Red Velvet - Wendy Extreme Weight Loss 2013 - 2017

[@draankpaank]

so basically the fans bullied her into an eating disorder and then shamed her for it afterwards

[@rehreh92]

D.P. Korea has really harsh standards. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@maiavitale8458]

what a messed up society we live in 😖😭

[@littlesadeo]

@@rehreh92 Idols seem so fake and it's not their personalities it's their happiness. In america if someone said "im used to not eating" every fan would jump into concernity! I want to slap all these "fans", steal these girls and help them! Some idols arent even allowed to date! I admire Asian culture but idol industries sicken me.

[@Mybloom1]

Then we wouldn't call them "fans"

[@Sajirah]

Yep. Korean fan culture and beauty standards are nuts.

[@terryprice4560]

I think when she’s at her “biggest” she still looks healthy, athletic, and beautiful

[@Jolovesdrpep]

IKR I would kill to look like her at her biggest 😫

[@yuukiruka3717]

she' at her biggest is much more thinner than me at my smallest

[@rajapranathadoloksaribu4808]

It's Korean standard to be as thin as possible.

[@kaiylac.1861]

29. Raja Pranatha Doloksaribu - KBUMN and?

[@linablues6881]

@@rajapranathadoloksaribu4808 Specially idol Korean standar.

[@Vadzx]

I hate how people went out of their way to bully her into thinking she's worthless then blame the company for telling her to go on a diet - chances are she's the one who wants to be on it because a bunch of idiots thought they had any right to criticize her for not being a size 0. Its like how so many "fans" were pretty much ready to sue Cube when they found out E'Dawn had a girlfriend then blamed the company when he got kicked out. No one wants to take responsibility for their behaviour and honestly this is just disgraceful.

[@abeautifullysadstory7953]

Vadz x 11:11 Exactly! And the irony- these "fans" are ugly and sitting behind the screen in their sweat shirts, eating chips and doing nothing, calling her ugly

[@NejiRaven]

This this this. Thank you. Finally, someone else who understands. I'm so tired of all these "X company is a snake" videos/posts; people act like fans have no role in idol behaviour. Yeah, most kpop companies are shtty but they're also a business? If fans scream for idols to be underweight ofc companies are going to oblige. People bully idols into mentally unstable states, and then when an idol breaks everyone goes "omg1!!1 what a awful company!!?? " like own up to your shtty behaviour. Case-in-point: Joy. If SM is responsible for Wendy, why haven't they forced Joy on a starvation diet? Bc no one comments on joy's weight and even deems it as a good thing. But Wendy doesn't get the same pass? What utter bs.

[@jenesaiis]

So true!!

[@asideofaioli4630]

It's called being slow and a hypocrite.

[@midnight3946]

@Brittany Beautiful I have heard that some K-Pop fans will get really upset if someone is just RUMORED to be in a relationship with an idol. Stories of girls getting hate mail and death threats just for spending time with an idol... it's honestly really fd up

[@cherryfi]

2:19 people are literally BRAINLESS calling her fat here. What the actual hell. She looks SO fit its insane id kill to be that muscular she looks incredible.

[@lanarose8002]

This is literally the dream body for EVERYONE except for Koreans smh.. Her legs are so sexy and a lil thicc there, her stomach is perfectly flat. That's so much prettier and sexier than the koeran beauty standards :(

[@kylemaylumboy3679]

I agree!

[@kikiknojj]

@@lanarose8002 ikr? they're crazy to think this is fat, I would kill to look like that

[@shreyosibanerjee4906]

Bro I'd spend hours at the gym to have them quads. Wtf

[@krustenpizza]

This and 3:37 looked the best in my opinion. Looks both amazing!!

[@elisinwonderland1306]

People: *bully this girl into an ED* Girl: *actually gets an ED* People: *surprised pikachu face* Edit: WTF how did I get so many likes 😐😐😐 thanks guys

[@emilie8487]

Maria Elisa Nasso I shouldn’t be laughing. But i am. I can’t breathe

[@offline5307]

Tbh the story of my life

[@elisinwonderland1306]

@@offline5307 sorry to ear that ) :

[@elisinwonderland1306]

@@emilie8487 I know I know

[@souljoe8125]

what's ED?

[@ilovekittie123]

wendy can sing. she can *really* sing. so can we stop focusing on whether she has a thigh gap?

[@ilovekittie123]

Miz Chan who cares?

[@LM-ix7pk]

Miz Chan Wendy still sings. Just because she is physically unable to perform anymore doesn’t mean she isn’t a talented vocalist

[@NoNo-zw2bz]

Miz Chan tf? Do you got a gap between your brain? How do you care more about her thigh gap than her actual singing talent. Y’all shallow and uncultured af. 😂

[@tokyochrist2897]

@Miz Chan okay and? why is that a problem?

[@Wiijimmy]

internet: wendy ur too fat wendy: ok wendy: *loses weight* internet: ok good wendy: *continues to lose weight* internet: wait-

[@animerocksyourworld6229]

insert pikachu meme

[@Trqnn]

I'm the 1.7k like also I really wish people would be more focused on the talent all idols have instead of their weight

[@ihyashh]

Internet: *suprised pikachu face*

[@terobaukotauko9876]

INSERT MY FAT BELLY LOL

[@ricezzz2665]

Taeyeon telling them it's okay to gain weight and they shouldn't feel guilty about it is so heartwarming.

[@iwatchyoutube7311]

Korea is kindy crazy... I miss when music was just about entertainment. This seems like a black mirror episode, but its reality, isn't it?

[@ixichil]

that miley episode pretty much describes artists real life. artists in general.

[@oxi_seannika1641]

When has music ever just been about entertainment?

[@jenesaiis]

@@oxi_seannika1641 that's the question

[@LM-ix7pk]

Kpop has never been just about “music.”

[@nosound__1236]

We need to start calling them out, they're freaking crazy and choose to ignore this serius issue

[@mollybrown8361]

The entertainment industry in Korea is straight out of an episode of black mirror

[@juliag.5114]

right? I've started listening to k-pop about 2 months ago and there's so many problematic things that i almost feel guilty to give money to an industry like that

[@anushkakulkarni112]

Not just the kpop industry almost every entertainment industry in the world is shady as hell

[@briannah7675]

honestly. and the fucking beauty standards.

[@cass7559]

people: *lose weight!* wendy: *loses weight* people: *yay* wendy: *continues to lose weight* people: *wait now you’re too skinny and it’s ugly* why can’t people get over looks and focus on her amazing voice?

[@moas13415]

Cassandra McGuire this is such a dumb comment. You know just as well as anyone else that kpop is maybe 5-10% about actual talent and 90-95% about looks.

[@jeongincansteponme1554]

matsern Your comment is dumb, If they didn’t have talent they wouldn’t of debuted.. use ur head to think instead of ur ass.

[@soah3590]

I never knew people like that existed they need a life!

[@Lenkunuwu]

@@soah3590 as much as I want to agree that u need some talent to debut, it is true that kpop is 90% visuals and 10% talent, sometimes you will see some idols that are not the prettiest (or maybe they are pretty but koreans are dumb uk what I mean) but are really talented, and they will still get hate for being too ugly or too fat or whatever

[@soah3590]

@@Lenkunuwu it matters about the personaltiy most but they care about the outside, how disapointing i hope every kpop idol gets treated the same

[@EirTheGhost]

People:Wendy needs to lose weight (stressing out Wendy) Wendy:*loses weight* People:wow she looks so good Wendy: becomes afraid of eating cause she doesn't want to deal with backlash and loses weight. People: Woah. Wendy is losing too much weight. It must be the company's fault. Yeah... definitely sounds like the company's fault.

[@daisychainmilk]

Both the fans and companies fault.

[@juliana-yw7bg]

IKR these people are unbelievable, like, how can they be so inhumane and dumb. i feel bad for wendy TT

[@kaileeortiz8095]

Literally their chubby is skinnier than I am now wtf

[@muskaannagra8459]

Litterally same

[@Cynthia-il8ju]

Tea spill it’s okay, love yourself. I’m currently struggling with my weight but let’s love ourself 😊

[@r-ina]

@Tea spill Just ignore them ;/ I'm being called a "stick" or a " twig" etc and ppl thing is okay to say that to me since other ppl do it to - :( Trust me, I feel how you feel. Just love yourself and the way you are ❤️ There's nothing wrong with any body size ✨

[@Antiqueobsession1]

Yeah their clothing sizes are insane too. Like an american large is a korean small or xs. So they really don't get very big because their beauty standards expect everyone to be super small

[@kimstrovlg4075]

Snow Flakesx I wouldn’t be allowed in Korea

[@CharleneOcampo13]

LOL Wendy's not a "foreigner", she immigrated. She left Korea when she was what, pre-teens? She doesn't have "fat, foreigner genes" because she's 100% Korean. She's probably fuller during predebut because of the Western food composition as well and the amount of excercise she used to have wasn't as much as she does now.

[@DanGetson]

Right, this is what I’m confused by. The idea that she’s considered a foreigner because she spent a big chunk of her formative years in North America but was born in and spent what the first 10 11 years of life in Korea?

[@LM-ix7pk]

Dan Getson Wendy didn’t spend a huge amount of time in NA. She only moved to Canada for high school and just stayed their for 4 years. She came back to SK after that and became a trainee.

[@DanGetson]

LM I thought she moved there when she was 10, 11 went to shattuck st Mary’s for middle school in MN USA and then moved to Richmond hill to finish high school so a bit more than a 4 years but the fact remains.

[@1ronpc218]

*Kpop idol gains weight* *gains hate* *Kpop idol loses weight* *gains praise* *Kpop idol loses even more weight* *receives hate* I don't understand life anymore.....

[@jannatinelma148]

i mean who r they to decide their weight HATERS

[@chalkypocky8024]

Am I the only one who's really happy for idols who are normal weights? Like Wendy was "overweight" she was just healthier. And she was freaking adorable. It brings a smile to my face when I see idols who are more than 50kg. But, if they are naturally underweight, it still is fine. But if an idol is like 180cm and 45kg I get very worried. Underweight idols is just showing how cruel the companies are.

[@cosmiccrush22]

How cruel korean society is

[@blumacaw9399]

50 kg is a healty weight for someone who's very short like me(152.4 cm)

[@chervilisbetterthancilantro]

No one is "naturally underweight". No one is "naturally" skinny either. It's all about lifestyle and eating habits. Lisa and Rosé, both idols who are medically underweight and have been told that on shows by medical professionals, are called "naturally skinny" when they're obviously restricting to maintain their sickly BMI of 15.

[@bailey2866]

I love Wendy but she has always been one of the members to get the most hate. Yeri is hated in Korea for being a late member, but people internationally always rush to defend her considering how unfair it is, while for Wendy it seems that neither side really even likes her. For Korea it has to do with her weight changes and appearance, while internationally they are about the insensitive and stereotypical imitation she did of black girls on that variety show (which was very wrong and im not at all defending her). She definitely isn't perfect and has done bad things, but I can't imagine how hard it must be to have so little support both ways. From the way her agency seems to treat her, I dont think even they care about her very much. It's probably the reason she's never been able to admit to her problem or recover. Thanks again for uploading this!

[@fleurnini8865]

Yea.. But she is my bias despite everything. She is a lovely hardworking girl but people still don’t like her that much..

[@echouniverse]

I like her and I think Wendy’s weight has always been fine except for during red flavor era but now I think it’s perfect and peekaboo era was perfect also and her comments didn’t really bother me considering many things

[@justanaverageteen8609]

Linn Knutson what were the jokes

[@cloudy7476]

A.udrey.l Wow. That’s definitely biased. First of all, Yeri wasn’t trained to be a singer. Second of all, I think the dancing part is legit biased because you don’t like her. she is a LEAD DANCER. On idol room she did this kick step without her hands which even Seulgi didn’t attempt or try to do.

[@snehachoudhury5721]

@@audrey7175 stfu

[@rainhappy2233]

This is scary to watch. She went from a perfectly healthy body weight to severely underweight with a clear ED. The fact people are admiring this and young insecure and impressionable fans are watching this happen is so disturbing.

[@rcmajo7946]

I want to hug her so bad I hate the idea of Korean "talent" standards, Wendy is (in my opinion) one of the bests vocalists I've ever heard, SM has gold in their hands and the only thing They do is making idols feel bad.

[@nono8551]

I used to have an ed myself and the way she described how she eats is really similar to how the ed community would skip out on food. Youd watch others eat and it would translate to yourself feeling 'satisfied'- its hard to explain without being nasty.

[@amfgvideos2517]

Wendy's story is just really sad like Uee. I really don't know why people dislike her so much. After power up her fan-base seems to be a bit stronger than before though. It's surprising because usually the strongest vocal is the most popular. Wendy is still pretty obsessed with dieting but she's really toned it down a bit. I think she's legit trying to find her balance so she can be happy and just have everyone leave her alone about it. The way people fat shammed her and called her gross after losing weight probably scarred her for a long time.

[@lilymeid]

Are you gonna make a part 2

[@amfgvideos2517]

I'm not sure yet. If I do it won't be for a while because I have alot of requests to get through :)

[@liccy1677]

She got into a really bad racism scandal after she imitated a black and a white girl and is to this day getting backlash from the public although the K-Pop industry is pretty much the most racism, sexism and homophobe out of all industries. This obviously doesn't excuse her behaviour but I feel like the way she imitated white girls was just as bad. It just disappoints me that she never apologized. Another point is that she's American and being a foreigner is usually a disadvantage in the k-pop industry (for example the public is more focused on the girls' weight like you mentioned, or just take a look at Nct WinWins, Yutas and Johnnys lines. Although the boys are, compared to Wendy, beloved by fans they rarely get center even when the song is in their native language (I'm sorry if this is a mess but it's nearly 1am in my home country and English isn't my first language but I was really glad you managed to reupload this video))

[@panda-panda757]

@@liccy1677 Not only that, but she apparently immitated black people again when Bad Boy came out, which got more people angry. I honestly don't think she meant to be hurtful, but she should have learned from the first time she did. And the fact that she's Canadian made it even worse.

[@rxie6005]

She said she lost a bit of weight this recent comeback because o her schedule.

[@phoenix1907]

Funny how “fans” hate on her when she gains weight but blame the company when she gets an eating disorder. The reason the company is doing that is because of the intense hate from these “fans”...

[@jeanetteliu6821]

"Suspecting her company is pushing her too hard" lmao is that a joke? It's all bc of u guys.

[@layloo5244]

It was SM too. Joy explained on happy together SM monitored their weight and made them weigh themselves everyday and tell them what they were eating etc. Plus the video of wendy trying to eat ice cream but couldnt because her manager was glaring at her shows her manager also didnt approve of her eating.

[@Adele5554]

OR it's herself. She probably puts too much pressure on herself. Why do people assume it's everyone else? I'm sure she feels a certain way about it or else she wouldn't have lost that weight before she debuted.

[@juliana-yw7bg]

@@Adele5554 bruh who wouldn't put pressure on themselves when the whole world LITERALLY forces them to lose weight. fans are lowkey bullying wendy to ED.

[@ShuichiMin57]

@@layloo5244 it is the company's fault too, but the "fans" got balls to blame ONLY the company when they demand for the idols to be underweight. it's both of their fault.

[@roo9642]

it's hard being a girl. no matter how you look or what you do, you'll always be labelled something

[@laras-tp6gl]

And the sad part is, she has lost a lot of weight again which you can see from her recent fancams

[@Meow_meowwww]

oh..really?

[@fairytalearts810]

as someone with an ED, who has known and seen other people develop EDs. she is definitely either on the verge of developing one or already has. the sad thing is, it will never go away completely. it will always be a voice at the edge of her mind. constantly being criticized will only make it worse. I really hope she can make a full recovery, and that fans will finally shut up about her weight.

[@anitapg75]

4:39 poor girl. she literally just said "nothing tastes as good as skinny feels" and it's an incredibly problematic mentality to have

[@eveslatter929]

I would hate being a Kpop idol, weight is everything in that industry.

[@swagtime8873]

I actually like ‘chubby Wendy’ even tho she wasn’t even chubby she’s was just thicc, Like girl looked good

[@MrsLPAmy]

At her "heaviest" she was still pretty skinny and normal, what the hell...

[@audriipockii7901]

Im one of those people who only really gain weight in their legs and face, even if i have a small bone structure, and i gain weight easily. it really sucks and its easy to feel self conscious about your legs. if you ever have a thigh gap, its a feeling that gives you the most happiness in the world. you begin to realize how easily your legs gain weight and so you eat less and less, three meals, to two meals, to one meal, to five bites, down to three. youre happy because the weight in your legs and overall body has reduced, but it becomes unhealthy. it takes a while to find a healthy point, because it just seems so hard to stay "fit." everyday i look at my legs and pinch at the fat, and without realizing eat less because it just comes natural. you begin to grow uncomfortable eating food. once at a school party we had snacks and i remember feeling sick after eating a few bites. heck, even thinking about it i have the feeling of putting snacks down. 7:20 this body would make people that gain weight like wendy and i extremely happy, to be at this point. i was happy for her when i saw this clip, and then the captions said negative things about it and my smile just dropped. i had no idea. i think, this video will help me realize how unhealthy it is to eat like this. this is how i feel when im NOT an idol. i cant imagine how pressured wendy feels as an idol. i think this is why my bias is wendy, because i understand the struggle. no matter what body, we should support wendy, and encourage her to live healthily!

[@HeatherMantica]

I can’t believe she was on a show talking about literal signs of an eating disorder and the editors just popped up text and sound effects they acted like it was nothing. She’s short it’s natural for her to be on the slightly thicker side this is so sad.

[@lacyyazzie4195]

this makes me so sad she’s perfect just the way she is and she didn’t deserve any of that especially the hate towards her weight every member on red velvet is beautiful

[@KM-wb1yd]

Ok but she was actually so beautiful and healthy in late 2015-early 2016. If I had to choose a physique, I would choose that one. It suits her too. I can’t believe netizens bullied her into that extreme weight loss. I really want her to be healthy and gain the weight back if she hasn’t already.

[@Anna-zp1ok]

The same fans that criticized her and now worried are the biggest hypocrites, they're the ones that put her on that path.

[@theprettiestgirll]

2:19 THAT’S FAT?! OHMYGOD THEN I’M A MEGALADON MIXED WITH A WHALE.

[@kikalcala]

I long for Wendy's body in the Dumb Dumb era, oh my gosh those legs are perfection. I love Wendy so muchhh! Go girl!!! Ignore the haters, you are so talented...!!! :)

[@Lostinmyhead23]

The way these fans over react to these celebrities “weight” gains you would think the celebrity became 600lbs over night. She looks average weight for her height.

[@reaganb6013]

6:00 broke my heart

[@lailaidouhmane9080]

Same 😞

[@f.justf.7230]

not even gonna lie, she looked really good thicc because it really fit her outfits and really good thin because it also fit her outfits. She's super pretty and kpop fanbases rly suck. have a nice day

[@morganfayeehumble8803]

3:00 I fucking love her. "They can't breathe because of you".

[@Chikimsan]

The heck I want to cry right now. It must be so hard for her to receive all these negative reactions from people WHO DOESN'T EVEN KNOW HER OR WHAT SHE'S GOING THROUGH. Koreans should wake up that they shouldn't focused that much on outward appearance. Don't let others decide your value, Wendy. 😭

[@ariana1020]

in dumb dumb era she wasn't even fat its so sad to se all the hate she received and still recieves

[@annek8552]

This is so sad, she didn't look chubby anytime

[@yackie8274]

UM.....thats muscle lol. if you're practicing ur choreo as often as her, you'll get toned.

[@skeletalwrld]

this video is like my guilty pleasure. i come back and watch it so often

[@meetmeinthehallwayoopies2081]

nothing breaks my heart more than this, Wendy deserves love and support for all her body sizes, she was never ever fat EVER

[@lucw3041]

I was worried about her health, obviously she's the thinnest out of all Kpop members, Wendy really deserved this spot and in the future, she shud be getting higher. She works very hard and stays humble and kind-hearted. My first idol

[@jesstaylor1872]

wow, literally the definition of an eating disorder... i hope she will be okay... I for one love her for who she is, it doesn't matter what she looks like (she was beautiful to begin with!)

[@aakritichourasia6495]

I got into Red Velvet because of Wendy. I saw her dancing so carefree in knowing bros that I fell for her instantly. You can tell that she is very cheerful and vibrant just from that dance. Seeing this video I got scared. Just what the hell is wrong with people? She is a lovely person, can't you see that ? I just really want to protect that carefree smile of hers. Please be ok Wendy. I really wish I could hug you right now. You are and always will be my queen . Saranghae !

[@MrChannelforwatching]

I was wondering why I wasn't getting any notifications from your channel and decided to look you up. I'm glad I found you again! Just a suggestion, maybe you could do Umji from Gfriend?

[@lilyyyy4851]

I’m crying, as someone who has issues with weight going to her face and legs and no where else, and feel huge and afraid to eat and become bigger, I can completely relate to all of this. I want to give her the biggest hug and tell her that no matter what she does, we all have her back and will support her no matter what the scale says

[@ele3284]

I don't rlly like Wendy but what the supposed fans did to her was beyond disgusting and disrespectful and no one should have to go through that

[@kosbud4330]

Even though Wendy is beautiful in anyway, but I feel like her being skinny really caught people’s attention because her body and Face really stands out once she lost those weight, and also I feel like she feels a lot more confident in her skinny times. Her body in Umpah Umpah is pretty good she seems really stunning but I don’t want Red Flavor to repeat again

[@hanna.608]

it makes me really sad to see that there are people that think it's okay to criticize these idols. if i had to take a guess, i would say that the eras where she was skinnier were probably the most miserable for wendy. i don't exactly understand korean culture, but in the us and canada (where wendy's grew up), we embrace every size and shape. it's really terrible that grown people have the hearts to say that wendy in the dumb dumb area is lazy.

[@linablues6881]

Hi, I don't understand: she borns in Canadá, why she went to South Korea!? Why several artists with Korean blood, born in USA go to KS? Why?

[@BeanSprouts02]

Lina Blues I mean why not? Korea is their hometown

[@eung4101]

Sometimes I remember all the things she has been through, and I wish she had stayed in Canada/Usa becoming a dentist or studying any of the careers she wanted to study.

[@helloeveryone5455]

Some fans get worried but when it comes to her gaining weight those fans are also the one hating! :/

[@shaikhaazzahra6751]

can people stop commenting abt any idols' body? focus on their talent. they aren't a group to be known for their "amazing bodies" they're known for their amazing vocal and dancing skills. skinny doesn't mean attractive.

[@arak-fz7mn]

Wendy: * looks normal and healthy * people: ew Wendy: * weight loss * people: 💖💖💖💖💖💖 Wendy: * afraid of food, still losing weight * people: * pikachu face * ew i hate this

[@morganfayeehumble8803]

I was healthier chubby. Just because someone is thin, doesn't mean it's healthy. In reality most of us are weak, frail, tired, dizzy, depressed, deprived.

[@MML-ds1jx]

I hope those People hating on her don't consider themselves as part of the fandom...Even when she's chubby that doesn't change her talent and personality but as was said, it's mostly all about appearance in Kpop industry.. Waiting for the day it's all about just a healthy body, talent, passion and personality..

[@yumifoxlyne9447]

Why r they giving her hate comments they rlly work hard and she's cute how can she be ugly + as long as she's healthy like bruh can't they be real fans and appreciate every member they r cute and beautiful no matter what they rlly work hard can't anyone be more humane it's not that hard to be nice🤦🏻‍♀️

[@charlie-hy1jl]

if i was as skinny as “thicker” wendy i would be happy sigh

[@ungegreier1802]

" You know the girls... _They bring the boys out!_ " My jam before all of your video... 😅 💕

[@summern8157]

Her dancing is so much less sharp and energized when she's really skinny. She's probably really undernourished and struggling to have the energy to perform.

[@hopeworld3477]

Thank you for this. I will never, never forget kfans for what they did to some idols. Taeyeon, Suri, Umji, Yeri, IU, Wheein, and more went through extremely dark and difficult days due to bullying, backlash and hate, this is absolutely sickening. It's always double sided and they're so hypocrite : "take care of yourself" but don't gain weight, "they are so healthy" when these idols are starving, "they look so good" when they are the skinniest ever, ect ... Obviously, idols mental health is pushed aside and when they express their sadness/sorrow about some moments being hard, it's always the "then you shouldn't have become an idol", like it was their job to obey fans and turn themselves into puppets who fans force to fit into a fucking unhealthy mould for their own pleasure. It's disgusting, that seriously makes me sick to the stomach. And they even dare to call ifans names ? They literally have EVERYTHING and because they are koreans they think they can dictate their lives so idols can be just like they would like them to be ? Yeah just shup the fuck up.

[@tarynjimison7889]

This video pisses me off she looked amazing when she was “chubby” that was a completely normal weight I can’t believe they made her lose weight from that

[@furqanrizvi8144]

it's either too skinny or too fat for k-pop fans, no in between. same can be applied to taeyeon, wendy, and lia.

[@jewelwood4587]

I rewatch this like every year and I have no idea why

[@jka1165]

To be kind with others and ourselves, and to avoid restricting ourselves

[@jewelwood4587]

@@jka1165 agreed, at one point my TW TW ed was so bad around two years ago. But here I am now eating delightfully although I do fall back sometimes but still going strong!

[@jka1165]

@@jewelwood4587 good to know that you are doing great now 💖

[@Esandeech2]

Such an intelligent and talented woman reduced to the stupid kpop standards.. I think that now she’s a bit older she’s realized her worth. She’s so so so much more than her weight!

[@meqnie6620]

As much as I hate that fans critiqued and criticized her body I’m very happy that this person used kind and good words to express her emotion on the situation

[@loverofeverything.]

poor girl, especially the interview clips from russian roulette era make me sad. hope she’s doing better now

[@echolime416]

Idk why people dislike the video, there is nothing wrong with it

[@daphneduck3294]

It's sad that they are so hyper focused on size like she definitely changed over time but it feels like everytime she gained five pounds someone had to write an article about it, like geez does it really matter if she's 120 or 125 pounds jesus

[@mrsvoice7292]

I was watching and I realized Wendy is the one who always has a smile the whole time on stage ❤️💜I hope she's happy on stage and her personal life

[@lalalalalahappiness422]

I don't care about her weight Wendy is so beautiful and cute 😍

[@rekisupremacy1496]

netizens: lose weight!!! wendy: *loses weight* netizens: ew not like that

[@justchats-_-7884]

Korea's beauty standards are so toxic she can be as big or slim as she wants she is a human being not a robot we gain weight it's something that we can't control.

[@wendysonbae7629]

This girl deserves so much love. Hope she realizes that she is perfect just the way she is.

[@zahmeraa8128]

Wendy is actually really fit compared to many people

[@SuperMarioGalaxy1357]

ppl be commenting about how she shouldn't focus on her weight but don't forget what the kpop industry sells: looks and visuals. I'm not saying in any way that it's justified to hate on someone because of their weight, but you guys are being too unrealistic with these comments. you think a group of overweight pop idols will sell better than idols who are petite? Sorry to say, that's just unrealistic especially since east Asian culture associates thin with beauty. again, not bashing overweight people here, but hell I've lived in both east Asia and the US and let me tell you there are barely any overweight people in Asia. it's just a cultural difference and you need to accept that Asian countries aren't as liberal as western countries when it comes to stuff like weight.

[@nerdydrawer7265]

Am I part of the minority of the fans who only really focuses on the song, voices and outfits in every comeback instead of the body types? I mean, shoot, Wendy has a better figure than most people and has a beautiful voice and face to boot. Seriously haters, stop looking at her body and appreciate her talent more, she's putting a lot of effort just to maintain both of them so the least you can do is enjoy her dance moves and vocals.

[@jenesaiis]

She really looked pretty and healthy back then but I won't say I prefer her better there or she looks unhealthy now..because what would I be doing ? The same. She's skinny now and people are blaming her that she's unhealthy, then she gains a little weight and people call her fat. What's wrong with these people? Can y'all just stop commenting on her body? Ik you're trying to make her feel good that she was healthy then and not fat but that doesn't help now. You're making it worse. Just stop commenting on her body. Is it that hard? If you want to comment just say Wendy you're really amazing. You're talented. And your pretty always. Beautiful you. ( That's all. Stop commenting she looks prettier before than now or whatever ) ..

[@msIlkaTan]

2:35 holy shit she’s PERFECT here

[@joshler1820]

archie exactly!

[@roseredmayne]

People called her fat at 52kg. That's ridiculous how someone that size could be considered fat! It broke my heart when she said she didn't enjoy eating because the other girls were thinner than her. Netizens need to learn that as long as a person is healthy that it doesn't matter how "fat" or "thin" they are.

[@avie1892]

1:55 every middle schooler’s hair in 2015

[@sinta1818]

It is easy to criticize than create. Every single human in this world think they are better then the others. I just thankful how Wendy can faces the hate comments and she has realize its a risk to be an idol. I pray she always healthy and happy.

[@euphoria.yunjin]

it's not about when she looked better- it's about NO ONE should have a say about anyone's body. YOU DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT.

[@AM-dg7ww]

Even at 2:35, her "heaviest," she's probably 118 pounds and that's perfectly healthy for someone her height. It shouldn't matter what somebody looks like, but whether they eat right, exercise, and overall are just healthy.

[@kylaokamoto9822]

It’s sad that when a person may be struggling the most or hurting the most is when they are getting love and praise. Then when they are happy and healthy is when they receive hate. Either way you receive hate.

[@lysosome2907]

This video is just a proof that people look at the outer appearance instead of focusing on the real inner appearance.

[@Anonjiminarmyfan123]

I get that weight somehow defines your looks and shape hence it is important in the industry,but some netz are so obsessed with it its becoming toxic,throwing that vast amount of hate on guys and girls who are only 20ish??Some people are just pure evil

[@kylapimentellucero2499]

Even she will be the fattiest kpop idol I still love her indeed I LOVE YOU WENDY💙💙💙 Even I watch it on facebook I still keep watching it

[@carpool.]

It’s disgusting how her fans said she was fat and lazy when she actually had a beautiful body, and shamed her because she was “too skinny” for their likings. Why can’t the idols just breathe, the focus should be on their voices and not how they look

[@jimingotjams]

she literally had a healthy body. she was young and craved food which is normal for her age. the media bullied her into thinking her body was gross and she was lazy all because they didn’t like the way HER body looked. This most likely affected her a LOT and she went on a diet. they praised her, and she probably felt loved and it gave her the valadiation she wanted. She decided to lose MORE weight in hope that people would love her more and people began to call her ugly and scary? what the fuck is wrong with people seriously. this girl was hurt by so many people and most likely suffered an ED because of toxic ‘fans’. i feel so bad that she felt the need to do this to her body because of how cruel people were to her. she is really beautiful and i hope she learns she doesn’t need to change her body for ANYONE. my heart hurts for her. people bullied her for ‘gaining’ to much weight and when she did so she got called more names. i’m so sick how can they’re be actual people like this that hate on peoples body for no reason. people who do that are full of insecurity and try to make other peoples lives miserable. shame on them.

[@colleen6341]

well good news i discovered red velvet because of this video and i’ve been a reveluv for over a year!!!! bad news i still have anorexia

[@leticiat.5994]

that makes two of us

[@twiceonce7223]

this is so sad. not only did wendy have to be an amazing vocalist, that wasn't enough for the cruel public apparently, and she had to starve herself. sometimes I wish she weren't an idol so that she could pursue her singing career without having to worry about her body. but I'm glad she's doing well now

[@emilyjacobs4803]

I’ve always loved Wendy the best bc she’s such a vibrant person, not bc of a stupid thigh gap. I hope she sees through the negative comments to the people who love her for who she is 😢

[@mickey7759]

As a hard stan Reveluv, this phase of Wendy really hurts me a lot. The way her confidence plummeted bec of those malicious comments. I can't believe how those words turn the brightest, bubbliest and kindest person to someone afraid and anxious. But now, I am happy that she's regained her confidence & is now very healthy. We will always, always be here for you Son Seungwan! We believe in you!

[@slendercnpsucks.gocryabout3984]

I cant believe this is two years ago

[@kunga3820]

Love all kinds of body type every human is beautiful in their own way