Pizza review: PATSY'S PIZZERIA (Brooklyn, NY) since 1933!

[@Jamesnu]

I've only been to the original Patsy's, but it's great to hear that the other locations are in line with the quality of the first restaurant.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

Loved the OG spot too. I actually liked this a little better because it was the MARGHERITA.

[@genebigs1749]

I just ate and now I'm hungry again. I haven't been to Patsy's in a while, it's time to head back there again! Thanks for the review!

[@s.macintosh-jc9rf]

Hi Antonio, Thanks for your review of Patsy’s Pizza 🍕. This pizza looks absolutely beautiful 🤩 to me! I always enjoy your reviews and your folksy manner! Best Wishes, Peter

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

Thank you for the feedback. :)

[@garychaiken808]

Great job. Thank you 😊

[@EricNickerson-f5q]

Great review 💯 Thank You

[@mikejohn7273]

Do u remember when tony owned a patsy's on richmond ave bk in the day it was good to it's a shame not enough people knew about it.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

Can't say I remember that. There's several locations. This place was spot on, the staff was great. Pizza as well.

[@mikejohn7273]

It was were enzo and tinos bakery was the old strawberry farms it was just like original patsy's same color scheme to green and white I think tony was frds with them the pizza was good.

[@dirkdiggler9482]

Wow, that looked as close to a coal fired Neapolitan pie as I've ever seen. Only the cornicione was a bit small compared to one. That's one of those places where the history is as appealing as the pizza. It's hard to say if that's the original oven, but it certainly looks old, and they're not making any effort to make it look fancy. I was aware that there was some connection between the place and Frank Sinatra, but I didn't know he actually mentioned it in a song. Now I'm curious which song it was. From what I remember of the review of the old place, it seemed like you went there on an off day, and this one looked better.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

I'm trying to find the song where Frank mentioned Patsy's. Oh the history is very much a main draw as well as the excellent pizza. If you can, try to see if you can find a photo of the original oven in Harlem. It's truly beautiful. This oven seems to be shaped in the same spirit as the original. Yeah, I went to the Harlem spot during the pandemic and it wasn't as well done, but I still enjoyed it. That wasn't the Marghertia though, but this was and I liked it better.

[@dirkdiggler9482]

@@pizzareviewsonthego that’s right, I forgot that this was a new location and that oven would not be very old.

[@cjaquilino]

@@dirkdiggler9482Sally’s and Patsy’s are the only two pizzerias I’ve seen Sinatra mention. There’s also an old clip on KZbin of him eating a slice from a place he thought wasn’t that good.

[@dirkdiggler9482]

@@cjaquilino I wouldn’t mind looking that up if you know the name of the place.

[@ramencurry6672]

I could be wrong but I think when Sinatra ate pizza, he mostly had it picked up by his assistants or some kind of delivery service. Same with Elvis. Back then they were so famous that they didn’t want to cause a spectacle for the small casual outings

[@dwaynewladyka577]

Margherita pizza is my favorite pizza. That pie looks awesome to me. The calamari also looks really good. Cheers, Antonio! 👍🏻👍🏻✌️

[@ramencurry6672]

I agree. You can’t forget the calamari because outside of the Northeast, it’s usually rare

[@PESTNewsNetwork]

I remember hearing that Harlem patsy’s sold their recipes to conglomerate that franchised them.

[@crostofor]

Great Review! 🍕 🐙 👍

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

Glad you liked it

[@rbiv5]

Looks great. I always thought the other Patsy's restaurants' were pretenders and not affiliated with the original one. Good to know the truth now!

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

They are affiliated. Same logo, coal oven, and the pizza quality is the same at all the various locations.

[@danielj3010]

THAT'S A NINE ALL DAY ON THE PLAY!!

[@TheBbtlegit]

That looks Delicious. Yes indeed

[@NoahEats]

Had the cheese slice in Harlem. Need to go back for that Margherita!

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

I had the cheese at the Harlem spot too. I heard they undercook them there, I liked this pizza better.

[@tonycamaj7243]

My personal favorite pizza from patsy’s in Harlem.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

I reviewed the original spot

[@YESIIIl]

Unbelievable 🇬🇧 here religiously watch you and portnoys pizza reviews yours is for the real ones tho

[@bb57365]

Went to the Harlem location a few years ago. Was disappointed, compared to Totono’s or John’s. Too lite of a pie for me. But it did look good.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

I get it, sometimes I want a thin, light pie though and this delivered. I scored it the same as Totonno's...or almost the same...

[@cafelate9515]

I am a serious pizza eater and I judge pizza by the look first then taste. Based on the look factor without trying it, I see it lacked in sauce and cheese. I wished they added a little more sauce and cover the entire pie with more cheese so I don’t see empty spots there. The dough has to be light and Krispy. Lately I had pizza and once the pizza gets cold the crust is hard like crazy. So I am watching your videos and I want to learn how to judge how a pizza is. Based on the pizzas out there I see them getting smaller and smaller and the price is getting higher and higher. As a kid back in the 70s and 80s they made good pizza back then now it is so so at best. So I want to see what is good out there and give my hard earn money and try.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

Oh this pizza is from the 30s. Crust is light. It's great if you are in the mood for light pizza, not too cheesy either.

[@kirkdavis2881]

Patsys always undercooked the pies at the original location. We always asked for well done.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

Yes I experienced that at the Harlem location but it was still very good . I think the customers may complain about the char over there

[@lynnmartin906]

Sorry not a nine missing cheese from some slices. Tighten up, baby.

[@ramencurry6672]

That’s intentional style. I think many people misinterpret that. A lot of people in the general public seem to prefer that extra cheese pull like how you see pizza portrayed in the movies. However many pizza aficionados actually prefer the opposite

[@ericleath9488]

The pizza is nothing like the Harlem location.

[@pizzareviewsonthego]

When I reviewed the Harlem location the pizza came out a bit undercooked, I still gave it a decent score. I guess you have to just get lucky and visit on a good day.