (doors, closet, and bed) as you hear him move.

[@emmajohnston343]

36:20 the frustration and "OH I forgot to check the CEILING!!!!" 😂😂😂

[@colleenthewizard7472]

things I loved: -how little shane wants to be involved paired with the fact that the anxiety never lessens even when he’s NOT playing -amanda not remembering the fox’s name is foxy

[@BenjaminNaman]

5:06 Shayne: Maybe the first night is chill? Markiplier: 👁👄👁

[@robotninjago]

Fr that’s what I thought

[@Hew91]

God I just need them to play all of them - and then have Matpat sit down and explain all the lore to Amanda. I can just imagine how invested she would be in the explination

[@ballorafnaf849]

I second this

[@dr.little7311]

43:10 In the midst of the Shortney marriage announcement, I feel obligated to point out this cute moment

[@thebigusboyus]

Wow didn’t even notice. The way he looks at her is special

[@Caprisonslurp]

I love you for that

[@k_a_t_i_e999]

Little rubbies 😂🥹

[@M_jh_]

43:58 Amanda: "Guys don't be upset with us about Night 3." Girl how could we be upset, you guys did SO WELL!!! You were applying the tips/strategies and were learning from your mistakes. You didn't complete it, but you did an AMAZING job guys!⭐

[@RiverFaye]

I think it would be funny to redo the Shayne Damian and Courtney video “who knows me better my work wife or work husband”. But it could be “work wife vs real wife”

[@aequitas775]

Except it’s Courtney vs Courtney Freakin’ Miller

[@Masquerade08]

I mean, I was gonna say, is Damian the work wife then?

[@Eselore]

@@Masquerade08 No, Damian and Shayne recently got married, Courtney is the work wife

[@Cream318]

@@EseloreIs this legit? I thought it was a prank

[@Eselore]

@@Cream318 Courtney and Shayne getting married was a prank, but the Shayne/Damian pictures that came out where 100% legit

[@javuspendragon2000]

Shayne taped into his inner Chosen Powers and unlocked afraction of his potential to catch that silly Horror Rabbit.

[@zawa5243]

"The first night in the games are usually not that bad" -Markaplier (moments before getting jumpscared by NightMare Chica)

[@Hasans_pookie]

REALLL

[@ThePi314Man]

Can't believe shayne didn't do the splits once smh he was so proud to announce it

[@nicole-pq3ft]

Shayne getting plushtrap to stop at the X with closed eyes truly demonstrates he is the chosen

[@myownbubble1]

He had to break the character "shayne" and become his original self which is the chosen

[@bwahhhhhhhh]

Shayne vibing the Plushtrap minigame is the most Chosen shit ive ever seen😭😭😭

[@Owainmclain]

This episode feels like Shayne's cosmic punishment for pranking Amanda and introducing her to FNAF

[@zurirobinson2749]

My roommate introduced me to FNAF a few weeks ago after I spent 10 years in peace (having seen the game trailer as an easily scared 14 year old and decided "fuck that"), should I make him play this with me

[@lanzo236]

The videos are filmed in advance, so any video about you know what has probably not been filmed yet

[@blahhheyy5962]

But they knew the schedule becoz the smosh mouth was filmed in advance as well!!!

[@thespankmyfrank]

I feel like if they were gonna post anything about The Thing they would've though. They could have easily planned a video in between. I swear they'll probably just keep quiet about it in the future lol. (I hope I'm wrong though, I'd love a tell all video but I totally see why they wouldn't want that based on how private they are.)

[@Icarus2134]

wait, what are you guys talking about? Did something bad happen?

[@Fanthomas1742]

@@thespankmyfrank its bound to come up sooner or later. In the podcast at the very least

[@user-fy3ni7yd8c]

​@@Icarus2134 oh you sweet summer child

[@AaronLevyDrums]

"Spenser: You put your left foot in" "Amanda + Shayne: And put your right foot out"

[@Mel-jy5sw]

maybe that’s how shayne finally learned how to do the splits

[@celinesantoyo4594]

dude when shayne legitimately got upset at the cupcake popping up that was so hilarious😂

[@TheBenevolent]

OMFG MY FAVORITE TALL WOMAN AND SHORT BIG GUY WHAT GIVES COMBO 😭

[@bryanmay4070]

What gives Big Guy?

[@ZoeBee123]

@@bryanmay4070 Shane’s muscles

[@nairocamilo]

Reminder to send them lots of Knuckles fanart and pics of birds (like the Roseate Spoonbill) 🥰🥰✨

[@bryanmay4070]

@@nairocamilo and as many links to Imagine Dragons as we can

[@TheBenevolent]

OMG MY CULT FOLLOWING 😭

[@naomistading8673]

Jumpscare list: 05:57- Toy Freddy on the bed ( Not going to note these guys every time, just when the game/ Shayne and Amanda does a jump scare) 15:26 - Nightmare Bonnie 25:31 - Plus Trap jump scare 26:33- Nightmare Chica 28:47 - Nightmare Bonnie 30:21 - Nightmare Chica 31:35 - Nightmare Foxy 33:37 - Nightmare Foxy 36:09 - Cupcake 38:30 - Nightmare bonnie 41:54 - Nightmare bonnie 43:01 - Foxy haha thanks spenner... 44:39 - Nightmare Fred Bear 46:44 - Nightmare Fred Bear (shayne's reaction lol)

[@elisabettaficini404]

Thank you so much!

[@chungleandthebims167]

BLESS

[@lukapuka7840]

just a small correction from a geek, the "toy freddy" are actually called Freddles /nm

[@violetdeaddd]

THANK YOUUU

[@faith-4059]

hero omg

[@camihaley1779]

OKAY IM A FNAF NERD I NEED TO TELL U THE STRAT!! so for night 5 basically check the left and right doors continually, when you get to the door flash QUICKLY and immediately close the door after. do this until you hear him laugh, pay close attention though, if u hear footsteps before the laugh he is still at the doors. If it is JUST A LAUGH look behind you and in the closet, he will be in one of these two places. if he isnt, it was a fake laugh and you need to go back to checking the left and right doors, keep doing this and you should be golden!!

[@KassidyBranch]

They need a resident FNAF expert to come in as a guide 😂

[@valkiii00]

I hope they see this and try again honestly fnaf 4 scariest one imo

[@maxwashere.]

@@valkiii00 plus, they gotta see the bite of “‘87” lmaoo

[@abstractfriends6722]

wow!

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

Never played the game but interacting to bump

[@marshallpires4906]

24:46 “I think people are way scarier than like evil entities.”-Amanda, 2024

[@YOUTUB-hs5hq]

Ive never noticed and I don't think matpats ever mentioned this but how is Freddys shadow there if golden freddy is no casting it

[@roadentrage]

they work super well as one unit doing the controls i genuinely wouldve never guessed LMAO

[@dykeisms]

right? granted, this game has a lot less controls to manage, but i think splitting them instead of yelling at each other to do something is working great for them here

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

Honestly impressivve!

[@sarahkelly7991]

Yah this was the way to do it. They never would’ve gotten through any night if they’d passed back and forth like the other ones.

[@JustKandyMan1]

I love how throughout this series Amanda has slowly built up her confidence to the point where she's now taking charge and leading the game, it took a while but Amanda has earned her gaming wings now. Maybe she'll finally play Diablo with her husband!

[@liamross340]

courtney grabbing shayne’s shoulder in a totally platonic friendly way OR SO IT WOULD SEEM

[@gabbieandliz]

when was that?

[@Valhalla2049]

​@@gabbieandliz 39:37

[@jessicajames6676]

The zoom on her hand 👀

[@xxty-pharbz75]

so friendly that now they are married (confirmed)

[@mariosheadlice]

@@xxty-pharbz75is it actually confirmed?

[@asyanoelle]

i loooove how into this amanda is. as someone who’s loved the games forever i love seeing it through her eyes. i think they’ll love sister location since it’s so different

[@deadapple1700]

Shayne deadass used the force in that plushtrap minigame

[@myownbubble1]

yeah he is just like that

[@zBIGFRIIZZz]

Amanda Lehan Canto and Shayne Topp Miller back at it again

[@yadito]

I would love to see Shayne and Amanda play "Observation Duty"! I think it's a perfect game that is scary enough but not traumatizingly scary, and viewers can play along while watching the video ;)

[@wildwesley9328]

Yes! I love this idea!

[@psyarti]

31:43 i love it when shayne tries to end the video during these , i swear nearly every time they’ve played he tries to cut it short 😭 (also yes ik hes not not saying it seriously but it still cracks me up lol)

[@JaxMax101]

SHAYNE don’t leave amanda without a coat and a wallet….

[@skelvetron]

in the cold

[@bbdumplin9146]

On a bridge

[@daynematthew]

@@bbdumplin9146in the rain

[@Idk_My_Name]

@@daynematthew with the keys

[@TaylerJoe]

All by herself.

[@WilsonWilson-d3q]

Yes, please, play sister location. It's more chill than this one. Also, before you do it, you might want to check out the crying kid cutscenes from this game that you didn't get to see, since the whole point of making Amanda play it is so she learns the lore.

[@samfiles8909]

True. She needs to see the bite

[@rszoom]

25:32 I just think it’s so funny how when they get jump scared, Shayne always immediately closes his eyes and Amanda somehow keeps her eyes open as she screams 😂

[@IzumisChild]

I'm gonna be so sad when they finish playing FNAF. I love watching Amanda and Shayne play scary games and of course, Courtney cameos are always awesome!

[@GuineaPigEveryday]

25:35 Amanda is a genuine scream queen, ive never heard such blood curdling screams except from the stock sounds they use in movie trailers. Like holy shit her screaming is more of a jumpscare than the monster

[@mrstanaka2211]

i don’t always jump at these types of jumpscares but amanda trulry makes it scarier 😅😅

[@kiwi9445]

EXOTIC BUTTERSSSSS

[@alisonrosenfeld650]

“soldiers don’t leave the soldiers” shayne needs to remember that when he throws amanda at the wolves with the controller

[@DonutFlameFPS]

8 minutes in, the fact amanda isn't checking the middle closet as much as the other doors is STRESSING me

[@bugginonthewall]

when she left Foxy still in nightmare mode, proceeds to get a cupcake jumpscare 😂

[@KeiranTrick]

Why does everyone think they're IN the closet when they first play? Drove me nuts when the game came out, still drives me nuts today!! 😂

[@maxwashere.]

@@KeiranTrick does the game tell you that foxy comes from the hallway? if so, i definitely missed that. i think most people see an open door and assume it’s another thing they need to consistently check, just like every other part of the room. how is a new player supposed to understand there’s a visual cue if they’ve not been told or shown?

[@WishGender]

well if you don't see the door move, you don't need to check the closet right?

[@reriykan]

@@WishGender sorry if this is /s and im just misinterpreting tone, but you do need to consistently check the closet. the closet door moving is a hint, and while helpful, it isn't a rule that it moves every single time foxy is transforming into nightmare foxy. /info for the others in this thread, yes- there are certain nights/times in nights where foxy starts appearing in the closet. i dont remember exacts, but the player doesn't have to check the closet consistently in the beginning. it is a good habit to get into though! /info

[@caraguy6446]

Courtney’s shoulder rub on Shayne I cannot believe I would of never noticed this prior April 1st 😭😭

[@coviegray4409]

i’m obsessed with the gradual progression of dread these games induce. the first two games you don’t have as many audio cues so you can talk and joke over them to relieve some tension. the third game has some audio cues and springtrap becomes more aggressive as the nights go on so you start to lose that casual attitude. this fourth game is just terrifying because of how silent you have to be, you can only build the anxiety and dread as the game goes on

[@basedmarlon]

It’s simple too which adds to the pressure and stress of it. It’s just you and a flashlight.

[@samoth5161]

And in this one you can't really track the animatronics like in the other games, you only see them once they're in your face

[@kateabek]

It's the way Shayne looks at Amanda silently asking if flashlight is okay Amanda is the master of these games now

[@Mario-us5xm]

This just in, Shayne is canonically a force-sensitive user.

[@phobos_irl]

has anyone ever seen shayne and obiwan in the same room ? if so what proof do they have they werent being manipulated by the force ?

[@brytonluxton7105]

Shayne's voice cracking on "Tell us the strategy" killed me

[@m_milos]

amanda's actually really good like if y'all could afford to actually make a series out of each game, i feel like she would be able to beat the game on her own

[@gideongivesharrowboners]

right??? she got the strategies down pretty quickly, i was surprised but so proud of her

[@soupeater]

ILY MITSKI PFP HAVER

[@geckopecko]

BMAMC TRUTHER 🗣🗣🗣

[@hrvbox]

The shoulder rub at 43:10 is so cute now that we have context

[@WackMaDino]

heat seeked to the timestamp

[@Pluto-Ice9]

*BOOM.* There it is. The deniers don’t have a single shred of proof now. They *cannot* have a valid counter-argument now. So happy for Shayne & Courtney! 🎉🎉

[@JesseRandall-g5j]

What happened?

[@beatrizreis156]

@@JesseRandall-g5jcourtney and shayne got married. You missed the craziest april fools day ever

[@krisjaniskurpnieks5486]

@@JesseRandall-g5j Someone isnt follow socials :D They got married!

[@sarahjessicka]

These videos are like my little checkmark that I made it through another month of working at my retail job. Like a little celebration I made it through another month.

[@rachaelaaa]

It’s the little things! Congrats on another month!! You got this!

[@Pauavi]

right there with ya friend, you can keep going :)

[@hannierzlol]

i love how every episode has a Courtney segment near the end?? IT IS SO FUN WHEN THEY JOIN

[@jennalakes6334]

I need Shayne & Amanda to go to through haunted houses together this fall

[@sarahmarie345]

Please! This is such a good idea.

[@ellebelleelise]

insane idea! I hope they see this!!

[@hernameispekka_Rebecca]

Oh my god yes!!

[@joshuamedina1459]

Sarah Christ and the Chosen

[@alpacafish1269]

YEEEES

[@glazomaniac]

"007 said that" already off to a surreal start.

[@michaelreblin2540]

I thought she combined die another day and tomorrow never dies.

[@ben._.carey316]

The little shoulder rub Courtney gives shayne at 43:10 makes me so happy

[@Emotochan3]

The smile gives her makes my heart melt! Whole new meaning 🥰

[@lisa_vxng]

his smile up is everythinggg

[@kaihilscher4131]

39:25 I love the little look between the three of them when Courtney said “Congratulations” 😂 So happy for Courtney and Shane ❤❤❤