Vocal Coach Reacts to EVANESCENCE- My Immortal

[@zeromiedo1218]

Amy Lee has one of the most beautiful voices of all time.

[@ahmadk7013]

it was terrible in this song, she cant even breath

[@mikewilson6393]

Incredibly talented young lady

[@ahmadk7013]

@@mikewilson6393 young? Realy? She is 40

[@mikewilson6393]

@@ahmadk7013 younger than me. That a problem I was being kind? You should try it

[@heatherwade2373]

Yes.

[@Thatkidx01]

I believe the most accurate description of Amy’s voice is “haunting”.

[@ShooterinOK]

Erie .

[@MrShoesmad]

Angelically haunting lol. Hypnotic.

[@mitchellholroyd2837]

Absolutely fucking lutley

[@spokelseX]

Begone demons! Shit...didn't work.

[@josephmarino310]

Hauntingly beautiful

[@kgot7436]

Amy Lee’s voice is hauntingly beautiful. She’s incredible.

[@sostruk]

K Got Amy is herself hauntingly beautiful, her eyes are hypnotic.

[@pedjavukmirovic6770]

She is overrated I come here after europeans symphonic metal band this lady is below average

[@bobicabayo]

🙂

[@gggBassman67]

@@pedjavukmirovic6770 lol

[@kgot7436]

@@pedjavukmirovic6770 Europe’s overrated.

[@WillRayneMC]

I'm a 36-year-old man, and I cried when the band kicked in. Damnit.

[@HusGNR]

"I've been alone all aloo(*band kicks in*)ooong" - gets me every f'ing time.

[@fibromanmusc4369]

I'm 32. I live with this chronic pain, fibromyalgia since I was 24. Its so relatable to this song, whatever or whoever this song is written for, I don't care, it relate me so much with this pain.

[@MrsWolf87]

Im almost a 30 year old woman, i remembered when her album came out in 2004, i fucking cried when My Immortal came on. That song, even many many years later can still stop me in my tracks and bawl.

[@dreichert1438]

@Nightman’s Sexy Hands 36 year olds aren't millennials. And I'm 46 so don't give me any shit , but I hear you

[@dreichert1438]

@@fibromanmusc4369 been living with that for a long time too my friend. So many people doubt your pain when you are so young. Don't let those people drag you down. But you can overcome with proper mindset. Not every day, but most if you try and have faith

[@matthewscott1091]

I’ve been an Evanescence fan since 2003, have been to 10 of their concerts, 9 front row & met Amy & the band at a meet & greet in 2012 (I won a contest). Aside from being a vocal powerhouse she’s the most down to earth, humble person. She’s used to praise but still acted almost embarrassed but honored when I told her what her music meant to me. I respectfully asked if I could put my arm around her shoulder for a picture & she smiled, grabbed my hand & pulled it around her waist. She’s so tiny my hand was on her stomach, lol. She’s a great artist & all around person. 👍🏻

[@amaya_ds8650]

Wow you're living my dream

[@matthewscott1091]

Faezeh _ds Haha. It’s still been a few years since I’ve seen them live though. I missed the tour they did with the full orchestra but have seen it online & it looks like it was amazing. I’m lucky, because the few performers I’ve met (Amy Lee, Shirley Manson (of Garbage) & Gwen Stefani (when she toured with No Doubt in 2009/10 I believe) they were all great. I’ve heard of people meeting their idols & it going badly so I’m glad that’s never happened to me!

[@amaya_ds8650]

@@matthewscott1091 oh man so happy for you❣

[@gigi.l]

You sir...won the lottery of life

[@matthewscott1091]

Gigi L Ha. Not really. With Amy, I paid an annual $30 to join the official Evanescence fan club (doesn’t exist anymore/it’s free) & my husband entered me into a meet & greet contest as a surprise when he saw they were having a meet & greet drawing in every city. They even let my friend come with me (even though she didn’t win she was just going to the concert with me). With Gwen/No Doubt I did the same thing, paid to join a fan club, paid extra for pit seats & got their 8 hours early! With Shirley Manson/Garbage we got there 10 hours early (not kidding) so we could be in the front row. Shirley, if she’s feeling up to it will often stay after the show (this was a smaller show in a bar/club) & walk around talking to fans. I mean, I know these women aren’t “Madonna” famous but I adore them, they have lots of fans & they’re millionaires. But they still manage to stay humble. Shirley even felt bad about having to cancel the original show date in Houston (because apparently Houston is one of Garbages top selling cities, they have a lot of fans in Texas), so at the rescheduled show she brought out a binder full of ALL her songs lyrics & took requests from the audience for over an hour longer than the original show. She would sing whatever songs fans asked for & it was great. Because with her long career & *many* songs she’d sometimes forget the words & just ad lib. Lol 😅 It was awesome. 🤘🏻

[@LeFringe27]

A song that still lingers with me til this day. Brings me back to a much different time. Amy Lee's voice is beautifully haunting.

[@kaidynreece6200]

_"Amy Lee's voice is beautifully haunting."_ Best description of her singing I've read. 100% agree!

[@tonksnjoysatan8503]

So... It brings you back to life?

[@Aiyoku4]

tonksnjoy Satan 😉Underated comment! 🙌🏾

[@Josh_17]

My Immortal is one of the biggest vocal flexes. With all of the emotion behind the lyrics, it just brings it out even more. It’s not often a voice can fully captivate you, but she does it perfectly.

[@lindseym4698]

Personally, I love her ranges the most in “Lithium” it’s amazing.

[@marcieharreld286]

She captivates you no matter what she sings!!!🤘🤘🤘🤘

[@carpediemearth]

Listen to Evanescence's whole discography, not just the singles. There's a whole realm of eclectic music and Amy's stunning voice to explore

[@YukiTheGremlin]

@@lindseym4698 lithium is insane

[@yendor1232]

Amy Lee is a classically trained pianist as well as vocalist. Her voice is quite simply angelic

[@XKathXgames]

I remember when they had their breakthrough there were so many bands where the "vocalists" were just random people screaming into the mic, then boom Bring me to life came out and I was like oh God FINALLY a real vocalist. There she was singing with such a hauntingly beautiful voice and you could feel the emotion in the songs, her love for her craft and her professionalism. I think every single one of us were and still are completely blown away by her.

[@gabriellashimone6546]

In my opinion, Amy Lee has the most amazingly powerful voice in the world. It's not manufactured, it's pure and natural. That voice comes from the depths of her soul and speaks to the world. I fell in love with her voice when I first heard _Bring Me To Life_ and that hasn't changed. Everything she's done since has been equally amazing. Thanks for this video. Between your words and the comments, I know I am not alone in being moved deeply by Amy Lee's vocals. Thanks again!

[@StolichnayaCzara]

The song was popular when my mom lost her battle with cancer. Most days I was at the hospital with her watching her dissolve into this person that weighed 85 pounds. It was very hard losing her. I would put this CD in and sing and cry to this song while driving. It made it easier to cope with the loss I was experiencing. It made me feel like I wasn't alone in experiencing such a huge loss. Although I don't play this song much anymore, it still has a certain comfort for me.

[@charlesmartinjr3971]

My mother died of cancer that year, too. And, after, yeah.......

[@jaxonhyde2562]

When Amy went "wow" to her band, you have to remember, she was 21 (or 22 at that time) and they were in their first year of breaking through. She got emotional that the fans gave such a response to their music, which is very personal to her and she fought so hard for to become what it is. This is the exact footage that introduced me to the band, and I never let go of them.

[@scottlevin3966]

Anne van der Schoot Amy was 21 when fallen came out.

[@katekinder]

Well Terry is in the band for this performance so this either would be 2003 near to the end after Ben left or could have been later on

[@sanderjansen4155]

Please don't ever appologize for showing your emotions, I love watching your videos because you can make me smile AND make me cry.

[@symbian74]

Amy Lee's vocals has that quality that projects genuine emotion that resonates with her audience. Love her songs.

[@machupikachu1085]

Agreed. Too bad we never got a duet. That would have been epic! :(

[@vonsuthoff]

This song reaches to the bottom of your soul and will not let go. It is real. It stirs the senses with it's melancholy beauty, while gently ripping your heart out by their roots. It's haunting message of love is universal and it is eternal. May we all find a love so inspiring and deep... but a love I wish we all could keep! Love.

[@angelsheart85]

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏exactly...... nuff said

[@rex2837]

Wow, perfect

[@msaz2720]

Amy has that rare gift of an angelic/powerful voice that pulls you in and makes you want to hear every note she’s singing! Phenomenal talent!❤️

[@Scottyyybee]

Amy Lee, to me, has the most gorgeous voice EVER!

[@exoticnoise420]

And shes absolutely beautiful on top of it.

[@CorpseTwist69]

Amy Lee is a Goddess

[@tristenpoirier6272]

When I was younger my only Christmas wish was to have any lee sing me to sleep

[@tatertott47]

Yes!!!!

[@hrdkor79]

@@tristenpoirier6272 younger?! That's my wish NOW!

[@TheMissEuphory]

Gosh, I want 2000's back so much!

[@419Koof]

& the twin towers

[@LednacekZ]

you can go watch them on tour even now

[@tylerkoflanovich3580]

Neb Oknenim hahahahaha somebody get this man a hug a shag or at least a cuddle

[@M-H433]

Why she is still here for you

[@sarab4486]

And the 90s lol

[@larytriplesix]

Her vocals are legendary. I tried singing My Immortal with my vocal coach and it went horribly wrong. Nobody nails this song like Amy.

[@ExulansDiomedea]

well someone might have nailed this song (My Immortal- Evanescence (Cover by Julien Kelland)) on yourtube

[@C.Church]

Gaga would dominate this song, better than the original.

[@littlemissnerd3761]

@@C.Church not even remotely. Lady Gaga is amazing and has killer vocals but her voice doesn't have the same classical/rock(the way she holds/cuts notes) quality as Amy's does. Amy was classically trained, Gaga was trained by the same person who trained Christina Aguilera which is why her voice always has a pop like quality.

[@C.Church]

@@littlemissnerd3761 And I say the opposite. The original singer sounds all up in her throat, it gives me phantom strained vocal chords listening to it.

[@MissEvanescenceFan]

@@littlemissnerd3761 gaga's voice also has a classicness to it, Rebecca has even commented on it before

[@tadijakrstanovic8484]

Amy and Chester singing is everything I ll ever need of music

[@HanS08393]

YES!!

[@jasminalgoet9632]

Mee too! Evanescence and Linkin Park were my fave band when I was 16years old! I’ve seen Linkin Park on Rock Werchter 2017, weeks before Chester died.. now I’m gonna cry 😞😭. .

[@sammywildflower1617]

@@jasminalgoet9632 wow. How lucky are you that you got to experience that.. 😢

[@Boxercise]

Yes ! You are so right ! 2 of my favourites

[@ramikhudair]

absolutely my 2 favorite singers. both magical voices of different sex's yet so alike

[@JustatypicalMILLENIAL]

I saw evanescence live when I was a teenager and it is still the single most powerful moment In my life. It was 80% amy and the piano. It was haunting. I'm sure everyone felt like I did which was like I was the only person in that whole arena. The videos online of her live are trash. It's her. Her presence her spirit. That make her voice/presence amazing

[@mu4705]

Evanescence was the first band I ever loved

[@metalmanny666]

Mu oh yeah?

[@cynthiaarevalos6561]

The same for me ❤

[@sarahwithstars]

They are such a gateway drug

[@joecrafted]

They were not the first band I loved, but they set me on the same path of discovery.

[@mu4705]

@@metalmanny666 absolutley! I remember the first time I heard them in my 8th grade science class because they were on the a playlist my teacher played while we worked amongst ourselves. I asked one of my classmates if they knew the group and the song and they replied "evanescence" to which I asked "who"? Because I honestly had no idea what was coming out of their mouth. I finally had asked them if they could spell it and they hesitated for a moment and then thought about it for a while and finally passed me a note that would open my eyes and send me on an awakening.

[@aperson9847]

do you ever stop to thank your lucky stars that you exist on this planet at the same time as amy lee? what an incredible talent.

[@robertzsebehazy1041]

I have loved Evanescence since their debut. This is such a huge song, I am always so impressed at Amy Lee's piano playing and how the boys stay quiet until that one part. It becomes so powerful. The piano is actually a percussion instrument (the hammers hit strings) amazing song driven by percussion.

[@guiguspi]

I would have to disagree. A bass or a guitar are also played by hitting its strings. They're all strings instruments: guitar, bass and piano.

[@luipars]

The piano is without a doubt a string instrument because it's sounds are generated from the vibration of the strings. However, it is unique in that it's played like a percussion instrument, which makes it incredibly difficult (nearly impossible for the normal person) to play it and sing at the same time.

[@mikeakers1209]

Her beautifully haunting voice gives you the sense of a devastating shock. That point in a severe heartbreak were you realize you whole world is just gone. And you don't know what to do or say next. It's like a deathly calm your whole body is numb. Than she delivers that last verse and all the emotions just crash. Yeah.... she's a top notch singer definitely on my permanent playlist.

[@wallihaley5194]

Mike Akers, that’s a very moving description of how it feels to have your heart broken.

[@mikeakers1209]

@@wallihaley5194 to some people heartbreak is a world ending thing it's like your insides die and all that's left is an empty shell and you're just moving in slow motion while the world is passing you at top speed some people are broken and can't be fixed thank you

[@killiansirishbeer]

The thing with her voice is that if you've listened and enjoyed it once it becomes unforgettable. Even if you spend some time without listening or even thinking about them, the moment you start hearing one of their songs, especially one as iconic as "My Immortal", it's like no time has past at all. At least for me 😍

[@xaviertheory]

Amy Lee is by far the best female vocalist. I ever heard

[@ysinvangulik1004]

Are you guys deaf. He likes Amy's voice more than alll the ones you are mentioning. And I agree. Taste is personal.

[@jokedyy764]

Its his opinion, you can keep your opinions to yourself, I dont think amy is the best either maybe barely in top5. She has really unique sound tho, always loved her and evanescence overall. But yeah, you cant fight about whos the best in your opinion lol.

[@ysinvangulik1004]

@@jokedyy764 Offcourse, but selecting your favorite singer isn't a sum of all kind of skills but about personal preferences. I can see and hear Floor has a lot of skills that exceeds Amy's. Nevertheless Amy has some unique features that makes me like Amy more.

[@Dantestopmenow]

Cyberdemon Mike Beyoncé 🤮

[@paingfoo871]

@Cyberdemon Mike Beyonce is overrated. I, personally dont like any of her music.

[@memoirsofamusicfreak2208]

This song has ALWAYS sent shivers down my spine every time I hear it 😭 Her voice is just so beautifully haunting!

[@madelief7603]

20 seconds into the song and i’m already crying lmao

[@seandan7873]

I stared with goosebumps but ended with tears too.

[@Kevin.7.]

XD Imagine live.

[@metalmanny666]

Madelief van der Horst I can’t take you to go watch the new Lion King.

[@charlesdow4802]

Everytime I hear her sing no matter what kind of song she makes me tear up. Absolutely the best singing voice ever

[@madelief7603]

wintersnake still haven't watched it because i know i will ugly cry a lot 😂

[@DylansPen]

She is one of the few singers that you hear them and it's like, "Oh come on, at least give everyone else a chance." Her voice and the emotion it carries is ridiculous it's so good.

[@StormChsr75]

She’s one of the few vocalists that give me goosebumps as well. Especially this song.

[@lttlejordan23]

Amy Lee has one of those voices that fills every aspect of the room and your soul. She has monster vocals. Beautiful voice! Loved seeing Evanescence live, especially back in the day when they were very popular.

[@0c569]

ALSO! They performed bring me to life during the same concert... That needs a review 😌

[@mrvinyl-mrchili9583]

100% agree that song never gets old . I have heard it every day for the last 11 years still so fucking epic

[@leebaldwinrealtytv]

Def!!!

[@rajdeepkromchengurung1019]

Especially the INTRO.

[@0c569]

@@rajdeepkromchengurung1019 so ipnotic and addicting

[@LeeMaitland]

They also performed Going under at this gig and it's an incredible performance. They really nailed it at this gig.

[@End3r_Wiggin]

In the early 2000's when she lived in Little Rock, AR she would come into a little bar called Jaunita's on some random weeknight and play. In such an intimate environment, it really was a religious experience.

[@ashleygallaher7837]

Ender Wiggin I miss Jaunita’s everyday

[@End3r_Wiggin]

@@ashleygallaher7837 Great bar and live music. Got a great story of a couple of roadies and me saving a soon-to-be-bride after she was savagely beaten by the future best man after they went out drinking. The night before the wedding. He caught an agg-assault charge on her, assault charge on me, drunken disorderly and possession. Fun times.

[@MusicMoviesTheaterHockeyOhMy]

@@End3r_Wiggin Thanks for being a stand up guy. I hope everyone would intervene or help out but you never know anymore

[@End3r_Wiggin]

@@MusicMoviesTheaterHockeyOhMy I don't usually want to get involved in situations I know nothing about, but this was clearly different. There was no way any of us were going to ignore. He took a swing at me just as sheriffs showed up and got bounced off the asphalt for it.

[@smdftb8495]

I remember when they played Night Life for NYE like 99 or 2000. Hated that place lol. Juanita's was the shit though (before they moved to the River Market).

[@jgale76]

I got to see her live this past summer and brought my teenagers. My daughter said she had full body chills for the whole concert. It was a religious experience.

[@HvyMetal4Ever]

To me, Amy Lee is much like Freddie. Often imitated, but never duplicated. Her voice is this beautifully haunting siren that draws you in. It's very distinct. It touches your soul. So so talented.

[@andrewbledsoe131]

That's 100% true. I always know it's her

[@garyfryza6541]

Good analogy

[@coolmandude1000]

Amy Lee has the Voice of a ANGEL. She can perform her songs live as well as she can in the studio. Thanks Rebecca for reviewing so many great vocalist. Oh and Rebecca you are awesome and a great vocalist and vocal coach. Keep up the GREAT work. Cheers from the USA \m/\m/...

[@rodakho]

and Enya too

[@gamingjim5919]

When this was released as a single, i read an interview and the guitarist (who i think left the band shortly after) said there's a recording somewhere of him singing it because he wrote it when he was 15!

[@lapenesr]

"Oh, this song is everything isn't it?” 2:42 Yes.

[@PixieGiggles33]

You're absolutely spot-on right about the purpose of singing- how it's all about connection. I believe singing is connecting with one's self, when writing and singing lyrics and melodies...and it's about connecting with one's band and how singers have to have a connection to every beat and note in a symbiosis of effort and collaboration...and how singing can connect one to his/her audience and the reactions and emotions they express. Whenever I sing, I have such a strong longing to be able to have a band and connect with them, as well as connecting with an audience. It's a passionate love affair like no other. I miss the times when I used to perform, the great love I connected with and felt from others, and I remember it was the most confident I've been in my whole life. I've watched so many of your videos, and I absolutely love how passionately you speak about both the music and singing techniques and training. Thank you for all your efforts to create such magic.

[@vincel.8122]

This song is pure magic. The band entry is pure exhilaration. You can feel a surge of power in your entire body. Makes you want to sing loud as well.

[@larryd4352]

Amy Lee has one of the most beautiful voices that I have ever heard...and I am 62 years old. She is in an elite class of vocalist. I have to go back over 40 years to Karen Carpenter to find someone who had such a special voice, where everything she sang made you feel like she was singing your own life.

[@Diavolo222]

Damn havent listened to this song in a while. Kinda brings me back to a completely different time in my life.

[@sarahwithstars]

Its incredible how songs can transport you like that, isn't it?!? The memory is so weird and wonderful

[@kimmyball4961]

This song still makes me cry after all this time. This whole album is a masterpiece. I've also used the word " haunting " to describe her voice.

[@craighenry2351]

Don’t pigeon hole her, though. She is so much more and I’m sure you know that. What she did on this song was hit the perfect vocal tone to express the emotion she wanted to get across. Although she is very haunting in Broken, which is meant to illicit similar emotions.

[@tandraallen8398]

I can honestly say that Amy Lee will be remembered as one of the greatest voices in rock.. She is simply amazing.

[@LednacekZ]

when you get the goose bumps in the first 15 seconds of the song, you know the artists is doing everything right.

[@ednorton1853]

You said you were in full goose bump mode. She does that to anyone who listens. She is a gift to our ears.

[@jasonveit3823]

It's ok to cry hun, I'm a military veteran and Amy's voice brings tears to my eyes as well 🤗

[@zlaja991]

This song brings up so many early adolescence memories, it's craaaazy. I love it.

[@johnnycang]

This vocal coach is so positive about singing, complimenting all the good aspects instead of overshredding and over technical ctitique that I am actually now interested in her channel and a fan. I just simped out for this chick she's great. I don't even watch vocal coaches.

[@craighenry2351]

For real, no Simon Crowell here, and even with the positivity, she isn’t overboard like Paula Abdul was.

[@chrysta77]

Amy Lee has been a vocal icon to me for years! Finally saw her live a few years ago and she's definitely AMAZING live 🥰😁❤️

[@jasonstinebaugh8447]

When this song was new my Dad was fighting cancer. The lyrics remind me of what my Mom was going through at the time and then the aftermath of his passing for the next five years. It was incredibly hard to watch her go through all of that. While at the same time dealing with my own grief. Still, it's a beautiful song, her writing, her amazing voice, as you said her emotional connection to the song itself. Makes me tear up every damn time. And I'm from the last of the generation where guys weren't supposed to show emotion, tear up, certainly not cry. Took me decades to get over that shit. I'm sorry, I just feel like I can talk to you Rebecca. Thank you for this lovely reaction. Thank you for being you beautiful lady.

[@rva]

Lots of love

[@jessdedication]

Jason Stinebaugh learned this on piano played for my dads funeral

[@andrewwilliams10785]

I was a junior in high school when this came out. This song got me through some dark times over the years.

[@tayadulcich6545]

One of my all-time favorite songs. I have seen her live. It is one of the most emotional concerts I have ever been to. She is remarkable.

[@ethanjaworski8680]

This video randomly appeared in my suggested, and reignited my love for Amy Lee's voice.

[@christiancampbell8252]

The buildup from 5:40 always makes it so beautiful when 6:00 hits and brings tears to my eyes every time, the goosebumps everything, just beautiful

[@tiffymcconkey]

One of my top 5 favorite songs of all time!!! She is Amazing

[@zenleto]

Lovely reaction, Rebecca. Amy Lee is probably one of my most favourite vocalists who I’ll never see live. She just has a wonderful voice and style. Thanks for this.

[@tammimarie]

Aww why won’t you ever see her? I used to think that but then I saw her twice in the last two years. They are writing a new album now.

[@zenleto]

@@tammimarie timing mostly. I'm in Australia and tours are pretty far apart as it is but juggling work with single parenting makes things difficult as well. I don't like relying on KZbin but it's the next best thing 🤘

[@wickederdock8361]

@@zenleto Single parenting is a pain in the arse when making plans, my wife died last year and raising a kid on your own is harder than people realise.

[@maineventmark]

I could listen to Amy Lee sing anything and I'd still love it. She is one of the best pure vocalists I've ever heard.

[@AM-br4ix]

Get emotional when you need to Rebecca... we are human. Emotion comes from our Soul. The Soul is the mentality of the Heart. The Soul : the Will; the Emotions and your Conscience. She sings so incredibly and amazingly beautiful! Truly layered emotional feelings!

[@ScatterSenbonzak]

Thank you for the great vid. I had a tear in the corner of my eye at the end of the vid. So much emotion in her voice, the feels!!

[@Tempest1816]

Amy has such a connection to the songs and her emotions translates to people who listen to her.

[@crystalxoxox7691]

This was a song played at my sisters (she’s not biologically my sister, but I’ve known her 20 years and she’s pretty much my older sister) kids funeral a few years ago. This song will ALWAYS and forever give me chills. The emotion behind it, her voice perfectly capturing that emotion too. This song will be one of my all time favourites ❤️

[@exlibrisas]

Beautiful ballad, but to me, "Hello" is the most amazing ballad ever written by Ev, probably. With incredible darkness.

[@hanakhalisa7914]

I'm agree with u

[@DOMSKYTRANCE]

Yea Hello is a great track. I'm pretty sure Hello is about the death of Amy Lees younger sister

[@sunflowernamedfern]

@@DOMSKYTRANCE it is! She has one song per album dedicated to her late sister

[@justintennison1226]

I absolutely LOVE "Hello"

[@jesseashmore8426]

When this came out I was around 12 and it made me cry. I had no clue what the song was about, it was just the sheer emotion in Amy's voice.

[@volcano83]

I saw them in my hometown in Australia for the same tour, and I distinctly remember the same massive cheer mid song after Amy finished the first chorus

[@stoneshack2000]

Fantastic reaction, your emotions were so compelling. I just love you, thank you for that one..

[@jimdemassi8788]

Rebecca, Rebecca, Rebecca, I will never get enough of seeing your reaction to songs and artists I love and that move me. Amy Lee singing this song has given me goosebumps for 17 years but your reaction to it gave me goosebumps as well. Keep em coming.

[@shannon1664]

Only Rebecca can take an old song I've heard a thousand times and help me appreciate it like I've never heard it before. Thank you, milady.

[@xxNightmareous]

That exactly what I felt right now! This is from an evanescence fan for 16 years!

[@charles9571]

Same

[@CoffeeForSandra]

In 2006 I had the pleasure to seeing her live, she sat there behind the piano about five metres away from me. Never ever heard someone sing like her, these emotions are incredibly touching. Awesome woman :)

[@Maribeth_Michelle]

Saw her live and it was one of the greatest shows I have ever been to!! She is truly on another level!!

[@MichaIgnaczak]

Don't be ashamed of your goosebumps and tears - I weep like a baby every time I hear this song - even knowing it for so many years and hitting it zilions of times :)

[@hilaryfijolek4608]

I had the privilege of seeing Amy Lee & Evanescence in person in Chicago many years ago. I still remember how amazing it was. I actually didn't listen to my CDs of Evanescence for months afterward, because Amy Lee's voice was simply so extraordinary in person, the CD couldn't capture her performance and was a letdown in comparison. I wanted to hold the memory of how beautiful the concert was as long as possible, without the CD recording interfering with that. May sound strange, but it's the only live performance that I ever felt was so far above recorded versions.

[@c.w_]

Muse are the same too!

[@JKM395]

Wow. Dang I'm glad you did this song Miss Rebecca. That woman... What an absolute angel! She has an amazing voice and she's clearly beautiful, as beside the point as that may be. Amy Lee is really something special. By the way, you needn't ever apologize for feeling the music. I don't trust musicians that can stand stock still and look bored when there's good music in the area. I certainly wouldn't trust a vocal teacher that could. I come here to see you being you, ma'am. You're extremely good at it. Keep up the good work.

[@davidbeals2056]

The only female singer I've found who can sing me to sleep at night and I can rock out to during the day. Her Synthesis album is absolute 🔥.

[@Sascha_Germany]

love her songs. and when the crowd sings, it has the xtra it needs

[@nedachilles8793]

Amy lee was and still a breath of fresh air is the music industry.

[@derrickfuson2793]

I could listen to her songs on repeat all day long! Simply amazing!

[@potatolew4495]

I truly appreciate this song . When I first acquired the album and heard this song I believe I listened to it for a week straight. The change from the piano to when the drums and electric guitar come in to me is indescribable. Amy's voice is otherworldly and so full of feeling.

[@lmaree200886]

The original non band version is just as good!

[@ajjames1498]

Amy Lee is one of a very few singers that you can just feel from within

[@0c569]

YES!!! TY! Finally Evanescence ❤️ you awesome btw, love your channel, educative and entertaining at the same time

[@rva]

Thanks for your support and comments 💖🌈

[@dimashi552]

@@rva New music video, Dimash Kudaibergen - Love of Tired Swans ~ Димаш Кудайберген - Любовь уставших лебедей [Official MV] - kzbin.info/www/bejne/b2PVZWqHiLeMeKs

[@wescourt9661]

I used to cry listening to this when I had nothing and nobody

[@williamarnett3234]

Gods always by you brother. Never feel that you are completely alone my friend. There is always someone with you.

[@ShamikaLMoore]

Your comment just made me cry. 😭 God bless you, I hope you're doing better now. 🖤

[@jefftraboulsy8631]

@@williamarnett3234 god isnt real

[@jefftraboulsy8631]

@@ShamikaLMoore god isnt real

[@thenorthman515]

@@jefftraboulsy8631 go and fuck off.

[@gabrielferreiradejesus5009]

Amazing. Amy's performance in "The Change" acoutisc is very impressive as well.

[@M4A3]

Amy Lee has a powerful, yet so delicate voice. Incredible!

[@boldcitymike]

I appreciate your honesty, your humanity to show emotion through a song that is absolutely meant to bring out whatever is inside of you that needs to get out.

[@Mister_Mag00]

when you show how emotional a song makes you, when you let us see that, I genuinely get emotional with you, you literally help me feel things in this world of toxic masculinity that says boys dont cry, well you help me cry, thank you so much for being so wonderful.

[@nancy-leaashmore5443]

so cute when she mimics the headbanging bit, just love watching you, I cant sing a note yet I love watching your vids.

[@ebbersa5993]

Rebecca that cornflower blue is YOUR colour 🔥😊❤

[@jefferymanuel4226]

Her voice is so powerful! I could wake up to her voice every single day!!

[@BUNKERJR53]

Amy Lee is one of the greatest vocalists to walk the planet. Her voice gives me chills and I am not afraid to admit it. I am a vocalist and I have a deep appreciation for great emotional vocals.

[@LoZenith75]

I have been a fan of her till I heard her live...thank God there are other really skilled singer and not fake like her...sorry

[@StephanieV04]

She's just gotten better over the years ( in my opinion). This is a very old performance you should check out a live performance from their most recent tour. I love this band!!! Evanescence is amazing, they helped me through some tough times in high school and beyond. The way she connects with her fans and the emotion she has while singing is amazing. I will always be a fan. Thank you for listening to them. Great video! Also, You should check out The Lone Bellow. I think you would like them.

[@DonutWorryFriend]

I was thinking the same thing!

[@visualrose85]

I was literally binge watching your videos yesterday and then listening to Evanescence and thinking how I would love to hear your reaction to her lol ❤️❤️❤️

[@Kid574]

Her voice in this song in particular is "silently shouting" something along the lines of "HEY YOU! There's so much freakin power in this lady just wait and see!!!!" 🤯

[@DaveDGRGray]

1:49 - you and me both, each and every time I hear it. Also, it's not attached to any significant memory in my life, just an almost overwhelming sense of emotion when I hear this song. I love that the human voice, combined with a piano can be so powerful.

[@TroyGerber]

A friend lost a child many years ago. When I told her how much I love this song, she shared that it reminds her of losing her son. I listened to the song wit new ears. I cry every time I hear it now. Amy Lee is a goddess

[@Thumpster59166]

I lost my daughter almost 10 years ago. This song is definitely hard to listen to.

[@andrewbledsoe131]

As a boy. Her voice is captivating. Insanity. I love every second of her singing

[@99Nights100]

As a boy, I can confirm.

[@juliadevore9602]

Amy Lee has the most beautiful and haunting voice I've ever heard.

[@Fer44_BR]

Thanks for reaction. Great singer. See "Lost in Paradise " sessions AMP rock.

[@АняХ-ц2ж]

Amy Lee is definitely my top favorite her voice is amazing! She always brings me back to life when I'm down and seeking inspiration!

[@christopherchuauhang4829]

You can't teach her voice! She's absolutely amazing!

[@kevinkelley3657]

Her voice is so pure, so light, so feminine, yet so sad, its beautiful