Our First Time Playing Five Nights at Freddy's

Someone should make a game about this.
SUBSCRIBE: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshGames
WEAR OUR JOKES: smosh.com
WHO YOU SEE
Shayne Topp // / shaynetopp
Amanda Lehan-Canto // / filmingamanda
WHO YOU DON’T SEE (usually)
Director: Spencer Agnew
Editor: Kevin Plachy
Director of Programming, Smosh Games: Spencer Agnew
Associate Producer, Smosh Games: Alex Tran
Art Director: Cassie Vance
Assistant Art Director: Erin Kuschner
Art Coordinator: Alex Aguilar
Director Of Photography: Brennan Iketani
Director, Design: Brittany Hobbs
DIT/AE: Matt Duran
Post Production Manager: Luke Baker
Production, EVP: Zoe Moacanin
Production Manager: Amanda Barnes
Production Coordinator: Heidi Ha
Production Assistant: Marcus Munguia
Senior Manager, Channel & Strategy: Lizzy Jones
Talent Coordinator: Selina Garcia
Office PA: Ovsana Tsaturian
OTHER SMOSHES:
Smosh: smo.sh/Sub2Smosh
Smosh Pit: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshPit
El Smosh (Spanish Dub): smo.sh/Sub2ElSmosh
SmoshCast: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshCast
FOLLOW US:
TikTok: smo.sh/TikTok
Snapchat: smo.sh/OnSnapchat
Instagram: / smosh
Facebook: / smosh
Twitter: / smosh

[@GameTheory]

Don't do this to yourselves... you both have a chance at normal, happy lives

[@cleggy375]

gam theory

[@Richard_E.]

From experience eh, Patthew Matrick?

[@hsuehejjw1731]

MAT I LOVE TOU ALSO I GOTTA SAY THAT THE CORREXT ORDER FOR THE GRAVE IN HELP WANTED IS CHICA FOXY FREDDY BONNIE GOLDEN FREDDY PUPPET

[@hsuehejjw1731]

YOULL GET SOMETHING SPECIAL IN THAT ORDER

[@Qwertyfluff]

No way! Is that the legendary true crime detective Matthew Patrick!?

[@TheRealSullyG]

"IS CHICA A BABY OR A WOMAN????" Please let them play through the entire series. This is golden.

[@Kxtie_A]

Yess, that'd be so entertaining to watch

[@nachofast6144]

AGREED

[@determinedmusic]

GOLDEN!?

[@joanparker921]

Toy Chica is chicken but a very sexy onr

[@ImSchneckenhaus]

20:14 is my favorite Chica moment so far HAHAHAHAHA

[@sebastianolsen4856]

scrap all of GameTheory’s FNAF lore, i want Amanda do an hour long video essay of what she believes the lore is

[@purplephantom2884]

YESSS

[@execrisiscoreonearth]

I literally bet she already has some theories running around in her head, as that is the case for many folks including myself when this game first came out/the experience was fresh. Lol. It really do have that effect on some folks.... Me being one of them. Lol. Kinda had to abandon the thought when I glanced at the rampant theorems going on in the wiki tho, and just never... Ever, looked back. Lol. It's always done a great job at throwing you into a weird situation with little bread crumbs to gleam a more sinister situation beneath the first game.

[@play-fool]

God, what a brilliant idea

[@gamesandfilmswithtodd4278]

Agreed this must be done

[@JeskidoYT]

my guy it will take her A WHOLE WEEK to play ALL the games and write an ESSAY

[@beanstheclown]

I NEED Amanda in the VR version where she can "use her hands." The extra level of immersion alone...

[@muznkamil9213]

This is GENIUS

[@MonsterPrincessLala]

Lol no babes in between this and that either. Straight 0 to 100

[@MannyNamiro]

That's way too much. She'll actually die. That VR horror stuff is crazy.

[@pavanbiliyar]

Plus, the VR version will let Amanda leave the security room if she wanted...

[@bondickle]

​@MannyNamiro yeah the only way I can see her do VR is if Smosh spend a ton of money making a padded room (for her safety!) 😂

[@PagiNANI]

Them not realizing that the sounds are from the calls is utterly hilarious

[@grime69]

SERIOUSLY LMAO. They just forget the calls exist altogether.

[@smmootoo18]

Yesss hahaha They're like "why he still calling us tf"

[@DarkLordTalon]

The only sounds from calls are at the start of the night... Any other sounds throughout the night are Not from the calls

[@kale_phresch_]

@@DarkLordTalon They're talking about the night 4 call, which has banging and animatronic noises in it.

[@Evan_Taylord]

I can’t believe Amanda is playing this game based on a true story

[@nerdscornercollectibles7902]

Like malignant?

[@sebas31415]

I know right!!!

[@theradicalginger3060]

It's about time she learned the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth 😂

[@tooclosetokyle]

It’s totally true! I was there ,man.

[@ninjaltofficial]

Yeah like this guy named William Affermack or something was the inspiration for the killer in the franchise!

[@emilyrichmond1973]

I love how Shayne said "we are surrounded" and Amanda goes "What instrument does Bonnie play?" lmao

[@Rawrmuffin0]

Always looking for lore

[@ember.raynestorm]

I adore that Shayne is clearly terrified, but that is outweighed by his enjoyment of Amanda freaking out, so that fuels him to keep going 😂❤

[@bondickle]

That, coupled with the fact that Amanda is engaged enough to try and play when he panic passed her the controller 😂😂

[@redbowsgaming2350]

The biggest “mom plays with her eldest son” energy I’ve ever seen. I need more.

[@Breadful1]

😳

[@wetblankkett]

like markiplier!

[@megm1937]

especially the "i love you but we gotta get out of this room"

[@crunchevo8974]

@@megm1937 "ok i get this is a horror game but what if we redecorate?"

[@blairtheclown7625]

THIS IS SO TRUE

[@emoclowngirl]

Shayne panicking while Amanda bombards him with questions about everything on the screen is the best thing ever.

[@Mack10011]

shayne: *about to cry* amanda: IS SHE A BABY OR A WOMAN???

[@alexiscake_]

shayne: *freaking out* amanda: YOU HAVE GOT TO LET ME KNOW WHEN YOU OPEN A DOOR

[@ale3786]

Everytime she hits him i die 😭😭

[@janaloff]

😂😂😂

[@jofip9199]

@@Mack10011that quote from her made me laugh sm i wasn’t ready 😂

[@dustpanhandle]

amanda taking the controller and slowly scrolling through all the rooms somehow made it 100x more stressful than when shane flashed through every camera 😭

[@bestenstarrie7951]

Amanda going “WHATS THAT.” To a SHADOW is fucking hilarious

[@morganpatterson1349]

Shayne revealed his level of little shit brother when he opened the doors and threw the controller at Amanda lmao insanely funny

[@Nealbader82]

The amount of pure, unfiltered PANIC that Amanda got! Amazing!

[@cassiesayshi8174]

Timestamp?

[@shadow_alpha_02]

​@cassiesayshi8174 it's at 24:42

[@knitwit9000]

Amanda is the mom who keeps on asking questions about the game and Shayne is the son who is trying to strategize the game

[@bubbledoubletrouble]

Amanda is the mom who only ever played Pong and isn't sure what's going on with her son Shayne's Nintendo but is there for him all the same

[@highdefinition450]

yea why does she feel older than the others lol she acts like such a mom sometimes it's great

[@wendybijellberg]

​@@highdefinition450i mean i think she's the same age as ian so she IS older than the others but her personality and the fact that she didn't grow up in internet culture definitely add to it lmao

[@magspie04]

@@wendybijellberg Specific at 10:30 she goes full mom lmaooo

[@elizabethpage_]

Exactly what I was about to comment. Love this mother and son gaming time

[@stephenbarringer235]

Amanda right after the Foxy jumpscare: "THAT WAS AWFUL! THAT WAS AWWWWW-FULLLL!" Amanda fifteen minutes later, asked what she thinks of the game: "I f****ng love it."

[@jacksonianian]

its so funny that amanda is literally predicting game mechanics for the sequels.

[@Lorenicities]

Can we just have a series where Shane and Amanda play ONLY horror games.

[@clndstnz]

THIS

[@srslyheidi]

please !!

[@punk-pangolins]

screw the podcast I NEED THIS NOWW

[@JorgePerozalikesbread]

I'm needing this

[@JorgePerozalikesbread]

​@punk-pangolins nah, the podcast is cool too

[@Lenji.y]

Amanda is actually just the embodiment of every older relative that’s vaguely interested in what you’re playing

[@Definitelynot_chronicallytired]

T H I S

[@baby_bear]

Or at least trying very hard to be interested in what youre interested in. And they see your frustration and want to help but dont know how the game works

[@sabsrina]

"do you want to play?" "NO, no, no..."

[@play-fool]

But in the best way. Real interest and so funny

[@JorgePerozalikesbread]

she has so mom energy in this that I can't believe it

[@kurojngyuki]

I didn't notice it until 23:35...but the green in Shayne's eyes is reacting to the greenscreen and whenever he changes the camera his eyes flash and that's kinda nuts lol

[@sparkless1549]

I was like how- and then I saw it super clear at 28:44 !!! Which makes me now wonder? I have green eyes so how would green screen work on my eyes?????🤔

[@kermitboy3686]

That is the most random thing ever but now I can't unsee it

[@Raider768]

It's so funny how Amanda anxiously says that sitting in a room waiting for the inevitable is akin to a horror movie...and then pitches the very common horror trope of going out and searching hahaa

[@Jassyt9008]

Amanda is going to 100% deep dive into the FNAF lore and go through the Game Theory rabbit hole. We won't see her again until the summer.

[@M0rbidCuriositea]

o7 Amanda

[@marydsc]

I'd love to see this as a sketch!

[@Peter-jg6gc]

MAN.Can’t wait for her to play fnaf 4

[@RonMantheWeb]

Amanda is gonna solve the lore before matt pat does

[@en9719]

This comment was too perfectly timed

[@lukasart3951]

Amanda keeps getting hung up on the most irrelevant details to survival and I love it. “Is Chica a baby or a woman?!”

[@acediaethos4469]

i'm trying so hard not to get frustrated by it 😂

[@keithredacted8154]

@@acediaethos4469 frustrated? It was so endearing like a little lore baby. I was in love with it.

[@caitlinwheeler7915]

“Wait they’re a band? So what does Chica play?” She’s sending me fr

[@hijfnhvbhbginvu]

my fav is when she asked, "what does the fox say"

[@robbinslol]

Yikes... I thought it was pretty funny, you should chill out, lol! 🩷🌝​@@acediaethos4469

[@KJHurrison]

Y'all got so INSANELY lucky that you were able to keep the doors closed that long

[@zanderisqueen]

It's not even luck, they have cheats enabled

[@KJHurrison]

@@zanderisqueen I figured that out eventually lolol

[@flesymevilanuottnawi]

@@zanderisqueen jus curious, how could u tell?

[@chasewilliams5048]

31:38 @@flesymevilanuottnawi

[@MackenziReacts]

33:14 Shane: "Actually this has zero fan base. Five Nights at Freddy's- Not many people know about it." Amanda: "Really? We should get more people to know about it". "We should promote this so people know about it" THAT PART KILLED ME LOL

[@raikaresha5906]

Usually when you're playing with someone else, it's less scary/stressful. But somehow they look more scared and stressed lmao

[@Verylengthyapple]

Maybe bc it’s like u can’t control what’s happening so it’s more scary as the witness

[@elrapido5150]

Yeah, Amanda having no composure gave Shayne no comfort, hence they both just wound up getting more scared together, lol

[@3seven5seven1nine9]

Shayne giving Amanda the controller on night 5 is CRAZY

[@jw5386]

Hello again lol

[@AvaOaks]

hello again@@jw5386

[@Oogabooga21]

Didnt get there yet, but that HAS to be some sort of crime 😭

[@princessadrigirl6774]

@@Oogabooga21the fact that he OPENED BOTH THE DOORS then tossed her the controller 😂😂

[@marzipanmenthol]

The captions of the introductory phone-call playing over their oblivious conversation is horrifying comedy gold

[@Nomzilladraws]

Knowing Amanda is a big horror fan it's not surprising that she loved this. We just need her to play more! And more horror games in general that would be amazing

[@riddlerosehearts8277]

I'd love to see them play poppy playtime 😂 especially once Chapter 3 comes out

[@AnnavelleLoc]

38:13 Whenever I watch someone play fnaf 1 for the first time, I always hope that they get to see Foxy running down the hallway. One of my fav scares from the entire franchise.

[@ericataylor7618]

Same!

[@xillinx_1363]

Same I was just waiting

[@Nanashi20]

i was hoping for both that, and golden freddy, doesnt even have to give the jumpscare, just want to see the reaction lol

[@sarahismyalias4672]

SAME I'm glad they got to see it. The FNaF 1 experience isn't complete without it!

[@manderzan]

SAMEEEEE I wish they did so bad

[@icedteapancake159]

I love that Amanda was so down to play the game after finding out it’s not a real true crime

[@icedteapancake159]

I MEAN TOTALLY REAL STORY (COUGH)

[@imgabiireyes]

@@icedteapancake159RIGHT

[@pizzgirl]

@@icedteapancake159😭😭😭

[@axinhedgelion8417]

It’s based on a real crime that happened at a Chuck E. Cheese

[@shae4453]

5:56 “I don’t like this guy. He knows we’re about to get f*cked over.” Right on the money😂

[@Gigimbr]

I love how Amanda basically guessed the mechanics of fnaf 3 at 35:05 This duo dynamic of Shayne and Amanda playing horror games is perfect

[@gloomy_gal]

This is actually so refreshing seeing someone play the game like its brand new.

[@rascal.breath]

Literally, this was actually so nostalgic

[@JackBin1289]

@@rascal.breathyesssss

[@highdefinition450]

yea i kinda want her to play more horror games now lol

[@phiraucous]

​@@highdefinition450 I would love to see her play Amnesia!

[@megadoodoo6511]

​@@highdefinition450Same here!!!

[@jazmines4324]

Amanda panicking so hard about Bonnie being at the door to the point that she forgets how to close it and Shayne refusing to say shit had me WHEEZING with laughter.

[@efenedick1305]

Based on the sound effects it seems like the door button got jammed

[@crunchysalmons]

she doesn’t learn very quick

[@amai_316]

@@crunchysalmonscognitive function tends to decrease when one is under extreme stress or anxiety, so… Let’s give Amanda some Lee-way and not be an a-hole, alright bud?

[@844pm2]

​@@crunchysalmons for someone who doesn't play games often, or at all, she did as good as you could imagine. I'm sure if I handed you a new tool that you're not familiar with and asked you to do something in less than 10 seconds under pressure, you'd too be shitting your pants crying for help

[@Nacho2003YT]

Either way, as soon as Bonnie got the light flashed on him the game just jammed the door button, so they were screwed anyway jdjdjdjjdjdjd

[@cosmickiwi2827]

Amanda just keeps bringing up things she wished she could do in this game that just show up in later games PGKSPPD and I love it

[@micksrj]

PLEASE HAVE THEM DO THE VR VERSION!!😂😂 bc Amanda is constantly wishing they could do more stuff with their hands loll

[@emma.prince]

she would actually die if she did that omg, i don't think she'd ever do anything horror based ever again

[@xHaste]

When Shayne opened both doors and then threw the controller to Amanda.. PEAK CONTENT LMAOOO

[@angelrain95]

Shayne gives huge older brother energy this whole video. As a younger sister, I felt Amanda's confusion and panic in my soul! 😂

[@faeri_]

@@angelrain95I would throw hands over that 😂

[@antonforsman8099]

Yea, he noticed that the battery was way too high on easy mode so he had to do something.

[@xillinx_1363]

Timestamp?

[@recklessboi-qs8yx]

24:51

[@EnigmaticVibe]

Amanda somehow predicted the 2 most important game mechanics in the next two games, the music room/box from fnaf 2 and the sound distractions from fnaf 3

[@alexafletcher8991]

Ikr when she said that I was like... "well... have I got news for you girlie"

[@roro7428]

I WAS JUST THINKING THAT, she is the real mastermind

[@ronisawyer5371]

When did she predict the music box lol? I missed it. That is really funny that she predicted that tho

[@mattybrunolucaszeneresalas9072]

No?

[@EnigmaticVibe]

33:54@@ronisawyer5371

[@liammcfarlane13]

Did Smosh up the “Shayne’s sleeve-tightening” budget because this shirt is hugging for dear life 😂

[@GuineaPigEveryday]

This game has been played so much and was such a huge let's play game years ago and yet Smosh somehow manages to make it interesting just with the fun of Amanda's total freaked out mom energy with Shayne

[@Evelyn-qt3hi]

Foxy doing literally nothing the entire time until Amanda plays 20/20/20/20 mode and then decides to participate and scare Amanda is iconic

[@lydiamarie9991]

he really waited for his time to shine so he could go sicko mode

[@ziggy2865]

I was waiting for her reaction to Foxy the whole video lmao

[@plasmarine5781]

Omg absolutely killed me 😂😂😂😂😂 Foxy just SPRINTING at Mach 20 and Amanda screaming is everything 😂😂😂😂

[@VehicularVortex]

I was waiting for it the whole time. I’ve never been so happy at Foxy jumpscaring me.🤣🤣🤣

[@jaggedhd1205]

The vibe switches from mom bonding with teenage son and older brother pranking younger sister and I love it 😂

[@ninjabluefyre3815]

Smosh is very much every family dynamic woven into each other.

[@joonkt90]

When he just gives her the controller and doesn’t tell her how to close the doors! Omfg soooo funny and cute

[@deviousdayz]

this is exactly how it is LMFAO

[@aavi.]

19:41 Chica appears and Shane looks instantly to Amanda to witness her get scared😂 true sibling reaction

[@shae4453]

11:16 “if this is a baby coming after us we’re f*cked” wait till she finds out about circus baby😂

[@Florkie]

She did now…

[@tianamunford5209]

The fact that the first night, Chica moved first, Golden Freddy tried and Foxy was being needy! Did Scott up the difficulty since?

[@Crea_dot]

Idk but I'm shocked noone else is talking about the fact they got golden on the first try-- I've been playing for yearsss and have probably only gotten golden abt 2 or 3 times

[@dawnreneegeertsema6053]

I’d love to see them play this in VR. The sheer massive size of the animatronics doesn’t translate until you see it in VR.

[@victoriasunivers]

One of my friends play it in his VR set

[@rhettmitchell]

I watched my roommate play it in VR and they could hardly make it through lmao

[@karolineleos]

Oh my god yes yes yes

[@crumblinggolem6327]

100% I would love to see them play a vr version

[@Deathbird_Mitch]

The only way yo play this game is in a dark room or VR.

[@mikmikDNA]

Shayne being a psychopath not telling Amanda how to shut the door is legitimately so funny for no reason

[@emyherrera]

Seriously it reminded me of the times I would try to play with my cousins and they’d just hand me a control. No instructions just vibes then death

[@bryce_jr]

the fact she was press g the right buttons but the door wouldn’t shut is hilarious

[@nevaehrose3235]

sry.. time stamp??

[@kartikiramugade6685]

​@@nevaehrose3235 it's @ 26:10

[@liv1131]

Props to the editors for putting some nice, calming backgrounds at the end to help us calm down after that thrill ride

[@drivingmissmolly]

The fact that Amanda was backseat gaming the entire time and second guessing everything Shayne was doing like she knew better than him and then proceeds to panic and fail spectacularly when she gets the controller was pretty great.

[@miritskeen]

you know theyre good friends but the absolute joy on shayne's face when amanda can't shut the door

[@lydiamarie9991]

literally they are suuuch a good duo

[@scorpihoe]

fr that gave brother sister vibes LMAO

[@breecheese]

Amanda’s reaction to that was exactly what I would have done too, except I probably would have actually cried lol

[@RebeccaSchwartz703]

And Amanda calling him a prick Multiple time

[@jaelance]

The fact that they got the "IT'S ME" easter egg on their first game is crazy

[@RhetoricalRemnant]

Literally 4 mins in. Insane.

[@swec_wub]

I know

[@fynntasticmovienight]

@@RhetoricalRemnant whats the timestamp?

[@markod5901]

​@@fynntasticmovienight 4:37

[@sloanhanberry2506]

What are the exact odds?

[@SmoshBaby2468]

For Amanda and Shayne: 1. The door/ person you saw was actually the gap between the tables in the dining area. 2. The white thing that you saw through the left window when that sound goes off is the light casting a shadow of one of the animatronics against the wall, meaning they're right out there 😂

[@dee_deer]

i was looking for this! thank you

[@sydneymitrecic]

14:14 "I HAVE to. That is the game of it Amanda. " The crazed smile got me

[@MithrilSqueegee]

I love how you can see Amanda gradually getting more and more into it so quickly 😂 but watching Shayne legitimately SWEATING and stressing out while Amanda makes polite conversation is a hilarious dynamic 😂

[@JorgePerozalikesbread]

YESSSS

[@kropotkinnie]

begging on hands and knees for these two to play all of the fnaf games so that amanda can learn the lore like she so badly craved in this video lmao

[@kveld9893]

them playing sister location 😍

[@notmalcolmm]

smosh cast guest starring (Mat)thew (Pat)tel

[@gemmacadd2252]

​@notmalcolmm who tf is Matthew Patel

[@kropotkinnie]

​@@earlofcockgobblingshire3666As someone with the misfortune of having grown up thru the games and learning the lore, I feel like they'll have about as coherrent a grasp of it as the rest of us do

[@soulcos123]

17:46 "Who's Scott Cathwon?" I died laughing 😭😭

[@turntapeover5749]

Smoehow the thing that horrified Amanda the most is that $120 salary. 😂

[@Chuck13s]

I love Amanda bringing in legitimate criticisms about the game the whole time: “we don’t get to experience being taken to the back room and shoved in an animatronic??”

[@rhettmitchell]

All shayne had to say was that the first game had a budget of 2 nickels lol

[@jennifertran7555]

that confuses me tbh bc isn't that the game over screen? you do get stuffed in a suit

[@spookydooms]

@@jennifertran7555yeah… they weren’t paying attention to that lol

[@v0mit4br4ins]

@@jennifertran7555 i think she meant like they didn't animate a death cutscene. like you don't literally get to experience being shoved into the suit, you just see the picture and are told that's what happens if they find you

[@TabbyWithMittens]

@@v0mit4br4ins Honestly think that's more scary then seeing it because you have to imagine what happened in that suit instead seeing it.

[@pickledpiss9522]

Shayne: “You ready, Amanda?” Amanda: “Fazbear, pizza, yes!”

[@xcheeseburgersaladx]

Mexican Salsa, Yes!💃

[@daisyallen4954]

this is a golden comment

[@jerbear3930]

@@xcheeseburgersaladxthat ice, cold, winter😂😂😂

[@djwilson1993]

Perfect

[@user-pk5zu4mz4q]

Okkkkkkkkk.

[@mitchfitch]

Can we please have an episode where Damien, Amanda, Kallmekris and Shayne play Phasmophobia? 😂

[@M1dkn1ghtFroggy]

2:51 "uh the animatronic characters here do get a bit quirky at night"

[@JuhoSprite]

Best quote of the game

[@FuhrerHeisen]

Shayne opening the doors and throwing the controller at Amanda is the most big brother shit ive seen all day lmfao.

[@sleepy_vi3nnq]

oh my god this is so real i’m crying

[@scrumplet1997]

"who's Scott Cathwan" was the comedic relief I needed in that moment 😂

[@dominickucela6144]

Amanda asks the real questions

[@SamanthasDoggos]

The way Shane goes so fast between cameras gives me so much more anxiety than the rest of the game 😅

[@hugh_dancy]

the way that shayne duos well with everyone is so incredible, i am loving the amanda/shayne duo so much and this video had awesome, awesome energy

[@dariyajordan]

the way they keep calling Foxy “Wolf” is making the video like 70x better

[@IvyG-C]

And calling Bonnie a girl 😭

[@Anzy.99]

​@@IvyG-CI mean, Bonnie os a "girl" name

[@IvyG-C]

@@Anzy.99 yes, classic mistake lol

[@Madison.Carolina]

this needs to become a series because amanda would LOVE security breach

[@rmgkng]

exactly the game i was thinking!

[@alexiscake_]

we gotta get someone that can endure the stress of fnafsb 😭

[@toadt0ad]

i was thinkin that too😭😭

[@Kirsikkalyhty]

Y'all are joking right?

[@hsisnothere]

we gotta work up to that 😭

[@Starthebard]

I normally get scared so easily, Amanda and Shayne making jokes make it so much better

[@mattybrunolucaszeneresalas9072]

16:19 how on earth did she read that so fast?

[@cardboardboy227]

Y'all need to bring MattPatt on the podcast and explain the lore to Amanda. Edit: this aged well. (Matpat is leaving game theory if you didn't know)

[@sofiedahlerus6503]

Omg yes, this is such a great idea!!

[@dylancole1910]

That would be great 😂

[@djwilson1993]

Please!

[@AutumnRose298]

OMG YES

[@ninjabluefyre3815]

You know how Starbomb did a couple of songs on complicated video game plots? They should do one more...

[@descent1667]

them beating all the nights while understanding none of the mechanics is so incredible, genuinely

[@ratatouilletea]

they had cheats on

[@lucaswells8651]

Yea they extra power or something

[@frida885]

i did it the first time i played, i never understood why this was supposed to be difficult? did they change the game or something?

[@annasophier1]

it was on easy mode :)

[@gemiae428]

They running the whole night with 4x power on god. They should’ve been out of power by 3am

[@fulcrum1575]

Them successfully navigating the Golden Freddy jumpscare around 30:00 was honestly really impressive.

[@hope6192]

20:20 “CHIKA! 👏🏻E👏🏻NOUGH!”

[@JeansXoX]

Can you guy have Shayne and Angela play "Don't Scream" horror game that listens to your mic and if you make any loud noise like scream at jump scares the game starts all over again. It would be funny to see the two loudest people play and try not to scream at that game lol

[@lollylolly8186]

Watching Sean play it cracked me up. I’m not sure Angela and Shane could make it through.

[@Sandi2105]

Amanda wouldn't make it through, either... "WHY ARE THERE VENDING MACHINES IN THE FOREST?!" 😂

[@hunneyz723]

Shayne and Amanda should definitley play more games together

[@scrrrt]

THIS

[@d_johhns0n]

oh my god that would be SO funny

[@hoyitsmiguel]

Okay but imagine Shayne introducing Amanda to some of the iconic ones of our time like Slenderman or in recent times the Backrooms

[@lydiamarie9991]

YES!! i seriously need to see these two play all the classics. their dynamic is everything to me

[@RaulHernandez-yx2pw]

Nah

[@lena__lu]

omg I haven't seen a Slenderman gameplay in years

[@TheUltimateYouTuberyay]

Or the SCP Foundation

[@rikkichadwick1622]

GOD YES PLEASENOMG

[@Goobergurl]

I think Amanda's my favorite from the Smosh cast. She's always makes me smile and laugh, and her personality is infectious

[@noface3641]

I need at least 200 more of this video. Amanda and shayne have such brilliant friend chemistry, and amanda's mom energy is so fun to watch interact with gaming, especially horror. I really would love for it to become a series where they play through the best FNAF games. Some of them are so intricate amanda's head would probably explode with lore😂

[@sighkick6938]

Jumpscare Times: 17:30 (Bonnie) 26:19 (Bonnie) 37:18 (Golden Freddy 1987 Easter Egg) 38:14 (Foxy)

[@Charisdreaming]

This needs to be higher up I’m a coward

[@dustedneonlight]

Thank you I’m a baby ❤

[@blooms454]

OMG THANK YOU why don't people do this anymore???? I LOVE YOU

[@posi1187]

Thank you thank you thank youuuu! You're a miracle worker!

[@twosdaybear]

Thank you dude!! Much appreciated 🫡

[@rainatl5y]

somehow amanda is giving mom energy and simultaneously shayne is giving older brother energy

[@Mariethechaotic]

It's giving "mom trying to take an interest in her moody teen son's interest". I'm half expecting him at any moment to be like "omg mom stooppp". Especially when he crosses his giant arms over his chest 😂

[@jaredfortin6810]

​@@Mariethechaoticzyessssss

[@bertwo7150]

Its just like Markiplier and his mom playing fnaf 😂

[@reneehoenicke4765]

13:20 Literally the SECOND Amanda finished her sentence, my computer that I was watching the video died and I got genuinely freaked out 🤣

[@nickf.747]

All things considered, the fact that neither of them has played this and yet they beat night 6 in one sitting is...actually pretty remarkable! Edit: It has been brought to my attention that they are, in fact, playing on easy mode, and I simply did not notice because I tuned back in at the wrong time. It takes a special kind of skill to miss information that thoroughly. Be jealous

[@zjmiller6627]

I’m fairly certain they were playing on easy mode, with the way they were playing they should have lost power by 3AM on night 1

[@boomgirlbucko]

They had cheats enabled

[@ronanballantyne6221]

@@zjmiller6627they were, Shayne says it pretty early on that they’re on the easiest mode

[@rhettmitchell]

They were in baby mode and prob some cheat making it even easier but it’s still surprising even with all that lmao

[@tyffaneelavely8087]

they are on easy mode. That's how they are so heavily relying on the doors. You can't do that normally. Still, was hilarious to watch lol.

[@madisonscebra8614]

Am I the only one that's blown away that their night six strategy was to just keep the doors closed the entire time and it WORKED?!

[@Warm_n_Crowzy]

yeah that doesn’t seem right? from what i know of the game that shouldn’t even work 😭😭

[@nategwright]

It you look at the title screen it says they have cheats enabled, probably gave them a lot more power. They probably did that so the video isn’t just them getting bodied on Night 3/4/5, but I do wish they were forced to adapt their strategy by losing power because they were able to just turtle for the entire night.

[@keeganbanner3035]

I think they had cheats on just to make it easier

[@Warm_n_Crowzy]

@@nategwright yeah bc they would’ve gotten so bodied 😭

[@zrc1514]

@@nategwright That makes so much more sense. I was seriously trying to figure out how they didn't run out of power almost immediately and why the animatronics didn't get that aggressive.

[@peachypanda57]

watching this as someone who used to be OBSESSED with fnaf is so funny because i’m used to the like “pro strats” gameplay and then there’s this 😭😭 amanda asking such normal questions and shayne not knowing anything 😭

[@mattybrunolucaszeneresalas9072]

15:34 no, he recorded those messages on his nightshift the week before

[@rileygrove7483]

yall should have matpat on a smoshcast just to explain some of the lore of the fnaf series to shayne and amanda. i think that episode would slap and do so well

[@sarahpocalypse_7102]

PLEASE.

[@chelseydunn3636]

YES. I would love this.

[@YourRyeBread]

Agree Agree

[@veronicadiaz337]

YES!🎉

[@RyanZeh5]

This would be so amazing

[@likeblessbutwithaG]

The fact Shayne flips through the cameras so quickly makes this so much more horrifying

[@ari8417]

FR IT WAS SO STRESSFUL

[@michaelrandolph6373]

Good seeing some newcomers to the series. Honestly when I play I rarely keep my doors shut for more than like 10 seconds and on real hard nights I don’t even use my lights to save power so keeping those doors shut so much had me so stressed out.

[@madisonkafka7427]

I absolutely loved this so much!!! It is very much needed that you guys do each game! I am most definitely here for it!!!

[@lukthar123]

Amanda and Shayne is the perfect gaming duo, they both fuel each others fears and it's beautiful to watch

[@KingOfGaymes]

Feels like a teenage son and his mom playing a game together where he keeps explaining the game to her

[@CarrieJerry]

We need a full 'Amanda and Shayne Play Horror Games' series 😂😂

[@ch3rri3s]

Yes please!!

[@patrickripleyiii134]

That is an amazing idea

[@RoeBoats]

YES I LITERALLY SAID THIS TO MYSELF OUT-LOUD AHHHHH

[@comeandgetlt]

literally they’re such a good duo for horror games

[@jaredramos6223]

Their dynamic is wonderous. And I second this idea

[@MulderWithGlasses]

“Who’s Scott Cathwon” lmao

[@kerithwooldridge]

Absolutely want them to play the series. These two are great together!!

[@savannahmay640]

they had markiplier-level luck when they got to the end of the 4th night 💀

[@corinnecollins1287]

They are playing on easy mode

[@Eris_Strife]

They had cheats enabled

[@Eris_Strife]

17:46

[@savannahmay640]

@@Eris_Strife i know that, i still thought it was cool that they completed the 4th night with 1% battery left 😅

[@wilhelmpaulm]

​@@Eris_Strifeis they probably got stuck at 4th night 😂

[@gatorex2452]

We totally need this to be a series where they play most of the main fnaf games and by the end Amanda becomes a fnaf lore expert

[@hazuki413]

After watching this I feel she’d be more confused lmao

[@rhettmitchell]

@@hazuki413 nah she’s got it. They just need MatPat on Smoshmouth to explain some stuff and she’ll be fine haha

[@marshallpires4906]

26:36 the door was jammed

[@canadiangopnik7007]

Please... dive headfirst down the rabbithole, It'd be so fun to have a full series where you play the 11 (I think) FNAF games, It's been so long since I've seen someone experience the lore for the first time, I NEED this

[@pedrocampos691]

Yeeeeeeeeess yeeeees yeeeeeees yees.

[@ghostlyxero9030]

Amanda being completely oblivious to FNAF and not knowing its cultutal impact is so funny for some reason

[@faeri_]

I wanna say @monkebrainiac made a compilation of Amanda being chronically not online and it’s the best thing I’ve seen all year 😂

[@rhettmitchell]

@@faeri_ oh yeah I watched that one too omg I’d been waiting for a compilation of that!

[@dragonoyxd]

Amanda's mother energy is so funny "We need to talk about this" "You need to ask me before opening the door" "Shut. The. Doors!"

[@Savitzen]

The whole video i was hoping that they would witness Foxy run down the hall, and im so glad its the last one of the video 😂😂😂

[@emilybarajas6576]

Shayne and Amanda are such an underrated duo. This video exudes sibling vibes 😂 Love them both ❤

[@cameronshindler7443]

"I don't know how to shut the door!" repeatedly from Amanda while she cries almost KILLED me laughing to death.

[@paigemurray8385]

It’s funny too cause she was pressing the right button but Bonnie jammed the door