Plasticity 3D vs. Moi 3D | Surface Modeling Comparison | Pros and Cons of both Tools

Plasticity 3D 1.0x vs. Moi 3D 4.0-5beta | Surface Modeling Comparison | Pros and Cons of both
Tools, and why I'am use both together.
Many people asked me, but it is extrem hard to make a logic and objectiv Surface Modeling Comparison, but I tried it, both tools have pros and cons
Get Plasticity on www.plasticity.xyz/ and save 10% discount code: "SWAGGER"
www.artstation.com/cinekopp4d
/ christianschweger

[@3dkiwi920]

I think if Plasticity ends up with some "Live" and "History" functionality, it'll be a seriously killer app, at that point I'd genuinely use it for quick cad work for cnc.

[@Kuechmeister]

While many moments I modeled this part, I wish I had some Moi3d tools kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXeYd617fciqorc

[@Andras111]

Agreed. Variable radius fillets for solid modelling, and the overall UX is just also makes it insanely efficient. If Nick keeps continue developing this program the way he did in the last year, listening to requests this will be truly the best choice for CAD modelling for product designers and 3D artists. There are some tools I really wish for, like T-splines in Fusion, and some more in depth hotkey customization (be able to edit tool specific hotkeys as well) and some others, but I feel the overall direction is pretty good, and im already switching many of my hardsurface modelling to this program. (for me the Ngon Obj export was the tipping point, that export is by far the best from any Cad software i met with)

[@StaleCookies]

You answered my comment on another of your videos; with a video! Nice work🎉

[@davidgriffiths300]

Thank you for the comparison. Nice to see your thoughts on both packages. It would be nice for Plasticity to get some of the Moi 3D tools for surfaces. Fingers crossed.

[@CarlosPrGr]

You did a great job of research in this video 👌👌

[@visitante-pc5zc]

!! High quality video !!! Complete

[@bzee777]

Thank you for this break down!

[@Kuechmeister]

Thank you, it's difficult to compare, where one tool gives up the other can continue and vice versa.

[@sturm3d]

doing the custom fillets by using pipes in Plasticty also seemed a bit wonky at 23:00 ..sure needs a lot of tweaking the pipe bends to get them right?

[@Geostationary0rbit]

I hope the developer sees this, especially for the symmetry update feature

[@Kuechmeister]

The developer know this. But in some Geometrie Kernels can do this better and some that.

[@sergeyink55]

Объективное сравнение. Спасибо что провел сравнение и выявил сильные и слабые стороны обоих программ.

[@matsy7450]

Thank you for this tut, it was needed. So if you are also using and comparing Moi beta 5, it means that when the final version comes out, it will not have the killer features of plasticity, and we will have to wait years (at the current pace of development).

[@sturm3d]

the hack for complex ngon surfaces in MoI3d at 17:00 seems nightmarish to me. Respect for anybody who chooses to go through this without swearing.

[@fernandoandresvera7787]

Do you have any course about moi3d with script because i like your videos I like the scale models and 3d printer resin

[@r.in.shibuya]

Have you tried the blender bridge yet?

[@ausgewogen]

Phantastic video. Meanwhile necessary.

[@noname-cp8ki]

nice video i really hope that this video will WATCH carefully both authors - Plasticity and Moi and make conclusions🤫

[@mrwitty331]

cool, thank you for the comparison if I may ask which of the two is better for product modeling for visualization ??

[@Kuechmeister]

I think meanwhile Plasticity with the new feature xNurbs is better and easier.

[@mikeekim2532]

Finding it impossible to update my home version of Plasticiy with no update feature. Someone said update through Discord but as expected nothing returns when searching disoFinding it impossible to update my home version of Plasticiy with no update feature. Someone said update through Discord but as expected nothing returns when searching discord for Plasticty. It should not be this hard to update a program. Can anyone please help provide a link to update the home version without going to the github area where there are dozens of oddly named files to who knows what?

[@schtroumpfyoda8469]

eheh ! à n'en pas douter, Plasticity 2.0 écrabouillera la concurrence ! ;) wait & see

[@Break95611]

Jokes apart though, that's a really cool looking mouse

[@user-ty4nw4bi7i]

Your voice can't be that bad

[@Michael-oy2ng]

Would you suggest one over the other to learn first for someone just starting?

[@3runjosh]

Do you like dark or light UI? haha. I reckon Plasticity. I know everyone says fillet this fillet that and it does matter a little bit even if we all use pipes and sweeps regardless. I do have a soft spot for for Moi3D and Rhino though. You will see a lot more current content for education if you go with Plasticity than you will see with Moi3D.

[@John-mz8rj]

Nice, whats best for obj fbx Export.

[@Kuechmeister]

Moi3d

[@sudeepsingh933]

which is good for begineer and which one is powerful: Moi 3D or Plasticity ?

[@Kuechmeister]

Plasticity is better for beginners and easier for hardsurface. For Surface Modeling cases is harder to say, both tools has pros and cons.

[@brandonhall3353]

Seems to me that Plasticity not having the live update is a major red flag and a hinder on performance.

[@SuperSuperka]

Does Plasticity has Sub-D with edges creases?

[@floodmachine1868]

of course no! Its not a some kind VR scetching funny 3d programm where u can even move those NURBS edges!

[@SuperSuperka]

@@floodmachine1868 Fusion360, Moi3D, Rhino3D does have Sub-D. Nothing funny.

[@3runjosh]

@@SuperSuperka no subd (yet). I think it is intended to work with a subd software though so it will focus on it's curves surfacing abilities.

[@kenw8875]

Plasticity + Blender + F360: OnPoint 🔥

[@mishalw210]

Plasticity + Blender + F360+ Moi3d🤘

[@Z-add]

Compare plasticity to shapr3d since both use siemens parasolid kernel

[@rajendrameena150]

Please also add rhino in comparison

[@Kuechmeister]

No, Rhino is a 1000 Euro tool.

[@kowy_m]

moi-killer futures ))

[@Kuechmeister]

It might be that later versions of Plasticity also have a live update feature, but I think some things are hard to do and some things are easier and it's because of the specific core features of each kernel.

[@doraafelfedezoofisol]

At the rate plasticity is developing I'm not sure how many advantages moi's gonna end up with in years down the line

[@Kuechmeister]

I think it could be a kernel thing, 2009-2012 Moi3ds developing was very fast too, but since v3 to v4 and now to v5 no big things are happend.

[@alaskandonut]

i own this mouse. it's decent.

[@user-jt7vj7xc1h]

Plasticity vs rhino ?

[@Kuechmeister]

Rhino is not a Mini 300 Dollar tool, it's hard enough to compare this class of tools, but Rhino is a pro tool.

[@TT-rl4su]

@@Kuechmeister If money was not an issue, which out of the 3 would you pick?

[@Kuechmeister]

@@TT-rl4su Moi3d

[@sergeyink55]

Well, you suggested, of course, it's clear that the rhino is better than mine and plastics combined, but have you seen the price tag? The only thing that stops using a rhinoceros is its high price.

[@mohameddawood1720]

@@Kuechmeister even after plasticity v24 , you would still pick Moi3d ? strange enough , can you please give a short answer on why you would go with Moi rather than plasticity ?

[@DirkTeucher]

Moi3d needs a darkmode.

[@Kuechmeister]

some people take this: moi3d.com/forum/lmessages.php?webtag=MOI&msg=10461.1

[@Hardkorny]

Moi3d Beta 5 includes a Darkmode and Theme Editor. i.imgur.com/TiX36yT.png

[@DirkTeucher]

@@Hardkorny Nice. Thats much better.

[@kurisuchiinathecrocodile333]

I'm in minority who prefers bright style haha. Maybe something with my vision. But yeah nice to have option.

[@DirkTeucher]

@@kurisuchiinathecrocodile333 100% ... I have no idea what the majority is. All i know is my preference. Good to have both.

[@PopcornSticker]

rhino is better

[@Kuechmeister]

possible

[@soulja123rob]

define better

[@ElvinDude]

Especially on Mac

[@gabrielegelfofx]

Rhinoceros is better because it has 25 years of development. Plasticity in three/five years will be much powerful than Alias+Rhinoceros+Catia excluding the PLM/CAM features which aren't important for 3d designers.

[@soulja123rob]

@@gabrielegelfofx Imo, it’s a downside of Rhino that it’s so old, because it feels dated compared to modern apps.

[@critical_always]

This is 2023. Microphones do exist.

[@Kuechmeister]

Never heard of this.

[@stuartgibson9755]

No audio👎👎

[@Kuechmeister]

OK. Next time, Blackmetal is playing as background music.

[@fernandoandresvera7787]

Do you have any course about moi3d with script because i like your videos I like the scale models and 3d printer resin