What If Obi-Wan Kenobi SURVIVED the Death Star (Star Wars What Ifs)

[@jackbaccarat4084]

What if dooku stayed to train anakin after phantom menace. Had the council saw fit to have the master of qui gon jin take on the chosen one after the demise of his former student. How would this change the narrative of the story. Would this accelerate anakin's fall, could we see dooku be redeemed, how would this impact obi wan?

[@fallsong1050]

Oooo I'd love to see this

[@crusader2112]

This needs to happen.

[@fearthepiggaming2998]

I have suggested this one myself. Dooku would have been a solid master for Anakin and I think the 2 would probably have a rough start but would eventually have nearly as good of a bond as him and Obi eventually did With the added bonus of the count actually demanding some respect.

[@jamie_michelson]

A very good suggestion. I asked that myself multiple times + Dooku is one of my fav characters so I can´t say no to What If like this! Would love to see PPSW write a story about this 😎👌

[@devinroebuck2311]

I love this idea ❤️

[@ogracid9883]

Man really just made his own starwars script. Respect.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@michellechen1726]

Can you make one where If Ben told Luke the truth about Vader as his father instead of lying to Luke.

[@bones0013]

​@@michellechen1726 intresting

[@Zobbtuna]

While listening to this I was seeing comic book like art in my head. Luke in a stance reminiscent of Anakin, Leia in stance like young obi wan with the two fingers, and obi wan standing like Qui Gon. Damn that would be a badass cover.

[@dewforpolitics]

Star Wars Elseworlds did a version of this. Yours and theirs is excellent. And yes Luke and Leia would kill Vader seeing how far he was gone as Obi Wan telling them the truth early on would lessen the impact of them ever turning to the dark side or not bothering trying to sway Anakin back to the light. Good video

[@oscarjacquot]

I don’t see it on his channel

[@dallasweasley2521]

Not gonna lie giving r2 ptsd like that is so sad but also the cutest but it's only cute in the sad kinda way 🥲🥲🥲

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

The worst part is that’s actually canon😭😭

[@blackcat940]

What if Anakin had visions of order 66 instead of padme dying of childbirth? What if shmi skywalker had a child with Clegg Lars? What if Anakin went undercover instead of Obi-Wan? What if tup went to the jedi temple instead of getting the atomic brain scan?

[@DarknessSlayerXX]

Thanks Pente Patrol Star Wars For Your Awesome Videos

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@stewlittle13]

What if Mace Windu waited until the rest of the Council returned to arrest Palpatine.

[@melindakilbourn7904]

This was a almost perfect story but when Ben slowly lowered Vader to the ground with tears in his eyes he should have told Vader that Luke and Leia's was his children and or had anakins force ghost show up for the last fight with palpatine and help kill him. I'm a total vader/anakin fan. That would of been perfect. Thank you

[@raycavazos8927]

In this timeline, Yoda doesn't die and finally moves past his exile after Sidious' death. He goes on to start a ballin ass line of starfighters call ToYoda.

[@thetacticalpagan5859]

I like how all your what ifs take place in the disney what if universe.

[@williamafton1353]

the instant hello catches me off guard everytime

[@jprice6419]

What if Yoda and Ben opened a Jedi school with the Skywalker babies? What if Maul only used a normal lightsaber? What if the Emperor cloned Mace from his Arm? What if Thrawn was an loyal advisor to the Jedi during the clone wars?

[@jeraldhall4603]

I enjoyed this story, however within this story exists another what if, during the story when Obi-Wan, Luke and Leia were facing Vader for the final fight and Vader recognized his old Lightsaber, Luke and Leia could have sensed that and confronted Vader revealing they they were his children, how would this have effected the rest of the story going forward. This was not a criticism just an idea of a twist in the story you relayed.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I honestly thought about doing that, but I feel like it would’ve taken away from the tension that was being built by the fight

[@davidalan528]

I had the same thought, but so many what-ifs go that route that it’s refreshing to occasionally just skip the revelation.

[@jacobkochanowicz9856]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Can you please please please make a what if Bly and Aayla feel in love video please please can you make the video?

[@typicalcanyon1283]

@@jacobkochanowicz9856 honestly I find myself growing sick of the love stories

[@aguest8150]

@@jacobkochanowicz9856 I like the idea as bly and Aayla could have surprise with that but she was with kit far before she met bly

[@JayF2912]

Nice! Really loved to see Kyle Katarn here in a story; PLEASE include him in more!

[@3.75istheway7]

Wow bud, your channel is growing fast! Well deserved! You are my favorite fan fictions writer on KZbin! 100%

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@JaceBakke3011]

This man the the G.O.A.T when it comes to what ifs

[@ranpan6082]

I know I've suggested this before, but what if Anakin killed Obi-Wan (Rako Hardeen) on Orondia? We saw how angry he became learning about the deception, and probably had shaken his faith in the Jedi and damaged his relationship with Obi-Wan. Yoda and Windu having to reveal the truth. I could see this pulling Anakin to the Dark Side and right into Palpatine's hands.

[@SheoTheFox]

I've been hoping for someone to make that one too

[@bizmasterTheSlav]

Suggestion: What if Darth Tenebrus' plan to make jedi obsolete while not destroying them physically worked? What if he did build a society so advanced that jedi would become obsolete and sith can take power?

[@thekaiser3815]

I'll add to that, what if the plane worked too well and the Sith themselves became obsolete?

[@JohnGeorgeBauerBuis]

@@thekaiser3815 This is a clever twist.

[@Fancast100]

Have you ever thought of doing a what if about what if Padme survived Child Birth and became a founder of the rebellion?

[@The_Shadow.Runner]

That’s a good idea

[@chrissummers2420]

That was one of your best. Disney should give you a job. Your stories feel like old school Star Wars.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@kappakiev9672]

What if Captain Rex raised Luke? Great video as always

[@notapplicable1296]

Add Ahsoka to that what if Rex and Ahsoka raised Luke and Obi-wan and Rabe'' raised Leia. Each twin being trained young. Luke being trained as a solider and jedi. Leia being trained as a Jedi and spy.

[@-Mankis]

Great video! I must say, you have much better script ideas than those at Disney.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@Milkman9833.]

your right

[@datruelordofdarings1274]

What if Ezra Bridger was the chosen one? Idk it just seems like he is in the perfect position to be the one to defeat the sith in Rebels. With mentors such as Obi Wan, Ahsoka, and Kanan (who is a criminally slept on character) along with possibly Maul (who could be a dark influence so he can learn to balance both the light and the dark side). Idk it was just an idea.

[@chocolatebust4342]

Personally(and factually) rebels is garbage

[@Wryyyyydio]

I mean true

[@Khrono_03]

yesssss

[@locoarticwolf2181]

Love the story and the various references to KOTOR 2, Kyle Katarn and other pieces of lore. The climax of these stories always pays off this one as well with the Duel rematch. Look forward to more and to see if any of them top your tops ones.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@FernandoLopez-oh4ys]

What if Obi-Wan went with Mace Windu to arrest Palpatine. The council would send a different Jedi and Obi-Wan would stay in the temple. Would Obi-Wan die along side with the others, who know?

[@jasonskeans3327]

well with obi there i feel like Aniken wouldn't have attacked mace

[@horseradishpower9947]

Why didn't Obi-Wan use Force Projection, like Luke used in The Last Jedi, disabling the tractor beam, and fighting Vader remotely? Seems an obvious way to have him survive to me.

[@goofboy96]

5th attempt of what if Anakin Skywalker and Galen Marek were rivals and trained together. 🥲

[@willamahrens538]

Great stuff. Thank you for these stories. Of course I have to chime in with future story suggestions. What if the Force was turned off and unavailable all of the sudden? I'd like to hear this especially during the time of Moff Tarkin, who I think would take over the Empire.

[@stewlittle13]

What if Obi-Wan & Yoda found Reva & Grogu at the Jedi Temple during Order 66.

[@Doobie0113]

At 51:24 now and I'm assuming that after the destruction of the death star Vader didn't hire boba Fett to try and track down information as to who Luke was. But considering Luke was with Obi wan at this time, I don't think he'd have been able to find him anyways

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

You are a very talented man for writing these Star Wars fan fictions , you got me watching / listening to these like they are mini movies because to me they are keep it up I’m in major support of what you do 🔥. - 👑Kingz #RKA👥

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@toptiergaming6900]

If I was in command of that 3rd SSD over Coriscant after the first 2 where destroyed by the Eclipse, I would have just decided "screw this" and just fired afew turbolasers at Palpatine's house and hoped the rebels accept me

[@karlvincentwillett4977]

I always wondered, "What if" this had happened ... thanks for answering this for me.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@CameronLogic]

Been waiting for this one, I cannot wait to watch

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@brokenbridge6316]

It was great seeing a "What if" like this one play out. I enjoyed this video a lot.

[@ItzSam._.324]

Darth was so pissed off he didn't even say anything to palpy

[@Exaris79]

In the comics before Return of the Jedi, without any training Leia was able to use phase shift walking thru walls as well as dimensional jump. It's short range but enough to escape her situation. The DeathStar should had blown Ryloth's moon instead of the planet. There's still a lot of collateral damage, but Ryloth still needs to evacuate.

[@Capsicle11]

What is padme lived and lived on Naboo and raised her kids and as they got older trained them with kenobie to try and save their father and succeed and finally get to live together.

[@FireballGrix]

Your stories are so beautiful!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@ScorpiusAkaTemplate]

1:02:00 then you mentioned Kyle Katarn and Hera watching for him like Kanan I understand quickly. Hera Syndulla ana Jan Ors (from Legend) have the same voice actress. I got you, men ! :D

[@Mark71697]

Always a pleasure to watch your vids

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@locoarticwolf2181]

-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies? -What if Revan escaped the Maelstrom Prison during the Clone Wars? -What if Anakin WAS granted the Rank of Master when appointed to the Jedi Council? -What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66? -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy? -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic? -What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious? -What if Grevious became Force Sensitive /can us the Force after that blood transfusion from Siyo Dias during his cybernetics reconstruction? -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1? -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc? -What if Luke never gave up during the Sequels and gathered/trained more Jedi and prepared? -What if Luke found Rey and ACTUALLY TRAINED her at the Jedi School he founded?

[@johnnybhoff226]

I love these really long episodes. It’s just super exciting and relaxing. Almost feature length. If we ever get a 2-3 hour episode I’ll go crazy (I know there’s one episode already 2 hours but who wouldn’t want more xD)

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Lmaoo y'all making me work lmao

[@johnnybhoff226]

@@PentePatrolStarWars I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to pressure you. Keep doing what you do.

[@jacobkochanowicz9856]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Can you please please please make a what if Bly and Aayla feel in love video please?

[@chuala428]

18:10 imagine if Grievous went in front and said GENERAL KENOBI THOSE LIGHTSABERS WOULD MAKE A FINE ADDITION TO MY COLLECTION

[@Bigbear-pi7nv]

Obi Wan was literally the Goat in terms of sith killing. He killed Maul and general grevious and trained the person who killed Dooku and Palpatine.

[@notapplicable1296]

I don't remember watching this though I know I did. Brilliant even more so on this 2nd watch. Thank you for actually making Leia a relevant character instead of a half successful prop that is just there to produce Ben. For years Luke was my favorite, then I read a few Leia books and what not and realized the wasted potential of Leia Organa Solo. So Again THANK YOU for not wasting her

[@tylergranger2159]

What if Yularen joined the Rebel Alliance? What if Anakin Skywalker seeks balance? What if there was a Second Blackwing Virus Outbreak during the Galactic Civil War? What if the Sith Purebloods didn't go extinct? What if Darth Bane had premonitions of Darth Sidious breaking and abolishing the Rule of Two? What if Darth Bane fought Darth Vader? What if Exar Kun fought Vader and Sidious? What if Darth Zannah was in the Galactic Civil War? What if Darth Bane had premonitions of turning Anakin Skywalker, a Jedi, to the Dark Side? What if Palpatine was Vitiate? What if the Eternal Alliance returned in the Galactic Civil War? What if Darth Malgus returned during the events of the Clone Wars? What if Darth Krayt got his revenge on Vader and Sidious?

[@no_respect_k_y_s]

what if palpy was vitiate is pretty brutal

[@Batman-ys2qy]

Carth's ghost is seething rn

[@ericcrabtree7075]

What if anakin found HK-47 Statement: greetings meatbags (Padme and Qui Gon )

[@3.75istheway7]

I think Vader knew that the rebels would defeat the Death Star and used the excuse of going out to fight as a smoke screen to get out of the Death Star just in case! And he ended up escaping the destruction of the Death Star!

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

He could have already seen a vision or even sensed the danger.

[@chaospony9923]

What if the Jedi Council had still refused to allow Anakin to be trained and he stayed on Naboo? What if Anakin had joined the Jedi Service Corps like the Explorational Corps instead of the Jedi Order itself? What if after killing Darth Plagueis Palpatine had abandoned the rule of two ASAP?

[@mercury2157]

the first one would just result in Sidious getting to him faster

[@Scurvybubble242]

What if dooku killed palpatine on the invisible hand when he was talking to Ani and obi

[@notapplicable1296]

53:00 Skywalker family drama begins. 56:00 Boss mode Leia doing her thang with a lil help from Ben

[@ovni2295]

One of the things that keeps coming up in these fanfics is how people think relationships = attachments, even though it's been expounded again and again that wasn't what was meant by the writers. It's kind of odd!

[@crusader2112]

Another banger. Keep up the great work. ✌🏻

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@crusader2112]

@@PentePatrolStarWars No problem 😉👍

[@Zionbahzard]

I got a good one for ya Pente "What if Obi-wan and Satine were either Anakin or Lukes parents in the order.

[@TotallyAndy]

What If Qui-Gon survived? What If Luke and Anakin switched roles? What If Obi-Wan turned to the dark side insted of Anakin? What If Rex killed Ahsoka? What If Anakin didn't get burned and get his limbs cut off? (Anakin still doesn't win, he just gets stabbed) What If Vader overthrew the Emperor?

[@Ammy-q4w]

If Anakin never became Darth Vader, that would mean he would still most likely be around as a father figure for both Luke and Leia, and this could be an Anakin who either never fell to the darkness or did, but realized the error of his ways and left before he could ever become Darth Vader. Luke & Leia would both get jedi training at a young age, resulting in their family having a lot of influence over the galaxy. I could see Luke succumbing to darkness as a result of feeling overlooked by both his father and sister who have more of an influence on the galaxy than him, and maybe Luke would be the scapegoat who would have to clean up their messes after they make mistakes whereas Palpatine would actually recognize both his power and potential encouraging Luke to join the dark side. The real question would be how this gets resolved, because Luke would be very powerful since he was trained from an earlier age, and with Palpatine backing him, they would be the greatest threats the galaxy has ever seen. Anakin would be the one to fight Palpatine and Leia would fight Luke.

[@Doobie0113]

Damn. Homie died without even knowing he had children. Sheesh. Tough way to go out. Wonderfully written though haha

[@dissectingdiy]

What if he survived? We would have a lot more hello there.

[@jimeley2580]

Love it! Still in excellent form!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@YAHUAHSsavagewarrior183]

as a Writer myself I respect your channel

[@zerrierslizer1]

the Empire destoying Riloth is the only thing i see as VERY unlikely, seeing as Riloth has materials needed to create Durasteel, which is a major material needed for armor, weapons and even ship productions. if the Empire destroyed Riloth, they would lose 40% of the material income they needed to effectively create Durasteel.

[@jamie_michelson]

Once again an excellent What If PPSW. Love seeing you grow so fast As I told you like only 2 or 3 months ago (maybe even less), patience will pay off and it looks like it did 🥰👍

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@jamie_michelson]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Yeah, let´s keep it rocking 😎👌

[@bweakland2003]

"Remember that it's not about strategy, it's about master flanks." Wouldn't a master flank part of your strategy?

[@CelticDragon0]

Nice job mixing canon and legends PPSW

[@ytuser2272]

Bro Vader really obliterated Ryloth. There goes the home of the Twi'leks. Still, nice work on the video

[@Snowthree]

Thought. Maybe retell Episode IV, but have all the characters be played by different characters of the same actor. I.E. Luke is Fire Lord Ozai/The Joker/some other character played by Mark Hamill, Han is Indiana Jones/James Marshell/etc, and so forth. Or... go the exact OPPOSITE direction and miscast them as badly as possible! Like, I dunno, Yoda being played by Mr. T! "I pity the fool who gives in to the dark side!'

[@raidmain1400]

Chewie also met several Jedi, he met Ashoka and the Youngling at the hunting grounds

[@thekaiser3815]

Determined ineptitude, i like that.

[@taramanning8996]

I see a lot of 'what if' that for some reason include Leia as a Jedi. She showed absolutely zero Force sensitivity. Sometimes you have to just let that ghost go folks.

[@BadenAW]

I legit felt a few tears fall at the Darth Vader death

[@benjaminobienu5297]

This is a lovely story you made with Obi-Wan surviving and how he survived from being killed by Darth Vader has a significant impact on the characters if he were alive in the original trilogy. How able sense Han is a good person despite his toughness pirate facade, which reminds him of that fake Jedi when he went to that planet to rescue Leia. What was his name, and what was the world Obi-Wan went to rescue Leia again? With Obi-Wan lived instead of fading into the force, and his revealed telling the truth to Luke and Leia that Darth Vader is their father is a big deal. In the original timeline, Luke learns the truth in a tragic way from Darth Vader, who for he reveals to him he is his father, and we get the ionic NO scene in the Star Wars Franchise. With Obi-Wan not being killed off and told to Luke and Leia about their father, Anakin Skywalker is Darth Vader; the siblings wouldn't have been surprised if Vader were revealed as their father if they tried to persuade joining him. What bothers me is that Luke is being ungrateful towards Obi-Wan for blaming him for not being the father figure he wanted. Luke should be grateful that Obi-Wan placed him into a lovely family that treated him way better. I'm saying this because Dumbledore did not consider if the Dursdeuly would want to take Harry in, especially Petrina ( Lily Potter's sister and mother Harry Potter) would hate for Harry for the reminder of Lily being more talented than her. I don't know if Petunia mourns or feels grief when her sister is killed by Lord Voldemort. I don't know what the relationship between Anakin and Owen was; I do bet Owen may care for Anakin when he met him before he massacred the Tusken raiders. And could have comforted Anakin and been happy for Anakin living life far away from Tatooine. Owen may be stern, but he does care for Luke a lot and does show it, and he actually fended off Reva, who tries to Luke for revenge against Anakin for what he did to her in the temple all these years ago. The way wanted to leave with Luke and his wife for their safety, but Beru wished to stay and fight and was willing to die for Luke, unlike Petrina and Vernon, would be happier if Harry had been killed or left for dead. So, in my opinion, Owen is a better uncle and great second father for Luke, and Beru is better than Petrina, for she wouldn't have a grudge against the child if she had a sibling who is way better at things; it wouldn't be her character. So what's better, Luke lived a normal childhood without mistreatment despite Anakin's reputation and treated him like he was their son and their only child. But I do have a question related to this topic. Would Owen and Beru treat Luke the same or different if they had their own children? If so, would Owen spoil his biological children with affection like Vernon did with Dudley, or would Owen treat his biological children and Luke the same as his own kids? What is your opinion on what things would be like if Owen had children and Luke came along? Would he be cast aside, given up for adoption, or still be loved? What is your opinion and why? Do you see what I'm trying to explain and tell the difference between the Lars and the Dursleys? Anyhow, with Obi-Wan serving and becoming Grand Master of the New Jedi Order, he now faces the reality that his friend and brother Anakin Skywalker is now part of the Force and Darth is no more. This could be an emotional final blow for Obi-Wan, for he had been failing his friend for the rest of his life. Luke and Leia are not going to have the father they always heard from Obi-Wan and had to deal with the fact they killed their father in a way to prevent him from causing more harm or inflicting pain across the galaxy. The Rebellion gained significant support from many planets and the destruction of the super star destroyers. The Galactic Empire had collapsed way faster than our original timeline with Obi-Wan lived. Many people in Coursconat, the capital of the Imperial regime, protested and welcomed the Rebels as heroes since they were fighting for freedom and democracy. While Emperor Palpatine, high-ranking Imperials, and Moffs were oppressing their own people without considering people could retaliate if they kept using fear, violence, and oppression and refused to invest more in the economy to improve the daily lives of the citizens. Anyway, this is a great chapter, my friend, for Obi-Wan survived in this alternate universe has made the Rebellion more significant in equal footing and upper advantage what the Galactic Empire lacked. That is better leadership, communication, respected staff, improvisation, and understanding of the values of what they are fighting for. My apologies for trying to compare Obi-Wan Kenobi to Dumbeldore and Lars to Dursleys. I just want to tell the difference between the two families, and Luke is grateful to have a loving and caring relative family who shows him love and affection. This is an awesome what-if video, Mr. Pente Patrol; keep good with the awesome you're doing, and remember, always try your best when things get tough, and May force is with you!

[@darkpone3731]

What if Qui-Gon's Force Ghost mentored Luke after the First Death Star.

[@crusader2112]

Ooh yes.

[@samanthaadams619]

Very good call!

[@cloebird123414]

What if Satine spoke to Anakin at Obi-Wan’s fake funeral. They were the only ones to really show a lot of emotions at the ceremony. In the episode I’m assuming Satine left with Padmé after but what if she was the last to leave besides Anakin and she decided to say something to him. “A whole funeral of mourners and it seems… we are the two who feel his loss the keenest. I presume we also have the most regrets…” I like the idea of something like that because it would go one of two days when it comes to saving or damning Anakin. It plants more resentment of the Jedi but more importantly I think Anakin would ask him for answers about his relationship with Satine, giving him more trust asking Obi-Wan for help with the visions of Padmé Or “The loyal brother and… and the woman who loves him. We are the true mourners” she pulls a flower from her cloak and speaks something loving in Mandoa as she twists the flower between her fingers, smells it and places it on the closed door on the floor. She looks back to Anakin “I thought we would have time after the war, maybe a second chance,” she stops herself “my apologies, excuse me,” and she leaves. That sorta thing would spur on Anakin’s anger to find the killer and increase his hate of the war. But when everything’s said and done with the undercover mission Anakin would push Obi-Wan for answers and Anakin would decide to leave the order after the war. Would Obi-Wan agree to do the same. But then I wonder if Anakin would then leave early with Ahsoka or see the war through

[@DarknessSlayerXX]

- What If Anakin Was Still Rejected By The Jedi Order Even After "Phantom Menace" - What If Yoda Trained Anakin - What If Dooku Trained Anakin - What If Barriss Offee Framed Anakin Instead Of Ahsoka - What If Anakin Was Trained By Revan's Spirit Or Just A Descendent Of Revan - What If Starkiller Survived "The Force Unleashed 1" - What If Cal Kestis Form "Fallen Order" Was Either Obi Wan Or Anakin's Padawan - What If Yoda Raised Both Luke & Leia - What If Star Wars Legends & The Movies Were Connected "With Some Minor Differences"

[@Brick_Sage]

Love the videos keep them coming. I believe that what if the prequels were written and then the original would be interesting because I believe that a lot of the weaker aspects of the prequels were due to them having to have the outcome of Vader and the empire. But what if the prequels were the original trilogy and how different would that make the Star Wars universe

[@Zachvonbarron]

What if Anakin was raised by Jango Fett? What if Obi Wan and Shaak Ti were in love? Attempt 15 1/2, and it’s my birthday 🥳

[@aqurium3255]

yea nice do a what if anakin accidently sliced padme when the poisonous bugs climbed on her in attack of the clones ive asked this alot

[@bcovington3811]

Henceforth you shall be known as doff somebody please give me a dark name

[@Dahaka-rd6tw]

What if jedi council learned about Anakin's attack on Tuskens?

[@nathanharris25]

what if luke stayed on dagugba

[@brennanvilcheck9469]

Idea: What if Cody never gave Obi-Wan Back his lightsaber on Utapau? (Or what if Obi-Wan lost his lightsaber on Utapau Cody almost started to walk away before he seemed to remember it. What if Cody never returned it and forgot?

[@peterpidrak9501]

Wow, well, if Obi-Wan has been defiling, Anakin no wonder he turned to the dark side.

[@charlescouch4733]

Well done sir. Loved it

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@jordanlane870]

I always love when obi wan lived what if obi wan killed Vader in their second fight

[@TheMimiSard]

One thign that occurs to me is that the surviving Twi'Leks are far more widespread and populous compared to the Alderani survivors, for the simple truth of how common enslaving Twi-Leks happen to be. I think it would possibly drive more slave rebellions, with the Twi'Leks wanting to coalesce for the sake of survival and re-establish their culture.

[@GcubePlayer8]

PPSW my favourite KZbinr who thinks rerecording audio is overrated

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Lmao

[@LovesCoffee]

Once again a masterpiece of a video. MORE!!!! May the force be with you

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@KuDastardly]

It makes me wonder why no one has thought to restore the old Jed'aii Order.

[@jackolantern147]

This was a very good one. But I would be remiss if I did not give my 2 credits on a few things I have noticed regarding the story. I mean no disrespect whatsoever, but things just seemed to go too easy for our heroes. 1.There's no way Vader would sit out the battle of Ryloth to watch the planet blow up. If anything, he would probably be on the first fighter out to vent his fury on the Rebels. 2. If Vader did survive the battle then he should play a much greater role in the story of the heroes. If Kenobi survived and was training new Jedi then he would have an even bigger target on his back than before. Vader would take his pursuit of Kenobi to new heights, with Palpatine giving him the full support of the Empire. Him sensing the growing light and his greatest fear of a new Jedi order coming true, placing the threat of a new Jedi order over the Rebellion. Which could give the Rebels a chance to win the support they did, with the Empires enforcer occupied elsewhere. 3. In exchange for the ease on the Rebellion, the Jedi would have Vader on their tails and would force them to flee more than once. Vader would likely learn that Luke was his son during his pursuit through Boba Fett like he did in Canon. 4. Having the Rebels take the Eclipse seems to give them too good an advantage, especially if they are reinforced with the Mon Calamari and other ships from various planets. Having it as an imperial ace in reserve seems a better fit for the dreadnought, plus it would be a worthy replacement for Vader on the front lines. 5. Vader dying by the Jedis hands, never learning of his children seems like a underwhelming end. He could fight them, but, maybe one on one with Luke while the forces of the Empire hold off the other 2. Giving them their first interaction with a lightsaber, and escaping him with the aid of Kenobi and Leia. With Luke believing he could be redeemed and Leia with Kenobi trying to sway him against it, creating tension between the Jedi. 6. Palpatine would call Vaders hunt to Coruscant to reinforce the planet and let the Jedi come to them. With the Eclipse and Vader, the Empire seems much stronger and gives real tension for the Jedi and Rebellion alike. 7. The Battle of Coruscant would play out a lot like the battle for Endor, with Vader fighting Luke and Palpatine fighting Leia and Kenobi. After an intense duel, Palpatine incapacitates Kenobi and tortures Leia with lightning. Luke would break off his fight with Vader and rush Palpatine, letting his feelings burst forth. Letting Vader know that Leia was his daughter. With both of his children being beaten and tortured by Palpatine and Kenobi defenseless on the other side of the room, he has to choose whether to finnaly kill Kenobi or save his children. Vader chooses to save his family. Fighting alongside Luke, they are able to defeat Sidious, with Anakin ending the nightmare at the cost of his own life. Anakin dies having brought balance to the force and in the arms of his family and master. 8. With Palpatien gone, the imperial forces falter and the rebellion is able to win the battle, although the Eclipse escapes into unknown space. To fade into legend as a ghost ship until it returns decades later as the flagship for the reborn Emperor. Those are my critiques on the story. Again, I mean no disrespect, It just seemed too easy for the heroes in certain areas and too rushed for the villains.Vader dying on a far off planet without ever knowing of his family seemed like the wrong course of action, plus it undermines Luke's character, believing his redemption was possible. Plus the fight with Palpatine and the Empire seemed like it was over before it began with victory after victory for the aliance. Thank you for reading this to the end, and again, I mean no offense by writing this, just a small critique from one Star Wars fan to another for anyone to enjoy. May the force be with you.

[@deerhunter7420]

Idea what if obi wan did not age quickly

[@notapplicable1296]

50:00 __ Skywalker family reunion 2-ABY___ wouldn't be a family get together without lightsabers

[@TheTeutonicPlague]

Hey you delivered on my idea! Hell yeah!! 😎

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

;)

[@typicalcanyon1283]

You’d think that it would be hard to gain sympathy for a battle station litterally named the Death Star

[@jameslightfoot1872]

Obi-Wan didn't lie about R2-D2. He said he never owned a droid, not that he never saw one. R2 was never Obi-Wan's droid. He told the truth, just not all of the truth.

[@brainiacworld71]

What If: Mace Windu waited for the council to return to Arrest Palpatine? What If: Ashoka Tano trained Ezra? What If: Maul Told Obi-Wan the True Sith Lord? What If: Commander Bly, Baccara, and Wolffe removed their chips? What If: Caleb Dume died and Depa Billaba lived? What If: Grogu Chose to be a Jedi? What If: The Rancor Ate Luke? What If: Han Solo did not survive the Carbo Freeze process? What If: Jesse killed Ashoka? What If: Kit Fisto trained Ashoka? What If: Oppo Rancisis Trained Anakin? What If: Coleman Kcaj Trained Anakin? What If: Yaddle Trained Anakin? What If: Yarael Poof Trained Anakin? What If: Kit Fisto and Aayla Secura fell in love? Please reply your fav. if you want to

[@Fhfjgndnf]

My fav is What If: Mace Windu waited for the council to return to Arrest Palpatine? since it might have changed the timeline drastically

[@crusader2112]

@@Fhfjgndnf Same 😎👍

[@imab0t274]

Imagine Vader trying to find and turn his son to the dark side just to find out that he had been eaten by a rancor

[@brainiacworld71]

@@imab0t274 He will be like "Oh sh*t my master is going to electrocute me

[@achuris77]

Destroying Ryloth, an imperial occupied world, literally made no sense. At all...

[@joshuasassaman450]

What if Mara Jade had successfully assassinated Luke Skywalker on Tatooine?

[@TheChosenOne_Anakin]

Bruh

[@00martoneniris86]

What if revan conquered the Republic What if revan Redeemed Darth MALAK