Purloining Perfume

[@LisaM1111]

The plaintiff is comparing losing cars and property to the defendant losing HER SON?!?! This woman is a clear sociopath

[@jaybur21]

You know this is the first time I think I seen someone correctly use the world sociopath on the internet.

[@14kchang]

This plaintiff is completely unreasonable. I honestly believe she needs to get a mental check.

[@judethaddeus9856]

Which plaintiff

[@hitfasthithard]

@@judethaddeus9856 the plaintiff is the one suing. The other is the defendant.

[@cheryldenainaathabascanak7870]

UGH Totally agree 100%!!!! So cold hearted to bring her sons passing to throw in her face like that, sickening with it all!!!

[@leogoddess3863]

WTF!? When plaintiff said she wasn't ashamed, the defendant should have definitely got her claim awarded. That was brazen

[@Alyra8]

She should’ve gotten emotional distress, because that’s traumatic.

[@dirtyboypdx]

It's on the fence, but in California at least I think that sending someone a photo of a deceased relative in such a threatening manner should probably qualify as Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress...

[@Linda235-z1b]

She should have at least received $100 or something. What she did was just cruel

[@judethaddeus9856]

Who is « she » and what was traumatic????

[@chrisleigh485]

@@judethaddeus9856What???

[@taylorditillio3990]

The plaintiff acting like she is right for her actions is so bizarre to me she’s a gross human.

[@PuffinPsychologist]

Insulting a grieving mother over ratchet, Half-empty, discontinued perfume and related items that you sold for $35…. is absolutely disgusting and displays a psychological disorder is at play. Even more telling is her nonchalant attitude and the “It was for this reason… don’t you get it??” No. We don’t get it. The majority of us: Do not live in a suspended-psychotic induced, manipulative, dishonest state of interaction TO OTHER HUMAN BEINGS… Go get yourself checked. You’re hurting innocent people.

[@granitemoss1451]

Did that witch just compare losing her cars and property to losing a child?!? As if those are comparable hardships? Absolutely astounding.

[@ms.teaversation8072]

Clearly something is not right with this lady...all over used bottles of perfume? 🤨 INSANITY ‼️

[@mrshappilymarried1]

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽BEST COMMENT!!!🏆🏆🏆🏆

[@w.p8960]

Even more disgusting is to pour the perfume to another container to rip somebody of $35 and pull the pity card..

[@stephanie5249]

@@w.p8960 nope

[@alexj.3375]

She thinks that smiling and having pink hair makes her bubbly and lovable, and everyone will be on her side

[@nerdalieisasleepyhead104]

You can tell she’s used to manipulating ppl who don’t know her true character.

[@teresalapier9354]

I had her number within 30 seconds

[@14moon85]

Hey really,,,,,, great analogy I would have never thought of that😆

[@silvermillennial]

And she had me for a couple minutes, not gonna lie. The illusion shattered the second they showed the email and I paused to read it, though. Good god, what a nightmare human.

[@jamiebaker-reese7450]

Well said.She is really crazy and her hair looks a mess. What an evil person.

[@estarateta]

The plaintiff seems like the kind of person that thinks that because she smiles while insulting makes it less hurtful.

[@naomiopeloyeru2912]

Ooo

[@naomiopeloyeru2912]

Ooo oo

[@lbu9542]

Exactly. She is calculating and mean spirited.

[@survivedandthriving]

She is OK with being totally hurtful. She just smiles so she can later claim it was not/less hurtful. Unfortunately, there are so many enablers in the world who are all too willing to accept the smile and so also to tell the victim 'she's just joking! you're too sensitive!' and other gaslighting phrases. I'm glad the judge saw through her (Judge Milian usually does see though this type of BS).

[@britney598]

17:20 The plaintiff is such a vile person. Her trying to justify her comments by comparing losing material possessions to the defendants son is SICK. I cant believe she decided to come on TV knowing this would be aired out 🤮

[@russellhunter363]

That's why I was thinking too. Losing property is WAY different than losing a person, especially your own son!

[@robbbietheim2096]

Trying to promote and market her brand you can tell she was almost way too excited to be on TV 💯

[@trekgirl65]

Wrong side, that was vile defendant. She is the evil one. LMAO! You looked at the wrong side. LMAO.

[@janessaflorian]

Literally. No trying to diminish anyone's feelings (although I don't think she was as heartbroken as she wanted us to believe) but during this Pandemic so many people were losing material items and it was honestly par for the course. Losing a son is on a whole other level that you just can't compare that too. Losing a car is not equivalent to losing a person. Most people would probably rather lose a car than a person.

[@benjie128]

I'm sure the defendant would much rather lose a car or a job than she would her son. For the plantiff to tout her sleuth skills, still learn the defendant's son is deceased, blame the defendant for the son's suicide, and still have the audacity to have no shame. Plaintiff's lack of character spoke volumes.

[@nerdalieisasleepyhead104]

And then she decided to make this insanity public!

[@bonkers5416]

@M No she's not. The plaintiff is an evil lying witch.

[@wontsufferfools9332]

As a mother I'd rather lose my life than lose my child And he's grown

[@jasonarnold3638]

She should have gotten the $500

[@franklesser5655]

The plaintiff is way too impressed with herself.

[@shannongrills7455]

You ain't kidding..that is the kind of woman that would get bitxh slapped...nasty nasty woman

[@hihosilverlining]

She used to getting her own way with charm…it must usually work. But in this case her real self appeared… So those that deal with het can see exactly who she is.

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

@Lowry The plaintiff has No Charm at all. She's truly a pathetic person. Shame on her.

[@christibarrick1768]

She’s not all she thinks she is 🙄 annoying af

[@janetmccoy7945]

What a despicable person! Reminds me of a narcissist. Judge Mathis would have awarded the defendant $500 for emotional abuse.

[@KPbouj]

He would have said “Ma’am, did you do this? 😡” he would have definitely gave her something if she asked for something.

[@MsBonitaDinero88]

Especially after she said she doesn't feel humiliated! He probably would've awarded her even more! She definitely deserved to win that!

[@BigLoBabyLo]

I love people's court BUT some cases need to go straight to Judge Mathis! He would of ripped that lady a new one and gave the defendant the $500. I can only imagine how she acts in real life! She is one of those people who never got their ass beat before. 👊🏾💥

[@judethaddeus9856]

Judge Judy would be better…

[@BigLoBabyLo]

@@judethaddeus9856 I don't watch Judge Judy lol

[@sarahwaters8262]

@@BigLoBabyLo *would have*

[@francisbouwman5287]

@@judethaddeus9856 Absolutely!

[@glamgirlkass]

wtf .. how dare the plaintiff reduce the pain of losing a son to “everyone goes through stuff” i’m absolutely disgusted, her place in hell is reserved.

[@CeltycSparrow]

Honestly, this plaintiff is a nutcase (and that's not even mentioning her ugly hair and tacky shirt). I think its a bit RICH that NOT ONLY is the plaintiff selling USED, half-empty bottles of perfume for $500, just because they have a Prada label....she is shipping them in a flimsy package, without proper wrapping and then, she wants to be pissed and say "no fair" when her product arrives damaged and nearly empty and the lady insists on a refund. She then has the GALL to call this lady a THIEF and say SHE is the reason that her son committed suicide? That is just CRUEL.

[@sheisme2]

Doesn’t change your message, but the perfume was being sold for $55.

[@KaylaDashay611]

I wish the Judge would have gave the defendant $100 on her emotional distress claim just because the plaintiff doubled down and yelled about not being embarrassed 🤦🏾‍♀️ what a foul individual

[@jenerin905]

I like when the judge awards $1 for principle. I would have been satisfied if she did that against the plaintiff.

[@johnpeters9793]

It almost looked like she changed her mind @ 18:45.....when she said, "Verdict for miss Ellen on that claim..." But the exit interview showed otherwise..

[@gbeez2303]

@@johnpeters9793 yea mee tooo!!.. i was like..YEAAHH.. then at the exit interview.. i was like oh no!

[@laurenrajman5959]

As a mother who lost my son, I am so grateful for your love and support and understanding stuff is meaningless when one losses a child. Hugs to Miss Ellen.

[@rckkeller9437]

Plaintiff should have accepted the return with class and dignity. Shame on her for going so low.

[@debrastone2198]

Our Mom just passed away after a year of being in ER, the hospital, & 2 different care facilities. Even before the past year, my brother & sister-in-law was keeping up Mom's property, making it look like a park. As I passed nearby her former property (now sold), I wanted to SCREAM!!! The lawn was half dead, & some weeds were growing all over the place. That was upsetting! I have since, made it a point, not to look towards that direction again!

[@dontaskmewhy1322]

Wow she’s going to continue to lose stuff and have the luck she does. What a terrible human. Saying we all loss cars, homes, etc. How does that compare to losing a child?! She’s a POS smh.

[@Possumpat84]

The plaintiff is a nut case and karma will catch up with her for making such comments to the defendant about her son. The defendant needs to make her profile private so only certain individuals can view such personal information but asking for $500 for emotional distress is just as silly as the plaintiff trying to get $500 for her used products. I was like the judge. I was so over with the plaintiff by the end. Put a fork in me! I’m done!!

[@alij6940]

She wouldn't have sued if the plaintiff didn't. Alot of people do that.

[@regisfilia]

She went to her dead son's profile. Unless the mom had his password she can't go in and easily change that setting. The plaintiff was just a vile, vindictive woman and it's completely understandable the defendant countersued. She obviously didn't care that she lost but she didn't want the plaintiff's atrocious behavior to go unrecognized.

[@arianefr78]

At 2:45 The plaintiff said there was a lot of interest, 3 people watching and even a bid of $50 (excluding shipping), then how and why did she accept $45 (including shipping) from the defendant, did she just lie and the judge didn't pick up on it? What a nasty piece of work that plaintiff is...

[@lionelluva]

She did lie.

[@somethingaboutbeaute]

I almost threw my phone at the wall over the way that woman talked!!!!!!!! Shame on the plaintiff. I would have awarded the counter suit. 😡

[@cbro2807]

I love when they show Douglas's expressions. Lol

[@jmusicproductions8394]

Shoudve went to Judge Mathis. He would've given her $5,000 for her saying that and emotional distress. And she still was not even apologetic at the end.

[@NuevaVidaFashion]

As an eBay seller I promise we aren’t all crazy like this lady

[@ebonypegasus9864]

The plaintiff is pretty nasty... over a $45 sale. It's a case of cyber bullying... which happens in adults as well as teens. All this boldness behind the keyboard and not thinking about the real person they are attacking. She's not embarassed by this? she should be. it's pitiful

[@arionlofton4721]

Just like that filter the plaintiff had on her face that kept glitching on and off of her 😅, her true colors was unmasked towards the end of this episode 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@Christy__M]

I was mostly listening across the room to this case but now I want to rewatch it!! 🤣

[@Honeyhollywood115]

The pink hair lady is wicked , her tone & her attitude . I can’t get over how this lady is so evil !!!!!!! Karma is gonna give you a nice lesson!!! How dare you how dare youuuuuuuuuu I’ve never watched a court case & got this so upset ! This is disgusting

[@vanessamcallister4235]

Totally agree.

[@colleenobrien8212]

How does Douglas not bust up laughing out loud listening to some of these cases.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

I wonder the same thing! I definitely couldn't..

[@arlenecoggins-john3795]

The plaintiff needs to find something constructive to do. She is vile for telling the defendant about her dead son, furthermore she should be ashamed to get on national Tv for $45.00. Really woman? Then it becomes $500 dollars 🤣🤣🤣

[@lindahodgson4307]

Love watching peoples court. Especially the judges verdict , after the show . What a loving couple these 2 are.

[@soloseraphimheartsong3710]

They are a relationship goal. They seem great together.

[@nerdalieisasleepyhead104]

Wait….are we watching the same video? Lol

[@34stzoo]

All I can say about your comment is, you are WRONG! She's not a good Judge and the crap they show after a case just proves my point. She has to be the loudest one in the room, she constantly interrupts, and talks over him. It was clear the defendant should've received a judgment for pain and suffering. This was a clear case that the plaintiff went out of her way to inflict emotional pain. She's not a good judge and her husband puts up with a lot! My prays go out to him!

[@peekaboots01]

@@34stzoo I disagree. She's the best judge. She had the good sense to not award the plaintiff. Bickering back and forth does not constitute pain and suffering. They are both B words. Judge Judy would not have awarded it either.

[@LDGbunny]

I knew the plaintiff was crazy af the moment she lifted her finger at the judge she’s nuts

[@Bigmuffin8]

Judge Mathis got me all confused because he being doing stuff I don’t see Other judges do 🥴🥴😂😂 He definitely would have gave the defendant some change for emotional distress

[@Talking_He4d]

No he wouldn’t maybe if she posted it publicly. He follows the law just like any other judge he just puts his personal input in certain situations just like millian

[@bridgetts4767]

Yes he definitely would have. He always does in a situation like that. Doesn't have to posted publicly because that was a personal shot at that lady and her dead son. Period! Judge Mathis would have definitely payed the defendant!

[@arlenecoggins-john3795]

She deserves emotional distress. The plaintiff could have caused this lady to commit suicide, she could have been at her breaking point. However, it could be based on the law in their state as well.

[@Bigmuffin8]

@@arlenecoggins-john3795 good point !

[@jccanteen]

I say that every time someone filed for emotional distress or harassment in this court 😂 As soon as I hear that I say nope not gonna get it 🤣🤣

[@crimsonfirelily]

This is such a nasty case over 45.00 whoa... Glad I quit selling on Ebay. It was difficult then with picky people when selling vintage items, Now? No way would I step foot on there. ✌

[@drayuh192]

I agree with you, but back in 2007 I was selling like crazy on ebay with no problems. Although I was selling hoodies at that time. From watching court cases now I would never sale on ebay too many problems from what I've seen.

[@cre8tivity87]

So true. Back in the early 00s, I sold various items on EBAY for years without any issues, then began selling my friend's high-end bags for her and had nothing but problems with picky/scamming buyers. Had to fight for every penny. Ended up quitting.

[@MissaPality]

@@cre8tivity87 honestly, I see so many complaints over designer items sold on Ebay. I would never consider dealing with designer merchandise on ebay. If it isn't the seller trying to pass off fake items, it is the buyer claiming either they did not get it or it was not as described or damaged.

[@cre8tivity87]

@@MissaPality Exactly and it's sad, you lose either way.

[@nybsbfan18]

Why was the plaintiff so cruel to the defendant...? Smh

[@jenerin905]

Mean people do mean things.

[@myowncelestial5017]

What a psychotic narc to be able to justify saying such a horrible thing to a mother who lost their child in one of the worst ways you can. My heart goes out to that grieving mother.

[@SString215]

The plaintiff is INSAAAAANE. 😳 The worst part is she has NO IDEA. My god, what an absolute lunatic.

[@tenfour10-400]

The post case banter today was great. Judge Milian’ parents sound lovely. No wonder the judge is a decent caring person.

[@jerryrodriguez7913]

"And can you identify the giant idiot in the courtroom today?" "Yes , it is the woman with the pink hair."

[@richardpodnar5039]

"I put on my Nancy Drew hat..." sort of implies that the plaintiff was going to sleuth out this whole regrettable mess quite aggressively. Such a shame!😟

[@Marshallpassmore]

I’ve seen this one before but I’m such a fan I’m going to enjoy it again

[@taylorgizelle]

Yes some I rewatch just because I love it so much 😂

[@skorwolf2719]

Judge milian kinda talk repetitive to me but i still watch her

[@coleenlawrence9809]

Judge Milan's face while holding her head between her two hands (10:53) says it all about this case.

[@Kaiel26]

The plaintiff is dead wrong

[@britneysylverton6151]

The amount of court cases I watch … I does just know how the ruling would be!! I feel like a judge!!! Is it me alone??? 😂😂

[@Christy__M]

🙋🏼‍♀️

[@Javier_529]

As anxiety goes up, empathy goes down.

[@NubianP6]

I think the defendant deserved a judgment for her emotional distress. The plaintiff is an evil, emotionally unstable person who will someday reap all that she has sown.

[@ginger7344]

The best thing about watching is that you know the video is not going to be taken down or marked private halfway through

[@MsLiz-rh7uj]

@1:45 When she tried to shut the judge up 🙄 shows her character!!

[@ashiajohnson1740]

This case gave me a headache 🤕 I know the judge 👩‍⚖️ is done ✅

[@hanaj]

I’ve been a regular seller on eBay for over 15 years. Yes there are many unreasonable people and scammers. But it’s the cost of doing business. Refund and move on. And people buy used lotions and perfume all the time. Especially if it’s a scent they can’t get anymore

[@Mocharocks9966]

How dare she speak to the defendant like that . Her and her pink hair can fry. She thinks the defendant was petty? You want samples back !!?? I hope your eBay gets taken down

[@Jessica_Costantini]

exactly if she said that to me i’d keep her stupid samples too

[@TheOnlyKateslate]

Took the wind right out of that plaintiff's sails. She wasn't so smug and cute at the end.

[@DavidKen878]

"On your claim against Ms. Ellen… $0. This will be now the fifth time that someone tells you that." 😂😂😂😂

[@34stzoo]

15:53 the look on Douglas face was priceless!!!!

[@PatDees]

I sell on Ebay and have done for since 1998 and for the pink haired lady to get personal by talking about the other ladies son is WRONG. Sometimes swallow your pride - give the lady a reasonable refund and move on or get out of business. Show some compassion with love & kindness. jeez Im only 11 minutes in and disgusted with her behavior.

[@tidbitsfromtime-melissa4192]

@The Traveling Picker - Patdees I also sell on Ebay and this plaintiff acted horribly and was totally out of line. She should have offered her a reasonable discount and move on. All the time she wasted she could have listed at least 20 items. These kinds of sellers give selling platforms and other resellers a bad name.

[@PatDees]

@@tidbitsfromtime-melissa4192 I was so disappointed in the way 😞 the human ugliness came out .... now both got an appearance fee for being on but this video really exposed the dark side of people..thanks for commenting. Follow me .

[@tidbitsfromtime-melissa4192]

@@PatDees I do follow you. I first saw you on Bearded Picker years ago and see you in lots of live chats. I usually just don't say very much lol.

[@PatDees]

@@tidbitsfromtime-melissa4192 yeah I'm not much in live chats as I host shows and do more pre-recorded content... trying to always be a better reseller..seeing this video 📹 and the ugliness of it I had to write something.

[@tidbitsfromtime-melissa4192]

@@PatDees Yes I don't usually comment on judge shows but I felt the same way.

[@mamabear154]

That lady is so disgraceful! The fact that she sued knowing this would all come out says so much! Shame on her!

[@riandraegon556]

And let’s just remember, there are thousands upon thousands of people just like this plaintiff in our country right now. Scary…..

[@lescobrandon9693]

Plaintiff is a prime candidate for libs of tik tok.

[@zzyzxy1]

The plaintiff is sick

[@shellwilliams6306]

Douglas just smiles and soooo wants to say how petty people are 🤣🤣🤣

[@joannadepriest1673]

I love the interview at the end. We need more of her. Lol.

[@sonquatsch8585]

when i feel insecure and doubtful about mere existence, things like this bring me back down to reality. it's not a big deal. it's getting easier to understand what it's all about. keep ego in check and things will shape right up. there are people suing over used perfume and willing to share such woes with the world.

[@tt.reactions]

She is disgusting! There’s no excuses for saying that.

[@twotragediesinlife667]

The pink hair lady is a disgrace that’s worth more than any amount the defendant could get.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

Plaintiff touched her nose 👃🏻way too many times throughout this case...her behavior was weird too....

[@warrenmooney9422]

The plantiff might not feel humiliated but she's been humiliated nonetheless.

[@d.wright6635]

1:44 - who tries to stop the judge from talking? that's nuts

[@madmel128]

The plaintiff is a very disturbed individual and needs serious help. Now her "stellar" eBay rating isn't going to be that great after this, is it?

[@HoneyBeeLuv22]

The plaintiff is evil! She disrespects the defendant, defendant’s deceased son, & then assumes the defendant is broke. She needs a her meds changed.

[@Ailenna]

Taking Nickle and Dimming to a new level....$35 dollars 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@reneerojas6046]

IN THE INTRO ---- Who else though the commentator was going to say, ''''The Defendant says the product she ordered weren't shit''''' when they actually said ''''weren't SHIPPED properly'''''??? LOLOL! I gasped, and jerked my neck back!!!

[@christianmom7542]

The lady in the pink hair needs SERIOUS MEDICAL HELP !

[@soloseraphimheartsong3710]

If someone told me that their loved one committed suicide my first reaction would not be “prove it”. I don’t understand some people.

[@basick86]

If two men are arguing they know that there's a fine line between words being thrown and fists being thrown.. but for women their strength is in the way they run their mouth and a woman will try to hurt you with words like you never imagined

[@EthanFindsOut]

They both sound unreasonable. I agree with the verdict…they both didn’t get any money.

[@Mrsjdw4]

JM should have awarded the defendant pain and suffering for dealing with that narcissist

[@dianepewitt696]

Wow the unmitigated gall of some people is sad. I guess they don’t care about the hurt they cause!!! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🕊🕊💖

[@Zackaveli]

What is the bar for emotional distress if that’s not it? I’m disappointed in the judge today.

[@DavidKen878]

Emotional distress is more than just saying something mean. You have to show what the person did or said gave you PTSD, made you depressed, gave you anxiety. None of which happened the to defendant. You can't sue for emotional distress just because someone said something that hurt your feelings. 🤕

[@inukoko2012]

The plaintiff is insane! Smh some ppl are so cruel.

[@ellyelisabeth2783]

All the hair dye, cheap jewellery and heavy makeup in the world can't hide a dark heart...nasty piece of work.

[@vokally718]

Nah, the defendant clearly deserved money here. That was some bs the plaintiff did.

[@jimster1577]

This has got to be the dumbest case I've ever heard.

[@shannoncarlson6960]

The plaintiff is so passive aggressive. It's one of the worst character traits. Also it would be so nice if this judge would hand out more emotional distress claims. I think I've seen her do it once. Sometimes they're really distressing and it's cyber harassment. This plaintiff is a horrible human being who really harassed the defendent and needs some good psychotherapy.

[@dellahicks7231]

Ebay can be such a dumping ground of individuals one sale or bid away from either a meltdown, or a full on battle, often times over crap!

[@frankflores5164]

The judge always tries to stir things up with private information that has absolutely nothing to do with the case

[@theresacotty8214]

The plaintiff should be ASHAMED

[@edwinferguson9703]

She should of gave the defendant the 500. Plantiff is cold hearted

[@darreylhenderson702]

The plaintiff looks like a heavier version of Mama Toad in 'Thumbelina'

[@Kay-Kiss]

She loves herself so much.

[@veronica5235]

What is wrong with this woman?? For $35?? The horrible part of this is that she clearly does NOT feel bad at all! She very clearly still feels justified and completely in the right. I've seen the judge rip into people for far less...I mean how did she not do it to this piece of work? Even Doug could haver done better with her. SMH!!

[@tenfour10-400]

The defendant was so nice. The red haired thing was horrid.

[@thetenthltr]

So, it sounds like some sellers mix partial bottles of perfume and sell it as whole.

[@mrsminerals6746]

When she says "if her son really is dead then shame on me and I apologize" but then turns right around and says she's not ashamed of the way she acted. This woman has a nasty soul and I hope I never come in contact with anyone like her.

[@elvickRULES]

She’s ridiculous and evil. Going there over $45. Shouldn’t ever say that, but it’s made so much worse for doing it for such a small reason. It’s like saying it over someone accidentally kicking your chair while walking by in a restaurant. Absurd woman.

[@courtneywin6528]

Douglas is giving me liiiife this episode. Lol

[@mrs.rogersneighborhood]

That perfume lady is VINDICTIVE.

[@teacupmagick7030]

1:27 Did she SERIOUSLY just refer to retail therapy as emotional abuse? She said something about her son calling it emotional abuse. Wtf?

[@obsidianwitch3334]

I sell online a lot and if any items get damaged depending on extent of damage I refund or offer large discount or accept a return. I don’t believe that customer satisfaction is that important to this plaintiff

[@trishamingin9003]

That plaintiff is a disgusting human! I lost my son 25 yrs ago and for a person to be so cold and callous about something like that is beyond a disgusting human being

[@tonya-mariejablonski8804]

The Plaintiff should be ashamed of herself....period