Problematic Hadith Promoting Pre-Modern Medicine | Part 15

Problematic Hadith Promoting Pre-Modern Medicine | Part 15 | Dr. Shabir Ally

Рет қаралды 4,349

Let the Quran Speak

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 116

@charlesmuhmanson3928 Жыл бұрын

Did they mention the prescribed camel milk mixed with camel tinkle? I didn't hear it.

@I-AM-Yousuf 6 ай бұрын

JazakAllah MashAllah learnt so much from this episode

@walkingwith_dinosaurs Жыл бұрын

So much nonsense among hadith! I happy dr Shabir started this deep dive series, so maybe the work of evaluating those narratives will be done again for our time and using the great technology we have, like big data analysis for example

@candicecole19 Жыл бұрын

“And be good ˹to others˺ as Allah has been good to you.” (Al Qasas - 28:77) 🤍 ”Don’t order others to do good while forgetting it yourself.” (Al Baqara - 2:44) 🤍

@ahmfarooq1823 Жыл бұрын

And there are so many unscientific hadiths which make no sense at all. These are not Prophet’s(pbuh) words, on the contrary these are made up narratives.

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 Жыл бұрын

You are correct 💯

@mohamedadan5842 Жыл бұрын

Just cause you can’t understand with you little Brain, how camel 🐪 urine is sometimes a cure for doesn’t mean it’s wrong. At the end of the day nobody is saying you have to drink camel 🐪 urine but it’s there

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

God's existence is not able to be proven by science, you'll deny that too?

@walkingwith_dinosaurs Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Danhave u listened to Dr Shabir at all?

@rodaaan3640 Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Danbro, what does that even mean? The problem here is not “scientific” prove of god, we have as many prove of his existence as well as his nonexistent. The problem here it’s not that, it’s when there are hadiths saying strange thing that contradicts the real world. If in Hadiths says you can fly, you will jump out of your roof cause of this hadiths? The Hadiths which contradicts natural laws contradicts God laws on this world

@saliksayyar9793 Жыл бұрын

Honey could change the microbiome and changing the microbiome takes time. So alternate story could be patient went to hospital and developed antibiotic resistant infection and died. Cupping, just means alternate days and the dates are given as doctors give to patients and write down the dates so the patient does not forget. Another patient comes and he is to gave it on three days, so Tuesday was intervening and it is consistent. Not enough data on black seed, but anecdotes are positive. Cauterization for dirty wounds ? Let blood flow for many reasons. Insufficient data and making sweeping statements.

@itsmeroky Жыл бұрын

Thank you. Good video.

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

Not really, there's no scholarship happening he's just belittling hadith for no reason other than his own weak understanding

@nazirkabbani Жыл бұрын

Doctors only take a few hours of nutrition in their years to study. I would not trust them on digestive issues.

@sandralazarus7338 Жыл бұрын

Thank you.

@AbdulRahman-uo9eb Жыл бұрын

Honey has benefits for the gut, it's antibacterial and prebiotic. So, I don't see any problem in that and even black seed has antioxidant properties. These are scientifically proven, the study on honey is available on pubmed as well in very detail.

@Nevjerovatno6 Жыл бұрын

I think it's problematic to say black seed is a cure for all diseases except death. Cause obviously that's not true

@I0888 Жыл бұрын

Rabbihi Mardiyyah ... Show respect ,

@Simarodra Жыл бұрын

... ah, and even with those problematic hadith, Islamic medieval physician came out with kitab Al-Hawi fi al-tibb, Tibb al-Muluk, and others that set foundation for modern medicine. It seems that Islamic scholars knew their stuffs and wisely get rid of the bad apples 😊

@TheTruth-hc7ww Жыл бұрын

Bad apples planted by whom?

@hueyf6593 Жыл бұрын

Allah has inspired Christians and Atheist to produce medicines. SMH

@I0888 Жыл бұрын

Make my cry and bleed inside...

@semiot8305 Жыл бұрын

It's fascinating the idea of an old wise man telling to his grandchild: "A man greeted the Prophet (with Salam), and he was urinating, so he did not respond to him." And that child will live his whole life keeping those precious words in his heart.

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

Don't return salaam while you're in the bathroom, that's the lesson

@semiot8305 Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Dan Only if you are urinating?

@semiot8305 Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Dan"The Messenger of Allah saw me urinating while standing, and he said: 'O 'Umar, do not urinate standing up.' So I never urinated whilst standing after that."

@abdallahkambi3613 Жыл бұрын

We have some situations where modern medicine fails to cure diseases but traditional medicine does. Research is also another thing, those things mentioned in the Hadiths if well researched can cure many illnesses. So I don't understand why call them problematic Hadiths. It seems like you're here to confuse people and lead them astray. Many people with no knowledge and little Iman will probably be lead astray by your views. They're not educative rather misleading

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

@@semiot8305 If you urinate while standing up you'll splash yourself. Unless you want urine drops on your shoes and pants, don't urinate while standing

@hartwo-001 Жыл бұрын

Again, Dr. is not doing justice to the topic. Cite hadith, give reference and tell whether or not the hadith is authentic. After that do a full analysis of scientific research on the topic of the hadith. OR DR.SHABIR CAN JUST COME OUT CLEAN THAT HE DOESN'T BELIEVE IN HADITH, HE HIS OF QUR’ANIYUN SECT OR WHATEVER

@kmedia975 3 ай бұрын

Thansk

@kmedia975 3 ай бұрын

The same thing non Muslims will do with the Qur'an

@TheTruth-hc7ww Жыл бұрын

I guess this is why Ali Dawah no longer believes in Scientific Miracles. I see feel his pain😢

@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Жыл бұрын

Forget about science. The new testament gives two different genealogies for Joseph the carpenter. You have two different fathers for the same man 🤯

@TheTruth-hc7ww Жыл бұрын

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 You worried about the genealogy of Joseph but where in the Quran can we find the genealogy of your prophet that leads back to Ishmael? Which verse?

@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Жыл бұрын

@@TheTruth-hc7ww haha you don't even bother to try to reconcile the clear contradiction in your holy scripture.

@TheTruth-hc7ww Жыл бұрын

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Obviously they are from two different sources. But Christ is not son of any man. “Before Abraham was I am”. But your prophet is said to be the descendant of Ismael yet his genealogy is nowhere in the Quran. Not a single name of even his parents. But Jesus mother is named and Moses and Abraham’s parents are named. Even Ismael ‘s father is named. What bout Muhammad’s Genealogy? Why that don’t bother you yet Joseph’s does?

@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Жыл бұрын

@@TheTruth-hc7ww So you concede that the Bible gets Joseph's genealogy wrong. The word of God can never contain contradictions. That's why we believe that the Qur'an is the word of God. The Prophet's genealogy all the way up to Ishmael pbut is recorded in the Hadith. I don't know why you feel it must be recorded in the Qur'an. At least the Qur'an is error free which you can't say for the Bible.

@kmedia975 3 ай бұрын

This is we come and sit said hadith, without saying if sahih or not and just its sall nonsense?

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 Жыл бұрын

Reconciliation is nonsense. It encourages accepting contradictions.

@Sum_Ting_Wong Жыл бұрын

Only if you put aside common sense, logic and rationale.

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 Жыл бұрын

@@Sum_Ting_Wong If common sense, reason, and logic were used, hadiths would be a thing of the past.

@whoisthispleasefathmah8963 Жыл бұрын

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 without hadith then Who is Muhammad rassul?

@islamforall437 Жыл бұрын

All i care about are the verses of Allah. I take hadith with a very open mind. If it makes sense And is not promoting harm nor contrary to the verses of Allah then i accept it. But if it promotes harm such as killing of apostates I completely reject it and i will never teach it to my kids. Islam has given religious freedom to all people from day one. Allah never commanded the Prophet to kill apostates, we see apostacy even in the Quran. Where people would believe but later disbelieve. But Allah never said kill them, instead HE promised them the fire of jahanam. So this hadith of Executing Apostates is completely horrendous and certainly not from the Prophet. These salafis who keep defending sick toxic ahadith are the reason why Islam is experiencing such phobic attacks. And this has to stop. For reals

@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Жыл бұрын

First off why are you commenting about apostasy when that's not the topic of this video. Secondly do you reject harm as a principle? If Yes then you must reject all the ayas in the Qur'an that prescribe violence. For example cutting off the thief hand.

@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Жыл бұрын

Lastly, if you think Islam's enemies are motivated by hate of Hadith only then you're naive. I'd suggest that you go back to the Qur'an and read the ayah that talks about the only condition Christians and Jews will be pleased with us.

@islamforall437 Жыл бұрын

@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 read before you oppose someone. Apostasy was an example of certain ahadith that I completely reject. The way you are coming in defense of these nonsensical ahadith it is as if you are equating ahadith with the Verses of Allah and that is the biggest mistake that people do. Hadith is not revelation and would never be. Revelation is Quranul Kareem, Injeel Isa, the Prophets of Israel (Isaiah, Ezekiel, Jeremiah), Psalms of David and the Torah of Moses. These are all the verses of Allah, I believe in all of them and I only use them to find spiritual clarification. I’m not like most of you to denounce the Jewish Scriptures because of ignorance, no. If the Quran is true then it will stand the test of Jewish Scriptures and I assure you that the Holy Quran is not a new message to Prophet Muhammad But Allah revealed the same message to the previous Prophets of Israel. You just gotta open your mind and read then you will never doubt that indeed Allah did speak to the Prophets of Israel as HE spoke to Prophet Muhammad because the messages is the same. I will never reject violent verses in the Quran because they are from Allah. Hadith are narrations that people made up or heard from the Prophet. Did the Prophet say Hadith is from Allah? Absolutely not.

@I0888 Жыл бұрын

Liars are going to the Bottomless Pit

@peterhwang352 Жыл бұрын

Honey, black seed, and cupping cure all, except on Tuesday? How can you build a society on these books?

@godisonegodhaswon Жыл бұрын

1. Linguistically Allah Elahi Eloah Alaha are all linguistic cognates for the one God not "gods" ilah is generic God in Arabic Allah is The One God in Arabic eloh is generic God in Hebrew Elohim is plural so can be used for Gods Eloah or Eloheinu is The One God in Hebrew Hebrew prayers still use Eloheinu e.g. Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu 2. Aramaic Hebrew Amharic and Arabic are all within the same family Semitic modernly or Afro-Asiatic 3. Factually Prophets such as Joshua Isaiah Elijah all praise YHWH ( btw YaHuWa in Arabic means "Oh He Is" or "Oh He Is the only one who ever was , is , and will ever be." HU and HUWA are referring to the Most High) 4. but what about all the -el prophets names in the Bible? Such as Ezekiel Daniel Ishmael these names praise Eloah or Alaha/Ilahi or Allah s.w.t. 5. Michael Gabriel also the Angels of heaven have -el names only 6. There are at least 72 names of God in Judaism and at least 99 in Islam many are identical Ar Rahman ArRachaman HaShem Hashim El Kodesh Al Quddus Ahad Echad Eloheinu Allah

@Capybased Жыл бұрын

☪amel urine is also medicine, according to abdoolism! -Sahih al-Bukhari 5686, Sunan an-Nasa'i 4024, Sunan an-Nasa'i 4027

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

It's been proven to treat cancer

@Quran_Alone_Dawah Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_DanCamel urine does not treat cancer. Chemicals extracted from it can. Learn the difference before slandering the prophet.

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

@@Quran_Alone_Dawah So the chemicals inside the camel urine treat cancer? Meaning drinking it treats cancer. Use your head lol.

@godisonegodhaswon Жыл бұрын

@I0888 Жыл бұрын

Don't listen ... i care therefore warning ⚠️

@I0888 Жыл бұрын

ismy ISMAEL

@RS_Holdings Жыл бұрын

Dont understand your own Quran

@RS_Holdings Жыл бұрын

Education of Ignorance

@sciencefollower Жыл бұрын

خدا کا پیغام صرف قرآن کریم میں ھے۔ اللہ نے قرآن کو کتاب مبین ، کتاب محکم ، کتاب میسر ، کتاب مفصل کہا ھے ، جس انسان کا نام قرآن میں نہیں ھے اس کی کوئی بات اور اس کا کوئی عمل صرف اس کی اپنی ڈات تک محدود ھے۔ اس کی بات یا اس کا عمل کسی دوسرے پر صادر نہیں ہو سکتا۔ ابوبکر صدیق سے لیکر آج تک مسلمانوں کے تاریخی واقعات ، ان کے اعمال اور ان کی باتیں، اسلام کا حصہ نہیں ہیں۔ خدا کا پیغام ، جو قرآن میں ھے ، صرف وہی اسلام ھے۔ قرآن کے علاوہ لکھی گئیں تمام کتابیں اور تفسیریں شرک ہیں۔ قرآن سمجھنے کیلئے کسی عالم، مفتی اور مفسر کی ضرورت نہیں ھے۔ ہر انسان کو قرآن خود پڑھنا چاہتے۔

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 Жыл бұрын

You are on point. Those hadiths, scholars and other none Quranic sources have put the Muslims in terrible condition.

@sciencefollower Жыл бұрын

@@hassanabdur-rahman1559 Thanks and regards.

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

People who reject hadith are not Muslims

@sciencefollower Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Dan حدیثیں 300 سال کے بعد لکھی گئیں۔ بقول آپ کے، بخاری سے پہلے لوگ نہ نماز پڑھتے تھے اور نہ وہ مسلمان تھے۔ ؟؟؟

@sciencefollower Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Dan قرآن حدیثوں کو جانتا ھے اور نا پہچانتا ھے۔ محمد صل اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم نے فرمایا، میں تمہارے پاس قرآن چھوڑ کر جا رہا ہوں۔ اسے مضبوطی سے تھام لو کبھی گمراہ نہیں ہو گے۔ آپ حوالہ کہاں سے ڈینگیں۔۔۔۔۔ ؟؟؟

@SuperJijja Жыл бұрын

BAATIL

@RS_Holdings Жыл бұрын

Lie more and more , play with Quran , carry on

@hueyf6593 Жыл бұрын

If she starts to really thinking about these issues and the suggestive answers being provided by her dad, she’ll soon be on her way to Realize Islam have too many issues both in the Quran and Hadith to be true.

@Halal_Dan Жыл бұрын

There's no issues with either, their faith is just very weak

@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 Жыл бұрын

@@Halal_Dan Walahi I'm not even sure they have enough faith to qualify as weak 😕 Truly sad seeing people spread with their misguided belief that their prophet PBUH spoke falsehood. Astaghfurullah.

@TheTruth-hc7ww Жыл бұрын

⁠@@mohamedsheikhmohamed5411 All these sources were written by Muslims, why would they want to make Islam look bad. Islam is doing a good job all by itself

@godisonegodhaswon Жыл бұрын

@RS_Holdings Жыл бұрын

Listen or get lost

@lahleholivia7398 Жыл бұрын

Very strange Allah say it took him longer to make the earth than the entire universe

@godisonegodhaswon Жыл бұрын

@lahleholivia7398 Жыл бұрын

@@godisonegodhaswon Quran Author does not use the name YAHWEH.

@godisonegodhaswon Жыл бұрын

Arabica Hebrew English Ar-Rahman, Ha Rakhaman, The Compassionate One; Ar-Rahim. El Rakhum, The Merciful One; Al-Quddus, Ha Kadosh, The Holy One; Al-Bari, Ha Boray, The Creator; Al-Aliyy, El Elyon, The Most High; As-Salam, Oseh HaShalom, The Peacemaker, Malik ul Mulk, Melek Malkay Melakim, King/ruler over all the kingdoms/kings; Al-Muhyi, Ha Michayah, The Giver of Life; Al-Mumit, Ha Maymeet, The Taker of Life

@lahleholivia7398 Жыл бұрын

@@godisonegodhaswon Why Al lah take longer to make Earth than universe. Yahweh didn't.❓

@godisonegodhaswon Жыл бұрын

@lahleholivia7398 You must be very doubtful in your heart that you need to pester Muslims who have Faith in their heart so much. Are you that shaky in your own beliefs?