Why Is American Patriotism So Weird?

[@SecondThought]

Howdy, friends! I hope you enjoy the episode. If you appreciate the work I'm doing and you'd like to help support the channel, please consider becoming a patron on Patreon! Every patron gets early access to every video, plus access to our patrons-only Discord server. It's a great place to learn and hang out with likeminded people. We even have a book club! patreon.com/secondthought

[@SOG1172]

I love your timing😂 Just got out of an hour long tik tok battle with an exceptionalist… I wish they could break out of this patriotic shell of theirs… Thanks for the video comrade. Always love your work.

[@grmpEqweer]

Another banger. ✊️ Frankly, when the far right calls any social justice movements or government social programs "socialism!"...Well, these movements and programs can often really help people. So the right is inadvertently leading at least some people to believe that socialism is when people are helped or supported? Not accurate, but useful to us.

[@monadolifesaver5613]

I know you were using them as an example, but why didn't you blur their email name? Though what they said to you could be considered controversial to your audience, your decision to leave the name is likewise, a possibly bad decision.

[@werbnaright5012]

Nationalism is just politics for basic people. -Beauofthefifthcolumn's shirt

[@nothanks9503]

Someone really tried to argue with me that kids these days need to stop demanding rights 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@podemosurss8316]

I'm Spanish. In my country some conservatives ask why we cannot be as "patriotic" as the US. My father gave me a great response when I was a kid: because we had a 40 years dictatorship in which the regime sponsored that blind patriotism.

[@conxa005]

In Chile happened the same thing. The dictatorship also forced that kind of blind patriotism and fractured the country in 2: The ones who benefited from the dictatorship and the rest. Luckily, that "patriotism" over time transformed into a cult of personality for the Dictator. Even more luckily, the trauma of the dictatorship makes it that, if you ever dare to speak good of that dictator, you immediately commits a "social suicide" (everyone will hate you)

[@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394]

I both like and hate that conservatism so often finds itself aligned with oppression and tyranny.

[@cristianhurtadocabezas208]

some spaniards want Franco to come back. Fortunatelyevery year there are less of them, slowly dying

[@IHateMyAccountName]

Franco? Yeah. That's rough.

[@asongfromunderthefloorboards]

I'm American but one side of my family moved to America in the 1950s from Germany. Why not pledge undying fanatical devotion to a leader who promises to make the nation "great again"? It didn't go well the last time.

[@Spieterlaman]

American patriotism is so odd because it's often conflated to morality. You'll often see a bunch of people calling others unpatriotic as if that means they are some how evil.

[@Hawkatana]

When usually it's he exact opposite.

[@jenniferreyes8187]

True

[@Dagowit]

Not sure if that's American only, in Poland it's pretty much the same

[@Γι3ργ0ς]

Ultranationalism.

[@Aleksssssssss]

Being unpatriotic is evil, imagine not loving your country

[@saevusbrutum2796]

“You’re not to be so blind with patriotism that you can’t face reality. Wrong is wrong, no matter who does it or says it.” -Malcolm X

[@angelcabeza6464]

yeah malcom x used violence wrong is wrong right?

[@saevusbrutum2796]

@@angelcabeza6464 how is self defense equal to systemic violence brought on to a community solely based upon race? Like genuinely please tell me

[@chriscortez2036]

@@angelcabeza6464 Is defending yourself wrong? Violence shouldn’t be a first resort but, as sad as it sounds, oppressors & oppressive systems can’t always be changed peacefully. Especially if the oppressors are themselves militant & uncompromising.

[@newt7590]

The US is still one of the least patriotic nations on earth. People need to travel and interact with the locals more. As an example the main thing stopping confederate Europe from becoming a union like the USA is their patriotism not wanting to give up their national identity. Becoming a union like the US has always been the goal of the EU

[@burninghard]

@@angelcabeza6464 A man tries to kill a kid on the street and the kid fights back. Would in your estimation that be wrong?

[@iloveplasticbottles]

It's weird how people's reactions to criticism of the US is "if you don't like it, then leave" instead of working to make it better. It's literally "Why solve a problem when you can just ignore it?"

[@thedukeofchutney468]

Usually it depends on the problem. Modern patriots and/or nationalist say that when someone is trying to change something seem as fundamental about America. So for example if someone was saying “We want more libraries!” No one would tell him to leave the country. However if they are talking about implementing socialism or getting rid of the first or second amendments (things that are seen as intrinsic to the nation) then they are told to leave as they would essentially want to change the nation so much that it would essentially be a different country all together.

[@MrNoncredo]

"if you don't like it you can leave" is the typical fascist response

[@MrNoncredo]

​@@thedukeofchutney468 implement socialism? aside maybe a couple of countries in the world, see "socialist" countries in Europe? In the long term, does the American model seem successful in any case or that the American model will last indefinitely compared to Europe?

[@thedukeofchutney468]

@@MrNoncredo Dude, that is not a fascist response AT ALL. A fascist would imprison or kill dissenters as they see the glory of the state as the highest good. While I don't see America being an indefinite part of the world (no nation or civilization is) I will say that I personally see it lasting longer than Europe. The latter is far too reliant on the American globalized order to be able to disconnect and run itself. Many nations such as Germany have pretty much nerfed their militaries as well making them even more vulnerable. For all of its hype I don't see the EU lasting for too much longer at least not in its current state due for a number of factors.

[@sketchiefello9002]

@@thedukeofchutney468 " A fascist would imprison or kill dissenters as they see the glory of the state as the highest good." you intentionally forgot the word "exile" in that sentence, as expected from dishonest scum

[@WoefulMinion]

I'm always astonished at people who say about our country (or the state we share), "If you don't like it, get out." I was born here and have lived here my whole life, so this is my home and I want it to be the best for everyone. It's as if, when your house is being robbed or burned down, the problem is your reporting it, not the robbers or arsonists actions.

[@Praisethesunson]

If you don't like it get out is the only form of choice they are given in the workplace. So naturally they extend the only choice they know of to people they don't like.

[@attilajuhasz2526]

Your second paragraph (re your house being burgled) is an outstanding analogy.

[@tblakemusic]

Plus, "packing your bags and leaving" is WAY easier said than done lol. Entertaining a move to Europe right now and man, immigration is way more difficult than I feel like it should be. Not to mention the costs incurred with moving on top of that.

[@WoefulMinion]

@@tblakemusic Yeah, too rich for my blood. I can't leave...unless the governor ships me off somewhere with a McDonald's gift certificate as a lagniappe.

[@JustMe-vn5pq]

What would the "Love It or Leave It" types have said to those awful protestors in 1776? It's not hard to imagine: "If you don't like the way King George is running his colonies, then you can bloody well leave." These love it or leave it types aren't Patriots, for in 1776 the true Patriots were the protestors. Instead, they'd have been the Loyalists, the Tories.

[@tomfoolery5680]

It always blows my mind how a country that declares how free it is so violently demands conformity.

[@JamesDavy2009]

The Kiwis enjoy the most freedom in the world.

[@Theomite]

It's a variation of "anyone who truly understands _____ can't disagree with it." For these people, the conforming is the same as being right, and a free person will inevitably become that if there aren't any institutions interfering with it. That's why they use the argument: freedom allows people to opt out of "being right" and that makes the government allowing that to be "tyrannical" because it somehow *compels* people to be counter-cultural through trickery or something.

[@etopsch369]

@@JamesDavy2009 maybe, I would have said the dutch. The USA isn´t even among the top ten. Kiwis are prohibiting smoking?

[@JamesDavy2009]

@@etopsch369 I don't know what my neighbours across the ditch are trying to do. As far as I know, smoking is verboten in certain places and vaping is also falling under the umbrella of smoking as it's a different method of ingesting nicotine.

[@com.7869]

Because freedom doesn't mean you can do anything you want. You must make concessions in order to be free. For example your freedom to force me to not be able to speak isn't allowed because it would violate my freedom to speak. Therefore you must conform to the law so that we may both be able to speak freely and spread ideas.

[@justsomeguy1408]

When I was in middle school, we got an assignment where we had to write an essay explaining why we were either proud or not proud to say the pledge of allegiance. I wrote that I wasn't proud because saying "one nation under God" didn't seem like a good separation of church and state and that it didn't seem like there was "liberty and justice for all." I remember, as an 11 year old, being pulled aside by my teacher who asked if I hated America and wanted to live somewhere else.

[@RIPKabosu2000]

It is truly disturbing as a child when you are chastised with dogma when pointing out flaws within that dogma.

[@coolioso808]

That's interesting, because what did they think was going to happen? Every kid would say they are proud? Of course some kids are going to think differently and explain their reasoning. Good for you. I think kids should have this basic assignment, these days: "What would happen if you woke up tomorrow and money didn't exist and nobody knew what it was? Everything built is already known, all the knowledge is still written down and we have some people with really big houses and jets and vain stuff like that, but money no longer exists. What do you think would happen in the next 7 days? The next month? And next year?" That's a Critical Thinking class question opener, I think.

[@LinguisticLifeform]

What a courageous 11yo. I wasn't that brave at 11

[@michaeld4861]

OMG, that's simultaneously awesome but also horrifying that the teacher would be so blindly uncritical and that an 11 year old has to point out basic reality to someone that is supposed to teach kids how to think critically.

[@lillilacac]

This is horrifying! It's like a filtration system...

[@davidblank420]

I love the argument of "You cant change the constitution!", bruv, of couse you can, we call them ammendments. 😂

[@Queen_of_Coffee]

Yikes, I pity the person who has to explain to such an individual that the Bill of Rights wouldn’t exist without the ability to amend the Constitution.

[@gren97]

In Germany there is a "Ewigkeitsklausel" for the first 20 laws of the Grundgesetz (german constitution) and therefore they can never be changed.

[@Fabioonn]

@@gren97 If the government realy needs or want to change one of the laws they can just change the Ewigkeitsklausel. Can't they?

[@gren97]

@@Fabioonn no. It would have to go through the Bundesrat and the Bundestag and because of the Ewigkeitsklausel being the Ewigkeitsklausel it wouldn't get far. But if the government decides to replace the Grundgesetz completely, I think it could be possible but wouldn't be easy.

[@divat10]

​@@gren97i like how "no" and "it would be possible" is in the same comment here

[@gamerguy5085]

I’m Australian, we used to look to America as a kind of benevolent big brother, someone to follow and admire, someone we knew had our back. Now America is viewed more like that crazy uncle you wouldn’t invite to a bbq.

[@88Expert]

Now we use it to laugh at them

[@bigfluffyhusky1624]

And I laugh at both of your corrupt politicians. It's something that keeps me from crying

[@kkpenney444]

You can thank your own Rupert Murdoch for carefully raising that crazy uncle. No one single person has done more damage to present-day America than Murdoch. Thanks a lot Australia.

[@mistressofstones]

​@@kkpenney444 we hate Murdoch too, he also harms our country.

[@ClaudeHopper1969]

@@kkpenney444 Good point!

[@Sector13Creative]

"The world is not going to be made better as long as the oppressed fight one another. for the crumbs dropped from the tables of the oppressors." What a quote!

[@MHWGamer]

If you aren't the biggest critic of your own country, something is wrong in your understanding of a democracy! The blind love for a country and its actions is fundamental dangerous. Sadly that is mostly the case when patriotism is part of your identity.

[@maslauer6411]

I completely agree with you! However in my country the people who hate Austria or even try to abolish it claim this opinion to be theirs. (sorry for my bad english)

[@professorminstrels6460]

Patriotism doesn't mean blind loyalism to your own country. In Ireland we are quite patriotic in our own way, but we are not overly militaristic and still critical of things our country/government does. We are generally quite Liberal too these days

[@tino5971]

@@professorminstrels6460But in America, it is. And we are talking about America.

[@professorminstrels6460]

@@tino5971 it doesn't have to be that way tho

[@tomthomassony8607]

If your definition of history is nostalgia wrapped up in a flag.......you’re a patriot.

[@pavelkiselev_youtube]

I am from Russia and it is so darkly ironic that patriotism in America and Russia is so similar

[@vanidemo]

It's pretty well known that if you don't like someone's personality trait it's because you yourself have that trait. This makes Russia, USA, China & North Korea the same in my book. They are the same rotten country, just speaking different languages

[@peterleadley]

The US has more money, so they can do it better.

[@ra.n9482]

​@@brenesser Judging by the context it's rather obvious that the user above was speaking figuratively

[@M1tZk1]

I was birn in Belarus but than moved to Germany and what I always tell people is that Russia is litteraly the same as the USA but without the sugar coating.

[@peterleadley]

🤣

[@Cobracommander1986]

Comedian George Carlin once said: "Rights aren't rights if someone can take them away. They're privileges. That's all we've ever had in this country is a bill of temporary privileges."

[@42069TV]

Ayy!!! My man, George Carlin!

[@HylianFox3]

If only he were still alive today.... he'd have a heart attack and die again at the state of this country.

[@lilahdog568]

How true

[@VChong1991]

Westerners and their bills. Hah. The west broke so many treaties to the point their word have zero credibility.

[@tavitafish]

"A true patriot seeks to make their country the best it could be through change and reform, a "patriot" seeks to keep their country stagnant as they see it as the best version of itself" - me, a couple years ago, also more than likely some dead guy who's way smarter than me

[@kyleyoung2464]

W

[@jayplay8869]

@@toolbaggers Germany was only trying to be 1900s america. They literally got 100% of their policy from American politics. America has segregation and slaving, while having killed off all our native populations, we also invented eugenics. So yea, Germany 1930 was based on the foundations of America. We have the letters between the two country’s to prove it as well. It’s a sad fact. We are the Nazis forefathers.

[@Trixie_Lavender]

The majority of people with famous or profound quotes are just as smart as you

[@RevolutionaryGuitar]

@@Trixie_Lavender I wouldn’t say that. Maybe as smart as this person. But if you’ve ever been out in ya’know the public. They are fucking stupid.

[@Terrorstar-gbp]

💯agree

[@richardspillers6282]

Growing up I always thought that the truest form of patriotism was loving your country enough to want to make changes for the better of its people. By my teens and twenties very common to hear "if you don't like it leave" as a response to the smallest of suggestions.

[@kenethrodriguez573]

As harsh as it sounds, that’s what many people do. Many people leave their countries because they don’t like their policies. Why can’t americans not content with the government do the same ?

[@autoteleology]

@@kenethrodriguez573 Because it sounds like you think the country belongs to you first, because you like it the way it is.

[@kenethrodriguez573]

@@autoteleology huhh ? No lol every country has a set of policies. That’s what our ancestors did also, left countries they felt uncomfortable. British left to come to the americas.

[@fuddwrecker3773]

@@kenethrodriguez573 A vast majority of people do not do that. Do you think George, Alexander, Thomas, Benjamin, and John should have just left the colonies instead of declaring independence from the British? Also, the Brits didn't leave a country they didn't like. They established colonies all over the world in the name of and controlled by their own monarchy. Most of those places became independent only after the citizens enacted bloody revolutions and established new governments. Most didn't just leave.

[@fuddwrecker3773]

The colonists who chose to revolt against the British government called themselves Patriots. Our modern use of the word patriotism is literally derived from that term. What's crazy is that some of the same people who tell others “if you don't like it, just leave” also say that storming the Capital was an act of patriotism. Why couldn't those people “just leave” instead of trying to stop the lawful transfer of power?

[@cajuncountry84]

There is a quote from a book that paraphrases John Steinbeck that I always like when discussing why the US is so like this. It sums up how I was raised and the general philosophy of the people in the midwest and rural US. “John Steinbeck once said that socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires.” -Ronald Wright, 'A Short History of Progress' (2005).

[@francisdec1615]

Most grass root right-wingers everywhere look at themselves like that. There is an internet forum in my country Sweden, called Flashback. Most people there are like US MAGA people. Just like US MAGA people it's also obvious that most of them are wage slaves and on welfare or disability. 90% of them would perish within a month or so, if the brutal social Darwinist society most of them want actually came true. But they're living on the illusion that they are temporarily embarrassed elite people.

[@hainleysimpson1507]

So blind hope and delusion.

[@HkFinn83]

This is 100% true. There are people living below the poverty line with no medical care, no education and no hope of ever getting any, but they’re against a minimum wage

[@clareshaughnessy2745]

And the rich see them as lazy potential scroungers

[@IceGoddessRukia]

Why I get annoyed when someone says "when I become a millionaire" like...hard work and progress in this society will save them.

[@haolekoa737]

"Patriotism is the belief that my country is the best because I was born here." -- Terry Pratchett, Jingo

[@kellydalstok8900]

@@justinratcliffe947 Pratchett is ridiculing patriotism/nationalism in Jingo.

[@DukeSar77]

Nationalism says "My country is better than yours." Patriotism says "I love my country."

[@Evolcun]

@@tobitobi628 Exactly, as a democratic socialist, I love the US, I want to see it's problems get solved, I'm not gonna pretend they don't exist like some people do.

[@Evolcun]

@@tobitobi628 And there's so much more too! Like fighting for economic equality, guaranteed housing, and empowering the people to have a real say in political, economic, and workplace decisions by redistributing power from the 1% to the other 99% of the population!

[@Jack-tk1is]

I mean, USA 🇺🇸 is the best, Im an immigrant from asia

[@user-em6ie2be7x]

A lot of people (Mainly Conservatives) I've talk to love their blind Patriotism & will overlook or outright ignore a lot of systemic problems of this country Mainly by saying "America is The Greatest Country on Earth, & if you don't like it go live somewhere else" it's Infuriating that people can be so oblivious. 🤦🏿‍♂️

[@LibertarianLiberall]

It was version of fascism. They called it "National-socialism". As russian i just say "DON'T BE AFRAID OF FASCISM, FIGHT IT". Well, or else you will live under fascism, as my deceived fellow citizens live and believe, who for 20 years already look like cattle, not people and are proud of Ruzzia, how much to take over the world!

[@jalfredl]

@@reyalsregnava or just plain idiots

[@jalfredl]

When they do say to me “leave if you don’t like it here” At times..I respond back to them: “Well I don’t to be a victim under US foreign policy “, and you wouldn’t believe how it goes over many heads (mostly right wingers)- I am truly amazed how ignorant this country really is

[@marym7104]

America IS one of the best countries on Earth… which says a lot about the current state of the world as a whole

[@mystman7722]

@Bonka I ask them "you hate it when a Democrat is president. Why didn't YOU leave when it was Obama?" I never get a reply 😅

[@Telleryn]

I've always thought of it like owning a house, pointing out a crack in the foundation or water damage in the walls doesn't mean you hate the house, and failing to recognize those problems will eventually lead to its destruction, so if you love the house, take good care of it

[@elliweick2252]

And sometimes when you ignore water damage too long, you might have to take the wall out and rebuild it. For the greater good of the house.

[@rizkyadiyanto7922]

thing is, people have different understanding/believe which thing is bad and which is good. whats your solution to that?

[@pallingtontheshrike6374]

@@rizkyadiyanto7922 democratic discussion focusing on the groups that specialize in each specific issue. Y'know, to avoid such farces as the recent congressional "hearing" on tiktok. And to avoid such things like the entire discussion being dominated by corporate media (a la most things in australia)

[@bondrewdthelordofdawn3744]

That really good analogy

[@mikeoveli1028]

​@@pallingtontheshrike6374 Tick-tock? You are correct. Democrats don't bother with things like ticktock 😂.

[@felipereyna1955]

Few things I am proud of my country, Mexico. We are very patriotic, but this love is towards the people and our culture. We never hesitate to accept that we suck at things like education, safety and inequality.

[@GabrielVelasco1908.]

Same as here in Brazil!

[@mikefilimon1584]

🇺🇸 ❤ 🇲🇽 ❤️ 🇧🇷

[@logician3641]

LOL...

[@Freezingpoint777]

I started noticing this in the early 2000's when I was opposed to the Iraq war, I was called unpatriotic and all kinds of other things, my favorite was being called a Muslim sympathizer which I had to laugh at and agree with, it's so weird to think being sympathetic is wrong.

[@MetalHeart8787]

actually the people were uneducated & I understand you didn't know what to say at the time. in Reality people / & ME who supported the war were Muslim sympathizers because we wanted the people of kuwait to live freely & Not be Killed by Saddams sorry ass Army.

[@mikejett2733]

I know my 1st girlfriend growing up was a Palestinian Muslim it's so sad that compassion is dead 😢

[@jeisselima]

As a muslim I appreciate your sympathy

[@olafsigursons]

Muslim integrism is religious fascism. It's not because you are a PoC that you are always right or you above any critism.

[@Matt-vq8fg]

@@olafsigursons Citation needed.

[@Sun-Tzu-]

"Patriotism is believing a country is the best because *you* were born in it" - Stephen Fry

[@Praisethesunson]

That makes sense to me. -Kayne West

[@phillygrunt2154]

“Try and take guns & rights away and I’ll take your life away” -me

[@zertun2380]

@@phillygrunt2154 What rights? Pretty sure in US you have to buy even basic human rights XD

[@TempleGuitars]

The sports team from my geographical location is far superior to the sports team from your geographical location.

[@korpen2858]

""Patriotism is believing a country is the best because you were born in it" - Stephen Fry" - Sun Tzu

[@tombrewsaugh1399]

I am 71 years old and you have articulated my feelings and beliefs better than I ever could have. Thank you.

[@codex8085]

Thanks for destroying our country Boomer

[@DarthFhenix55]

Man, you really had the opportunity to see a lot of things happen.

[@kareemashry7475]

Here in Egypt "patriotsm" is a greatly hated concept among the public nowdays specially the young, cause it's only promoted by the ruling class, most of us don't feel like we are attached to our country anymore. This makes sense considering being ruled under a dictatorship regime. Hope this changes in the near future.

[@antiabrahamicreligion]

How it is there?

[@syafsmith5085]

Hope you guys are able flip Sisi upside down like the Egyptian Mussolini that he is

[@TheDarthbinky]

"You wouldn't want a constitution written by a bunch of frat boys to be immortal and unchangeable, would you?" Funny story, Thomas Jefferson (one of the big brains behind the constitution) actually advocated for changing it periodically to update it with the times. He claimed that not doing so was like forcing a grown man to continue wearing the clothing he wore as a child.

[@dyent]

That was the purpose of the whole system of amendments - to amend and update the constitution over time. A perfect example is the second amendment. It was written when there was no standing army in America, having just won independence primarily because Britain couldn't get soldiers to the battle fast enough..The "security of a free state" isn't talking about individual states - its talking about the nation. It was basically saying "We need militias to defend against invasion, so lets ensure everyone is able to form a militia as quickly as possible". It was never about personal self-defense or to fight against your own government.

[@samyloaiza98]

@@dyent it goes beyond that too. The US can't be conquered anymore so the reason doesn't exist in the current era. You have the most nukes and the biggest military. That alone is sufficient to deter anyone from wanting to fight a war on your soil, which is why you haven't seen a war on continental soil since the civil war. Now what you do have is the only country with a mass shooting problem, and cities with homicide rates as high as some zones controlled by narcos in Latin America.

[@TheSandsofFlowingTime]

@dyent pretty sure "the security of a free state" goes against what you said. If the government becomes a dictatorship, it's no longer a free state, to which having guns would be very useful for removing the dictatorship and reinstating a better government. Your country can't become a dictatorship if your reign of power would last maybe a month. The second amendment was written to stop the government from becoming tyrannical, because they had just won a war against their own government for that exact reason and they didn't want to do it again You can say all you want against the second amendment, but it is the reason we still have as many rights as we do. I know without a doubt that the government would remove many of the rights we have if they could. What stops them is 1/3 of the country owning guns and many of those people willing to fight their government in order to keep their freedom. Think of it this way, if I don't go around committing crimes and killing people, then why does it matter if I own guns? Guns are used many more times per year to defend someone, than they are to hurt someone innocent.

[@TheSandsofFlowingTime]

@@samyloaiza98 the mass shooting problem is because the media glorifies it. We have guns in order to keep our freedom and stop our government from deciding that some of our freedoms aren't needed. If you think the shootings happen too often, then why not have security guards at the areas where it happens? Let's have someone there to stop it. Or maybe make it harder to get in to a school with a gun, by idk, having security guards, or a front desk that controls electronic locks in the doors to stop anyone from coming in with a gun. If we guard everything else with guns, why don't we guard schools too?

[@nuclearsimian3281]

Of course. He also advocated for distribution of wealth every few generations too.

[@wilsel1394]

I get the impression that a lot of American 'patriots' haven't visited many other countries, so their patriotism is not based on experience, just what they've been told.

[@antonmoller624]

Agreed. I would go so far as to submit that many of the ‘patriots’ haven’t even crossed state lines and have no idea how much time it takes to cross through a national border post. If they did they would see that borders are not as wide open as their propaganda has led them to believe.

[@Predestinated1]

this

[@assassinunknown6664]

And I get the impression you are guilty of the same crime

[@wilsel1394]

Well I'm afraid you're wrong@@assassinunknown6664

[@shingrandfather]

@@assassinunknown6664even if that was true. america is the dominant culture in media and internet. we are always seeing american politics and american opinions online. and for me personally, i tried to visit america and see what it’s like but i got my tourist visa rejected 4 times all because i happen to have an unfavorable passport.

[@ryankline1164]

"It is lamentable, that to be a good patriot one must become the enemy of the rest of mankind." - Voltaire As an American I was always curious where our patriotism came from. The Founding Fathers, certainly must have had some love (like?) of the British. They were just under the yoke of the Crown, which they didn't hate, just wanted independence from. All you have to look at is how quickly we tried to repair our relationship with them after the war.

[@felicityc]

WW2 and the cold war is really the start of modern patriotism in my historical understanding. We did not really repair our relationship entirely until WW1. We even tried to invade them in the War of 1812 which was our fault (Well, Canada, but that was still British at the time, not Canadian as we know it whatsoever) and it didn't work very well. Burning the first white house is still a symbol of patriotism to this day.

[@phillygrunt2154]

Our relationship didn’t get anywhere until ww1.

[@twilightprince4833]

It wasn't freedom to be equal, it was freedom to hold slaves when the rest of the world was ending it. Then conservatism turned to fanaticism which slowly turned the country into a mindless drone. This same thing was done in Afghanistan, the once liberal people are now fanatically conservative due to US's involvement..

[@kimobrien.]

England had its own earlier revolution lead by merchants who came in conflict with King Charles I. The king was executed after a meeting of 59 commissioner. A war broke out the ended with restoration of the King and Amnesty for all except the 59 commissioners. Those still living were forced to run for their lives to New England, the Dutch republic and Switzerland. The dead were dug up and hung in post mortum execution.

[@isaacvarela667]

I love how “patriotic” people’s answer to distaste and disgust at crumbling American society is to just leave 😭 “I know this country is turning to shit but if you don’t like it then leave 😡”

[@carlfrye1566]

Democrat run cities are most certainly turning to shit, people can't leave them fast enough.

[@miguelchavez8347]

Bro, exactly.

[@Слышьты-ф4ю]

When "winners" of the Cold War are turning into ex-ussr...

[@juehju]

Hear it everytime.

[@isaacvarela667]

@@tomservo75 Pointing out problems we face and telling someone to leave for pointing out problems we face are two different things. Please, reread my comment. If other countries have better systems and perks than us, why shouldn’t we want that? I don’t understand that, considering this is the best country on Earth.

[@HistoryforThinkers]

“The most dangerous man to any government is the man who is able to think things out for himself, without regard to the prevailing superstitions and taboos. Almost inevitably he comes to the conclusion that the government he lives under is dishonest, insane, and intolerable...” -HL Mencken

[@okkine]

Ironically, those who are blindfully patriotic, and willfully ignorant, are the ones who are most likely to scream "Learn To Think For Yourselves!". 🤔🙄

[@chriscortez2036]

Conservatives: “If you don’t like this country, why don’t you just leave?” Also Conservatives: “Immigrants should go back to their own country and fix it instead of stealing our jobs.”

[@JamesDavy2009]

"Uh oh, two independent thought alarms in one day." -Principal Seymour Skinner

[@HegelOnHisHead]

As an American I've always been pretty critical and weirded out by patriotism/nationalism. My introduction to american patriotism when i was a kid was in school where we had a veteran come in and explain to us 'the flag'. It's history, the rules of how you treat it etc. They told us that you should never let it touch the ground and handed us all some mini flags. I as a pretty skeptical and curious child took my flag and dropped it on the ground in front of everyone. This wasn't out of "cool based anti american sentiment" or whatever but based off of me wanting to see people's reaction. Alot of kids got offended and started yelling at me, and I thought it was weird that they would be offended over dropping cloth that they had no other reason to think was immoral other than the fact that they had just been told to believe it. And this pretty much sums up my view of american patriotism for the rest of my life. A bunch of intellectual children being angered by things that don't hurt people for reasons they have never thought about and don't understand.

[@Spengleman2]

I’m not an American so patriotism and nationalism are completely different things for me. Some people get confused and conflate the two, but I don’t think that means we should do the same thing.

[@tylerblue9691]

@@Spengleman2 That's the thing, you aren't American, and that is how it is unfortunately here. The typical "Patriot" here IS a Nationalist. Patriots in your sense of the word, and the correct definition, don't call themselves Patriots, rather "true patriots" or nothing, because they don't want to be compared to the nationalists.

[@yohannessulistyo4025]

Exactly the moment when American individualism is gone and become collectivist drone-minded shills they often think their enemies are. When an American found everyone else odd, I always pointed out how it is very American to do so, while claiming to be "free" and "open minded" or living in a "melting pot" country. It is the same old American exceptionalism all over again: we were taught that everyone else will appear weird, because they are "different" from us. Americans however, tend to judge others from their own lens / perspective. They are more personal. There is a code to respect the flag - and things are kept like that to make any symbol matters / sacred / meaningful in a culture. And if they respect that, I hope they can respect other culture, and not do what Logan and Jake Paul did in Japan.

[@Spengleman2]

@@tylerblue9691 it seems to me that part of the reason the American political landscape is so hostile is because language is so heavily manipulated. Both sides seem to constantly change the meaning of words and phrases as they become associated with cultural phenomena. How are people supposed find mutual understanding if they literally fail to understand each other? I don’t think it’s a good idea to change the practical definition of words unless everyone is very clear about the new meaning.

[@marilynknepper1953]

When my mother passed away a couple of years ago. My two older sisters and I were moving stuff out of the house, throwing things away, donating stuff, etc. My father was very patriotic and had a American flag from before Hawaii became a state. I decided to keep it. One because it's unique and Two it was my father's. My oldest sister saw me with it and said " Don't throw that out ! " I told her I was keeping it and she calmed down. What she don't know is he had a modern one he would hang on the porch I threw out right before that. She also got upset when mom was going to throw out the family bible when dad died because it was falling apart. I don't know what else to say. Just wanted to tell the story I guess. I'm equal parts proud to be American and equal parts ashamed to be American.

[@raindropinparadise8212]

If we in Germany pledged some kind of allegiance to the flag then the rest of the world would be worried but when Americans do it it‘s alright? It‘s not any less weird?

[@husooderudo210]

Well we startet two world wars (yes i know first one by Austria etc just to simplify what Americans are thinking) and America never startet cruel wars without cause…. Oh wait irak, Vietnam, and just so much more (but Americans don’t talk about that)

[@bloopahVIII]

it's pretty much normalized, considering americans have been doing it ever since it was first established doesn't mean that it's not weird

[@cadjebushey6524]

​@@husooderudo210Franz Ferdinands assassination at Sarajevo in 1914. Dont tell me Americans think Germany started the great war.

[@JamieNoah638]

​@@cadjebushey6524sadly many do cuz the education system is shit.

[@juliuscaesar4818]

Um guys german and american patriotism is like exactly the same thing guys. I mean both germany and america have a long history of being freedom loving, human rights preserving, bastions of liberty and peace right guys? I really loved the part when germany during the last few hundred years has spread their peaceful and loving ideas to their neighboring countries even if those dummies didnt want to accept the germans loving and kind embrace!!

[@ComradeHanzo]

A lot of Americans treat their country like a religion or, worse, a cult.

[@LiShuBen]

Thank you for speaking on the African American struggle within American patriotism. Very often, when these kinds of videos are made, this is a subject very lightly touched on, but I appreciate you taking the time to touch on not only the history but call out one of the biggest "shut up and dribble " talking points we have thrown at us.

[@hueypautonoman]

It's unfortunate that sometimes leftists make the same racist claims as conservatives like "race shouldn't matter. Just accept my political theory and everything will work out." It's much more complex, and I'm glad this channel recognizes that. In this society, race and class intersect, and you can't just fix one and expect the other to "work out "

[@Sojo214]

@@hueypautonoman I've been learning more about the lack of change from policing coming from within the community, e.g. the racial makeup of the local police force is similar to that of the population they police, yet issues and brutality remain the same, the needle doesn't even quiver. It really puts into perspective how much work needs to go into all facets of these issues to change... literally anything.. To the point it becomes rapidly overwhelming to try to wrap your head around it all at once, at least as some single rando on the internet.

[@hbsupreme1499]

@@hueypautonoman bing9

[@LiShuBen]

@Sojo even though you're some rando on the internet, you're capable of doing something the majority of Americans have been unable to do for the past few centuries. That's something to be proud of even if you don't have a solution or something to contribute other than affirmation that you see what we have been saying. For me, at least, that's plenty.

[@LibrasLion]

Agreed

[@x1_n_only_jtm_]

Everyone knows that after the national anthem is played, EVERYONE cheers and claps, yet if you ask them if they like how America is in its current state, most will say no. "Not my president. I hate this, I hate that." Americans like the "idea" of America, but with no one wanting to work together, it can never be that "idea" that they want it to be.

[@nobody8328]

Dismissing concerns because 'someone else has it worse' is emotional abuse. Seriously, ask a therapist.

[@jasongaylor2232]

It's yet another excuse they always make. They'll say..."well, just think if you were in a third world nation" how bad it would be". So that means we have to accept the United States being an oligarchy and never strive for anything better? So we have to accept the majority of people living in poverty and our environment being destroyed because our Government is thoroughly corrupted by corporate cash? It's like these people don't have a braincell in their skulls. I usually say to them..."You don't want us to be #1? You want the Scandinavian Countries to keep kicking our ass?"(by the way, these are usually the people who supported Trump with that slogan of "make America great again", quite ironic) That really annoys them. Especially when I get out my cellphone and show them the graphs and data! 😆

[@johnl6176]

It's also a logical fallacy known as "whataboutism" which is a form of Appeal to Hypocrisy.

[@avataranonymous]

In psychology, this is called minimization.

[@medicusofthedamned]

Gaslighting

[@PhedelCastro]

So do you support the folks who claim anti white racism? They have concerns but many say that other racial groups have it worse?

[@valleyofthedolls666]

will never forget a teacher yelling at me for not standing for the pledge, saying it was ungrateful to her military husband…. some of us have our sense of selves way too woven into this country

[@goinggoneification]

I was visiting Mount Rushmore and didn't sing the national anthem before they raised the flag or whatever. I stood up and kept my arms by my side. Some woman after told me that it was incredibly unpatriotic of me to not join in. I laughed and said "Oh no sorry but I'm Irish." She told me that that shouldn't matter.

[@eureka5635]

I stood, but I never put my hand to my heart or say the pledge. The pledge just feels cultist to me. I like the US to an extent, I like most of the people and the land, but the government has shown time and time again that it serves its self and those who run it and not it's people.

[@AB-ou8ve]

She was probably cheating on him, so to hell with her.

[@BlastedRodent]

The way Americans revere their constitution reminds me a lot of how many religious people approach their holy books. It was handed down from these semi-legendary figures, it can never be changed, and interpreting it to find out what someone hundreds of years wanted the country to be is more important than figuring out how we want the country to be today. In most other countries, constitutions can be rewritten or replaced if they are no longer fit for purpose.

[@89five3five]

Well the US constitution can be rewritten. It’s called an amendment

[@phillygrunt2154]

@@iPlayOnSpica “shall not be infringed” The 2nd amendment protects the 1st, to think the government cares about you is 100% a disillusion.

[@krillin876]

The reason is because despite our country only being about 200 years old it's still the oldest constitution on Earth and that's something to value

[@KuK137]

@@phillygrunt2154 What part of WELL ORGANIZED MILITIA does not get through your skull? They meant guns for what is today national guard, not every wannabe mass shooter...

[@phillygrunt2154]

@@krillin876 no it’s not, not in anyway to democrats.

[@jonathanellis6097]

I'm in the UK and honestly American patriotism and watching some of them in church scares me. They seem nuts, to someone from the outside it looks like blind devotion and extremism.

[@jifij89]

yeah it’s weird. our ‘patriots’ are weird too but no where near like this.

[@Rackyack]

@@toolbaggers why are you spamming this lol

[@2nd100k]

theyre brainwashed

[@2nd100k]

@@jifij89 our UK patriots look like nothing compared

[@lonestarr1490]

@@AK-jm1sc I mean, it probably requires something close to an entire dissertation to really make this point, but I'd argue that's exactly what America is: a giant cult.

[@baskoller5506]

I am Dutch and had the misfortune to live in TX during the Reagan years. When I had a presentation I dared to question American freedoms. Mainly freedom of Speech. I made (or tried, I was just 14) the case that I found Amercian patrotism totalitarian as it did not allow for critism. Long story short. I got my ass kicked on the track field, ending my American experiment as my parents found it safer if I went back to my own country. Where patrotism is reserved for soccer games.

[@TheBeatlesShow]

I want to apologize for what my fellow Americans did. I'm embarrassed to live in a nation where so many people will literally attack other people for questioning their system.

[@baskoller5506]

@@TheBeatlesShow No need to apologize. Not trying to blame anyone. Just wanted to give an outsiders view on what so many Americans take on face value. Their precious freedoms. Besides, I learned (Texas) English as a kid. How cool is that.

[@HylianFox3]

I like how they basically proved your point.

[@DarthFhenix55]

@@TheBeatlesShow Honestly his problem was more about having bad luck of living with hyper conservative people than those conservatives being Americans. Every country has irracional people like that.

[@baskoller5506]

@@DarthFhenix55 I lived in many countries. It is no5t about X conservative people or X irracional people. American exceptionalism is a thing. Bred in schools, nr 1, USA,USA!. Pledge of alligiance. I am not blaming people, I was critiquing a social system.

[@Lobo-ih3bh]

America’s nationalism, religiosity, unbridled capitalism and violent nature is deeply scary to those elsewhere in the world.

[@Dontstopbelievingman]

I'm forever grateful we don't have much oil here.

[@VoidDragon82]

Thankfully we don’t have much oil on UK soil, otherwise I’m sure we would’ve received some “freedom and democracy” bombs.

[@jackvue722]

I took two of my friends from China to an NBA game, and in the beginning there was the usual national anthem ceremony. My friend then turned to me and asked, "is this a religious thing"? Makes you realize just how weird US patriotism is.

[@aprilk141]

I would have said, no, it's a cult thing.

[@tperk]

I attended a game in the Chinese pro basketball league and the crowd stood and sang their national anthem louder than I'd ever heard the USA anthem sung anywhere. Nationalism is much stronger in China.

[@RictusHolloweye]

@@tperk - Was that a domestic event or were they competing with a team from another country?

[@tperk]

@@RictusHolloweye Chinese Basketball Association finals between domestic teams.

[@JamesTDG]

I actually refuse to stand up for those things. Seriously, it is a violation of people's rights to force em to stand for the anthem, and I do not care about the dirty looks I get.

[@lizk96]

One time I was working at a sports game and I was told to go run off and handle something just before the national anthem started. Which I did because you know... Its my job. Some guy in the stands threw a full bottle of beer at me (which I dodged 😎) and had to be removed from the stadium, where he was yelling to security that nobody respects the flag anymore. It's kind of comedic but also kind of scary how violent and delusional these people are.

[@gallowglass2630]

Liz Thats something thats different to my country. The national football/soccer and rugby coach appointment is looked upon with the same interest as the appointment or more than the appointment of the prime minister and thats the same for most countries other than american team.Yes you have the dream team ,but generally patriotism is not focussed on national sports team . Which is a pity because national sports teams provide a more positive outlet for patriotic fervour

[@michaeld4861]

@@gallowglass2630 Yeah, there's an interesting book outlining how Nelson Mandela utilized South Africa's rugby team to help overcome (the white people's) fear of ending apartheid. Helped some of the more ambivalent white folks realize that black folks loved the same sport and humanized them enough to change some minds.

[@landonbarretto4933]

Most assuredly he was a redneck with perhaps a high school education. Low income earner.

[@destituteanddecadent9106]

They call it patriotism, but really it's nationalism.

[@RoanShip]

I have no idea

[@colinbrown7305]

It's fascism.

[@frazyfrog]

Fascism my boy, one day americans will wake up

[@Wandering_Trainer]

​@@colinbrown7305 what are the laws or the customs that make them fascist?

[@nelson_rebel3907]

We literally had people hit the capitol being upset with the government. Trust me, we have zero love for the government. Its only a neccessary evil. The patriotism we have isnt because we think we're better. We just love where we live and love the lifestyle we're allowed to live

[@trixie2558]

I've said this a thousand times: this is not patriotism, it's nationalism.

[@cowfat8547]

and both are fine

[@alibarznji2000]

​@@cowfat8547nationalism will lead to fascism, while Patriotism is a whole different thing bru

[@cowfat8547]

@@alibarznji2000 depends on how far nationalism goes. nationalism at its basic level is simply putting the priorities of your own country over other countries. if it’s something like civic eco-nationalism (putting the protection of one’s country’s environment over everything else), it could be beneficial

[@leyrua]

Yeah sure, because climate change will _respect_ your nation's borders. The video points out how borders are just arbitrary lines drawn on a map. What affects your neighbor can also affect you indirectly. All too often, nationalists have a tendency to say "not our problem" when another country is suffering, and then complain about the price of certain products going up, never realizing that they went up because the SUPPLIER of those goods is the country that we ignored while it was burning.

[@cowfat8547]

@@leyrua Yeah and it’s a terrible video. Also I completely understand that what affects other countries affects us too. Globalism has made the world’s economy much more integrated which is a great thing. There’s also just simply helping out countries because it’s the right thing to do like with Ukraine. Plus when it comes to civic eco-nationalism, since the world ecosystem is interconnected and climate change is global, focusing on protecting one’s country’s environment means pushing for global policy change for the environment.

[@markeppley1287]

There's nothing I love more than the "if you don't like it you can leave" argument. It's usually said by people who cry the loudest about their 1st amendment rights being taken away. Nothing says freedom quite like the choice between blind nationalism or exile!

[@markeppley1287]

I also love the irony that the people who claim to love the US the most and are the most vocal about it also despise over half the population and want to take their rights away

[@TempleGuitars]

The empty can rattles the most.

[@ChuddleBuggy]

It actually speaks well of that country that tells you to leave it if you don't like it. Afterall, it's the oppressive states that keep you from leaving it if you don't like it.

[@Classwarvet]

@ChuddleBuggy It's kind of insidious though because while you are "able" to leave physically, financially most can not. Also doesn't help that our leaders made us very unpopular worldwide.

[@kimobrien.]

@@Classwarvet Oppressive states keep you from leaving. East Germany collapsed a long time ago now you don't want immigrants coming into the Imperialist nations. You talk of needing to build a wall because capitalism doesn't work for the masses of people as if you could survive without foreign trade. The bosses only hire if they can make a profit and because those who work can not buy back all that can be produced capitalism becomes the first system to fail due to overproduction of commodities . Capitalism can not use all the productive capacity and the stats kept by the Federal Reserve bank bear that out. The use of productive capacity has been in decline since stats began being kept in 1968.

[@devinfaux6987]

The obnoxious part is that those who most need to hear this message have been trained all their lives not to listen to it.

[@codacreator6162]

Worse, to reject it out of hand as subversive and criminal. We blacklisted writers in Hollywood, for crying out loud, because they were or were suspected to be members of the Communist Party. As a kid of the Cold War and the son of military vets, I was confused and terrified that such a thing could happen in America. But I credit my early history classes with providing me enough of the truth that I could go on and learn to think critically about the country in which I was born.

[@Praisethesunson]

I can't hear you over all my freedumbs™!!! Brought to you by Walmart©

[@RTMonitor]

@@Praisethesunson i love my country!!!™ Brought to you by Carl's Jr.

[@DeathBYDesign666]

There's no need to be nice about it by saying "trained" they are fully indoctrinated to the core to ignore any facts and evidence that doesn't jive with their views of reality. It's not a coincidence that most of these types of people fall into the fundamentalist Christian nationalist category. These people have stepped up their game in recent years because they know they are a dying breed.

[@JamesDavy2009]

@@Praisethesunson "Welcome to Walmart. Get your shit and get out!" -Walter

[@jakobbauz]

As a German I can only say: It's probably a good idea to be a little careful with that "patriotism" thing. ;) Cheers guys

[@sweetpeach3649]

Concern yourself with your own country please. Thank you

[@jakobbauz]

@@sweetpeach3649 I am concerning myself with Germany, actually(?). Are you saying that I shouldn't be informed about or shouldn't be in contact with people from other countries? If so: Why the hell would I limit my intellectual scope like that?

[@SovermanandVioboy]

@@sweetpeach3649 Oh what an Archetype of an American. Sad little creature xD...

[@liz_violet]

@@sweetpeach3649 yea, but like we do the same 🙄

[@Mao_Dedong]

@@sweetpeach3649 When you are from the US, this would be pretty hypocritical

[@troyygsi8771]

I remember reading something a long time ago that said the reason American patriotism is still so alive and well as opposed to Europe was because it hasn't blown up directly in our face yet. In Europe, patriotism or nationalism directly resulted in two world wars and massive destruction on a level that no one had seen up until that point. This caused Europeans to tone down nationalist rhetoric, if not turn away from it entirely, for fear of experiencing another devastating war. Meanwhile, for the US, far enough away from the frontlines to avoid any direct consequences of the wars, patriotism is seen as something that actually helped us win those wars. And even though blind patriotism hasn't really helped in any American war since then, since the US is so far away from their opponents, the average American has never actually faced the consequences of it.

[@yorkerold]

I don't know, there were many fascist/nationalist regimes in Europe even after ww2, like in Spain, Portugal, and Greece, and there are many powerful nationalist parties in many countries. Some of them directly tied to Nazis and fascists. They're even in power in Italy.

[@lilybertine5673]

While this is true, one should ask why America engaged in those wars to begin with. I doubt it was for the freedom of their people.

[@Celatra]

the us has won no wars, ever

[@bladerunner3314]

That's why I say the US is so hot for any war - after the civil war they haven't had one in their own country.

[@lilybertine5673]

@@Celatra They did... albeit not militarily...

[@Diptera_Larvae]

14:56 I’m always amazed that people can reconcile that poor needs to “pull themselves up by their boot straps” instead of asking for a handout, yet it’s okay for big corporations to get bailouts and tax cuts 😅

[@scarman1675]

My personal theory from observation is that you talked to any of the voters who say bootstraps stuff, they are going to not like bailouts either (unless it's a company they work at). It's the lobbyist-led politicians who we all elect to do the bailouts, whether its cronyism or fear of economic collateral damage

[@MetalHeart8787]

OH and are the Rich people of Russia, England, France helping their poor people? you people really NEED to do some more World Studying

[@myrnarabie]

@@MetalHeart8787 I barely see a country actually helping their people, but only a pretty handful, one I know is Japan, the others idk but I'm sure there are, rest like US, China, Russia, UK, France and more? Hahaha no, also Russia is ruled by Soviet oligarchs so pretty much this explains it

[@Tzensa]

@@MetalHeart8787 Of course they’re not. First of all this video wasn’t about those countries so what you just did is classic example of tu qouque. Secondly it shouldn’t be surprising in the slightest that the poor in those countries face similar oppression as all of the nations you mentioned are capitalist countries, which means their ruling class have very similar motivations to the ruling class in the US.

[@marocat4749]

Have same people tried to pull themselves up their bootstraps, "Getting out of that is as easy as pulling up by your bootstraps" was coined by unions, because, well its night impossible. So have you tried to pull up yourself up your bootstraps, try it, might be a good answer.

[@flobwad]

My dad told me this story: He used to work with an elderly man who was an immigrant from Nazi Germany, and made a miraculous escape from the country during the Holocaust. When I was in elementary school living in a conservative part of New York, his friend/coworker couldn’t drive to work one day, so my dad decided to carpool and pick him up at his apartment complex while driving me to school. When we pulled up to my school so I could be dropped off, the front entrance’s walkway had a line of poles with American flags on each side (it looked ridiculous, but “Patriotism”, I guess). My dad said his friend/coworker (who, to remind you, was a refugee from Nazi Germany) got quite a disgruntled look on his face. He pointed to the display of flags and said: “This. This doesn’t look good.” Won’t forget that story.

[@yougetwhatyoufuckingdeseRVE77]

So being a conservative or Just a patriot means being a nazi oh Jesus could yall just use another argument yall are doing every time it has to do with any non woke left thing yall be like if u voted for trump u a nazi if u conservative u a nazi if u oppose abortion u a fascist if u dont follow every single word we say and be exactly the sheep we want you to be u a nazi it's pretty good tactic of pushing your values under the im the good guy who fights nazism role

[@yougetwhatyoufuckingdeseRVE77]

@@superkingoftacos2920 so patriotism = nazism? Oh guess the next thing would be a Christian = nazi

[@brianshaker1885]

It's interesting to me how Germany may be one of the most progressive countries in the world. They took being Nazi's and causing WWII and the holocaust to heart. And they STILL get called Nazi's to this day. Just because we won 80 years ago doesn't mean we now have the moral high ground. We literally took all the Nazi's, made them work for us, and we are closer to creating a fascist regime than any other country.

[@dsamuel2116]

True,, it’s like the statement that goes: “if you don’t think your country has propaganda, it’s working too well. “

[@Saffy1]

Germany wasn't the one who was attacked and getting gassed in camps my friend

[@jonathanrees8288]

Just recently came across your channel. As an Englishman, I must say just how fantastic your insight is. It's very interesting to get a better understanding of the American narrative from an insiders' point of view, especially one aware enough to be able to critique so well. Bravo. I will say I've met a lot of Americans out and about in London and other European cities, and astonishingly, those who travel (outside of the US) seem to be a lot more collected and critical than the portrayal of a lot of US citizens from your news media. Anyway, thank you.

[@assassinunknown6664]

So your telling me your statement isn’t just a regurgitated stereotype

[@jaska3900]

When my sister was an exchange student in America, every day she would get in trouble for refusing to recite the Pledge of Allegiance at her school. She told her teachers that "this is some North Korea shit". Seems very bizarre to force kids to stand up and pledge allegiance every morning at school. Tho I heard that not all states require this.

[@borissinaga]

LOL. Some north korean shit. The irony.

[@hittingyouoverthehead]

Pledge of allegiance is not problematic on its own. We have it in schools in India too but then again, India didn't attack a nation two continents away for oil after lying about it having WMDs. I guess WHO you pledge allegiance to is what matters.

[@melissabrock4114]

I sat down during the pledge of allegiance once in high school and a male classmate kicked me and told me to "stand up."

[@suzannahdarcy6903]

yes, as someone who has never lived in the US, it comes off as super creepy and North Korea-like. Also, non-US citizens going to school in the US shouldn't say the pledge . . . they have their own citizenship and country. Why would they expect a child to have an allegiance to a place where they are just doing an exchange?

[@melissabrock4114]

@@suzannahdarcy6903 non-Americans actually haven't been been expected to say the pledge, and it's also becoming an antiquated practice

[@RedMeansRecording]

Rad to hear my library music in a video on a subject I am interested in and done so well. Thanks for your hard work.

[@SecondThought]

Thank you for yours!

[@jammystraub488]

How fun, the intersection between two of my favorite KZbin channels. Serendipitous!

[@DevinMacGregor]

Completely agree with you. I am an Army Veteran. I wanted to go into the military since I was 10. I love my country but I see its flaws and many are ugly AF. I enlisted when I was 17 before my senior year and went active duty after HS graduation and turning 18 that July. I saw myself as a Lincoln/Teddy Republican. I had bought a computer game on the 88 POTUS election. You could run actual politicians or you could run as yourself after you took this political test which was the most thorough test I have seen to date. I came up on the Left though and this befuddled me. Then came the examination of the GOP overall and they were no longer the party of Lincoln/Teddy. 8value says I am a Libertarian Socialist. I am not a purist though. There is a lot of flag waving and sabre rattling in the military but I was never any of that. I saw the repression inherent in the system. I wanted to correct that and make things better. I wanted to do 20+ years in and get my retirement but after 4 years I was done. At least for the Army. What gets me are those on the outside who say, thank you for your service. I mean wtf? We have a huge Vet suicide and homeless issue and that saying is like saying to someone, we send our hopes and prayers. You are doing absolute zero to effect change. See I worry every time my brothers and sisters get deployed in another war that has nothing to do with preserving our freedoms but just making rich people richer. I want to know, do we have an exist strategy? Are we actually helping the people there? See I am addressing our policies but to do so you get called unpatriotic. I get the blindness by service members, it is those civilians I am addressing who have never been in the military before. They gaslight on the poor foreign policy by making it about the troops themselves. They completely take the lessons of Vietnam wrong. You support the troops by questioning why they are there etc. You support them by when they get home with their mental health issues, physical issues, etc. Supporting the troops does not mean accepting poor foreign policies. Outside of that the GOP likes using children all the time in the same compacity. The US Constitution is a living document, meaning it is supposed to change with the times. This soldier though loves history. Not only would I read in fox holes, I was an atheist in them, still am. The history of the US though has been the history of various groups fighting for inclusion to be considered English White. I think we can do far better than we have and have a long way to go. I swore to defend that Constitution. The 1A is not saying you can go around saying racial slurs etc but is saying you can openly air your grievances about your govt at all levels. In large part due to our innate Tribalism we tend to treat politics like sport teams. We cheer for our team while we leer at the other team. Our team can do no wrong as we boo the ref for calling a penalty on our team, "what, are you blind!" We know damn well our team committed a violation but for the other team, we cheer when a penalty call is made but will never come clean that we damn well know it was a bad call. BUT, we do this also for things like a movie. Someone does not like a movie and another gets offended because we make all of this personal. Oh yeah, you do not like that movie means something is wrong with me. You do not like it? So you are saying something is wrong about me? So instead of critical thinking of examining the validity of said criticisms, we personalize it as an attack on us personally.

[@jchung1506]

Very well said. Thank you for posting this.

[@scientificallyaccuratespino]

Well said!

[@scientificallyaccuratespino]

@Okami Amaterasu My man didn’t read the whole comment

[@DevinMacGregor]

@@okamiamaterasu5416 I have relatives I cannot even talk to any more. As kids, politics I do not recall ever being discussed but now they make everything about politics with little digs here and there. I have a cousin who is a lot younger than me and I have only seen him maybe 4 times in my life but he has an ass whooping coming to him. I had to unfriend and block him. He wanted me to block him and just kept making comments to every post I had ever made till I did block him. He then went to his friends about how me, a libtard, could not handle the truth. Another of my friends watched him post that shit to his friends. All of this because I made two posts. One was of President elect Trump over white supremacy groups to which I said he needs to distance himself from those types of groups and if not hate crimes will go up because they will think he approves of them and they can now come out into the light. So my cousin was calling me a jackboot over that as well as a Nazi. I found a clip of the 1980 GOP primaries where Reagan and Bush ran against each other. The question was on illegal immigrants to which both said, they just come here for jobs and should not be criminalized, the guilty party are those who hire them. I said, wow how much as the GOP changed on this stance. It was an objective statement of fact. CA Senator Pete Wilson (R) said the same thing when he became CA governor in the 1990s and wanted to go after businesses. That was short lived and I am sure he was taken aside and talked to. Instead no fines to businesses and just the capture and deportation of those immigrants. So here again, he was posting I was a jackboot and a Nazi because I was not bashing the Democrats as well. So I found a clip of Clinton in his first term and Obama in his first term talking about immigration and they were consistent. Both were deporting people and some even called Obama, Deporter in Chief due to this.

[@augustuslunasol10thapostle]

@@DevinMacGregor republican’s seems to scream nazi at anyone while reading mein kampf and agreeing with it

[@evanlaney5806]

“If you REALLY love America, you better love it so much that you ignore its historical and present flaws!” American patriotism/nationalism in a nutshell

[@libtearsreeee]

Every country has historical flaws einstein..

[@evanlaney5806]

@@libtearsreeee attaboy let the whataboutism surge inside you

[@philipangelo595]

How true.

[@theguythatasked6400]

@@libtearsreeeeyes, but do all of those countries ignore those flaws?

[@libtearsreeee]

Most do COMRADE~...You have a low IQ@@theguythatasked6400

[@prashanthb6521]

This video is GOLD ! I am from India and this video is apt for us too. The language of struggle you spoke is universal. Irrespective of the borders we all are in the same boat indeed as you said. Regarding the issue of Hyper Patriotism & Nationalism we are facing the same problems from extremists. Times are bad right now. I wish your channel grows even more. All the best.

[@mastershooter64]

Lmfao bro ikr!! just one sentence about india in some video and then half the comments will be like "India best country in the worldd!!!" "India India India!!", "Indians are the besttt!!!" like bro wtf? chill out. damn those people are annoying and make us look bad

[@aprilk141]

Love and solidarity to you from Minnesota!

[@nishantbodkhe7443]

Bro i was like when he was ' no other country...' , idk about that, we're just as bad😂

[@PharaohDom]

I grew up in a Black, military family and it took me many years to properly break and the programming of the propaganda I was fed. It's taken me even longer to verbalize many of the points brought up here. This video is a great resource. I've been having this argument with my retired military family members forever and a day. Maybe this will get through to them.

[@joshuahudgins]

It wont patriotism is a choice. No one forces you to be patriotic.

[@Jujube285]

Good luck man. My people are the same way. Feels like a fruitless fight sometimes.Only thing you can really do is not pass the torch of misinformation to the next generation.

[@murk4552]

​@Joshua Hudgins no it isn't, America coerced and forces people to believe all the bullshit the US shoves down our throats for centuries "just because".

[@marcusonesimus3400]

Terrific comment. Mind you, I've not experienced anything remotely like what you describe. For all 'patriots' and people in professions which look 'glorious' to the public eye, this is sobering: (Psalm 49:20) 'Man in his pomp, yet without understanding, is like the beasts that perish.'

[@ohmygoditisspider7953]

I really hope it has gone well thus far.

[@allenmontrasio8962]

Anyone who's travelled even a modicum won't be able to help noticing that the US is the *only* country where people fly the national flag outside private homes en masse.

[@Lichenroc]

I know right. I plan to move to NZ in another year and it's completely uncommon there.

[@mirkoferrini6909]

It also happens in Norway, though not in an overly nationalistic way. Some just genuinely appreciate the values of the country.

[@balajay8921]

Except for 1 month in a year to celebrate National Day, it’s not even allowed in my country..

[@desireepetitdemurat8660]

That has always amazed me, I don’t get the point.

[@jeremiahbaxter6887]

Countries with cool flags get a pass. Canada, Angola, China, etc. US flag is mid af@@mirkoferrini6909

[@aldaurum1678]

I was having this conversation with a friend talking about how it would be absolutely insane for people to just start chanting their countries name out of nowhere, like imagine people in a car just yelling "SPAIN! SPAIN! SPAIN!", also talked about how it's more similar to how the rest of the world treats sports club

[@ellenewaskowitz5448]

The people who do that graduated high school and took the Pep Rally mentality with them throughout their adult hoods. They feel a part of something, like they are sitting in the lunch room at a table with the popular kids. It's just never blipped their screen that life is not a pep rally.

[@richardbuckharris189]

"What a strange development of patriotism that turns a thinking being into a loyal machine!" ~ Emma Goldman

[@seanosull2884]

I find certain phrases Americans use, to be so odd. 'That's unamerican behavior' or 'he's an all-American boy.' As though being American is associated with morality. No other country does this. I'm Irish, I've never heard of 'un-Irish behavior.' Nor does any other country do this.

[@shadowfurydono]

India does it too. Sadly.

[@creamysmooth79]

Australia does it as well.

[@fishergreer36]

Canada does it :(

[@seanosull2884]

I'm not surprised by Russia, but I didn't know Australia, India and Canada said it. To say something is 'unirish' behaviour would only only ever mean that someone is supporting the interests of the UK and perhaps was used in during the war of independence. The idea of one's nation being directly related to morality, is so strange to me.

[@catkelly78]

England does it.

[@Citizen_Bane]

As an American, I find our sense of patriotism and national identity to be very superficial and hollow. It's all about flags and songs. It's style over substance, form over function. American patriotism is not about doing what's best for America, but assuming that we already are the best so we make excuses for not actually putting forth the effort to make America as best as we can be. Also, the fact that we make children say the pledge of allegiance every single day is incredibly disturbing. Imagine forcing people to say a pledge to remind them of how free they are. If that's not Orwellian doublespeak, I don't know what is. State mandated patriotism is the kind of thing that dictatorships are made of.

[@greasechoreography5501]

THIS! Is the best comment. I am American and completely agree. I was a teacher feeling so out of place when it was time for pledges.

[@ThirsttyRecon]

America is free only for the people who agree with the ones in charge

[@tootnfart]

and i was shamed during freshman year when i stopped standing for the pledge. i soon began standing but not saying anything. i gave into peer pressure. they said i didn’t respect vets and soldiers. but i do. the pledge is not about respecting american soldiers. it’s about the government. if it was about the veterans, it would mention them.

[@shindisingh1165]

Its due to a very dirty truth Americans have been conditioned to overlook, whilst the results of which are obvious to many around the world ... America took in many of the top Nazi officials after the wars and they've basically amalgamated their propaganda methods - because their belief systems are basically the same. Turn the volume down and its all the same thing... only difference is the Nazis probably didn't wear their flag on their underpants like the Americans do 😅

[@zaxbitterzen2178]

@@tootnfart Holy s%^t me too! I legit got pulled aside by the teacher and they attempted to guilt-trip me with military related nonsense of all things. Like lady first the vast majority of "soldier's" in the U.S. military have never seen violent action. Second I told her it shouldn't be required and they got visibly upset.

[@isixqueenxofxmadness]

As a foreigner to the usa all you said is pretty evident from the outside. I feel like I already knew everything you said! Regarding patriotism, I consider myself patriotic even when my country is very capitalist and I'm an anarchist. This is because I love my language, many parts of my culture, our history, our sense of humor and so on. Many have told me to leave if I hate our system so much, but I believe leaving is selfish. I must stay and do all in my power to make the changes my people need.

[@nocantry]

Hopefully we can unite on day, so that all of our efforts can be directed towards the greatest good.

[@hansiza9701]

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!! ANARCHISM!!! HAAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!!!

[@hansiza9701]

@@nocantry the day the world unites is the day pigs can fly. (and also the day i kill myself)

[@LinguisticLifeform]

@@hansiza9701 so...why are you laughing in a way that coveys to us that we should know the reasons for your laughter? Are you finding it hard to mount an argument or is it just Tourettes?

[@tonyhakston536]

@@hansiza9701 you okay dude?

[@Mirro18]

As somebody coming from Austria and of course are generally coming from a German speaking country... US patriotism is something so foreign unlike anything else they are doing. The kind of pride everybody seems to take in the worst aspects of their country just blows our mind in some parts. We have patriots too of course... but if they act the way the average American is acting about their country you get already weird looks and a... mental note to check for anything weird should you ever enter their house.

[@Commanderziff]

There's a common saying I've heard throughout my life: "Fascism could never take hold here, because we know what REAL freedom is." The older I get, the more it worries me when I hear someone say it. Because people who say stuff like that are often the most aggressively patriotic and nationalistic. Exactly the kind of people who would blindly follow a fascist leader, because that leader would promise to 'Preserve America". They would gleefully burn democracy to the ground, as long as the thing that took it's place was white, christian, and brutally capitalistic.

[@cantthinkofaname5046]

I think it’s because America is in the grand scheme of things really young. A lot of younger nations have tons of patriotism, like in a lot of the counties in South America

[@maka6134]

@@cantthinkofaname5046 I think it also has to do with war. Patriotism or nationalism whatever you want to call it isnt prevelant in Europe because its associated with the death and destruction it caused. We dont have flags everywhere because that was something the nazis did when they occupied our lands.

[@cantthinkofaname5046]

@@maka6134 that also makes a lot of sense

[@maka6134]

@@cantthinkofaname5046 And seeing as the US has mainly fought wars abroad there hasnt been any death and destruction inside the US associated with flags and patriotism. Nobody came in and beat the nationalism out of them like what happened in most other countries. The only other places that have so much nationalism and flags everywhere are dictatorships. Even the same military glorfying tradition as the US

[@thekwjiboo]

My favorite symptom of the American patriotism disease is this amazing double standard. If you don't like your country? LEAVE Meanwhile, people don't like Mexico and try to leave. Those same "if you don't like it, leave" folks - Don't run away, FIX YOUR OWN COUNTRY!

[@ashlirabid9614]

Exactly

[@b99b12]

It’s also really eerie to see it spreading over to Canada. Protesters holding up American flags and spouting “freedom” nonstop.

[@RictusHolloweye]

Australian politicians have been trying to import US style ideology, including exceptionalism. It's had varying degrees of success (with right wing, conservative people) but I am hopeful the majority will detect and reject it.

[@ColdBaltBlue]

Whenever I see a car drive by with Canada flags, I don’t know if they just like Canada or are a nationalist freak.

[@adamrosendahl8090]

There is growing fascism in Canada.

[@adamrosendahl8090]

@Zaydan Alfariz freedom of speech is dangerous. The "convoy" protests are a prime example of this. I'm in favor of this kind of interjection made by the state. Also a socialist.

[@DylanRoberts7]

@Zaydan Alfariz I was personally in favor of the use of the emergencies act. The trucks should have been towed day 1. Nobody has the right to block our roads and the people behind all of the noise complaints should have been fined. The casual protester who wasn't disturbing the peace at night is perfectly fine. The emergencies act was required because the cities police force was incapable of maintaining the rule of law and so was the province of Ontario. This never should have gotten out of hand to the point where the federal government had to intervene, but municipal and provincial government was unable to enforce the law.

[@erichansen2860]

The weirdest experience I've had with this kind of patriotism was at my daughter's Girls' State graduation. The American Legion people running the program did a slide show of the weeklong event set to the awful Lee Greenwood song "Proud to be an American". 90% of the parents in the audience stood up and put their hand over their heart like it was the national anthem. With the American legion people being so serious like they are, the terrible song, the parents in the audience standing for a jingoistic pop song performed by a guy who never joined the military himself, wow. The whole spectacle was so strange.

[@Hardmanferdead]

The only time I’ve found that Greenwood song enjoyable was when it was remixed for Chicago footwork by DJ yung tellem.

[@jamiehenry3135]

Lee Greenwood had a theater 10 mins from my elementary school. We had to go on field trips to hear him perform. I thinks that was the start of my radicalization.

[@piccalillipit9211]

As a European this was my comment: *OH MY GOD* are Americans "proud" they have a lot of billionaires....??? I never knew that, I thought that would be something you would know but keep quiet about and not mention ---§--- It had never occurred to me in my life that this could be perceived as a thing to be proud of "LOOK - WE HAVE MASSIVE WEALTH INEQUALITY"

[@YFNA1978]

They used to play that song at the completion of every underway replenishment on my first ship in the Navy... Nausea inducing.

[@felicityc]

@@piccalillipit9211 Many Americans are convinced that it is an obtainable dream and that they worked hard to get there, and didn't just get lucky or nepotism'd in to it. They think effort correlates with success which is of course absolutely hecking ridiculous. re: the song. They played that for us after our field training in BMT. I thought it was a bit weird at the time but it wasn't until later I realized how hecking weird it was. I very much appreciate people having outside opinions, because when you are inside the system, sometimes it is hard to realize problems.

[@roveplanteater6738]

Many of my teachers back in high-school were completely outraged that I would never say the pledge. It was weird.

[@ultraclunt9667]

Similar thing happened to my classmate in middle school. Our instructor lost his mind, threw a desk and chair across the room, and sent my classmate to the dean and principal while screaming "Don't you come in my room and breathe my air!!".

[@interstate80.]

@@ultraclunt9667 wild

[@kidoncrack4164]

Good

[@jayvhoncalma3458]

@@ultraclunt9667 I hope that teacher lost their ability to teach

[@Ninja-gt3zi]

What is the pledge? Do Americans school kids have to say it every day or weekly?

[@pietjepuk8653]

The daily Pledge of Allegiance at schools is really sick.

[@jchirox144]

As a german this video is very interesting. The last time we tried Patriotism it didn’t work out quite well, so there is not this kind of patriotic national pride like in the us. I personally think that this is a great advantage for example in history class where we learn (from what i can tell) out of an very objective standpoint. Don’t mind me please if there are any grammar mistakes

[@WileyCylas]

No your grammar was great! Thanks for commenting!

[@andrewjacks2716]

As an American, I'm always told that "patriotism" =/= nationalism. Yet, since before I was born the two have been conflated heavily and whatever distinction there ever was has neither been clearly articulated to me nor seems to accurately describe how the terms are used.

[@magesalmanac6424]

Ah but Germany has excelled so much as a country in the past decades. You have overcome a lot and are now one of the leading nations in the world. You don’t try to cover up past mistakes. And that is something to be proud of as a German!

[@kkpenney444]

@@magesalmanac6424 They never would have developed that way if they hadn't been completely defeated so the Allies could direct their rebuilding and reshaping.

[@jolp9799]

@@magesalmanac6424 one thing about the germans is they do not try to cover up their past, they actually learn from it. From teaching history to kids in school and banning the nazi salute in public, is them owning up and learning from their mistakes. ...the japanese on the other hand...LOL

[@RTR_87]

At the beginning of the video you said “if you love your country, you should be the first to point out its problems” and that’s the thing right there, they don’t see racism, sexism, etc as problems. It’s there deeply held belief that that is just how it should be, which is why they feel personally attacked when you advocate for those things to cease.

[@GlassThirdEye]

It blows my mind that this isn't the most obvious thing in the world to everyone. It's really hard not to see.

[@icarusxedits]

As someone who grow up in Germany and is currently a teenager, all that patriotism and nationalism feels incredibly strange.

[@qqqqqqqqqqqqqq7665]

Yeah as a German I agree

[@realdragon]

Same in Poland

[@scrambler69-xk3kv]

I can see why you would not be proud of your own country.

[@jaydee5312]

​@@scrambler69-xk3kvbeing proud of any country is weird...what are you proud of? The leaders? The people? The land mass? You have had little contact with and little influence over most of those

[@DiabolicalAngel]

American here and I agree, that's why I don't partake.

[@strb3305]

I was always confused why Americans think red white and blue are there colours, like dozens of countries have that on their flags

[@JamesDavy2009]

Try the majority of 196 countries.

[@B-A-L]

Lmao I once saw an American who has his own KZbin page watch a video about the Netherlands and when he saw the flag he said, quite seriously, 'Copycats!' just because of the red, white and blue and yes he did cop a load of flak over it and plenty of New Amsterdam references!

[@jasoncallow860]

Shock horror. Apple pie wasn't invented in America either and the music to their anthem is a British drinking song :D There are apple pie recipes dating back to the 1500s and earlier.

[@soisaidtogod4248]

Never forget, they have usa educations.

[@MetalHeart8787]

@@B-A-L well OK that guy is an idiot. Thats why people should watch my Videos about Flags,

[@rhidiandavies1991]

The biggest weird thing for me is the pledge of allegiance. The fact that you force little kids to ritualistically recite it every morning, stood up, hand on heart, is just plain creepy. It’s almost got a nazi Germany or soviet Russia vibe to it.

[@Lurts]

Yeah I was really baffled when I heard that kids do that every morning in school. As a Finn, it seems so bizarre, almost dystopian lol

[@Elimba78]

Lol ironic they do same things in socialist regime's, stop dissing usa...

[@Lurts]

@@Elimba78 so you're saying it's okay because authoritarian dictatorships do it too?

[@Jujube285]

Even as a child I knew something was wrong with this. I’d routinely refuse the pledge & be punished for it.Mostly sent to the principals office & talked to. This was the 90’s in Florida btw.

[@rhidiandavies1991]

@elimba78 lmao but that's exactly my point, you dullard

[@dueiu3383j]

As a Russian this topic of uncritical patriotism really hits close to home, thank you for the video. Edit: Don't read the replies if you value your sanity :)

[@MatheusFernandes-xf4zm]

How many military bases does Russia have in Latin America?

[@dueiu3383j]

​@@MatheusFernandes-xf4zm Would you support literally any murderer or terrorist so long as they oppose the US? This is the logic of a 10 year old who got into trouble for shoplifting who thinks he did nothing wrong because his friends who did it with him avoided trouble.

[@MatheusFernandes-xf4zm]

@@dueiu3383j I can't support any people who fight against dollar hegemony and fascist imperialism, oh my god I'm so wrong🤡

[@dueiu3383j]

@@MatheusFernandes-xf4zm You can say whatever nonsense you want but at the end of the day it's s just one breed of fascists vs another breed of fascists to anyone with a brain.

[@MatheusFernandes-xf4zm]

@@dueiu3383j USA: "800 military bases around the world, created a military dictatorship in my country and condemns us to poverty" Illuminated Anon: "You should love America" stupid puppet

[@Serinebanders]

I must say my eyes have been opened hugely by this content! From a very cold overworked south west England

[@molybdomancer195]

I’m a British mother of sporty kids. The only time I heard national anthems at one of their sporting events is when they competed in international events when the opening ceremony played all the competing countries’ anthems and the winner’s anthem was played at medal ceremonies. At even national level event we didn’t play the British anthem at all

[@catmonarchist8920]

God save the King it's exactly a banger to be fair

[@notyourbusiness3751]

It’s like that in Balkans also.

[@ME-hm3tc]

In Scotland our national anthem is played a lot, but it makes sense since we're a lot more patriotic and nationalist than England.

[@jesseandersen9762]

It's nuts here

[@catmonarchist8920]

So the Balkans are less nationalist than Scotland? How times change

[@jammmmmmmm]

I fully agree with you. As a non-American, I found that the US brand of patriotism simply isn't patriotic. It doesn't aim to better the country. A patriot must aim to better and change their nation-state, not follow a dogma of what the country is.

[@codex8085]

As a non-american you should focus on your own country which will undoubtedly be less successful

[@dadaismotienekasepta]

This. Too bad many people think patriotism is blindly loving ur countrie's flaws instead of improving them. It sucks because right wingers are like this, which leads to some left wingers to be scared of the word "patriotism" because it's fascist to them

[@Medium341]

@@codex8085 Patriotard spotted

[@tomowens1571]

@@Medium341 I'm not American but your lack of patriotism sickens me especially since you're willfully ignorant of how NATO and the finance world push foreign policy which is the only criticism anyone can hold against America. And such thing you and your ilk support

[@bluester7177]

@@codex8085 you're literally proving their point

[@filofaxiAltAcc]

im swedish and visited the US (east WA) last year and yeah, its surreal, and uncomfortable seeing nearly all my pre-imagined stereotypes about US patriotism come true to the point of parody (visiting during the midterms probably didnt help though lol) also somewhat besides the point, but i had such a lightbulb moment when watching the signs by the road and watching tv- 'christ, all the american memes ive seen online, all the inside jokes- 90% of them are from COMMERCIALS'. it felt very bleak to realize that

[@masterofalltrades_]

The second largest party in Sweden (and an ally of the current government) was founded by literal Nazis. America isn't the only country with problems like these

[@kkpenney444]

I'm sorry you experienced that. The weirdest thing about America is you would have had the opposite impression if you had visited Western Washington. We are deeply bipolar.

[@marianotorrespico2975]

SURPRISE! | They really are paper dolls; they really admire Nazism; they really are silly people who believe their own lies; they were created by the strictly COMMERCIAL function of the U.S. as country.

[@landonbarretto4933]

East WA ain't the greatest place to go either.

[@LeeshMa]

as a German I may have a biased view on patriotism bc here its neither taught, lived nor encouraged but I gotta say its odd to pledge allegiance in the classroom every morning and hoisting your countries flag on ur house

[@icarusxedits]

As a German I agree

[@snoozy04]

Patriotism is the conviction that your country is the best simply because you were born and/or raised in it.

[@youtubeuniversity3638]

I'd call that nationalism...

[@MaatStile]

its kind of weird, because, patriotism is really an invention of the state, you are made a patriot, the state (as nation-state) created all sorts of mechanisms to alienate its population to feel part of their country (the flag, national anthem, national heroes, iconography, and so on) having a patriotical population, means its easier for the government to do things without getting questioned

[@lonestarr1490]

@@ramenbomberdeluxe4958 So, in other words, American patriotism is a (deliberate) misnomer and what they're actually shipping is outright nationalism.

[@kronop8884]

@@lonestarr1490 In the words of Emmanuel Macron in an address to Trump and Putin in 2018 "Patriotism is the exact opposite of nationalism. Nationalism is a betrayal of patriotism. By putting our own interests first, with no regard for others, we erase the very thing that a nation holds dearest, and the thing that keeps it alive: its moral values."

[@wrestlar3246]

Eh the U.S is in a better situation than most nations to survive the coming events over the next few decades. If globalization ceases, wars prop up, climate change gets worse, and the birthrate crisis hits hard. The U.S will come out a hell of a lot better than Europe, the UK, China, or anywhere else

[@brigc7755]

For english class we actually read a selection that had statistic analyzing the U.S. vs. European countries and their characteristics of patriotism. What was found is that essentially, the U.S. has a "you have the freedom to choose what 'group' to be in, but once you're in it, you have to be uncritically loyal to the group, or just leave", while Europeans had a more "Be in the group, see issues, improve on issues" mentality.

[@jesseleeward2359]

Yes Germans are co operative

[@bereal6590]

And that is why as a uk citizen I want eu alignment and not brexit! With american interference

[@bereal6590]

@@tobitobi628 I have absolutely no idea what you're going on about

[@bereal6590]

@@tobitobi628 if you think you're teaching anyone anything you're mistaken

[@bereal6590]

@@tobitobi628 nothing you impart is anything I wish to learn

[@franceb7566]

Thanks!

[@Souchirouu]

American patriotism is far closer to a religion than it is to a love of their nation and many of the arguments patriotic americans make are very similar to those made by religious people.

[@vylbird8014]

There is a term for it, the "American civil religion." The idea that American patriotism, though not actually a religion, does share a similar social function. It has rituals, and symbols, and a notion of righteous and sinful behaviour. It serves to unite the community, and in doing so to also define outsiders who are not part of that community. And it has certain sacred elements that must be accepted for a person to be considered part of that community.

[@zaberfang]

It's a cult

[@Kehwanna]

@@vylbird8014 Indeed. Which is funny considering those that claim to be "Christian nationalists" are violating the whole no idolatry and serving two masters thing in the Bible. What does pledging allegiance to the flag or standing up for the anthem in any country actually achieve unless you believe it is spiritually empowering the people of the nation somehow. I get that it's a sign of respect in some regard, similar to standing at a funeral, but come on. Let's not forget about the North Koreans that see Kim Jong Un as a type of God and have pictures of him in their home that they pray to as well as make pilgrimages to his grandfather's home.

[@ryanweible9090]

if you are familiar with the bad religion song "the american jesus" it deals with it. its weird, because i consider myself religious, but its just a bizarre mix.

[@JamesDavy2009]

@@zaberfang Too bad a lamb is not leading it.

[@Jamesssssssssssssss]

As someone who spent over a decade in becoming a US citizen. I find my self in the same thought process but also recognizing the amount of hard work that had to be put in to finally being an American. Its strange because the grand majority of citizens did not have to do anything for it, they just were born into it. Among them people who probably think of me an immigrant and never a "real" American. When im Patriotic, the pride I feel is mainly driven by the fact that I choose to make this my home and fight hard to belong. Great video.

[@thelatinoguy]

"Real" Americans don't exist. True Americans are people who are either natural born citizens are people who are naturalized. The most radical right leaning Americans simply cannot argue against someone if they both come here legally and become naturalized.

[@soisaidtogod4248]

I feel sorry for you, you chose poorly. Yankee-ville is an unhappy land.

[@codex8085]

As someone who begins a sentence with as some one identifying their identity I would say it's fair to imagine you as solely Psychologically composed of your identity so it's fair to think of you as an outsider cause you think of yourself as an outsider

[@engelbrekthaakansson4100]

@@codex8085 You should reread that and try to understand what it actually means.

[@codex8085]

@@engelbrekthaakansson4100 You do realize that saying you should read that again and try to understand is a far right Trope let that sink in

[@mylesiswhite4122]

I went to a nhl game and seeing people cheering during the national anthem and celebrating veterans in the audience by listing all their accolades was the weirdest culture shock as an Australian

[@MrFelixify]

To then not giving a fuck about homeless veterans what so ever.

[@SteveGraegert]

That was weird for me as well. Playing the national anthem at a league game and honoring veterans or the military in general made me feel uneasy. What has sports to do with that? Sports is in its core indifferent of nationality, military affiliation, ideology and eveyone's way of life.

[@michaeladkins6]

@@SteveGraegert 9/11 amplified that and that was 21 years ago.

[@felicityc]

There is a big split on this with veterans. I don't know numbers but I am a veteran so I have seen both pretty often. You have one side (almost always marines and army) who are still brainwashed because that is what was pushed into them so much. You then have the ones who LOST all their patriotism and felt like they never had any honor or pride in what they were doing and generally became mental wrecks/homeless or whatever (not to say the same does not happen to the patriot ones for different reasons). I feel that patriotism is imposed on me and it's awful. People who did not serve do not understand that there was no glory in what we were doing, period, in any war. Especially the most unjust ones. In my opinion they honor veterans like they honor sewer workers. "It's really important but I would never do it!!" Except we're even less important than sewer workers.

[@ajwashere8996]

Omg I was at a flyers game just before Christmas it was a whole different world. The constant selling packing every moment, the veterans and police celebrations, I was scared not to stand up for the anthem despite being Australian but felt super uncomfortable with the hand on the heart stuff…. I still have to explain to my American that you just see Australian flags on government buildings and car lots not on everything definitely not on homes even on Australia Day and getting an Australian flag tattoo makes us a little wary you might be going all Cronulla riots. We can love Australia and shit but praise the dude calling the prime minister a dickhead in the shops. My gut feeling has always been putting that much effort into praising something that doesn’t feel or need your praise is about control not pride.

[@HkFinn83]

It’s not the patriotism that is worrying to me, it’s the militarism. The frankly creepy way people interact with ‘veterans’ is like something out of a dystopian sci fi novel.

[@syafsmith5085]

@@eh3744The bitter irony is that those same people who advocate for needless wars are ones who push policies that rob them of their care, welfare, benefits and housing once they’ve completed their service

[@tootnfart]

yeah people told me i was disrespectful to the veterans and soldiers when i didn’t stand for the pledge. IT DOESNT EVEN MENTION VETERANS 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

[@reversefulfillment9189]

Good stuff JT. I'm originally from Canada and moved to the USA 30 years ago, I noticed Canadians have become more nationalistic since I've left. The USA ideas have infected a good portion of Canadians. I find patriotism grotesque and would prefer no borders, one world.

[@abnelalvarez6034]

One question for you. Do you really trust one man to rule the world without opposition? I don’t trust men with unlimited power. I prefer a world where power is divided. Because if one of those powerful rulers became evil, there can at least be others to put him down.

[@Jess-zf3ve]

@@abnelalvarez6034 they didn’t mention anything about one man ruling the world - they wish for an open world in which people empathize and share with each other without sociological barriers put in place by the divisive ideology of capitalism and nationalism.

[@abnelalvarez6034]

@@Jess-zf3ve would you let anybody get in your house? Probably not. Barriers create society, is a necessity.

[@reversefulfillment9189]

@@abnelalvarez6034 No I don't advocate one person ruling the world. I imagine something where each culture, region elects their best to represent them on the global scale and some hierarchy that coordinates those regions to maximize value for the whole planet. Some international police that prevent the remaining bourgeois elements from fucking it up.

[@abnelalvarez6034]

@@reversefulfillment9189 again, do you really trust that hierarchy to have all power?

[@curtisthomas2670]

Many US citizens are so blindly patriotic or so unaware of outside the US that they actually believe that the US is the best at practically everything, when an unbiased look at worldwide standards would show that the US doesn't lead (and in may cases doesn't even make the top 10/20) in most metrics that measure quality of life, safety, freedoms, rights etc. What the US leads in is economic and military power, as well as people in prison, police killings, Covid cases and deaths and many things no one should be proud of.

[@maddi62]

Thanks

[@luvlee-]

The amount of times Americans (not all obvi) have called me a commie is insane.. im norwegian- idk the american flags and all that just reminds me of a certain mid century european country waving their flags proudly around all over the place aswell

[@JamesDavy2009]

These are the people who think apple pies were invented by Lenin or that cheese is Communist.

[@luvlee-]

@@JamesDavy2009 Fr tho

[@masterofalltrades_]

Or even Britain today, ironically

[@MN-vz8qm]

In Europe, we have toned down patriotism considerably, because it led to countless wars, ending with 2 world wars and untold destruction and death. Here in France, people tend to be a little bit more patriotic than most other western europeans (bar the brits), but still, if you see a french flag in front of a house, you can be sure the house owner is a nationalist. In the case of the US, I think that not only you guys ended up better off after each world war, but on top of that the nationalist war propaganda seem to have never stopped, being reignited each time you go to a war or another (so very often in the last 50 years). And this is extremely dangerous. I remember when things were heating up before the iraki war. The US administration was unable to provide evidence of their accusation that Irak was building WMDs, so here people were very critical (I have no doubt my country had its own geopolitical interests, but still). But still, there were debates here in France on the subject. Meanwhile, in the US, there was no opposition, nobody dared question the US administration, journalists were closer to propagandists than anything else. And anyone opposing the war was branded un-american. And the US went to war for fake motives.

[@painkiller9310]

Something interesting is that the context for raising a flag can be very different here in the U.S depending on what flag you raise as well, especially if you're a minority. I say that since you mention that patriotism is toned down in Western Europe and those who do hang a flag are easily identified as nationalists. ( I would like to Europeans reaction if they visit places like Spanish Harlem, NY or Fresno, CA ). There are alot of latin immigrants that come to the U.S, many of them raise their own flags from their country of origin but it's never a sign of patriotism/nationalism, but rather pride of your culture and never forgetting where you come from. The only downside to that is you're more easily targeted by racist people who are patriotic and, sadly, many minority families do hang U.S American flags to integrate to its culture or show pride to be in the "best country in the world". My family painted a U.S flag on a piece a pallet wood and hung it on our fence to show our "patriotism" because now we live here and not Mexico and also because me and my little brother are first generation. It honestly bothered me because why would I be patriotic to a country that treats its minorities horribly, in which I'm in that minority group, and a bunch of other terrible things in it's history. Honestly that last part can go out to every single country but it's so ingrained and enforced here in the U.S because of how self-centered we are, that we are the best became we promise "freedom". The irony is that its only a matter of time before it leads to oppression.

[@kidoncrack4164]

Anti American bot

[@cathysamborn4709]

People in the U.S. did protest against the 2nd Iraqi war. I was at an anti-protest rally in mid-size city in Wisconsin (not Madison or Milwaukee). The crowd took up the whole public which took up five city blocks. I wish the crowd was bigger. There were plenty of Americans who didn't for a minute believe there were WMD's in Iraq. Bush's neoconservatives had their own motives. They were patting themselves on the back for winning the election and asleep at the controls when the warnings came in about 911.

[@leangrypoulet7523]

MN, interesting that you say Brits are more patriotic than the French. As a 50yr old Brit (specifically English) who’s lived in France for almost 20 years, I’d beg to differ. If you take Brexit, and our frankly idiotic reasons for leaving, out of the debate, British patriotism at a Government level is no different between our two countries. Additionally, just as you point out, a flag hanging out of a window or planted in a garden, can be seen to be at the right/nationalist end of the spectrum. Although that depends on the flag, as if it’s Welsh or Scottish, it’s given a pass, as is the Union Flag. But an English flag has very much been stolen by the right. Interestingly though, see it on top of an old (Ironically) Norman church in a traditional English village and it looks normal, at home. But where I disagree with your sentiment about patriotism being more prevalent in the UK than France is at a public level. In Government and at the extremes, we are the same, but amongst average man or woman, the French are more patriotic. This isn’t shown as overtly as in America, it’s far more subtle than that, but it is everywhere. For example, almost everything that is made in France will have a ‘Produit de France’ sticker on it, and more likely than not, most French will choose that item over one that is made elsewhere. We don’t have that. Perhaps a little on fresh food, but not on everything. In France it could be on your housing insulation, your cement, your tool, furniture, car tyre etc. And French will choose that item unless there’s a vast difference in price. And then there’s food. Wine. Cooking. It is absolutely ingrained in French culture from day one. Most French will never accept that wine from other countries is palatable, let alone can be better. They’ll drink rubbish or wine that (Euro for Euro) isn’t as good, simply because it’s French. In the UK we will drink anything from anywhere. And normally too much. 😂 Similarly, food. French food (to a Frenchman) is best. No debate. And for some, no other nations on the planet even know how to cook. Certainly not the Brits. But in the UK we don’t have this food culture, in any way shape or form, so we’ve accepted food from all over the world. Outside of Paris or other large cities (I live in the Alps) you’re hard pressed to find foreign foodstuffs (pasta doesn’t count) in a supermarket or restaurants from other world cuisines beyond Burgers and Pizza (although the burger will have reblochon on it, the pizza cream 😢). In the UK, apart from the tiniest one-pub village, you’ll be able to find foreign food stuffs in all our supermarkets, you’re as likely to find Thai or Vietnamese food as Fish and Chips, and foreign cuisine is almost all that’s cooked on our TV shows. And then there’s French culture. Your art, your monuments, your buildings, your galleries. You all know about it, you’re all taught about it, and you’re all fiercely proud about it. And at the most overt end, your language, you have a 300 year old institution that’s there to protect it. To actively stop it evolving or modernising. And outside all these great institutions you will see the tricolore proudly on display. Every Mairie, every town square, every Trésor, Prefecture, Museum, etc etc. And on days of national importance, Bastille Day, a Mairie will be covered in flags in the same way they would in the US. My local Mairie must have 30+ all over it. In the UK, apart from central government buildings, the odd castle and some churches, flags are almost non existent. They’ll usually only be raised for Remembrance Day and the Queen’s (and soon the King’s) Birthday. But beyond that…..very very rare to see. So I’d suggest in a more subtle way, France is far far more patriotic than the UK. As I said, if you ignore that bi-partisan, divisive stupidity that was Brexit. But at a national level, of everyday man and women, you have a far greater understanding and sense of what it is to be French, to think French and to support France. And in some areas (wine) blindly so. One could argue a similar exceptionalist point of view as that of an American. And do you know what? Do you know why? Because you have an exceptional country. In all those areas I mentioned above (art, culture, food, way of life, the geography, architecture etc) you excel. You have arguably the greatest country on earth. You can be drinking the best wine and looking out at the Med on the Côte d’Azur one day, walking through the castles of the Loire the next, skiing and eating raclette in the Alps the day after that, and then heading to Paris to pass the night in a (formerly) Smokey little bistro listening to the greats of French songwriting the day after that. France is amazing. And a Frenchman or woman knows it and secretly (or sometimes not so secretly when I’m reminded how shit British food can be) loves it. But here’s the thing, unlike America, you’re also able, indeed happy, to criticise it. To moan, and complain about the institutions, the government, the politics, the politicians, the image abroad. The reason you’re as famous for being grumpy as you are proud. And it’s allowed, but with a caveat. Criticism of France is allowed, but only by the French and in France. You’ll never be called unpatriotic like an American might. But do it abroad or to a foreigner (as occasionally my French university girlfriend would) and you risk the wrath of your patriotic countryman. So in many many ways, as an outsider, you are a little America. The difference is that you can be self critical (often too much), but importantly you have good reason to be as proud as you are, whilst America has (IMHO) a lot less reason for its unbending patriotism. Finally, on Iraq. I served with the British and US armed forces in Iraq in 2004. Between the two key conflicts of that generation I lost seven friends that I’d served with. And in my opinion, lives wasted. I watched the Blair government’s blind support of the Bush administration with shame and was mortified and embarrassed that we went into Iraq. The French government’s decision to not go, was brave, was right, was fantastic. Something you should be proud of. Although as you say, it likely stems from a personal agenda (one we could argue is rooted in French military exceptionalism when it left NATO in 1966 and believed it could and should be a self-determining military state). Whatever, it was the right decision. So, you French are far more patriotic than we Brits (I think we’re confused, I think we’re divided and I think by the time I leave this planet we shall have divided into two, if not four separate nations), and rightly so. I’m frankly embarrassed by the UK now, a shadow of its former self. And your passion for your country is shown most beautifully when La Marseillaise is sung at Stade de France in two weeks time. You even manage to have the second best (best clearly goes to Italy) National Anthem. I mean, wow. Hearing that sung by 80k people brings out the goosebumps. And indeed based on what I’ve said throughout this reply, but mainly that last couple of paragraphs, is why I have applied for French citizenship. There’s a lot not right about France, but there’s a lot, lot more that is. And I’ve lost any affinity towards the UK, a country I shall never go back to. And here’s the irony based on the video we’ve both watched, I can say that as someone who served his country without fear of being called unpatriotic, unlike an American might suffer in similar circumstances. Vive la France 🇫🇷 . Allez les Bleus 🇫🇷 🍷🥂🥖🥐🧅🧀etc etc….

[@MetalHeart8787]

@@cathysamborn4709 oh of course Many protested, LOOK at what's going on NOW, Russia attacking Ukraine, protests? hardly any

[@benjaminhenderson5025]

"Every beer is a gun" I dont know why but this line made me laugh soooo hard

[@shinnam]

Unquestioning patriotism breeds complacency. This video is spot on, unfortunately the people that need to hear this message will tune it out. The vocabulary is quite high for most jingoistic Patriots

[@donaldtrumplover2254]

Europeans tend to misunderstand American patriotism, they get annoyed at Americans being in their face about patriotism and than call our country unstable. We understand that thoughtless patriotism is stupid. The United States thrives off instability and counter cultures. We just have an overly zealous attitude towards our society while doing it. Look at the protests of Vietnam and the mass hatred towards the war in Iraq. It paints my exact story

[@masterofalltrades_]

​@@donaldtrumplover2254 I think you are quite right but your rhetoric and your username contradict each other

[@donaldtrumplover2254]

@@masterofalltrades_ not really, im not a conservative. But one could easily take the point of view I made in that comment and still have no issues. The main goal of conservatism is to preserve/conserve tradition at the end of the day, not to over obsess about our nation being the greatest thing to ever exist or that protesting "immoral wars" is a bad thing. Even Trump stated the second gulf war was a mistake directly to one of the Bushes live. The more you talk to actual intelligent conservatives and listen to them you will see what I mean.

[@GigglelandEmperor]

I agre that patirot ism is dum. I also thing that peeple shood get free stuff bcuz historcal oppreshion and inequity. I am very smrt and enlightend.

[@danandkiko]

Well spoken. As an American, you realize the main differences once you live in another country.

[@dudoklasovity2093]

Very nicely said! Unfortunately, my guess is that majority of fellow citizens are so ignorant this will fall on deaf ears. 🇺🇸

[@thekwjiboo]

I can't even begin to imagine how angry a lot of my fellow Americans would be just seeing the title of this video.

[@Zech84]

no shit

[@assassinunknown6664]

“I’m better than everyone, and they are so stupid because they aren’t me”

[@Zech84]

@@assassinunknown6664 so true

[@Supernimo735]

​@@Zech84we clapped you guy's cheeks in the 1770s lol

[@roelkolthek1466]

Thank you, after just a few minutes I subscribed. Am Dutch, living in Germany, age 78. Having lived in the Netherlands, England, Canada and now Germany and having traveled extensively to and all over the U.S.A. (approx 140 times in my life so far) and always having had a very mixed up "like/dislike" feeling, your approach to what I experienced being excessively weird (and stupid), i.e. this nationalism/so-called patrottism, your narrative is refreshing and - I think - absolutely neccessary and true. Thx again!

[@haileybalmer9722]

Living in it is weird, especially when you don't believe in it and everyone around you does. They told me that the US was the best place on earth, and I thought, well, how can I know that? I've never been anywhere else. My stepmother, who considers herself a very liberal person, used to tell me to pack my bags and move to the third world if I felt that way when I'd ask that kind of question. It's intense, it's constant, and very few people think it's odd here. It's sort of like the gun issue. What's weird is it gets selectively localized based on what patriots want to see happen. Right now, there are people leaving my city in droves because the homelessness problem is so bad here. They think it's our "liberal policies*" that are causing this unique problem in our city alone. They don't realize that it's because of the skyrocketing cost of living, and that it's happening nationwide. It's not a US problem, it's this evil liberal city that just lets the poors do whatever they want, like be schizophrenic in public or live outside because they can't scrape together $1400 every month for a 300 sq ft apartment! They don't live like this in the rest of the US! And, well, the bizarre propaganda news they watch is all too happy to let them think this is a West Coast issue, and it's because we won't just shoot them or something. It's not reality at all, but it's what they see, and since it's completely legal to call a pile of reactionary lies "news" here, they believe it. *Yeah, they're liberal, and it's a huge problem, but they don't know what that word means at all. It's a stopped clocks situation. They think it means permissive instead of money focused. We're very money focused, as long as we have it now. Investing it in community welfare so we solve our problems and have more money later? That's COMMUNISM!

[@michaeladkins6]

I live in a very red state. When Im ready to fly to Western Europe, so many people at work will tell me how dangerous it is. They warn me about all of the knife attacks. Most have never left the US.

[@lucasgrey9794]

@@michaeladkins6 Knife attacks are only a problem in London. If you stay away from the black and brown areas you'll be fine.

[@lucasgrey9794]

What one needs to grasp when someone says what your stepmom said, is that it's the Pareto Principle at play; 80% of people are glorified sheep. They literally can't form an original thought so they regurgitate what their parents, church, school and favorite media outlet told them. Trying to convince them is a total waste of time and energy. It's honestly much easier to find like minded people instead.

[@Fractured_Unity]

@@lucasgrey9794 Ironic: you’re repeating something instead of coming up with an original, or correct, analysis. Where do you think that places you on the Pareto Distribution of individuals who can socially analyze?

[@phillygrunt2154]

@@lucasgrey9794 that’s pretty fucking racist.