Patterrz Reacts to "Film Theory: The World of One Piece is BROKEN!"

Patterrz Reacts to "Film Theory: The World of One Piece is BROKEN!" • Film Theory: The World...
Subnoodle is available! (limited time) www.makeship.com/products/sub...
Main channel / patterrz
TWITTER - / patterrz
Instagram- / patterrz
save on gamersupps!! gamersupps.gg/?ref=Patterrz
Discord link: / discord
#patterrz #react #morepat

[@MorePatterrz]

Subnoodle is available! (for a limited time) www.makeship.com/products/subnoodle-plush

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Please do a reactions of the live action OP

[@bananamanduh3171]

yeah it is

[@samfisher6606]

I love that MatPat comes to the conclusion that the One Piece world would be just the worst. And in the series, it is just _the worst!_ All the problems that MatPat calls out in this video are rampant in the One Piece world. We have people killing marines just so they can feed their families. We have mass starvation, slavery, etc.

[@JamienautMark2]

Yeah while One Piece has a lot of comedy. Looking at what REALLY happens the world straight up sucks. Constant inequality, basically anyone with a strong Devil fruit or haki could just go and ruin you and your family’s life.

[@TrueWarriorJak]

I feel a lot of people misunderstand what he's saying he literally ends the video saying. Yeah, the OP world sucks and that it's somewhat accurate based on what they showed us in lore lol he doesn't say it wouldn't work irl quite the opposite actually.

[@sujithsudhakaran745]

The reason for most of problems in one piece world is not the climate but the rule of the world nobles which creates civil wars and mass Starvation due to heavenly tributes

[@farfetchdthegamer3810]

@@sujithsudhakaran745True, but from 1089 it seems that Imu might have some power over what seems like sea levels, so…

[@IamGrimalkin]

That's not due to lack of resources though, that's because they gave all their money to the Heavenly tribute and received nothing back for it.

[@awesomeocelot7475]

On the Going Merry and Thousand Sunny they actually had machines that pulled salt water out of the ocean and turned it into drinkable water.

[@pyrotempestwing]

IIRC, that tech exists irl. I want to say, at least at one point, cruise ships had them.

[@StickfigureGreen1]

Really?

[@keiviroque5666]

What I think is more baffling is that Mat doesn’t even try to bring up the possibility of distilled water.

[@limb.dondototohasstartedso7288]

​@@keiviroque5666 mat pat creates bad theory but entertaining video that's why he is successfull

[@blackmanta66]

​@@limb.dondototohasstartedso7288In real life distilling water is not particularly easy or quick, also the other points Matpat made about the issues of the calm belt, red line, grand line are still big issues in the real world

[@Malstrx]

The biggest problem with his theory is that the red line and grand line don’t run the equator and prime meridian they bisect the world diagonally

[@cassandrafiscus9192]

Speaking of when Sanji is on the rock with his future adopted dad, did you know that in the manga it wasn't that he lost his leg saving Sanji, he just cut it off and ate it on the rock so Sanji could have all the food salvaged from the shipwreck.

[@FinnManusia]

I remember that scene. It is kind of same when they added a dragon island in the anime before they go to the Grandline.

[@jonmcknight18]

It's also the time Sanji learns starving sucks and will kick you teeth in it you waste food

[@getshwifty3101]

The only real issue about the Rain Shadow Effect that Mat talks about, is that: Yes, it's more islands, rather than land. There's over twice as much distance to be traversed. The winds over a sea are usually stronger, which is helped when.....y'know, the whole WORLD is just a sea. AND finally, we don't actually know (at least I don't) where their adventure actually starts in the East Blue. Which means that the islands JUST east of the Red Line, on both sides of the world, might be desert. But the rest SHOULD be fine on vegetation. The actual problem would be the huge, possibly frequent, hurricanes that would actually happen. But that's just my take. A DUUUUMB take! Thanks for reading.

[@luxaeterna365]

Seeing how little time it took them to get to reverse mountain, they probably were close the grand line all the time. At some point they even get into the calm belt by accident, so they were almost at the grand line since the beginning, they were just trying to get there without dying.

[@dragonbretheren]

Also, the rain shadow exists because there's no water past the mountain range to distribute. In the One Piece world, past the Red Line mountains is... more ocean. Which could evaporate and become rain systems to islands just east of the Red Line...

[@AlexT7916]

​@@luxaeterna365we have no about how much time passes between islands

[@kunilsen2519]

@@AlexT7916 But they spent, what? Maybe close to two years together as a group traveling, if that long. If they had to travel for long then more time would have passed.

[@IamGrimalkin]

​@@luxaeterna365Here's the other thing though: close to reverse mountain at least, the winds don't go in that direction. The winds and sea currents on all four blues head towards reverse mountain; we see this explictly in the manga. The issue si that Matpat (or whoever wrote his script) hasn't actually read the manga, he's just read a plot synopsis.

[@BloodKills]

One major thing he got wrong, is that the grandline does not wrap around the equator, it wraps around the world diagonally, same as the red line, so fishman island and reverse mountain are like the part the X marks.

[@Slacker420]

Fun fact, we actually have the technology to turn regular seawater into drinking water by taking out all of the salt but it just takes so much energy in order for us to properly that it’s not actually worth it for us but it would probably be worth it for the people in the one piece world since they don’t have an alternative

[@elplaceholder]

Yeah, but consider that they are at a 19th century level of tecnology, at least in the live action, so i dont think they can do that

[@starburst98]

Franky is a cyborg, as in most of his body has been replaced with metal and machinery. And later builds a full sized mecha. So the tech is just all pver the place.

[@madhatter2549]

@@elplaceholder what? their tech is insanely beyond advanced, sure some things arent modern but they have robots like kuma, cyborgs like franky, and all kinds of wacky tech thats miles beyond modern tech

[@elplaceholder]

@@madhatter2549 i was talking about the live action, they barely have Electric lights and metal ships

[@binay413963]

​@@elplaceholderok

[@AlexDayz]

I think your question -“what’s the point of this theory”- is why Game Theory rarely make science based theories nowadays. Sure it’s fun to apply real science to fictional scenarios, stories, games, etc. but after a while it gets boring repeatedly hearing “this isn’t possible IRL” when most people already know that

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

LOVE your reactions to theories! More food theory please 😊

[@muhammadibrahim2505]

Yup we need more

[@dz5214]

Patternz makes a really good point. If you look at a map of the U.S., you can easily see that most east side of the country has plenty of vegetation. The rain shadow effect runs out after about over 1,000 miles. if the world of one piece really is that big, then most of the islands actually would have plenty of vegetation.

[@Flufferz626]

Also even though a portion of it was Croc's doing, Alabasta is an arid climate. Which after Drum Island (freezing tundra is also a desert often) is the second place they encounter in the Grand Line. Maybe he did not research that bit? Also there is the suspicion still speculated to this day if the Red Line is artificial.

[@4zechan271]

People don't know this because its a recent manga development but we recently found out that One Piece's world is post apocalyptic.

[@swissgoat4981]

I just got into OP and that honestly makes sense

[@4zechan271]

@@swissgoat4981 its a crazy world

[@Flufferz626]

It has implied that long ago in the series since the poneglyphs were introduced and the Void Century.

[@Im_stealing_comment]

17:34 the size doesn’t matter because it is a connected line so there is absolutely no wind can go pass

[@Fool_ish]

for anyone saying the live action is getting things wrong remember that oda is working with them

[@jaidenavery7118]

Yeah, people don't realize that everything they're adding, changing, and removing is all under Oda's guidance meaning it's all things he either wanted to put but couldn't or wanted to change but couldn't

[@elijahboyd2758]

I think the most important thing for a live action one piece would be to have the actor that plays luffy to be someone who enjoys the role, because we wouldn’t have the same energy if it was the other way. That is why we have the best newbie to play luffy.

[@FallenChaos]

So, the one piece is Groudon in a poke ball, confirmed...

[@Wyvernatus]

That’s kind of depressing. Even when he tried to make an uncontroversial theory, the One Piece fandom finds a way. Shouldn’t have dabbled your toes in that one Matthew Patthew.

[@kunilsen2519]

I mean, the fans are just saying what is a fact in that world. It's pretty brave to make a theory video about the whole of One Piece world(as a theory channel) when you don't have all the known facts. The world of One Piece is huge and has had over 20 years of worldbuilding and fans digging deep and getting to know this world on quite a detailed level. He/they did a good job, but they missed some pretty important details that do affect the theory.

[@PowerSpirit50]

I wouldn't make a video on something I don't have a proper amount of information on. Doesn't help when they get so many basics wrong. Almost feels like mockery.

[@Wyvernatus]

@@PowerSpirit50 That’s what I said “Shouldn’t have dabbled your toes in that one Matthew Patthew.” But I don’t care enough about One Piece to elaborate any further, I’m not MatPat’s lawyer lol.

[@PowerSpirit50]

@@Wyvernatus It's not like we're making up new lore to counter act him in order to find some way to be upset.

[@Wyvernatus]

@@PowerSpirit50 I know, I wasn’t trying to come off as rude. I’m curious to know what lore he ignored aside from whatever mystical forces there are in One Piece given the theory was addressing how the world would work if it was real.

[@justinmoore3669]

There are sky island people that study weather (Namis training during timeskip) and go around helping islands.

[@elviswilliams1131]

I finished the live action already and it was great! Yeah there were some changes but they didnt make the show worse actually i think they made it better and more engaging for current one piece fans to see new Interactions and other stuff. So yeah i give it a 10/10 hope we get a season 2

[@tashu6573]

that is why sanji's all blue is logical. break the red line and calm belt

[@dartagnanjames8069]

It really bothers me that Film Theory got their whole premise wrong with the Grandline NOT running along the equator. Like the whole video is moot after that lol

[@jackrogers6580]

Did mat pat forget that there's ocean on both sides of the mountain so rain water shouldn't be a problem

[@TheBlaziking666]

Reading the manga is honestly faster than watching. I got a bunch from my library and are kind of switching between watching and reading to catch up

[@dragonblast417]

the Grandline is basically what we think the bermuda triangle is x100 plus its not just a triangle, it circles the Earth

[@muhammadibrahim2505]

Being a anime fan i was really exited for this

[@justsortathere540]

My fav One Piece videos so far is actually someone new. They go by the name MUGIWARA NO GOOFY. If you understand why that’s the name of the channel then congrats

[@matai5923]

You talking about the crazy crackhead

[@8829patrickcox8829]

i have been wondering why no-one seams to remember that there many ways to turn sea/ocean water into fresh water

[@psachickennugget8617]

News is controlled by the government? Big news Morgan would be quite upset at that insinuation XD

[@Nastyn1nja808]

0:56 its imprtant to pointniut that Oda and his people went to Netflix not the other way around. Lol

[@knightcatz5533]

The rock as all might

[@wetrisolesse619]

In zou you had the filter system that was built before the minks tribe even settled in it

[@anime_enjoyer5507]

i first read one piece and caught up when its on punk hazard, which is 2013 according to wiki.. and i reread it again when its over 700 chapters for a week, 7 days, which means 100 chapters a day.. i dont know how long it'll take me again if i reread it but i think its very easy to do it when you're just reading onepiece.. onepiece is very enjoyable so you wont feel like you're forcing yourself reading it

[@VSiFer]

In One Piece world, learning latin is literally a crime.

[@VeryEpicGamer123]

3:24 Matt pay canonically was 4kids one piece

[@alexzurita2049]

Thanks for your content

[@cloudkitsune17]

My favorite vids on One Piece so far, is MelonTeee. Sadly, not many have reacted to her content. Also... I LOOOOVE the One Piece rap. XD It goes so hard, wft.

[@swampboyblack5628]

Bro your suppose to turn the red line 45 degrees

[@anthonyrebuffo9509]

Were and when was the live made

[@CupOfCheese]

I ve watched the live action version of one piece and it isn’t bad

[@kuronekomema]

The world in One Piece is basically, if you took the world in Attack on Titan and made it worse than it should be... racism between humans and fishmen, even the world government has nuclear bomb-class weapons... lol

[@IamGrimalkin]

I feel like after the end of Attack on Titan it's hard to imagine a worse world, and if it exists one piece isn't it.

[@ParaHard]

One Piece fans when you say Gold. Roger

[@maribrooks359]

DONT GIVE IT UP LUFFY, DONT GIVE IT ZORO🗣🗣

[@dragonblast417]

I can believe someone being able to read the entire One Piece manga in 8 days, since I was able to read up to chapter 130 in 1 day, while taking a break and doing house chores.

[@anotherpawn]

Wait what? A fantasy world doesn't work like earth! IMPOSSIBLE!!

[@RickKouwen]

3:42 thanks kaiba 😂

[@Dabi7274]

why is Kaiba the narrator for that? at least it sounds like him

[@saki1333]

Rain powder is a thing you were thinking about. That's how they solve the water problem.

[@Mark_o_Helm]

I think the One Piece is a Fourth Wall Break joke. Like a library of all the One Piece Manga or a TV that plays the anime.😁

[@orioncrawford9618]

He is forgetting the under sea currents

[@passjoey5130]

In the beginning of the rap I thought it was seto kadia

[@thepokekid01]

I remember watching this video and thinking "Why is Matpat focusing so much on ecology when there are a million more obvious reasons to One Piece fans as to why it wouldn't be the best world to just live in!" lol

[@ericsanders9847]

I’ve watched the live action series well so far it is better than any other live action series that is based on any other anime

[@christophermartinez8836]

Do you know about MatPat's new Theory Channels, Food Theory and Style Theory, yet?

[@colddekstar]

The One Piece world is tilted about 45 degrees from what is shown in the video, idt this is important information to the video, but it's tilted in a way where the oceans are in their respective cardinal directions and the Grand Line and Red Line form an X across it

[@mohammadmurie]

It is very important actually because then the water would indeed mix just in their own segment making that whole point nonexist

[@colddekstar]

@@mohammadmurie density still wouldn't allow this That or anime magic

[@colddekstar]

The oceans are still connected, just at a different angle Since the calm belt doesn't mix with the oceans or Grand Line, we can assume it's a different density that keeps it separated Or, if all the oceans are the same density, they still have the calm belt and grand line separating them, we don't have any boundaries the real world between the oceans, it's just arbitrary lines we made up centuries ago, in this world there are lines of totally still water between an ocean and the Grand Line, filled with sea kings that would eat anything that tries to pass through it, plus most saltwater fish aren't acclimated to stillwater, fish are very particular, if they are in water that they just barely aren't used to, they die

[@mrbox9654]

THE ONE PIECE! THE ONE PIECE IS REAL!

[@awesometastic-1017]

So my knowledge of One Piece is YEARS behind the current episodes, but there are so many things on that world - before we even consider magic - that would make no sense. I think Matt was focusing more on the science in that sense, such as “would life be able to survive on this world” and “if life could survive without magical intervention, what would life look like.” Long and short - life would struggle VERY hard on this planet and likely largely exist deep in the sea. Surface waters would be very hot, and land would probably be dominated by some smatterings of terrestrial life in little pockets where conditions were more stable. Most islands would be wastelands, and sea faring would be a death sentence.

[@starburst98]

But without magic the calm belts wouldn't exist, you can't pick and choose which magic is active, ether the world has all magic, or. o magic.

[@hakimalam7753]

We need your honest opinion on LA after this

[@MorePatterrz]

I love it

[@storymaster21]

Wasn't the Alabasta arc literally the plot pf this entire theory video?

[@Nastyn1nja808]

4kids Rap is soooo good but people forget that the Narrator is Brock from Pokémon lpl

[@greenapple9477]

The 4Kids opening for One Piece is probably the only (universally) good thing about 4Kids. For me personally, it exposed to Sonic, which became my first special autistic interest.

[@dragonwaz]

Was the Sonic X theme from 4Kids? Cause that was great too.

[@greenapple9477]

@@dragonwaz Not as cool as the Japanese opening, but I agree.

[@buymesomedogecoindoit3538]

what a weird reaction. Oh well.

[@samueletatani1145]

One error that mat Pat makes destroy the whole theory

[@markangelobacunawa1335]

I would really love for you to watch alan beckers stickman animation, i like to see your opinion

[@omranhamed1272]

Spoilers for egghead arc No the world of one piece is even more advanced but 800 years ago all the tech was erased but some still remains and it's thousands of times more advanced than what we have irl

[@oskarikallio9327]

Am i the only one bothered from that opening song when theres zoro they say dont give it up zolo

[@NgoniTheMango]

listen too rustages anime raps thier like cam steadys

[@kavangallagher30]

make a one piece live action react

[@bazzfromthebackground3696]

Did he like, miss the whole video? The idea behind it *IS* applying real world science to the world of One Piece. Saying "I feel like it would be 'x'" doesn't change the science applied.

[@DarkCipher-1]

To be fair the sceince in the video is just plain WRONG so theyre both basically saying "I feel like it would be 'x'"

[@antonioguerrerolopez591]

Live action, watching it with my sister and yeah I am like he said this, but overall the changes etc it is fun I love it goofy and funny, the live action now so good tbh, I am excited for the other anime live actions, but zom 100 live action was funny but so stupid like I dislikes it a lot ngl it was so bad.

[@Sam_the-man]

Anybody else hate Lluffy’s voice in the live action

[@MR_ZERO230]

Me

[@danielhuelsman76]

The live action version of One Piece is good, and I hope it gets better.

[@HansAdiWijaya]

"japanese dub" wait what isn't japanese is their original language🤔?

[@biggestanimeweeb-kd6lx]

If you watched one piece for kidz you didn't have a childhood

[@madpsycho6]

Never watched the dub of One Piece, only watched the sub.

[@silysloht_slow_man]

Day 7 of asking to watch owl house timeline pls

[@Balajamas]

Meppod

[@rioritasimba6707]

bruh wrong one that was more kiddie dan kiddie bro i watch the actual one that actually had blood

[@dragontrainer-ng1tc]

Another intro better in English is sonic X

[@ziadelbarbir7546]

I watched one piece in 2 days

[@zacharybenn1497]

MatPat assumes that the world of one piece has the same tilt as earth and the position in the solar system in relation to the sun is also the same but it isn’t. I Oda has actually given us specifics on things like the tilt of the planet so this theory is just straight up wrong if you so much as apply the tiniest bit of logic.

[@mt32boi45]

Matpat 100% learned the lore through the wiki /hj

[@plaqueywakey5631]

Alright then Considering that, how would the world of one piece be if real world logic was applied to it?

[@lolface_9363]

From what I’ve seen it’s literally got basically the same amount of tilt as the earth

[@shinycaterpie4443]

​@@plaqueywakey5631If you applied all the scientific principles Matpat did none of them would be an issue. Here's 2 examples: 1)The Redline isn't big enough to leave HALF THE PLANET dry. The 1st 2 Islands in the Grandline, Whiskey Peak and Little Garden, are even summer islands so we do get to see the effect he talks about take place and everything is fine because, again, the Red line isn't big enough to have that effect THAT far away from it 2)The Grandline is not the equator, it is 45° to it. That means that most of the Grandline isn't being drastically heated by the sun like he suggested and 2 of the 4 blues have sections that do sit on the equator so instead it does have the sea currents in the one piece world disperse heat in basically the same way our world does just in "smaller" sections than ours (smaller is in quotes because the world is much bigger than ours so those sections are actually bigger but a smaller % of the planet)

[@plaqueywakey5631]

@@shinycaterpie4443 point 1 i thought of when i watched but in point 2, if the two lines are 45 degrees of the equator, wouldn't that mean 2 of the 4 oceans don't receive enough warm water?

[@DC-rb3uz]

Matpat vedios are just based on theories not fax like he didn't address the fact that one piece has six moons which means one piece planet has to be mush bigger then our planet so op islands be mush bigger. Edit: One Piece planet is 84% the size of our Sun. no hate to matpat but theory was fail from start.

[@Cl1fges1de16-bw5gw]

HA HA HA HAAAA was my reaction when mat pat said only 1000 episodes those are small numbers compared to the amount of Pokémon episodes there are

[@trashboat5388]

Too bad everything in the video was false and was already answered in the manga and anime

[@swapnarupbarua4668]

When u have a 🧠 of a size of a 🥜

[@Pancake_001]

as a one piece fan at ep 800ish I CAN NOT Believe you like the 4kids DUB its the worst thing ever its making odas masterpiece into some crappy thing

[@dinofun8063]

No idea what one piece is

[@PurpleHeartE54]

Then why are you here? A fan of Patterrz perhaps?

[@elviswilliams1131]

For real?

[@Bengt2509]

@@PurpleHeartE54that’s why i’m here. i’ve heard of one piece but still haven’t watched it, but i still watch this because it’s patterz

[@Bengt2509]

⁠@@elviswilliams1131it’s not that hard to believe someone hasn’t heard of a show, for example i never heard of dragon ball or dbz until a few years ago, and it’s not like everyone knows one piece

[@fakereal-qe6jx]

first view and like

[@RiotIglol]

Too late I was first fam

[@dellgo2456]

booh i dont agree with matpat

[@MuzammilButt-pn3ns]

it looks so bad

[@bryananimation342]

Shut up i want to listen to game theory

[@VSiFer]

The English dub is so bad... 🤢

[@gaminglol5492]

Well okay

[@Pancake_001]

as a one piece fan at ep 800ish I CAN NOT Believe you like the 4kids DUB its the worst thing ever its making odas masterpiece into some crappy thing